2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: 2aHawaii on February 27, 2014, 02:52:38 PM

Title: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: 2aHawaii on February 27, 2014, 02:52:38 PM
Apparently there is some confusion as what I'm reading says these organizations (amici curiae) don't have the power to request a rehearing en banc.


Still waiting to hear on Baker v. Kealoha


PDF below:
http://www.hoffmang.com/firearms/Peruta/Peruta-121-1-Amicus-Petition-2014-02-27.pdf (http://www.hoffmang.com/firearms/Peruta/Peruta-121-1-Amicus-Petition-2014-02-27.pdf)
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: 2aHawaii on February 27, 2014, 03:06:13 PM
There's also word that the California AG has filed as well.


ETA: https://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-kamala-d-harris-appeals-ninth-circuit-concealed-weapons-permit
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: punaperson on February 27, 2014, 09:04:47 PM
From:
NO LAWYERS - ONLY GUNS AND MONEY
"SEND LAWYERS, GUNS AND MONEY. THE SHIT HAS HIT THE FAN." - WARREN ZEVON

[with live links to the documents] http://onlygunsandmoney.blogspot.com/2014/02/antis-seek-en-banc-review-of-peruta.html (http://onlygunsandmoney.blogspot.com/2014/02/antis-seek-en-banc-review-of-peruta.html)

Anti's Seek En Banc Review Of Peruta Decision

You just knew that the gun prohibitionists would not take the win in the Peruta decision lying down especially since San Diego Sheriff Bill Gore decided to accept the decision.

Today, in what seems to be a coordinated effort, California Attorney General Kamala Harris, the Brady Campaign, the Legal Community Against Violence, the California Peace Officers Association, and the California Police Chiefs Association filed petitions requesting an en banc hearing. The State of California represented by Harris and the Brady Campaign also filed motions to intervene in the case.

02/27/2014     121    Filed (ECF) Amici Curiae California Peace Officers Association and California Police Chiefs Association petition for rehearing en banc (from 02/13/2014 opinion). Date of service: 02/27/2014. [8996109]--[COURT UPDATE: Attached searchable version of petition. Resent NDA. 02/27/2014 by RY] (PRC)
02/27/2014     122    Submitted (ECF) Intervenor brief for review and filed Motion to intervene. Submitted by State of California. Date of service: 02/27/2014. [8996638] (GDB)
02/27/2014     123    Submitted (ECF) Intervenor brief for review and filed Motion to intervene. Submitted by Brady Center to Prevent Gun Violence. Date of service: 02/27/2014. [8996736] (NRO)
02/27/2014     124    Filed (ECF) Amicus Curiae Legal Community Against Violence petition for rehearing en banc (from 02/13/2014 opinion). Date of service: 02/27/2014. [8996737] (SJF)

In an article by Emily Miller this evening, Chuck Michel questioned whether any of these parties have standing.
Chuck Michel, the west coast counsel for the National Rifle Association, said Ms. Harris‘ motion to intervene was far out of line because her office wasn’t part of the lawsuit.

“They are trying to improperly influence the court,” Mr. Michel said in an interview. “The are stretching the rules to file in order to get their arguments in front of the court in the hopes that a liberal judge will get the message and ask for a vote himself.”...

“Obviously, what this tells us is the folks that advocate civilian disarmament are upset about the opinion and want to throw everything they can at it to bottle up the 9th Circuit or get it overturned,” said Mr. Michel, whose firm, Michel and Associates, represented the plaintiffs in the Peruta case up to the appeals court level.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: Hawaii Volcano Squad on February 28, 2014, 03:19:06 AM
Lawyers kill Constitution, Film @ 11   :tinfoil:


Peruta En Banc Appeal Filed (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FrOp5OlzRcM#ws)
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: 2aHawaii on February 28, 2014, 09:37:07 AM
Now I'm hearing that every appeal is inconsistent with normal court proceedings.

