2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: edster48 on December 09, 2014, 08:27:31 PM
-
This is in response to a comment on another thread regarding why we don't hear of more prosecutions of police when this kind of thing happens.
I'm interested in finding out what people would really do if faced with this situation.
What would you do?
-
'Cuz I need the money to fund my 2a habit. :thumbsup:
-
Because Due process is required by LAW. The judicial system is does not give police powers to falsely arrest people.
-
I'd start with a department complaint against the officer, then file a cause of action for violating my civil rights. Willful or not, violating someone's civil rights must have consequences. That is the only way to hopefully prevent these types of acts in the future.
I sympathize with the job cops have to do day after day, and I know it's difficult. However, no citizen's rights should be compromised to make the job of law enforcement easier. I think we have way too many laws on the books. If I have to play by all these rules or risk being fined or arrested, then the cops can do the same.
-
I sympathize with the job cops have to do day after day, and I know it's difficult. However, no citizen's rights should be compromised to make the job of law enforcement easier. I think we have way too many laws on the books. If I have to play by all these rules or risk being fined or arrested, then the cops can do the same.
heard that!
-
I'd start with a department complaint against the officer, then file a cause of action for violating my civil rights. Willful or not, violating someone's civil rights must have consequences. That is the only way to hopefully prevent these types of acts in the future.
I sympathize with the job cops have to do day after day, and I know it's difficult. However, no citizen's rights should be compromised to make the job of law enforcement easier. I think we have way too many laws on the books. If I have to play by all these rules or risk being fined or arrested, then the cops can do the same.
I agree. Too many laws, many of them contradictory, leaving citizens in a "Catch 22" situation. We're beyond the point of saturation, we're being buried under an avalanche of ridiculous laws designed to allow the government to control our day to day lives.
I'd like to think it would be possible to simply review the statutes and remove the laws that infringe upon our freedoms and give too much power to the government, but at this point I think the task is too monumental. Even if we could get our legislators up off of their collective asses to make the attempt.
-
I would love to be holier than thou and sue the Department, City Etc. but in reality it costs a lot of time and money.
To put up all that attorney money for a case which is very difficult to prove and roll the dice wouldn't be worth it to me.
Best case scenario, officer gets fired, but what are your damages ? You were held for a few hours. ( Doesn't Hawaii have a 48 hour hold law or something to that effect ? )
Worst case scenario, you lose the case and the PD and City get awarded fees and costs. Now your paying for the lawyers and court costs for both sides, your broke and shit out of luck and doubly pissed off.
It's a roll of the dice at best.
Of course this is just an opinion ( unpopular, realist one at that )
I agree. Too many laws, many of them contradictory, leaving citizens in a "Catch 22" situation. We're beyond the point of saturation, we're being buried under an avalanche of ridiculous laws designed to allow the government to control our day to day lives.
+1
Catch-22
-
I would love to be holier than thou and sue the Department, City Etc. but in reality it costs a lot of time and money.
To put up all that attorney money for a case which is very difficult to prove and roll the dice wouldn't be worth it to me.
Best case scenario, officer gets fired, but what are your damages ? You were held for a few hours. ( Doesn't Hawaii have a 48 hour hold law or something to that effect ? )
Worst case scenario, you lose the case and the PD and City get awarded fees and costs. Now your paying for the lawyers and court costs for both sides, your broke and shit out of luck and doubly pissed off.
It's a roll of the dice at best.
Of course this is just an opinion ( unpopular, realist one at that )
+1
Catch-22
This isn't a popularity contest a-hound. I commend you for your honesty and bringing the realities of such an endeavor to light.
Even though taking them to court would be the "right" thing to do, realistically they would put as many obstacles in your path as possible. I imagine that about half of those that feel they would take on the task would give up when faced with the cost and work involved.
-
I agree. Too many laws, many of them contradictory, leaving citizens in a "Catch 22" situation. We're beyond the point of saturation, we're being buried under an avalanche of ridiculous laws designed to allow the government to control our day to day lives.
