2aHawaii
Tools and Uses => Firearms and Accessories => Topic started by: punaperson on June 30, 2014, 12:59:06 PM
-
I had a hellacious nightmare yesterday shooting a Steel Challenge match, with a malfunction on almost every string. Wondering where I can post describing the problem, maybe some pics, and asking for suggestions to solve the problem. :shaka:
-
1. Was the gun functioning well before the match with the same ammo and lot number?
2. Was the gun dirty?
3. Were there any part swap outs: trigger, sear springs firing pins?
4. Did you clean and inspect your magazines?
5. Did you have a knowledgeable gun guy check it out ?
-
6. Did you lubricate the moving parts?
-
Thanks for responding. :shaka:
1. Was the gun functioning well before the match with the same ammo and lot number?
The previous match it worked well until almost 200 rounds into the match. It looked really dirty and someone suggested I spray any kind of lube in there to clean it out... and from that point it worked pretty well, but not perfectly as it had before. I shot it at the range a few times, but not quite to the point of putting 200 rounds through it, and it worked well... just an occasional FTF. Last time I went to the range, the week before the match it started to FTF after only about 50 rounds, even using different brands of ammo. A couple of day prior to the match I bought some Federal Match Grade hoping that would solve the problem, didn't get a chance to test it, but it didn't... FTF right from the start... clean gun. I did use three brands of ammo after several rounds of FTF... no difference.
2. Was the gun dirty?
Cleaned every time I shot it, including prior to the match, using Frog Lube.
3. Were there any part swap outs: trigger, sear springs firing pins?
No.
4. Did you clean and inspect your magazines?
They're nearly new... probably each have less than 200 rounds of use. They looked clean, and I did wipe them down with CLP and the rag was barely smudged after.
5. Did you have a knowledgeable gun guy check it out ?
It was just yesterday, so not yet. Asking here first to see if people have suggestions... figured maybe someone with the same gun had the same problem and discovered a fix. Several of the people at the match seemed rather knowledgeable. The guy who runs the match suggested I install the VOLQUARTSEN EXACT EDGE EXTRACTOR. He has the same gun and said he had a similar problem and the new extractor fixed it. I'll likely try that unless I get some other suggestions to try first. I guess my first plan is to clean it, number my magazines, go to the range and shoot several brands of ammo using the different mags. I really don't think it is the ammo or the mags... because most of the people there were shooting Ruger Mark IIIs with all different kinds of ammo and older mags and they rarely, if ever, had an FTF.
6. Did you lubricate the moving parts?
Frog Lube... but I do wipe most of it off prior to re-assembly. Like I say, same cleaning/lubing procedure before prior match and worked well until it got really dirty. Other people were firing the same number of rounds in the same guns and didn't seem to need to lube/clean theirs during the course of the match... if that is of diagnostic use.
Thanks again! :shaka:
-
I had a mkII that was picky with the brand of ammo. Mine is old and beat up pretty badly though.
How is the ammo jamming in your gun? Nose diving and getting hung up on the feed ramp?
-
Was it ejecting the empty before feeding?
Or was it just not feeding from the magazine?
Was this the Steel Challenge at Glenwood yesterday?
My MK II gave me the fits for a while until I got it sorted out.
-
I had a mkII that was picky with the brand of ammo. Mine is old and beat up pretty badly though.
How is the ammo jamming in your gun? Nose diving and getting hung up on the feed ramp?
:shaka:
One picture would be worth a bunch of words, but haven't had time to get to that yet... the bullet nose ends up above the chamber, it has gone right past the chamber opening, with the entire round at a very steep angle, but not vertical, with the base of the cartridge blocking the feed ramp. When I would rack the slide to clear it, of course that doesn't work, with the result that now another round has gone from the magazine straight into the middle of the nearly vertical round that is blocking the feed ramp and the chamber... then it's a really ugly mess to clear as they often jammed in there to the extent that a magazine removal tool were needed to get the rounds out. Needless to say that kind of slowed down my times... those 30s really kill!
