2aHawaii
General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: 230RN on February 28, 2011, 08:54:50 AM
-
OK, so I'm trying to reduce my 100 lbs or so of old American Rifleman magazines to 99 lbs or less.
So I'm going through them, using post-it notes to flag articles I want to cut and keep. So I'm in the November 2007 issue and I find this on page 34, in the "Second Shots" section, where they review tidbits from past issues:
FACTS AND FIRE ARMS
The old sergeant's remarks regarding the ignorance displayed by many newspaper reporters when writing about fire arms are very truthful. It is vastly amusing to read the reports that appear in the daily press, in which it is made to appear that 12 gauge shot cartridges are useful in rifles, that shotguns are loaded with the deadly .303, and where the trigger snapped, when the hammer is meant, besides many other lamentable errors. Another startling and amusing "break" often occurs in reporting a fire in a hardware store or gun shop. Here the scribe is in his glory when he writes of the bullets flying in all directions, "endangering the lives of the firemen and spectators." The enterprising jouranlist ought to know that if he were to throw a handful of rifle cartridges in the fire, the brass cases would blow off, being lighter than the bullet. Of course, in the event of a cartridge being backed up against a solid obstruction, the bullet would be thrown off with a great deal of velocity, but not sufficient to endanger the lives of the firemen and spectators.
--B. Kelly
This appeared 100 years before, in the November 1907 issue!
Makes you wonder about what they teach in Journalism classes about fact-checking --even today.
Jes' fer grins.
Terry, 230RN
-
As someone who teaches at a university in the field of Communication as part of a very small program, I can assure you that the situation will only get worse. Students for our school rag usually write their entire articles in one sitting, without leaving the campus, citing whatever the first hit they get from Google tells them. They won't make phone calls or visit a person to do interviews; instead, they email a list of questions designed to make the interviewee write their own article. Then, when those questions are never answered, they just shrug and proceed to quote paragraphs from Wikipedia.
-
As someone who teaches at a university in the field of Communication as part of a very small program, I can assure you that the situation will only get worse. Students for our school rag usually write their entire articles in one sitting, without leaving the campus, citing whatever the first hit they get from Google tells them. They won't make phone calls or visit a person to do interviews; instead, they email a list of questions designed to make the interviewee write their own article. Then, when those questions are never answered, they just shrug and proceed to quote paragraphs from Wikipedia.
My question would be, are you allowing that? Wikipedia ? (lol!!!) My online instructors would implode if if I cited wikipedia lol.
-
You mean they aren't even smart enough to cite the citations instead of the Wiki article itself?
Hooooly cow!
Wikipedia is a valuable source of information, especially on technical matters, although sometimes they're screwed up as well. Even allowing for legitimate differences of opinion on a particular technical item.
But as far as "authoritativeness" on things like current events or personalities and the like, forget it. About all you can do there is use it as a source of leads on which to follow up for the real skinny.*
I do have a small beef with them as far as their constant "citation needed" flags go. You can say "the sky is blue" or "guns go bang" and boom, there's a little blue "citation needed" note for it before you know it.
Terry, 230RN
_________________
* "The real skinny" is a technical phrase used only by real professional authors and writers.[citation needed]
-
You mean not everything found on the internet is true?
Gaah!
:rofl:
-
My question would be, are you allowing that? Wikipedia ? (lol!!!) My online instructors would implode if if I cited wikipedia lol.
I'm not the newspaper prof, so I'm not in a position to allow or disallow anything. I merely share my observations.
-
My question would be, are you allowing that? Wikipedia ? (lol!!!) My online instructors would implode if if I cited wikipedia lol.
I'm not the newspaper prof, so I'm not in a position to allow or disallow anything. I merely share my observations.
Do they publish this work anywhere? Would like to read it, maybe we could provide some responses in criticism to the articles and give them an opportunity to counter.