I've also heard comments that the Baker decision won't be released until after Peruta (and Richards) is settled.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: Funtimes on February 28, 2014, 09:49:11 AM
Now I'm hearing that every appeal is inconsistent with normal court proceedings.  I've heard this.  A Hawaii case called Day appears to be controlling on this.  But, it doesn't matter... either they take it up or they don't.

I've also heard comments that the Baker decision won't be released until after Peruta (and Richards) is settled. I don't really know about 'settled' but our opinion would come after both cases are released.  That's how they write the opinions in order of which they are argued.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: Hawaii Volcano Squad on February 28, 2014, 09:58:31 AM
Whether or not the Calif. AG En Banc request is technically within the law may be totally irrelevant. Any judge on the 9th circuit can start an En Banc review with NO PAPERWORK at all.

The key therefore is: if there is a judge on the 9th circuit who wants to review the Peruta case, it will be reviewed. If not, it will not be reviewed.

 :popcorn:
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: Funtimes on February 28, 2014, 10:22:46 AM
Whether or not the Calif. AG En Banc request is technically within the law may be totally irrelevant. Any judge on the 9th circuit can start an En Banc review with NO PAPERWORK at all.

The key therefore is: if there is a judge on the 9th circuit who wants to review the Peruta case, it will be reviewed. If not, it will not be reviewed.

 :popcorn:

Well, to clarify for those viewing, any judge can request a vote.  You need to have a winning vote to take the case up by the larger panel.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: Hawaii Volcano Squad on February 28, 2014, 10:51:56 AM
Well, to clarify for those viewing, any judge can request a vote.  You need to have a winning vote to take the case up by the larger panel.

That may be a distinction without a difference. If a sitting judge wants to review a case I have a hard time imagining his brethren refusing it, but it theoretically could happen.

BOTTOM LINE: Sweat it out! March 7th is the deadline for a judge to request an En Banc review.

Meanwhile I will be using a my tin foil hat attempting to divine the future and transmit the 2nd amendment via psychic waves>  :tinfoil:
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: Funtimes on February 28, 2014, 11:12:42 AM
That may be a distinction without a difference. If a sitting judge wants to review a case I have a hard time imagining his brethren refusing it, but it theoretically could happen.

BOTTOM LINE: Sweat it out! March 7th is the deadline for a judge to request an En Banc review.

Meanwhile I will be using a my tin foil hat attempting to divine the future and transmit the 2nd amendment via psychic waves>  :tinfoil:

It happens often. People request it all the time.  You will know when people really wanted it if there are dissents from the denial of the request.   Our date is march 6th for the court to take it up on themselves.  The deadline for filing the request has since past.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: punaperson on February 28, 2014, 11:47:27 AM
It happens often. People request it all the time.  You will know when people really wanted it if there are dissents from the denial of the request.   Our date is march 6th for the court to take it up on themselves.  The deadline for filing the request has since past.
Hi Chris. Wondering if you know IF a judge requests a vote on en banc, how long before that vote takes place? AND IF they do vote for en banc (I believe 14 would be a majority, as there are currently two vacancies on the 29 member circuit) how long before the case is argued en banc? Are we possibly looking at another two years or more for an en banc decision? Thanks.  :shaka:
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: Funtimes on February 28, 2014, 12:24:12 PM
Hi Chris. Wondering if you know IF a judge requests a vote on en banc, how long before that vote takes place? AND IF they do vote for en banc (I believe 14 would be a majority, as there are currently two vacancies on the 29 member circuit) how long before the case is argued en banc? Are we possibly looking at another two years or more for an en banc decision? Thanks.  :shaka:

Here is an article that covers a lot of the process behind the scenes:
http://www.arizonalawreview.org/pdf/48-2/48arizlrev325.pdf (http://www.arizonalawreview.org/pdf/48-2/48arizlrev325.pdf)

But the TLDR is: We will know when they release an order, or we will know that they didn't want to hear it on the 6th of March.  How long till argued is very questionable, they would need to do briefing and stuff.. probably looking at a year or so, then a year or so for an opinion. 
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: Hawaii Volcano Squad on March 06, 2014, 01:14:55 AM
It happens often. People request it all the time.  You will know when people really wanted it if there are dissents from the denial of the request.   Our date is march 6th for the court to take it up on themselves.  The deadline for filing the request has since past.

