2aHawaii
General Topics => Off Topic => Topic started by: monster796 on September 28, 2014, 07:51:32 PM
-
Hello all,
I was wondering why the prohibition on beards for military members was put in place and is changing the policy possible?
-
Hello all,
I was wondering why the prohibition on beards for military members was put in place and is changing the policy possible?
Why? Mainly because oxygen masks aboard aircraft, gas masks on the ground, and other protective gear won't work if you can't get a seal against your face.
The Navy was the last to allow beards. I remember seeing sailors with beards as late as 1979. I think one rationale for the Navy having beards was the water situation when deployed at sea for months.
If you have a medical condition that prevents shaving regularly, you can get a shaving waiver.
As far as changing the policy, I doubt the rules will change to allow just anyone that wants a beard to have one. Although, there are rumors Muslim members in the military are pushing to get the rules changed to allow beards in uniform for "religious reasons."
This is a special case, but ...
Fort Hood shooting suspect Nidal Hasan allowed to keep beard
http://www.cbsnews.com/news/fort-hood-shooting-suspect-nidal-hasan-allowed-to-keep-beard/ (http://www.cbsnews.com/news/fort-hood-shooting-suspect-nidal-hasan-allowed-to-keep-beard/)
and, then...
Nidal Hasan's beard shaved off by force
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/sep/04/nidal-hasan-beard-shaved-force (http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/sep/04/nidal-hasan-beard-shaved-force)
-
He pretty much covered it. The reason was because of the seal for masks.
The only official reason for keeping a beard is either health or religious reasons.
However, "off the record", certain special forces groups are allowed to grow beards while on deployment in certain areas.
The "official" reason is because they say it helps when dealing with the locals, whether is be troops they are training, or local civilians they are trying to deal with. This is because some members of the Muslim community do not show the same respect for a man without a beard as they do a man with a beard. At least that's the justification they usually give the brass.
Most guys that can get away with growing a beard, usually do so as a badge of honor. Being able to grow one usually means you are so deep in high speed combat and shit that they give you a "pass" on certain regulations.
-
Thanks for the responses! I feel the gas mask seal issue, while legitimate, is being used to strip men of their right to grow a beard. Why not ensure that a beard does not go past a certain length? Or ensure it is within the seal of a mask? I am not religious at all, borderline athiest. I feel like these folks getting a waver for their religion is unfair. As for the special operators, if anything, they should need to shave as they have a higher risk of a CBR environment compaired to other folks in desk job community's. And for the belending in portion, a clean shaven face screams MILITARY with local community's and it makes it easy for folks to take advantage or alienate. I feel it is not so much a gas mask issue and maybe more of a control and allienation issue. Maybe I need to seek out the lawer that helped the Rabbi in the Army with his beard issue.
-
Thanks for the responses! I feel the gas mask seal issue, while legitimate, is being used to strip men of their right to grow a beard. Why not ensure that a beard does not go past a certain length? Or ensure it is within the seal of a mask? I am not religious at all, borderline athiest. I feel like these folks getting a waver for their religion is unfair. As for the special operators, if anything, they should need to shave as they have a higher risk of a CBR environment compaired to other folks in desk job community's. And for the belending in portion, a clean shaven face screams MILITARY with local community's and it makes it easy for folks to take advantage or alienate. I feel it is not so much a gas mask issue and maybe more of a control and allienation issue. Maybe I need to seek out the lawer that helped the Rabbi in the Army with his beard issue.
A beard of any length has the chance of preventing a positive seal using a current issue mask (M50 model). The seal is created above the jawline, so any beard would have to be shaved from the jawline up. Thickness or length isn't the problem. The beard can't be between the mask and the skin where a seal is required. Stubble or 5 O'clock shadow is fine. A week's growth will probably get you killed.
