2aHawaii
General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: ren on January 12, 2015, 05:53:55 PM
-
http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/27832947/manoa-burglary-victim-questions-why-officer-didnt-stop-suspects (http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/27832947/manoa-burglary-victim-questions-why-officer-didnt-stop-suspects)
A report was written though :thumbsup:
-
Bet she would've been all over it if they were doing 10 mph over the speed limit and couldn't produce a valid insurance card though!
-
http://youtu.be/XO8yQOdRU_c (http://youtu.be/XO8yQOdRU_c)
-
A police supervisor tried to meet with the restaurant management yesterday, but they weren't available.
Oh, like that's going to help anything now! She had the crooks in sight, and she ..... called for back up? :wtf:
I hope this Cop gets fired. There's forgivable mistakes, and then there is plain lazy and incompetent!
Guarantee you, these same thieves have hit more than just these two places.
She could have gotten these two slimes off the streets for a little while and saved who knows how many other business, home and car owners the headache and expense of these two criminals' activities.
-
Sounds to me like this officer belongs in D6 and NOT D7 night shift.
-
"She looked like she came into the restaurant with high beams on." :shake: :rofl:
-
http://youtu.be/XO8yQOdRU_c (http://youtu.be/XO8yQOdRU_c)
OMFG !!!!!!!
:rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
Thats the best laugh I've had in awhile. !
Thanx.
-
HPD To
Protect, To Serve To take notes. :(
-
http://youtu.be/XO8yQOdRU_c (http://youtu.be/XO8yQOdRU_c)
No ways. Can't believe that...must've been a movie scene
-
No ways. Can't believe that...must've been a movie scene
Most likely, still hilarious
:rofl:
Sooo....if there is no obligation to protect private property then Upholding the law is optionable?
I guess they pick battles they can win.
-
Most likely, still hilarious
:rofl:
Sooo....if there is no obligation to protect private property then Upholding the law is optionable?
I guess they pick battles they can win.
It was during the filming of a movie. That clip's been around for awhile on FB. You can even hear the direction being given on load speaker during the scene.
-
I wouldn't Monday-morning quarterback but will say one officer and two suspects. I am not for single officer patrol cars though.
-
Even I have to confront trespassers and pseudo-burglars (people stealing fruit) on my property, sometimes on a weekly basis. There are usually at least 2 trespassers every time this happens, and I'm typically alone. On several occasions the trespassers refused to heed my command to leave and became aggressive. Even after calling the police countless times, they can't do much, and for the most part I am left to my own devices to deal with it.
I can understand a female police officer not wanting to confront 2 males, but considering what the police leave me to deal with on my own, she has to.
Also, even if she did not want to confront the robbers, why couldn't she have just followed them in her patrol car?
-
I passed both links around and got this back from somebody.
That was a big miss!!
We love Serg's in Manao and Waimanalo and sorry they are getting hit.
If police policy is for a lone officer to call for back up, then there should be two officers in every squad car.
I guess that is not efficient, so they just let the damn burglars go.
Who want's to chase down a crack head anyway? Prosecuter just lets them out of jail, since they are over crowded.
We should send all our crack heads to Colorado so they can smoke pot and get off the crack.
Cheers,
Rehab ? :crazy:
-
I can understand a female police officer not wanting to confront 2 males, but considering what the police leave me to deal with on my own, she has to.
that sucks that people steal your fruits, i have a mango tree, thank goodness i live in a quiet cul de sac, but i smell you, once in a while people will come to my door asking for mangoes, despite the NO TRESPASSING and BEWARE OF DOG signs........ only to be told "NO, I DON'T WANT TO GIVE YOU MY MANGOES, I DON'T KNOW YOU" :rofl:
I wouldn't give any officer the benefit of the double standard, gender or sex doesn't matter when they all wear the same uniforms and have the exact same duties to uphold the same laws. There is no space for discrepancy in duties due to difference in gender, when these people have dedicated their lives to serving their duty and upholding the law, duty and law shouldn't bend for lack of male organs, the double standard exists but there is no place for it in the police department
if i may suggest, get a DOG, best theft deterrent ever (and best friend) :thumbsup:
-
My boy is studying criminolgy and criminal justice in college.
He said that the officer did exactly the correct thing.
-
Fuck it she should have just shot the mother fuckers dead. (Sarcasm)
-
How long was it before another officer arrived on scene?
I've been pulled over for a headlight out and had 3 cars roll up inside of a couple of minutes. Hell, on my way home from work today in Waikiki I saw no fewer than 6 cops and four marked cars writing up a bum for something. On my drive into work, daily, I see between 3 and 5 cars patrolling Kalanianiole. But they couldn't spare more than one for a burglary in progress?
Guess their priorities are different from ours......
-
My boy is studying criminolgy and criminal justice in college.
He said that the officer did exactly the correct thing.
Was there an explanation to go along with that opinion? I'd be very interested to know why she couldn't have given chase, maybe caught one, and let the other keep going. Normally one will roll on the other to cut a deal.
I believe this state, which is probably not unique, views property crime as a low priority. With drugs driving the need feed a habit, stealing becomes commonplace. Meth is the problem, but theft and muggings are the symptoms.
So, it doesn't surprise me if the officer was following policy and procedures. It just flies in the face of Carlisle's declaration that officers have a sworn duty to protect Hawaii's residents. I guess they draw a line between physical safety and financial loss. Not everyone has insurance and/or affordable deductibles.
-
.
-
In all fairness, I think the PO did the right thing for officer safety. Two suspects with unknown potential weapons. After all, thats why we have insurance, I suppose.
-
In all fairness, I think the PO did the right thing for officer safety. Two suspects with unknown potential weapons. After all, thats why we have insurance, I suppose.
So, when Carlisle said Police Officers have a sworn duty to protect, he meant themselves?
I'm 100% for Cops making it back home at end of shift, but that shouldn't mean they should avoid confrontations just to play it safe. She had no evidence they had any weapons at all. She has weapons, including firearms.
My totally personal, semi-informed opinion is, she should have taken steps to apprehend the thieves and assess the threat to her own safety in the process. If things get ugly, THEN retreat and wait for backup.
Excusing her inaction in the name of personal safety with no evidence of any weapons is too convenient. Cops could say "I didn't chase the criminal, because he might have had a gun!" to excuse their inactions in pretty much any situation if we accept it for this Cop.
If she saw one of them carrying a gun, knife, or crowbar, would that make her more, or less, likely to pursue them? A stolen firearm being carried off into the night represents a more violent threat to the public at large than someone merely fleeing a break in.
-
Was there an explanation to go along with that opinion? I'd be very interested to know why she couldn't have given chase, maybe caught one, and let the other keep going. Normally one will roll on the other to cut a deal.
I believe this state, which is probably not unique, views property crime as a low priority. With drugs driving the need feed a habit, stealing becomes commonplace. Meth is the problem, but theft and muggings are the symptoms.
So, it doesn't surprise me if the officer was following policy and procedures. It just flies in the face of Carlisle's declaration that officers have a sworn duty to protect Hawaii's residents. I guess they draw a line between physical safety and financial loss. Not everyone has insurance and/or affordable deductibles.
...
I'll ask him about that.
But in the meantime, here is my personal opinion.
1. It was 2 to 1 right off the top.
2. The building might have had more perps inside as the crime scene was unsecured at that time.
3. The building might have had injured civilians inside.
4. The fleeing suspects posed no immediate threat to anybody.
I commend the officer for exercising restraint and not giving in to the urge to be a hollywood action hero.
-
The way I read it, they also had at least a crowbar and screwdriver. That's not "weaponless."
-
Sorry guy's, IMHO
Putting on the uniform is putting your life on the line.
You knew that when you applied.
That is what you are trained for, that's what your paid for.
The way I read it, they also had at least a crowbar and screwdriver. That's not "weaponless."
That's why HPD has the right to carry a firearm ( but I don't).
It was 2 to 1 right off the top.
That's why HPD has the right to carry a firearm ( but I don't).
Not saying I was looking for another HPD questionable shootting, but statistics show the presentation of a firearm is enough to stop a crime.
Scenario:
Single HPD officer rolls up and officer exits vehicle.
(Other officers should be enroute already. I wonder what that window was ?)
Criminals exit building lit up by the patrol cars lights.
Officer legitimately draws fire arm when she see's suspects exit building with objects in hand (crowbar) and tells them to stop.
There you are, lit up by the headlights of a police cruiser with an armed and ready officer.
What do you, the perp do and the reaction by HPD is subjective but the point here is THE OFFICER TOOK ACTION !
But then again, maybe I'm just thinking what I would do if I was the owner of the business and I rolled up to the scene in a state with legit gun laws allowing me to protect my family, business and property. :closed:
-
I don't think p.o. is supposed to draw gun unless there is imminent threat to a person.
Anybody know what the hpd policy is?
-
I don't think p.o. is supposed to draw gun unless there is imminent threat to a person.
Anybody know what the hpd policy is?
I've seen officers roll up weapons drawn on kids reported for playing airsoft. I think there just has to be the possibility of a viable threat for drawing a weapon, and that's perfectly fine however imminent threat is needed to fire.
Of course I could be talking out of my ass but from a logical/common sense perspective it seems legit lol.
-
I don't think p.o. is supposed to draw gun unless there is imminent threat to a person.
Anybody know what the hpd policy is?
Of course there was an imminent threat, why do you think she stayed in the cruiser till they left ! :shake:
-
There is a long line of precedent regarding fires, liability, and tort law that pretty much drove this. Unless the police have assumed a special relationship, that relationship was known, and the individual detrimentally relied on that relationship you are going to have a hard time putting liability to these people.
One thing that I don't think we have really seen yet is the liability assumed with police / government workers providing paid private security functions. I've been searching but haven't been able to find anything on it yet in that regards. When we "pay someone" to provide protection etc, that is certainly a "special relationship" as it's outside of the normal scope of what citizens are provided; not to mention there is probably a contract for it.
-
What is the "normal scope" of police function? Writing tickets, and shooting drunk drivers? Just being facetious, but just wondering what is it that our tax dollars are purchasing?
-
False sense of security...
-
What is the "normal scope" of police function? Writing tickets, and shooting drunk drivers? Just being facetious, but just wondering what is it that our tax dollars are purchasing?
Potholes, poorly educated kids, EBT, UH football.......
-
maybe the owners of the establishment can invest in better doors and locks
remember the 3 Little Pigs and the straw house?
-
Seriously, who keeps money in the cash register overnight? Most business owners I know and worked with, never do that. Most tend to just keep money either in a safe or carry it with them.
If I had a business in that particular area, I would just keep the register with some Monopoly money it just to give a big middle finger to the wanna be thief.
-
Several people have said now that the police officer in this story might have acted properly, at least in regards to police procedures. So I guess my question becomes, what if the robbery had instead occurred at someone's home with the homeowners still inside? Are we expected to accept that a lone police responder is allowed to hide in her car, and do nothing except call for backup which never arrives?
If that's all they are obligated to do then why ever bother calling the police for anything. Something seems off.
-
Several people have said now that the police officer in this story might have acted properly, at least in regards to police procedures. So I guess my question becomes, what if the robbery had instead occurred at someone's home with the homeowners still inside? Are we expected to accept that a lone police responder is allowed to hide in her car, and do nothing except call for backup which never arrives?
If that's all they are obligated to do then why ever bother calling the police for anything. Something seems off.
...
I watched the report again. He says the officer stayed in the car for 42 seconds. It probably takes that long to call for backup.
-
When seconds count, police are only 42 seconds away........Not bad!
-
The fact that she didn't do anything once she was out of the car speaks volumes as well.
I agree with Rocky, once you put on the uniform and strap on a gun, putting yourself in harms way IS your business. That's why you're getting paid.
If you wanted a "safe" job you should've been a florist.
-
Seriously, who keeps money in the cash register overnight? Most business owners I know and worked with, never do that. Most tend to just keep money either in a safe or carry it with them.
If I had a business in that particular area, I would just keep the register with some Monopoly money it just to give a big middle finger to the wanna be thief.
When I had my retail store, I kept $50 in the cash register with the drawer open overnight.
And when I was an unarmed* Security Guard between regular jobs, we were told that we were "two legs, two eyes, two ears, and one finger." (To dial the police.)
Terry
*Yeah, suuuure.
-
Let's see one officer with a 360 threat environment two known suspects run off in a semi-known direction towards an unknown direction and unknown potential additional threats and then the building itself has the potential to have additional unknown suspects within building. Do, (insert self), make chase after two visible suspects going in an unknown direction to an unknown location with potential for unknown additional assailants or a potential ambush, or do, (insert self), a search of the exterior of the premise then interior of the premise by yourself. If you have really truly done an armed search (or even scenario based training, only I have done in GA) of a building in a reduced light scenario it is a self fulfilling response.
I am not saying the HPD and the officer in question is right or wrong but it is the totality of circumstances and pulling a gun and taking a life is an extremely serious issue that I think a robbery shouldn't be elevated too. I am slower, older, wiser and I guess dumber but that is my opinion. Now in my house is a different story with ample warning and the person shows intent to harm me or my family.
-
What is the "normal scope" of police function? Writing tickets, and shooting drunk drivers? Just being facetious, but just wondering what is it that our tax dollars are purchasing?
The courts basically used common sense in these applications and it has gotten us to where we are, if you had two fires, but only one fire-company... obviously someone is screwed.
It would make no sense to spend public dollars reimbursing these individuals for not being able to protect those individuals involved (i.e. putting the fire out). Where and would someone draw the line? The courts made it simple and said no duty is owed, which stopped any negligence actions off the get go.
One thing to remember is you always want more than the other guy before you start something. If there is one person, we want two or 3... if there are 2 people, we want 4 or more. When I worked in the prison, for every (1) guy in a cell, we were supposed to have (5) people to handle them in an appropriate manner. Now think of stuffing 10 (12 if you count the inmates) dudes in a full size bathroom b/c that's about how it felt haha.