This will get stretched out a few more weeks.  ::)

There was new court  filing that states the date for submitting arguments [on behalf of Peruta] addressing En Banc  review & Intervening party to SCOTUS must be filed by March 26th. Here it is>

http://michellawyers.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/11/Peruta-v.-County-of-San-Diego_Order-re-Ordering-Response-to-Motions-to-Intervene.pdf (http://michellawyers.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/11/Peruta-v.-County-of-San-Diego_Order-re-Ordering-Response-to-Motions-to-Intervene.pdf)

The issue is will there be an En Banc or will CA AG be granted status to allowed to appeal to SCOTUS. If En Banc review is not enpaneled and the AG allowed to appeal to SCOTUS there are good and bad consequences.

The good news is all the sister federal courts will have to follow the supreme court final ruling, spreading this ruling across the nation. This decision is so closely based on Heller, SCOTUS would have to overturn it's own decision.

The bad news: the Supreme Court may alter the ruling ever so slightly, turning this victory into a loss across all the jurisdictions.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: suka on March 06, 2014, 02:36:09 AM
The CA AG is not a defendant and by all accounts cannot officially file an en banc. Only involved parties may file.
The Court may grant an en banc but is not required and the ruling may stand.

If Gore does not file to motion, in which means the AG and Brady cannot be involved.
however , Im sure the AG will be pressuring the sheriff  to file.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: Hawaii Volcano Squad on March 06, 2014, 07:22:28 AM
The CA AG is not a defendant and by all accounts cannot officially file an en banc. Only involved parties may file.
The Court may grant an en banc but is not required and the ruling may stand.

If Gore does not file to motion, in which means the AG and Brady cannot be involved.
however , Im sure the AG will be pressuring the sheriff  to file.

The AG has filed belatedly as a Proposed Appellee Intervenor. Here is the filing the Peruta team has until March 26 to present an argument against

http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/general/2014/02/28/10-56971_motion_to_intervene.pdf (http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/general/2014/02/28/10-56971_motion_to_intervene.pdf)

In oral argument, all the judges were snickering at the AG who did not want to get involved but made certain she was notified that she could be but she declined to during the case.

Here is the actual audio of the oral argument direct from the courtroom:

Peruta 9th Federal Circuit Audio (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5XoF9e8Pv98#)

The amazing part is were James Chapin states that "A handgun and two clips is a weapon of mass destruction"
I have never seen or heard of a handgun that can load or fire a clip.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: MisterEd on March 06, 2014, 07:55:34 AM
The AG has filed belatedly as a Proposed Appellee Intervenor. Here is the filing the Peruta team has until March 26 to present an argument against

http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/general/2014/02/28/10-56971_motion_to_intervene.pdf (http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/general/2014/02/28/10-56971_motion_to_intervene.pdf)

In oral argument, all the judges were snickering at the AG who did not want to get involved but made certain she was notified that she could be but she declined to during the case.

Here is the actual audio of the oral argument direct from the courtroom:

Peruta 9th Federal Circuit Audio (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5XoF9e8Pv98#)

The amazing part is were James Chapin states that "A handgun and two clips is a weapon of mass destruction"
I have never seen or heard of a handgun that can load or fire a clip.

Link didn't work for me...  tried 2 browsers....  both said 'video is unavailable...    >:(
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: Hawaii Volcano Squad on March 06, 2014, 08:06:02 AM
Link didn't work for me...  tried 2 browsers....  both said 'video is unavailable...    >:(

Youtube is taking forever to "process" the video. it is 40 minutes of argument so give it a few minutes I guess.  ::)
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: Hawaii Volcano Squad on March 06, 2014, 08:33:51 AM
Looks like it is working now for me... sorry it took youtube a few minutes to process, whatever that is.

Can you view the video now?   :shaka:

It was pointed out that there was a stripper clip loaded handgun. You can search youtube for video to see one.

