2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: Funtimes on February 13, 2014, 08:53:10 AM
-
9th Circuit Court of Appeals rules that Carry is a right and that may issue licensing is unconstitutional. Opinions for Richards v. San Diego and Baker v. Kealoha not published at this time.
http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2014/02/12/1056971.pdf (http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2014/02/12/1056971.pdf)
TLDR version:
1.) A right to carry firearms for self-defense exists outside the home. Heller was not specific, but pointed squarely to this reasoning.
2.) History shows that bear meant to carry outside for self-defense.
3.) That right can be either/or, or both concealed or open, but one *must* be available to *ALL* common citizens. May issue policies are wholly unconstitutional.
-
Congrats!
-
Congrats!
It's not mine yet - but this would be a nail in the coffin.
-
Yes!
-
Exciting news. Waiting on the others... :)
-
This is awesome news. 2014 is off to a good start.
-
Excellent news. Thanks Chris for the info and all your hard work in making your case go the distance for those of us here in Hawaii (I only say that 'cause now you're a Cali boy...)....
When you come back, drinks are on me!
-
.
-
Thanks for the info, Funtimes.
I have not yet read the entire 79-page majority opinion, or the 48-page dissent, but from face value, this sounds promising!
Good luck, my man... I'm keeping my fingers crossed for a ruling in your favor!
TLDR version:
1.) A right to carry firearms for self-defense exists outside the home. Heller was not specific, but pointed squarely to this reasoning.
2.) History shows that bear meant to carry outside for self-defense.
3.) That right can be either/or, or both concealed or open, but one *must* be available to *ALL* common citizens. May issue policies are wholly unconstitutional.
-
Chris,
Your motion is for a preliminary injunction, correct? Any idea how this will effect your case in the short term (i.e. the injunction)? The long term implications are certainly positive.
Here's Eugene Volkh's quick take on the ruling
http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2014/02/13/ninth-circuit-holds-second-amendment-secures-a-right-to-carry-a-gun/ (http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2014/02/13/ninth-circuit-holds-second-amendment-secures-a-right-to-carry-a-gun/)
http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2014/02/13/more-on-the-reasoning-of-the-ninth-circuits-right-to-carry-a-gun-opinion/ (http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2014/02/13/more-on-the-reasoning-of-the-ninth-circuits-right-to-carry-a-gun-opinion/)
-
Chris,
Your motion is for a preliminary injunction, correct? Any idea how this will effect your case in the short term (i.e. the injunction)? The long term implications are certainly positive.
Here's Eugene Volkh's quick take on the ruling
http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2014/02/13/ninth-circuit-holds-second-amendment-secures-a-right-to-carry-a-gun/ (http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2014/02/13/ninth-circuit-holds-second-amendment-secures-a-right-to-carry-a-gun/)
http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2014/02/13/more-on-the-reasoning-of-the-ninth-circuits-right-to-carry-a-gun-opinion/ (http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2014/02/13/more-on-the-reasoning-of-the-ninth-circuits-right-to-carry-a-gun-opinion/)
Here is my best guess, and I see a few different paths.
1.) Court grants my injunction to the law, and orders the C&C to issue me a permit to carry firearms.
2.) Court says that the law was not clear at the time. Therefore, because it was not clear, the judge himself couldn't have been required to know what the standard was - that a right existed outside of the home. They would likely find error, but not grant it, and send it back to be re-heard.
3.) Court denies the PI and tells us to move on. We either A.) Amend the complaint to remove some stuff, refile, tro / pi, or B.) just go forward and file a motion for summary judgement consistent with the opinions released in Peruta / Richards.
4.) Our case is stayed, again, pending an En Bach request in Peruta or Richards.
A lot of this depends on when they release my opinion. Peruta was heard earlier in the day than my case by a few hours. Richards opinion should come soon. Mine should follow right after that.
All this said, best case is that Hawaii is some form of shall issue this year. Worst case is that En Bach is granted, all cases are stayed, opinion of the panel is reversed or altered in a fashion that dramatically alters what we currently think is a victory. Aside from that, San Diego could also appeal to the SCOTUS directly and not request En Bach.
-
Reading quickly through the opinion. Noticed this quote.
To reason by analogy, it is as though San Diego County banned all political speech, but exempted from this restriction particular people (like current or former political figures), particular places (like private property), and particular situations (like the week before an election). Although these exceptions might preserve small pockets of freedom, they would do little to prevent destruction of the right to free speech as a whole
-
The majority opinion summary:
We conclude by emphasizing, as nearly every authority on the Second
Amendment has recognized, regulation of the right to bear arms is not only
Legitimate but quite appropriate. We repeat Heller’s admonition that
“nothing in our opinion should be taken to cast doubt on longstanding
prohibitions on the possession”—or carriage—“of firearms by felons and the
mentally ill, or laws forbidding the carrying of firearms in sensitive places
such as schools and government buildings, or laws imposing conditions and
qualifications on the commercial sale of arms.” Heller, 554 U.S. at 626–27.
Nor should anything in this opinion be taken to cast doubt on the validity of
measures designed to make the carrying of firearms for self-defense as safe
as possible, both to the carrier and the community.
We are well aware that, in the judgment of many governments, the
safest sort of firearm-carrying regime is one which restricts the privilege to
law enforcement with only narrow exceptions. Nonetheless, “the
enshrinement of constitutional rights necessarily takes certain policy choices
off the table.. . . Undoubtedly some think that the Second Amendment is
outmoded in a society where our standing army is the pride of our Nation,
where well-trained police forces provide personal security, and where gun
violence is a serious problem. That is perhaps debatable, but what is not
debatable is that it is not the role of this Court [or ours] to pronounce the
Second Amendment extinct.” Id.at 636. Nor may we relegate the bearing
of arms to a “second-class right, subject to an entirely different body of rules
than the other Bill of Rights guarantees that we have held to be incorporated
into the Due Process Clause.” McDonald, 130 S. Ct. at 3044.
The district court erred in denying the applicant’s motion for summary
judgment on the Second Amendment claim because San Diego County’s
“good cause” permitting requirement impermissibly infringes on the Second
Amendment right to bear arms in lawful self-defense.
REVERSED and REMANDED
-
This great news. Fingers crossed that Chief Kealoha will have to eat it.
-
Right on Chris, this is great news!!
I'm REALLY hoping this has a positive impact on Oahu's CCW laws and process!!
-
Congratulations Chris! :thumbsup: :worship: :shaka: I certainly hope that this decision bodes well for your case, as well as all the rest of us in Hawaii who would like to exercise our Second Amendment rights.
Thanks to you, and the attorneys and their assistants, for enduring a long, grueling, costly path. I appreciate all your efforts and wish you the best, whatever the outcome of your particular case. I'm sure the Ninth Circuit taking all three of those cases simultaneously will end up having a long term impact. I hope it's in your and our favor.
-
9th Circuit Court of Appeals rules that Carry is a right and that may issue licensing is unconstitutional. Opinions for Richards v. San Diego and Baker v. Kealoha not published at this time.
http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2014/02/12/1056971.pdf (http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2014/02/12/1056971.pdf)
TLDR version:
1.) A right to carry firearms for self-defense exists outside the home. Heller was not specific, but pointed squarely to this reasoning.