I'd like to think it would be possible to simply review the statutes and remove the laws that infringe upon our freedoms and give too much power to the government, but at this point I think the task is too monumental. Even if we could get our legislators up off of their collective asses to make the attempt.
The number of laws is the result of action by the legislature. Legislators pride themselves in the number of bills they are able to successfully get passed into law. Lobbyists under the employ of companies or industry groups communicate with legislators all the time to get favorable laws passed. There is no reason why we shouldn't get involved in this process as citizens. The squeaky wheel gets the oil.
On a tangent....
HCR-PAC is the advocacy organization in Hawaii that talks to the legislators about pro-2a issues. We need to support this PAC.
As citizens, we should also educate ourselves about the HRS so we can have an intelligent conversation about the current laws with Dr. Cooper (HCR-PAC) and our elected representatives.
I am guilty of not having read through or knowing the HRS myself and will take the time to learn it from now on. Bedtime reading? :sleeping: :sleeping: :sleeping: If there are too many laws, a good topic would be laws that should be repealed.
Link to Hawaii Revised Statutes Table of Contents
http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/docs/HRS.htm (http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/docs/HRS.htm)
A good starting point: HRS 134 (Firearms, Ammunition and Dangerous Weapons)
http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-.htm (http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-.htm)
As it relates to this topic: HRS 803 (Arrests, Search Warrants)
http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol14_Ch0701-0853/HRS0803/HRS_0803-.htm (http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol14_Ch0701-0853/HRS0803/HRS_0803-.htm)
-
I choose the last option but I would prefer to sue only the officer. Suing the city or settling seems counter productive as it's my tax dollars that pay for all this. Me and my fellow tax payers did no wrong so why should we suffer? I'd like the individual know there are consequences to their actions. I'd also like that person to be out of a job as well. Well maybe just out of a job with the city because it annoys may when they remove someone as on officer but give them a city desk job instead.
-
I choose the last option but I would prefer to sue only the officer. Suing the city or settling seems counter productive as it's my tax dollars that pay for all this. Me and my fellow tax payers did no wrong so why should we suffer? I'd like the individual know there are consequences to their actions. I'd also like that person to be out of a job as well. Well maybe just out of a job with the city because it annoys may when they remove someone as on officer but give them a city desk job instead.
The problem with suing just the individual is, what if they use the defense they were not properly trained, or there is a pervasive attitude in the department allowing such misconduct to go unchecked? If the office could prove those points and diminish his own responsibility in his bad behavior, now you have to start all over again to go after the organizations who are to blame.
Better, I think, to file one action and let them all turn against each other. It only takes one of them refusing to be the scapegoat to shine the light on the real culprit.
-
I choose the last option but I would prefer to sue only the officer. Suing the city or settling seems counter productive as it's my tax dollars that pay for all this. Me and my fellow tax payers did no wrong so why should we suffer? I'd like the individual know there are consequences to their actions. I'd also like that person to be out of a job as well. Well maybe just out of a job with the city because it annoys may when they remove someone as on officer but give them a city desk job instead.
You really can't sue "just the officer" as he will claim qualified immunity. I think you would have to sue the department and have a judgement for you, then initiate (maybe you can do so concurrently) a 42 USC 1983 (civil rights violation) action against the individual officer.
-
I am pretty sure you can do so concurrently. It will be only one lawsuit, probably with multiple defendants: both the department and the individual officer(s).
If you can prove that your civil rights were violated AND that the individual officer(s) did not follow their department's guidelines, then you can recover monetary damages from the individual officer(s). Though in practice I think the money will come from the department because the officer's employment contract probably has an indemnification clause, shifting responsibility to the department.
If you fail to prove either one of those two things, then the individual officer(s) will get off based on qualified immunity. That's my understanding anyway, someone please correct me if I'm wrong.
-
The problem with suing just the individual is, what if they use the defense they were not properly trained, or there is a pervasive attitude in the department allowing such misconduct to go unchecked? If the office could prove those points and diminish his own responsibility in his bad behavior, now you have to start all over again to go after the organizations who are to blame.