"The Mauser C96 (Construktion 96) is a semi-automatic pistol that was originally produced by German arms manufacturer Mauser from 1896 to 1937."
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: punaperson on March 10, 2014, 08:29:24 AM
http://www.nranews.com/cam/video/ken-klukowski-after-peruta-where-we-go-from-here/list/sportsman-channel-videos (http://www.nranews.com/cam/video/ken-klukowski-after-peruta-where-we-go-from-here/list/sportsman-channel-videos)

NRA News on Sportsman Channel six minute video (March 7) with Ken Klukowski, the senior legal analyst at Breitbart News, on Peruta decision whether or not to grant intervenor status to California Attorney General Kamala Harris. He states that the decision "could take months" and mentions possible "private" intra-court conflicts that can lead to long drawn out decision-making. He also stresses the importance of the upcoming elections as every federal judiciary nominee made by Obama needs to be ratified by the Senate, where it might be possible to overcome the Democratic majority this November. Not that Hawaii would elect a non-Democrat to the Senate, but we could make some effort anyway. Quite a few of these decisions are by one judge (Peruta 2-1, Heller 5-4, McDonald 5-4, etc.) so having the ability to approve or reject these appointments could be important in the future.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: Hawaii Volcano Squad on March 10, 2014, 11:51:25 AM
Good Post Punaperson!
The paperwork the court asked for from the Peruta side rebutting the CA AG's Intervenor states as well as the Brady Gun Violence filing is due on March 26th. I read the filings, and the Brady filing is extensive, the CA AG less so.
If I was the Peruta team I would ask for an extension to respond to each point made and leave to go past the 6,000 word limit on account of there being so many issues raised. It is like the Brady people threw the kitchen sink in the thing.

IN THE MEANTIME, Peruta is the law of the land and until overturned or at least stayed pending an appeal, it seems to me that NOW is the time to demand CCW "good cause" requirement to be eliminated to conform with the 9th Circuit court ruling. If the AG and Police chief decline, file for a "writ of mandamus" to force the issue and pray they choose to actually follow the law as it is now, not as they would like it to be.  :popcorn:
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: punaperson on March 10, 2014, 12:11:41 PM
...
IN THE MEANTIME, Peruta is the law of the land and until overturned or at least stayed pending an appeal, it seems to me that NOW is the time to demand CCW "good cause" requirement to be eliminated to conform with the 9th Circuit court ruling.
...
{For those who may not watch the above video interview...] Ventura and Orange Counties have announced that they are conforming to the Peruta decision to allow "self defense" to be considered "good cause". Due to overwhelming demand for CCW permits the Orange County board of supervisors authorized $1.5 MILLION to hire 15 people to at least temporarily process the huge amount of paperwork coming in for the permits there.

Any guesses as to whether Hawaii would hire people to process the paperwork or just keep the normal staff and let it pile up for a year or two? The courts are going to be busy trying to knock down every unconstitutional rule or regulation or delay Hawaii will conjure up in order to continue to deny law-abiding citizens their natural, civil and Constitutionally-protected right to self defense by bearing arms. Then again, if Abercrombie gets the boot in November and we have some top down leadership, maybe things will change more quickly than it now appears.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: Hawaii Volcano Squad on March 10, 2014, 12:31:22 PM
The State of Hawaii & The Governor are not above the law. They must comply with 9th Fed. Court rulings i.e. Peruta.
My reasoning is that if we ask nicely for a CCW permit application that complies with Peruta, and the State of Hawaii declines, then file for a Writ of Mandamus and have a judge order it.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: 2aHawaii on March 10, 2014, 12:59:04 PM
Due to overwhelming demand for CCW permits the Orange County board of supervisors authorized $1.5 MILLION to hire 15 people to at least temporarily process the huge amount of paperwork coming in for the permits there.

Wow, those are some cushy temp jobs.

