2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: suka on February 22, 2014, 10:47:21 PM

Title: Failure to ID
Post by: suka on February 22, 2014, 10:47:21 PM
Does Hawaii laws require a person to ID or present ID of themselves to an officer?
No crimes or driving involved, just walking or loitering?

a personal experience i saw ; was a man sitting at a stairwell in Waikiki minding his own business a little drunk it seems
5pm so daylight not late night.
Two beat officers approached him and asked for a picture ID.

man refused..........."I no moah".
cops replied ...."we gon bring u in"
back and forth goes the replies
blue/wht pulls up
I left.......................

Is one required by law HRS to show ID while detained , again no crime committed?
protection under the 4th Amendment?


Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Darmok and Jalad @Tanagra on February 22, 2014, 11:24:09 PM
If the encounter with police is Consensual (you are not being detained or arrested), then you are not required to answer questions, give your name, or show ID.

If being detained or arrested, you must identify yourself.  ID cards are not required to be on your person unless operating a vehicle or boarding a commercial aircraft.

If unsure whether you are being detained, you merely ask if you are free to go.  If told yes, don't ask any more questions and calmly walk away.

As far as I can find, Hawaii has no Stop & Identify laws, which would make it a crime to not show identification if asked during detention or arrest.

It's against the law to lie, so the best thing is to not say anything at all..

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop_and_Identify_statutes#States_with_.E2.80.9Cstop-and-identify.E2.80.9D_statutes (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop_and_Identify_statutes#States_with_.E2.80.9Cstop-and-identify.E2.80.9D_statutes)
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: suka on February 22, 2014, 11:29:39 PM
Local HPD
Chime in.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Funtimes on February 22, 2014, 11:38:54 PM
If you don't identify yourself with things like name / date of birth etc., you can be brought in until that identification is made.  They need to know where to write the ticket / citation / arrest.

If you aren't suspected of anything or being cited, then there is nothing you can get cuffed up for if you don't I.D.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: suka on February 22, 2014, 11:50:20 PM
found this on the Blaze whilst researching




http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2014/02/21/i-didnt-fking-do-anything-wrong-why-did-a-woman-allegedly-on-a-jog-end-up-screaming-and-in-handcuffs/ (http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2014/02/21/i-didnt-fking-do-anything-wrong-why-did-a-woman-allegedly-on-a-jog-end-up-screaming-and-in-handcuffs/)

She Allegedly Went on a Simple Jog in Her Toe Shoes. So Why Did She End Up Screaming and in Handcuffs?
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Funtimes on February 23, 2014, 12:34:36 AM
found this on the Blaze whilst researching




http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2014/02/21/i-didnt-fking-do-anything-wrong-why-did-a-woman-allegedly-on-a-jog-end-up-screaming-and-in-handcuffs/ (http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2014/02/21/i-didnt-fking-do-anything-wrong-why-did-a-woman-allegedly-on-a-jog-end-up-screaming-and-in-handcuffs/)

She Allegedly Went on a Simple Jog in Her Toe Shoes. So Why Did She End Up Screaming and in Handcuffs?

I imagined this was what you were talking about with the first post.  The girl was pretty stupid imo!
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: suka on February 23, 2014, 01:04:01 AM
Sure seems that way
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Haoleb on February 23, 2014, 06:08:22 AM
If the encounter with police is Consensual (you are not being detained or arrested), then you are not required to answer questions, give your name, or show ID.

If being detained or arrested, you must identify yourself.  ID cards are not required to be on your person unless operating a vehicle or boarding a commercial aircraft.

If unsure whether you are being detained, you merely ask if you are free to go.  If told yes, don't ask any more questions and calmly walk away.

As far as I can find, Hawaii has no Stop & Identify laws, which would make it a crime to not show identification if asked during detention or arrest.

It's against the law to lie, so the best thing is to not say anything at all..

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop_and_Identify_statutes#States_with_.E2.80.9Cstop-and-identify.E2.80.9D_statutes (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop_and_Identify_statutes#States_with_.E2.80.9Cstop-and-identify.E2.80.9D_statutes)

I think the issue is a bit more complex than this and requires one to be aware of the laws and their rights. There are endless videos of people being illegally detained. It seems like there is a great number of law enforcement across the country that really does not understand fully much of the laws they are tasked to enforce. If you know the law and feel confident in that fact however, stand your ground.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Bunker on February 23, 2014, 08:23:03 AM
Not saying this is the case...I don't know any of the details other than what the OP posted, which was he was in a stairwell in Waikiki minding his own business and a little drunk. Could this possibly be a public intoxication case, which can also be very fuzzy? Don't know what stairwell but if he was inebriated in a "deemed" public place could this potentially be interpreted in HPD's view as public intoxication? Or was the stairwell he was loitering in a private residence (condominium) that he does not reside and tenants were alarmed? Also unknown...did someone call HPD about this individual? Maybe he was doing something else prior, like being disorderly before the OPs observation.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: ren on February 23, 2014, 08:49:14 AM
Illegal immigrants got more rights than that girl!  :shake: ::)
Title: .
Post by: Q on February 23, 2014, 10:41:07 AM
.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: suka on February 23, 2014, 06:35:53 PM
From my observations

There was no probable cause.
Did not appear drunk until he spoke with a slurrd speech.

