2aHawaii

General Topics => Off Topic => Topic started by: mauidog on July 16, 2014, 09:03:59 PM

Title: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: mauidog on July 16, 2014, 09:03:59 PM
Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman

:worship:            :worship:            :worship:            :worship:            :worship:            :worship:            :worship:            :worship:            :worship:         
   

http://youtu.be/Ry3NzkAOo3s (http://youtu.be/Ry3NzkAOo3s)


Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: wirecounter on July 20, 2014, 12:52:51 PM
 :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: GreenStomper on July 20, 2014, 03:00:38 PM
 :thumbsup: :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: Rocky on July 21, 2014, 07:24:48 AM
 :thumbsup: :thumbsup: :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: hvybarrels on July 21, 2014, 10:30:53 AM
That line of thinking taken to it's logical conclusion justifies things like manifest destiny, slavery, and Japanese internment camps. It has no place in modern society, but sadly the owners of the Heritage Foundation are grasping at whatever means available to distract the population from their crimes. Distract the masses by blaming the powerless, so the powerful are free to rob and kill at will.
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: sworbeyegib on July 21, 2014, 05:20:07 PM
She cited a lot of numbers, and had a lot of flash... but didn't answer the question that was asked.  Rather she turned it around and blamed the girl for not asking the right question.
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: mauidog on July 21, 2014, 06:33:13 PM
She cited a lot of numbers, and had a lot of flash... but didn't answer the question that was asked.  Rather she turned it around and blamed the girl for not asking the right question.

What I got out of the video is this:

The Muslim lady's question included the statement that the majority of Muslims are peaceful.  She then asked how do you win a war of ideologies.

The answer was clear:  the peaceful majority throughout history have been irrelevant.  The peaceful majority are complacent and allow the radical minority to determine the group's agenda and destiny.

For an additional example, in the American Revolution, as popularized by the saying, "I am part of the III%," only an estimated 3% of colonists were committed to fighting the British.

In my opinion, she answered the question quite well, and she backed it up with historical facts.

Ideological conflicts sometimes last centuries because the peaceful majorities refuse to get involved.  Small battles are won, but the war goes on for generations. 

The "meat" of her answer was near the end:  where are all the Imams and other peaceful Muslims not at that meeting?  Why only one?  Why aren't the peaceful Muslims asking the government to provide real answers on what happened in Benghazi? 

When will the peaceful majority realize they are irrelevant and decide to take a stand on one side or the other?


How does a nation/group win a war of ideologies?  The peaceful majority has to stop being so passive.
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: mauidog on July 21, 2014, 06:35:16 PM
Quote
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: ren on July 21, 2014, 07:22:09 PM
bravo!
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: Antithesis on July 21, 2014, 11:57:17 PM
That was awesome. 
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: hvybarrels on July 22, 2014, 01:02:51 PM
The logic is that because some of them are bad that none of them have a right to exist.

How quickly we forget.

http://youtu.be/6mr97qyKA2s (http://youtu.be/6mr97qyKA2s)
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: ren on July 22, 2014, 01:35:21 PM
I think the answer is that Muslims need to control those in their ranks to include those radicals instead of being passive victims. They need to empower themselves. They need to stand up to the radicals.
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: mauidog on July 22, 2014, 10:01:03 PM
The logic is that because some of them are bad that none of them have a right to exist.

How quickly we forget.

I have no idea how you came up with that logic?

I'm not sure you can call the Japanese American community back then a majority, passive or not.  I don't remember hearing about Radical Japanese Americans sabotaging US military bases or factories.

Apples and Oranges.
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: BigBlue on July 24, 2014, 12:20:13 AM
What I got out of the video is this:

The Muslim lady's question included the statement that the majority of Muslims are peaceful.  She then asked how do you win a war of ideologies.

The answer was clear:  the peaceful majority throughout history have been irrelevant.  The peaceful majority are complacent and allow the radical minority to determine the group's agenda and destiny.

For an additional example, in the American Revolution, as popularized by the saying, "I am part of the III%," only an estimated 3% of colonists were committed to fighting the British.

In my opinion, she answered the question quite well, and she backed it up with historical facts.

Ideological conflicts sometimes last centuries because the peaceful majorities refuse to get involved.  Small battles are won, but the war goes on for generations. 

