2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: Q on September 19, 2013, 01:09:29 PM
-
.
-
Well This is wrong actually. Here is the video you need to learn how to deal with police. Basically, invoke your constitutional rights and don't talk at all. You don't need to give them ID or argue or do anything. Just ignore them. Here is a lawyer explaining: "Don't talk to the Police"
Dont Talk to Police (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc#)
Also print this out and have it right by the front door of your house, glove compartment of your car, wallet, etc. You can substitute in your own lawyers info for the Cal Guns:
http://www.calgunlaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/APPS-Notice.pdf (http://www.calgunlaws.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/07/APPS-Notice.pdf)
Be safe!
-
There have been several posts over the past couple months showing individuals throwing temper tantrums when cops stop them for exercising their 2A rights, and completely neglect to observe that the videographers are acting like complete assholes, provoking a situation with the police. While it is important to defend your rights, we also have a moral obligation to do so with respect and tact. Just because you are entitled to something doesn't mean you can treat people like shit in the process, just because its legal, as it has the potential to escalate the situation into something completely unnecessary.
THIS is how you deal with the situation. Notice that they did not need to get into a shouting match, or demonstrate how much more the know about state/federal laws or the constitution; they simply complied with the officers requests and made him look like the bad guy with his own actions.
http://youtu.be/CVHrpScqHsg (http://youtu.be/CVHrpScqHsg)
Yeah sorry Q. I would have told that guy to pack sand, but in a polite and respectful tone.
I don't appreciate the guys who go 'taunting' the cops, but, if I was that guy who walked up in the end and the cop was like I need your ID, I would have been like "Um, no?" lol.
-
Can we please move this topic to the LEGAL section?
Thank you.
-
.
-
There have been several posts over the past couple months showing individuals throwing temper tantrums when cops stop them for exercising their 2A rights, and completely neglect to observe that the videographers are acting like complete assholes, provoking a situation with the police. While it is important to defend your rights, we also have a moral obligation to do so with respect and tact. Just because you are entitled to something doesn't mean you can treat people like shit in the process, just because its legal, as it has the potential to escalate the situation into something completely unnecessary.
THIS is how you deal with the situation. Notice that they did not need to get into a shouting match, or demonstrate how much more the know about state/federal laws or the constitution; they simply complied with the officers requests and made him look like the bad guy with his own actions.
"This is all you got?"
It's a friggen passport man!!! It's better than a drivers license. Geesh.
-
I think cops can only check DMV records and not passport records since they are federal?
I don't really know and the above statement is more of a guess.
-
Can someone on this website find a prominent 2nd amendment attorney in Hawaii to get some stickers, and right invocation notification to police cards/letters [similar to Calguns] for the members of this website and local gun shops to distribute? Would be good free advertising for the right law firm.
Still, all in all America is the best country on Earth.
My country 'tis of thee [1903] - Iwo Jima (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xpTWAqu3t6s#)
-
.
-
.
-
Not the way I would have handled it, Not sure what state they were in and if OC requires a permit or not, but as far as everyone not carrying a weapon they all should have denied showing their ID
-
Okay, I will be applying for my passport soon, or should be updating my passport.
-
.
-
If I were you, I'd pay to have both card and passport.
Passport card? This is the first time I heard of this. Guess I will be searching about this.
Stupid question, do cops have the right to confiscate old expired drivers licenses, drivers permits and military ID cards?
-
.
-
THIS is how you deal with the situation. Notice that they did not need to get into a shouting match, or demonstrate how much more the know about state/federal laws or the constitution; they simply complied with the officers requests and made him look like the bad guy with his own actions.
http://youtu.be/CVHrpScqHsg (http://youtu.be/CVHrpScqHsg)
First, I strongly disagree. First thing those folks should have said was "Am I being detained." Second thing should have been "What crime do you suspect me of committing."
I would not have given my ID unless he said I was being detained.
All done in a respectful, but firm manner.....
-
.
-
Oh, here we go again.
First, this police officer is violating Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. 1 (1968), Delaware v. Prouse, 440 U.S. 648 (1979), Brown v. Texas, 443 U.S. 47, 52 (1979), and U.S. v. DeBerry, 76 F.3d 884, 885 (7th Cir. 1996). A visible firearm is not reason in and of itself to justify asking for ID or detaining an individual. The police - like this officer in the video - are behaving illegally when they detain and ask for ID when no crime has been committed or a suspicion of a crime. Second, those people you accuse of being "assholes" are merely exercising their unalienable rights. Third, if LEOs would only follow their oaths, these confrontations would go down like this one: http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=a8a_1379922014 (http://www.liveleak.com/view?i=a8a_1379922014)
If an open carrier is on private property like this Walmart, they can be asked to leave, but no signs were posted that stated they couldn't open carry. So this officer's actions are unwarranted.
-
As I have stated, its not what they said, but in the manner in which they conducted themselves. They didn't open try to start an altercation with the officer like most try to do, and ended up making the cop look like a dumb ass on his own accord.
But it is what they said and did. The police officer had no suspicion that a crime was committed. The encounter was a consensual one that either side could have legally terminated at any time. The police officer had no authority to ask for ID from the either the those that were packing guns or those that came into the encounter later.
Asserting your rights, and declining to willfully participate in illegal activities, is not trying "to start an altercation..."
They didn't make the cop look dumb, but they sure could have.....
-
If you are going to renew your passport better do it this week in case of a government shutdown.
-
.
-
I haven't confirmed any facts so I'm taking the cites on face value. ( and I trust you guys )
But if lived in an open carry State and an officer approached me and asked for ID I'd like to give him a business card printed with:
Terry v. Ohio, 392 U.S. 1 (1968), Delaware v. Prouse, 440 U.S. 648 (1979), Brown v. Texas, 443 U.S. 47, 52 (1979), and U.S. v. DeBerry, 76 F.3d 884, 885 (7th Cir. 1996).