When you join the military, you make sacrifices. Many of those sacrifices include the right to choose your own standards of appearance. Haircut, facial hair, weight, physical condition, eye wear, piercings, visible tats, other body mods ... Whether or not the standards are "legitimate" is not an issue. The standards are just that -- standards. If you don't like it, maybe the military isn't the place for you? (Using "you" in general).
-
.
-
Great info! Thanks! I was oblivious to things in the past and was kinda a sheep in certain topics . I have matured and now care greatly about our essential freedoms. I agree with the ban if legitimate, I don't agree with the "oh this is banned and no one has an explanation as to why". Thanks again for the info. So how about shaving at the jaw line? My buddy did a college paper on shaving in the military and aside from the Gas mask, his only finding was people who shave are easier to control. I never cared before but now I question everything. I am getting out soon but, I beleive if there is any possible injustice occurring, I should at least try to correct it for our future members. Another problem I see now is the ban for concealed carriers on military installations and the ban on OC spray.
-
Great info! Thanks! I was oblivious to things in the past and was kinda a sheep in certain topics . I have matured and now care greatly about our essential freedoms. I agree with the ban if legitimate, I don't agree with the "oh this is banned and no one has an explanation as to why". Thanks again for the info. So how about shaving at the jaw line? My buddy did a college paper on shaving in the military and aside from the Gas mask, his only finding was people who shave are easier to control. I never cared before but now I question everything. I am getting out soon but, I beleive if there is any possible injustice occurring, I should at least try to correct it for our future members. Another problem I see now is the ban for concealed carriers on military installations and the ban on OC spray.
I think "injustice" is a mischaracterization. The US military is an all-volunteer force. The government takes care of recruits' needs. From housing to clothing, medical and dental, you get everything you need. You're paid for your service, are afforded educational opportunities, and can retire with decent benefits if you hit 20 years active service.
What the military asks in return is broad and varied. Adherence to traditions, standards, and regulations is expected (and enforced).
So, you willingly join the military, they compensate you comparatively well for that service, and in return, you must do as they say.
I'm not sure what part of that arrangement constitutes an "injustice". Another word for justice is fairness. The military abuses everyone. What could be more fair than that? :)
-
Do many 17 or 18 year olds care about certain issues when they enlist? Not really, but once that person grows older their "blind" outlook on life dissolves and they want or care about restrictions that are imposed. Look at gay folks that were prohibited from disclosing their sexuality. It went against their first amendment right, you do not lose all rights for service. That is my point, my point here was to inquire about the ban and challenge it's validity. Sure people sign up willingly but, are the restrictions right or constitutional? Hazing was considered normal back in the day, beating another person was the thing to do. Now it is deemed inappropriate. Military Commanders were able at some point in time able to restrict their junior members ability to own firearms. That was struck down too. Do you loose first amendment rights in the military? A judge said no and DADT was repealed. A judge said military commanders could not restrict the 2nd amendment either.
-
The ban on beards makes sense while deployed (for gas masks), but doesn't make sense in peacetime and in garrison when a mask is not used except for those that need to train with a mask. Though you do give up rights when you join the military, there has to be a good justification for giving up those rights and a specific time and place to give up those rights. If a service member doesn't wear a mask, and I'm sure most aren't required to on a regular basis, then they should be able to wear a beard.
-
A judge said military commanders could not restrict the 2nd amendment either.
that's not 100% true. A soldier can't carry a personal firearm while deployed or while in garrison - if that's what you meant. If you live on post all personally owned firearms are stored in a unit central vault. All those restrictions don't sound like a pro 2A environment.
-
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facial_hair_in_the_military (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facial_hair_in_the_military)
...
Sweden
The regulations requires personnel to be "well shaved" (välrakad). Within the Royal Guard (Högvakten), the royal companies (Livkomp) and other personnel performing ceremonial duties, temporary or on a regular basis, the regulations are strictly enforced.
Within other units beards tends to be allowed under the discretion of the company commander (or other higher ranking commander). The general provisions of well managed appearance is enforced also when it comes to beards.
Soldiers are however by practice allowed to grow beard during service abroad, for example in Afghanistan.
The motivation for the regulation prohibiting beard is that it interferes with the gas-mask and makes it difficult to achieve a perfect air-tight fit. Shorter beard and gun grease or ointment is one remedy but will increase the time for the application of the gas-mask which in turn will put bearded personnel at increased risk of exposure.
...
-
that's not 100% true. A soldier can't carry a personal firearm while deployed or while in garrison - if that's what you meant. If you live on post all personally owned firearms are stored in a unit central vault. All those restrictions don't sound like a pro 2A environment.
Hi ren,
I was only talking about military commanders having the ability to determine whether or not members could own a firearm out in town on American soil, sorry I should have elaborated :D
Zippz, I agree 100%. Rules and regulations are awesome, our military is amazing. I merely wanted information on the topic and you folks have done a great job, thanks. I felt uneasy about this ban with folks just going along without asking why. It is a dangerous thing to just do and not ask why, for any topic.
-
Info from the U.S. naval institute(http://news.usni.org/2014/10/23/brief-history-grooming-u-s-navy (http://news.usni.org/2014/10/23/brief-history-grooming-u-s-navy)). The CNO in 1984 banned beards for the navy because of the gas mask seal but the secretary(maybe if the navy) said it was for the image.
My point is this, if a base or command or whatever has no gas masks on site, doesn't that defeat the damn purpose of banning beards anyway? I heard Jewish and Sikh(I probably spelled it wrong :D) men suing the army for the prohibitation. There is one guy in the army that has his beard. Yea I can see if a gas mask is readily available but if there exists places that do not keep them available, this prohibitation for these folks at these places, in my opinion needs to be removed. It's so weird though. If someone wants to challenge this do the need a military or a civilan lawyer? I know a guy that lawyers up every year for the "mandatory" flu shots. He refuses they threaten NJP, he lawyers up and they back off..... Thoughts my peeps?
-
.
-
I like the way Q thinks ...
When people join the service, there is an understanding on both sides you are giving up certain freedoms. Standards of appearance, in my mind, is very minor compared to:
- little to no choice in duty location
- little to no choice in the job you get
- little to no choice in the clothes you get to wear
- no choice on if you will have your wisdom teeth removed
- no choice in vaccinations you are required to have
- no choice in how much salary you will be paid (based on your pay grade and any special incentives for certain jobs such as pilots)
- no choice on whether you will be separated from your loved ones for months/years
However, how many other employers offer:
- meals or subsistence allowance
- housing or housing allowance
- clothing or clothing allowance
- free or greatly subsidized education, to include college degrees
- on-the-job training with equipment and systems costing from many thousands to millions of dollars
- leadership and supervisory opportunities
- fully paid-for relocations
- access to free/nearly free medical services for you and your dependents
- 20-years to be fully vested in a lifelong retirement program with pay, shopping benefits, and medical coverage
The service is like any other employer. They get to set the rules. If you like them, you stay, if you don't, then look for greener pastures.
If you think you can get the employer to change rules you disagree with, then you have that right. They also have the right to say, "No," regardless of how wrong you think they are.
-
EVERY unit has gas masks; it is part of the basic load out, and is stored in the designated NBC area when not in direct possession of a service member.
And with these guys complaining that the military is not allowing them to exercise their religious beliefs because they won't let them have a beard: when you sign the dotted line, you care committed to the military and it's standards. You don't NEED to join, as our military (at the current moment) is an all volunteer force. If serving their country AND maintaining their religious practices is an important issue to them, there are other civil service jobs that will allow them to serve the community in far better ways than they may have could in the military, and will allow them to still exercise the practices of their religion.
YOU conform to the military and it's standards; it's not the other way around. If you don't like it, take a hike and stop putting even more unnecessary burden on the armed forces by taking focus away from individuals who truly want to be there, and who were willing to make their own sacrifices to do so.