Just because he looked homeless was no reason for a so called stop and ask.

Private stairway in a normal Waikiki Terrance.

Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Dblnaknak on February 23, 2014, 07:27:26 PM
Yes you need to present an ID to an officer if so requested. You can be arrested for failure to present ID upon lawful request.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Darmok and Jalad @Tanagra on February 23, 2014, 07:42:12 PM
Yes you need to present an ID to an officer if so requested. You can be arrested for failure to present ID upon lawful request.

Describe "lawful request".  It doesn't include all circumstances.

Failure to present ID won't get you arrested, because that's not against the law here.  But lying about your identity will.  They can DETAIN you until they verify your identity.

And it's not illegal to be out without an ID unless engaging in driving or flying commercially.
Title: Failure to ID
Post by: Dblnaknak on February 23, 2014, 07:51:05 PM
Describe "lawful request".  It doesn't include all circumstances.

Failure to present ID won't get you arrested, because that's not against the law here.  But lying about your identity will.  They can DETAIN you until they verify your identity.

And it's not illegal to be out without an ID unless engaging in driving or flying commercially.

Sorry, but again, you give bad advice because you assume, again, that you have a clue. It is, in hawaii against the law to refuse to provide your ID.

I would give you the HRS but since you know everything you can go read the HRS and find it your damn self.

If an officer is asking for your id there is a reason, likely a complaint or you match a description. They are not there for fun because they have better shit to do then talk to you for no reason.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Darmok and Jalad @Tanagra on February 23, 2014, 07:52:24 PM
Sorry, but again, you give bad advice because you assume, again, that you have a clue. It is, in hawaii against the law to refuse to provide your ID.

I would give you the HRS but since you know everything you can go read the HRS and find it your damn self.

If an officer is asking for your id there is a reason, likely a complaint or you match a description. They are not there for fun because they have better shit to do then talk to you for no reason.

I call BS.  If you had the statute, you would have posted it..

 :wacko:
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Darmok and Jalad @Tanagra on February 23, 2014, 07:54:52 PM
Here's that link from earlier in this thread....since you failed to read it I'll post again.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop_and_Identify_statutes#States_with_.E2.80.9Cstop-and-identify.E2.80.9D_statutes (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop_and_Identify_statutes#States_with_.E2.80.9Cstop-and-identify.E2.80.9D_statutes)

Hawaii has no Stop & Identify law.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Dblnaknak on February 23, 2014, 08:00:47 PM

Here's that link from earlier in this thread....since you failed to read it I'll post again.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop_and_Identify_statutes#States_with_.E2.80.9Cstop-and-identify.E2.80.9D_statutes (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop_and_Identify_statutes#States_with_.E2.80.9Cstop-and-identify.E2.80.9D_statutes)

Hawaii has no Stop & Identify law.

LMAO!!! I can see it now.

(While at HPD or Sheriff Receiving getting booked)

You: Officer why did you arrest me for failure to provide ID?

Officer: because it's against the law and your an idiot.

You: but, Wikipedia said it's not required in Hawaii.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: suka on February 23, 2014, 08:40:25 PM
Lets be gentleman like and keep this to a from being locked.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Tom_G on February 23, 2014, 08:43:26 PM

I would give you the HRS but since you know everything you can go read the HRS and find it your damn self.


I'd sure like to know the statute.  Sharing of information would be a friendly gesture.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Funtimes on February 23, 2014, 08:50:13 PM
I would give you the HRS but since you know everything you can go read the HRS and find it your damn self.

I don't know everything, and I would be more than interested in seeing the statute.  Would you be kind enough to provide it? I've already searched through my available methods and I have not produced anything fruitful yet.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: survivorman on February 24, 2014, 01:42:48 AM
I don't know everything, and I would be more than interested in seeing the statute.  Would you be kind enough to provide it? I've already searched through my available methods and I have not produced anything fruitful yet.

The only thing I could find was HRS Section 291c-172(a), but that section appears to apply only to traffic offenses and is an infraction/not an arrestable(criminal) offense.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: suka on February 24, 2014, 02:04:53 AM
Can't find anything either


HRS 291 is all related to traffic
And 172 is refered back to part vii:  pedestrian failing to obey signals ( jaywalking)



Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: suka on February 24, 2014, 02:16:35 AM
Another example ( not real )

Having a picnic at Waihiawa  fresh water boat launch Public picnic table area. Just grindz and talk story.

No signs of fishing gear whatsoever nearby except a cooler.

Fishing gear is lock in the trunk of car parked 20 yards away. ( not in plain view ). I fish saltwater, do not have a fresh water license.