2.) History shows that bear meant to carry outside for self-defense.
3.) That right can be either/or, or both concealed or open, but one *must* be available to *ALL* common citizens. May issue policies are wholly unconstitutional.
Today is an EXCITING day.
I predict that SCOTUS will grant cert to Drake (New Jersey) and Peruta will not be heard en banc.
Assuming Peruta stands, how will you go about attacking Hawaii.
134-9 is obviously not suitable to this decision. 134-9 deems that in an uncommon occurance that one may be issued an open carry license and in an exceptional case, a CCW license may be granted. This will have to be struck.
Second point, it seems they would be free to issue you either an OC or CCW license, you wouldn't be able to demand one or the other, but at least one. HI would probably go with CCW.
Third point, the county restriction is an undue burden, if the state's limited public safety interested is satisfied by one chief issuing you a license, then it should be valid statewide.
Not to get ahead of myself, but if 134-9 is either replaced or an alternative to a newly created shall-issue statewide CCW law, PLEASE, do not forget about non-residents, if Hawaii doesn't want to recognize out of state licenses then perhaps they can have non-residents mail applications to the AG or the Department of Safety.
Just some thoughts.
-
Boo-YAH!!
-
GREAT news. Thanks for the updates and effort you put forward. We all appreciate it. :shaka: CC in Hawaii soon fingers crossed
-
Today is an EXCITING day.
I predict that SCOTUS will grant cert to Drake (New Jersey) and Peruta will not be heard en banc.
Assuming Peruta stands, how will you go about attacking Hawaii.
134-9 is obviously not suitable to this decision. 134-9 deems that in an uncommon occurance that one may be issued an open carry license and in an exceptional case, a CCW license may be granted. This will have to be struck.
Second point, it seems they would be free to issue you either an OC or CCW license, you wouldn't be able to demand one or the other, but at least one. HI would probably go with CCW.
Third point, the county restriction is an undue burden, if the state's limited public safety interested is satisfied by one chief issuing you a license, then it should be valid statewide.
Not to get ahead of myself, but if 134-9 is either replaced or an alternative to a newly created shall-issue statewide CCW law, PLEASE, do not forget about non-residents, if Hawaii doesn't want to recognize out of state licenses then perhaps they can have non-residents mail applications to the AG or the Department of Safety.
Just some thoughts.
We still need to wait on the decision in Baker v. Kealoha then we'll see where it goes. For Chicago, the city had a set time period to get a new law on the books.
-
We still need to wait on the decision in Baker v. Kealoha then we'll see where it goes. For Chicago, the city had a set time period to get a new law on the books.
True, but keep in mind that Illinois had no carry system. They would have to had basically deputize people as peace officers to be able to carry. CA and HI are different in that they have laws already on the books for permits. While an intern period probably would be granted, it would most likely be shorter.
-
Great News !
Is it time to organize the Great Hawaii CCW application day ?
Class action anyone if Peruta stands and Hawaii fails to fall in line ?
If we can assert that HI doesn't grant anyone CCW permits on principal, and we don't have open carry, I would think we'd have a good chance to prevail.
We could also address the dissenting opinion at the same time, since they're saying the court should only be addressing CCW, not the right to bear.
( I didn't read the actuall opinions, just the links from Tom which seemed very informative. Thanks Tom. but it still means I'm ignorant. )
Keep up the good fight Chris, and thanks from all of us for the work you're doing ! :shaka:
-
Great News !
Is it time to organize the Great Hawaii CCW application day ?
Class action anyone if Peruta stands and Hawaii fails to fall in line ?
If we can assert that HI doesn't grant anyone CCW permits on principal, and we don't have open carry, I would think we'd have a good chance to prevail.
We could also address the dissenting opinion at the same time, since they're saying the court should only be addressing CCW, not the right to bear.
( I didn't read the actuall opinions, just the links from Tom which seemed very informative. Thanks Tom. but it still means I'm ignorant. )
Keep up the good fight Chris, and thanks from all of us for the work you're doing ! :shaka:
If Peruta stands, you will have carry in Hawaii sooner rather than later.
Let's just hope they don't opt for shall issue open carry with the hope of ostracizing people and intimidating them from carrying. This could happen but it seems unlikely.
People OC in Guam and it's been accepted for the most part. You would think they would offer them a CCW permit in Guam but they haven't... But at least they have a mode of carry.... Soon HI will too :)
-
Great News !
Is it time to organize the Great Hawaii CCW application day ?
Class action anyone if Peruta stands and Hawaii fails to fall in line ?
If we can assert that HI doesn't grant anyone CCW permits on principal, and we don't have open carry, I would think we'd have a good chance to prevail.
We could also address the dissenting opinion at the same time, since they're saying the court should only be addressing CCW, not the right to bear.
( I didn't read the actuall opinions, just the links from Tom which seemed very informative. Thanks Tom. but it still means I'm ignorant. )
Keep up the good fight Chris, and thanks from all of us for the work you're doing ! :shaka:
Let's do this Jeff!! Take a day off from work to stand in line for a good cause!
-
:shaka: :thumbsup:
-
If this goes up to SCOTUS, pray that no one on the bench retires before then.
-
If this goes up to SCOTUS, pray that no one on the bench retires before then.
This. But great news no doubt!8)
-
:thumbsup:
This news calls for a beer!
Superbowl Beer Review (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FR7NnKU_1zw#ws)
:shaka:
-
Not to get ahead of myself, but if 134-9 is either replaced or an alternative to a newly created shall-issue statewide CCW law, PLEASE, do not forget about non-residents, if Hawaii doesn't want to recognize out of state licenses then perhaps they can have non-residents mail applications to the AG or the Department of Safety.
There is no residency requirement. The only thing HPD said is that people need to apply in person, because they are going to see you sign the paperwork and print you. That's what was told to me a while ago. Technically, when I applied I was a non resident military.
-
All this legal stuff makes my brain hurt, but from what I can tell things are looking up. Thank you for all your hard work.
-
There is no residency requirement. The only thing HPD said is that people need to apply in person, because they are going to see you sign the paperwork and print you. That's what was told to me a while ago. Technically, when I applied I was a non resident military.
Right. I was assuming if the state is forced to go shall issue and they adopted the bill that Sam Slom has been pushing for years. That bill requires residency. I was just thinking 3 steps ahead :)
I just hope they don't bounce your case due to Your LEOSA coverage.
-
I cant wait. Good job Funtimes. Just no get swell head. All this no mean we even LIKE you. Just kidding. Hang in there fella's. Good job.
-
is there an estimated time when Hawaii's case will be decided on?
-
Did a bit more reading on the decision today.
By a 2-1 vote, the three-judge panel of the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said California was wrong to require applicants to show good cause to receive a permit to carry a concealed weapon.
"The right to bear arms includes the right to carry an operable firearm outside the home for the lawful purpose of self-defense." Judge O'Scannlain
Since Hawaii is a part of the 9th circuit like California, if this goes through, we'll have cc. I doubt this will go to scotus. If scotus were to go against this, it means all the other states with shall issue cc are incorrect.