Better, I think, to file one action and let them all turn against each other. It only takes one of them refusing to be the scapegoat to shine the light on the real culprit.
Not properly trained is not an affirmative defense. Only qualified immunity can preclude any criminal suit and if they are not in the right can be held for criminal and civil penalties.
Better to go with the flow then have your attorney show where the fruit of the poisonous tree throws out subsequent finds.
-
The number of laws is the result of action by the legislature. Legislators pride themselves in the number of bills they are able to successfully get passed into law. Lobbyists under the employ of companies or industry groups communicate with legislators all the time to get favorable laws passed. There is no reason why we shouldn't get involved in this process as citizens. The squeaky wheel gets the oil.
On a tangent....
HCR-PAC is the advocacy organization in Hawaii that talks to the legislators about pro-2a issues. We need to support this PAC.
As citizens, we should also educate ourselves about the HRS so we can have an intelligent conversation about the current laws with Dr. Cooper (HCR-PAC) and our elected representatives.
I am guilty of not having read through or knowing the HRS myself and will take the time to learn it from now on. Bedtime reading? :sleeping: :sleeping: :sleeping: If there are too many laws, a good topic would be laws that should be repealed.
Link to Hawaii Revised Statutes Table of Contents
http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/docs/HRS.htm (http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/docs/HRS.htm)
A good starting point: HRS 134 (Firearms, Ammunition and Dangerous Weapons)
http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-.htm (http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol03_Ch0121-0200D/HRS0134/HRS_0134-.htm)
As it relates to this topic: HRS 803 (Arrests, Search Warrants)
http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol14_Ch0701-0853/HRS0803/HRS_0803-.htm (http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/hrscurrent/Vol14_Ch0701-0853/HRS0803/HRS_0803-.htm)
This is a HUGE part of the problem.
It seems as though these days everything has a law attached to it. They're going for quantity over quality. Not to mention making laws to give advantage to their biggest campaign contributors. It's no longer "By the people, for the people" it's "buy the legislator, for the highest bidder". Governance by the biggest wallet.
IMHO this is wrong.
Especially here. We don't have a huge population, 1.2 million people wouldn't even fill a single suburb in L.A. What the hell are they writing all these laws for? You're right, I don't know enough about the HRS and I too will begin reading up. Every law they pass infringes on our freedoms juust a leetle more, they're virtually never written to provide more freedom.
Personally, I think they should only be allowed to meet for 4 months every other year, like Montana. It would help keep them from screwing things up.
-
I declined to vote because it is a little too generalized.
Now if it were truly an illegal arrest and one done maliciously by the officer then I would make an internal complaint and perhaps consider a small claims suit against the city for lost wages, other costs suffered etc. Losign a few hours wouldn't really amount to much "injury" to claim in court. Making the internal complaint is what is going to teach that officer a lesson and keep the department accountable. Granted a complaint or lawsuit isn't a guarantee, especially when it comes to their word vs yours but if one officer consistently gets the same types of complaints then there is a much better case to be made that the officer is abusing their power somehow.
If it were made by an officer who was negligent of the law then I would probably still take the same route because even though the officer might not have been malicious it is important to have the officer learn the laws/regulations he/she has to enforce. No one can know every law and regulation so a smart cop will realize that if they are not sure then it is better to err on the side of caution and not arrest rather than arrest and have the person be innocent.
I would bet that a lot of people don't really know the law that well though and what they think is an "illegal arrest" really isn't. Arresting the wrong person is not the same thing as an illegal arrest. Remember that an officer might arrest the wrong person out of no fault of his own and though the person may think they were illegally arrested the officer is covered by good faith. The thing that comes into play in this sort of instance is whether the officer did his/her job properly and the mistake was beyond his/her control.
-
Your point brings validaition to Ed's so clearly. Too many laws, and no one knows them... you could conceivably get arrested for no reason at all and whomever so inclined could "find" some dirt to throw on you. We might be breaking some law now, just don't know it!
