2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: Heavies on June 20, 2011, 07:59:57 PM
-
Neighbors big a$$ dog jumps the fence, threatens my families safety, my dogs safety, and my safety.
I am talking BIG. I believe Alaskan Malimute. Looks like a fricken wolf.
What to do?
Came this close to getting my gun.
Luckily me being so pissed scared the dog back over the fence.
Thoughts?
-
Depends on the behavior of the dog, but I would think you would be well within your right to take any and all actions to protect you and your family. Did you discuss it with your neighbor after the incident was over?
-
Discussion was with high volume, choice words, and colorful metaphors.
I have been having much problems with these folks for a while now. Very inconsiderate people for sure. I have had to call HPD on them many times.
I have tried to be civil with no results. HPD can do next to nothing.
-
I would use a baseball bat. Is it possible to be its friend and feed it some treats?
-
Are you sure you aren't possibly exaggerating on the threatening safety portion :O. If the dog took off, he's probably more scared of you, then you are of him. Shooting your neighbors dog will make for a interesting event lol - so i recommend against it. I don't have time, but there are leash and animal control laws. Contact them, see what they say. Spray the dog with pepper spray imo (that was its original design) if you feel you need to fend him off. One of most worrying parts of serving court documents was dealing with the dogs. I have had to go on some properties while the dog was barking and looking mean as shit, but they were really just a big baby. Dog treats go a long way lol. For 99.9% of people, there isn't a dog you can own that will look away from a t-bone or dog treats :P.
Relevant rules can be found here: http://www1.honolulu.gov/council/ocs/roh/7.pdf (http://www1.honolulu.gov/council/ocs/roh/7.pdf) the important portion is the 'strays'. One thing though, don't let the dog become the weapon or victim for dealing with your shitty neighbors. It's not his fault his owners are fucking garbage :(. He may just want a friend and wants to come visit you lol. (no seriously!)
-
Thank you for the replies and the info.
The dog may be friendly, and it may not be. I don't want to find out with the safety of my family.
You have to realize this dog is not the size of a normal dog. If it stood on its hind legs it probably be taller than me, and easily much larger than my wife. I talking at least 70 lbs+. I have been working a lot lately, and dead tired. And, to be woken from a dead sleep with the wife screaming that the dog was on our property was very unsettling. Luckily, the dog was not mean, and pretty much listened to what I was telling it to do, which was to 'go home'. But, with an animal of this size, I don't care if it is naughty or nice, if it decided to attack there would have been some serious injury.
Here is a pic I found on the net. This one is fatter than the one we encountered, but the height looks about right. Chest high for me..
http://www.carnivoraforum.com/index.cgi?board=discussion&action=print&thread=9769 (http://www.carnivoraforum.com/index.cgi?board=discussion&action=print&thread=9769)
(http://www.alaskan.ru/upload/files/286.jpg)
If the dog was mean, and I had to bat, shoot it, or whatever, what charges would I face? Knowing this state I probably would have been up sh_t creek. :(
After my immediate and unequivocal reprimand, back door neighbor erected a wooden board, thus blocking the access the dog had to jump over the fence.
I just hope they wise up. :P
-
Lol -- yeah dude, smashing the neighbors dog is probably going to have your ass at trial. I mean that stupid lady went to trial for a peacock... Imagine when star advertiser reads "Local Man smashes man's best friend in face, slaying fluffy puppy." If he ran away when you went home, I would be willing to wager that the dog is not violent. He is probably not given the attention he needs, not exercised, and not taken care of properly. Those dogs are not the type to just sit around -- they need lots of exercise.
-
Having kids of my own, I completely understand where you're coming from. BUT you do NOT want to shoot your neighbors pet. Even if justified, I can almost guarantee you'll get sued and likely never own a firearm again (after being charged with some B.S.).
Malamutes are intelligent and friendly dogs, so I'm almost positive you can easily befriend it. If that doesn't work, file a nuinsance complaint and call the Humane Society. Your neighbor will have to improve the fence, chain the dog, or get just rid of it.
-
Pungi sticks....
-
Did you check with the Humane Society ?
Did thay have anything meaningful to add?
Neighborhood Board?
Above all, DO NOT LOOSE YOUR TEMPER. Play it COOL.
Got video camera? Or regullar digital camera with Video. Great evidence if it has to go to court.
If ALL else fails, do you have a lawyer/attorney that you can talk to?
By Law, maximum height of fence/wall permitted is 6 feet.
Unfortunately, if you have problems, file a police complaint First, before the neighbor does.
Keep us informed
-
Sticky situation with many of the pros and cons of defending yourself already mentioned.....I would add that if you choose to use pepper spray, maybe one with a dye would be useful to ID the dog after the fact....
-
Relevant rules can be found here: http://www1.honolulu.gov/council/ocs/roh/7.pdf (http://www1.honolulu.gov/council/ocs/roh/7.pdf) the important portion is the 'strays'.
And the section on penalties on the owner.
Eh, I know what I would do here, but I am not going to post it. >:D
So you called the police? Did they show? Animal control? Need some more background.
-
I just saw something on the Hawaii News Now website that may relate to this topic. Abercrombie signed 15 bills into law today one of which was:
Another, Senate Bill 1068, classifies killing or attempting to kill someone's pet without their consent as animal cruelty in the first degree.
Edit: Nevermind. The bill contains the text:
Subsection (1) (b) shall not apply to:...
Conduct which the actor believes to be necessary to
avoid an imminent harm or evil to the actor, another
person, or an animal; provided that the harm or evil
sought to be avoided by such conduct is greater than
that sought to be prevented by this section and is
justifiable as provided in section 703-302 for choice
of evils; provided further that, for purposes of this
paragraph, as the justification described in section
703-302 shall also apply to conduct which the actor
believes to be necessary to avoid an imminent harm or
evil to an animal.
-
At my job we do a lot of work where we disconnect service when they don't pay.. A lot of times we have Dog Spray to fend off their family pets.. I even was put outta work for getting bit by a customers dog once for like a month from tenden damage in my hand..
Man that sux.. Thats why Will Ferrell, Adam Sandler, Jack Black, Ben Stiller ETC. make "Dry Humor" movies, so these lame people catch on... :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
-
Shux this is a good post... I would do things that I can't mention here.. No one, absolutely no one threatens the OHANA!! >:(
-
I just saw something on the Hawaii News Now website that may relate to this topic. Abercrombie signed 15 bills into law today one of which was:
Another, Senate Bill 1068, classifies killing or attempting to kill someone's pet without their consent as animal cruelty in the first degree.
Thats whats wrong with our crappy politicians.
Passing more animal cruelty laws instead of spending their time and effort on more meaningful issues.
-
Man, everytime I hear that name Abercrombie, I think of Sodom and Gomorrah.....Guess what happen to them :-\ God gives us Free Will and we spit all over it... Sorry kinda graphic...... >:(
-
Man, everytime I hear that name Abercrombie, I think of Sodom and Gomorrah.....Guess what happen to them :-\ God gives us Free Will and we spit all over it... Sorry kinda graphic...... >:(
Yep, that's the first thing he did while in office.
He took care of the homosexuals.
Thanks a lot whoever voted him in. :thumbsup:
-
I totally sympathize with Heavies' situation. I have a slightly different situation. My neighbors are very good owners, but they have a very bad and very large dog. He is aggressive towards everyone, and I am 98% sure if I ever entered his enclosure, he would try to kill me. My neighbors NEVER let that dog out of their yard, and very rarely let him out of the enclosure.
This past weekend, while I was at the Shooting Sports Fair, that large dog killed my favorite pet which had escaped and gone into its enclosure (I admit it is my fault). When I went to get the body, that dog took an attack stance to kill me. It was not the stance or mannerisms to intimidate or scare away a stranger.
My neighbors handle that dog as well as possible, but if that dog gets loose even once, it will be a bad situation. If it came into my yard, I think shooting it on sight would be totally justified...that is, if I could somehow get to a gun in time.
-
Peashooter,
That is sad. Did the owner of the vicious dog make any effort to give you justice?
-
Not really, but I didn't see that as a problem. My pet was not an expensive animal. If it had been another dog, or a parrot (the most expensive animals I can think of) then maybe it would have been a little different.