-
is there an estimated time when Hawaii's case will be decided on?
Soon (tm).
-
Right. I was assuming if the state is forced to go shall issue and they adopted the bill that Sam Slom has been pushing for years. That bill requires residency. I was just thinking 3 steps ahead :)
I just hope they don't bounce your case due to Your LEOSA coverage.
I can say with 100% honesty I cannot carry yet. So it's not an issue. Even if it was, it's still recommended by all agencies to get carry permits to avoid things like GFSZ etc.
-
Since Hawaii is a part of the 9th circuit like California, if this goes through, we'll have cc. I doubt this will go to scotus.
It probably will since the different circuit courts are coming to different conclusions about a federal constitutional right. This is ripe for a supreme court decision to unify the different decisions.
If scotus were to go against this, it means all the other states with shall issue cc are incorrect.
Not necessarily. It would mean it is up to the state to decide if you can carry. If the supreme court rules that self defense outside the home is not a a right, the states can still allow carry, it just wouldn't be a right guaranteed bu the 2nd amendment. The crux here is that Heller and MacDonald said that owning a gun in the home for self-defense is protected by the second amendment. This case says that carrying a gun ("bearing arms") is also protected by the second amendment. They basically say either open carry or conceal carry. States have to allow one. California and Hawaii allow neither.
Once again, I'll refer to Eugene Volokh's excellent analysis:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2014/02/13/more-on-the-reasoning-of-the-ninth-circuits-right-to-carry-a-gun-opinion/ (http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2014/02/13/more-on-the-reasoning-of-the-ninth-circuits-right-to-carry-a-gun-opinion/)
-
If the court ruled a choice between concealed or open by choice of the State, How does that pan out? Meaning if a State decides concealed is all they will allow how does one conceal a rifle/shot gun? How is it they could conclude that at least one must be allowed, why not both are expected? That really makes no sense as it can be used to reduce the type of weapons that are carried while further adding to the illusion of an arms free society further exacerbating the intolerance of arms by hiding them. Whereas open carry will cause less people to want to carry...allowing only one form of carry enables the State to manipulate/infringe upon the second amendment in what ever direction they feel more inclined. They can either reduce the number of firearms in public by making them mandatory visible or continue exacerbating the arms intolerance through hiding their existence while disallowing rifles and shotguns. I see that part of the ruling as another form of long term eventual detriment to the carry amendment and flawed at its core with regard to potential alienation of rifles and shotguns (long guns). Perhaps the justice hadn't completely thought that part through to its inevitable end? Anyhow... I'm happy to see some adherence to our Constitution beginning to guide this matter. A rightful ruling overall.
-
If the court ruled a choice between concealed or open by choice of the State, How does that pan out? Meaning if a State decides concealed is all they will allow how does one conceal a rifle/shot gun? How is it they could conclude that at least one must be allowed, why not both are expected? That really makes no sense as it can be used to reduce the type of weapons that are carried while further adding to the illusion of an arms free society further exacerbating the intolerance of arms by hiding them. Whereas open carry will cause less people to want to carry...allowing only one form of carry enables the State to manipulate/infringe upon the second amendment in what ever direction they feel more inclined. They can either reduce the number of firearms in public by making them mandatory visible or continue exacerbating the arms intolerance through hiding their existence while disallowing rifles and shotguns. I see that part of the ruling as another form of long term eventual detriment to the carry amendment and flawed at its core with regard to potential alienation of rifles and shotguns (long guns). Perhaps the justice hadn't completely thought that part through to its inevitable end? Anyhow... I'm happy to see some adherence to our Constitution beginning to guide this matter. A rightful ruling overall.
Concealed carry is NEVER legal for long guns, only pistols & revolvers. A long gun would merely have to be carried unloaded in a case for transport, or in places where open carry is legal, in a "non-aggressive, non-brandishing" manner. Also, you couldn't walk around with one in, say, a guitar case, loaded and ready for use.
Open carry is not as "acceptable" in some places, as some people are nervous around a firearm hanging from someones belt or slung over their shoulder while standing in line at a checkout stand.
Open carry can also make you a target. A shooter could target you first if his intent is a mass shooting, or a thief could jump you to try and steal the gun. Concealed carry would lessen those risks.
Most states that have Constitutional open carry do so for certain purposes in mind, such as wearing a handgun while hunting or working a section of land where natural predators may roam. While open carry is legal in the city as well, for the reasons stated above, it might be wiser to choose concealment.
Lastly, in states with open carry, it is not necessary to have a permit. Therefore, if you are visiting from out of state, haven't applied for CCW, and just don't carry all the time, open carry may be your only legal option if you wish to be armed.
For example, I can carry in NC when I visit, but only openly at the moment. When I receive my Maine non-resident CCW permit in the mail, I'll be legal to carry concealed in NC, too. I liked having my pistol in the center console while I drove, especially long road trips, and then being able to clip it on my belt and walk from where I parked to where I was staying. If I went out shopping or to a restaurant, I'd leave it in the trunk locked in a secured case. I can't remember seeing anyone without a badge carrying openly in public. CCW is so easy to obtain there, it just makes sense to get the permit and keep the gun out of plain view..
Any day now!! The backlog for a Maine CCW permit has been horrible. I sent the application in August, my payment cleared in October, and I was reading last week they had completed processing 5,000 backlogged applicant in January! :shake:
-
I can say with 100% honesty I cannot carry yet. So it's not an issue. Even if it was, it's still recommended by all agencies to get carry permits to avoid things like GFSZ etc.
You won't have to worry about FGFSZA in HI, you are licensed to possess a firearm simply by registering it.
In fact, that's why I only registered one of my guns in HI, because the state did a background check and licenses me to possess a gun by issuing me a registration certificate.
-
Should we apply now?
:shaka:
-Rico
-
Any day now!! The backlog for a Maine CCW permit has been horrible. I sent the application in August, my payment cleared in October, and I was reading last week they had completed processing 5,000 backlogged applicant in January! :shake:
holy smokes, i knew they had a backlog but when I got mine a year ago I got the permit maybe 2 weeks after they deposited the check. The biggest reason they have such a backlog is because I believe it is the only state where you can get a non res permit basically through the mail without any prints or anything
-
So legally speaking what does this mean for Hawaii? We have to follow the 9th circuit so do we really have to wait for our own case or can it sort of just be determined that the case would win and concealed firearm permits then be issued?
-
The 9ths first 2 opinions appear to be a very complete and well grounded opinion. What are the chances the SCOTUS will hear only those circuit opinions in conflict with the individual right that placed State safety interests (a conjecture based position) above the individual right, effectively rending the second amendment archaic (isn't that legislating from the bench?). I don't understand how any justice can justify rendering (legislating) an individual right as archaic by virtue of taking a conjecture based position of State interest above an individual right.
After seeing how the SCOTUS ruled on the ACA accepting it as a Tax when originating from the Senate ( a rather dumbfounding contradiction), I'm not so sure I could trust the SCOTUS to make a legislative free decision on these matters either.
-
So legally speaking what does this mean for Hawaii?
Looks like the Hawaii case is now a slam-dunk, unless the 9th contradicts itself.