The "meat" of her answer was near the end:  where are all the Imams and other peaceful Muslims not at that meeting?  Why only one?  Why aren't the peaceful Muslims asking the government to provide real answers on what happened in Benghazi? 

When will the peaceful majority realize they are irrelevant and decide to take a stand on one side or the other?


How does a nation/group win a war of ideologies?  The peaceful majority has to stop being so passive.

Do you have a source for that 3%? Remembering my american history there were close to a quarter million estimated to serve with the Revolutionary army over the war with the average something like 80k. Population back then was something like 2.5 million.

Eliminating the very young, old, and women, that gives you a pool of probably 625k (napkin math, assuming a population pyramid similar to a modern developing country as people didn't live so long back then and had a lot of kids - so breaking out males age 15-45 gives you typically 25% of the population).

250/625 = 40% of the population served total, with approximately 13% serving at a time on average. That actually sounds high to me, so I'm probably a bit off. Running armies back then took a massive # of people on the logistics/manufacturing/etc side of things. Still nowhere near 3% though.
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: hvybarrels on July 24, 2014, 12:56:14 AM
I have no idea how you came up with that logic?

I'm not sure you can call the Japanese American community back then a majority, passive or not.  I don't remember hearing about Radical Japanese Americans sabotaging US military bases or factories.

Apples and Oranges.

After Pearl Harbor everyone of Japanese ancestry was under suspicion and many got hassled, just like a lot of innocent Muslims and some members of other groups who have nothing do do with Islam but looked a little 'suspicious' at the time. There are too many parallels to mention. The only difference is one group is easier for you to identify with.
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: mauidog on July 24, 2014, 12:57:00 AM
Do you have a source for that 3%? Remembering my american history there were close to a quarter million estimated to serve with the Revolutionary army over the war with the average something like 80k. Population back then was something like 2.5 million.

Eliminating the very young, old, and women, that gives you a pool of probably 625k (napkin math, assuming a population pyramid similar to a modern developing country as people didn't live so long back then and had a lot of kids - so breaking out males age 15-45 gives you typically 25% of the population).

250/625 = 40% of the population served total, with approximately 13% serving at a time on average. That actually sounds high to me, so I'm probably a bit off. Running armies back then took a massive # of people on the logistics/manufacturing/etc side of things. Still nowhere near 3% though.

I'm not sure I've seen a bonafide "source".  What I find are basically mass acceptance that the 3% concept appears reasonable and generally accepted as "highly probable."  Here's an example:

http://sipseystreetirregulars.blogspot.com/2009/02/what-is-three-percenter.html (http://sipseystreetirregulars.blogspot.com/2009/02/what-is-three-percenter.html)

There are plenty of stories that demonstrate how divided the colonists were.  Going against King and Country was about as radical as anyone could be then.  The link states about 30% were supportive of the Revolution, but only about 3% were actually fighting in the field.

Quote
During the American Revolution, the active forces in the field against the King's tyranny never amounted to more than 3% of the colonists.
They were in turn actively supported by perhaps 10% of the population. In addition to these revolutionaries were perhaps another 20% who favored
their cause but did little or nothing to support it.

Another one-third of the population sided with the King (by the end of the war there were actually more Americans fighting FOR the King than there
were in the field against him) and the final third took no side, blew with the wind and took what came.
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: mauidog on July 24, 2014, 01:18:47 AM
After Pearl Harbor everyone of Japanese ancestry was under suspicion and many got hassled, just like a lot of innocent Muslims and some members of other groups who have nothing do do with Islam but looked a little 'suspicious' at the time. There are too many parallels to mention. The only difference is one group is easier for you to identify with.

How are your comments related to the answer given in the video?  It seems to me you may be speaking only from the perspective of the Muslim asking the question. 

Who you or I identify with is irrelevant.    I was not the person speaking in the video, and it is her answer and comments I am discussing, not mine.

From a historical and pragmatic viewpoint, I think the speaker makes a great point.  The majority can ideologically support a radical position, or they can oppose it.  Unless that majority is willing to put some serious action behind that stance, their position is totally irrelevant because the minority will win. 