DLNR walks up  " do have ID, fishing license, what's in the cooler, can you open it? "

Obligated to just refuse to answer all his questions?
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: edster48 on February 24, 2014, 07:09:51 AM
I've been unable to find a statute that provides for HPD being able to demand ID without cause, as far as I can see, it doesn't exist.

They can ask to see your drivers license if you're operating a vehicle, they can demand id if you're suspected of a crime.

So it comes down to knowing your rights. You DO have a right to ask questions, and they MUST answer. [ I've had them tell me they don't, that's BS ]

Let's take suka's example;
 While minding your own business, an officer walks up and demands ID, and further asks if you have a fishing license, and asks to look in your cooler. How do you respond?

First, keep it polite, there's no reason to be confrontational. Simply ask "Why officer?", at that point he can either explain himself to your satisfaction, or he can demand ID without explaining himself.
 In the case of the latter, your response should be: "Am I being detained?" If he answers "No" simply say "have a nice day officer."
If he says "Yes", understand that you have a RIGHT to know what you're suspected of, and he MUST explain it to you. As long as he does, present your ID, if you don't, he can charge you with obstruction. [ If you don't have ID on you, give him your name and birthdate, or ss number.] Don't be afraid to ask "What am I being charged with?"

As far as the fishing license, "I'm not fishing" will do, he has no right to pursue the matter further if you're not actively fishing.

As far as the cooler, it's your personal property and as such is protected under the 4th amendment. He has no right to search it without your permission, or a warrant. If you give him permission, you have waived your rights to protection under the law.
You should just say "I don't submit to any searches of myself or my property". If he proceeds anyway, he's breaking the law.

Always remember, the police can lie to you to get you incriminate yourself, or waive your rights. You must know your rights under the law!

Most importantly, you should either be filming the encounter [ yes, you have a right to] or you should have some good friends around to witness the encounter. If it's your word against the officer's, the court will ALWAYS find in his favor.
                                                               
                                                                                                     :geekdanc:
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Dblnaknak on February 24, 2014, 08:37:40 AM

Another example ( not real )

Having a picnic at Waihiawa  fresh water boat launch Public picnic table area. Just grindz and talk story.

No signs of fishing gear whatsoever nearby except a cooler.

Fishing gear is lock in the trunk of car parked 20 yards away. ( not in plain view ). I fish saltwater, do not have a fresh water license.

DLNR walks up  " do have ID, fishing license, what's in the cooler, can you open it? "

Obligated to just refuse to answer all his questions?

You're in a public park. There is no drinking in a public park. You have a cooler. Coolers are used to keep beer cold among other things. Now he has PC to talk to you. How do you know he hasn't received a complaint that someone was drinking in the park. Sometimes it easier to just comply then to act like a dumb ass and dig yourself deeper in a hole.   

Just like the earlier example about the guy in Waikiki. How do you know hpd wasn't called there for the drunk guy.

If they approach you 99.9 % they already have PC.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Teichi on February 24, 2014, 08:42:28 AM
HAWAII STATUTES AND CODES

§291C-172  Refusal to provide identification.

     (a)  Except as provided in subsection (b), any person detained for a violation of this chapter shall provide the person's name and address, or any proof thereof, or both, upon the lawful order or direction of any police officer in the course and scope of the officer's duties pursuant to this chapter.

     (b)  A pedestrian who is detained for violating part VII of this chapter shall provide the person's name and address upon the lawful order or direction of a police officer in the course and scope of the officer's duties.  If the officer has reasonable grounds to believe that the person is being deceptive or misleading in providing the person's name and address, the person shall provide such proof thereof, upon the lawful order or direction of the police officer. [L 1978, c 111, pt of §2; am L 1984, c 215, §1; am L 1995, c 169, §1]
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: edster48 on February 24, 2014, 08:48:56 AM
You're in a public park. There is no drinking in a public park. You have a cooler. Coolers are used to keep beer cold among other things. Now he has PC to talk to you. How do you know he hasn't received a complaint that someone was drinking in the park. Sometimes it easier to just comply then to act like a dumb ass and dig yourself deeper in a hole.   

Just like the earlier example about the guy in Waikiki. How do you know hpd wasn't called there for the drunk guy.

If they approach you 99.9 % they already have PC.

BS, the fact that you have a cooler is not probable cause. He has no idea what's in the cooler. If he saw you with a beer in your hand, that's probable cause.

He still has to explain WHY he's asking for ID. You are not compelled to give it to him simply because he demands it, the 4th amendment applies.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: edster48 on February 24, 2014, 08:51:20 AM
HAWAII STATUTES AND CODES

§291C-172  Refusal to provide identification.

     (a)  Except as provided in subsection (b), any person detained for a violation of this chapter shall provide the person's name and address, or any proof thereof, or both, upon the lawful order or direction of any police officer in the course and scope of the officer's duties pursuant to this chapter.