-
This is great news Chris...thanks for all of your diligent effort!!! BTW is California worst than Hawaii from a 2A prospective...just curious on your take of two very liberal states that you have had the chance to live in?
-
This is great news Chris...thanks for all of your diligent effort!!! BTW is California worst than Hawaii from a 2A prospective...just curious on your take of two very liberal states that you have had the chance to live in?
Hawaii is no where near as bad as CA depending on where you live. If "carry" is your biggest thing, then HI would be worse. But gun / mag restrictions etc. here are way more of a pain in the ass (and more expensive).
-
Hawaii is no where near as bad as CA depending on where you live. If "carry" is your biggest thing, then HI would be worse. But gun / mag restrictions etc. here are way more of a pain in the ass (and more expensive).
I used to carry before Hawaii, so carry is a big thing, not sure about the biggest thing though. I have no love for CA gun laws, or Hawaii for that matter, and how's that micro-stamping gem of a law being embraced and enforced if at all, or is that in the courts? Again just curious since you have boots on the ground, sort of speak.
-
Just read through my NRA newsletter on the 9th circuit court. This is very encouraging! Funtimes, I've been trying to follow as much as possible and truly appreciate the work you've put in and continue to do. This is monumental for Hawaii's stand on the 2nd Amendment. I'll keep positive thoughts flowing! Oh, so should we all be applying? Or do we wait?
-
If the 9th. Ruling is in favor of Baker, would it put weight on the present bills by Slom or Gabbard to pass and force a signature from Abacraper.
-
Just read an article that says everyone in the 9th circuit (like hawaii) should apply for a concealed carry license before Feb 28th. That's when the sheriff of San Diego has to decide whether to appeal to the entire 9th circuit. If they do, the ruling would be stayed until the 9th circuit decides. If HPD (or any other local official) denies the permit before the order is stayed, the person who was denied a permit would have standing in the 9th circuit.
http://www.ammoland.com/2014/02/california-hawaii-time-to-apply-for-carry-permits/#axzz2tNkVjq7b (http://www.ammoland.com/2014/02/california-hawaii-time-to-apply-for-carry-permits/#axzz2tNkVjq7b)
Any thoughts on this?
-
I'll wait until its actually official we can do it in Hawaii after Chris's case is upheld. Maybe we can all get together there on a day to apply.
-
I'll wait until its actually official we can do it in Hawaii after Chris's case is upheld. Maybe we can all get together there on a day to apply.
:thumbsup:
-
Great News !
Is it time to organize the Great Hawaii CCW application day ?
Boy, I'd like to see that! (Talk about the "How's the line at Honolulu PD?" thread!)
Here's hoping it all goes as we're hoping.
Especial thanks to Chris for pushing on this subject as well.
-
Just read an article that says everyone in the 9th circuit (like hawaii) should apply for a concealed carry license before Feb 28th. That's when the sheriff of San Diego has to decide whether to appeal to the entire 9th circuit. If they do, the ruling would be stayed until the 9th circuit decides. If HPD (or any other local official) denies the permit before the order is stayed, the person who was denied a permit would have standing in the 9th circuit.
http://www.ammoland.com/2014/02/california-hawaii-time-to-apply-for-carry-permits/#axzz2tNkVjq7b (http://www.ammoland.com/2014/02/california-hawaii-time-to-apply-for-carry-permits/#axzz2tNkVjq7b)
Any thoughts on this?
The IL court did not stay the order; they only gave the legislature time to make a policy. I don't see any specific reason this should get stayed. Many other places in California are shall issue already. There are quite a few suggesting that it would only get stayed if En Banc was granted.
-
I'm Chris's lawyer along with RIck Holcomb. Do not apply for a CCW right now. You will just be denied. Wait until at least Baker comes out.
As for carrying long arms, that issue is going to be resolved in Young. Hawaii conceded that Hawaii's complete ban on carrying rifles and shotguns is unconstitutional.
Still you'll have to wait for a decision in Young for that concession to mean anything.
-
Not to muddy the waters, but it just occurred to me. Since every (legal) gun owner in HI has already jumped through the background checks, etc. to even own a firearm (or maybe just handguns), wouldn't that make every owner in HI automatically eligible for a carry permit upon a "final" favorable decision by the Court(s)?
After all, haven't you already "presented yourselves in person," "at room so-and-so" at "such-and-such building," etc. and been pre-qualified for shall-issue that way?
Dumb mainlander here, not very familiar with the hoops you've got to jump through, asking what is probably a dumb question.
Terry
-
From an NRA link to a FOX News article on this subject:
While the 7th Circuit court of Appeals came to a similar decision as this court, cases for other states such as Maryland,
New York, and New Jersey have come out quite differently and let the states decide if people have a “good reason” to protect
themselves. This almost guarantees that a case will find its way to the Supreme Court.
Fox’s John Stossel, who has faced many death threats, was denied the right to carry a concealed handgun permit in
New York City (the segment on Fox News is almost amusing).
This case is unlikely to be the only time that courts step in to rein in California’s extreme gun control laws. While Californians
may soon have the right to carry a concealed handgun, the micro-stamping law, requiring a microscopic marking onto the tip
of the firing pin that etches a marking on the ejected cartridges, is proving impossible to comply with.
The ultimate question is: do only the most privileged have the right to defend themselves? Thursday's decision by the 9th Circuit says “no.”
http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2014/02/13/it-may-soon-be-easy-to-carry-permitted-concealed-handgun-in-california/ (http://www.foxnews.com/opinion/2014/02/13/it-may-soon-be-easy-to-carry-permitted-concealed-handgun-in-california/)
-
Here is my email just sent to all the Hawaii State Senators, with the list of email addresses at the end. I'm curious to see what they will do, but given history there will be extremely serious foot dragging. :geekdanc: :shaka:
Dear Senator,
As a public servant, I'm asking you to do your duty to uphold your sworn allegiance to abide by and enforce the Constitution.
Please support one of the currently pending "Shall Issue" Concealed Carry bills (SB2168 or SB2353) (hopefully) coming before the appropriate Senate Committees in the very near future.
Please use whatever influence you may have to encourage committee chairpersons to schedule hearings, and then encourage all committee members to recommend the bill(s) out of committee.
As I'm sure you know the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, which applies to Hawaii law, has ruled on February 13, 2014 in Peruta, et. al. v. County of San Diego that the necessity of showing "good cause" in order to acquire a concealed carry permit is unconstitutional. While the specific Hawaii case, Baker v. Kealoha decision has not been announced yet, the premises of Hawaii law regarding this issue are essentially the same ("exceptional case") as the unconstitutional "good cause" requirement. And the results are the same: NO PERSONS in the last 10 years in the entire state of Hawaii not employed as security company personnel have been granted concealed carry permits (to the best of the publics ability to ascertain such information). Thus the Hawaii "exceptional case" requirement, resulting in 100% denial of concealed carry permits to civilians, is unconstitutional, as it de facto bans the Second Amendment guaranteed right to self defense by "bear[ing] arms". The Ninth Circuit ruled that "self defense" alone is constitutional justification requiring issuance of a concealed carry permit (which allows "bearing"), assuming the applicant is not a prohibited person according to the other currently existing criteria for that classification.
