2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: punaperson on January 26, 2015, 10:18:10 AM

Title: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: punaperson on January 26, 2015, 10:18:10 AM
I'm just starting to work my way through the new firearms legislation for this session. There are way too many to read through at once, but upon cursory examination, here are a few highlights and lowlights from my perspective.

This House Bill HB710 introduced by Hamakua representative Mark Nakashima simply strikes the "exceptional case...may" phrase and replaces it with "shall" issue. I like the simplicity, but doubt many legislators would go for that, it's too close to the actual constitutions... well, except that the constitutions don't mention needing any government permission of any kind, at all.

http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2015/bills/HB710_.htm (http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2015/bills/HB710_.htm)


SB955 by Slom and Gabbard:    Provides protections against burdensome retroactive regulation and lawsuits; prevents frivolous claims against shooting range operators and individuals engaging in target shooting.

http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2015/Bills/SB955_.PDF (http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2015/Bills/SB955_.PDF)



From senator Shimakuburo, SB783:

http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2015/bills/SB783_.HTM (http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2015/bills/SB783_.HTM)

Mental Health; Firearm Permit Requirements; Psychological Clearance Requirements

Description:    Specifies that an additional penalty for refusal to submit to a breath, blood, or urine test and requires the surrender of all firearms and ammunition within possession. Requires firearms permit application forms to be accompanied by an affirmation that neither the applicant nor any family or household member is or has been diagnosed with or treated for certain mental disorders and that if the applicant or family or household member is subsequently diagnosed, the applicant shall lock and secure or surrender all firearms and ammunition within 48 hours. Requires payment of a fine of $50 per day of noncompliance with the requirement to lock and secure, or surrender, firearms and ammunition within 48 hours. Specifies failure to pay child or spousal support as a good cause for revocation of a firearm permit or license. Creates an exemption for law enforcement officers.


SB196    Firearms Registration Fee; Firearms Permit to Acquire Fee; Counties [From ESPERO, Galuteria, L. Thielen]

http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2015/bills/SB196_.HTM (http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2015/bills/SB196_.HTM)

Description:    Allows each county council to establish a processing fee for a firearms permit to acquire and firearm registration.

[Yeah, now we get to pay for BOTH EACH permit to acquire AND EACH registration. Waddya guess they're gonna decide is a "fair" fee for each process? One dollar? Or Twenty-five dollars? Here's a hint from the bill: "(d)  A fee of [$10] $25 shall be charged for each license and shall be deposited in the treasury of the county in which the license is granted." So they are not satisfied with merely violating our constitutionally-guaranteed rights by requiring that we ask for and acquire permission from "our" government to keep a firearm, but now we must pay them each time we go ask for the privilege of submitting to their tyranny. Gotta love it. I get the Boston Tea Party thing. Profanities deleted.]

Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: HiCarry on January 26, 2015, 10:32:36 AM
I love the way the police get an exemption from both the blood/breath/urine test and the failure to pay child support.....if the police are as law abiding as regular citizens why must they need such an exemption?
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: punaperson on January 26, 2015, 10:53:39 AM
I love the way the police get an exemption from both the blood/breath/urine test and the failure to pay child support.....if the police are as law abiding as regular citizens why must they need such an exemption?
What? You don't support their position as the "only ones" deserving of "special treatment" in exchange for their service in support of the elite?

Actually there is a bill (which I can't recall the number or sponsors at the moment) that would subject them to possible NON-special treatment in cases of domestic abuse where the accused is a police officer, though it really only requires that each county police agency post their policies re such investigations for public viewing (as opposed to not having any policies, or not making them available to the public, or having a (unofficial?) policy of special treatment that they don't want made public). Apparently there have been complaints that when officers go to investigate a domestic violence call and find out they are investigating a fellow officer, it's possible, that sometimes, maybe, the investigating officers used different policies and procedures than had the suspect been a non-officer. I know, that's hard to believe, but the accusation is out there. I guess in the form of 38 formal complaints in the last year on Oahu alone. Go figure. I know here on the Big Island we have had two notorious cases of officers murdering their wives in (obviously) suspicious circumstances, and yet it took years in each case to actually result in prosecution. Just sayin'...
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: Jdelacruz on January 26, 2015, 11:04:47 AM
Never heard of Mark Nakashima but I'm going to send him a message of thanks for putting that bill up. Also a thank you note to Slom and Gabbard. The others will get a different kind of note from me.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: z06psi on January 26, 2015, 12:27:41 PM
I love the way the police get an exemption from both the blood/breath/urine test and the failure to pay child support.....if the police are as law abiding as regular citizens why must they need such an exemption?

Gun owners don't have a public union.  That's all it is.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 26, 2015, 03:22:25 PM
I love the way the police get an exemption from both the blood/breath/urine test and the failure to pay child support.....if the police are as law abiding as regular citizens why must they need such an exemption?

Police officers are regularly piss tested for drugs. I am not sure why they would be exempted from the child support provision. Maybe because they can use personal guns for duty use?
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: z06psi on January 27, 2015, 01:18:41 PM
Police officers are regularly piss tested for drugs.

So are the military.  What of it?
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: z06psi on January 27, 2015, 01:21:54 PM
So we make an unconstitutional law (Registration) and then have no way to support the law (only one spot for 900k people to register) and then want to tax those same people to support the unconstitutional law?  Sounds about right.  Now I wonder why I made the statement about not staying here after retirement.   Hawaii will only get worse as this will be the only bill to pass this year and the justification is liberty robbing.   
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 27, 2015, 05:02:36 PM
So are the military.  What of it?

Then perhaps active duty military should be exempt as well. But the military is not a local government employee. Remember though, I am just speculating.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: z06psi on January 27, 2015, 05:06:17 PM
Then perhaps active duty military should be exempt as well. But the military is not a local government employee. Remember though, I am just speculating.

How about no dumbass unconstitutional law in the first place?
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: edster48 on January 27, 2015, 05:25:38 PM
Police officers are regularly piss tested for drugs. I am not sure why they would be exempted from the child support provision. Maybe because they can use personal guns for duty use?

I get regularly piss tested for drugs at my job. Can I be exempt too?  :wacko:
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: MauiLeatherwork on January 27, 2015, 05:46:23 PM
When will they move on this legislation, and who do we contact to encourage?  Only our local representative?  Or also Gabbard etc?

Incidentally, I asked for a ccw application today in Maui county. They have me one, and I could take it with me.  No problem!  Why?  Because MAUI has 7 pages stapled together and requires a "firearms proficiency test, signed by the instructor, complete with scores".  When I asked, WHO/what/where?  Is this test?  I got a smile, and "I have no idea" answer from the records dept.  they have prohibited me from submitting an application if I can't complete and pass the "mystery" test.  Believe me, I am calling and researching in earnest. This was supposed to be an exercise in applying so they could deny me.  Now I can't even apply!  What a learning experience!

If "may issue" is changed to "shall" issue, that would be amazing
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: macsak on January 27, 2015, 05:49:02 PM
When will they move on this legislation, and who do we contact to encourage?  Only our local representative?  Or also Gabbard etc?

Incidentally, I asked for a ccw application today in Maui county. They have me one, and I could take it with me.  No problem!  Why?  Because MAUI has 7 pages stapled together and requires a "firearms proficiency test, signed by the instructor, complete with scores".  When I asked, WHO/what/where?  Is this test?  I got a smile, and "I have no idea" answer from the records dept.  they have prohibited me from submitting an application if I can't complete and pass the "mystery" test.  Believe me, I am calling and researching in earnest. This was supposed to be an exercise in applying so they could deny me.  Now I can't even apply!  What a learning experience!

If "may issue" is changed to "shall" issue, that would be amazing

can you send a copy of the app to the HRA, please?

mahalo
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: MauiLeatherwork on January 27, 2015, 06:37:28 PM
I emailed it this afternoon to the HRA president. Two messages, 7 photos total
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: macsak on January 27, 2015, 07:19:00 PM
Mahalo
It will be out to good use, I think
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 27, 2015, 08:43:26 PM
How about no dumbass unconstitutional law in the first place?

Well obviously there is some disagreement on that particular issue. (the constitutional part)
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: z06psi on January 27, 2015, 08:54:40 PM
Taxation is a government infringement on a freedom. Just think if they taxed free speech.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: punaperson on January 27, 2015, 10:01:38 PM
When will they move on this legislation, and who do we contact to encourage?  Only our local representative?  Or also Gabbard etc?

The proposed legislation I listed in the opening post are all Hawaii state proposals, and as things develop to committee hearings, etc., some of us here and/or HRA will let people know when and where to submit testimony via email or in person. If you are referring to U.S. Representative Tulsi Gabbard (not her father Hawaii state senator Mike Gabbard), she has nothing to do with those proposed laws above... but she will possibly be voting on California Representative Honda's proposed bills to ban civilian possession (turn 'em all in) of "military grade" body armor (The Responsible Body Armor Possession Act), The Homemade Firearms Accountability Act (I think you can guess), and The Home-Assembled Firearms Restriction Act (ban the purchase and sale of 80% lowers and 3-D printed "guns"). I'm not making this up... read his self-aggrandizing press release here: http://honda.house.gov/news/press-releases/rep-honda-introduces-legislative-package-to-promote-public-safety-in-week-two-of (http://honda.house.gov/news/press-releases/rep-honda-introduces-legislative-package-to-promote-public-safety-in-week-two-of)

Incidentally, I asked for a ccw application today in Maui county. They have me one, and I could take it with me.  No problem!  Why?  Because MAUI has 7 pages stapled together and requires a "firearms proficiency test, signed by the instructor, complete with scores".  When I asked, WHO/what/where?  Is this test?  I got a smile, and "I have no idea" answer from the records dept.  they have prohibited me from submitting an application if I can't complete and pass the "mystery" test.  Believe me, I am calling and researching in earnest. This was supposed to be an exercise in applying so they could deny me.  Now I can't even apply!  What a learning experience!

This echoes the experience (written about in another thread) of reporter Emily Miller, who, after Palmer required D.C. to take applications for CCW, applied and discovered that she had to complete a class, and discovered that there were no classes! That has since been remedied, but there are no public shooting ranges in D.C., so I'm not sure where the classes are held, nor how much they cost. Please let us know when Maui P.D. provides you with the information you need to attempt to get their permission to exercise your natural unalienable civil right to bear arms.

If "may issue" is changed to "shall" issue, that would be amazing

"Amazing" is a gross understatement. :shaka:
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: Heavies on January 28, 2015, 05:54:44 AM
Tagged
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: MauiLeatherwork on January 28, 2015, 10:06:32 PM
Please let us know when Maui P.D. provides you with the information you need to attempt to get their permission to exercise your natural unalienable civil right to bear arms.

Maui county ccw application update:

I asked a whole list of people about the test, no one knew what it was.  I went back to the records dept today and asked again.  I was politely persistent.  None of the clerks knew, so they sent the supervisor out to help me.  She said there is no definitive test. If there were a specific test, then it would be listed and described. The burden is on the applicant to structure their own proof of firearms proficiency with the oversight of a certified instructor.  This is very interesting. Basically everything is at the discretion of the chief of police, including the firearms proficiency test that the applicant submits. 

At this point I CAN NOT even apply for a ccw.  Sorry, guys. I sure tried!


I am content in my search for information at the moment. It will take me some time to decide whether or not to pursue the "test" on my own. It would require planning, practice, and financial investment.  Until there are any significant changes to the laws, I imagine it is an exercise in futility.  Everyone who knows anything says I absolutely will be denied.  A law enforcement friend said I might have to become a private investigator if I wanted to carry.  Have any of you ever considered that?  A career change just so you can carry?
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 28, 2015, 10:49:56 PM
Taxation is a government infringement on a freedom. Just think if they taxed free speech.

I wouldn't equate any and all taxation or regulation to be an infringement. It really comes down to a case by case basis, but that really is a separate issue in and of itself, worthy of discussion but I don't want to sidetrack the issue too much.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: mauidog on January 28, 2015, 11:12:37 PM
I wouldn't equate any and all taxation or regulation to be an infringement. It really comes down to a case by case basis, but that really is a separate issue in and of itself, worthy of discussion but I don't want to sidetrack the issue too much.

Your thinking is exactly what's dividing this country.  You think we can pick and choose which freedoms are really freedoms, and which ones are more like privileges subject to the whims of an over-sized government.

Look at the outrage at Voter ID cards.  People (legislators and Presidents included) scream that the requirement to present ID is an attempt to disenfranchise voters -- to infringe on their Constitutional right to vote.

But they think nothing of taxing guns and ammo, creating permit and registration processes that don't do anything close to the justifications they used to get them passed into law, but that's okay.  Case by case.  By the way, you may not be handing over cash each time you get a pistol permit, but nothing the government provides is free.  All services are at the courtesy and expense of Mr and Mrs Tax Payer.  That doesn't include the amount of time you lose during normal work hours to run to the police department and gun store multiple times to complete this process.

When you adopt the attitude that "not all rights are sacred," you are saying it's okay with you if freedoms are deteriorated as long as the ones you care about aren't eroded (case by case).

How will you feel when a right that does matter to you is suddenly reclassified under the "can be infringed" case? 
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 29, 2015, 10:40:22 AM
When you adopt the attitude that "not all rights are sacred," you are saying it's okay with you if freedoms are deteriorated as long as the ones you care about aren't eroded (case by case).

How will you feel when a right that does matter to you is suddenly reclassified under the "can be infringed" case?

I don't claim to be able to draw the line perfectly on exactly where and when a right can be regulated. I do however recognize that no right is absolute. If no right is absolute then there is inherently a grey area where a line is drawn and since that grey area exists you will have differing positions on the matter. It is not an attitutde but a fact of the matter. Because of this I look at each attempt to restrict or regulate a right on a case by case basis rather than a blanket position on the matter. Because of this we have to be open to recognizing that a line can be drawn somewhere and just try to make sure the line is drawn with as minimal inconvenience as reasonable.

The fact that we cannot yell fire in a crowded building is probably the most illustrative example of how even our most important right can be regulated.

Even though the second ammendment says it shall not be infringed I am sure that there is some situation where even the more ardent gun rights supporters would say, Ok, this person should not be having a firearm.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: mauidog on January 29, 2015, 11:09:37 AM
I don't claim to be able to draw the line perfectly on exactly where and when a right can be regulated. I do however recognize that no right is absolute. If no right is absolute then there is inherently a grey area where a line is drawn and since that grey area exists you will have differing positions on the matter. It is not an attitutde but a fact of the matter. Because of this I look at each attempt to restrict or regulate a right on a case by case basis rather than a blanket position on the matter. Because of this we have to be open to recognizing that a line can be drawn somewhere and just try to make sure the line is drawn with as minimal inconvenience as reasonable.

The fact that we cannot yell fire in a crowded building is probably the most illustrative example of how even our most important right can be regulated.

Even though the second ammendment says it shall not be infringed I am sure that there is some situation where even the more ardent gun rights supporters would say, Ok, this person should not be having a firearm.

Please define a "situation where ... this person should be having a firearm."

Then, explain the rationale for not allowing a convicted felon to have a firearm.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: HiCarry on January 29, 2015, 11:26:00 AM
I don't claim to be able to draw the line perfectly on exactly where and when a right can be regulated. I do however recognize that no right is absolute. If no right is absolute then there is inherently a grey area where a line is drawn and since that grey area exists you will have differing positions on the matter. It is not an attitutde but a fact of the matter. Because of this I look at each attempt to restrict or regulate a right on a case by case basis rather than a blanket position on the matter. Because of this we have to be open to recognizing that a line can be drawn somewhere and just try to make sure the line is drawn with as minimal inconvenience as reasonable.

The fact that we cannot yell fire in a crowded building is probably the most illustrative example of how even our most important right can be regulated.

Even though the second ammendment says it shall not be infringed I am sure that there is some situation where even the more ardent gun rights supporters would say, Ok, this person should not be having a firearm.
While no right is absolute, most of those now currently trying to find that line you speak of are inherently disingenuous with their methodology. Core, fundamental rights should always be interpreted using strict scrutiny. Period. That isn't the case and courts are batting around interpretations of allowable restrictions/infringements based on intermediate or lesser standards. And, those restrictions are being allowed are prior restraint, which is almost unheard of in restricting fundamental rights. Contrary to popular belief, you can indeed yell fire in a crowded theater. If you do so and there is no fire and you cause a panic, you are then held responsible. But what doesn't happen is that you have to get a permit prior to going into the theater.

We need a bright line. Allowing "the government" to evaluate or restrict on a "case by case" basis without clear and unequivocal guidance is asking for the same situation we have now here in Hawaii with concealed carry. All it takes in one individual in a position of power to negate all the rights and protections of those rights the Constitution affords.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: mauidog on January 29, 2015, 11:36:49 AM
While no right is absolute, most of those now currently trying to find that line you speak of are inherently disingenuous with their methodology. Core, fundamental rights should always be interpreted using strict scrutiny. Period. That isn't the case and courts are batting around interpretations of allowable restrictions/infringements based on intermediate or lesser standards. And, those restrictions are being allowed are prior restraint, which is almost unheard of in restricting fundamental rights. Contrary to popular belief, you can indeed yell fire in a crowded theater. If you do so and there is no fire and you cause a panic, you are then held responsible. But what doesn't happen is that you have to get a permit prior to going into the theater.

We need a bright line. Allowing "the government" to evaluate or restrict on a "case by case" basis without clear and unequivocal guidance is asking for the same situation we have now here in Hawaii with concealed carry. All it takes in one individual in a position of power to negate all the rights and protections of those rights the Constitution affords.

To tie into that "prior restraint" comment, no one stops you at the theater entrance and tells you not to enter because they have reports that you yelled "fire" in another theater 20 years ago, or that your doctor diagnosed you as a "yeller" and should not be allowed anywhere yelling can be a problem, such as crowded theaters.

You watched "Minority Report," I'm sure.  The concept of PreCrime was to catch and punish people before they commit a crime (in the movie, murder was the primary focus).  As the movie pointed out, trying to take someone's freedom before they have committed the act is fundamentally wrong.  We would all argue that killing Hitler before he became Fuhrer would have been great, but you have to stop and wonder if there would have been any way to justify that murder prior to his crimes.  Hindsight is always 20/20.  Predicting human behavior is at best inexact and subject to too many factors.

Therefore, it's my contention that there is no way to infringe on EVERYONE'S rights with the justification being you want to preemptively deter the bad acts of a few. 
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: new guy on January 29, 2015, 01:54:23 PM
.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 29, 2015, 04:10:09 PM
While no right is absolute, most of those now currently trying to find that line you speak of are inherently disingenuous with their methodology. Core, fundamental rights should always be interpreted using strict scrutiny. Period.

I would tend to agree. I don't know if I would say most but certainly a lot.

Quote
We need a bright line. Allowing "the government" to evaluate or restrict on a "case by case" basis without clear and unequivocal guidance is asking for the same situation we have now here in Hawaii with concealed carry. All it takes in one individual in a position of power to negate all the rights and protections of those rights the Constitution affords.

When I said case by case basis I meant as to my personal position on a proposed law. I look at each one and try to evaluate it based on the method, the merits, whether it is supported by facts etc. I was not referring to a government official just having free reign.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 29, 2015, 04:36:13 PM
Please define a "situation where ... this person should be having a firearm."

Then, explain the rationale for not allowing a convicted felon to have a firearm.

How about someone on a terrorist watch list for being suspected of planning to blow up a public target?

How about someone who has severe hallucinations and repeatedly talks about assassinating a president but has never actually showed intent to follow through so the charge of threatening wouldn't stick.

Or how about an individual convicted of molesting a child and then murdering the child. The individual has served there time in prison and is now out.

In a personal example, I had an adopted brother who was the product of a mom on drugs. He had emotional problems and anger problems. My dad ended up having to give him back to the state because he was getting increasingly violent and dangerous around my younger adopted brother.

Or how about any of the most recent individuals who went on mass killings and later it was revealed to the public that they had mental problems.

Do any of the above scenarios warrant the restriction of the right to own a firearm in your opinion?

As for not allowing a felon to own a firearm I would say it serves a number of purposes. One it serves as a deterrent to commit felonies, another is that felonies are generally serious crimes and if an individual is willing to commit serious crimes then it might stand to reason that they would be more willing to commit serious crimes of violence or with a gun. I don't necessarily believe in a blanket ban on felons owning firearms though. Certain types of non violent felons I think should be allowed to regain said right after perhaps a certain amount of years.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: mauidog on January 29, 2015, 05:36:35 PM
How about someone on a terrorist watch list for being suspected of planning to blow up a public target?

This is being debated today.  We have Gitmo for a reason.  To incarcerate a terrorist (enemy combatant) who is not part of any formally declared hostility by any sovereign nation makes holding and charging them very difficult.  Were they on US soil, they would be afforded the same rights we give citizens.  If these were Russian spies and terrorists, we would have avenues of punishment for both the combatant and the country he is part of. HOWEVER, you are telling me that without anything more concrete than suspicion, you believe his rights should be stripped away?  No proof, no day in court, just an accusation unfounded or not?  As I said earlier, you can't punish someone for what you think they might do.  If you have proof (not just suspicion) he was actually conspiring, planning, and assisting in the act, then that's different.  We actually have laws against conspiracy as they relate to certain crimes.  Suspicion?  How about, I saw eyeeatingfish downtown taking pictures of large buildings, making notes about the schedules of government workers, and complaining online about the overthrow of the Hawaii monarchy.  I suspect he might be planning some sort of attack in retaliation.  Is that enough to have you arrested and shipped off to Cuba?

How about someone who has severe hallucinations and repeatedly talks about assassinating a president but has never actually showed intent to follow through so the charge of threatening wouldn't stick.

This is different.  We have a case of someone with a HISTORY of having not just hallucinations, but fantasies of killing the prez.  Based on that , he is clearly in need of psychiatric care, and should not be trusted with firearms.  If he is later deemed to not be a threat, he will then have his rights intact.  This doesn't have to be a lifetime rights-ectomy.  this is a DEMONSTRATION of an actual threat, not a perceived problem based on no history or observable evidence.  To reduce the apples-to-oranges equivalence here, the guy in the first example would need to state his intentions to blow something up, not just be suspected.  Evidence!  Sometimes it's required! 

Or how about an individual convicted of molesting a child and then murdering the child. The individual has served there time in prison and is now out.

What if that same guy is living alone and is being threatened with violence by neighbors for his crime?  Does he have the same right to self-defense as you or I?  Will keeping a gun from him make the next kid he kills any safer (chances are the first victim wasn't shot -- that's not common for child molesters)?  The gun is not the problem.  The problem is a sexual predator who probably should NOT be released into society, because the chances he will do it again are greater than many other crimes due to the obsessive nature that drives these people to act.  Turning a criminal into a victim after they serve their time is not the way to make him a productive member of society.  But, neither is releasing someone with a real mental illness like pedophilia into open society without a short leash and supervision.

In a personal example, I had an adopted brother who was the product of a mom on drugs. He had emotional problems and anger problems. My dad ended up having to give him back to the state because he was getting increasingly violent and dangerous around my younger adopted brother.

Again, history of violence and mental issues.  Actual evidence of being a safety problem trumps his rights.

Or how about any of the most recent individuals who went on mass killings and later it was revealed to the public that they had mental problems.

Many of those were the product of psychotropic drugs used to treat a HISTORY of mental illness.  Again, evidence over suspicion or labeling.

Do any of the above scenarios warrant the restriction of the right to own a firearm in your opinion?

You are making a case that you should assign the same level of punishment (stripping people of rights) to an entire group because SOME in their group kill.  NOT ALL PEOPLE WITH A GIVEN ILLNESS KILL.  In fact, very few will.  Is it a common factor in some cases?  Probably, but it is not an indicator of future bad acts.  Rights are not supposed to be afforded only to people we feel safe around.  With freedom comes risks.  You're taking the stance that all people like X are dangerous, and they need to be disarmed; but not people like Y are dangerous (e.g. people with autism but no history of psychotropic drug use, for example)?  These people you disarm will still be dangerous without a gun.  They just won't make the news. 

So punishing 100% of these people by your accounting is okay since maybe less than 1% will kill.  I think you could make the same case for people with NO diagnosed mental illnesses (the "normal" among us).  If we go by your logic, disarming us all is justified on the exact same grounds since I bet the percentages are every close.



As for not allowing a felon to own a firearm I would say it serves a number of purposes. One it serves as a deterrent to commit felonies, another is that felonies are generally serious crimes and if an individual is willing to commit serious crimes then it might stand to reason that they would be more willing to commit serious crimes of violence or with a gun. I don't necessarily believe in a blanket ban on felons owning firearms though. Certain types of non violent felons I think should be allowed to regain said right after perhaps a certain amount of years.

Laws are not a deterrent for any crime if you are already a criminal.  The law will not stop you from acting.  The laws might deter SOME law abiding people, but we know it doesn't if they are really bent on doing something wrong.  The deterrent argument is always weak in that regard.

Quote
According to the CEPR study, nonviolent offenders make up more than 60 percent of the prison and jail population.
Nonviolent drug offenders now account for about one-fourth of all inmates, up from less than 10 percent in 1980. Much of
this increase can be traced back to the “three strikes” bills adopted by many states in the 1990s. The laws require state
courts to hand down mandatory and extended periods of incarceration to people who have been convicted of felonies on
three or more separate occasions. The felonies can include relatively minor crimes such as shoplifting.

Quote
What have longer prison sentences accomplished? Research by the Pew Center on the States suggests that
expanded incarceration accounts for about 25 percent of the drop in violent crime that began in the mid-1990s—
leaving the other 75 percent to be explained by things that have nothing to do with keeping people locked up.

So, basically, locking people up for longer and longer periods with mandatory sentencing seems to be a better way to take the violent repeat offenders off the street.  Taking away rights to vote and own guns are no deterrent.  If the longer sentences and loss of freedom won't stop a criminal act from happening, then what you do to them after they get out isn't going to do a thing. for deterrence.

Therefore, if longer, mandatory sentence are resulting in fewer violent offenders on the street, then those being released are ......

less violent ... and maybe should have .......

rights restored?
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: HiCarry on January 29, 2015, 05:39:22 PM
I would tend to agree. I don't know if I would say most but certainly a lot.

When I said case by case basis I meant as to my personal position on a proposed law. I look at each one and try to evaluate it based on the method, the merits, whether it is supported by facts etc. I was not referring to a government official just having free reign.

And therein lies the problem. ALL RIGHTS are EQUAL in terms of how they should be applied and how possible infringements to accomplish governmental goals should measured. The right to be free from warrantless searches is every bit as important as your freedom of religion, which is every bit as important as your right to free speech, which is every bit as important as your right to keep and bear arms.

Thinking such as yours has lead us to the position we are in now insofar as others (judges) somehow think one right (Freedom of Speech) should somehow be applied differently and infringements measured differently because "they" don't happen to think another right (keep and bear arms) is as important as the other.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: HiCarry on January 29, 2015, 05:56:05 PM
How about someone on a terrorist watch list for being suspected of planning to blow up a public target?

How about someone who has severe hallucinations and repeatedly talks about assassinating a president but has never actually showed intent to follow through so the charge of threatening wouldn't stick.

Or how about an individual convicted of molesting a child and then murdering the child. The individual has served there time in prison and is now out.

In a personal example, I had an adopted brother who was the product of a mom on drugs. He had emotional problems and anger problems. My dad ended up having to give him back to the state because he was getting increasingly violent and dangerous around my younger adopted brother.

Or how about any of the most recent individuals who went on mass killings and later it was revealed to the public that they had mental problems.

Do any of the above scenarios warrant the restriction of the right to own a firearm in your opinion?

As for not allowing a felon to own a firearm I would say it serves a number of purposes. One it serves as a deterrent to commit felonies, another is that felonies are generally serious crimes and if an individual is willing to commit serious crimes then it might stand to reason that they would be more willing to commit serious crimes of violence or with a gun. I don't necessarily believe in a blanket ban on felons owning firearms though. Certain types of non violent felons I think should be allowed to regain said right after perhaps a certain amount of years.
I think Mauidog did a great job of responding to your responses, but let me add a few things.

You know that the terror watch list, as Mauidog said, is based on suspicion and that many of those on it (like the "no fly" list) are erroneous and include good, law-abiding citizens who happen to have similar names, right? You also know that there is no way to appeal your placement on the list should you be one of the many thousands that are allegedly on the list because of similar names, right? You cannot petition the government to remove your name, you cannot produce evidence to refute your placement there, you're just stuck. Guilty without proof and with no means to clear your good name. How would you feel and what would you do if you were placed on that list without merit and the law to restrict firearms ownership from those on the list? Still sound good to you?

As for your naive thoughts on felons and the crimes that will make you one: Imagine you are walking through a National Forest in the Pacific Northwest. You see a feather and bend down to pick it up. Admiring it you slip it in your pocket so you can show your fellow campers when you get back to camp. Once you get there you whip out the feather to show your friends and a warden sees you. He walks up to you, slaps cuffs on you because the feather is from a Bald Eagle and possession is, you guessed it, a felony.

California passed 900 laws last legislative session. We have so many laws it is impossible for any one person to know, and therefore abide by them all. Stories abound about otherwise law-abiding citizens running afoul of arcane or little known laws. It's easy to be a non-violent felon, just ask Martha Stewart. What benefit is it to society to bar these non-violent felons from owning a firearm for the rest of their lives? How many gun crimes do you think such a ban has prevented?
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 29, 2015, 09:24:29 PM
I think Mauidog did a great job of responding to your responses, but let me add a few things.

You know that the terror watch list, as Mauidog said, is based on suspicion and that many of those on it (like the "no fly" list) are erroneous and include good, law-abiding citizens who happen to have similar names, right? You also know that there is no way to appeal your placement on the list should you be one of the many thousands that are allegedly on the list because of similar names, right? You cannot petition the government to remove your name, you cannot produce evidence to refute your placement there, you're just stuck. Guilty without proof and with no means to clear your good name. How would you feel and what would you do if you were placed on that list without merit and the law to restrict firearms ownership from those on the list? Still sound good to you?

As for your naive thoughts on felons and the crimes that will make you one: Imagine you are walking through a National Forest in the Pacific Northwest. You see a feather and bend down to pick it up. Admiring it you slip it in your pocket so you can show your fellow campers when you get back to camp. Once you get there you whip out the feather to show your friends and a warden sees you. He walks up to you, slaps cuffs on you because the feather is from a Bald Eagle and possession is, you guessed it, a felony.

California passed 900 laws last legislative session. We have so many laws it is impossible for any one person to know, and therefore abide by them all. Stories abound about otherwise law-abiding citizens running afoul of arcane or little known laws. It's easy to be a non-violent felon, just ask Martha Stewart. What benefit is it to society to bar these non-violent felons from owning a firearm for the rest of their lives? How many gun crimes do you think such a ban has prevented?

Oh, believe me, the point of obscure and overbearing felonies is not lost on me. Like I said though I do not believe in a blanket ban on firearms being owned by a person convicted of any and every type of felony.

And yes I do realize that a terror watch list could be abused or catch up innocent people but all the monday morning quarter backs in the world would ask why the guy on a terror watch list was legally allowed to buy a firearm the day after he killed multiple people. I do believe the courts ruled that people are allowed to petition the government to remove their name from the no fly list now though.

And therein lies the problem. ALL RIGHTS are EQUAL in terms of how they should be applied and how possible infringements to accomplish governmental goals should measured. The right to be free from warrantless searches is every bit as important as your freedom of religion, which is every bit as important as your right to free speech, which is every bit as important as your right to keep and bear arms.

Thinking such as yours has lead us to the position we are in now insofar as others (judges) somehow think one right (Freedom of Speech) should somehow be applied differently and infringements measured differently because "they" don't happen to think another right (keep and bear arms) is as important as the other.

I think all rights are equally important however each right touches a different area and any proposed infringement needs to be taken on a case by case basis with regards to the right being infringed.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 29, 2015, 10:03:04 PM
Laws are not a deterrent for any crime if you are already a criminal.  The law will not stop you from acting.  The laws might deter SOME law abiding people, but we know it doesn't if they are really bent on doing something wrong.  The deterrent argument is always weak in that regard.

Generally punishment is not a very strong deterrent. The strongest deterrent is whether the criminal thinks he will get caught when violating the law. Laws themselves do deter an activity though since many or most people generally follow laws. But keep in mind that I am not proposing that convicted felons should never be allowed to own a gun again as some deterrent, I am just pointing out that it does exist, even if a weak one.

As for the scenarios:
For the terror watch list, I posted my explanation on to Hilary's response

For the individual hallucinating and fantasizing about killing the president, I would agree that this person should not be allowed to have a gun. This is an example of my point that no right is absolute and individual exceptions can be made in certain circumstances. Now my follow up question is, how are we to restrict this individual from buying a firearm if we are unable to perform any type of background check? How are we to take away a firearm already owned by this individual unless we know he has a gun (gun registration)? I am not trying to make the case that we need more background checks in Hawaii but I feel that these are strong arguments being made by those who do want to maintain or add more regulation and I don't have a good answer. How can we stop a person or people who should not be allowed to own a firearm from owning a firearm if any system that regulates firearm ownership is deemed unconstitutional?

If we say yes, this person is dangerously insane and he shouldn't be allowed to own a firearm but at the same time insist that we oppose any system that would allow us to prevent that person from buying or owning a firearm then it appears we are indifferent on whether the crazy person actually gets a firearm or not. Because the minute that a crazy person shoots up a bunch of people with a gun they legally purchased the monday morning quarterbacks will decry why we didn't have a system in place to stop this crazy person from buying a gun and I guarantee a large portion of the population will be thinking the same thing.

My other adopted brother is slightly mentally retarded due just to genetic conditions. He has not really displayed violence as far as I know and he can hold down a basic job in a supermarket. His motor skills are not terribly well and sometimes hist judgement choices are questionable but again not violent or aggressive. My father won't let him near the guns but this brother is now an adult I believe (they live on mainland). Since I am not real close to him I cannot form a real solid opinion on whether he should be denied firearm ownership but I do trust the judgement of my father who was a cop and an avid firearms enthusiast. Tough call.

I actually feel that for many of those who went on mass shootings, the mental illnesses they had didn't necessarily warrant restricting their gun rights. The guy who shot up the elementary school was said to have been diagnosed with autism and in general autistic people are not aggressive or violent, quite the opposite in fact. I feel the columbine shooting could have been avoided even if school officials were more on top of bullying issues, but thats a whole separate discussion.

I am not suggesting a blanket rule be made, I am just trying to illustrate that there are times when a constitutionally guaranteed right can be taken away.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: mauidog on January 29, 2015, 10:04:46 PM
Oh, believe me, the point of obscure and overbearing felonies is not lost on me. Like I said though I do not believe in a blanket ban on firearms being owned by a person convicted of any and every type of felony.

And yes I do realize that a terror watch list could be abused or catch up innocent people but all the monday morning quarter backs in the world would ask why the guy on a terror watch list was legally allowed to buy a firearm the day after he killed multiple people. I do believe the courts ruled that people are allowed to petition the government to remove their name from the no fly list now though.

I think all rights are equally important however each right touches a different area and any proposed infringement needs to be taken on a case by case basis with regards to the right being infringed.

I don't think our government cares whether the watch list ever catches anyone.  They just use it to harass air passengers so the TSA can demonstrate how much safer they make our country.

Quote
Some analysts claim the Tsarnaev brothers' mother, Zubeidat Tsarnaeva, is a radical extremist and supporter of jihad, who influenced her sons' behavior.[199][200][201] This prompted the Russian government to warn the U.S. government about the family's behavior, on two occasions. Both Tamerlan and his mother were placed on a terrorism watch list about 18 months before the bombing took place.[202]

According to a Wall Street Journal report citing statements by anonymous US officials, Russia withheld information from U.S. intelligence after its initial warning, after which it denied U.S. requests for more information.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: HiCarry on January 30, 2015, 10:30:38 AM
Oh, believe me, the point of obscure and overbearing felonies is not lost on me. Like I said though I do not believe in a blanket ban on firearms being owned by a person convicted of any and every type of felony.

And yes I do realize that a terror watch list could be abused or catch up innocent people but all the monday morning quarter backs in the world would ask why the guy on a terror watch list was legally allowed to buy a firearm the day after he killed multiple people. I do believe the courts ruled that people are allowed to petition the government to remove their name from the no fly list now though.

I think all rights are equally important however each right touches a different area and any proposed infringement needs to be taken on a case by case basis with regards to the right being infringed.

So what felonies and which felons should be exempted? Be specific.

The fact that you are OK with innocent people being caught up and denied the exercise of their fundamental rights is frightening. The fact that you seem to condone the use of a list to identify people who's rights will be restricted without the benefit of due process is a clue to your misunderstanding of what living in a free society means. The fact that you seem OK with innocent people having to spend lots of their money to try and get their names removed from a secret list so that they can prove their innocence in order to exercise their fundamental rights shows a complete misunderstanding of how our legal system should work. As Blackstone said, "It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer." 

You never answered the question about what you would do if it were you on the list.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 30, 2015, 10:01:48 PM
So what felonies and which felons should be exempted? Be specific.

The fact that you are OK with innocent people being caught up and denied the exercise of their fundamental rights is frightening. The fact that you seem to condone the use of a list to identify people who's rights will be restricted without the benefit of due process is a clue to your misunderstanding of what living in a free society means. The fact that you seem OK with innocent people having to spend lots of their money to try and get their names removed from a secret list so that they can prove their innocence in order to exercise their fundamental rights shows a complete misunderstanding of how our legal system should work. As Blackstone said, "It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer." 

You never answered the question about what you would do if it were you on the list.

You want a list? It would take some time and space to make a comprehensive list. How about a simple basic one? I would say many felony crimes of violence would qualify.. Attempted murder for example.

I am not OK with innocent people being caught up and denied fundamental rights. I never said I condone the use of such a list, I merely listed a myriad of examples where someone might consider the denial of the right to own firearms as being justified.

I didn't notice the question of what I would do if I were on the list, sorry. If I were on the list I would fight it. I would start by making complaints or inquiries to the appropriate agency. If that didn't work perhaps contact a representative. Next could be the media or seeking a remedy through the courts. I am sure there are other options available I am unaware of.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 30, 2015, 10:04:03 PM
Maui, I am particularly interested in your answer to this section of my reply to you previously:

"For the individual hallucinating and fantasizing about killing the president, I would agree that this person should not be allowed to have a gun. This is an example of my point that no right is absolute and individual exceptions can be made in certain circumstances. Now my follow up question is, how are we to restrict this individual from buying a firearm if we are unable to perform any type of background check? How are we to take away a firearm already owned by this individual unless we know he has a gun (gun registration)? I am not trying to make the case that we need more background checks in Hawaii but I feel that these are strong arguments being made by those who do want to maintain or add more regulation and I don't have a good answer. How can we stop a person or people who should not be allowed to own a firearm from owning a firearm if any system that regulates firearm ownership is deemed unconstitutional?"
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: Jdelacruz on January 30, 2015, 10:36:51 PM
My answer to your question is "You don't."  The president has the Secret Service for his protection and should be able to (if he or she chooses) to carry their own firearm for personal protection.

In my opinion rights are absolute. Folks like to say you can't yell "fire" in crowded theater where there is none as it could get people hurt or killed as a reason to free speech limitations. But speech is like a gun, it's neither good or bad. Speech is used should have consequence just like how a firearm is used (for defense or murder) has consequences. Rights should not preempted based on a possibility as there are already laws and punishments for actual actions.

Now folks may be uncomfortable with my opinion but as it has been said before "I'd rather err on the side of freedom." If we were all free would be able to protect ourselves instead of relying the government to protect us by limiting our rights as a whole.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: mauidog on January 30, 2015, 11:54:29 PM
Maui, I am particularly interested in your answer to this section of my reply to you previously:

"For the individual hallucinating and fantasizing about killing the president, I would agree that this person should not be allowed to have a gun. This is an example of my point that no right is absolute and individual exceptions can be made in certain circumstances. Now my follow up question is, how are we to restrict this individual from buying a firearm if we are unable to perform any type of background check? How are we to take away a firearm already owned by this individual unless we know he has a gun (gun registration)? I am not trying to make the case that we need more background checks in Hawaii but I feel that these are strong arguments being made by those who do want to maintain or add more regulation and I don't have a good answer. How can we stop a person or people who should not be allowed to own a firearm from owning a firearm if any system that regulates firearm ownership is deemed unconstitutional?"

The problem with the generic term "background check", it could entail too little or too much personal information, none of which is guaranteed to prevent the purchase of a firearm in and of itself.

HPD and other public employees, unless already trained and experienced in another job, do not have the professional skills to determine the mental capacity of any one individual.  That's why the courts seek out professionals in those areas for things like ability to stand trial and assist in their own defense. 

HMOs and private doctors not having an occasion to discuss your life and all your problems have no idea what's going on inside your head.

So what do they do?  They look for markers.  They flag people for further interviews and, if warranted, treatment.  The flags may or may not indicate a problem with someone's mental condition.  They simply help screen people for additional followups.

Using these flags to prevent someone from exercising their rights is another preemptive punishment.  Without actually diagnosing someone, you have summarily stripped them of a Constitutional right because a flag gives you suspicion ... nothing more.

 If it comes to the guy hallucinating and actually telling people he plans to kill someone, president or not, then the people he tells should be responsible for making a report to police.  If they don't, then why is it now a problem for government?  Government can not, and should not, be making rules and doing background checks simply because citizens don't take responsibility to warn of danger. 

For owning a firearm, it should be a very quick and simple check:  identity, local and federal criminal history especially outstanding wants and warrants, TROs, other domestic complaints, and what I call black ball entries.  If a customer has been diagnosed as being mentally unfit to own a firearm, that MUST be in the NICS file.  If it's not, that's a failure of the CURRENT system. 

Did you watch the testimony before Congress when Gabbard's husband, Mark Kelly, spoke after Sandy Hook?  He testified one of the things his group found out is we have a gigantic backlog of unentered data regarding psychological evaluations on patients.  Basically, if NICS doesn't get updated, the doctor's recommendation to keep you from buying guns can't stop you.  That's one reason we now have laws that let HPD go directly to doctors and HMOS to ask the question.  If the system worked as designed, that extra burden, cost, and point of failure would not exist.  It's yet another example of how government, especially politicians, don't fix problems.  They just create a new law to work around it and the rest of us have to live with it.

So, in that respect, let's break down your question.  Is the problem that the guy bought a gun?  That's only one avenue of getting guns, so even the best background check in the world that prevents him from buying in no way guarantees he can't ever get his hands on a gun (see "Adam Lanza" for how that conclusion is supported).  We can't guarantee he can't get a gun.

So now what?  Can we lock him up?  Only if someone reports they heard him make the threat and it's deemed credible.  Or if he demonstrates he is a danger to himself or others in some way.  Unless that happens, we can't just lock him up for no reason.

Where are we?  We can't lock him up if we don't know he's dangerous, we can't stop him from buying guns if we don't know he's dangerous, and we can't guarantee he can't get guns outside the normal retail FFL process.

I guess the only thing left is be prepared for an attack, and hope it never happens.  Sound familiar?  This is what 2A is all about.  Self defense is YOUR responsibility.  Not the government, and not the mental health industry.  As Jdelacruz said, the President has protection because they full well know all threats can not be stopped preemptively.  Sometimes you have to be able to meet force with force.  This same protection is what the background and firearms laws seek to infringe on: our individual right AND responsibility to defend ourselves.  I'd love to hear of the Secret Service being told they can't carry weapons for 2 weeks until they all renew their permits.  You think Obama would venture out during that time?

And remember, even though any government official or celebrity can be at higher risk from loons because of their public exposure, it in no way makes their lives more valuable than yours or mine.  We deserve the same right to protection regardless of the probability of being targeted.  If that means they get to hire professionals, and we are required to use the DIY method, I'm fine with that as long as they stop trying to reduce the number of options I have at my disposal!
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 31, 2015, 10:04:58 AM
The problem with the generic term "background check", it could entail too little or too much personal information, none of which is guaranteed to prevent the purchase of a firearm in and of itself......

A very thought out reply. I too would find a quick check such as you mentioned entirely reasonable. These checks should on average only take 15 minutes per person unless there are certain serious red flags that need further investigation. I was not aware though that there is a backlog of info not in the system though. There is no excuse for that.

I don't fully understand the doctor and patient privacy rules so I am not sure exactly when a doctor could be required to inform the police. I do believe that they are required to inform authorities if there is imminent danger though. If the doctor fails to inform the police of an individual diagnosed with a dangerous mental condition or the doctor fails to properly recognize a dangerous condition then the system will fail. In the case of my adopter brother, once he turns 18 are his juvie records sealed? I don't know. Or if I know my son is dangerously mentally unstable but I cannot afford a psychological diagnosis, once he turns 18 what legal block stands in his way? At least though, the crazy ones do not make up a large portion of the gun murders in this country.

The second flaw I see is that if there is no system that tracks ownership of a firearm by a person then there is no way to take away the gun already owned by someone who becomes diagnosed with a dangerous mental condition, or some appropriate violent felony conviction. I realize the double edged nature of requiring firearms to be registered but it is also essential if we are expecting to be able to take away guns from certain dangerous people. Thus I have mixed feelings on gun registration. I sure do hope though that if we got invaded by some foreign enemy, someone at HPD would have the wherewithal to delete the gun registry.

And the third flaw I see is in the private sales where background checks are not required. (Not in Hawaii but in other states) A private citizen has no way to ensure that they are not selling their firearm to someone who should be restricted from firearm ownership. The system in Hawaii, even though cumbersome, does prevent this. I do think though that perhaps this could be remedied by some system where a seller is able to consult law enforcement with the information of the potential buyer and get the OK. This would be easier than going back and forth to the police station 3 times.

I realize that of course even a perfect system would not prevent a person from getting a gun through the means of theft but I still feel there are some flaws.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: HiCarry on January 31, 2015, 12:46:22 PM
You want a list? It would take some time and space to make a comprehensive list. How about a simple basic one? I would say many felony crimes of violence would qualify.. Attempted murder for example.

I am not OK with innocent people being caught up and denied fundamental rights. I never said I condone the use of such a list, I merely listed a myriad of examples where someone might consider the denial of the right to own firearms as being justified.

I didn't notice the question of what I would do if I were on the list, sorry. If I were on the list I would fight it. I would start by making complaints or inquiries to the appropriate agency. If that didn't work perhaps contact a representative. Next could be the media or seeking a remedy through the courts. I am sure there are other options available I am unaware of.

Sorry, it certainly sounded like you supported the terror watch list and using that list to restrict rights, including innocent people who would then have to fight to prove their innocence. You said:

Quote
And yes I do realize that a terror watch list could be abused or catch up innocent people but all the monday morning quarter backs in the world would ask why the guy on a terror watch list was legally allowed to buy a firearm the day after he killed multiple people. I do believe the courts ruled that people are allowed to petition the government to remove their name from the no fly list now though.

Either your naivete or your willful ignorance make your suggestions that innocents on some governmental watchlist can just make a few calls or go to the newspaper to remedy the problem laughable. Anyone caught up in the maze of bureaucracy and administrative roadblocks that are the hallmarks of this type of program will tell you it is anything but easy. The criteria for getting on the list is minimal and the obstacles to get off of it nearly insurmountable.

Quote
The watchlist tracks “known” and “suspected” terrorists and includes both foreigners and Americans. It’s also based on loose standards and secret evidence, which ensnares innocent people. Indeed, the standards are so low that the US government’s guidelines specifically allow for a single, uncorroborated source of information – including a Facebook or Twitter post – to serve as the basis for placing you on its master watchlist.

Of the 680,000 individuals on that FBI master list, roughly 40% have “no recognized terrorist group affiliation”

http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/aug/30/terrorist-watch-list-rules-innocent-people (http://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/aug/30/terrorist-watch-list-rules-innocent-people)

And while the list has snared many innocents, it has failed to stop those on the list from flying, the most notable example is the Christmas Day underwear bomb plotter Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab, who had a record in TIDE (the master list used for the terror watch list and the no-fly list)  but still boarded a plane to the United States in 2009. So the program fails at its primary mission and ensnares multiple innocents with some routine, and that is the list you think is a valid argument by "someone" who thinks it should be used to restrict rights?

What felonies should NOT disqualify you from owning a firearm?
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: MauiLeatherwork on February 01, 2015, 09:21:31 PM
I am most interested in HB710.  I sent testimony on 3 bills according to the instructions on HRA's site and contacted my representative with specific info about Maui county's difficult application process for ccw. 

Thanks to this forum I will now be following Peruta, Baker, Young, and some house bills.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on February 02, 2015, 10:09:58 AM
Either your naivete or your willful ignorance make your suggestions that innocents on some governmental watchlist can just make a few calls or go to the newspaper to remedy the problem laughable. Anyone caught up in the maze of bureaucracy and administrative roadblocks that are the hallmarks of this type of program will tell you it is anything but easy. The criteria for getting on the list is minimal and the obstacles to get off of it nearly insurmountable.

I never made it sound easy, you asked me what I would do and I listed the steps I would take.

Quote
And while the list has snared many innocents, it has failed to stop those on the list from flying, the most notable example is the Christmas Day underwear bomb plotter Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab, who had a record in TIDE (the master list used for the terror watch list and the no-fly list)  but still boarded a plane to the United States in 2009. So the program fails at its primary mission and ensnares multiple innocents with some routine, and that is the list you think is a valid argument by "someone" who thinks it should be used to restrict rights?

Sounds like the system isn't being operated properly. If the system worked properly and prevented those people from flying would you be more supportive of it?

Quote
What felonies should NOT disqualify you from owning a firearm?

I would say perhaps most that don't involve any element of violence, once a person has served their time. However if someone has a large number of convictions for felonies, violent or not, then perhaps that wight could be taken away.

I would say that there is always the process of wiping your record as a way to reinstate your rights but as I have heard it is immensely complicated to do that in Hawaii.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: zippz on February 02, 2015, 02:40:04 PM
Please let us know when Maui P.D. provides you with the information you need to attempt to get their permission to exercise your natural unalienable civil right to bear arms.

Maui county ccw application update:

I asked a whole list of people about the test, no one knew what it was.  I went back to the records dept today and asked again.  I was politely persistent.  None of the clerks knew, so they sent the supervisor out to help me.  She said there is no definitive test. If there were a specific test, then it would be listed and described. The burden is on the applicant to structure their own proof of firearms proficiency with the oversight of a certified instructor.  This is very interesting. Basically everything is at the discretion of the chief of police, including the firearms proficiency test that the applicant submits. 

At this point I CAN NOT even apply for a ccw.  Sorry, guys. I sure tried!


I am content in my search for information at the moment. It will take me some time to decide whether or not to pursue the "test" on my own. It would require planning, practice, and financial investment.  Until there are any significant changes to the laws, I imagine it is an exercise in futility.  Everyone who knows anything says I absolutely will be denied.  A law enforcement friend said I might have to become a private investigator if I wanted to carry.  Have any of you ever considered that?  A career change just so you can carry?

Do you have another state CCW such as Utah?  Prior military?  NRA certification?  try submitting those.  Will probably be denied anyways, but the point is to show demand for CCW.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on February 02, 2015, 06:41:59 PM
Do you have another state CCW such as Utah?  Prior military?  NRA certification?  try submitting those.  Will probably be denied anyways, but the point is to show demand for CCW.


I doubt that demand or lack of demand has anything to do with whether they issue a permit or not.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: punaperson on February 02, 2015, 08:07:12 PM
I doubt that demand or lack of demand has anything to do with whether they issue a permit or not.
No doubt. If 10% of the population applied, they'd deny licenses to 10% of the population. However, I believe that at some point somewhere some official (somebody help me out here... HiCarry? Funtimes?) stated that the failure to issue CCW licenses wasn't really an issue of any import BECAUSE so very few people apply that it indicates there is no real interest in it anyway. Apparently the supposition being that if so very few people want to exercise their rights, it's alright for government to violate the Constitution and deny them the exercise of those rights. A novel legal theory to say the least. If that is an argument, I'd ask what is the necessary number or percentage requesting to exercise their civil rights when it becomes NOT okay for the government to deny those rights? As a followup question I'd ask how many angels can dance on the head of a pin?
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: MauiLeatherwork on February 02, 2015, 09:12:32 PM
Do you have another state CCW such as Utah?  Prior military?  NRA certification?  try submitting those.  Will probably be denied anyways, but the point is to show demand for CCW.

I would consider setting up a test that emulated mpd or sherif.  The records dept supervisor specifically said they were NOT asking for a safety or training course.  For the moment, our only public range: Ukumehame is closed because the Nēnē are nesting.

No I don't have a ccw, military, or NRA cert. I've lived in Hawaii since 1999.  Maui is rumored to be particularly harsh in denying ccw even to retired law enforcement officers.  Making them perform difficult tests as a requirement.  I know one officer who carries concealed, and even he wasn't able to offer much immediate help.  His suggestions showed how difficult Maui's current laws are. I may try to move forward with this, but it will be slow.  Sorry about that. A closed range is part of that problem
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: HiCarry on February 03, 2015, 12:06:34 AM
I never made it sound easy, you asked me what I would do and I listed the steps I would take.

Sounds like the system isn't being operated properly. If the system worked properly and prevented those people from flying would you be more supportive of it?

I would say perhaps most that don't involve any element of violence, once a person has served their time. However if someone has a large number of convictions for felonies, violent or not, then perhaps that wight could be taken away.

I would say that there is always the process of wiping your record as a way to reinstate your rights but as I have heard it is immensely complicated to do that in Hawaii.

But, IMHO, your seemingly cavalier attitude towards the difficulties encountered by individuals presumed to be innocent until proven guilty, who are supposed to be given fair opportunity to address their accusers, certainly appear to make you very supportive of this fatally flawed system. Then, you further show your naivete or willful ignorance when you ask if I would support it if it "worked properly." And therein lays my concern. You seem incapable of realizing that by their very nature these types of bureaucratic systems, especially those have have been granted seemingly extrajudicial powers, inevitably don't work "properly." Denying otherwise law abiding individuals from exercising their rights should be fraught with difficulties for those seeking to limit rights. The system should favor the individual in terms of correcting mistakes and inevitable paperwork screw ups, not shield the governmental functionaries from scrutiny when those mistakes happen.

Restoring your rights is yet another typical perversion of the supposed checks and balances on governmental overreach. As you said, once you serve your time you should be able to at least start the process to restore your rights. One might quibble about the specifics but at least we agree with the concept. Yet, those same people you think can somehow magically turn this dysfunctional system around and manage the terror watch list "properly", effectively shut down anyone's chances of restoring your rights by defunding the program meant to effect this process.

And this may be the fundamental problem in terms of arguing gun rights with you. You believe that a big, intrusive, powerful governmental agency tasked to enforce these types of "common sense" laws will actually do their job with wisdom, benevolence, and a concern for the rights of those under their charge. While I believe that such an agency, inevitably, will grow ineffective, ask for even more intrusive and powerful "tools" when the original ones fail to accomplish the originally stated goals, and will ignore the rights of those very people it was originally tasked to protect in order to preserve itself and continue receiving funding. One need not look far to see the many examples of just such a genesis. The ATF, for example. We're supposed to trust that an agency that was willing to set up one of its own agents and lie in Federal Court is going to be concerned about us peons?
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: HiCarry on February 03, 2015, 12:14:05 AM
No doubt. If 10% of the population applied, they'd deny licenses to 10% of the population. However, I believe that at some point somewhere some official (somebody help me out here... HiCarry? Funtimes?) stated that the failure to issue CCW licenses wasn't really an issue of any import BECAUSE so very few people apply that it indicates there is no real interest in it anyway. Apparently the supposition being that if so very few people want to exercise their rights, it's alright for government to violate the Constitution and deny them the exercise of those rights. A novel legal theory to say the least. If that is an argument, I'd ask what is the necessary number or percentage requesting to exercise their civil rights when it becomes NOT okay for the government to deny those rights? As a followup question I'd ask how many angels can dance on the head of a pin?

In the past the police have testified that concealed carry isn't a big deal and that "we" were just a vocal minority. No one was really interested in concealed carry or there would be more applicants, they would say.

Furthermore, when Funtimes started his legal endeavors, he had several others apply for CCWs knowing they would be rejected. When the AG's yearly report came out, the number of applicants was much less than it should have been based on Funtime's personal knowledge of the many others that had applied.

So, the basis for the effort to get more applicants was to address the first issue (no "real" interest in CCW in Hawaii) and the documentation of the denials was to address the questionable numbers of applicants reported by the AG's office.

Hope that fills in some of the background info for everyone.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: Funtimes on February 03, 2015, 06:53:56 AM
In the past the police have testified that concealed carry isn't a big deal and that "we" were just a vocal minority. No one was really interested in concealed carry or there would be more applicants, they would say.

Furthermore, when Funtimes started his legal endeavors, he had several others apply for CCWs knowing they would be rejected. When the AG's yearly report came out, the number of applicants was much less than it should have been based on Funtime's personal knowledge of the many others that had applied.

So, the basis for the effort to get more applicants was to address the first issue (no "real" interest in CCW in Hawaii) and the documentation of the denials was to address the questionable numbers of applicants reported by the AG's office.

Hope that fills in some of the background info for everyone.

not only that, but it shows a lot of lies... like them saying no other process servers etc. have ever applied.  You know, except for my boss, who went with me on the same day and I typed up his narrative and we did the whole thing together lol.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: punaperson on February 03, 2015, 08:31:14 AM
not only that, but it shows a lot of lies... like them saying no other process servers etc. have ever applied.  You know, except for my boss, who went with me on the same day and I typed up his narrative and we did the whole thing together lol.
Hi, Chirs. Thanks for chiming in on this one. Do you expect me to really believe that my "public servants", who I pay to serve me (duh!), would intentionally lie to me in order to facilitate imposing an unconstitutional denial of my civil rights? Well, that'd be a first... oh, wait...

 :shaka:
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on February 03, 2015, 04:40:27 PM
No doubt. If 10% of the population applied, they'd deny licenses to 10% of the population. However, I believe that at some point somewhere some official (somebody help me out here... HiCarry? Funtimes?) stated that the failure to issue CCW licenses wasn't really an issue of any import BECAUSE so very few people apply that it indicates there is no real interest in it anyway. Apparently the supposition being that if so very few people want to exercise their rights, it's alright for government to violate the Constitution and deny them the exercise of those rights. A novel legal theory to say the least. If that is an argument, I'd ask what is the necessary number or percentage requesting to exercise their civil rights when it becomes NOT okay for the government to deny those rights? As a followup question I'd ask how many angels can dance on the head of a pin?

Good point. I do suppose that the more numbers you have the weaker the argument that they could make that only "isolated gun nuts" want them.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on February 03, 2015, 05:02:16 PM
But, IMHO, your seemingly cavalier attitude towards the difficulties encountered by individuals presumed to be innocent until proven guilty, who are supposed to be given fair opportunity to address their accusers, certainly appear to make you very supportive of this fatally flawed system. Then, you further show your naivete or willful ignorance when you ask if I would support it if it "worked properly." And therein lays my concern. You seem incapable of realizing that by their very nature these types of bureaucratic systems, especially those have have been granted seemingly extrajudicial powers, inevitably don't work "properly." Denying otherwise law abiding individuals from exercising their rights should be fraught with difficulties for those seeking to limit rights. The system should favor the individual in terms of correcting mistakes and inevitable paperwork screw ups, not shield the governmental functionaries from scrutiny when those mistakes happen.

Restoring your rights is yet another typical perversion of the supposed checks and balances on governmental overreach. As you said, once you serve your time you should be able to at least start the process to restore your rights. One might quibble about the specifics but at least we agree with the concept. Yet, those same people you think can somehow magically turn this dysfunctional system around and manage the terror watch list "properly", effectively shut down anyone's chances of restoring your rights by defunding the program meant to effect this process.

And this may be the fundamental problem in terms of arguing gun rights with you. You believe that a big, intrusive, powerful governmental agency tasked to enforce these types of "common sense" laws will actually do their job with wisdom, benevolence, and a concern for the rights of those under their charge. While I believe that such an agency, inevitably, will grow ineffective, ask for even more intrusive and powerful "tools" when the original ones fail to accomplish the originally stated goals, and will ignore the rights of those very people it was originally tasked to protect in order to preserve itself and continue receiving funding. One need not look far to see the many examples of just such a genesis. The ATF, for example. We're supposed to trust that an agency that was willing to set up one of its own agents and lie in Federal Court is going to be concerned about us peons?

I am sorry but you are mistaken. I have always been a strong critic of the inability to appeal being placed on a watch list and I was happy to hear when the courts (supreme court?) ruled that people do have the right to challenge their name being on the terror watch list. I am able to look at the idea of a watch list independently of whether it was implemented properly in this instance. The unconstitutional nature that the no-fly list was employed does not mean it is impossible to implement a watch list that is effective without denying citizens their rights.

Your main argument appears to just be undermining the belief that the federal government can do anything large or complex. So what is the alternative, just have them not even try? After all they will never do their job with wisdom, benevolence, or concern for individuals rights.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: mauidog on February 03, 2015, 05:19:53 PM
Good point. I do suppose that the more numbers you have the weaker the argument that they could make that only "isolated gun nuts" want them.

About 0.30% of Hawaii residents are employed in the Journalism industry.  That includes newspaper, radio, television, social advocacy organizations, periodical and other publishers, cable and subscription programming, as well as independent artists, writers, and performers.

The demand being less than one-third of a percentage point of the population, it's reasonable to assume the majority of the residents have no interest in exercising their First Amendment Rights to free speech in any meaningful way -- particularly as a professional pursuit.

Therefore, due to a miniscule level of demand in journalism and related occupations, we should stop licensing or allowing any and all professional press-related activities in the state.  To continue to support such a small minority's Constitutional rights is not cost effective.  It also ignores the obvious desire of the majority to do away with  these rights for the minority.

----------------------

Rights of the minority should never be decided by the majority.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: HiCarry on February 05, 2015, 05:01:09 PM
I am sorry but you are mistaken. I have always been a strong critic of the inability to appeal being placed on a watch list and I was happy to hear when the courts (supreme court?) ruled that people do have the right to challenge their name being on the terror watch list. I am able to look at the idea of a watch list independently of whether it was implemented properly in this instance. The unconstitutional nature that the no-fly list was employed does not mean it is impossible to implement a watch list that is effective without denying citizens their rights.

Your main argument appears to just be undermining the belief that the federal government can do anything large or complex. So what is the alternative, just have them not even try? After all they will never do their job with wisdom, benevolence, or concern for individuals rights.

Always been a strong critic? Really? Where? Certainly not on this forum. But, assuming that is indeed the case, let's look at your statement that even though the no-fly list was unconstitutional, you think it's possible to implement a watch list that would survive real Constitutional scrutiny. How do people get on the list? If people get placed on the list and then have any rights restricted, how can this be constitutional? Have they they been adjudicated or was placement on the list based on suspicions and innuendos? The fact of the matter is that if you deny people their rights without due process, that's unconstitutional, period. A watch list, at least as perceived using the current government model would be impossible to use without trampling the constitutional rights of those on the list. So, please, tell us all how you would envision such a list being implemented and used. I'm quite interested in how that would work.

As for the issue of the large, unwieldy and intrusive government and alternatives: Yes! A prime example is the BATF. There is nothing they do that could not be transferred to the FBI. The BATF is fraught with government overreach and self-serving "interpretations" that seem more intent on maintaining their power than actually enforcing existing laws. "How can we make ourselves more needed" is what the BATF seems to do particularly well...let's get gun stores to go along with straw purchases to Mexican bad guys so we can claim that Mexican drug cartels get most of their firearms from the US because of its lax gun laws. Sound familiar?  The BATF's opinion(s) on a piece of hardware (the Sig arm brace, the mechanical device to let you "rapid fire" a semi-automatic rifle, etc.) are frequently changed after the detrimental reliance on that opinion. Why? Did they just change their mind or is it a means to keep them relevant and "enforcing" gun laws? Want to increase your workload so it appears your agency is "needed?" How about creating a new administrative rule that you have to report any purchase of two or more rifles at a time or within 30 days? That should create more work so they can ask for more money to keep the agency afloat, right? So yes, let's get rid of some of these ineffective and self-serving dinosaurs. The fact is that we could do quite well with a smaller, less intrusive government. But since we're asking questions, let me ask you this: Name a big governmental agency that you think does a good job at what it's supposed to be doing.   
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: Jared on February 23, 2015, 07:16:55 PM
But since we're asking questions, let me ask you this: Name a big governmental agency that you think does a good job at what it's supposed to be doing.

Definitely the post office. They are much better than the common carriers..... At least when it comes to delivering illegal drugs  :geekdanc:
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: new guy on April 23, 2015, 07:56:34 AM
.
Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: macsak on April 23, 2015, 11:01:48 AM
I've been really derelict in my personal duty to keep up-to-date on legislation, this session, and with just 2 weeks remaining, I am humbly asking if someone would kindly provide any updates.

Thanks!  :shaka:

HAWAII CITIZENS’ RIGHTS POLITICAL ACTION COMMITTEE
The only political action committee in Hawaii supporting the 2nd Amendment
 
Aloha, Gun Rights Supporters.
 
The Hawaii State Legislature is finishing up for the year with adjournment scheduled for May 7, 2015.  Once again NO ANTI-GUN BILLS ARE PASSING.  Thanks to aggressive grass roots lobbying by many of you, some very nasty bills were laid to rest.  IT IS TIME TO EXPRESS OUR APPRECIATION TO THE MANY LEGISLATORS WHO SUPPORTED OUR RIGHTS this session by supporting their re-election campaigns.
 
Several of the conservative House Democrats who looked after your interests this session are holding a joint fundraiser next Tuesday, April 28, 2015, 5:30-7:30 pm, at Jade Dynasty Restaurant (Ala Moana Shopping Center).
 
Please attend and thank:
 
Speaker Emeritus CALVIN SAY, Representatives ISAAC CHOY, SHARON HAR, KEN ITO, JO JORDAN, DEREK KAWAKAMI, AND JIMMY TOKIOKA. 
 
 If you cannot attend, please send your contribution to your favorite Legislator(s).
 
Friends of KEN ITO, P.O. Box 4354, Kaneohe, Hawaii 96744
 
Friends of Sharon Har, Box 101, 590 Farrington Highway #210, Kapolei, HI 96707
 
Friends of Derek Kawakami, P.O. Box 3136, Lihue, Hawaii 96766
 
Friends of Jo Jordan, P.O. Box 1398, Waianae, Hawaii 96792
 
SUGGESTED DONATION at the door, $100 each, or whatever you can afford will be welcomed.  Don't forget to mark your check, "Thanks for your support of gun rights."
 
Some accept Pay-Pal online.  Google their Official Websites.  Do not send to their Capitol offices, as campaign rules prohibit such.
 
 
 
Mahalo,


 

Title: Re: New 2A laws, new "fees", HB710 Shall Issue CCW Law pending introduction, etc.
Post by: new guy on April 23, 2015, 01:04:00 PM
.