2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: Q on September 20, 2013, 07:00:51 PM
-
.
-
.
-
More fun with Rep. Lee! :D
He recently posted a picture with this quote:
" A church's right to freely practice is inextricably linked to a person's right to freely marry." - CHRIS LEE
Here is my response:
Chris Lee,
I fully believe that all men and women are created equal, and are endowed upon them, by their creator, with the uncertain inalienable rights of Life, Liberty and the Pursuit of Happiness. If two people, regardless of gender, find happiness with each other, then it is their right to do so, and I honor and respect their happiness as long as they do not encroach on the rights of others.
However, I still find it discerning that you would support such specific issues relating to a few, yet do not voice your opposition to the degradation and encroachment of other constitutional rights that effect ALL groups, i.e. 2nd amendment rights.
It is my belief, as well as the belief of millions of other Americans, that the 2nd amendment protects and enforces these unalienable rights that are guaranteed to all individuals, so that all may live in peace and without fear knowing that they can defend themselves. Because of this, I would like an explanation as to why you have decided to focus on specific issues of a particular group, all while ignoring and/or opposing support for the constitutional right to bear arms that would allow all couples to protect themselves and their loved ones.
Keep up the fight brother! Fight the good fight!
-
He supports specific issues relating to a few (dems, libs etc ) at the FORCED EXPENSE OF THE REST !!!!!!!! His definition of social justice ??? Where is our justice ??? At the forced expense of ..................criminals ???
-
.
-
This guy is really a tool. Whenever I try to engage in 'friendly' discussion with him, he simply ignores my messages or comments. It is only when I 'hijack' his posts that he elects to respond.
This is why I believe we are beyond the point of solving this problem through discussion. If those whom oppose us aren't even willing to debate the issue for fear of being proved wrong, what is the point of trying to discuss/debate at all? People are influenced by only 2 things in life: hope and fear. They definitely don't have any hope for/from us, and damn sure don't fear us at the moment.
During the hearings etc. this past year on SB69 I wrote many legislators (and called some, too) asking them to provide me with their rationale and evidence as to why a person from out of state bringing in an "unusable... unserviceable" firearm needs to be fingerprinted (and pay $25 for the privilege) for a NICS check and sign a waiver for release of their mental health records. Surely there is some evidence that such people and such firearms have committed crimes in the past and this measure closes that criminal activity "loophole", right? Well, no, not really. Not one single legislator provided me with one scintilla of evidence as to why this bill ought to be passed for any public safety or any other reason (I guess "We want to control everything everyone does" might not be all that welcome an admission). I emailed this question to my representative here in Puna, Russell Rudermann, at least eight times, each time quoting his most recent response in which he gave absolutely no reasons or evidence for his support of the proposed law. How hard a question is that? You are voting for a bill: why? Please provide me with any evidence that there have been how many crimes committed, or if there has ever been even a single crime committed by a person who brought in an "unusable, unserviceable" firearm, which this bill is designed to prevent. (Of course, if someone brought in such a firearm with the intent to use such a non-functioning non-repairable firearm with the intent of committing a crime with it, I highly doubt they'd go do the already required registration, much less the proposed background checks. But don't let logic or rationality get in the way of imposing new laws on the law-abiding citizens of Hawaii.) Not one legislator could provide any such evidence. Most of them ignored my request for their rationale for supporting the bill. The few that responded sent canned generalized (and to me, meaningless) responses. :wtf:
They "damn sure don't fear us at the moment."
And I won't even go into the fact that the Hawaii Rifle Association SUPPORTED this bill (which, of course, became law) despite the NRA-ILA sending out many alerts to oppose the bill.
-
And I won't even go into the fact that the Hawaii Rifle Association SUPPORTED this bill (which, of course, became law) despite the NRA-ILA sending out many alerts to oppose the bill.
I don't understand HRA. They supported Rhoads who was very anti-gun.
-
I don't understand HRA. They supported Rhoads who was very anti-gun.
I was stunned when one of the legislators I was communicating with told me the HRA supported SB69, as I had only been receiving the NRA-ILA alerts that urged strong opposition to the bill, in all its forms. After learning of the HRA support for the bill I attempted to contact, via email, all of the officials of that organization that I could find in order to ask them for their rationale and evidence. I got zero (0) replies. So, to this day it is still a mystery to me why the HRA would oppose the NRA and support SB69. If they had reasons, a rationale or evidence, they weren't willing to tell me about it. Thanks for nothing.
-
I don't understand HRA. They supported Rhoads who was very anti-gun.
The HRA rates legislators in a very similar manner as the NRA, voting record and response to a survey. His rating was "favorable" based on those two criteria at the time the ratings were determined. Now, as he's revealed his true colors, his rating will be more accurate.
We are always looking for ways to improve this process, so if you're interested, please feel free to suggest alternates to the current method....and of course actively participate in the process of evaluating all the sitting legislators and candidates using your method.
-
I was stunned when one of the legislators I was communicating with told me the HRA supported SB69, as I had only been receiving the NRA-ILA alerts that urged strong opposition to the bill, in all its forms. After learning of the HRA support for the bill I attempted to contact, via email, all of the officials of that organization that I could find in order to ask them for their rationale and evidence. I got zero (0) replies. So, to this day it is still a mystery to me why the HRA would oppose the NRA and support SB69. If they had reasons, a rationale or evidence, they weren't willing to tell me about it. Thanks for nothing.
I'm not sure who you tried to contact, but the HRA sent out many communications to members and non-members about our position on SB69. Yes, the HRA took a position contrary to the NRA on this bill. The information about why we took this position is on the website. Here's the link:
http://www.hawaiirifleassociation.org/latest-news/8-legislative-reports/18-hra-legislative-report-sb69 (http://www.hawaiirifleassociation.org/latest-news/8-legislative-reports/18-hra-legislative-report-sb69)
http://www.hawaiirifleassociation.org/latest-news/8-legislative-reports/11-hra-legislative-report-april-25-2013-by-dr-maxwell-cooper (http://www.hawaiirifleassociation.org/latest-news/8-legislative-reports/11-hra-legislative-report-april-25-2013-by-dr-maxwell-cooper)
I'm sorry if you had some difficulty getting answers at that time. We try to be responsive but all of the HRA are volunteers with real jobs and during the legislative session things are even busier than "normal." That's not an excuse for not getting back to you, just the reality of working with an all volunteer organization...
-
.
-
[Rep. Lee wrote:]
As a longtime gun owner I'm entirely familiar with the 2nd Amendment. The issues I choose to focus on are those both within my jurisdiction, and those our community has made priorities.
Nothing the state can do will ever trump federal law, and there is nothing the state can do to infringe upon any Constitutional right, including the 2nd Amendment. More to the point though, in the spectrum of issues that our community has asked be addressed, this issue isn't one the district has reached out on. In fact, in the two surveys done on the issue, an overwhelming majority prefer no change to our laws (not that ours could trump federal law anyway) and wish to maintain the status quo.
I'm really not sure what infringement of the 2nd Amendment you are referring to, because anything the state did would be overturned in court. However, if it's federal law you would like to see changed I suggest reaching out to our federal representatives.
Translation: "Neither I nor my constituents (as polled by me, of course [I'd like to see the exact wording of the questions.]) care about this issue. It is not important to any of us. Besides, whatever the courts say is the law, IS the law, and we all know that never changes as cases work their way through various levels of appeal. Like, for instance, you are not allowed to own a handgun in your home if you live in Washington, D.C. or Chicago, Illinois... oh, wait. I agree with whatever the courts say. If they rule a 180 degree change tomorrow, I will then agree with that. In the meantime please leave me alone and stop the silly pestering about some issues that no one cares about except a fringe minority of extremists that really has no power at the polls. Why should I care, much less take a position?"
Similar to my State Senator (Russell Rudermann) who when asked to provide detailed specifics about the reasoning and evidence he has used to support his anti-Second Amendment policy positions simply replies "No one is trying to take your guns away. These laws are reasonable." I seriously doubt these people could be influenced by anything other than receiving fewer votes than their opponent on election day. Until then, they will say whatever they think they need to say to get the most votes.