Any guesses as to whether Hawaii would hire people to process the paperwork or just keep the normal staff and let it pile up for a year or two? The courts are going to be busy trying to knock down every unconstitutional rule or regulation or delay Hawaii will conjure up in order to continue to deny law-abiding citizens their natural, civil and Constitutionally-protected right to self defense by bearing arms. Then again, if Abercrombie gets the boot in November and we have some top down leadership, maybe things will change more quickly than it now appears.

If we just moved to "shall issue" (or better yet, "constitutional carry") those backups and delays shouldn't be a problem. Of course, if Hawaii goes in and makes it a drag out fight, we could see the same issues as California. We still have to wait for the Baker opinion to come out. There may be some more meat to it than just "see Peruta."
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: new guy on March 10, 2014, 01:42:28 PM
.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: punaperson on March 10, 2014, 01:44:54 PM
Wow, those are some cushy temp jobs.
At least the taxpayers are getting something for their money... which isn't the case for a substantial percentage of government expenditures...

If we just moved to "shall issue" (or better yet, "constitutional carry") those backups and delays shouldn't be a problem.
Well, no matter the wording of the "shall issue" or "Constitutional carry" provision, unless you believe in miracles there are going to be a significant number of hoops to jump through and pay for. No way is this current regime going to allow people to carry "arms" in public without erecting barricades and delays. FCS, Hawaii already has the f***ing longest "waiting period" by far, and the only place besides D.C. that has all encompassing pre-confiscation, I mean "registration", so unless all these bureaucrats have brain transplants, no matter what the courts rule, we'll be twiddling our unarmed thumbs for quite a while IMO.

Of course, if Hawaii goes in and makes it a drag out fight, we could see the same issues as California. We still have to wait for the Baker opinion to come out. There may be some more meat to it than just "see Peruta."
Really? Oh, crap. I was hoping for:

In light of our disposition of the same issue in Peruta v. County of San
Diego, No. 10-56971, — F.3d — (Feb. 13, 2014), we conclude that the district
court in this case erred in denying Richard’s Baker's motion for summary judgment
because the Yolo County Hawaii policy impermissibly infringes on the Second
Amendment right to bear arms in lawful self-defense.
REVERSED and REMANDED.

I am concerned about the judges questioning of the Baker attorney at the beginning of oral arguments as to what would happen even if they ruled for Baker and against Kealoha. I'd have to listen to it again, but even then I might not understand the legal ramifications for the rest of us firearms owners in Hawaii, much less those of us on islands other than Oahu. If someone knows exactly what they meant and how that would effect Hawaii law in general as opposed to just the plaintiff, I'd appreciate an explanation.  :shaka:
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: Hawaii Volcano Squad on March 10, 2014, 03:04:38 PM


In light of our disposition of the same issue in Peruta v. County of San
Diego, No. 10-56971, — F.3d — (Feb. 13, 2014), we conclude that the district
court in this case erred in denying Richard’s Baker's motion for summary judgment
because the Yolo County Hawaii policy impermissibly infringes on the Second
Amendment right to bear arms in lawful self-defense.
REVERSED and REMANDED.

I am concerned about the judges questioning of the Baker attorney at the beginning of oral arguments as to what would happen even if they ruled for Baker and against Kealoha. I'd have to listen to it again, but even then I might not understand the legal ramifications for the rest of us firearms owners in Hawaii, much less those of us on islands other than Oahu. If someone knows exactly what they meant and how that would effect Hawaii law in general as opposed to just the plaintiff, I'd appreciate an explanation.  :shaka:

This is the State of Hawaii's lawyer: "Criminal's might be more likely to carry guns if they think their victims are armed"
Judge: : "But criminals aren't being issued permits! At least I don't believe they are."
State of Hawaii: "If their victims are being issued permits than the criminal is more likely to come with a gun too."

This has to be the most stupid circular logic I have ever heard!
Judge:   If the victim of has a permit the victim has a little more chance of surviving an attack.
State of Hawaii lawyer:  that is not what the empirical evidence that the State of Hawaii relied upon shows is true.

Judge: So even though I may have a right to self defense under the second amendment, Hawaii can tell me outside my home how I can be safest in exercising that right.
State of Hawaii: And how everyone can be safest. Yes your honor.


Anybody want to drink that Kool-aid?

Would be really nice if they remanded it, however after i listened to the Baker oral arguments, it seems that PROBLEM with Hawaii laws are so muddled and poorly conceived and executed, that the judges were trying to question the Baker lawyer about how the chief was or was not in compliance with a law at the same time they were asking about scrutiny levels. perhaps the laws were written this way so they could be interpreted any way  the State wished. Does the state get to determine that different levels of scrutiny the moment you step outside the home? It was all so damn muddled i would not be surprised if the judges STILL don't comprehend how the law is supposed to work. And THAT is why no ruling has been forthcoming on the Baker case even though it was argued & submitted 12-6-2012.

Peruta dealt exclusively with the County Sheriff's policy and not with the State codes. Therefore waiting for the Baker case to be reversed & remanded seems pointless if we limit our request to asking for a form that complies with Peruta instead of issuing an actual permit. Don't challenge the code, challenge the sheriff's permit policy.

GAO-12-717, Gun Control: States’ Laws and
Requirements for Concealed Carry Permits Vary Across the Nation.
Page 75 of the study, clearly shows that in all of Hawaii there are no active permits
Page 76 shows that in New Jersey there are 32,000 active permits

Baker lawyer therefore argues that for regular citizens the policy constitutes an absolute ban.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: punaperson on March 10, 2014, 03:22:31 PM
State of Hawaii lawyer:  that is not what the empirical evidence that the State of Hawaii relied upon shows is true.
I haven't read the Hawaii state documents to see who or what they "relied upon" as "empirical evidence", but I'd be willing to bet that it comes from the Brady Center etc., Mayors Against etc., Moms Demand etc., or some (medical) "researcher" bought and paid for by the Joyce Foundation, LCPGV, VPC, etc.

In the opening of the oral argument Baker attorney Richard Holcomb is questioned by the judges about a preliminary injunction and how that would relate to "abuse of discretion" by the lower court judge. Judge Thomas, who wrote the dissent in Peruta (and re-iterated his objections in affirming Richards)  says to Holcomb, "Your case is in a completely different posture" (compared to Peruta and Richards).

I'm curious to see not only what the court rules in Baker, but how wide or narrow the ruling is. I'm rooting for Baker, of course, and extra wide, but suspect it might be rather narrow. Just gotta wait and see.  :shake:
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: Hawaii Volcano Squad on March 10, 2014, 03:40:22 PM
If there are issues with the legal Strategy in how the Baker case was pursued, and the judge implied that the lawyer may have "shot himself in the foot" I suggest coming at it from a different angle.
Ask for a CCW application form that complies with Peruta.  Ask for any CCW application form! WHEN they deny to do even that, that is completely unconstitutional on the face of it and citing Peruta & also Richards I can not imagine ANY judge not issuing a Writ of Mandamus if applied for in Superior court.

It is always hard to tell if the judges questions are because they likely to rule for or against your position.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: new guy on March 10, 2014, 03:45:24 PM
.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: Hawaii Volcano Squad on March 10, 2014, 03:55:14 PM
What is a Writ of Mandamus?

Who can request one?

How does one go about filing for one?

Mandamus = mandate. A writ of Mandamus is a writ requiring a public official to either do something he is required to do or prohibit the public official from doing something.

Hire a lawyer and have him file in Superior Court.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: new guy on March 10, 2014, 04:10:06 PM
.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: Hawaii Volcano Squad on March 10, 2014, 04:34:20 PM
So anyone can request a Writ of Mandamus?

Have to be represented by a lawyer to file anything in Superior court.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: new guy on March 10, 2014, 05:21:02 PM
.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: Hawaii Volcano Squad on March 10, 2014, 06:19:03 PM
Thanks; last question... what is Superior Court?

It's where you end up if you carry a gun without a permit.
Title: Re: Confusion? CPOA/CPA request rehearing En Banc in Peruta
Post by: new guy on March 10, 2014, 06:21:01 PM
.