     (b)  A pedestrian who is detained for violating part VII of this chapter shall provide the person's name and address upon the lawful order or direction of a police officer in the course and scope of the officer's duties.  If the officer has reasonable grounds to believe that the person is being deceptive or misleading in providing the person's name and address, the person shall provide such proof thereof, upon the lawful order or direction of the police officer. [L 1978, c 111, pt of §2; am L 1984, c 215, §1; am L 1995, c 169, §1]


The key word is "Detained". If you're not being detained, you are not compelled by law to present ID.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Dblnaknak on February 24, 2014, 09:04:28 AM

BS, the fact that you have a cooler is not probable cause. He has no idea what's in the cooler. If he saw you with a beer in your hand, that's probable cause.

He still has to explain WHY he's asking for ID. You are not compelled to give it to him simply because he demands it, the 4th amendment applies.

If he got a complaint he has a duty to investigate. In the course of his investigation you have a cooler. Now you're compelled to provide an ID. He has another thing called reasonable suspicion.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: edster48 on February 24, 2014, 09:08:54 AM
HAWAII STATUTES AND CODES

§291C-172  Refusal to provide identification.

     (a)  Except as provided in subsection (b), any person detained for a violation of this chapter shall provide the person's name and address, or any proof thereof, or both, upon the lawful order or direction of any police officer in the course and scope of the officer's duties pursuant to this chapter.

     (b)  A pedestrian who is detained for violating part VII of this chapter shall provide the person's name and address upon the lawful order or direction of a police officer in the course and scope of the officer's duties.  If the officer has reasonable grounds to believe that the person is being deceptive or misleading in providing the person's name and address, the person shall provide such proof thereof, upon the lawful order or direction of the police officer. [L 1978, c 111, pt of §2; am L 1984, c 215, §1; am L 1995, c 169, §1]


Further, if you are being detained you have a RIGHT to know what you're being detained for, the officers innate curiosity isn't enough to denote probable cause.
 Remember, the burden of proof is on the STATE. You're innocent until PROVEN guilty, and the 5th amendment gives you RIGHT to NOT incriminate yourself.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: edster48 on February 24, 2014, 09:11:14 AM
If he got a complaint he has a duty to investigate. In the course of his investigation you have a cooler. Now you're compelled to provide an ID. He has another thing called reasonable suspicion.

Only if he's told you you're being detained, if you're NOT being detained, he may ask, but you are not compelled to comply. As far as the cooler, the 4th amendment applies.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Darmok and Jalad @Tanagra on February 24, 2014, 09:19:30 AM
HAWAII STATUTES AND CODES

§291C-172  Refusal to provide identification.

     (a)  Except as provided in subsection (b), any person detained for a violation of this chapter shall provide the person's name and address, or any proof thereof, or both, upon the lawful order or direction of any police officer in the course and scope of the officer's duties pursuant to this chapter.

     (b)  A pedestrian who is detained for violating part VII of this chapter shall provide the person's name and address upon the lawful order or direction of a police officer in the course and scope of the officer's duties.  If the officer has reasonable grounds to believe that the person is being deceptive or misleading in providing the person's name and address, the person shall provide such proof thereof, upon the lawful order or direction of the police officer. [L 1978, c 111, pt of §2; am L 1984, c 215, §1; am L 1995, c 169, §1]

The key word here is "detained."  As I said earlier, if the conversation is consensual, no ID is required (except when driving or flying).  This section specifies you are being detained.  That requires the officer has probable cause you have or are about to commit a crime, in which case you must identify yourself.  To give fake information is a crime in and of itself if detained.

As for the cooler example, NO!  The officer can not assume you have beer in your cooler.  Saying "How do you know he hasn't received a complaint that someone was drinking in the park. Sometimes it easier to just comply"   is ridiculous.  He must have a reasonable suspicion based on an articulable fact WHY he has that suspicion. 

How do you know WHY the COP is asking for ID?  You open your mouth and ASK HIM, "Sir, are you asking because you think I've broken some law?" 

That's not being an a hole.  That's being a well-informed citizen who knows compliance with whatever a policeman tells you to do is NOT required if you are breaking no laws and if the request is not related to safety (like being asked to move your car so approaching emergency vehicles can take your place).  Either he leaves you alone at that point, or he explains what you are doing wrong.  Searching a cooler or detaining you without probable cause is illegal.  COPS have to follow the laws, too.  They can only exceed their legal authority if we allow it.

YOU do whatever makes you feel cooperative.  I'll do what keeps me out of jail by not handing the police a case against myself.  We have the right to not incriminate ourselves.  The only a hole is the one who advocates everyone follow your lead and comply every time when it's the worst possible thing you could do.


If you haven't ever watched this video, it's worth the time.  It's over 48 minutes, and if you don't have that much time or attention span  ;), at least watch the first speaker.  He's much more entertaining than the COP, anyway!
http://youtu.be/6wXkI4t7nuc (http://youtu.be/6wXkI4t7nuc)

Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Funtimes on February 24, 2014, 09:31:44 AM
If he got a complaint he has a duty to investigate. In the course of his investigation you have a cooler. Now you're compelled to provide an ID. He has another thing called reasonable suspicion.