-
Not only are there too many laws, so many that it is impossible for the average person to know, let alone understand all of them, a recent SCOTUS decision said that evidence of a search, even one predicated on a "misunderstanding" of a law used to establish probable cause, is admissible.
http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2014/12/16/supreme-court-traffic-stop-search-ok-despite-mistake-law/ (http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2014/12/16/supreme-court-traffic-stop-search-ok-despite-mistake-law/)
So now, you can be stopped, with probable cause for said search based on an officer's understanding of a law, even if that understanding is factually incorrect, and any evidence found is admissible. Great......
-
Obviously there are so many laws even the police don't/can't know them all.
It's starting to boil down to "We think you did something illegal, hang around for awhile and we'll figure out what it is."
This is not how things are supposed to be in the United States of America.
-
Obviously there are so many laws even the police don't/can't know them all.
It's starting to boil down to "We think you did something illegal, hang around for awhile and we'll figure out what it is."
This is not how things are supposed to be in the United States of America.
Two words: Fundamental Transformation :shake:
-
Read the article. The idiot gave consent. I didn't read the Supreme Court ruling but just stopping him could have been a voluntary stop and/or a terry stop then officer says mind if I search the car and you can polite say no thank you which an officer may say that is RS that a crime is afoot but believe that could be held in court. You tell the officer sure search it when there is known contraband well your an idiot.
-
You're right kong, he stupidly gave consent. He probably would've been nailed anyway when they brought the dogs to sniff for drugs.
Interesting that Sotomayor of all people dissented on the basis that the law should be "knowable".
-
Not certain what policy is for dogs sniffing but that may get into fourth amendment search and seizure issues if no RS or PC can be articulated.
-
Read the article. The idiot gave consent. I didn't read the Supreme Court ruling but just stopping him could have been a voluntary stop and/or a terry stop then officer says mind if I search the car and you can polite say no thank you which an officer may say that is RS that a crime is afoot but believe that could be held in court. You tell the officer sure search it when there is known contraband well your an idiot.
True
-
Not certain what policy is for dogs sniffing but that may get into fourth amendment search and seizure issues if no RS or PC can be articulated.
True, but this a quite common practice in many states. Search is declined, officer states he has RS there may be drugs in the vehicle, detains you and calls for dogs to be brought to the scene. It is generally considered legal for the dogs to sniff the outside of your vehicle. If it "indicates" there are drugs, they can arrest you, impound and tear apart your car, or simply tear it apart at the scene. It's also not unheard of that the dogs will indicate mistakenly.
The wondrous "War on Drugs" has given a great deal of leeway to how the police can handle these situations, 4th amendment or no.
-
He would need to articulate how his training or experience led his to RS and if the court doesn't justify it then everything gets throw out. Now if the courts and the department are in cahoots were screwed.
-
Obviously there are so many laws even the police don't/can't know them all.
It's starting to boil down to "We think you did something illegal, hang around for awhile and we'll figure out what it is."
This is not how things are supposed to be in the United States of America.
Sometimes an officer will need to take a moment to clarify a technicality in a law but they need to articulate reasonable actions while they detain a person. The more invasive the police action the more they need to justify it. Detaining someone briefly is not so hard. Detaining them longer takes a little more. Arresting them takes even more. So on and so forth. If an officer detains someone for 5 minutes peacefully only to find out that the action wasn't actually prohibited then I don't think we are talking about a serious illegal action by an officer. However if an officer arrest someone for sticking middle finger, something obviously protected by the first amendment, then it is most certainly an illegal action and one that needs to be addressed.
Most laws that an average police officer will enforce are derived from basic values we should all know to be wrong. Things like causing injury to a person or taking/damaging someone elses stuff is obviously wrong and the public doesn't really have an argument that there are too many laws. However when it comes to traffic violations then sure there are so many laws most people could't keep track. For example it is illegal to coast your car in neutral. Why? I don't know but I sure wouldn't consider it obvious!
-
He would need to articulate how his training or experience led his to RS and if the court doesn't justify it then everything gets throw out. Now if the courts and the department are in cahoots were screwed.