Someone I wrote to earlier today just wrote back saying that a double feed might be caused by the magazine lips needing to be bent inwards very slightly... but I don't think it is double feeding... I thought that second round that is jammed up against the first "vertical" round happened when I racked the slide attempting to clear the first FTF. But I'm not sure. Thanks for the help! :shaka:
-
Was it ejecting the empty before feeding?
It seemed to eject the empty cartridge without issue... which is why I'm wondering about the suggestion to install the Volquartsen ejector... but what do I know?
Or was it just not feeding from the magazine?
It fed, but the bullet nose went up the ramp and right past the chamber opening (see above post) to sit in a nearly vertical position blocking the next round...
Was this the Steel Challenge at Glenwood yesterday?
Yes. Good turnout... only ran 6 stages in spite of having two courses set up at once, but not running simultaneously.
My MK II gave me the fits for a while until I got it sorted out.
I'm pretty frustrated today... not as bad as yesterday... but I probably put 100 unfired rounds on the ground clearing those jams, and started developing a bad habit of "expecting" the gun NOT to fire... plus, I said some really bad words on the firing line... :geekdanc: Maybe your fix for your MKII would help my MKIII? Thanks. :shaka:
-
My MK II had a different problem than you seem to have. Mine would stovepipe about 3-4 rounds on every magazine I had (6). Didn't matter what ammo I fed it.
After my second trip to the range, and a couple of hundred rounds of ammo later, I was sitting there staring at it with the bolt locked open and an empty magazine in it. I saw the ejector was bent down a bit to where it was just touching the magazine.
I don't know how it got bent, but I bent it back up just a hair until it cleared the mag. Been fine ever since. Went through a couple of bricks without any malfunction.
In your case, I would check and compare all your magazine's lips' spacing. They may be a bit too wide. You can check the width easily. Load them up and push them out by using your finger. You should be able to see if there's a problem. They can be bent back inwards until each round strips smoothly and evenly. I ended up doing that on mine too. Too tight, and it won't feed. Good luck and let us know how it goes.
-
My MK II had a different problem than you seem to have. Mine would stovepipe about 3-4 rounds on every magazine I had (6). Didn't matter what ammo I fed it.
After my second trip to the range, and a couple of hundred rounds of ammo later, I was sitting there staring at it with the bolt locked open and an empty magazine in it. I saw the ejector was bent down a bit to where it was just touching the magazine.
I don't know how it got bent, but I bent it back up just a hair until it cleared the mag. Been fine ever since. Went through a couple of bricks without any malfunction.
In your case, I would check and compare all your magazine's lips' spacing. They may be a bit too wide. You can check the width easily. Load them up and push them out by using your finger. You should be able to see if there's a problem. They can be bent back inwards until each round strips smoothly and evenly. I ended up doing that on mine too. Too tight, and it won't feed. Good luck and let us know how it goes.
Thanks! Been reading some and watching some videos... apparently Ruger Mark IIIs have these FTF problems fairly often (I had one decades ago and seem to remember it performing flawlessly). Several have mentioned mag lip interference with the stationary extractor... so bend them in, or file them down. I'll check that out and keep reading and let you know what I do and how or if it works... probably won't make it to the range this week... maybe next week. Mahalo! :shaka:
-
Gotta check the feed ramp alignment with the magazine. Both may need to be polished. Also the guns can be ammo picky. I have best luckahshooting cci mini mag, blaser and the federal automatch. It gun hated federal blue box, bulk remmy and most winchester 333/555. Check the edge also of the extractor it can easly round off and not be sharp. Alsoas well as fire pin alignment into the bolt face.
If u need more check in with the gang on rfc.com talk to sanora gunworks
-
Gotta check the feed ramp alignment with the magazine. Both may need to be polished. Also the guns can be ammo picky. I have best luckahshooting cci mini mag, blaser and the federal automatch. It gun hated federal blue box, bulk remmy and most winchester 333/555. Vheck the edge also on the extractor as well as fire pin alignment.