Sir, you are just not correct in your application of search and seizure law. He has to articulate why - my cooler - among all other coolers needs to be inspected. You can't just go around inspecting everyones cooler.  Insert - backpack, purse, car, home, pockets or any other compartment and the point should be clearly evident to you. Moreover, it's not a crime to have a cooler, which means you can't detain me and compel me to provide identification. You can't just say, "Oh, I had a report."   What if they reported the guy was black? Just going to run through and stop every black man in the park? Try that in Chicago or Oakland - see how it works out for you.

What articulation would you utilize to justify your stop and detain me? I would certainly tell you that I'm not answering any questions and will not comply or consent to searches of my person or property.

You said that you have experience in this stuff, I'm really starting to wonder what type of agency or entity you could work for that didn't train you properly on this. 


To prove my point, I could always bring my cooler near you while on duty and you can try inspecting it without a warrant!  My friends kids need more college funds.

I'm currently up a win against the city and they are having to pay my legal expenses for thinking they can delete comments off of Facebook.  I will soon be 2-0 with the completion of a gun case.  We could count it 3-0 if you consider our draft of a lawsuit made parks department comply with our demands. 
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Funtimes on February 24, 2014, 10:05:15 AM
Also, that law is only for that chapter.  So, one must be detained for a violation in and under Chapter 291: Traffic Violations for the failure to identify law to apply.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Darmok and Jalad @Tanagra on February 24, 2014, 10:07:10 AM
You said that you have experience in this stuff, I'm really starting to wonder what type of agency or entity you could work for that didn't train you properly on this. 
I get the impression his "experience" is not from Law Enforcement's perspective ... 
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: HiCarry on February 24, 2014, 10:08:53 AM
If he got a complaint he has a duty to investigate. In the course of his investigation you have a cooler. Now you're compelled to provide an ID. He has another thing called reasonable suspicion.

So, there is a complaint that someone in the park is selling drugs but without any further description of the suspect. Since drugs can be hidden in pockets, purses, bags, and cars, and there is no description of the suspect, that allows the responding police officer to search everyone's pockets, purses, bags and cars?

Yeah, I don't think so......
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Funtimes on February 24, 2014, 10:19:20 AM
Many people may not be aware, but Hawaii has some of the strongest fourth amendment protections in the entire country.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Funtimes on February 24, 2014, 10:30:03 AM
To add:

You can see in part (2) that a pedestrian must be lawfully detained under:

Part XIII. Operation of Bicycles and Play Vehicles

291C-141 Effect of regulations

291C-142 Traffic laws apply to persons riding bicycles

291C-143 Riding on bicycles

291C-144 Clinging to vehicles

291C-145 Riding on roadways and bikeways

291C-146 Carrying articles

291C-147 Lamps and other equipment on bicycles

291C-148 Driving upon sidewalk

291C-149 Bicycle racing

291C-150 Bicycle helmets
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: edster48 on February 24, 2014, 10:36:51 AM
Many people may not be aware, but Hawaii has some of the strongest fourth amendment protections in the entire country.

That's the biggest problem, as I see it. People aren't aware what protections they're entitled to under the Constitution, and state or federal law.
This is something we used to learn in civics class, but that's something the schools have deemed a "waste of time".
Hence, our children are told "just do what the nice policeman says, and you won't get into trouble".
Nothing could be further from the truth.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Funtimes on February 24, 2014, 10:39:03 AM
That's the biggest problem, as I see it. People aren't aware what protections they're entitled to under the Constitution, and state or federal law.
This is something we used to learn in civics class, but that's something the schools have deemed a "waste of time".
Hence, our children are told "just do what the nice policeman says, and you won't get into trouble".
Nothing could be further from the truth.

When we were setting up for a traffic checkpoint case, I thought it was really interesting to learn about why Hawaii doesn't authorize individuals to be brought out of the car for every offense.  In most other states, it seems that "officer safety" was the only requirement and you could have a person step out of the car.  In Hawaii, they need RAS to get you out of a vehicle, so it has to be something way more concrete!
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Darmok and Jalad @Tanagra on February 24, 2014, 10:43:20 AM
Many people may not be aware, but Hawaii has some of the strongest fourth amendment protections in the entire country.

Unfortunately, I've had more than one friend or coworker tell stories about Hawaii COPs with egos and attitudes.  When you state what your rights are, the COPs often lie straight to your face and try to tell you the exact opposite.  Then they get very angry because you insist that you have a right that keeps them from forcing you to comply.

Case in point:  COPs were called because my buddy followed the lady that opened her car door on his BMW to her house and asked for her insurance info and driver's license.  After he left, a neighbor of hers told her to call the police and report him for threatening her.  Of course, the threatening report was a lie, otherwise the COPs would have just arrested him when they came to his house.  The COPs talked to him in the front yard outside his house.  At some point, after he denied the allegations, the COPs said they were going to arrest him if he bothers her again.  He told them if they come back, they need to bring a warrant, or he'd have them arrested for trespassing.  One COP got really irate, saying he could come on his property any time he wants and there's nothing my friend could do to stop him, warrant or no warrant.