You mean something along the lines of "I thought I smelled marijuana" I presume? Or the ever popular "The suspect was behaving in a suspicious manner".
That's all it really takes, the courts will grant the officer the benefit of the doubt, not the citizen.
-
You mean something along the lines of "I thought I smelled marijuana" I presume? Or the ever popular "The suspect was behaving in a suspicious manner".
That's all it really takes, the courts will grant the officer the benefit of the doubt, not the citizen.
Perhaps you have never heard an officer on a rant about how stupid the courts were in dealing with some particular case. The courts certainly don't give the officer the automatic benefit of the doubt however the courts do usually consider the officer to be a more reliable witness for multiple reasons. If it really came down to an officer not having any more clout than the defendant then no one could ever be convicted.
If the defense attorney is worth anything he will press the officer for clarification on a vague testimony such as "the suspect was behaving suspiciously" and if the officer cannot even explain what he means then his testimony is not as strong.
-
You really can't sue "just the officer" as he will claim qualified immunity. I think you would have to sue the department and have a judgement for you, then initiate (maybe you can do so concurrently) a 42 USC 1983 (civil rights violation) action against the individual officer.
You will actually end up just suing the "City and County of Honolulu." I could explain it all, but the department is the same entity as the city (in the end).
-
I thought won't work in court. It has to be factual based to stand up in court. I.e. Terry v Ohio was based of an unmarked officer during the middle of summer watching two or three individuals wearing winter coats walking back and forth in front of a convenience store. He made contact with the individuals and did a frisk and found weapons. They challenged it in court under fourth amendment and the frisk was upheld since a frisk can be done under reasonable suspicion given the totality of circumstances. I understand people's wariness of government and the law but the more you know the better we all are.
-
True, but this a quite common practice in many states. Search is declined, officer states he has RS there may be drugs in the vehicle, detains you and calls for dogs to be brought to the scene. It is generally considered legal for the dogs to sniff the outside of your vehicle. If it "indicates" there are drugs, they can arrest you, impound and tear apart your car, or simply tear it apart at the scene. It's also not unheard of that the dogs will indicate mistakenly.
The wondrous "War on Drugs" has given a great deal of leeway to how the police can handle these situations, 4th amendment or no.
Generally speaking, an alert by a dog gives the officer PC to search. But, the officer cannot, independent of any other facts detain you just to have the dog search your vehicle. So, if you get stopped for a simple traffic violation the officer cannot legally detain you longer than it normally takes to complete the encounter just to have the dog sniff your vehicle.
As for the false alerting, yes dogs do false alert. Sometimes they do so innocently, sometimes through cues (purposeful or not) from the handler. Remember, the dog wants to please the handler so it's very easy to influence the dogs behavior through subtle (again, conscious or unconscious) cues from the handler.
-
Generally speaking, an alert by a dog gives the officer PC to search. But, the officer cannot, independent of any other facts detain you just to have the dog search your vehicle. So, if you get stopped for a simple traffic violation the officer cannot legally detain you longer than it normally takes to complete the encounter just to have the dog sniff your vehicle.
As for the false alerting, yes dogs do false alert. Sometimes they do so innocently, sometimes through cues (purposeful or not) from the handler. Remember, the dog wants to please the handler so it's very easy to influence the dogs behavior through subtle (again, conscious or unconscious) cues from the handler.
First, I said in my post that the officer "states that he has reasonable suspicion" that there are drugs in the vehicle. This would give him cause to detain you until the dogs could be brought to the scene.
Second, I didn't attempt to place any blame on the dog. Dogs should be held blameless because, well, they're dogs.
Third, I set forth a specific scenario for this poll, an officer illegally detains you, lies to you and arrests you. Whether they're "supposed to" or not is irrelevant to this discussion. They obviously can and do detain and arrest people illegally, and they get away with it. The object of the poll is to find out what, if anything, you would do about it once the incident has occurred, not to incur a debate as to the legality of the search, the conditions of which will vary from state to state in any case and is, again, irrelevant. Nor am I attempting cast all police officers in the same light, these types of things are generally committed by a small percentage of LEO's. Most of them do their best to do the job right, within the limitations set forth in the law.