It is thus your duty, as you have sworn to uphold the Constitution, to invalidate Hawaii's currently unconstitutional law, and replace it immediately with a constitutional one ("shall issue") that will allow law-abiding Hawaii citizens to carry a concealed weapon for self defense purposes.
The fact that there are over 8 MILLION current concealed carry permit holders in the United States, and that as a group they have a lower rate of criminal activity than both the general public and (even lower than) law enforcement officers. The rate of crime has almost always gone down when locales have instituted "shall issue" concealed carry laws, as one would suspect, given that criminals no longer know that every single person they view in public as a potential victim is unarmed, and thus the criminal is more likely to risk failure at their criminal enterprise, or even serious injury should they just happen to select a concealed carry permit holder as a potential victim. Thus the "public safety" interest is enhanced by concealed carry, and ought to be instituted as "shall issue" even if the overwhelming requirement of constitutionality was not present.
Do your job: Serve the public. Abide by the Constitution. Institute "shall issue" concealed carry.
thank you,
senbaker@capitol.hawaii.gov,
senchunoakland@capitol.hawaii.gov,
sendelacruz@capitol.hawaii.gov,
senenglish@capitol.hawaii.gov,
senespero@capitol.hawaii.gov,
sengabbard@capitol.hawaii.gov,
sengaluteria@capitol.hawaii.gov,
sengreen@capitol.hawaii.gov,
senhee@capitol.hawaii.gov,
sendige@capitol.hawaii.gov,
senihara@capitol.hawaii.gov,
senkahele@capitol.hawaii.gov,
senkeithagaran@capitol.hawaii.gov,
senkidani@capitol.hawaii.gov,
senkim@Capitol.hawaii.gov,
senkouchi@Capitol.hawaii.gov,
sennishihara@capitol.hawaii.gov,
senruderman@capitol.hawaii.gov,
senshimabukuro@capitol.hawaii.gov,
senslom@capitol.hawaii.gov,
sensolomon@capitol.hawaii.gov,
sentaniguchi@capitol.hawaii.gov,
senthielen@capitol.hawaii.gov,
sentokuda@capitol.hawaii.gov,
senwakai@capitol.hawaii.gov
-
thanks for clearing that up wolfwood. sure would be nice to have a legal truck gun
-
Not to muddy the waters, but it just occurred to me. Since every (legal) gun owner in HI has already jumped through the background checks, etc. to even own a firearm (or maybe just handguns), wouldn't that make every owner in HI automatically eligible for a carry permit upon a "final" favorable decision by the Court(s)?
After all, haven't you already "presented yourselves in person," "at room so-and-so" at "such-and-such building," etc. and been pre-qualified for shall-issue that way?
Dumb mainlander here, not very familiar with the hoops you've got to jump through, asking what is probably a dumb question.
Terry
You have to bring photos of yourself (for the license), pay $10.00, and fill out the application with the firearms you will carry. That's pretty much it.
-
Hawaii is no where near as bad as CA depending on where you live. If "carry" is your biggest thing, then HI would be worse. But gun / mag restrictions etc. here are way more of a pain in the ass (and more expensive).
True enough Chris.
I am now half owner in a place in Sacramento, and the wife and I have toyed with the idea of moving to America.
My collection of rifles and pistols may or may not pass CA muster. I makes the Oregon coast look better.
-
Please keep the discussion going. I am learning as I read. Cant wait till I apply for CCW.
-
Not to muddy the waters, but it just occurred to me. Since every (legal) gun owner in HI has already jumped through the background checks, etc. to even own a firearm (or maybe just handguns), wouldn't that make every owner in HI automatically eligible for a carry permit upon a "final" favorable decision by the Court(s)?
After all, haven't you already "presented yourselves in person," "at room so-and-so" at "such-and-such building," etc. and been pre-qualified for shall-issue that way?
Dumb mainlander here, not very familiar with the hoops you've got to jump through, asking what is probably a dumb question.
Terry
This would not exactly qualify you for a carry permit. Some states also require you to have specific training to get a concealed carry permit. The Maine concealed carry permit I have required me to take a NRA handgun class as one of the requirements, or you may also demonstrate proper handgun safety to someone like the police chief in your local town. I took the NRA pistol class here in Hawaii primarily for the purpose of getting my Maine CWP, but also as a way to introduce my girlfriend to firearms as I made her take it with me, which she really enjoyed btw! Maine also does not care what guns you plan to carry so they do not ask for that information but some states do. I saw a NY state permit that had each of the handguns listed on the back of the permit.
I would assume that a state such as Hawaii would require some kind of specific training. In many states you can open carry without any permit at all. Then again, in many states you can walk into a gun store buy whatever the hell you want and leave there 10 minutes later gun in hand with only filling out the ATF 4473 form we all know that is not the case here.
-
Hopefully our NRA certified firearms training for handguns will cover it. Idk why it shouldn't. It proves we demonstrated safe handling and operation of a firearm and were taught about the laws.
-
Hopefully our NRA certified firearms training for handguns will cover it. Idk why it shouldn't. It proves we demonstrated safe handling and operation of a firearm and were taught about the laws.
If I were to guess, I would say no because they would probably require stuff specific to CCW and any legal stuff pertaining to it. I just can't imagine they would make it easy for anyone, especially since in reality, they don't want anyone to have one to begin with. Just my opinion.
-
Hopefully our NRA certified firearms training for handguns will cover it. Idk why it shouldn't. It proves we demonstrated safe handling and operation of a firearm and were taught about the laws.
Other than the handgun fundamentals, I would say that people need a completely different course of training for CCW. Whether or not the state requires that we would see (they would, we know they would). I'm more of a fan of the Arizona style licensing. Constitutional carry for most areas, and then permitted carry in dense zones which requires training (schools, entertainment venues etc.).
-
19 states petition SCOTUS re "justifiable need" for CCW... sound familiar?
From TTAG, with hyperlinks to original material, at http://www.thetruthaboutguns.com/2014/02/matt-in-fl/weekend-digest-215/#more-297219: (http://www.thetruthaboutguns.com/2014/02/matt-in-fl/weekend-digest-215/#more-297219:)
The Wyoming Attorney General’s Office, acting as counsel for Wyoming and 18 other states, filed an amicus brief on Wednesday asking the U.S. Supreme Court to grant a hearing in the case of Drake v. Jerejian, a New Jersey case which has at issue “(1) Whether the Second Amendment secures a right to carry handguns outside the home for self-defense; and (2) whether state officials violate the Second Amendment by requiring that individuals wishing to exercise their right to carry a handgun for self-defense first prove a “justifiable need” for doing so.” The Wyoming brief says that the 19 states are concerned that if the appeals court ruling stands, it could threaten their less restrictive concealed carry laws.” The NRA has also filed a brief in support of the case. The other states joining in the brief are Alabama, Alaska, Arizona, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Michigan, Missouri, Nebraska, New Mexico, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota and West Virginia.