Keep informing us of Mr. Lee's responses. I'm not expecting anything substantive, but curious about his strategy. Thanks.
-
Translation: "Neither I nor my constituents (as polled by me, of course [I'd like to see the exact wording of the questions.]) care about this issue. It is not important to any of us. Besides, whatever the courts say is the law, IS the law, and we all know that never changes as cases work their way through various levels of appeal. Like, for instance, you are not allowed to own a handgun in your home if you live in Washington, D.C. or Chicago, Illinois... oh, wait. I agree with whatever the courts say. If they rule a 180 degree change tomorrow, I will then agree with that. In the meantime please leave me alone and stop the silly pestering about some issues that no one cares about except a fringe minority of extremists that really has no power at the polls. Why should I care, much less take a position?"
Similar to my State Senator (Russell Rudermann) who when asked to provide detailed specifics about the reasoning and evidence he has used to support his anti-Second Amendment policy positions simply replies "No one is trying to take your guns away. These laws are reasonable." I seriously doubt these people could be influenced by anything other than receiving fewer votes than their opponent on election day. Until then, they will say whatever they think they need to say to get the most votes.
Keep informing us of Mr. Lee's responses. I'm not expecting anything substantive, but curious about his strategy. Thanks.
Fortunately Ruderman is focused on GMO and Fracking so firearms takes a backseat to his efforts. But it does seem he blindly follows the party line and seems to be a supporter of Roger Chritsie. At least he reponds to your messages. Faye Hano-Hano? Never heard from here after sending how many messages??/
-
Heller made any references to the militia a moot point. The right is an individual one, unrelated to membership in a militia (or non-membership...)
McDonald incorporated the right under the 14 Amendment, so that the individual right interpretation cannot be ignored by the states.
-
.
-
I was going to incorporate the Heller and McDonald cases, but I have a feeling that I would just be wasting my time. What I did want to do was prove that we are, under law, members of the unorganized milita, and thus we can tell them to shove it up their ass if they decide to use specific terminology and say 'hold the phone...you aren't militia, and the 2nd amendment says militia!'
His story is beginning to crack, though. First he was a 'former owner of firearms', and now he is a 'long term owner of firearms'.
I say he is just a frickin' tool! :shaka:
-
.
-
.
-
I hope they -have- woken the "sleeping giant". We really need new blood. Red american blood. These people do not respect us. Or our cause. Nor our constitution. They will interpret it as they see fit.I believe in the in alienable right to self protection.Those that shirk or try to prevent others from protecting or defending women, children and all that is Gods-which is our DUTY- refuses to believe it is their responsibility as a God fearing and freedom loving American.A gun is neither good -nor bad-it is simply a tool. A tool that OUR founders liberated themselves with to achieve what we call freedom. Responsible U.S. citizens use guns 2739 times every day to defend the old, weak and those unable to defend themselves. From evil.......and now a tyrannical government gone wild. Far beyond our fore fathers dream.My gladiator days are over. At 57, I believe at being peaceful and avoiding conflict.But if conflict should come, let it come in my time.That my children may-be- free.The line has been drawn. "They will not pass here".I'm with you on this one Q.
-
.
-
Gladiator days...I like that, I will now use that as a reference. Thanks Q for keeping us in the know. I am gonna start doing more research on it. You Da Man!
-
.
-
Q.........just press !!!!!
-
great job Q. Id like to see a face to face dialogue.
-
.
-
UPDATE: He is now removing my posts. :rofl:
Well, Q, that's just him exercising his "common sense speech safety" rules for the First Amendment. If even just one politician can be spared some grief, he must act... :wtf:
-
.
-
good points
-
Fun with rep .Lee :rofl: good advice new guy
-
Let's be smarter than these guys and use our brains and wits to expand support for the cause.
I'm curious as to what your program of action is for using our brains and wits expand support for the cause? Please be specific and give details. Perhaps especially with legislators who want to avoid having a public or private discussion about these issues, but vote against every gun rights bill and for every gun restriction bill. Thanks. :shaka:
-
.
-
I'm curious as to what your program of action is for using our brains and wits expand support for the cause? Please be specific and give details. Perhaps especially with legislators who want to avoid having a public or private discussion about these issues, but vote against every gun rights bill and for every gun restriction bill. Thanks. :shaka:
I think what hes trying to say is dont turn into a troll?
-
.
-
.
-
But being a troll for assholes like rep. Lee is so fun! :rofl:
Thank you for the input newguy :shaka:
The real fun was when we used to post on the Official HPD facebook page and everyones comments were getting deleted!!!!
-
might i suggest someone start a Facebook page discussing all local politicians and issues. that way the platform would broaden beyond 2ahawaii and be out in the general population. then you can talk sh*t and not worry about being deleted for your views. :shaka:
-
.
-
.
-
Q.Calm down. DONT get your bowels in an uproar. If you should decide to run for office, seek counsel from several sources first. Your Pastor and elders for a start. Have the prayer team pray and ask the Lord IF YOU are called to the position. Then others as to the logistics etc. It WONT be fun.But it will be an experience. I have found you to be pretty level headed for a young fella. Well focused, articulate.My senior pastor ran for county council and boy let me tell you. You really find out who is your friend. I think you would do well. I would support you as best I could from here I will tell you that. We need young articulate people in politics. Not them knarly old crocs we have now. Besides, we on this site would hold you accountable, trust me. Or as my grandmother would say "cut off your ears and make soup".
-
Q.Calm down. DONT get your bowels in an uproar.
Just hope irritable bowel syndrome is covered under Obamacare...
-
.
-
Q. This dude needs to learn that gun people are versatile, agile and mobile. When angered we are hostile and to challenge us is futile. Hope this helps.
-
.
-
.
-
You should have seen what I saw today...
License plate: OBAMAS.
What the hell man...
Some people treat this president like their Messiah. It's sickening! That's how Jim Jones got his start....
-
Not unless you get the silver or gold plan.
Thank god all us guys get awesome prenatal and maternity care though!
And the females get coverage for their prostrate exams and the PSA test. I mean, fair is fair and equal is equal, right? /end sarcasm :wtf:
-
Saw this sticker on a car, earlier this afternoon, and I thought I'd share...
(http://i1164.photobucket.com/albums/q565/dubya808/20131117_090135_zpse12a7aab.jpg)
I would not have believed this shit if I had not seen it with my own eyes. :crazy:
Here's a bumper sticker I saw today...
(http://i95.photobucket.com/albums/l134/surfgeorge/b34e2a64-e54e-4643-9bfb-5f838542dde7.jpg)
In my garage...
You can imagine how popular this is in Puna...
-
...
Also, getting to this point effectively prevents you from asking the legislator to answer any further "difficult" questions, as such requests can be disregarded as your continued "badgering," "pestering," or in the worst case, "harrassing," or, "threatening," the legislator; it provides a legislator with a convenient "out" to ignore you.
...
Let's be smarter than these guys and use our brains and wits to expand support for the cause.
@new guy: Thanks for taking the time to post and re-post some of your thoughts on specific strategies to address our legislators and the public in general about issues that concern us as adherents to a certain view and interpretation of the Second Amendment. I know that you were responding to and addressing Q in your remarks, but if you and Q don't mind, I'd just like to add a brief comment.
I concur with the strategies you outlined for presenting the issues to the general public. I wouldn't be the person to take on those roles, but support those who do (the articulate, charismatic, attractive, etc. public relations types). I also agree that in public forums there is a point of argumentation or persistence in asking for clear and direct answers to questions wherein other readers or listeners will begin to have a negative view of the tactic. However, I believe there is a place in private communication with the legislators for being totally clear, direct and honest in language regarding their unwillingness to provide clear answers to our questions (e.g. Please provide me with the evidence you used to vote for a bill wherein a person bringing an "unusable, unserviceable" firearm into the state must be fingerprinted, undergo a NICS FBI check, sign away their rights to any privacy regarding their physical and mental health records, and have the privilege of paying for it while taking time off of work to do so because the office that performs these tasks is only open during banking hours (actually far fewer than banking hours these days). Please provide me one iota of evidence that such nonfunctional, unrepairable firearms have ever been used in any crime, ever, in the state of Hawaii. If there is no such evidence, how can you justify... etc.).
When I see this kind of attack (and all the others) on the rights, liberties, freedoms, and privacy of American citizens supposedly living under laws governed by the Constitution I get frustrated, angry and outraged because I am wanting such laws and legislators to uphold their oath to abide by and support the Constitution and to use logic, rationality, critical thinking skills and evidence that will withstand critical scrutiny to come to conclusions about which laws would serve what public interest in what way to what degree. As you may have noted, that doesn't happen a lot, some I'm rather angry, and believe it is my right under the First Amendment to express my anger in clear terms to these legislators. When they lie about statistics, I call them liars.
Do they then ignore me? Of course they do. They mostly ignore me no matter how civil and polite I am in my initial contacts with them. It's only after they ignore me completely, or send disingenuous canned responses that ignore everything I actually asked them, that I begin to press the points of contention. Will any of them ever change their position because of what I write or call in to them? Extremely unlikely. Will any of them ever change their view or votes based upon what the charismatic, articulate, attractive public relations type tell them? Extremely unlikely. If you have some examples to show where these people were amenable to learning and/or changing votes, I'd appreciate hearing the details of the stories and the strategies that resulted in a gun control advocate voting for a gun rights bill.
My view is that they need to know that there are at least some citizens who take this seriously, know they are liars and/or ignorant, and are calling them on it. That's just me. I don't recommend it for anyone else. You know, you might end up on some list or have someone snooping on your emails or calls or something. But I support Q in his efforts to press anti-Second Amendment legislators in whatever way (short of violence or threats of such) he believes or feels might have some beneficial effect, even if it might have some negative effect as well. After all, as we've seen in the past month, some segment of the American people believe that their leaders ought not be questioned, and that those who raise questions about the integrity and truthfulness of some leaders ("If you like your health plan, you can keep your health plan. Period", etc.) are unpatriotic jihadists or racists. Certainly we aren't concerned about how to win over such people, as that is impossible.
In my view, these legislators are selling out our country and our Constitution. They deserve to have at least a few people "hassling" them.
-
Here's a bumper sticker I saw today...
(http://i95.photobucket.com/albums/l134/surfgeorge/b34e2a64-e54e-4643-9bfb-5f838542dde7.jpg)
In my garage...
You can imagine how popular this is in Puna...
If I see you on the road I'll give you a big thumbs up!
-
.
-
This is my personal take on it:
..........
"Give 'em hell." :thumbsup:
:shaka:
-
.
-
.
-
UPDATE:
So as I expected, instead of answer my question, he has opted to restrict me to only seeing his posts and not being able to message him or comment on any of his photos / status updates. I guess when all else fails, tuck your legs between your legs and block people on FB.
NewGuy - looks like there will be no more trolling on my part. :rofl:
Is this his personal FB page? If so, then he has a right to do so; but if its his page related to his political office then he can't do that. If I remember HPD has their own page and they did the same thing but retracted their censorship as they were a city organization.
-
.
-
Hell, after reading all this crap, I'm still on (a) The militia of the United States consists of all able-bodied males under 45 years of age
Am I too old to have a gun per 2a ?
Maybe I should be at drunken posting ! :geekdanc:
-
Hell, after reading all this crap, I'm still on (a) The militia of the United States consists of all able-bodied males under 45 years of age
Am I too old to have a gun per 2a ?
Maybe I should be at drunken posting ! :geekdanc:
Have to update our interpretation with the times....
No gender or age discrimination allowed, including in the militias!! :thumbsup:
-
It's his public page.
I was contacted by someone with another Chris Lee account, who basically gave me the 'stop picking on me' speech and then blocked me. I am still allowed to view his posts and tag him in my comments, which means that he blocked me from his public page.
Contact Chris Baker. He pushed the HPD FB issue and should know what the censorship limits of their "public" pages are....
-
.
-
Excellent discussion. You guys are good! Feet to the fire and all that.
"(2) Appear to be a suitable person to be so licensed;"
I love that one.
Terry, 230RN