I liked my pet a lot, but nothing can replace him, so there's nothing really for me to do now. I think that most dogs would have tried to kill my pet in that situation, even nice ones. It just happens that this particular dog is also large and dangerous to people. A lot of large dogs are nice, and a lot of small dogs are mean. A pitbull for example doesn't bother me that much because pitbulls are only medium size. If I had to I could probably kill one with my bare hands.
Actually, these same neighbors have always kept one large dog over the last 20 years or so. If I remember correctly, this is their 3rd one. Their first one was very nice and died of old age. Their second one was just like this one. He escaped one day and probably tried to kill someone. However, the person killed the dog by kicking it in the nose. Must have been a pretty capable person. No one ever found out who it was.
-
Shux this is a good post... I would do things that I can't mention here.. No one, absolutely no one threatens the OHANA!! >:(
I dunno about the rest of you, but my dogs are members of my family. If someone shot one of my dogs I'd be looking for swift and vengeful retribution (granted, my dogs are well trained and docile animals). While yes you or your family members may be frightened by the animal, are you warranted in taking it's life?
Moreover, is someone who doesn't take the time and responsibility to train their dogs to keep it from jumping fences and potentially attacking people, the type of person who could see the rationality of why their dog was killed, or would they be seeking vengance against you and your family? Is a neighbor with a vendeta who knows when you'll be home and when your family will be vulnerable, more dangerous than a big dog that jumps a fence? All things to conside before using a firearm to "solve" this problem.
-
Thats true Antithesis, plus every situation is different.. In a situation where my human family is in danger from a force that does not stop by a loud clear command must be stopped by another means.. Even if my own dog bites or attacks my family or someone elses family it will be put down.. Human life is more important to me.. That is just my opinion I guess.. Don't mean to offend any other dog owners.. I'm mature enough to not go out and kill a pet for no reason, thats just not right... Depends on the situation...The health and welfare of my wife and children are all I have....Peace :thumbsup:
-
With all due respect to those who have pets that are integrated deeply into their family, they are still pets. Pets are not worth the safety of a human being. With regards to what should be used........anything that will quickly stop the threat including firearms. Same argument used to stop a human that is threatening my friends, family, myself.
It is easy to make an argument of what should have been after the fact, but if you are in the moment and the pet has to die, then so be it. It is the responsibility of the pet owner to control their pet, not yours to instantly understand what that pet's intent is.
Here is a story from today's paper about an attack at the K-Bay sandbar:
http://www.staradvertiser.com/news/20110623__Dogattack_victim_undergoes_surgery.html (http://www.staradvertiser.com/news/20110623__Dogattack_victim_undergoes_surgery.html)
Dog-attack victim undergoes surgery
By Rosemarie Bernardo
POSTED: 01:30 a.m. HST, Jun 23, 2011
A woman remained in a hospital after surgery Tuesday night to repair deep cuts from an unprovoked attack at the Kaneohe sandbar by a bull mastiff that weighs as much as she does.
The victim, a veteran crew member of the Dreamer Yacht Charters, suffered deep lacerations behind her ear, on the back of her neck and on top of her head from the attack by the 130-pound dog.
"She is still traumatized," said Rob Mathews, operations manager of Dreamer.
The woman, described as 5 feet 4 inches tall and 130 pounds, was in stable condition and is recovering, he said. She is expected to remain at the hospital for the next three days. Mathews said doctors are concerned about infections that might develop from the bite wounds.
The state Department of Land and Natural Resources is continuing an investigation of the attack at the sandbar, which falls under state jurisdiction. Spokeswoman Deborah Ward said the dog was released to its owner after the attack because the state doesn't have rules relating to dangerous dogs.
The Hawaiian Humane Society could not impound the dog because the attack occurred outside its jurisdiction. If a serious dog attack occurred on land on Oahu, the Humane Society, in general, would have the authority to impound the animal, said Keoni Vaughn, the society's director of operations.
Under Honolulu's dangerous-dog ordinance, violators face a fine of $500 to $2,000 and a maximum jail term of 30 days. The owner also could be mandated to pay restitution to the victim of medical expenses and financial loss.
The ordinance applies to dogs that have a history of attacks. If the dog has no history of attacks, the offense would be downgraded to an animal nuisance dog bite where the owner can face a fine of $50 to $1,000 and up to six months' probation.
Vaughn said the Humane Society issued the owner a warning Tuesday to document the attack.
Tuesday afternoon, the victim was setting an anchor when the dog from a recreational boat 100 yards away jumped on her and dragged her underwater, Mathews said. The captain of the chartered yacht grabbed a bullhorn to alert the dog owner and jumped into the water to help the victim, he said.
The owner responded as soon as he realized what was going on, Mathews said. "If it happened to a child, the results would've been completely catastrophic," said Mathews, noting that he sees children at the sandbar every day.
-
quote]
Spokeswoman Deborah Ward said the dog was released to its owner after the attack because the state doesn't have rules relating to dangerous dogs.
Under Honolulu's dangerous-dog ordinance, violators face a fine of $500 to $2,000 and a maximum jail term of 30 days. The owner also could be mandated to pay restitution to the victim of medical expenses and financial loss
So which is it? Is there a law or isn't there? ???
-
quote]
Spokeswoman Deborah Ward said the dog was released to its owner after the attack because the state doesn't have rules relating to dangerous dogs.
Under Honolulu's dangerous-dog ordinance, violators face a fine of $500 to $2,000 and a maximum jail term of 30 days. The owner also could be mandated to pay restitution to the victim of medical expenses and financial loss
So which is it? Is there a law or isn't there? ???
State of Hawaii does not currently have laws related with "dangerous dogs". C&C of Honolulu does (hence the fine and jail term). Because the attack happened on the Sand Bar, the new reporter is saything that it falls under State jurisdiction rather than C&C of Honolulu. Hence Humane Society did not take the dog into custody because of the attack. Personally, I think the owner of the animal is deffinently in hot kim chee for the dog's actions. They may not be getting a criminal charge, but I'm pretty sure they'll be liable for any and all associated medical costs for this woman...
-
quote]
Spokeswoman Deborah Ward said the dog was released to its owner after the attack because the state doesn't have rules relating to dangerous dogs.
Under Honolulu's dangerous-dog ordinance, violators face a fine of $500 to $2,000 and a maximum jail term of 30 days. The owner also could be mandated to pay restitution to the victim of medical expenses and financial loss
So which is it? Is there a law or isn't there? ???
State of Hawaii does not currently have laws related with "dangerous dogs". C&C of Honolulu does (hence the fine and jail term). Because the attack happened on the Sand Bar, the new reporter is saything that it falls under State jurisdiction rather than C&C of Honolulu. Hence Humane Society did not take the dog into custody because of the attack. Personally, I think the owner of the animal is deffinently in hot kim chee for the dog's actions. They may not be getting a criminal charge, but I'm pretty sure they'll be liable for any and all associated medical costs for this woman...
I would fully expect to get sued if I were that dogs owner.
-
Totally agree Vood. They (the owners) should be thankful the dog didn't attack some toddler or little kid (as little kids are often times at the Sand Bar). If that 130 lbs dog had gotten a hold of a child, things would have ended up far worse...
-
You could certainly bust their butts in civil court. I can't think of any jury that wouldn't give them a judgement for failing to leash their pet.
-
I dunno about the rest of you, but my dogs are members of my family. If someone shot one of my dogs I'd be looking for swift and vengeful retribution (granted, my dogs are well trained and docile animals). While yes you or your family members may be frightened by the animal, are you warranted in taking it's life?
Moreover, is someone who doesn't take the time and responsibility to train their dogs to keep it from jumping fences and potentially attacking people, the type of person who could see the rationality of why their dog was killed, or would they be seeking vengance against you and your family? Is a neighbor with a vendeta who knows when you'll be home and when your family will be vulnerable, more dangerous than a big dog that jumps a fence? All things to conside before using a firearm to "solve" this problem.
Anti,
I have pups too, and yes they are a part of my family. That is the reason I was so enraged. When an other dog, that could easily damage my little dogs, enters my property, I'm gonna side with suspicion and caution. You can bet that the strange mutt is the one that will be going down first.
It is the same as if a 250 lb burglar entered my home. I'm not going to wait till he does some dastardly deed before I take some kind of action, if at all possible. Am I wrong?
-
I dunno about the rest of you, but my dogs are members of my family. If someone shot one of my dogs I'd be looking for swift and vengeful retribution (granted, my dogs are well trained and docile animals). While yes you or your family members may be frightened by the animal, are you warranted in taking it's life?
Moreover, is someone who doesn't take the time and responsibility to train their dogs to keep it from jumping fences and potentially attacking people, the type of person who could see the rationality of why their dog was killed, or would they be seeking vengance against you and your family? Is a neighbor with a vendeta who knows when you'll be home and when your family will be vulnerable, more dangerous than a big dog that jumps a fence? All things to conside before using a firearm to "solve" this problem.
Anti,
I have pups too, and yes they are a part of my family. That is the reason I was so enraged. When an other dog, that could easily damage my little dogs, enters my property, I'm gonna side with suspicion and caution. You can bet that the strange mutt is the one that will be going down first.
It is the same as if a 250 lb burglar entered my home. I'm not going to wait till he does some dastardly deed before I take some kind of action, if at all possible. Am I wrong?
Hey? Why does the burglar have to be 250 pounds?
Don't you know you're more likely to be robbed by a 120 pound meth head?
-
I dunno about the rest of you, but my dogs are members of my family. If someone shot one of my dogs I'd be looking for swift and vengeful retribution (granted, my dogs are well trained and docile animals). While yes you or your family members may be frightened by the animal, are you warranted in taking it's life?
Moreover, is someone who doesn't take the time and responsibility to train their dogs to keep it from jumping fences and potentially attacking people, the type of person who could see the rationality of why their dog was killed, or would they be seeking vengance against you and your family? Is a neighbor with a vendeta who knows when you'll be home and when your family will be vulnerable, more dangerous than a big dog that jumps a fence? All things to conside before using a firearm to "solve" this problem.
Anti,
I have pups too, and yes they are a part of my family. That is the reason I was so enraged. When an other dog, that could easily damage my little dogs, enters my property, I'm gonna side with suspicion and caution. You can bet that the strange mutt is the one that will be going down first.
It is the same as if a 250 lb burglar entered my home. I'm not going to wait till he does some dastardly deed before I take some kind of action, if at all possible. Am I wrong?
Hey? Why does the burglar have to be 250 pounds?
Don't you know you're more likely to be robbed by a 120 pound meth head?
This!
I also heard on 690AM that the state will be banning alcohol at the Sandbar for the 4th and possibly on future holidays. They made mention of the dog attack. Glad to see that dogs will not be getting hammered at the sand bar.... :crazy:
-
Well in Hawaii you have to be reasonably certain your life is in danger to justifiably use a firearm against another human being, so being 250 pounds versus 120 pounds would be relevant. Not saying it should be, just that it is.
-
Well in Hawaii you have to be reasonably certain your life is in danger to justifiably use a firearm against another human being, so being 250 pounds versus 120 pounds would be relevant. Not saying it should be, just that it is.
Source?
-
quote]
Spokeswoman Deborah Ward said the dog was released to its owner after the attack because the state doesn't have rules relating to dangerous dogs.
Under Honolulu's dangerous-dog ordinance, violators face a fine of $500 to $2,000 and a maximum jail term of 30 days. The owner also could be mandated to pay restitution to the victim of medical expenses and financial loss
So which is it? Is there a law or isn't there? ???
State of Hawaii does not currently have laws related with "dangerous dogs". C&C of Honolulu does (hence the fine and jail term). Because the attack happened on the Sand Bar, the new reporter is saything that it falls under State jurisdiction rather than C&C of Honolulu. Hence Humane Society did not take the dog into custody because of the attack. Personally, I think the owner of the animal is deffinently in hot kim chee for the dog's actions. They may not be getting a criminal charge, but I'm pretty sure they'll be liable for any and all associated medical costs for this woman...
When the lawsuits start hitting I'll bet the State tries to worm out of this and say it's a Coast Guard matter.