Put another way, #HASHTAGS-R-IRRELEVANT.  If the extent of the majority's support or opposition is to Tweet about it, then they have lost before they even started.

Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: hvybarrels on July 24, 2014, 02:01:14 AM
I'm guessing by 'majority' she means all Muslims. In that case she is making the argument that because some Muslims are bad, that it's ok to indiscriminately violate the human rights of anyone who belongs to the 'majority' because willingly or not, every one of them participated in the terrorist acts simply because of belonging to the larger group which the terrorists also happen to occupy.

I've never heard of her before, but apparently it's her job to incite hatred for Islam in hopes of swaying public opinion in favor of whatever godawful mess the State Department is cooking up next, allowing Heritage Foundation associates to continue their war profiteering unimpeded.
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: mauidog on July 24, 2014, 02:10:21 AM
I'm guessing by 'majority' she means all Muslims. In that case she is making the argument that because some Muslims are bad, that it's ok to indiscriminately violate the human rights of anyone who belongs to the 'majority' because willingly or not, every one of them participated in the terrorist acts simply because of belonging to the larger group which the terrorists also happen to occupy.

I've never heard of her before, but apparently it's her job to incite hatred for Islam in hopes of swaying public opinion in favor of whatever godawful mess the State Department is cooking up next, allowing Heritage Foundation associates to continue their war profiteering unimpeded.

Okay, you've established more than once that the peaceful majority has human rights.  I heard nothing in her comments that dispute that.

What I have not heard you mention once, but was IMO the theme of her statement, is:  what responsibilities does the peaceful majority have?

I get tired of hearing about how so many people demand their rights, but so many wouldn't know their responsibilities if their lives depended on it....and she named several points in history where that was literally the case.
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: hvybarrels on July 24, 2014, 11:11:21 AM
It's also our responsibility to keep our own government in check, but does that mean we should be held accountable when our government arms thugs and murderous puppet dictators who massacre their own people? Does that mean those people have a right to organize themselves into a paramilitary force and attack civilians in our country as a response?
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: mauidog on July 24, 2014, 11:28:36 AM
It's also our responsibility to keep our own government in check, but does that mean we should be held accountable when our government arms thugs and murderous puppet dictators who massacre their own people? Does that mean those people have a right to organize themselves into a paramilitary force and attack civilians in our country as a response?

Rhetorical questions at best...
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: hvybarrels on July 24, 2014, 11:48:11 AM
It's not rhetorical because it can be answered definitively, but I understand why you hesitate because doing so would expose the underlying ugliness of her way of thinking.



http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/how-we-work/201111/how-avoid-becoming-person-you-hate (http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/how-we-work/201111/how-avoid-becoming-person-you-hate)

Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: mauidog on July 25, 2014, 10:50:05 PM
It's not rhetorical because it can be answered definitively, but I understand why you hesitate because doing so would expose the underlying ugliness of her way of thinking.



http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/how-we-work/201111/how-avoid-becoming-person-you-hate (http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/how-we-work/201111/how-avoid-becoming-person-you-hate)

They are rhetorical because the answers are obvious.  A question is rhetorical when you don't really expect an answer, not because it can't be answered "definitively".

Quote
Q:  It's also our responsibility to keep our own government in check, but does that mean we should be held accountable when our government arms thugs and murderous puppet dictators who massacre their own people?

A:  We can't hold anybody accountable LEGALLY for doing what you said in the first question unless there are specific laws against it -- trade embargoes, international laws /see below/, ... .  If you are asking whether we, the people, should hold they, the government, morally accountable --- that's what elections are for.  Whether or not accountability is applied depends on how interested or outraged the voters are.  That's a whole, long discussion in itself on whether that happens enough times and what factors affect public sentiment.

Q:  Does that mean those people have a right to organize themselves into a paramilitary force and attack civilians in our country as a response?

A:  Civilians are almost never "fair game" for military/paramilitary targeting.  Collateral civilian deaths are always a part of any war, but to specifically target civilians without having a tactical or strategic military target as the primary objective is difficult to justify morally.

We have the Geneva Convention treaties for a reason:  to establish the standards of international law for the humanitarian treatment of war and of conflicts contained within the borders of a single country, such as a government fighting rebel forces.  Chemical and biological weapons of mass destruction are now illegal  So is the indiscriminate killing of civilians.  Since these acts are considered war crimes, it is appropriate for the international community to try to prosecute and punish those responsible.  Retaliating by targeting civilians as retribution for supporting violent governments is illegal and a crime against humanity.   Doing so is usually a bad tactic anyway, as most times it's tried, the population wants to retaliate instead of capitulate. 

Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: hvybarrels on August 04, 2014, 07:43:45 AM
Nice try skating around the issues, but you didn't answer the questions. Instead you just inserted some politically correct war criminal babble that aggressive countries would use to placate legitimate human rights concerns. I'm pretty sure we aren't going to get anywhere so I'll spell it out. If all Muslims are somehow responsible for the attacks on American civilians by a few radicals, then American civilians are also guilty of supporting the war crimes of our government against Muslim civilian populations. Any argument about 'moral imperative' is just propaganda, and an attempt to get the population to accept two conflicting truths simultaneously (aka Orwellian doublethink).

Speaking of which, here is a perfect example of where the blind logic of people like Bridgette Gabriel would happily lead us if most Americans didn't find this kind of naked fascist rhetoric so unpalatable.

http://www.vice.com/read/israeli-racism-gaza-kleinfeld-511 (http://www.vice.com/read/israeli-racism-gaza-kleinfeld-511)

For now she has to dance around the issues and pretend she's not saying what she's really saying so she won't get booed off the stage.
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: mauidog on August 04, 2014, 03:59:17 PM
Nice try skating around the issues, but you didn't answer the questions. Instead you just inserted some politically correct war criminal babble that aggressive countries would use to placate legitimate human rights concerns. I'm pretty sure we aren't going to get anywhere so I'll spell it out. If all Muslims are somehow responsible for the attacks on American civilians by a few radicals, then American civilians are also guilty of supporting the war crimes of our government against Muslim civilian populations. Any argument about 'moral imperative' is just propaganda, and an attempt to get the population to accept two conflicting truths simultaneously (aka Orwellian doublethink).

Speaking of which, here is a perfect example of where the blind logic of people like Bridgette Gabriel would happily lead us if most Americans didn't find this kind of naked fascist rhetoric so unpalatable.

http://www.vice.com/read/israeli-racism-gaza-kleinfeld-511 (http://www.vice.com/read/israeli-racism-gaza-kleinfeld-511)

For now she has to dance around the issues and pretend she's not saying what she's really saying so she won't get booed off the stage.

You accuse me of skating around the issues, when in fact you're just trying to muddy the water with a bunch of unrelated slippery slop diatribe and ideological labels like "fascists".

If the leaders of a group, any group, who  are in a position to affect the attitudes and actions of their followers do and say nothing, I believe they share some of the blame when the violence continues.  It's no different than someone watching a house burn standing next to a fire hose.  You might not have started to fire, but you sure as hell aren't doing anything to help.  Maybe that's the kind of world you want to live in?  Everyone just ignores what others do, and just live your own life without responsibilities or duties to society.  As long as nobody bothers you, you could care less what happens to others.

That's the point.  Period.  Nobody is being rounded up and interred, and nobody is being lynched.  I simply believe community and religious leaders have a responsibility to SPEAK OUT so that those who commit acts of death in the name of religion will know where the majority stand.

Silence is tacit approval, and in many cases (I'd bet everything I own) these peaceful Muslims actually support the violence.  I don't think it's the majority, but a good many do.  That's what the culture and the religion teaches, so why wouldn't they?  We see today Hamas fighting Israel for one purpose - to kill all Jews.  It's in their charter.  You might not like hearing it, but it's the truth.

We live in an age of information that can quickly change the hearts and minds of millions of people almost instantaneously.  By refusing to use their influence to halt the violence, they remain silent.

I've drawn my conclusions.  If you disagree, then you're welcome to your opinion.  If that doesn't address the issue well enough, please let me know and I'll answer any questions ... I don't want to be accused of skirting issues.

Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: hvybarrels on August 07, 2014, 08:45:34 AM
You are being trained to dehumanize them. It's the first step down the road to preparing you to support mass murder. Hundreds of thousands of Iraqi civilians have already died for  nothing, but that's OK because they didn't speak up enough? That's some sick twisted logic.
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: mauidog on August 07, 2014, 01:32:38 PM
You are being trained to dehumanize them. It's the first step down the road to preparing you to support mass murder. Hundreds of thousands of Iraqi civilians have already died for  nothing, but that's OK because they didn't speak up enough? That's some sick twisted logic.

The radicals are already proving they have dehumanized themselves by their own barbaric acts! 

If the iraqi's died for nothing, then it's not because we didn't try ... up until this administration anyway.

My logic is not twisted.  It might be cold, but it's honest. 

We can't have peace through absence of conflict.  That will never happen realistically.  Peace can only be obtained when we have the will and the means to defend ourselves and our allies.

Obviously, our foreign policy and resolve is too weak to matter, as is evident by the way our leader makes speeches and only acts when he feels compelled to help the Muslim Brotherhood or other Al Quaeda groups.

This administration has already committed mass murder by allowing those depending on our protection to be left up to their own defenses.    In Iraq, we didn't transition anything.  We disrupted a tyrannical government, we gave them a few guidelines to adopt, we helped rebuild some infrastructure, and then we pulled out before they were ready.  The results were predictable.  Lots of civilians and noncivilians died because we left too soon.  Nothing twisted about my logic.  The twist is in our government's commitment to our allies.
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: hvybarrels on August 08, 2014, 03:47:40 AM
That's funny I remember Rummy saying something about "weeks not months" and "greeted as liberators" when we first rolled into Iraq a decade ago under the pretense of stopping weapons of mass destruction that were an imminent danger to the United States. I guess someone pressed the history eraser button. As far as the motives of BG and her war profiteer colleagues at the Heritage Foundation, I suggest you reference the following graphic.
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: mauidog on August 08, 2014, 09:33:41 AM
That's funny I remember Rummy saying something about "weeks not months" and "greeted as liberators" when we first rolled into Iraq a decade ago under the pretense of stopping weapons of mass destruction that were an imminent danger to the United States. I guess someone pressed the history eraser button. As far as the motives of BG and her war profiteer colleagues at the Heritage Foundation, I suggest you reference the following graphic.

Is that graphic telling you something new?  Of course every nation tries to make themselves out to be morally right in any conflict.  But what does that change?  What can it teach?  I say "nothing."

I think you're trying your best to muddy the water with as many politically charged accusations as possible.  The discussion is not about what we are doing.  It's about what those who decry being identified with the "bad" Muslims are NOT doing.

Approximately 23% of the world's population is Muslim. Current estimates conclude that the number of Muslims in the world is around 1.6 billion.  Therefore, if just 1% are violent radicals, that's 16 million people.  Don't know about you, but that scares me quite a bit.
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: hvybarrels on August 11, 2014, 12:56:04 AM
It's definitely more important to be concerned about what we are doing. Our government is infested with criminals who are working as hard as they can to destabilize as many nations as possible around the world in a desperate move to shift the blame away from themselves when our currency collapses. The easiest targets are those who don't have a voice or the resources to stand up for themselves in the face of an overwhelming media brainwash onslaught.

That woman stood up and pointed out the gross misrepresentation of her people, and BG did everything she could to demonize her and shut her up with playground bully tactics. BG is counting on the under-educated trash-tv watching Americans who don't own a passport to back her up with an outpouring of xenophobic outrage, which they did. What BG did was to insult the whole audience by appealing to their ignorance.
Title: Re: Brigitte Gabriel gives FANTASTIC answer to Muslim woman
Post by: mauidog on August 11, 2014, 01:39:02 AM
It's definitely more important to be concerned about what we are doing. Our government is infested with criminals who are working as hard as they can to destabilize as many nations as possible around the world in a desperate move to shift the blame away from themselves when our currency collapses. The easiest targets are those who don't have a voice or the resources to stand up for themselves in the face of an overwhelming media brainwash onslaught.

That woman stood up and pointed out the gross misrepresentation of her people, and BG did everything she could to demonize her and shut her up with playground bully tactics. BG is counting on the under-educated trash-tv watching Americans who don't own a passport to back her up with an outpouring of xenophobic outrage, which they did. What BG did was to insult the whole audience by appealing to their ignorance.

You seem to have a very broad brush yourself!