Is there anything else you require clarification on?
-
First, I said in my post that the officer "states that he has reasonable suspicion" that there are drugs in the vehicle. This would give him cause to detain you until the dogs could be brought to the scene.
Second, I didn't attempt to place any blame on the dog. Dogs should be held blameless because, well, they're dogs.
Third, I set forth a specific scenario for this poll, an officer illegally detains you, lies to you and arrests you. Whether they're "supposed to" or not is irrelevant to this discussion. They obviously can and do detain and arrest people illegally, and they get away with it. The object of the poll is to find out what, if anything, you would do about it once the incident has occurred, not to incur a debate as to the legality of the search, the conditions of which will vary from state to state in any case and is, again, irrelevant. Nor am I attempting cast all police officers in the same light, these types of things are generally committed by a small percentage of LEO's. Most of them do their best to do the job right, within the limitations set forth in the law.
Is there anything else you require clarification on?
Lets keep in mind that the feds can do things that local PD cannot. The feds might be able to search based off of a dog hit but from my understanding Honolulu PD would have to apply for a search warrant. I think it would be hard to develop reasonable suspicion that there were drugs in a vehicle just from a traffic stop in order to justify a detention long enough to bring a dog on scene. Now marijuana has an obvious smell but since small quantities of marijuana was misdemeanor cases, is an officer really going to spend that much time and effort for a bogus case?
As for an officer lying? Well they can lie to people, as long as it is not about certain things. If officers couldn't lie then no one could ever go undercover! The illegal arrest is the most serious concern in my opinion.
-
Lets keep in mind that the feds can do things that local PD cannot. The feds might be able to search based off of a dog hit but from my understanding Honolulu PD would have to apply for a search warrant. I think it would be hard to develop reasonable suspicion that there were drugs in a vehicle just from a traffic stop in order to justify a detention long enough to bring a dog on scene. Now marijuana has an obvious smell but since small quantities of marijuana was misdemeanor cases, is an officer really going to spend that much time and effort for a bogus case?
As for an officer lying? Well they can lie to people, as long as it is not about certain things. If officers couldn't lie then no one could ever go undercover! The illegal arrest is the most serious concern in my opinion.
Any amout of drugs can be grounds to confiscate your property (car) without due process, arrest or court warrent under Hawaii state property forfeiture laws.
-
Lets keep in mind that the feds can do things that local PD cannot. The feds might be able to search based off of a dog hit but from my understanding Honolulu PD would have to apply for a search warrant. I think it would be hard to develop reasonable suspicion that there were drugs in a vehicle just from a traffic stop in order to justify a detention long enough to bring a dog on scene. Now marijuana has an obvious smell but since small quantities of marijuana was misdemeanor cases, is an officer really going to spend that much time and effort for a bogus case?
As for an officer lying? Well they can lie to people, as long as it is not about certain things. If officers couldn't lie then no one could ever go undercover! The illegal arrest is the most serious concern in my opinion.
What we have here is a failure to communicate.
Third, I set forth a specific scenario for this poll, an officer illegally detains you, lies to you and arrests you. Whether they're "supposed to" or not is irrelevant to this discussion. They obviously can and do detain and arrest people illegally, and they get away with it. The object of the poll is to find out what, if anything, you would do about it once the incident has occurred, not to incur a debate as to the legality of the search, the conditions of which will vary from state to state in any case and is, again, irrelevant. Nor am I attempting cast all police officers in the same light, these types of things are generally committed by a small percentage of LEO's. Most of them do their best to do the job right, within the limitations set forth in the law.
Please feel free to read this as many times as it takes for it to sink in.
-
What we have here is a failure to communicate.
Please feel free to read this as many times as it takes for it to sink in.
Edster, I fully understand the question, I am merely providing a bit of context since an illegal arrest can be comprised of different things depending on what agency you are dealing with. It is important for us all to know our rights because frequently people will think they were detained illegally when they weren't or were detained illegally and they didn't know it.