I can see you have a couple of fallacies. First off Let's say you are wrong about every unit having masks. What then? It deafeats the purpose of shaving right? Secondly, you said that one needs to conform to the military's standards which is awesome but, lets say for a second that the head individual that enacted this ban did not really do so for the reason and just preferred other folks shave their beards (maybe they had something against it). So what your saying is almost the same lines of if Hawaii says no lawful carry of a firearm to shut up, stop asking questions and just conform...philosophy encourages challenging fixed beliefs. I guess if Copernicus kept his mouth shut, we would still possibly beleive in the Ptolemaic universe in which the earth is the center of our solar system lol. All I am saying is folks need to ask the questions and also revisit certain topics. Yes the military is amazing. Just one piece I disagree with no need to crucify over opinions. Also Mauidog, your last part where you said that people have the right to ask for the employer to review or change their rule. That is what I was also pointing at, that folks have the right to ask/question things.
-
I can see you have a couple of fallacies. First off Let's say you are wrong about every unit having masks. What then? It deafeats the purpose of shaving right? Secondly, you said that one needs to conform to the military's standards which is awesome but, lets say for a second that the head individual that enacted this ban did not really do so for the reason and just preferred other folks shave their beards (maybe they had something against it). So what your saying is almost the same lines of if Hawaii says no lawful carry of a firearm to shut up, stop asking questions and just conform...philosophy encourages challenging fixed beliefs. I guess if Copernicus kept his mouth shut, we would still possibly believe in the Ptolemaic universe in which the earth is the center of our solar system lol. All I am saying is folks need to ask the questions and also revisit certain topics. Yes the military is amazing. Just one piece I disagree with no need to crucify over opinions. Also Mauidog, your last part where you said that people have the right to ask for the employer to review or change their rule. That is what I was also pointing at, that folks have the right to ask/question things.
Yes. you have the right to question a policy. But if you don't like the answer, you don't have the right to continue asking or to try and force an employer to change their policies or regs -- unless it violates the law, higher directives, or some moral imperative.
Remember, you are allowed to voice whatever opinion you have to the people who employee you. You also have the right to endure whatever consequences your continued voicing brings.
The military doesn't owe you a job. The first time you give them cause for terminating your service with them, your "rocking the boat" could come back to bite you.
In other words, use wisdom when choosing the right time and cause over which to fall on your sword.
-
BTW, your analogy about questioning shaving regs compared to acceptance of Hawaii CCW laws is an "apples to oranges" analogy.
Private citizens have more latitude to question unconstitutional laws than a military member has to question grooming standards. You signed a contract and swore an oath. Private citizens have no such commitment to the state.
-
.
-
.
-
I think this is the biggest problem: people these days see the military and political office as a job/career and not a service.
When you do something because you feel it is your patriotic duty, you do it don't ask questions and do not complain unless it is necessary (i.e. excessive abuse, detrimental actions/scenarios to soldiers and units, etc.). Too many kids are joining the military just for the benefits, only to realize that they don't like the requirements of serving something greater than themselves, for the betterment of an entire nation and the world. This is why the quality of the military has degraded so much, because there are too many people who don't truly want to be there for anything else other than the paycheck and/or benefits, and they make it miserable for the people who see it as an honor and a privilege to serve because those who actually care have to do 10x the work, only to be shafted anyway. That is why so many of the best soldiers from the units I've been apart of quit and refused to enlist, because they were sick of all the people who just didn't give a shit or didn't take it as serious as it needed to be.
I wasn't the best soldier, but I believed that it was the greatest honor to serve our country as a soldier, and I gave it my all in everything I did. I can tell you that toward the end of my service, my disdain for the military came not from the organization itself, but from the whiny little bitches that comprised the majority of the military, who were simply there to pay for college and/or have a paycheck.
Very profound. I share the same sentiments
-
If you really want facial hair join the guard or reserve and shave only 1 weekend a month and 2 weeks a year.
-
If you really want facial hair join the guard or reserve and shave only 1 weekend a month and 2 weeks a year.
Or separate :D