2aHawaii
Tools and Uses => Hunting => Topic started by: Antithesis on January 25, 2011, 02:48:54 PM
-
I just want to preface this by saying I mean no disrespect to anyone in the hunting community for asking this question, it's just something I've been tossing around for the past few days.
We all know of the strict limitations of the Kokohead Shooting complex: only 5 rounds per magazine, no rapid fire, no shooting targets closer than 25 feet etc etc. The private ranges are expensive, and have their own slew of restrictions. After reading through the rules and regulations the DLNR has for hunters, compared to private or public shooting ranges, hunters have much more freedom in the usage of their firearms. As far as I can tell, there aren’t any rules against rapid fire, quick-drawing, or shooting at a close range target. These are all skills vital to self-defense, but are next to impossible to practice in Hawaii.
My question is, what’s to prevent an individual (or a group of individuals) from getting hunting permits, going to a designated hunting zone, finding an isolated area, and practicing with their firearms? People on the mainland go off into the wilderness to shoot all the time; the main reason people cannot do that in Hawaii is because of the finite amount of land. What I’m purposing is using land that’s already been allocated by the state as okay for shooting, and shooting on it.
Now I have no experience with hunting, so I’m not sure if this would violate hunting customs/culture, or scare away the game, or have some other negative consequences that I haven’t thought of yet. Just throwing this idea out there to see what people think of it.
These are the restrictions I found on hunting with firearms:
http://www.state.hi.us/dlnr/dcre/mammalguide.html (http://www.state.hi.us/dlnr/dcre/mammalguide.html)
Legal Hunting Animals and Weapons
When hunting with dogs where permitted, hunters may use any muzzeloading rifle with a minimum of 0.45 caliber bore diameter; any rifle using at least a 0.22 caliber magnum load or center fire cartridge; shotguns loaded with slugs or 00 or larger buckshot or spears or knives.
When hunting without dogs, hunters may use any rifle with a muzzle energy rating of 1,200 foot pounds or more; shotguns loaded with 00 or larger buckshot and muzzleloader rifles with a minimum of 0.45 caliber bore diameter (Breech loaders may not be used during muzzleloader only designated hunts).
When hunting with a bow, the following drawing tension requirements are applicable: Long bows must have a minimum of 40 pounds at a 28-inch draw; Recurved bows must have a minimum of 35 pounds; Compound bows must have a minimum of 30 pounds
http://www.state.hi.us/dlnr/dofaw/hunting/BirdHuntingRegs_Chap122-02.pdf (http://www.state.hi.us/dlnr/dofaw/hunting/BirdHuntingRegs_Chap122-02.pdf)
(b) With respect to WEAPONS, the following conditions and restrictions shall apply:
(1) No person shall possess or discharge any firearm within any public hunting area, without
having a valid Hawaii State hunting license in their possession;
(2) Legal game bird hunting weapons include shotguns and bows and arrows;
(3) No person shall possess any arrows equipped with explosive heads or heads containing
drugs or poison;
(4) While hunting, each hunter shall be limited to carrying on their person only legal weapons
that are consistent with the hunt. In addition, each hunter is required to make their weapon,
cartridges or muzzleloader firing components, game and license available for inspection,
upon the request of a duly authorized representative of the department. Refusal to permit
said inspection shall be considered a game law violation and may result in the revocation of
hunting privileges by the department, after notice and hearing;
(5) When hunting with a bow, no person shall use:
(A) Long bows with less than forty pounds of drawing tension at a 28 inch draw;
(B) Recurved bows with less than thirty-five pounds of drawing tension; or
(C) Compound bows with less than thirty pounds of drawing tension.
(6) A firearm that utilizes cartridges shall be considered unloaded if no ammunition is in the
chamber or an attached magazine. A muzzle loading firearm is considered unloaded if the
ignition component (primer, percussion cap or priming powder) is removed from the ignition
system and for flintlocks the powder is removed from the pan, the frizzen is up and the cock
(hammer) is down. “Cartridge firing†and “muzzleloading†firearms must be unloaded just
as described above to enter any safety zone or to transport the firearm in a vehicle within
the hunting area. However, when crossing or entering a public highway or exiting a public
hunting area, all fireable cartridges and muzzleloader firing components must be removed
from the firearm, including powder and projectile(s).