-
First, I said in my post that the officer "states that he has reasonable suspicion" that there are drugs in the vehicle. This would give him cause to detain you until the dogs could be brought to the scene.
Second, I didn't attempt to place any blame on the dog. Dogs should be held blameless because, well, they're dogs.
Third, I set forth a specific scenario for this poll, an officer illegally detains you, lies to you and arrests you. Whether they're "supposed to" or not is irrelevant to this discussion. They obviously can and do detain and arrest people illegally, and they get away with it. The object of the poll is to find out what, if anything, you would do about it once the incident has occurred, not to incur a debate as to the legality of the search, the conditions of which will vary from state to state in any case and is, again, irrelevant. Nor am I attempting cast all police officers in the same light, these types of things are generally committed by a small percentage of LEO's. Most of them do their best to do the job right, within the limitations set forth in the law.
Is there anything else you require clarification on?
My, feeling a little defensive? I was making very general comments about the process. Yes, if the officer has RAS of illegal activity he can detain you. However, how long he can detain you is up for debate. Some courts have held that with RAS a 45 minute wait is OK. Without RAS the time a person can be held must be "de minimus" which, as is usually the case, ill defined.
As for the dog, again, I was making a general comment, not accusing you of blaming the dog....
But hey, thanks for the clarification....
-
Leo's can initiate a voluntary contact at any time and from the voluntary contact with a Leo's experience and training can articulate RS for a terry stop that is not illegal. If a bolo goes out and they stop you and do a terry frisk of you and vehicle and go into the trunk and find contraband that is an illegal search that can be thrown out unless you have said officer consent. Due to the nature of a terry stop is for weapons on a person or in the immediate lunging area of a vehicle. If during the search for weapons in an officers experience he feels and articulates drugs in your pocket wherever the. He can confiscate that and no arrest you for contraband and do an sia. If you want more info we can discuss all types of scenarios at length as well as resource location. Though I will not post on an open forum any resource location. Fed state and local all follow same court precedence.
-
Leo's can initiate a voluntary contact at any time and from the voluntary contact with a Leo's experience and training can articulate RS for a terry stop that is not illegal. If a bolo goes out and they stop you and do a terry frisk of you and vehicle and go into the trunk and find contraband that is an illegal search that can be thrown out unless you have said officer consent. Due to the nature of a terry stop is for weapons on a person or in the immediate lunging area of a vehicle. If during the search for weapons in an officers experience he feels and articulates drugs in your pocket wherever the. He can confiscate that and no arrest you for contraband and do an sia. If you want more info we can discuss all types of scenarios at length as well as resource location. Though I will not post on an open forum any resource location. Fed state and local all follow same court precedence.
AGAIN, I'm not trying to ascertain what constitutes a LEGAL STOP. That is a subject for another thread. The point of the poll was to find out what, if anything, people would do if they WERE detained, lied to, and arrested ILLEGALLY. The assumption, for the purposes of this poll, is that you know the law and have done nothing illegal. For whatever reason, the LEO has decided to give you a hard time. Maybe you look like the guy he caught his wife banging, whatever, he's decided to give you a hard time and kick the 4th amendment to the curb in order to do it. Whether or not this will hold up in court is irrelevant, as you were released after a few hours with no charges.
Resource location??? Isn't that Fed, State and local LAW? These aren't "secret" and can be accessed by anyone. Feel free to post them in the open, this is the United States of America.
-
My, feeling a little defensive? I was making very general comments about the process. Yes, if the officer has RAS of illegal activity he can detain you. However, how long he can detain you is up for debate. Some courts have held that with RAS a 45 minute wait is OK. Without RAS the time a person can be held must be "de minimus" which, as is usually the case, ill defined.
As for the dog, again, I was making a general comment, not accusing you of blaming the dog....
But hey, thanks for the clarification....
BS, you were specifically rebutting my prior post, and taking the thread off on a tangent.
You're welcome for the clarification.
-
OK, I've locked the voting.
I find it interesting that 20% of the respondents would just let it go and accept that this could be done to them in the USA.
