2aHawaii

General Topics => Off Topic => Topic started by: ren on October 31, 2014, 12:28:37 PM

Title: Why we have stupid laws...
Post by: ren on October 31, 2014, 12:28:37 PM
cuz we got stupid people
http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/27176801/2-people-arrested-after-cutting-through-county-land-near-puna-lava-flow (http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/27176801/2-people-arrested-after-cutting-through-county-land-near-puna-lava-flow)
Title: Re: Why we have stupid laws...
Post by: mauidog on October 31, 2014, 12:47:48 PM
cuz we got stupid people
http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/27176801/2-people-arrested-after-cutting-through-county-land-near-puna-lava-flow (http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/27176801/2-people-arrested-after-cutting-through-county-land-near-puna-lava-flow)

Ages 65 and 59 ....  older, but not much wiser!!
Title: Re: Why we have stupid laws...
Post by: one2boost on October 31, 2014, 03:12:49 PM
Why is it I have a hunch, if they would've been severely injured or worse one or both would have died, a law suit for not enforcing the law to the extreme or to the point of having better security preventing any access.
Title: Re: Why we have stupid laws...
Post by: dogman on October 31, 2014, 04:57:12 PM
Why is it I have a hunch, if they would've been severely injured or worse one or both would have died, a law suit for not enforcing the law to the extreme or to the point of having better security preventing any access.
yup +1
Title: .
Post by: Q on October 31, 2014, 05:14:10 PM
.
Title: Re: Why we have stupid laws...
Post by: edster48 on October 31, 2014, 05:31:45 PM
I think it would be simpler to have a law that states "If you are doing stupid shit while breaking the law, or just stupid shit in general, you're responsible for your own stupid shit. Not us.
Title: Re: Why we have stupid laws...
Post by: bass monkey on October 31, 2014, 06:09:31 PM
National guard got called up to help out down there.
Title: .
Post by: Q on October 31, 2014, 06:22:53 PM
.
Title: Re: Why we have stupid laws...
Post by: ren on October 31, 2014, 06:46:46 PM
You mean like hiking on an illegal trail that is located next to the range, and then going on Hawaii public television and openly stating that you know the trail is illegal and still hike on it?

Oh Greg...how sometimes I wish....
If there is enough people wanting to break the law then the law becomes unenforceable...hence if there are enough people wanting to get next to a 2,000 degree hot lava flow and get crispy creamed then there would be no NG call up or police on overtime.
Let stupid people be...Darwin gets to them :thumbsup:
(http://khnl.images.worldnow.com/images/5502076_G.jpg)
(http://khnl.images.worldnow.com/images/5502084_G.jpg)
Title: Re: Why we have stupid laws...
Post by: punaperson on November 01, 2014, 06:44:03 AM
If you are going to use the "precautionary principle" as the basis for laws restricting people's behaviors based upon what might happen, then you have to make alcohol and cigarettes illegal immediately. Nothing good can come from those behaviors (which has been demonstrated time and time again), and which some people might say are even "stupid". Driving motor vehicles would need to be outlawed as well due to the extremely high rate of injury and death... more than any other single cause outside of medical issues.

For 30 years lava has been erupting and many people have viewed it up close, both in legal venues and "illegally" (due to some bureaucratic decision that determined that what was "safe" yesterday, is "dangerous" today... and not because of some event that demonstrated danger). In the 80s and/or early 90s even the national park allowed people to walk right up to the flow... how many people were injured? I believe that there are perhaps two cases in the past 30 years of public resources being used to rescue or aid "illegal" hikers/viewers (who were actually "in trouble", and not just violating some arbitrary line of demarcation between "safe" and "dangerous"). Compare that to the amount of public resources used to assist the results of drunk driving accidents. But by all means, let's have more laws restricting more people from doing more things, especially where no danger is actually proven, but surmised as a "possibility". Or better yet let the lawyers rule and conjure up the "liability" bullshit. Can I sue the county because they gave a drivers license to some reckless driver? No liability there? What about when they don't stop someone from driving after several DUIs? No liability? Why? But by all means take the time and resources to arrest a couple of people who safely hike to and from the lava flow on "our" public land. Next thing you know they'll be arresting and convicting and imprisoning people for growing a plant significantly less dangerous than (legal (state controlled and "approved" and heavily taxed)) tobacco or (legal (state controlled and "approved" and heavily taxed)) alcohol.
Title: Re: Why we have stupid laws...
Post by: Walena on November 01, 2014, 08:55:27 AM
A little over 10 years ago, a woman went on a tour into the Kalapana flow when it was very active. Got separated from the tour, and was found dead on the lava the next day. National park personnel brought her body out of there on foot before she could be airlifted. My friend who was one of them, said that she was found slow cooking on the pahoehoe.

If I recall correctly, she was visiting from the cruise ship. When the ship left port, her husband didn't know that she wasn't on board.

There were numerous rescues of people hiking in from the wrong area thinking they that they know better than the authorities.
Title: Re: Why we have stupid laws...
Post by: edster48 on November 01, 2014, 09:30:53 AM
We all know, or should know, what these laws are really about.