A visible firearm is not reason in and of itself to justify asking for ID or detaining an individual.
Someone should make those.
It'd be interesting to see the officers reaction. >:(
-
.
-
If I followed you around and taunted you like those kids were following Petraeus in the other video, would you consider that acceptable behavior?
Complete apples and oranges scenario. Those leftist pieces of trash confronted Petraeus and started it. The LEOs are the ones that start the confrontations, and the vast majority of time they do so under a false premise, i.e., a visible firearm being the sole reason for the stop.
If the open carriers want to engage in a consensual meeting with the police, that's their perogative. But the minute a cop says they're detained and the reason for their detention isn't reasonable suspicion of a crime being committed but rather the weapon they're carrying, then it's the LEOs acting like assholes and violating the very oaths they swore.
Just because I can do something, doesn't mean I should act like an asshole to do it.
A right not exercised is a right lost. And the vast majority of the OCers ARE respectful. It's the cops that are acting like assholes, just like these idiots: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ah3a7dQqyZI (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ah3a7dQqyZI)
Was what the officer did right? Hell no...
And there you go again defending behavior that isn't right, but giving a pass to LEO because, in your mind, their badges somehow absolve them from following the same rules we live by. Right is right and wrong is wrong. You can't admit a LEO does something wrong and then just brush it off.
Every time you excuse behavior like this from police, you're adding to the problem and not fixing it. So, go ahead and continue to look the other way when cops behave illegally. We know your background and it's obvious you're unable to look at the issue without bias.
I would like to respond to this point, but I'm not sure if you were the one who knighted me the heavenly defender of LEO, so I'm not going to answer that one.
I don't care if you respond to my last point or not. What I wrote is correct.
-
.
-
HA! I knew it was you! I was wondering when you would show up, because I knew you would have the same anti-cop comments as last time. I missed you :'( :'( :'(
Translation: Little Q is unable to offer a response to the aforementioned legal findings I've presented along with the logical arguments on my side, so he resorts to an Appeal to Ridicule retort. Hint: using logical fallacies is a sign you've lost the argument.
LOL. "Anti-cop comments." You don't know a damn thing thing about me. Quit projecting.
P.S. Can you clarify if you have ever CC on the mainland, or have you always lived in Hawaii? You seem like one of those people that claim to know everything about CC or OC, yet have never done it yourself.
It's none of your business whether I lived in Texas for 5 years and another year in Los Angeles. Your question is just another silly little deflection.
-
.
-
rSo basically what you mean to say is you have no experience with CC or dealing with the issues that involve CC; poor guy :'( :'( :'(
Actually, I never wrote anything like that, but you keep on believing that crap if it makes you feel better.
I lived in Texas - which has for less restrictions than here - for sometime, and that's all I say about my private life. If you want more personal info., give me your hottest sister's digits and I'll get on divulging more.
No need to get butt hurt man. If its still too much for you to accept, I'll be sure to bring my violin and some cheese to complement your whine next time we have this type of discussion.
Keep on believing that nonsense, little Q. If anything has been proven, it's that you get owned every time with logic, legal rulings and facts. Oh, and that you have to resort to logical fallacies to make vapid, nonsensical arguments.
-
2) Just because I can do something, doesn't mean I should act like an asshole to do it. If I followed you around and taunted you like those kids were following Petraeus in the other video, would you consider that acceptable behavior? Id hope not, because regardless of what rights we have, we should exercise self control and tact when enforcing that right. That is the major problem I have with most of these videos; they go around, getting involved in situations they know will draw LEO suspicion or response, and act like complete jerk-offs just to show how much they know about something. The people in this video approached the situation in a completely different manner, which is why they weren't getting curb stomped. Was what the officer did right? Hell no; but the way the individuals conducted themselves prevented an escalation of force on the officer's part, which could have resulted in bodily harm or death on their part.
So, if the open carriers had, instead of quietly acquiescing to an unlawful detention and demand for ID, responded with less "self control and tact," say by stating something to the effect of "are you detaining me" or "why do I need to show you my ID" or even quoting relevant statutory language it would have somehow justified "getting curb stomped" by said officer violating their civil rights?
I would suggest that even if they had exercised less "self control and tact" that short of attempting to fight with that officer or draw their firearm, said officer would not have been justified in 'curb stomping' them. It is difficult for me to understand how you seem to place all weight of potential escalation of force on the innocent folks lawfully exercising a right, while seemingly excusing the officer conducting said illegal detention and demand for ID should HE escalate force unnecessarily because those lawful citizens didn't respond with the degree of respect you think he should be afforded regardless of HIS actions. In other words, a cop can act like a bullying, arrogant, self-righteous a$$hole and law abiding citizens should quietly take it while complying with any illegal order issued, but if a law abiding citizens dares question the illegal detention and orders in anything less than a demur, "thank you may I have another" demeanor, it opens them up to a (justifiable??) "curb stomping?"
In many, many instances where civil rights (or rather the infringing thereof...) were being protested in the past, folks took actions that they know would "draw LEO suspicion or response" and many times this was simply the attempt to exercise the right being restricted. If you don't remember the civil rights protesters clashing with the police you can easily Google it. I don't think many would now claim that the violence perpetrated on those protesters was warranted, even if they did yell or shout at the police. It's the same thing. We citizens are told ignorance of the law is no excuse and if we are held to that standard, so should all police. To excuse a police officers illegal detention of someone who has committed no crime, either through ignorance of the law or in defiance of it, and then to somehow justify violence upon that person by the police simply for asserting their rights in a manner you deem a lack of self control or tact, is, IMHO, reprehensible and wrong.
-
.