If u need more check in with the gang on rfc.com talk to sanora gunworks
Thanks for the info. I'll check it out. :shaka:
-
Federal match ammo tends to be a bit weaker than their standard HV stuff. I have a ruger I'm working that refuses to feed federal auto match. But works fine with the federal HV and Mini Mags.
-
Federal match ammo tends to be a bit weaker than their standard HV stuff. I have a ruger I'm working that refuses to feed federal auto match. But works fine with the federal HV and Mini Mags.
Thanks. That might be the first thing I try... before altering anything on the gun or mags. This could take a while... one step at a time per range day... :shaka:
-
:shaka:
One picture would be worth a bunch of words, but haven't had time to get to that yet... the bullet nose ends up above the chamber, it has gone right past the chamber opening, with the entire round at a very steep angle, but not vertical, with the base of the cartridge blocking the feed ramp. When I would rack the slide to clear it, of course that doesn't work, with the result that now another round has gone from the magazine straight into the middle of the nearly vertical round that is blocking the feed ramp and the chamber... then it's a really ugly mess to clear as they often jammed in there to the extent that a magazine removal tool were needed to get the rounds out. Needless to say that kind of slowed down my times... those 30s really kill!
Someone I wrote to earlier today just wrote back saying that a double feed might be caused by the magazine lips needing to be bent inwards very slightly... but I don't think it is double feeding... I thought that second round that is jammed up against the first "vertical" round happened when I racked the slide attempting to clear the first FTF. But I'm not sure. Thanks for the help! :shaka:
I'll second the feed lips. That is what it sounds like by your description of the malfunction. Problem is bending them at the correct angle needed to feed into the chamber, and to do it consistent with all your mags, might prove difficult... Do all the magazines have the same issue? Was the mags dropped on the ground?
-
I just noticed the word COMPETITION in there.
On some Comp pistols the chambers are tighter than regular chambers get some used 22 casings from another gun and see how well they fit. If they are tight then you have a very close tolerance chamber.
-
This is a common problem with .22 pistols which require the magazine lips to be adjusted perfectly in order to feed properly. The magazine pretty much "points" the round towards the chamber. If the feed lips of the magazine are too tight or too loose (I forgot which) this problem will occur. Do you have one magazine that works flawlessly? If so, it would help to measure the distance between the lips and adjust your other magazines accordingly. Are the magazines factory magazines? After market magazines are almost always suspect. Also, make sure this is no build up of any crud under the feed lips of the magazine.
I had the same issues with my High Standard which uses remarkably similar magazines.
The website called Rimfire Central is the best place to find the answer to your question. Here is a link to a similar problem you are having:
http://www.rimfirecentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=537328&highlight=Boosted3g
and the follow-up to it:
http://www.rimfirecentral.com/forums/showthread.php?t=546735
-
I'll be at the range this Saturday for the class in the morning. Look for the guy with the Craftsman tool bag. I can give you a hand after the class.
-
if your ftf failure to fire or feed?
-
I'll be at the range this Saturday for the class in the morning. Look for the guy with the Craftsman tool bag. I can give you a hand after the class.
Thanks for the offer. I haven't been following the thread recently so didn't see your offer until after the fact. You are talking about the Glenwood range, correct? Saturdays are not good for me because that is errands-in-town day. I have removed the Loaded Chamber Indicator, and rounded the front edges of the rear lips of a couple of the Ruger and aftermarket magazines (I still have some of each with original configuration). The lip spacing on all the mags is very very close to the same. Hope to get to the range this week to see if those mods make any difference. I just got the Volquartsen exact edge extractor, but don't want to install it until I see if the mag alteration and the LCI removal make any difference. I also intend to remove the "magazine safety" if/when I install the new extractor. If none of those things work, I'll definitely PM you and beg for help. :shaka:
if your ftf failure to fire or feed?