That's just one story of many.  COPs are being trained to use force to make us comply with their orders, regardless of how benign our noncompliance is.  Plenty of video evidence out there on how people are being forced to comply, even killed, when the situation could have been resolved more peacefully without any bloodshed. 

I'm seeing too much evidence of a police state, where compliance is mandatory regardless of your rights, and the consequences are "shoot first, ask questions later."  I'm sure that isn't the majority of LE, but how do you really know if you've met such a COP until it's too late?  I've invested in a dash cam that can record audio & video of the road ahead and the inside of the car.  If I get pulled over, you can bet that lens will be pointed at my driver side window!
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: edster48 on February 24, 2014, 10:51:40 AM
When we were setting up for a traffic checkpoint case, I thought it was really interesting to learn about why Hawaii doesn't authorize individuals to be brought out of the car for every offense.  In most other states, it seems that "officer safety" was the only requirement and you could have a person step out of the car.  In Hawaii, they need RAS to get you out of a vehicle, so it has to be something way more concrete!

OK, here's my opportunity to learn something! I've never been asked to step out of my vehicle before, so I don't know this.
What do you mean by RAS?
What do you mean by more concrete? Please give an example! I'm not a lawyer, and I try to be well informed, the myriad laws we have tend to make this difficult.
Thanks!
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Funtimes on February 24, 2014, 11:05:09 AM
OK, here's my opportunity to learn something! I've never been asked to step out of my vehicle before, so I don't know this.
What do you mean by RAS?
What do you mean by more concrete? Please give an example! I'm not a lawyer, and I try to be well informed, the myriad laws we have tend to make this difficult.
Thanks!

You can go to most youtube videos, and you may see the officer pull the individual over and then ask them to "step out to the side,"  "Come hang out around the back,"  or "sit on the hood" etc.   The thought here is that with the officer being able to completely see the individual they can't grab for anything that isn't on them.  They also can't hide evidence while they are sitting in the car.  In Hawaii, this practice was ruled on after an individual moved to suppress a traffic stop where he turned his vehicle around prior to a sobriety checkpoint  and was followed where a traffic stop was initiated.

RAS is "Reasonable Articulable Suspicion";  it is essentially the Officer's ability to articulate (state, like verbally) why he is asking you do something or why that they suspect you of something.  They may not have to tell you, but they generally do tell the individual if for no other reason to quell the "OMG! WHY ARE YOU ARRESTING ME" stuff.    For example, Officer pulls you over, he may say "Good Afternoon Sir/Mam, I'm not sure if you are aware, but I clocked you going 67 in a 55."  What the officer has done here is articulated why he stopped you (speeding, 67 in a 55).  This is his/her reasonable suspicion that you were committing an offense.   This would also be what the officer puts in his reports and stuff to kind of lead into proving that whatever he did or saw suggested you were doing something bad.

When we say concrete, we are generally thinking of things that may not change often or easily.  For example,  I'm looking for a male with a 6" scar on his face, who has been reported to be in the vicinity of a robbery.   In a sense, just "male" is not very concrete.  I can't just go stop every male on the block and search them.  But, if I had a male with a scar on his face then that might be different.   Concrete can also refer to the 'strength' of something (We have concrete evidence that he committed this offense!). 
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: edster48 on February 24, 2014, 11:28:25 AM
Thanks Funtimes. I do understand Reasonable Articulable Suspicion, just didn't get the abbreviation as I'm not LE.  :crazy:
 I remember the case you're talking about, as I remember, the guy got off because they had no reason to follow him other than he turned around to avoid a checkpoint.
Thanks for the clarity!
                                                         :shaka:
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Darmok and Jalad @Tanagra on February 24, 2014, 01:32:52 PM
Here's a sample of why more and more people are filming their encounters with police.  Had the video not surfaced, this man would have been going to prison for years.

http://abclocal.go.com/wabc/video?id=9440993 (http://abclocal.go.com/wabc/video?id=9440993)
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: HiCarry on February 24, 2014, 02:28:15 PM
Here's a sample of why more and more people are filming their encounters with police.  Had the video not surfaced, this man would have been going to prison for years.

http://abclocal.go.com/wabc/video?id=9440993 (http://abclocal.go.com/wabc/video?id=9440993)

I hope the officers are being charged under USC 1983, as if so, they loose their qualified immunity and the individual officer is responsible for any judgments, not the the police department and hence, the tax payers.....
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Funtimes on February 24, 2014, 02:50:21 PM
I hope the officers are being charged under USC 1983, as if so, they loose their qualified immunity and the individual officer is responsible for any judgments, not the the police department and hence, the tax payers.....

I'm sure a plaintiffs attorney will be in contact with the individual lol.  I know I would.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: kong on February 24, 2014, 03:30:26 PM
You can go to most youtube videos, and you may see the officer pull the individual over and then ask them to "step out to the side,"  "Come hang out around the back,"  or "sit on the hood" etc.   The thought here is that with the officer being able to completely see the individual they can't grab for anything that isn't on them.  They also can't hide evidence while they are sitting in the car.  In Hawaii, this practice was ruled on after an individual moved to suppress a traffic stop where he turned his vehicle around prior to a sobriety checkpoint  and was followed where a traffic stop was initiated.

RAS is "Reasonable Articulable Suspicion";  it is essentially the Officer's ability to articulate (state, like verbally) why he is asking you do something or why that they suspect you of something.  They may not have to tell you, but they generally do tell the individual if for no other reason to quell the "OMG! WHY ARE YOU ARRESTING ME" stuff.    For example, Officer pulls you over, he may say "Good Afternoon Sir/Mam, I'm not sure if you are aware, but I clocked you going 67 in a 55."  What the officer has done here is articulated why he stopped you (speeding, 67 in a 55).  This is his/her reasonable suspicion that you were committing an offense.   This would also be what the officer puts in his reports and stuff to kind of lead into proving that whatever he did or saw suggested you were doing something bad.

When we say concrete, we are generally thinking of things that may not change often or easily.  For example,  I'm looking for a male with a 6" scar on his face, who has been reported to be in the vicinity of a robbery.   In a sense, just "male" is not very concrete.  I can't just go stop every male on the block and search them.  But, if I had a male with a scar on his face then that might be different.   Concrete can also refer to the 'strength' of something (We have concrete evidence that he committed this offense!).

Actually, you need RS for a terry stop/frisk though there are certain exceptions like mobile conveyance, due to licensing requirements, exigent circumstances, etc.  Example, you can get stopped for a regular traffic infraction and with the plain view doctrine (if you left your weed pipe on the seat next to you, scent of mj, etc) have PC to expand the scope of their search to finding the smallest amount of drugs.  Also, BOLO is reason for a terry stop since it is articulable facts that an officer is on the look out for.  We are all sea lawyers so just be careful fighting it.  Biggest question I would ask if this is a Terry stop or voluntary contact. 

Also, comply and if the search or seizure (including yourself) was done illegaly it will get thrown out along with everything that follows due to the fruit of the poisonous tree doctrine.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Funtimes on February 24, 2014, 05:03:37 PM
Actually, you need RS for a terry stop/frisk though there are certain exceptions like mobile conveyance, due to licensing requirements, exigent circumstances, etc.  Example, you can get stopped for a regular traffic infraction and with the plain view doctrine (if you left your weed pipe on the seat next to you, scent of mj, etc) have PC to expand the scope of their search to finding the smallest amount of drugs. Terry stop and production of identification are two different things.  Terry stop also requires that criminal activity be afoot; the frisk requires RAS that you may armed and/or presently dangerous.Also, BOLO is reason for a terry stop since it is articulable facts that an officer is on the look out for. I kind of covered this above dealing with the male and the scar.  We are all sea lawyers so just be careful fighting it. Sure. I'm not a lawyer.  But, I did do legal investigations, read briefs, and study the 4th amendment to help attorneys find loop holes or problems.  It's also covered significantly in my previous academics to include courses on  criminal investigations, Criminal law, criminal procedure, and public law and policy. Biggest question I would ask if this is a Terry stop or voluntary contact.  Just ask if you are being detained or if you are free to go.  If free to go, don't hang around talking - just leave.   Even if they don't say anything, attempting to leave can be beneficial anyways.  If they touch you, order you to stop, and so forth it just increases the amount of evidence in favor of an involuntary seizure.

Also, comply and if the search or seizure (including yourself) was done illegaly it will get thrown out along with everything that follows due to the fruit of the poisonous tree doctrine. I would say never comply, but do not resist.  Hopefully that is understood.  If you want to smash my window, break into my car and search go for it.  I'm not going to give you the keys. I won't unlock the vehicle.  I won't consent to the search.  I'm just not going to forcefully resist the individual doing it.  Most importantly, let it be known that you do not consent.

Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: bubba808 on February 24, 2014, 05:03:53 PM
I imagined this was what you were talking about with the first post.  The girl was pretty stupid imo!
just curious, why do you consider the girl stupid?
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: bubba808 on February 24, 2014, 05:29:51 PM
Darmok - recently in "off topic" you wrote a post about we being here for 2A or to talk about guns... im just curious how this post relates to 2A or guns as it is posted in legal and activism for 2A? Please articulate
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Darmok and Jalad @Tanagra on February 24, 2014, 05:34:00 PM
Darmok - recently in "off topic" you wrote a post about we being here for 2A or to talk about guns... im just curious how this post relates to 2A or guns as it is posted in legal and activism for 2A? Please articulate

This is not my topic.  Recommend you redirect your question to the OP (suka).

Mahalo!

 :stopjack:
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: suka on February 24, 2014, 06:33:02 PM
Darmok - recently in "off topic" you wrote a post about we being here for 2A or to talk about guns... im just curious how this post relates to 2A or guns as it is posted in legal and activism for 2A? Please articulate
It has to do with the legal system, and seems the best of the categories to place it under.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Funtimes on February 24, 2014, 09:29:37 PM
just curious, why do you consider the girl stupid?

Because they were doing targeted enforcement, it's hard to say if she wouldn't have gotten a ticket, but a couple of things come to mind.  Firstly, pay attention to your surroundings!  According to witnesses, officers were all around the street doing targeted enforcement.  Maybe it's not the best idea to do stuff you know is wrong when a bunch of police are around.  Most of us I think would try to follow the laws when we see police around.    Secondly, she obviously wasn't paying even more attention to the individual who grabbed her.  It was reported that she pulled away and pushed the officers hand off her and then continued to run off. That doesn't seem to be the brightest moment of her life. You just put your hands on an officer.   Lastly, there is an opportunity that she could have utilized her... features? ... to get out of a ticket.  Let's not think this doesn't happen. As I said above, it might be harder due to targeted enforcement, but she's not the ugliest thing in the world.  A little bit of professionalism, politeness, and a smile could have gone a long way in getting out of her current situation.  Instead, she threw herself on the ground and refused to even give her name.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: kong on February 24, 2014, 09:36:03 PM
Funtimes I was going off of your examples about BOLO's RS, PC, etc.  And when you bring in RS then that is usually a Terry Stop i.e. in LA in certain known areas where individuals do shoot out with the police an officer can articulate that they effected a high risk stop at 9pm at night on a Thursday due to four males between the ages of 18-25 in said vehicle vice Hawaii where that is not reasonable as the only shootout I am aware of was the one with the solo bike officer. 

I agree if consensual then to terminate the contact and leave.  What I meant by comply is to not resist or fight.

For a voluntary stop from a training manual 'an officer may ask questions even incriminating ones, may request but not demand ID, may ID him or herself and show creds, and may seek consent for a search.  There are also factors that a court would look at with regards to whether the voluntary contact became an investigative detention.'
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Funtimes on February 24, 2014, 09:53:08 PM
Funtimes I was going off of your examples about BOLO's RS, PC, etc.  And when you bring in RS then that is usually a Terry Stop i.e. in LA in certain known areas where individuals do shoot out with the police an officer can articulate that they effected a high risk stop at 9pm at night on a Thursday due to four males between the ages of 18-25 in said vehicle vice Hawaii where that is not reasonable as the only shootout I am aware of was the one with the solo bike officer. 

I agree if consensual then to terminate the contact and leave.  What I meant by comply is to not resist or fight.

For a voluntary stop from a training manual 'an officer may ask questions even incriminating ones, may request but not demand ID, may ID him or herself and show creds, and may seek consent for a search.  There are also factors that a court would look at with regards to whether the voluntary contact became an investigative detention.'

Yeah there are some elements of time, location (high-crime areas) that come into play with this!  Like you said, don't resist or fight that doesn't go well.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: eyeeatingfish on February 25, 2014, 10:46:33 PM
Hawaii does not have a law against pubic intoxication.
Hawaii does not have a law requiring you to have ID on your person unless you are driving.

Suka you observed a small bit of the overall picture. For example let say someone called crime stoppers to report that this individual was John Doe who was wanted for robbery. The police arrive and find a male matching the description of the wanted warrant suspect. The male gives a name, DOB, and SSN that does not match and appears to be trying to conceal his identity. In this situation the police have reason to believe this individual is wanted and can articulate further detention. If they have enough info they could even make the warrant arrest and asking for ID is merely to give the guy the chance to prove he is not the wanted individual.

When you see a police interaction such as this you don't know what the officer knew prior to the encounter, you don't know what type of reasonable suspicion or probable cause the officer has.
Title: Re: Failure to ID
Post by: Water on March 11, 2014, 12:29:16 AM
HAWAII STATUTES AND CODES

§291C-172  Refusal to provide identification.

     (a)  Except as provided in subsection (b), any person detained for a violation of this chapter shall provide the person's name and address, or any proof thereof, or both, upon the lawful order or direction of any police officer in the course and scope of the officer's duties pursuant to this chapter.

     (b)  A pedestrian who is detained for violating part VII of this chapter shall provide the person's name and address upon the lawful order or direction of a police officer in the course and scope of the officer's duties.  If the officer has reasonable grounds to believe that the person is being deceptive or misleading in providing the person's name and address, the person shall provide such proof thereof, upon the lawful order or direction of the police officer. [L 1978, c 111, pt of §2; am L 1984, c 215, §1; am L 1995, c 169, §1]

You know what's funny about this section?  Its only a fine!  See how dumb lawmakers are in Hawaii?  I consulted with a buddy, who is an Officer here, about this.  He said only if you commit a violation under the City Ordinances, you can be arrested for refusing to provide ID... and almost all City Ordinances mirror the Hawaii Statutes in some way.

Like what someone said, im sure HPD doesnt stop any random person doing "nothing" without reason or getting complaint from someone.  This aint L.A.