Control.

Being responsible for your own actions is one of the cornerstones of personal freedom. By allowing that the state, and therefore the people to be held responsible for acts of God, or nature if you prefer, our judicial system, in its infinite wisdom {  :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: } has paved the way for the "presumption of stupidity" . Take the Mothers day incident at Sacred Falls in Punaluu. A sad incident to be sure, but one where nobody could have predicted a rock fall could have happened at that exact moment. The state was held "liable" for actions beyond their control due the argument that they hadn't done "enough" to protect people from their own ignorance that things like this happen in nature. The fact that those people ignored signage warning them of the dangers be damned. This ruling, and others like it, presume that even though they saw the signage warning them of the dangers, they were too stupid to realize that there was "actual" danger. Therefore it is the state's responsibility to step in and protect them from themselves and pay for the results.

This is all part of the "dumbing down" movement prevalent in our society right now. By playing to the lowest common denominator the state is allowed great latitude to deal with behaviors of ALL citizens. Presuming that they are too stupid to make decisions for themselves, the state may then drag out he old liability issue and use it to control any behavior that they deem "unsafe". Making criminals out of people for using their own judgment whether good or bad.

The ignorant revel in this, feeling that it gives them "freedom" to do things without thinking or being held responsible for their decisions, not realizing that they've given up their true Freedom for "free stuff" and a cage of laws.
Title: Re: Why we have stupid laws...
Post by: punaperson on November 01, 2014, 01:51:27 PM
There were numerous rescues of people hiking in from the wrong area thinking they that they know better than the authorities.
How many rescues over what period of time? What conditions existed that required their rescue in each individual case? How many people hiked "in the wrong area" or "illegally" and did not require rescue or assistance? Without the bigger picture context data, "numerous" doesn't mean anything at all. The rate of rescued hikers is what, maybe 0.001 percent? What's the rate of government assistance ("rescue") due to the behavior of people under the influence of alcohol? Independent of the rate, what is the total cost?

And, my main contention is that nanny-state proscription of victimless actions (arbitrarily dubbed "crimes" by our public servants) via civil and criminal penalties (including arrest or citation, incarceration, fines, etc.) is the real issue here. The "arbitrary and capricious" nature of such law-making and enforcement almost by definition makes it anti-liberty and opposed to personal freedom. Sort of like the situation with CCW: no evidence at all to support the government claim of "public safety" for denial of the right, while no one who is sane and looks at the evidence could possibly deny that alcohol has several orders of magnitude greater harm (physically, psychologically, and financially) to our society than either CCW or cannabis (to say nothing of hiking to a lava flow), yet the former is legal and sanctioned by the government while the latter are 100% illegal in Hawaii (unless you get the government approved "medical" exemption from criminal prosecution for cannabis... and then you have to follow lots of detailed rules about how much, when, where, etc. And for CCW, no way, never, no exceptions despite the law wording as "may issue". Imagine if alcohol sales were "may issue" but only two people in the last 20 years were actually able to legally acquire alcohol... hey, the state knows best, right?).
Title: Re: Why we have stupid laws...
Post by: Walena on November 01, 2014, 03:29:30 PM
Stupid law exist because of stupid people. The county expected this (not the state), so the law came into effect. HPD, HFD, Civil Defense, and the National Guard will have their hands full with stupid people. Stupid people will ignore all warnings with their "ainokea attitude", and attempt stupid things like trespassing on private and county property just to get up close.

If it's the law, then gotta obey. If there's no law, then no problem.

I have no sympathy for those arrested. The will be less of them there in the way when we are trying to get work done before the lava hits town.

Sorry, I don't  keep track of how many rescues, nor do I plan on keeping track of the cost of all this. There's a guy that shoots at the range here who works for the county's accounting office, and told me that he's one of those that does.

I am far from being an accountant. He has the percentages and costs for those concerned.
Title: Re: Why we have stupid laws...
Post by: edster48 on November 01, 2014, 08:40:56 PM
Stupid law exist because of stupid people. The county expected this (not the state), so the law came into effect. HPD, HFD, Civil Defense, and the National Guard will have their hands full with stupid people. Stupid people will ignore all warnings with their "ainokea attitude", and attempt stupid things like trespassing on private and county property just to get up close.

If it's the law, then gotta obey. If there's no law, then no problem.

I have no sympathy for those arrested. The will be less of them there in the way when we are trying to get work done before the lava hits town.

Sorry, I don't  keep track of how many rescues, nor do I plan on keeping track of the cost of all this. There's a guy that shoots at the range here who works for the county's accounting office, and told me that he's one of those that does.

I am far from being an accountant. He has the percentages and costs for those concerned.

Wrong.

Stupid laws exist to allow the state { The state being government, either federal, state, city or county } more control over the people they govern. Stupid people are just a means to an end.