-
And for another view of the issue (I'd pay to see her come to Hawaii and debate Abercrombie on Second Amendment issues... how much more different could two governors be?):
SC Governor Haley Supports Constitutional Carry
By Dean Weingarten on February 15, 2014
Hot on the heels of signing a bill allowing concealed carry in South Carolina bars and restaurants, Governor Nikki Haley has come out in favor of dropping the permitting process altogether. The idea is to restore the right to carry arms without government permission. According to thestate.com, ”Nikki Haley said Tuesday that she backs a proposal that would make it legal for most South Carolinians to carry guns – concealed or in the open – without a permit or the training that the state currently requires.[emphasis added]” . . .
Constitutional carry is currently the law in five states and is being considered in several others. No problems have been noted in those states that can be attributed to the restoration of full Second Amendment carry rights.
State Sen. Lee Bright, R-Spartanburg, the chief sponsor of the constitutional-carry proposal, says the 2nd Amendment gives Americans the right to carry firearms without any government restrictions.
As usual, there are the “I support the second amendment, but” naysayers. Chief among them appears to be Senator Larry Martin R-Pickens, who is the head of the Senate Judiciary Committee, where the constitutional carry bill is currently bottled up. He’s credited with killing constitutional carry last year. Here’s the money quote, emphasis added:
“Is it (carrying firearms) a right under our Constitution? Sure it is. But it’s also a huge responsibility that we as citizens should respect.”
Respect does not mean we must allow the government to charge us fees and require us to attend classes and essentially prove that we are not criminals before we can exercise our rights. That’s what’s known as prior restraint.
©2014 by Dean Weingarten: Permission to share is granted when this notice is included.
Gun Watch
From (with hyperlinks to original material): http://www.thetruthaboutguns.com/2014/02/dean-weingarten/sc-governor-haley-supports-constitutional-carry/#more-296555 (http://www.thetruthaboutguns.com/2014/02/dean-weingarten/sc-governor-haley-supports-constitutional-carry/#more-296555)
-
I'm Chris's lawyer along with RIck Holcomb. Do not apply for a CCW right now. You will just be denied. Wait until at least Baker comes out.
As for carrying long arms, that issue is going to be resolved in Young. Hawaii conceded that Hawaii's complete ban on carrying rifles and shotguns is unconstitutional.
Still you'll have to wait for a decision in Young for that concession to mean anything.
Thanks Wolfwood.
-
All very hopeful, nevertheless if ruling is upheld, and Hawaii politicians being what they are, I'd expect a torrent of legislative end runs designed to thwart the effectiveness of carry laws. Probably in the realm of not allowing ammo to be kept in vicinity of carried weapons or some such nonsense.
-
I'm Chris's lawyer along with RIck Holcomb. Do not apply for a CCW right now. You will just be denied. Wait until at least Baker comes out.
As for carrying long arms, that issue is going to be resolved in Young. Hawaii conceded that Hawaii's complete ban on carrying rifles and shotguns is unconstitutional.
Still you'll have to wait for a decision in Young for that concession to mean anything.
Thanks wolfwood. I was wondering if there was a date set for all of us to meet and apply on the same day.O0
Please keep us posted. Happy Aloha Sunday Gang!
-
Thanx to punaperson for a great letter. :thumbsup: :thumbsup: :thumbsup:
I modified it slightly, just so it's not identical, and sent to each and every senator.
-
Thanx to punaperson for a great letter. :thumbsup: :thumbsup: :thumbsup:
I modified it slightly, just so it's not identical, and sent to each and every senator.
You're welcome. Just thought I'd share it and the easily paste-able senate email list in case other people want them to know that we are watching what they do, or, more likely, don't do. I'm not expecting any action will be taken until the courts demand the legislature end the unconstitutional current laws. I suppose it's possible that someone besides Senator Slom, and possibly Senator Gabbard, could voice support for the Peruta decision and the fact that the exact same legal reasoning applies to Hawaii's "no issue" concealed carry policy.
I modified the second paragraph/sentence slightly and sent it to all the representatives:
Please support one of the currently pending "Shall Issue" Concealed Carry bills (SB2168 or SB2353) (hopefully) coming before the appropriate Senate Committees in the very near future. I'm asking that you lobby for these bills with your Senate colleagues and that you then support whatever form the bill(s) take when taken up by House committees and the full House.
repcachola@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repaquino@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repawana@Capitol.hawaii.gov,
repfale@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repbelatti@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repbrower@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repcabanilla@Capitol.hawaii.gov,
repcachola@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repcarroll@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repchoy@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repcreagan@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repcullen@capitol.hawaii.gov,
reping@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repevans@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repfukumoto@capitol.hawaii.gov,
rephanohano@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repito@capitol.hawaii.gov,
rephar@capitol.hawaii.gov,
rephashem@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repichiyama@capitol.hawaii.gov,
reping@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repito@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repjohanson@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repjordan@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repkawakami@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repkobayashi@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repclee@capitol.hawaii.gov,
replowen@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repluke@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repmatsumoto@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repmcdermott@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repmckelvey@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repmizuno@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repmorikawa@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repnakashima@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repnishimoto@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repohno@capitol.hawaii.gov,
reponishi@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repmoshiro@capitol.hawaii.gov,,
reprhoads@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repsaiki@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repsay@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repsouki@capitol.hawaii.gov,
reptakai@capitol.hawaii.gov,
reptakayama@capitol.hawaii.gov,
reptakumi@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repthielen@capitol.hawaii.gov,
reptokioka@capitol.hawaii.gov,
reptsuji@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repward@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repwoodson@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repwooley@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repyamane@capitol.hawaii.gov,
repyamashita@capitol.hawaii.gov
-
Hopefully our NRA certified firearms training for handguns will cover it. Idk why it shouldn't. It proves we demonstrated safe handling and operation of a firearm and were taught about the laws.
NRA has a separate class that covers carry. Basic Pistol does not, and is not intended to, prepare you for carrying open or concealed. Should the state legislature think to ask, NRA will certainly tell them that Basic Pistol doesn't cover it, and HRA will be obliged to also support that party line. No, when shall-issue comes to Hawaii, expect to see new training requirements.
-
No, when shall-issue comes to Hawaii, expect to see new training requirements.
Hi Tom... wondering if you might have a wild guess as to what the total cost might end up being to be a legal CCW "permit/license" holder in Hawaii, should that ever happen. :shaka:
-
Wild guess? Nah. However, if the leg were to decide that NRA classes fit the bill, I would expect those classes to be rather affordable. Since you would be supplying the gun and (most likely) the ammo, most of the overhead disappears.
However....
Under the current structure, you must take a series of classes:
Personal Protection Inside the Home (8 hours)
Personal Protection Outside the Home, Level 1 (9 hours)
Personal Protection Outside the Home, Level 2 (5 hours) (optional, but I think it likely Hawaii would mandate this)
Even with low overhear, 3 days of training is going to have some cost. NRA is currently developing a new class called Defensive Pistol, which will hopefully be a more streamlined approach.
[EDIT]
Oh, I forgot... there is a section of PPOTH that must be taught by a practicing attorney, or LEO, or someone qualified to teach said laws in the state. That will probably run the cost up a little.
-
So, what would be the ballpark figure for this 3 day course? $300?
-
Even with low overhear, 3 days of training is going to have some cost. NRA is currently developing a new class called Defensive Pistol, which will hopefully be a more streamlined approach.