That 77% would at least attempt to fight this kind of injustice is encouraging, This is the only way we can protect our Constitutional rights, short of civil war.
Thank God, at least one person would post this on You Tube!
Thanks to everyone for participating! :shaka:
-
My personal opinion is I have to call bullcrap on at least 50% of the 80% who say they would take legal action...
Especially if detainment was only a few hours and no charges were filed.
Ideals and action are 2 different things.
-
My personal opinion is I have to call bullcrap on at least 50% of the 80% who say they would take legal action...
Especially if detainment was only a few hours and no charges were filed.
Ideals and action are 2 different things.
I think that figure would vary as well, based on the severity of the encounter. If the worst that COULD have happened was a couple of weekends community service or a fine, then most would walk away and and say, "Whatevah!"
If, however, you were being railroaded on a charge that could land you years in prison or some other life-changing sentence, I think that would factor into your "stress meter", making it more likely you'll retaliate with charges of your own.
As for the YouTube Video comment from Edster, you split that off from the other options. Had this been a multiple selection poll, I would have chosen that on top of the answer I gave. In fact, I have a dash cam in my vehicle which should catch the beginning of the encounter, and if I don't get too distracted, I would hope to remember to switch on my cell to record, too. Whether that makes it to YouTube or not would depend on the content and quality of the recordings.
:shaka:
-
I won't post in the open for any potential criminals or idiots. Fight the cop if the arrest is legal or not and see what happens. For me I would try to talk then if he is set on arresting call an attorney.
-
BS, you were specifically rebutting my prior post, and taking the thread off on a tangent.
You're welcome for the clarification.
No, I wasn't but you're free to think whatever you want....
-
Lets keep in mind that the feds can do things that local PD cannot. The feds might be able to search based off of a dog hit but from my understanding Honolulu PD would have to apply for a search warrant. I think it would be hard to develop reasonable suspicion that there were drugs in a vehicle just from a traffic stop in order to justify a detention long enough to bring a dog on scene. Now marijuana has an obvious smell but since small quantities of marijuana was misdemeanor cases, is an officer really going to spend that much time and effort for a bogus case?
As for an officer lying? Well they can lie to people, as long as it is not about certain things. If officers couldn't lie then no one could ever go undercover! The illegal arrest is the most serious concern in my opinion.
They don't really need any additional suspicion from the initial stop. In a related case, around 7 minutes was deemed reasonable in addition to the original stop. There isn't a "time frame" articulated, but if the K-9 is in the general are and could get there in less than say 10 minutes, they could pretty much hold anyone.
Now, honestly, the cop could go call him, sit in the car, run the plates, take his time... play some candy crush while he waits, write a ticket... and then the dog would be there anyways lol.
-
My personal opinion is I have to call bullcrap on at least 50% of the 80% who say they would take legal action...
Especially if detainment was only a few hours and no charges were filed.
Ideals and action are 2 different things.
I can pretty much guarantee you I would drop a suit lol.
-
My personal opinion is I have to call bullcrap on at least 50% of the 80% who say they would take legal action...
Especially if detainment was only a few hours and no charges were filed.
Ideals and action are 2 different things.
I completely agree with this post. You'd be amazed at how many people contact me telling me their civil rights have been violated by the police and want representation without compensation. I take a few cases pro bono when I like the client such as with George Young current appeal or when I believe in the issue like Baker. However I've got bills to pay myself and typically need money up front to take a case. Its amazing how many people who just get done telling me the police are not willing to pay are not willing to put up a retainer.
-
I completely agree with this post. You'd be amazed at how many people contact me telling me their civil rights have been violated by the police and want representation without compensation. I take a few cases pro bono when I like the client such as with George Young current appeal or when I believe in the issue like Baker. However I've got bills to pay myself and typically need money up front to take a case. Its amazing how many people who just get done telling me the police are not willing to pay are not willing to put up a retainer.
Therein lies the problem, not many have the time nor the funds to do much really. Unless you go through the channels with your complaints, they are addressed, and wrongful parties are held accountable..... eheh yeah right....