(7) A bow shall be considered loaded if an arrow is nocked on the bowstring; and
(8) No person shall possess any rifle, combination-rifle firearm, rifled slugs buckshot or altered
shotgun shells where game mammal hunting is closed. Only the weapons that are
authorized for the particular hunt are to be in the hunter’s possession while in the hunting
area.
-
As far as I can read...nothing.
I doubt any others in the area would be happy with what you are doing though.
I saw some guys up at Peacock flats taking shots a a target way up on a hill. They were there for about an hour...no issues (or DLNR) in sight.
Sad that one must go to this extreme to get decent practice.
-
Well if anything you'll get some good exercise hiking all that gear in.
-
Keep in mind that if you don't have the right kind of ammo or too much in a magazine, there could be issues with the DLNR officer should you run across one.
-
I'm new to this forum, but a very experienced hunter. This is not meant to be insulting (just as your post wasn't), but here's how I see it as a hunter.
"Practicing" as you describe can be dangerous and inconsiderate. It would be only safe if you had a clear back trap such as a very large hill that would catch the occasional flyer. As you know, stray rounds can travel very far with lethality. Remember, it is also unsafe for you to be in hunting areas without proper attire (appropriate minimum blaze orange) as your movements at distance could be mistaken for game. Lastly, it is inconsiderate to actual hunters as your activites will surely scare off any game remotely close to your location. A single round going off can chase off game from a mile away. OGC's range, when open, will let you draw from the hip and rapid fire. You should consider practicing in that controlled environment -- the safety issue is worth the cost.
-
I don't see nothing wrong with the occasional practice in a hunting area. I have done it many times, and even sighted in a scope because I didn't want to wait 45 min at kokohead to fire 3 rounds. Just make sure you have a suitable backstop and know what is behind it. I have been hunting for over 20 years and have seen it done by others many times in many different states. In my book it's acceptable.
-
On Kauai now that they shut down the rifle range for private citizens, we are forced to go to hunting areas to practice, and to site in scopes. While in hunting areas all hunting rules apply though. Blaze orange must be worn at all times no more then a ten round mag, I think, but don't quote me handguns must have a 5" barrel. Like I said don't quote me on that one. And you have you hunting license on you at all times. Oh yeah have a good backdrop, but I'm sure you know that already. But the best thing is to do is call DLNR and ask the game warden.
-
Has something changed in the last couple years? I dont recall there ever being a magazine limit (other than the obvious 10 round pistol mag limit) for land mammals, only ammunition and barrel length requirements (for handguns).
-
I don't think so about the mags.
Everytime I been in kailua I would stop at the DOCARE office and ask about this. One officer said he was unsure. I asked him if he knew the citation number or why its illegal and he said he has to look into it.
Another time I went and asked about Target practice or sighting in a scope and the officer said nope can't, go to the shooting range that's what its for. I asked if it was illegal and he gave me the, just trust me, don't do it, go to the range. Now when I see him he
-
Hello everyone, I've been creeping around this forum for a little while now. Though now might be a good time to chime in. The Magazine limit while hunting or in a hunting zone is 3! You can have no more than three rounds in your weapon. It states that in the DLNR rules and Regs. I also recently took the excruciating hunter safety coarse out here where they beat that horse to death.
-
This is an interesting development.
-
and welcome EF.
-
3 rounds in the magazine? I have never seen that in the books. I've seen barrel lengths, caliber, safe zones, with dogs and without dogs, showing paperwork, keeping the gun clear, do you remember what section of the rules it was under?
-
Hello everyone, I've been creeping around this forum for a little while now. Though now might be a good time to chime in. The Magazine limit while hunting or in a hunting zone is 3! You can have no more than three rounds in your weapon. It states that in the DLNR rules and Regs. I also recently took the excruciating hunter safety coarse out here where they beat that horse to death.
That's BS. I've had a hunting license for almost 20 years now. There is no HRS that states you can only have 3 rounds in the mag. DLNR regs come from the HRS. If its not in the HRS they can't charge you with a crime. I've actually ran across a DLNR game warden a few years back in the trail with a 20 round mag in my SKS. He didn't say not one word about my 20 round mag. He did ask if we saw a group of boy scouts in the area. :shaka:
-
^^^I'll confirm that when I took the Hunters Ed class (years ago) we were told about a round limit loaded in the magazine.
-
No mention of magazine limitations that I can find:
http://hawaii.gov/dlnr/dofaw/hunting/game_summary (http://hawaii.gov/dlnr/dofaw/hunting/game_summary)
Legal Hunting Animals and Weapons When hunting with dogs where permitted, hunters may use any muzzeloading rifle with a minimum of 0.45 caliber bore diameter; any rifle using at least a 0.22 caliber magnum load or center fire cartridge; shotguns loaded with slugs or 00 or larger buckshot or spears or knives. When hunting without dogs, hunters may use any rifle with a muzzle energy rating of 1,200 foot pounds or more; shotguns loaded with 00 or larger buckshot and muzzleloader rifles with a minimum of 0.45 caliber bore diameter (Breech loaders may not be used during muzzleloader only designated hunts).
http://hawaii.gov/dlnr/dofaw/hunting/bird_summary (http://hawaii.gov/dlnr/dofaw/hunting/bird_summary)
Legal Hunting Animals and Weapons Only shotguns, and bow and arrow may be used to hunt game birds. The use of BB or larger sized shot is prohibited except during the Spring Turkey Hunt.
http://www.state.hi.us/dlnr/dofaw/rules/Ch123/Title13_Chap123.htm (http://www.state.hi.us/dlnr/dofaw/rules/Ch123/Title13_Chap123.htm)
§13-123-22 Conditions and restrictions. The following conditions and restrictions shall apply to game mammal hunting in public hunting areas:
(b) With respect to weapons, the following conditions and restrictions shall apply:
(1) No person shall possess or discharge any firearm within any public hunting area without having a valid Hawaii State hunting license in their possession;
(2) While hunting, each hunter shall be limited to carrying on their person only one legal firearm that is consistent with the hunt. However, a hunter may carry another hunter's unloaded firearm in addition to his own unloaded firearm in close proximity to the other hunter. In addition, each hunter is required to make their weapon, cartridges or muzzleloader firing components, game and license available for inspection, upon the request of a duly authorized representative of the department. Refusal to permit said inspection shall be considered a game law violation and may result in the revocation of hunting privileges by the department, after notice and hearing;
(3) No person shall possess any firearm or weapon in any public hunting area during a closed season or on non-hunting days during open seasons, as provided in Exhibits 1 through 12, attached at the end of this chapter. No person shall possess any illegal weapon on a public hunting area at any time;
(4) No person shall possess a loaded weapon once they have filled their bag limit;
(5) When hunting without the use of dogs, no person shall use the following weapons:
§13-123-22
(A) Cartridge firing rifles with a muzzle discharge energy rating of less than twelve-hundred foot pounds;
(B) Shotguns loaded with shot smaller than 00 buckshot;
(C) Muzzleloading rifles, with less than a 44 caliber (0.44") bore diameter regardless of mode of ignition. Breech loaders are prohibited during "muzzleloader only" specified hunts; and
http://www.state.hi.us/dlnr/dofaw/rules/Ch122/Title13_Chap122.htm (http://www.state.hi.us/dlnr/dofaw/rules/Ch122/Title13_Chap122.htm)
§13-122-12 Conditions and restrictions.
(b) With respect to weapons, the following conditions and restrictions shall apply:
(1) No person shall possess or discharge any firearm within any public hunting area, without having a valid Hawaii State hunting license in their possession;
(2) Legal game bird hunting weapons include shotguns and bows and arrows;
(3) No person shall possess any arrows equipped with explosive heads or heads containing drugs or poison;
(4) While hunting, each hunter shall be limited to carrying on their person only legal weapons that are consistent with the hunt. In addition, each hunter is required to make their weapon, cartridges or muzzleloader firing components, game and license available for inspection, upon the request of a duly authorized representative of the department. Refusal to permit said inspection shall be considered a game law violation and may result
-
Are pistols allowed in the public hunting areas?
-
Are pistols allowed in the public hunting areas?
I think minimum is 357 pistol for hunting but I might remember incorrectly
-
I think minimum is 357 pistol for hunting but I might remember incorrectly
Hmmm...thanks...I gotta check on that... :shaka:
-
call up hunter's ed and ask them.
and double check the laws.
i recall 357 pistol and 223 rifle, minimum.
-
It actually depends on how much the bullet will expand. The point being that it efficiently kills the animal in the most humane way possible. check out dlnr website hrs for specifics. you are allowed to use a 22lr when hunting with dogs during a specific season. I am not 100% sure but you can hunt with 9mm with an expanding round like hollow point or soft round.
-
roger that..thanks! :shaka:
call up hunter's ed and ask them.
and double check the laws.
i recall 357 pistol and 223 rifle, minimum.
-
There's a lot more places like this than most of you know lol, but its a JOURNEY, almost not even worth it. Just make sure you know the right people is all I have to say. ::)
-
I test my loads on local hunting land. Low round count, try to dig out all my lead afterwards, shooting mid-day, mid-week for minimal disruption, etc. Never even seen another person much less a game warden. The only downside, really, is the 15 walk to the shooting area I picked (farthest from nearby houses, decent open area, solid backstop) but its nice to not have to navigate range rules. And the walk is nice, really.. Anyway, I've looked at the laws a lot recently.
Handgun rounds WITHOUT dogs: the laws are screwy. They go by size and are pretty much written so that only 357 and 44 mag (or bigger) are legal for pistol hunting, with a specific exception made for 10mm. Idiocy, but such is life.
WITH dogs you can use anything since they figure its just for an up close kill shot - applies to both handguns and long guns.
Long guns without dogs, they figure it by energy. Not looking at the laws right now, but think the muzzle energy needs to be at least 1200. That includes factory .223 but NOT most factory 7.62x39. Handloads are a different matter but if you are ever called on using a normally weak round by loading it hot it is probably your responsibility to prove that your loads meet the muzzle energy requirement.
There are no mag cap limits of any kind, which is very unusual for those coming from the mainland where hunting mag limits are canon. You can have several firearms in your vehicle but can only carry ONE at a time - with the exception of handing your weapon to a buddy when you need your hands to navigate an obstacle for safety reasons.
Here on the Big Island there are a couple known shooting ranges on hunting land. Technically ALL hunting laws must be followed to shoot at them (blaze orange, bring yer dog if needed, don't carry more than 1 weapon at a time, etc.) and be VERY respectful and cooperative if a warden happens by and takes an interest in what you're doing. I'd grab a copy of the laws and keep it with you. Know it. Love it. Have it on hand so you can point it out to an officer that is questioning your judgement. I have PDF versions on my phone.
-
On the big island I think as clshade said, it seems perfectly ok. The so called range we have is located in a state hunting area anyway. Since everyone knows it is a range and even DLNR has put up signs saying please take your trash.. etc. Clearly they do as well. I wear a blaze orange shirt when I go to the range mostly because I do not want to get shot if someone drives up and starts popping off while I am out checking targets but technically you are supposed to anyway.
I have also gone up to mauna kea to shoot above the treeline. It is a legal hunting area but there are also signs warning to stay on the trail system (the road that goes up) and I feel like it is a bit more of a sensitive area. Although with all the cinder cones makes for excellent long range shooting with good backstops. And no worries about someone popping out from a bush because there arent any.