If you include photos, fingerprints, and a "fee" (of up to $100 in Gabbard's SB2353 CCW bill), and the "training", it looks like it'd be pushing $500. I don't know of any other fundamental individual inalienable natural and civil rights guaranteed by the Constitution that cost that much (or anywhere near that much) to get permission from the government to exercise. Where's the bill to have Hawaii join the five other states that have "Constitutional Carry"?
Oh, I forgot, one step at a time. :geekdanc:
One of the emails I sent to legislators re the current CCW bills is that the high cost of obtaining a "license" is clearly a discriminatory impediment to lower income people being able to exercise a Constitutional right. $500 is a LOT of money to a LOT of people. Even $400.
-
Copied it, pasted it, sent it. Now for the reply.
-
So, what would be the ballpark figure for this 3 day course? $300?
I'm not going to make up numbers. But we can do a comparison. Most local sources run $100 - $150 for the Basic Pistol (or equivalent) class. If you simply triple that, you get the $300 - $450 range. But it's not that straightforward. Unlike Basic Pistol, it would be reasonable to ask students to supply their own ammo for PPITH and PPOTH, so expenses drop. And students will need to provide their own firearms, so again, expenses drop. Then you have to turn around and pay a lawyer, or LEO, for an hour or two of their time, which is an all new expense. And there is always insurance and classroom materials.
If you had an outfit where all the instructors were volunteers AND they had a volunteer attorney/LEO for the laws, and were allowed to use the public range, I could see it being as little as $75. If you were dealing with a commercial enterprise, had to pay full lawyer's rates, and use a private range, I could see it being as high as $800.
-
It would be nice if there was some allowance for people with out-of-state CCW licenses to skip some of the training. :geekdanc:
-
[EDIT]
Oh, I forgot... there is a section of PPOTH that must be taught by a practicing attorney, or LEO, or someone qualified to teach said laws in the state. That will probably run the cost up a little.
Which is exactly why we should lobby against any additional training requirements structured under the NRA. And, instead, go by requirements that are "Use of a holster" "drawing a weapon" and scoring requirement with a set time frame (8 hours course).
Going with one specific brand is garbage; on top of that - I can't really say that NRA courses are the pinnacle of firearms training.
-
So, what would be the ballpark figure for this 3 day course? $300?
Well first, a 3 day course is bullshit. That should not be required. John Lott has data that as soon as you hit 9 hours (day 2), about 1/2 the people drop off. It just gets worse.
For gun training, from a lower qualified instructor, you are looking at about $150 dollars a day. Will people do it for less - sure.
-
Which is exactly why we should lobby against any additional training requirements structured under the NRA. And, instead, go by requirements that are "Use of a holster" "drawing a weapon" and scoring requirement with a set time frame (8 hours course).
Going with one specific brand is garbage; on top of that - I can't really say that NRA courses are the pinnacle of firearms training.
As someone who teaches for a living, I can honestly say I have NEVER had someone else hand me a curriculum that I 100% agreed with. This is also true of NRA. Their classes, at least the ones I have experience with (which are about half the roster), have a LOT of good content in them. And they have some strange restrictions. And a few things that are just poorly-thought-out. Pinnacle of firearms training? No. Mighty fine classes with good resource materials and organization? Absolutely. A curriculum that a competent instructor can feel certain will cover the essentials? Again, absolutely.
I agree that the current structure, requiring two days with an optional third, is onerous. We're all hoping that the new class, when it is revealed, will make more sense. Will that be true, and will it happen before Hawaii gets shall-issue? Unknowns.
But NRA is the recognized standard for civilian firearms training. For good or ill, it's the first name that pops to mind when people wonder "Gee, where should I turn to get instruction on how to use my gun?"
Now, if we are lucky and diligent, any new requirements will be worded like the current ones, requiring a class that is taught by a certified instructor (NRA certification would be one option), and requiring certain elements like you mentioned (laws, holster, accuracy come to mind), but not actually specifying a curriculum.
-
Well first, a 3 day course is bullshit. That should not be required. John Lott has data that as soon as you hit 9 hours (day 2), about 1/2 the people drop off. It just gets worse.
For gun training, from a lower qualified instructor, you are looking at about $150 dollars a day. Will people do it for less - sure.
my fear is that even if we get "shall issue", the requirements will be high and there will be no reciprocity
-
my fear is that even if we get "shall issue", the requirements will be high and there will be no reciprocity
If other states that were unwillingly dragged into "shall issue" by the courts (e.g. Illinois) are any example, I can only imagine the absurd impediments that have already been "brain stormed" by the Second Amendment opponents in our public servant offices (legislators, police, attorney general, governor, etc.). And I can only imagine the hours and dollars that will be involved to exercise a fundamental civil right guaranteed by the Constitution. But then I'm a cynical old geezer. Perhaps they will be "reasonable" and generous and actually act according to a rational evaluation of the evidence and the law. :rofl:
-
Copied it, pasted it, sent it. Now for the reply.
I did the same...Modified the original letter and sent to the representatives.
-
This graphically illustrates the government of Hawaii's attempt to remain an extreme minority bastion of unconstitutional subversion of the right to keep and bear arms.
Article written by Dave Kopel at the Volokh Conspiracy blog at the Washington Post: http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2014/02/17/growth-chart-of-right-to-carry/ (http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp/2014/02/17/growth-chart-of-right-to-carry/)
Let's hope Peruta is upheld.
(http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/volokh-conspiracy/wp-content/uploads/sites/14/2014/02/image001-carry.png)
-
So, we have laws being overturned in California, Illinois, and DC recently where the courts declared the laws to be unconstitutional.
Logically, if the legislators who passed, and the executive officer who signed, these laws into existence were upholding their oath of office, we would never have a need to do this with a few rare exceptions! All laws would have already been scrutinized to ensure they abide by the Constitution well before passage.
What we are seeing is a Liberal agenda to pass these unconstitutional laws, then force citizens or states to contest them in court -- a lengthy and costly proposal.
These are the same law makers who swear on a Bible to support and defend the Constitution.... but don't worry! They all support the Second Amendment, too!
-
Logically, if the legislators who passed, and the executive officer who signed, these laws into existence were upholding their oath of office, we would never have a need to do this with a few rare exceptions! All laws would have already been scrutinized to ensure they abide by the Constitution well before passage.
It appears impossible for ideologue legislators/politicians to understand that "keep and bears arms" actually means "keep and bear arms". I mean, really, how difficult is that to comprehend? I suppose if your starting point is "no civilian ought to be able to own/possess firearms", then you must define "the people" and "keep and bear arms" in such a narrow way that it actually makes no sense. Politicians making no sense in order to impose their agenda, imagine that. >:(
-
The reason we see this sort of unconstitutional legislation is because there is no personal consequences for violating the Constitution through a legislators vote. It is true that they do have the right to vote their conscience but their conscience is supposed to be principally bound by the Constitution. Thus an outright test (vote) against the Constitution is nothing less than an assault upon the Constitution unless cast through Constitutional amendment procedures. The way I see it is at minimum - a legislator who votes in favor of an unconstitutional bill that is later decreed unconstitutional by the Courts should then automatically lose their seat, lose all benefits derived from such service, be barred from all political activities as well a forfeiture to the right to vote and contribute to any campaign fund. Barred from all political activities for the remainder of their lives.
As it stands today... the legislative as well as the executive branch have overburdened the judiciary, rendering it largely ineffective, thus we have a clear breakdown in the check and balances. If there were ample consequences for voting in favor of unconstitutional legislation our checks and balances could be restored, the judiciary burdens relieved and the allure to office by unscrupulous personality types reduced substantially.
In the early days of this country, the population was largely driven by integrity and those who veered from such integrity were automatically ostracized. Today we've lost that integrity and we're not going to reclaim it until the expectations to conduct one self with integrity is re-enforced.
-
I would like to see a compromise:
1. Take a defensive carry training course (and passing a written/live fire test)
or
2. Take a written exam and a live fire test, consisting of safely firing from the holster, hitting 7 out of 10 rounds on a silhouette target at 10 yards.
-
The way I see it is at minimum - a legislator who votes in favor of an unconstitutional bill that is later decreed unconstitutional by the Courts should then automatically lose their seat, lose all benefits derived from such service, be barred from all political activities as well a forfeiture to the right to vote and contribute to any campaign fund. Barred from all political activities for the remainder of their lives.
I really like that idea. My predictions on the House and Senate votes on a bill to implement such an idea: House 44 nays to 7 ayes: defeated; Senate 23 nays to 2 ayes: defeated. Common excuse: "I shouldn't be held responsible for some activist judge revisioning the Constitution. Next thing you know some judge will declare that "keep and bear arms" means "keep and bear arms". That's outrageous!"
-
It's an election year.....now is the time to vote these "fuggers" out! PERIOD!
-
I really like that idea. My predictions on the House and Senate votes on a bill to implement such an idea: House 44 nays to 7 ayes: defeated; Senate 23 nays to 2 ayes: defeated. Common excuse: "I shouldn't be held responsible for some activist judge revisioning the Constitution. Next thing you know some judge will declare that "keep and bear arms" means "keep and bear arms". That's outrageous!"
Of course you're point is valid and hence outlines the necessary route for ratification.
I see a few ways of getting it through. First and foremost, it it should be adopted as a voter base litmus test accompanied by a few other new integrity based questions. For example - replacing the dead horse question of abortion with the question of a "Call to integrity" amendment (where do they (the candidate) stand?). Secondly a grass roots movement across the nation through the ballot box State by State to bring about a Constitutional Convention for such an amendment, thus circumnavigating the legislative representatives altogether. So it could be pushed through the campaigning litmus test process and become a conscience within Congress and the Executive or State by State on the ballot for Constitutional Convention. Since a Constitutional Convention has yet to place a single amendment into the Constitution, such an amendment would indeed be fitting as the first to accomplish such a task while demonstrating the ultimate power of the people. So how is it promoted? First the amendment is drafted and then promoted through alternative media, grass roots parties, such as the Tea party , Libertarian party and within the Democratic and Republican parties. I can see it as a binding catalyst in which all parties would be committing political suicide not to observe, respect and support the proposed amendment. Argument to such a litmus test question indeed displays a propensity to negate accountability on behalf of the candidate.
BTW... sorry for hijacking this thread, will pursue this elsewhere. If there's any interest. I'll let someone else nominate it as a topic if interested.
-
From Ken Klukowski, senior legal analyst for Breitbart News and on faculty at Liberty University School of Law:
San Diego may well now petition the Ninth Circuit to rehear the case en banc, meaning that eleven of the court’s judges would rehear the case. Given its heavy leftward bent, an en banc court would very likely reverse the three-judge panel.
But either way, this case is also a good candidate for Supreme Court review. Depending on whether this case goes to an en banc court, it could be before the Supreme Court in 2015 or 2016—not long before the presidential election.
Full Article: http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Government/2014/02/14/Federal-Appeals-Court-Ruling-a-Major-Pro-Gun-Victory-Could-Go-to-Supreme-Court (http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Government/2014/02/14/Federal-Appeals-Court-Ruling-a-Major-Pro-Gun-Victory-Could-Go-to-Supreme-Court)
Klukowski also appeared on the NRA News show Cam & Company on 2/14. Stephen Halbrook also appeared that day also commenting on the Peruta decision. http://www.nranews.com/cam/list/cam-company (http://www.nranews.com/cam/list/cam-company)
-
From Ken Klukowski, senior legal analyst for Breitbart News and on faculty at Liberty University School of Law:
San Diego may well now petition the Ninth Circuit to rehear the case en banc, meaning that eleven of the court’s judges would rehear the case. Given its heavy leftward bent, an en banc court would very likely reverse the three-judge panel.
But either way, this case is also a good candidate for Supreme Court review. Depending on whether this case goes to an en banc court, it could be before the Supreme Court in 2015 or 2016—not long before the presidential election.
Full Article: http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Government/2014/02/14/Federal-Appeals-Court-Ruling-a-Major-Pro-Gun-Victory-Could-Go-to-Supreme-Court (http://www.breitbart.com/Big-Government/2014/02/14/Federal-Appeals-Court-Ruling-a-Major-Pro-Gun-Victory-Could-Go-to-Supreme-Court)
Klukowski also appeared on the NRA News show Cam & Company on 2/14. Stephen Halbrook also appeared that day also commenting on the Peruta decision. http://www.nranews.com/cam/list/cam-company (http://www.nranews.com/cam/list/cam-company)
The 9th Circuit was the first court to rule that the Second Amendment was an individual right not connected to the militia. Something to think about!
-
The 9th Circuit was the first court to rule that the Second Amendment was an individual right not connected to the militia. Something to think about!
I guess every once in a while they get one right! They are the most over-ruled circuit by far (thus the common pejorative "Ninth Circus"). Let's hope this panel decision on Peruta is one of those that SCOTUS confirms rather than over-rules. I suppose Klukowski could be wrong and that even the en banc could uphold it, if it's appealed to them and accepted. It certainly seems "right" reasoning to my reading, but I'm more than a little biased.
I look at the Ninth Circuit website every morning hoping to see Baker v. Kealoha posted... gotta be soon, right? :shaka:
-
The 9th Circuit was the first court to rule that the Second Amendment was an individual right not connected to the militia. Something to think about!
Nordyke? I thought Parker (the forerunner to Heller) held that honor?
-
Nordyke? I thought Parker (the forerunner to Heller) held that honor?
Yes. Nordyke gave incorporation first - even prior to Heller! The case only lasted like a decade :P
-
When someone breaks the law, they usually get sent to jail right? Since the Constitution is the highest law of the land, shouldn't something happen to those that break and disregard the constitution?
-
When someone breaks the law, they usually get sent to jail right? Since the Constitution is the highest law of the land, shouldn't something happen to those that break and disregard the constitution?
It's too bad that it doesn't work that way.
It should though.
-
When someone breaks the law, they usually get sent to jail right? Since the Constitution is the highest law of the land, shouldn't something happen to those that break and disregard the constitution?
It's called due process. If nobody (for example, Eric Holder, the US Attorney General) investigates and files charges, then nothing happens to the oath-breaker, (fill in your own example here).