Feed. The nose of the round appears to go upward past the chamber opening... but that's what it looks like after I've tried to clear the FTF by manually pulling the bolt back and releasing it, which sends another round into the unfed one... so it might look different if I didn't "rack" it... since I was shooting in competition I didn't want to stop and look at it prior to attempting to clear the malfunction... but I should have... after three malfunctions in five shots another default 30 second time wasn't going to make any difference.
-
Update, July 22, 2014:
After a week of rain, finally got a mostly dry morning to go to the range to test the two modifications I had done: 1. removed Loaded Chamber Indicator (LCI) and 2. slightly rounded the front square corner of the rear magazine lips. I had read (and watched youtube videos) for quite a few hours exploring the failure to feed properly issue, and there was no lack of people with suggestions. When I checked the amount of force that was required to move the LCI, it seemed to be more than I suspected (some people claimed that a less than freely moving LCI could cause chambering problems) was necessary, but since I have no other Ruger Mark III to compare it to, it may have been the normal pressure. I removed it. I numbered all my magazines (3 Ruger factory mags, 3 Mec-Gar) and rounded the front of the rear lips of 2 of the Rugers and 2 of the Mec-Gars as per photo below. Quite a few people claimed that helped feeding problems with their Mark IIIs due to possibly too close a tolerance interfering with the fixed extractor ejector and/or the rim coming out of the magazine.
(http://i95.photobucket.com/albums/l134/surfgeorge/rugermarkIIImagliproundingMK2magazineTWEAK.jpg)
Even though I had 4 kinds of .22LR ammo, I chose to use only the stuff (Federal Target Grade Performance) that I have enough of to shoot the next Steel Challenge match (and which is what I used in the last match when I had all the problems), and see if I could get that to work. I shot five rounds per magazine, multiple times. The two altered Ruger mags worked perfectly through 25 rounds each. The one unaltered Ruger mag had a couple of failures to feed in 20 rounds. One unaltered Mec-Gar mag didn't work well at all, the other two had 3 or 4 FTFs in 25 rounds. This was a dramatic improvement over what had happened in the last Steel Challenge match wherein I rarely if ever got off 5 rounds without an FTF. I looked very closely at the mags having problems and decided to bring the front lips slightly closer together on a couple of them as they seemed slightly wider than the perfectly functioning mags. It may have been only a few hundredths of an inch, but they worked slightly better once they were closer, especially the one where one side seemed way too wide. So, way better overall.
Went home and finished with the other mods: 1. removed magazine disconnect safety, installed Tandemkross Magazine Disconnect Bushing (I was prepared to use the super cheap washer technique, but decided to splurge and spent the $10 for the bushing), and 2. replace existing extractor with Volquartzen Hard Edge Extractor. So, over 4 (FOUR!) hours later... JFC... at least half of which was spent watching and re-watching and re-re-watching re-assembly videos (where's the damn third hand and special bent-nose tweezers when you need them?)... it was all put back together! Nothing to it! I learned a lot! I also modded the remaining two original square lipped magazines and sanded the newly rounded corners down nicely with 600 grit sandpaper. (Also polished the sear, hammer, and trigger plunger a bit).
Went to the range this morning. I also made sure to check the alignment of the first/top round in each mag prior to loading into the mag well.
(http://i95.photobucket.com/albums/l134/surfgeorge/rugermarkIIIroundnosealignmentinmagazineandfeedingproblemsmagfeeding.jpg)
Put 35 rounds through each magazine in sets of 5, shooting at my steel plates. 210 rounds.100% perfect. Not a single FTF! Woohoo! :thumbsup: Of course I don't know for sure what part each mod played in correcting the faulty feeding... it may have been that I just needed to clean the gun better or remove excess Frog Lube or who knows? Anyway, I'm going to be practicing a few more times before the next match, and if I have any problems I will update.
Thanks to everyone who took the time to make suggestions and offers of help. If anyone has similar FTF problems with a Mark III I'd be glad to share the sources of my information though most of it is pretty easy to find. :shaka: