2aHawaii

Tools and Uses => Reloading => Topic started by: paka808 on February 14, 2015, 03:57:18 PM

Title: 556.
Post by: paka808 on February 14, 2015, 03:57:18 PM
Can you guys give me an idea of how much it would cost to do 556 rounds..cost of equipment and materials.And can I get everything I need on island.Aloha
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: justin1098 on February 15, 2015, 12:08:19 AM
depends...

you can get everything on island but it'll cost you.
you can get a lee breechlock kit from amazon with free shipping for 126.99 and dies will another 40 bucks. you will also need a case trimmer ($70) and calipers($30). Powder on island is about 30 to 40 bucks a pound and primers are like 4-5 dollars for 100. bullets are $7-$40 for 100. brass is recyclable so i don't really count that. you will have to ream or swage the the crimp out of the primer pockets. tools are $20 to $80. 

so that's about $350 to make your first 100 rounds. you can spend a lot more or a bit less. if you buy all your tooling on island it will probably be closer to $500.

I advise you to do some research and look at someones setup if you can to figure out what you want and avoid buying things that you will want to upgrade right away. I would recommend a decent electronic scale and a little crow WFT case trimmer to speed up the most tedious parts of loading.

hope that helps
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: suka on February 15, 2015, 03:50:30 AM
Ask yourself first :
buy a full kit or all items seperate
progressive press or single press
press brand and price range
reload from new cases or once fired cases


once fired, 5.56 case necks will stretch (grow) after each shot. So you'll need a trimmer and set of calipers along with a tumbler


please do a bit of research first, there are tons of equipment out there. or you can build your own press.

(http://i1327.photobucket.com/albums/u666/suka5168/Mobile%20Uploads/IMG_2415_zps0d7e7eef.jpg) (http://s1327.photobucket.com/user/suka5168/media/Mobile%20Uploads/IMG_2415_zps0d7e7eef.jpg.html)


Title: Re: 556.
Post by: paka808 on February 15, 2015, 08:57:51 AM
Thank you guys.I really appreciate the feed back.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: jc2721 on February 15, 2015, 10:41:51 AM
Buy a good reloading manual first.  The reloading equipment you buy will probably last a lifetime (if you buy quality).

The big "expense" in reloading is the time you put into it--if you take shortcuts or are prone to "rush jobs" you'll probably blow something up at best, hurt someone at the worst.  If you look at reloading as a hobby and/or have more time than $$$, then it makes sense.  If you have more $$$ than time, then buying case lots may make more sense.

My .02
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: justin1098 on February 15, 2015, 01:03:18 PM
Here is some helpful links

A bunch of articles from sierra that cover a lot especially if you are loading military rifles.
http://www.exteriorballistics.com/reloadbasics/index.cfm (http://www.exteriorballistics.com/reloadbasics/index.cfm)

the 223 page on accurateshooter with some good info about components and sierra load data.
http://www.accurateshooter.com/cartridge-guides/223rem/ (http://www.accurateshooter.com/cartridge-guides/223rem/)

Title: Re: 556.
Post by: oldfart on February 15, 2015, 01:58:27 PM
Can you guys give me an idea of how much it would cost to do 556 rounds..cost of equipment and materials.And can I get everything I need on island.Aloha
...
What is your goal? Blasting ammo or accuracy ammo?
Also, what kind of rifles are you using?
What is your budget?
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: paka808 on February 15, 2015, 02:06:32 PM
It would be a mixture of accuracy and blasting,i will be using this ammo for my scar16 and ar15,and my budget will be around $500.Again thanks for all the help guys, helps me out alot.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: justin1098 on February 15, 2015, 03:35:53 PM
It would be a mixture of accuracy and blasting,i will be using this ammo for my scar16 and ar15,and my budget will be around $500.Again thanks for all the help guys, helps me out alot.

$500 should get you going. Making ammo that shoots accurately in your rifle has more to do with brass prep, attention to detail, and load work-up than how much you spend on tooling.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: ren on February 15, 2015, 03:59:43 PM
If you decide to go progressive - which I think will fit your needs, WGS has Dillons. I'd suggest the 550B. Great all around machine and works semi progressively. Another one is the Hornady AP. READ about these machines, WATCH THEM in YouTube.
Sorry, the words "research" and "read" get so lost in meaning as they are often wrongly used. When I started the grad program that's one of the the first things we humbly learned. OK <RANT OFF>

Dillons have a good resale value. Reloading rifle cases will require to spend some time in case prep i.e. sizing, trimming etc. A progressive machine or semi (550B) will allow you to complete multiple processes at the same time with one stroke of the lever. Saves time. You can dump powder, seat the bullet and crimp if you wish. Those are the main steps a progressive machine will allow you to do. Sizing is done first, then trimming. I suggest the Giraud TriWay http://www.giraudtool.com/Tri%20Way%20Trimmer.htm (http://www.giraudtool.com/Tri%20Way%20Trimmer.htm) It trims, deburrs the cut and chamfers the neck for seating of the bullet.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: paka808 on February 15, 2015, 04:12:32 PM
Thanks ren
I will definitely look up that equipment,and check out some you tube vids
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: fang23 on February 16, 2015, 04:33:52 PM
Reloading 5.56? Don't limit yourself.  There are more recipes for .223. Differences in pressure and chamber dimensions. General rule: you can fire 223 in a 5.56 weapon, but most advise against  firing 5.56 in a .223 weapon. Load .223 and don't sweat it.

Do your research first: Check out this book by Christopher Ohland: AR 15 Ammunition Relocating: A beginner's guide....It's available on Amazon. Has specific recommendations and detailed step-by-step guide so that i was able to . load .223 ammo that fired and functioned well in my Savage .223 and ARs on the first try.  Recomends Sierra HPBT 69 grn and Varget, which is just one of a zillion possibilities, but as a good a place to start as any.

Books are cheap. Do your research first: The ABCs of Reloading (now in its 9th edition), the .223 Rem edition of the Loadbooks series (cheap [photocopies of various manufacturers' recommended loads). Agree with JC2721, buy a good reloading manual. Sierra, Nosler, Hornady, Lee, etc. Some manufacturers have information on the Internet, but a lot of the other stuff on the web is worth what you pay for it -- nothing. JC's advice about not rushing or cutting corners is well taken. It's easy to make crappy ammo. Just hope the cost of sloppy reloading doesn't get someone hurt.


You can get started for $500 if you shop carefully, but that will likely be just the beginning of a whole new way to spend your money. I started reloading a few years ago, after the first Obama scare, when 5.56/.223 was scarce and expensive. Bought a 550B from Dillon.and a Wilson hand-crank trimmer, Redding balance beam scale. Used the 550B's powder drop. Spent plenty trying to get it to meter more accurately, and learned that there are many powders and powder measures that work better. Now have a couple of $20 Lee PPMs dedicated to particular loads, among several powder measures. Added a couple of Lee presses and an RCBS Rockchucker. Still use the Dillon  for seating and crimping. BTW, if  you're using once-fired 5.56, add the cost of something to swage out the crimp in the primer pocket. Dillon works for me, but is pricey. Lee stuff is cheap, and might not last, but it's a good way to start on a budget.

 Bottom line: If you're going to handload to save money, you will probably be disappointed. Even if you just spend $500 to get started, you'd have to shoot a lot of rounds to cover the difference between commercial ammo and your handloads. Bullets cost money. Figure 10 to 25  cents a round for a decent .224 pill, plus 4 cents and up for a primer, and about 10 cents for powder (roughly based on  23 grains per round, so about 300 loads from a a pound of powder -- 7000 grains ag $30/lb. Those prices are low if you're buying components locally.   Didn't even include the cost of brass. You're already looking at about  25 cents/round. Commercial ammo is down to about 37.5 cents per round these days.
 HOWEVER, reloading does enable you to tailor ammo exactly for your needs. Once you get the hang of it, you will have the satisfaction of knowing a valuable skill; you will know a heck of a lot more about what happens when you pull the trigger;  you will be less dependent on manufacturers and retailers, and when the next scare happens and ammo becomes unobtainable or stupid expensive, you will be happy.

Title: Re: 556.
Post by: paka808 on February 16, 2015, 07:23:44 PM
Reloading 5.56? Don't limit yourself.  There are more recipes for .223. Differences in pressure and chamber dimensions. General rule: you can fire 223 in a 5.56 weapon, but most advise against  firing 5.56 in a .223 weapon. Load .223 and don't sweat it.

Do your research first: Check out this book by Christopher Ohland: AR 15 Ammunition Relocating: A beginner's guide....It's available on Amazon. Has specific recommendations and detailed step-by-step guide so that i was able to . load .223 ammo that fired and functioned well in my Savage .223 and ARs on the first try.  Recomends Sierra HPBT 69 grn and Varget, which is just one of a zillion possibilities, but as a good a place to start as any.

Books are cheap. Do your research first: The ABCs of Reloading (now in its 9th edition), the .223 Rem edition of the Loadbooks series (cheap [photocopies of various manufacturers' recommended loads). Agree with JC2721, buy a good reloading manual. Sierra, Nosler, Hornady, Lee, etc. Some manufacturers have information on the Internet, but a lot of the other stuff on the web is worth what you pay for it -- nothing. JC's advice about not rushing or cutting corners is well taken. It's easy to make crappy ammo. Just hope the cost of sloppy reloading doesn't get someone hurt.


You can get started for $500 if you shop carefully, but that will likely be just the beginning of a whole new way to spend your money. I started reloading a few years ago, after the first Obama scare, when 5.56/.223 was scarce and expensive. Bought a 550B from Dillon.and a Wilson hand-crank trimmer, Redding balance beam scale. Used the 550B's powder drop. Spent plenty trying to get it to meter more accurately, and learned that there are many powders and powder measures that work better. Now have a couple of $20 Lee PPMs dedicated to particular loads, among several powder measures. Added a couple of Lee presses and an RCBS Rockchucker. Still use the Dillon  for seating and crimping. BTW, if  you're using once-fired 5.56, add the cost of something to swage out the crimp in the primer pocket. Dillon works for me, but is pricey. Lee stuff is cheap, and might not last, but it's a good way to start on a budget.

 Bottom line: If you're going to handload to save money, you will probably be disappointed. Even if you just spend $500 to get started, you'd have to shoot a lot of rounds to cover the difference between commercial ammo and your handloads. Bullets cost money. Figure 10 to 25  cents a round for a decent .224 pill, plus 4 cents and up for a primer, and about 10 cents for powder (roughly based on  23 grains per round, so about 300 loads from a a pound of powder -- 7000 grains ag $30/lb. Those prices are low if you're buying components locally.   Didn't even include the cost of brass. You're already looking at about  25 cents/round. Commercial ammo is down to about 37.5 cents per round these days.
 HOWEVER, reloading does enable you to tailor ammo exactly for your needs. Once you get the hang of it, you will have the satisfaction of knowing a valuable skill; you will know a heck of a lot more about what happens when you pull the trigger;  you will be less dependent on manufacturers and retailers, and when the next scare happens and ammo becomes unobtainable or stupid expensive, you will be happy.
yeah I understand what your saying about 556 buying inexpensive right now, thought I would start with 556 because that's what I mostly shoot and work my way to other calibers.thanks for all your input.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: oldfart on February 16, 2015, 08:44:55 PM
The other guys have covered most all the usual stuff. The only thing I can add is that I recommend loading some ammo with a buddy that already reloads.
You will learn much faster.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: paka808 on February 16, 2015, 10:17:57 PM
The other guys have covered most all the usual stuff. The only thing I can add is that I recommend loading some ammo with a buddy that already reloads.
You will learn much faster.
I will definately do that,i might just blow my self up.lol
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: Kingkeoni on February 17, 2015, 04:17:49 AM
I will definately do that,i might just blow my self up.lol
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: oldfart on February 18, 2015, 10:05:49 AM
----
Reminder that I do have a standing invitation to newb reloaders to drop by my house to see how I do my reloading.
I'm more geared to handgun loading but the basic principles are the same.
A number of fellas have taken advantage of the offer.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: Bushido on April 18, 2015, 08:59:31 AM
Rather than start another "newbie question" thread and my question relates to OP, I'll post here if you don't mind. ---- I've been collecting my reloading equipment for several months now and finally have what I feel I need to drop my first charge. I'm reloading .223 Rem for a bolt gun. Using once fired WCC brass, CCI BR-4 primers, 69grn HPBT Sierra Matchkings. I bought Varget and H335 and was planning to start with H335 and hold the Varget for later use. The data shows 22grns of H335 as the starting load and 24grns being the max load. I was planning to load 20 rounds each of 22grns and increasing by .5grn to a max to 23.5grns for a starting point. I would be looking for overpressure signs along the way. After I find the load that shoots the best in my rifle, I was planning on increasing/ decreasing the charge by .2grns next than .1grn to fine tune and possibly playing with OAL.

My primary reason to reload is for accuracy but cost is also a major factor. I would like to end up with a load similar to Federal Gold Medal Match as my rifle shoots those really well.

With that in mind, I'm open to your thoughts and suggestions.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: jonjon on April 18, 2015, 09:12:12 AM
----
Reminder that I do have a standing invitation to newb reloaders to drop by my house to see how I do my reloading.
I'm more geared to handgun loading but the basic principles are the same.
A number of fellas have taken advantage of the offer.

old fart helped me out and pointed me in the safe and right direction  :shaka:
Title: 556.
Post by: Mr. Farknocker on April 18, 2015, 04:02:11 PM
Rather than start another "newbie question" thread and my question relates to OP, I'll post here if you don't mind. ---- I've been collecting my reloading equipment for several months now and finally have what I feel I need to drop my first charge. I'm reloading .223 Rem for a bolt gun. Using once fired WCC brass, CCI BR-4 primers, 69grn HPBT Sierra Matchkings. I bought Varget and H335 and was planning to start with H335 and hold the Varget for later use. The data shows 22grns of H335 as the starting load and 24grns being the max load. I was planning to load 20 rounds each of 22grns and increasing by .5grn to a max to 23.5grns for a starting point. I would be looking for overpressure signs along the way. After I find the load that shoots the best in my rifle, I was planning on increasing/ decreasing the charge by .2grns next than .1grn to fine tune and possibly playing with OAL.


If your starting load is 22 and max load is 23.5, and you go up in 0.5 gr increments you will only have 4 loads to play with. That's too big a spread in my book to efficiently find the sweet spot on a rifle. Those who load for accuracy know that rifles can have several loads that run well in a particular firearm. For example, my AR shoots well with 23.7 gr of Varget and 24. 0.1 gr can and often does make a significant difference so working up loads for accuracy should be done in smaller increments than 0.5 gr.  Since you can find accurate loads at any point, you may as well start with the starting load and work your way up in 0.1 increments otherwise you'll just end up confusing yourself. For example: say you load 22, 22.5, 23 and 23.5 and then find that 22.5 is the most accurate load.  Then you load up a few more above and below that in increments of .2 gr. so you now have a load of 22.3 and 22.8.  As you continue to look for the best load and make fine adjustments, it gets difficult to keep track of that on paper. My suggestion is that if the Start and Max load is only a two grain difference, start with the starting load and then increase it by 0.1 gr.  Take photos of your groupings and then go home to review them and if necessary, take measurements.

20 round for each load is also way too many rounds to efficiently test each load and may be a waste of bullets and powder if the load turns out to be a loser. You should be able to compare loads with just five shots. 

What I do is make a set of five rounds for each load. This gives me a decent grouping to compare and doesn't clutter the target with holes.

Here are sample photos of .223 using Varget and range brass at 50 yards. I started with 23.5 gr. and worked my way up to 24.2 gr. in 0.1 increments, labeling each load with letters A through H.   As you can see, there are definite changes in accuracy when a load is increased/decreased by just 0.1 gr.

(http://i1292.photobucket.com/albums/b569/808Snarfblat/A%20-%20B_zpssezhonbt.jpg)

(http://i1292.photobucket.com/albums/b569/808Snarfblat/IMG_8026_zpsopx3yfjc.jpg)

(http://i1292.photobucket.com/albums/b569/808Snarfblat/IMG_8039_zpsa7n6y4cn.jpg)
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: Inspector on April 19, 2015, 03:04:17 PM
Rather than start another "newbie question" thread and my question relates to OP, I'll post here if you don't mind. ---- I've been collecting my reloading equipment for several months now and finally have what I feel I need to drop my first charge. I'm reloading .223 Rem for a bolt gun. Using once fired WCC brass, CCI BR-4 primers, 69grn HPBT Sierra Matchkings. I bought Varget and H335 and was planning to start with H335 and hold the Varget for later use. The data shows 22grns of H335 as the starting load and 24grns being the max load. I was planning to load 20 rounds each of 22grns and increasing by .5grn to a max to 23.5grns for a starting point. I would be looking for overpressure signs along the way. After I find the load that shoots the best in my rifle, I was planning on increasing/ decreasing the charge by .2grns next than .1grn to fine tune and possibly playing with OAL.

My primary reason to reload is for accuracy but cost is also a major factor. I would like to end up with a load similar to Federal Gold Medal Match as my rifle shoots those really well.

With that in mind, I'm open to your thoughts and suggestions.
I reload with both H335 and Varget and I use 69gr SMK's. For my guns I found that while H335 provided the best accuracy for 65gr bullets and under, Varget provides the best accuracy for heavier bullets. Don't get me wrong, I like H335 and with 64gr Bergers I get one hole for 5 shots at 100yds with my Rem 700 5R. But with any bullet over 65gr that I have tried including 69gr SMK's, Noslers, Hornady's, Barnes, etc all the way to 80gr I get worse results with H335 and better results with Varget. I use 63gr and 65gr Sierra's with H335 and get almost one hole accuracy at 100yds as a plinking round. My Noveske AR loves the Sierra 65gr bullets with H335 as well.

I encourage you to try the H335 in your gun with the 69gr SMK's but don't be afraid to open up that bottle of Varget and try it out. You might see similar results as I do.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: Pit808 on April 19, 2015, 03:05:54 PM
I've never saw that big a difference with 0.1gr change. It would be hard to say it wasn't my shooting that made the difference unless I had weight matched bullets & cases, meticulous brass prep and assembly, no wind, one helluva rest, and monitored barrel temp. I don't see measurable change in accuracy until about 0.3
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: Bushido on April 19, 2015, 07:15:40 PM
Mahalo for the replies all.

Mr Farknocker, very interesting I was not expecting that kind of results from a .1grn increment. Is there any reason why you do your load development at 50yrds instead of 100yrds? My thoughts would be that shooting at 100yrds would tell me more about the load than at 50yrds. As well my thinking was that shooting 2-3 groups of 5 will be a bigger sample than 1 group of 5. My plan was to focus more on the vertical stringing than the horizontal as I work on the load. Hopefully this doesn't come off in the wrong way I'm not doubting you in anyway (sometimes typing can come off wrong), just curious and trying to learn. I'm new to reloading, not to shooting. My setup has shot sub 1/2" at 100yrds with good ammo on a good day. I was thinking that shooting at 50 may have too small of a discernible difference between loads.

Inspector, my plan was to run Varget exclusively as I've read the same experiences you're having online. The problem was that I could only find #1 of Varget and found many of H335. My barrel is a 26" 1/9 and has shot 62grn soft points up to 75grn good. It seems to really like 68 and 69grn the best. I was planning to try some Berger 70 VLDs and Amax 75s down the road. There's been times that 75 HPBTs has shot unbelievable in my rifle and other times the groups looks like shotgun patterns. What twist does your 700 have?
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: Inspector on April 19, 2015, 07:44:50 PM
Mahalo for the replies all.

Mr Farknocker, very interesting I was not expecting that kind of results from a .1grn increment. Is there any reason why you do your load development at 50yrds instead of 100yrds? My thoughts would be that shooting at 100yrds would tell me more about the load than at 50yrds. As well my thinking was that shooting 2-3 groups of 5 will be a bigger sample than 1 group of 5. My plan was to focus more on the vertical stringing than the horizontal as I work on the load. Hopefully this doesn't come off in the wrong way I'm not doubting you in anyway (sometimes typing can come off wrong), just curious and trying to learn. I'm new to reloading, not to shooting. My setup has shot sub 1/2" at 100yrds with good ammo on a good day. I was thinking that shooting at 50 may have too small of a discernible difference between loads.

Inspector, my plan was to run Varget exclusively as I've read the same experiences you're having online. The problem was that I could only find #1 of Varget and found many of H335. My barrel is a 26" 1/9 and has shot 62grn soft points up to 75grn good. It seems to really like 68 and 69grn the best. I was planning to try some Berger 70 VLDs and Amax 75s down the road. There's been times that 75 HPBTs has shot unbelievable in my rifle and other times the groups looks like shotgun patterns. What twist does your 700 have?
My Rem 700 5R is 1 in 9 and does not shoot anything over 69gr or 70gr very well. I have seen keyholing with some 75 and 80gr bullets, but not all. In that weight range mostly VLD's won't stabilize. The sweet spot for my 700 is 63gr-65gr but the 69gr SMK's and 69gr Nosler's are almost as good. My Noveske AR is 1 in 7 and while it does really well with 55gr to 80gr bullets it has a sweet spot of 65gr-70gr. A lot of that might be the inability to load the bullet close to the lands in the AR.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: Inspector on April 19, 2015, 08:05:51 PM
I didn't want to quote Mr Farknocker's post as it is quite large. But to continue with his comments I have found with my reloading and my guns very small amounts of change when using 0.1gr increments. No matter how hard I try I cannot rest my gun steady enough to see a lot of difference. So I use 0.5gr increments to get a base line. And I'll try 0.2gr or 0.3gr increments if I have not reached my goal. But I also stop trying smaller increments if I hit my goal. For instance, as I mentioned a single ragged hole using Varget and 64gr Berger's. I could probably take that a step further and reduce the size of the hole using smaller increments. But I surpassed my goal and I stopped. So it is up to you to try smaller increments if you feel the need to. I also stopped using 0.5gr after using much cheaper Sierra 63gr and 65gr hunting bullets and reaching my goal of 0.5" MOA at 100yds. I am sure I could reduce that some by trying smaller increments.

One thing I also noticed is that starting from the minimum recommended starting load as I worked up in powder charge I see an increase in accuracy. Then after a certain point I see a drop in accuracy. But as I surpass that and approach the maximum recommended load I see an increase in accuracy again. Sometimes the difference between the two points of utmost accuracy using vastly different powder charges is quite minimal.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: whynow? on April 19, 2015, 08:56:52 PM
For the reloaders, how important is it to have a chrono when testing your different loads?
I don't own one and was wondering if the general consensus is that the manuals listed velocity is close enough for your satisfaction .   Difference being barrel, twist, case and primer listed and your own.
For target and defensive purposes does accuracy trump velocity for up to 100 yards?   Just trying to get educated if that sounds like a dumb question.   
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: Bushido on April 19, 2015, 09:06:23 PM
Inspector, Thank you very much for the info. My thoughts were similar in that I was thinking to start course, finish fine. I would be satisfied if I can find a load that produces 1/2 MOA consistently. I will look into the 65s, I have never had the chance to try any. I' ve gone as far as 77s and never experienced any keyholing, but the groups were terrible. I have noticed that AR carbines with a 1:9 does no like the same as a 1:9 bolt. Mine has a long barrel so it may like a slightly different grain than a shorter tube. I shoot a Savage so if and when I change the barrel, I was thinking 1:8 or 1:7 around 22".

If you don't mind me asking, where do you get your Varget? You can PM me if that's better. I only found #1 at WGS and bought that.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: Mr. Farknocker on April 20, 2015, 07:27:07 AM

Mr Farknocker, very interesting I was not expecting that kind of results from a .1grn increment. Is there any reason why you do your load development at 50yrds instead of 100yrds? My thoughts would be that shooting at 100yrds would tell me more about the load than at 50yrds. As well my thinking was that shooting 2-3 groups of 5 will be a bigger sample than 1 group of 5. My plan was to focus more on the vertical stringing than the horizontal as I work on the load. Hopefully this doesn't come off in the wrong way I'm not doubting you in anyway (sometimes typing can come off wrong), just curious and trying to learn. I'm new to reloading, not to shooting. My setup has shot sub 1/2" at 100yrds with good ammo on a good day. I was thinking that shooting at 50 may have too small of a discernible difference between loads.



There are differing thoughts on the optimal distance you should test your loads at. Some say 50 yards is too short and doesn't give the bullet sufficient time to stabilize. Others say that bullet spread at 50 will be worse at 100 so testing at 50 will give you a  "rough cut" of what you can expect at 100 and beyond. For me, I test my AR and iron sight rifles at 50 to get a rough cut of what I can expect at 100, because I can't see far enough at 100 with my irons or close/medium range optics or red dot and because it minimizes the influence wind has on the bullet's trajectory.  I do final testing at 100 and will use 100 for a hunting rifle with optics powerful enough for me to see zero.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: Pit808 on April 20, 2015, 08:20:55 AM
For the reloaders, how important is it to have a chrono when testing your different loads?
I don't own one and was wondering if the general consensus is that the manuals listed velocity is close enough for your satisfaction .   Difference being barrel, twist, case and primer listed and your own.
For target and defensive purposes does accuracy trump velocity for up to 100 yards?   Just trying to get educated if that sounds like a dumb question.

At 100 target shooting  I'd say a Chono isn't that necessary. Just watch for pressure signs. I use one to see where factory ammo is in that particular gun /barrel length as a reference for my reloads. I think it is necessary when shooting distance as you can plug in your numbers to see trajectory for that weapon / load.  For hunting, you will also know what distance your particular bullet hits the fps that it will not expand well.  :shaka:
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: whynow? on April 20, 2015, 09:06:40 AM
At 100 target shooting  I'd say a Chono isn't that necessary. Just watch for pressure signs. I use one to see where factory ammo is in that particular gun /barrel length as a reference for my reloads. I think it is necessary when shooting distance as you can plug in your numbers to see trajectory for that weapon / load.  For hunting, you will also know what distance your particular bullet hits the fps that it will not expand well.  :shaka:
I see your point about getting chrono info to figure trajectory at farther distances, especially since KHSC is only 100 yds.
How far do you place your chrono from your barrel at KHSC?
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: Pit808 on April 20, 2015, 09:58:41 AM
I see your point about getting chrono info to figure trajectory at farther distances, especially since KHSC is only 100 yds.
How far do you place your chrono from your barrel at KHSC?

10ft. At KhSc I go prone on the left side cuz it's flat.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: justin1098 on April 20, 2015, 10:14:14 AM
I see your point about getting chrono info to figure trajectory at farther distances, especially since KHSC is only 100 yds.
How far do you place your chrono from your barrel at KHSC?

Get a magnetospeed, they are on sale right now! You attach it to your barrel so no need to set up a tripod down range and you won't accidentally shoot it.
A chronograph isn't a requiremnet for load development but it helps a lot as you get more data to see what's going on with your loads. If you ever plan to shoot at longer ranges, you will be a bit disappointed when your loads that shoot great at 100 yards are shite at 600 because you have a standard deviation of 100fps.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: whynow? on April 20, 2015, 01:20:03 PM
Get a magnetospeed, they are on sale right now! You attach it to your barrel so no need to set up a tripod down range and you won't accidentally shoot it.
A chronograph isn't a requiremnet for load development but it helps a lot as you get more data to see what's going on with your loads. If you ever plan to shoot at longer ranges, you will be a bit disappointed when your loads that shoot great at 100 yards are shite at 600 because you have a standard deviation of 100fps.

Was looking at it but the price is too high for me.   Midway USA  has discontinued the magnetospeed for some reason.   Thinking about one of the Chrony type with the remote screen and try to go on a sunny, low wind day.  Chrony sells lots of replacement parts which is good if you accidentally blast the posts.
  I use BL(C)-2 (that's what I got from before) and am deciding on a load of 24.4 gr. as it had good grouping at 100 yds with 77 SMK.  Lyman 49th manual lists 24.7 gr, and Hodgdon list 24.9 gr. as max load.   I tried  24.5 gr. but started opening up a little (could have been me).
Not sure how much deviation in velocity 0.3 gr. would make.   But then again like you mentioned, 100 yds. might be good but farther out a different story.
 I use LC brass where manuals list Winchester brass so due to thickness I tend to be more conservative on powder load.   My load development started at 23.0, 23.2, 23.4, 23.6, 23.9, 24.0, 24.2, 24.3, 24.4 and 24.5.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: Inspector on April 20, 2015, 03:59:42 PM
Inspector, Thank you very much for the info. My thoughts were similar in that I was thinking to start course, finish fine. I would be satisfied if I can find a load that produces 1/2 MOA consistently. I will look into the 65s, I have never had the chance to try any. I' ve gone as far as 77s and never experienced any keyholing, but the groups were terrible. I have noticed that AR carbines with a 1:9 does no like the same as a 1:9 bolt. Mine has a long barrel so it may like a slightly different grain than a shorter tube. I shoot a Savage so if and when I change the barrel, I was thinking 1:8 or 1:7 around 22".

If you don't mind me asking, where do you get your Varget? You can PM me if that's better. I only found #1 at WGS and bought that.
I have been using Varget for quite some time. I had purchased 10lbs from OGC when Carter last brought in Varget and Titegroup around 4 years ago. While I was using it up I started buying 1lb bottles any time I saw them at a LGS (YG's, WGS, SEC, etc.). I don't have any where near that much any more but I still have enough to keep me going until powder becomes more available. I would also try J Hara Store as they seem to have a lot of popular powders.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: ren on April 20, 2015, 05:39:29 PM
There is a reason why heavy Sierra bullets such as the 77s and 80s suggest shooting them in 1 in 8 twist barrels or faster on their boxes. Barrel length is not the factor.
(http://www.dillonprecision.com/uimages//22-77mk_m.jpg)
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: whynow? on April 20, 2015, 08:29:24 PM
Get a magnetospeed, they are on sale right now! You attach it to your barrel so no need to set up a tripod down range and you won't accidentally shoot it.
A chronograph isn't a requiremnet for load development but it helps a lot as you get more data to see what's going on with your loads. If you ever plan to shoot at longer ranges, you will be a bit disappointed when your loads that shoot great at 100 yards are shite at 600 because you have a standard deviation of 100fps.

I originally posted that Midway discontinued magnetospeed due to googling this A.M.  However looking at their main site tonight, Midway does still sell the V3 which is on sale for $380 but also sells a sporter version for $179.99.  Right now the sporter is on backorder so I put my name in to be notified.
Looks like the V3 has pc interface options which is above my pay grade anyways.   Never knew about the sporter version but is affordable.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: whynow? on April 20, 2015, 09:06:11 PM
Primary Arms has the magnetospeed sporter on sale for $179 and in stock.  Just ordered one.
Mahalo to Justin for prompting me to look into magnetospeed again.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: justin1098 on April 21, 2015, 07:42:22 AM
You're welcome. Just be ready to answer the "what the hell is that" questions at the range.

I checked the website and you can get the cable to connect the sporter to your phone
http://www.magnetospeed.com/collections/magnetospeed-accessories/products/pre-release-magnetospeed-xfr (http://www.magnetospeed.com/collections/magnetospeed-accessories/products/pre-release-magnetospeed-xfr)

I have the V1 and am thinking about upgrading my display.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: Bushido on April 21, 2015, 06:58:36 PM
There is a reason why heavy Sierra bullets such as the 77s and 80s suggest shooting them in 1 in 8 twist barrels or faster on their boxes. Barrel length is not the factor.

I don't think barrel length is as much a factors as is gas guns vs bolt guns. I do think barrel length has a little to do with it though. F-Class shooter use extremely long tubes to take advantage of the velocity benefits.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: whynow? on April 21, 2015, 10:15:34 PM
There is a reason why heavy Sierra bullets such as the 77s and 80s suggest shooting them in 1 in 8 twist barrels or faster on their boxes. Barrel length is not the factor.
I shoot 77 gr. SMK out of a 18" barrel upper with 1 in 8 twist.  Later will also use my 16" barrel upper with 1/7 twist. 
Title: 556.
Post by: Bushido on April 22, 2015, 12:23:25 PM
whynow? Are you shooting your own loads? Out of magazine?

I have two friends I shoot with both have 1/7 16" carbines. One is a DI the other is a piston. They both seem to top out on 69grn. All factory ammo though
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: Mr. Farknocker on April 22, 2015, 04:30:54 PM
I didn't want to quote Mr Farknocker's post as it is quite large. But to continue with his comments I have found with my reloading and my guns very small amounts of change when using 0.1gr increments. No matter how hard I try I cannot rest my gun steady enough to see a lot of difference.

Speaking of resting your gun...How do you rest your gun when testing loads? What I do for rifles is to rest the stock on a sand bag and prop the buttstock on a sand bag to eliminate the need for user input as far as the position of the rifle is concerned.The rifle is free to move back and forth with the recoil.  I do not shoulder the rifle nor place my left hand (i'm a right handed shooter) on any part of the rifle. If at all possible, I do not place my cheek on the cheek weld and limit the contact of my trigger hand to the trigger only. This is an awkward way of firing the gun but I find that once the rifle is set up pointing toward zero, there's no shaking of the rifle at all. The thinking here is that the less user input there is, the less chance of error there is and the more consistent the shots will be. The results are consistent and I've gotten good results with this technique but I'm not sure if this technique is the best way to go. For one thing, this is not how I normally shoot. Second, I'm aware of the role harmonics play in testing loads so if the rifle is not engaged in the manner that it's intended to be shot when loads are tested, the rifle may shoot differently when the rifle is actually held and shot the way it was intended to be shot. How do you fire your rifles when testing your loads?
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: Inspector on April 22, 2015, 05:01:01 PM
Speaking of resting your gun...How do you rest your gun when testing loads? What I do for rifles is to rest the stock on a sand bag and prop the buttstock on a sand bag to eliminate the need for user input as far as the position of the rifle is concerned.The rifle is free to move back and forth with the recoil.  I do not shoulder the rifle nor place my left hand (i'm a right handed shooter) on any part of the rifle. If at all possible, I do not place my cheek on the cheek weld and limit the contact of my trigger hand to the trigger only. This is an awkward way of firing the gun but I find that once the rifle is set up pointing toward zero, there's no shaking of the rifle at all. The thinking here is that the less user input there is, the less chance of error there is and the more consistent the shots will be. The results are consistent and I've gotten good results with this technique but I'm not sure if this technique is the best way to go. For one thing, this is not how I normally shoot. Second, I'm aware of the role harmonics play in testing loads so if the rifle is not engaged in the manner that it's intended to be shot when loads are tested, the rifle may shoot differently when the rifle is actually held and shot the way it was intended to be shot. How do you fire your rifles when testing your loads?
I do something similar to you. I use a Harris Bipod on the front. Harris Bipods are quite stable. I have not found another bipod as solid and stiff as a Harris. I bring some wood shims to put under one of the feet if the rifle needs leveling. Some benches are pretty good but others are terrible. I have a nice Protektor leather sand bag with ears I bought off eBay. The ears fit the contour of my stock pretty good. I move the bag back and forth to get sighted in vertically. I place my shoulder close but not touching the stock. I don't touch the stock with my left hand. I try not to put any undo pressure in any direction on the stock. I do try and place a light cheek weld. Take a deep breath and let half of it out and slowly squeeze the trigger. Hopefully not on a windy day. I don't know if this is the right or wrong way to do it. I just know it works pretty well as I get pretty consistent shots. I am aware of the harmonics of the barrel being different depending on how the rifle is shot. All I do after I choose a load is I sight in the scope to POA. I have not noticed much of a difference at 100yds due to different dynamics though I am sure it will make a huge difference at longer distances. I have a slightly different approach for my AR's as I found it didn't make much difference how I held it steady. As long as it is steady.

I could be wrong but I think consistency is more important than form. If you can be consistent doing it your way then that is the correct way to do it. I guess I could buy a Led Sled but it is more more thing to carry and I am not sure it is worth it for me at this time.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: whynow? on April 22, 2015, 06:21:36 PM
whynow? Are you shooting your own loads? Out of magazine?

I have two friends I shoot with both have 1/7 16" carbines. One is a DI the other is a piston. They both seem to top out on 69grn. All factory ammo though
I have shot my reloads of 77SMK from a 1/8 AR loaded thru NHMTG and Colt mags and fed/fired properly.   I try to aim for 2.250" but due to differences in the Sierra bullet tip (above the ogive)  I get from 2.247" to 2.252" in my reloads.
Before loading my own, I fired factory Hornady 75gr. BTHP and Fed Premium 77 SMK with no issues.   Also before making live rounds, I made some dummies and they cycled thru the 1/8 then proceeded to load actual rounds.
I have not fired my reloads or tried my dummy rounds with similar COL thru the 1/7 AR yet, which is why I said I'll try later on. 
 I did not know that anything over 69 gr. will not feed properly  in 16" 1/7 carbines or midlengths.
I'll try to cycle the dummy rounds thru the 16" to see.  If they hang up then will just stick to the 1/8 upper.   Just started reloading for the .223 so I move slowly and ask questions to learn.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: ren on April 22, 2015, 07:59:50 PM
These loads especially the RL15 powder data are tried and have produced excellent results from my experience.
http://www.whiteoakprecision.com/info-reloading.htm (http://www.whiteoakprecision.com/info-reloading.htm)

I have read many great results with 77 SMKs with 24.0 RL15, LC cases and with a Rem 7 1/2 primer. It is my benchmark load. I've tried over and under this load with no appreciable gains. I always come back to this load. I have had many close cleans at 200 and 300 yards - if I can only shoot it better. I've used 1x7 and 1x8 barrels Wilsons cut by White Oak - same results - flash hider or without - same. I have a Shilen 1x7 barrel that I have next in line to rebarrel, maybe for Camp Perry this year?! I don;t expect anything less.

Our club has a practice day at Puuloa this Sunday - welcome to try out your loads at 200 yards and beyond. For more info check out the events section or www.puuloa.com (http://www.puuloa.com)
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: Heavies on April 22, 2015, 08:09:32 PM
I am entering late into this thread, but I think that interjecting OCW method of load development will save you a lot of time and money when you are looking for a good load.  You can use this process to find an optimum charge, then fine tune to your OCDs desire.  It has worked for me for many years and uses the least amount of powder, components, and range trips.  Also to add the proceedure has been proven to me in match and competition.   Any errors in shooting are produced by me.  I am that confident in the load and this particular load devolopment process.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: whynow? on April 23, 2015, 12:00:39 PM
whynow? Are you shooting your own loads? Out of magazine?

I have two friends I shoot with both have 1/7 16" carbines. One is a DI the other is a piston. They both seem to top out on 69grn. All factory ammo though
Today tested my dummy 77 SMK rounds on a BCM 16" midlength and a LE6920 carbine gas length 16".   Used a Colt, Magpul, NHMTG, DH and Center Ind. mags.  Dummies were all between 2.248" and 2.252" with one at 2.254".   They all were checked in a Wilson case gage and all cases trimmed to 1.750".  All dummies fit in mags, functioned properly, went in battery, ejected and fed next round in the BCM and LE6920.  Only for the DH mag took little more effort to load for some reason.
After the test I re-measured the COL and most dummies had increase of .004" and one was at 2.269" (rechecked with 2 calipers).   As said never noticed any problems so I don't know when that dummy went to 2.269".  Manuals list the max for mag length at 2.260".  Later although the tip touching the side I was able to load into the Colt mag.  I might be wrong but think that after cycling each dummy 10 times  maybe inertia pulled the bullet out like using a bullet puller.   ALL were FL sized and seated with the same dies and I used a factory Fed Premium round to set the seating die to get in the ballpark.   Don't know if this is a good method but was recommended on several articles.  None of my dummies or live rounds were crimped just neck tension.  Maybe need to look into a very light crimp although no cannelure.   Trying to get some with cannelure to try out.

Also I noticed after testing that all bullets had scratches or small nicks.  Don't know if this is normal for amount of times cycling or this may be a warning of headspace? issues.
This test only shows that the dummies cycled properly and I don't know if my reloads or factory ammo will do the same but I'll try it later at the range.  Right now I'm using it for the BCM 18" upper with rifle length gas system and have shot about 80 reloads with it.   As stated I'm a novice reloader and welcome any improvements or criticism to what I'm doing.  Safety first over a bruised ego if I'm doing wrong.   Only reason why I started reloading 77 SMK was not wanting to pay $30 a box of 20.

Bushido, what kind of issues did your friends have ?  Later I also plan to try some 69 SMK.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: whynow? on April 23, 2015, 12:03:22 PM
These loads especially the RL15 powder data are tried and have produced excellent results from my experience.
http://www.whiteoakprecision.com/info-reloading.htm (http://www.whiteoakprecision.com/info-reloading.htm)

Our club has a practice day at Puuloa this Sunday - welcome to try out your loads at 200 yards and beyond. For more info check out the events section or www.puuloa.com (http://www.puuloa.com)
Ren, don't know if directed to me or all commenters but thanks for the offer.
Title: 556.
Post by: Bushido on April 23, 2015, 12:26:08 PM
whynow? I've read that the heavier longer bullets may have difficulty feeding out of some AR mags. I was just wondering if yours were experiencing the same.

My friends ARs, both 1/7s, just didn't seem to shoot the 75s well. Seems to like 68s and 69s. They haven't had the chance to shoot many brands yet. I bought a box of PPU 75grn from WGS for $17/20. They shot really good in my rifle. I went back and bought a few more boxes. I will let them try a few of those.

Heavies, found a long read about OCW. Will read when I have time. Thank you as well as all who have replied.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: ren on April 23, 2015, 05:02:36 PM
All the variables you are experimenting with have been done before with the 77 SMKs. no crimp or crimp = no difference. I tried seating them out to touch the lands once at 600 yards and found nothing different. Seat at mag length, dumped 24.0 RL15 in a Remington 71/2 primed case - done. I then go shoot. All that is done on a Dillon 550. I cut my cases with a Giraud TriWay and sized it before with a RCBS XDie on a Lee press. Nothing special. Shoots like Black Hills ammo.
If you are chasing benchrest results - then have at it. If you are looking at trying VLDs then you have a lot to play with, but with 77 SMKs the loads are pretty much proven by shooters with a lot of interest in results.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: whynow? on April 23, 2015, 07:59:00 PM
whynow? I've read that the heavier longer bullets may have difficulty feeding out of some AR mags. I was just wondering if yours were experiencing the same.

My friends ARs, both 1/7s, just didn't seem to shoot the 75s well. Seems to like 68s and 69s. They haven't had the chance to shoot many brands yet. I bought a box of PPU 75grn from WGS for $17/20. They shot really good in my rifle. I went back and bought a few more boxes. I will let them try a few of those.
I thought you meant anything over 69 gr. rounds did not cycle in your friends ARs, my bad.  The Lyman manual has longer than mag length OAL for 80 gr HPBT, 75 gr. Hornady A-max and there maybe others. 
Is the PPU round dirty or not bad?  That sounds like a decent price for 75 gr. .223, better than $30/box of 20.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: whynow? on April 23, 2015, 08:06:38 PM
If you are chasing benchrest results - then have at it. If you are looking at trying VLDs then you have a lot to play with, but with 77 SMKs the loads are pretty much proven by shooters with a lot of interest in results.
Basically I'm just  trying to get the best results using 77 gr. SMK with the powder I got .   
Will probably just stick to Sierra MK instead of trying VLD type.  Thanks.
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: Bushido on April 24, 2015, 09:07:17 PM
I thought you meant anything over 69 gr. rounds did not cycle in your friends ARs, my bad.  The Lyman manual has longer than mag length OAL for 80 gr HPBT, 75 gr. Hornady A-max and there maybe others. 
Is the PPU round dirty or not bad?  That sounds like a decent price for 75 gr. .223, better than $30/box of 20.

Sorry about that. Reading my post I can see how that was comprehended. Both are fairly new guns to the owners so they are still seeing what it likes. I shoot a bolt gun in a AICS style DBM so depending on which magazine I choose, my COAL can be very generous feeding out of the magazine.

I didn't notice any abnormal carbon or copper buildiup with the PPU. That's "Match grade" ammo too. I was surprised at how well it shot our of my riffle. He had some reloaded 80grns but passed on those,
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: Bushido on April 24, 2015, 09:10:18 PM
Basically I'm just  trying to get the best results using 77 gr. SMK with the powder I got .   
Will probably just stick to Sierra MK instead of trying VLD type.  Thanks.

Any particular reason? I've read good things about SMKs and VLDs. I just haven't got a chance to try the VLDs
Title: Re: 556.
Post by: whynow? on April 24, 2015, 10:02:49 PM
Any particular reason? I've read good things about SMKs and VLDs. I just haven't got a chance to try the VLDs
The only reason for me is I"m new to reloading and don't want to get confused about getting into a lot of different things.   That's the way I look at it and take my time and in no rush since I retired.  People probably get fantastic results with VLD bullets and they have many good reviews.
 Some have long lengths and I only have semi auto .223/5.56 rifles and don't plan on getting a bolt rifle in .223.  I use a 3X9X40 scope and don't plan on long range stuff.  Things may change later but as Larry Potterfield says " and that's the way it is".
So to answer your question it's how I see things nothing wrong with VLD bullets.  Good luck.