Were stupid people allowed to learn their lessons the "hard way" the dialog would be much different and there would be no cost to the public at large other than to have fewer people doing stupid shit without them having to get involved and spend our money on them.
For example: Farmer Keoni has put up signs that say "No Trespassing, Trespassers will be shot" signs on his fence around his farm. Dick decides that he will ignore these signs because it's more convenient for him to reach his destination by crossing Farmer Keoni's property. Farmer Keoni shoots Dick in the ass with a load of rock salt from his .410. Dick limps painfully back to his car and drives himself back to the hospital and calls the police to complain about Farmer Keoni's actions. The police show up and ask him a few questions like "Did you see the No Trespassing signs posted all around Farmer Keoni's fence?" Then proceed to write him a citation for trespassing and admonish him by saying "Don't ignore the warning signs next time, dumbass." Everyone in town hears about Dick's adventure, and the result. Dick feels shame and embarrassment, as well as ass pain, and never does stupid shit like that again. Parents use it as an example of what NOT to do and admonish their children "Don't be a Dick". A lesson is learned by one and all.
A happy ending for everyone but Farmer Keoni who is now down one .410 shell.

The same holds true in your example of the woman that died on the lava flow.
Stupidity has a price. Stop expecting the people around you to pay it in order to protect you from yourself.
Title: Re: Why we have stupid laws...
Post by: punaperson on November 02, 2014, 08:08:16 AM
Stupid law exist because of stupid people. The county expected this (not the state), so the law came into effect. HPD, HFD, Civil Defense, and the National Guard will have their hands full with stupid people. Stupid people will ignore all warnings with their "ainokea attitude", and attempt stupid things like trespassing on private and county property just to get up close.

I'm wondering if you, or the other writers proclaiming these people as "stupid" could clarify what exactly they did that merits your judgment and evaluation. Please tell me what you are referring to as "stupid". The two most obvious possibilities are 1. they put themselves into a physically dangerous situation with the hiking terrain or the lava itself (and the "huge" methane explosions: see county warnings on dangers of lava flow), and/or 2. they violated a county ordinance, knowing full well the possible legal ramifications and consequences. Which is it? If the first, then who is responsible for negligently allowing our Untied States House of Representative member Tulsi Gabbard to walk to with 15 feet of the active lava flow? That person(s) ought to be arrested for endangering a member of Congress. What if one of those "huge" methane explosions had taken place as she stood there and thrown a huge rock and or molten lava onto her head and/or caused her to lose her balance and fall into the lava? It's either dangerous or it's not... or are there "special rules" for "special people"? If the latter (they "broke a law"), then let's use another example of lawbreaking and please tell me if you judge this lawbreaker to be "stupid". Suppose someone due to unfortunate and unexpected circumstances (recover and assist a family member whose vehicle has broken, or whatever) is required to venture into a known high-crime area at a time of known high-crime activity. For reasons of personal self-defense they arm themselves with a currently illegal-to-bear-outside-your-private-property weapon (it's a fairly long list in Hawaii... so choose whatever one suits you). Is this person "stupid"? If so, why? If not, why not?

If it's the law, then gotta obey. If there's no law, then no problem.

So you follow your own assertion and obey all laws all the time? You've never exceeded any speed limit ever under any circumstances? Never consumed alcohol while underage? Etc. If you ever have engaged in any illegal activity, are you "stupid"? Were the Jews in Germany in 1939 who broke the law and refused to enter the Ghetto and illegally acquired false papers allowing them to leave the country or illegally acquired firearms and fought the SS "stupid"?

I have no sympathy for those arrested. The will be less of them there in the way when we are trying to get work done before the lava hits town.

How did these people hiking out to the lava interfere in any way with the "work" being done? Have all the other people that have hiked out there also interfered with such work? Perhaps you believe 24 hour surveillance is necessary including helicopters with infrared cameras for night patrol to end all the disruptive hiking? What are you talking about?

Sorry, I don't  keep track of how many rescues, nor do I plan on keeping track of the cost of all this. There's a guy that shoots at the range here who works for the county's accounting office, and told me that he's one of those that does.

If you are going to make claims about things, then it's my fault for assuming you could back up those claims with some actual data. My bad. Could you put me in contact with this person who know that actual numbers? Thanks. So this source of yours knows exactly how much the county has spent 1. enforcing the lava flow trespassing laws and the rescue efforts of hikers in trouble, and 2. all the county costs for police calls, arrests, prosecution, and incarceration for all crimes committed under the influence of alcohol, right? We are talking about "public safety" and county laws, and what is appropriate for government to regulate based upon the reality of public safety concerns versus pure tyrannical control for no actual public safety reasons.

I am far from being an accountant. He has the percentages and costs for those concerned.

Great. Have him get me the numbers. Maybe he, or through you, could actually post them here for all of us to see. Certainly when I get them I will post them here. I'm waiting for a PM. Thanks.
Title: Re: Why we have stupid laws...
Post by: Walena on November 02, 2014, 06:24:29 PM
PM sent.
Title: Re: Why we have stupid laws...
Post by: punaperson on November 03, 2014, 06:22:09 AM
PM sent.
PM replied to. Thanks Walena.  :shaka: