2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: SpeedTek on March 17, 2015, 09:04:31 PM

Title: Now that the M855 Ban has redirected! BBQ's are next!
Post by: SpeedTek on March 17, 2015, 09:04:31 PM
Obama's EPA now going after your BBQ emissions! and your meat smokers too!

http://www.thefederalistpapers.org/us/backyard-barbecues-and-smokers-in-danger-from-epa-regulators (http://www.thefederalistpapers.org/us/backyard-barbecues-and-smokers-in-danger-from-epa-regulators)

I suspect they will go after gunpowder emissions soon also!
Title: Re: Now that the M855 Ban has redirected! BBQ's are next!
Post by: edster48 on March 18, 2015, 05:23:07 AM
This just proves there is nothing that they won't try to regulate. The idiocy of this is staggering. What about all those pollutant spewing cooking fires in 3rd world countries? SMH
Title: Re: Now that the M855 Ban has redirected! BBQ's are next!
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 18, 2015, 08:42:55 PM
Hmm, gonna reserve judgement for now until I see what their actual proposals are. It is conceivable that they come up with a regulation or suggestion that makes sense so I will wait for updates.
Title: Re: Now that the M855 Ban has redirected! BBQ's are next!
Post by: mauidog on March 18, 2015, 09:30:03 PM
Hmm, gonna reserve judgement for now until I see what their actual proposals are. It is conceivable that they come up with a regulation or suggestion that makes sense so I will wait for updates.

Why do I have a suspicion you'd be much happier living in New York City?

Everything they pass laws against "makes sense." 

No sodas over 16 oz (Sugary Drinks Portion Cap Rule),
tobacco laws are extremely strict and cigarette taxes are the highest in the country,
regulating sodium and trans fats,
one of the strictest gun law states in the US,
and so on.

Everything the New York law makers and former Mayor Bloomberg did was in the best interest of their residents.  Better health, safer streets, fewer tobacco-related health problems ... it all just "makes sense."

If you think it's government's role to tell us what we can and cannot do based on a politician's idea of what "makes sense," then that's your prerogative.  The EPA has no business spending tax money to study something that they have no business regulating.  The expansion of the EPA's power is amazingly scary.  All they have to do to shutdown a business or bankrupt a homeowner is pass a new law that makes something they have done for years suddenly illegal.

The problem with the laws Congress makes is, they always seem to cost the very people they are "helping" the most money.
Title: Re: Now that the M855 Ban has redirected! BBQ's are next!
Post by: punaperson on March 19, 2015, 06:16:49 AM
Why do I have a suspicion you'd be much happier living in New York City?

Everything they pass laws against "makes sense." 

No sodas over 16 oz (Sugary Drinks Portion Cap Rule),
tobacco laws are extremely strict and cigarette taxes are the highest in the country,
regulating sodium and trans fats,
one of the strictest gun law states in the US,
and so on.

Everything the New York law makers and former Mayor Bloomberg did was in the best interest of their residents.  Better health, safer streets, fewer tobacco-related health problems ... it all just "makes sense."

If you think it's government's role to tell us what we can and cannot do based on a politician's idea of what "makes sense," then that's your prerogative.  The EPA has no business spending tax money to study something that they have no business regulating.  The expansion of the EPA's power is amazingly scary.  All they have to do to shutdown a business or bankrupt a homeowner is pass a new law that makes something they have done for years suddenly illegal.

The problem with the laws Congress makes is, they always seem to cost the very people they are "helping" the most money.
Now now mauidog, there you go again ranting, this time against "common sense environmental and health safety regulations". Next thing we know you'll be ranting against "common sense gun safety regulations" like minimum 14 day waiting periods (even for people who already own guns), 10 round magazine limits, "assault pistol" bans, full registration with fingerprinting and relinquishing medical information privacy rights, etc. Why would you want police officers to be harmed by 11 round magazines? Or something.
Title: Re: Now that the M855 Ban has redirected! BBQ's are next!
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 21, 2015, 08:58:27 PM
Why do I have a suspicion you'd be much happier living in New York City?

Everything they pass laws against "makes sense." 

No sodas over 16 oz (Sugary Drinks Portion Cap Rule),
tobacco laws are extremely strict and cigarette taxes are the highest in the country,
regulating sodium and trans fats,
one of the strictest gun law states in the US,
and so on.

Everything the New York law makers and former Mayor Bloomberg did was in the best interest of their residents.  Better health, safer streets, fewer tobacco-related health problems ... it all just "makes sense."

If you think it's government's role to tell us what we can and cannot do based on a politician's idea of what "makes sense," then that's your prerogative.  The EPA has no business spending tax money to study something that they have no business regulating.  The expansion of the EPA's power is amazingly scary.  All they have to do to shutdown a business or bankrupt a homeowner is pass a new law that makes something they have done for years suddenly illegal.

The problem with the laws Congress makes is, they always seem to cost the very people they are "helping" the most money.

Still I will reserve judgement. Lets just say that hypothetically they found a serious side effect to grilling. Perhaps some dangerous chemical came out of charcoal or whatever, wouldn't you at least want to know? Studying the issue does not necessarily mean that some regulation will come out of it, it is possible that just a health advisory is given. Perhaps some scientists somewhere know a lot more on the subject about me and they have a good reason to want to study the effects of grilling. Unfortunately the article doesn't seem to go into detail there. I notice people often complain about stuff that sounds stupid to them when in reality there there is a decent reason they just didn't know about, thus I reserve judgement for now.
Title: Re: Now that the M855 Ban has redirected! BBQ's are next!
Post by: ren on March 21, 2015, 09:03:25 PM
Its amusing to think that the Army developed M855A1 for environmental reasons.....
Title: Re: Now that the M855 Ban has redirected! BBQ's are next!
Post by: mauidog on March 21, 2015, 09:26:14 PM
Still I will reserve judgement. Lets just say that hypothetically they found a serious side effect to grilling. Perhaps some dangerous chemical came out of charcoal or whatever, wouldn't you at least want to know? Studying the issue does not necessarily mean that some regulation will come out of it, it is possible that just a health advisory is given. Perhaps some scientists somewhere know a lot more on the subject about me and they have a good reason to want to study the effects of grilling. Unfortunately the article doesn't seem to go into detail there. I notice people often complain about stuff that sounds stupid to them when in reality there there is a decent reason they just didn't know about, thus I reserve judgement for now.

That study came out in the 80s -- grilling with charcoal or wood adds carcinogens to your food when cooked.

Quote
... cooking meat at the high temperatures you use to grill—as well as broil and fry—creates heterocyclic amines (HCAs) and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), compounds linked with some cancers.

Animal and laboratory studies suggest that HCAs may damage DNA and spur the development of tumors in cells of the colon, breast, prostate and lymph system. At temperatures of 350°F and hotter, amino acids and creatine (a natural compound that helps supply energy to muscles and nerves) react to form HCAs. PAHs form when fat drips onto hot coals, creating smoke that settles on food; these compounds have been associated with increased risk of breast cancer.

But "within the big picture of cancer prevention, there are much greater risks than grilling," says Colleen Doyle, M.S., R.D., director of Nutrition and Physical Activity for the American Cancer Society. For example, "if you’re 30 pounds overweight, that puts you at much greater risk for developing a number of cancers [than does eating grilled meats]."

Many use propane now, which allows better control over the temperature while cooking.  I believe most opt for propane out of convenience and reduced prep, heating, and cleanup time.  Those who prefer the flavor of a chargrilled entree have continued to use that method. 

In other words, even with this information, I haven't seen anyone pushing to regulate or control the grills we use to make us healthier.  While the studies might provide useful information, we need to leave that to the medical industry and CDC, not the EPA who only wants to increase their oppressive power over things they should not.
Title: Re: Now that the M855 Ban has redirected! BBQ's are next!
Post by: robtmc on March 22, 2015, 10:58:18 AM
Many use propane now, which allows better control over the temperature while cooking.  I believe most opt for propane out of convenience and reduced prep, heating, and cleanup time.

But, but, but.  Your meat sends off dangerous pollutants when it flares up and smokes.  Scientists are hard at work devising catalytic converters for your Charbroil as we speak.

Alter all, it is reasonable, and for the chirruns.....
Title: Re: Now that the M855 Ban has redirected! BBQ's are next!
Post by: mauidog on March 22, 2015, 11:04:39 AM
But, but, but.  Your meat sends off dangerous pollutants when it flares up and smokes.  Scientists are hard at work devising catalytic converters for your Charbroil as we speak.

Alter all, it is reasonable, and for the chirruns.....
You left out "common sense", and eyeeatingfish's favorite .... "rational" !!    :crazy:
Title: Re: Now that the M855 Ban has redirected! BBQ's are next!
Post by: mauidog on March 22, 2015, 01:19:44 PM
EPA's Wood-Burning Stove Ban Has Chilling Consequences For Many Rural People

Quote
This is but another example of EPA and other government agencies working with activist environmental groups to sue and settle on claims that afford leverage to enact new regulations which they lack statutory authority to otherwise accomplish.

“Sue and settle “ practices, sometimes referred to as “friendly lawsuits”, are cozy deals through which far-left radical environmental groups file lawsuits against federal agencies wherein  court-ordered “consent decrees” are issued based upon a prearranged settlement agreement they collaboratively craft together in advance behind closed doors. Then, rather than allowing the entire process to play out, the agency being sued settles the lawsuit by agreeing to move forward with the requested action both they and the litigants want.

And who pays for this litigation? All-too-often we taxpayers are put on the hook for legal fees of both colluding parties. According to a 2011 GAO report, this amounted to millions of dollars awarded to environmental organizations for EPA litigations between 1995 and 2010. Three “Big Green” groups received 41% of this payback, with Earthjustice accounting for 30 percent ($4,655,425).  Two other organizations with histories of lobbying for regulations EPA wants while also receiving agency funding are the American Lung Association (ALA) and the Sierra Club.

In addition, the Department of Justice forked over at least $43 million of our money defending EPA in court between 1998 and 2010. This didn’t include money spent by EPA for their legal costs in connection with those rip-offs because EPA doesn’t keep track of their attorney’s time on a case-by-case basis.

The U.S. Chamber of Commerce has concluded that Sue and Settle rulemaking is responsible for many of EPA’s “most controversial, economically significant regulations that have plagued the business community for the past few years”. Included are regulations on power plants, refineries, mining operations, cement plants, chemical manufacturers, and a host of other industries. Such consent decree-based rulemaking enables EPA to argue to Congress: “The court made us do it.”


http://www.forbes.com/sites/larrybell/2014/01/29/epas-wood-burning-stove-ban-has-chilling-consequences-for-many-rural-people/ (http://www.forbes.com/sites/larrybell/2014/01/29/epas-wood-burning-stove-ban-has-chilling-consequences-for-many-rural-people/)
Title: Re: Now that the M855 Ban has redirected! BBQ's are next!
Post by: mauidog on March 22, 2015, 01:24:53 PM
http://conservative50plus.com/blog/just-in-time-for-summer-obamas-epa-to-go-after-your-bbq/ (http://conservative50plus.com/blog/just-in-time-for-summer-obamas-epa-to-go-after-your-bbq/)
Title: Re: Now that the M855 Ban has redirected! BBQ's are next!
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 22, 2015, 09:44:42 PM
In other words, even with this information, I haven't seen anyone pushing to regulate or control the grills we use to make us healthier.  While the studies might provide useful information, we need to leave that to the medical industry and CDC, not the EPA who only wants to increase their oppressive power over things they should not.

That is a very good point, it would not be their job to go after health related issues. I just hesitated to jump onto some issue because someone framed the topic in some emotional crazy sounding thing. We all know asbestos is harmful now but certainly when the government first started looking at banning it as  household construction material someone could have framed the issue as being the government just wants to enter your home to regulate your popcorn ceiling! It would sound absurd but we all now know there is a good reason.

Now the EPA's job is pollution and in that sense it might be possible that they could make an argument about wood grilling causing more pollution. The question I guess is at what point do we step in and draw a line for allowable pollution? Even if man made global warming is completely false we still know that humans can make the air polluted. Ever seen photos of Hong Kong with so much air pollution the air looks disgusting? I would think BBQ is a pretty small culprit in such a thing but I admit I might be wrong. I certainly have no idea how many people BBQ how often and how much air pollution that causes.
Title: Re: Now that the M855 Ban has redirected! BBQ's are next!
Post by: mauidog on March 22, 2015, 10:59:00 PM
That is a very good point, it would not be their job to go after health related issues. I just hesitated to jump onto some issue because someone framed the topic in some emotional crazy sounding thing. We all know asbestos is harmful now but certainly when the government first started looking at banning it as  household construction material someone could have framed the issue as being the government just wants to enter your home to regulate your popcorn ceiling! It would sound absurd but we all now know there is a good reason.

Now the EPA's job is pollution and in that sense it might be possible that they could make an argument about wood grilling causing more pollution. The question I guess is at what point do we step in and draw a line for allowable pollution? Even if man made global warming is completely false we still know that humans can make the air polluted. Ever seen photos of Hong Kong with so much air pollution the air looks disgusting? I would think BBQ is a pretty small culprit in such a thing but I admit I might be wrong. I certainly have no idea how many people BBQ how often and how much air pollution that causes.

You didn't watch the video in the link I posted.

http://conservative50plus.com/blog/just-in-time-for-summer-obamas-epa-to-go-after-your-bbq/ (http://conservative50plus.com/blog/just-in-time-for-summer-obamas-epa-to-go-after-your-bbq/)
Title: Re: Now that the M855 Ban has redirected! BBQ's are next!
Post by: kekoa on March 23, 2015, 01:55:39 PM
This has already been attempted here on Kauai. They say a ban on chimney smoke but it extended to smokers, grill and even dust you create as you work in your yard. i.e. mowing the freakin' yard :shake:
http://thegardenisland.com/news/local/airing-their-grievances/article_e553c0ac-9aec-11e4-be0f-1767384e53d3.html (http://thegardenisland.com/news/local/airing-their-grievances/article_e553c0ac-9aec-11e4-be0f-1767384e53d3.html)
Title: Re: Now that the M855 Ban has redirected! BBQ's are next!
Post by: eyeeatingfish on March 24, 2015, 04:41:50 PM
You didn't watch the video in the link I posted.

http://conservative50plus.com/blog/just-in-time-for-summer-obamas-epa-to-go-after-your-bbq/ (http://conservative50plus.com/blog/just-in-time-for-summer-obamas-epa-to-go-after-your-bbq/)

The video wasn't working for me. I am just sort of pondering the issue of where to draw the line. I think that if every family BBQ food every day you would have a significant amount of air pollution. Obviously that is not the case but as populations get more dense and air pollution gets worse people are going to try and look to see what can be done to reduce the pollution which has become a serious problem in some cities.
Title: Re: Now that the M855 Ban has redirected! BBQ's are next!
Post by: mauidog on March 24, 2015, 08:56:12 PM
The video wasn't working for me. I am just sort of pondering the issue of where to draw the line. I think that if every family BBQ food every day you would have a significant amount of air pollution. Obviously that is not the case but as populations get more dense and air pollution gets worse people are going to try and look to see what can be done to reduce the pollution which has become a serious problem in some cities.

Try YouTube.....

https://youtu.be/E6jQsI8ieIk