2aHawaii

General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: colorado_shooter_dh on August 30, 2011, 05:53:52 PM

Title: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: colorado_shooter_dh on August 30, 2011, 05:53:52 PM
I was thinking about this and wondered if the lawsuit is passed and permits are issued, as they should per our constituional rights... I wonder how much hassle would be in store for anyone carrying one? If the legislation and law enforcement is so adamantly against this, and it gets passed, wouldn't it be kinda ugly even getting pulled over for speeding or something? Back in Colorado, they "say" that law enforcement do NOT know about this but I know for a fact they do - I have many friends in law enforcement who say there is definitely an indicator on your record when they bring it up, even on the side of the road. I would bet if you had one and got pulled over they would know..... thoughts?
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: BananaClip on August 30, 2011, 06:04:05 PM
I gotta say it would be awesome knowing I can "actually" protect my family as well as myself without explaining that the baseball bat and mit "in the trunk" is for baseball and not for "protection"....pretty lame....   :thumbsup:
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: colorado_shooter_dh on August 30, 2011, 06:19:51 PM
That is a definite given... but missing my point. I am simply contemplating the reaction by our beloved HPD and contemporaries.
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: 2aHawaii on August 30, 2011, 06:24:02 PM
In many states there are indicators marking if you are licensed to carry or not. Some will pull it up with your drivers license and some will pull it up with your license plates. But that's all it should be. Any harassment because of that shouldn't be allowed. Not to say it won't be at first, but it would be bad for the state and the police if they start harassing carriers. Someone will be bound to pull a lawsuit for rights violations. It seems like a pretty easy win.

I think that the biggest thing would be "confining" a firearm during a stop. Even then, I think that would have to be defined as to whether it will pass snuff.
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: antoinebugleboy on August 30, 2011, 06:46:53 PM
I'd probably get one so I can get guns without the hassle (I'm assuming this would be the case.), but I would have to submit to a lot of training before I'd feel comfortable carrying daily. I tend to stick my nose into things (helping breaking up a fight, steering drunk, passed-out old men to their homes, etc.), so I'd want to know that I wouldn't get myself into trouble.

Given the low crime level here in Hawaii, and the fact that I generally stick to the safer parts of town, I don't feel threatened enough to feel I need to carry, anyway.
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: vooduchikn on August 30, 2011, 06:58:47 PM
I'd probably get one so I can get guns without the hassle (I'm assuming this would be the case.), but I would have to submit to a lot of training before I'd feel comfortable carrying daily. I tend to stick my nose into things (helping breaking up a fight, steering drunk, passed-out old men to their homes, etc.), so I'd want to know that I wouldn't get myself into trouble.

Given the low REPORTED crime level here in Hawaii, and the fact that I generally stick to the safer parts of town, I don't feel threatened enough to feel I need to carry, anyway.

FTFY.  Vicious crimes happen hourly that never make the news.

I carry on the mainland.  I used to be that guy that would try to break up a fight, negotiate with drunken idiots in an attempt to de-escalate a situation. Since carrying, I stopped this behavior and I don't even do it now unless it is directly aimed at me (rare).

When you carry, these actions can lead you down a road that ends in someone seriously injured or dead and you in steel bracelets. These are the situations that the antis think will happen on a routine basis. Fact is, they do not.

If you are one to get into business that is not your own, then don't carry at places this may happen. I do not mean to lecture, but carrying is a mindset and a lifestyle, not as simple as carrying a pocketknife.

As far as signs. There are rules with the signs. Take Georgia for example. They can have a sign, but who's to say you saw it or can even read. And if you are carrying concealed...who is going to know but you?


Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: colorado_shooter_dh on August 30, 2011, 07:16:15 PM
I guess I'm just excited... I got the email regarding the lawsuit, and my usual mental picking apart the issue began. Believe me - I would be in line immediately for CCW here, regardless. Yes, I would imagine a harrassment suit would be in order, but you know how that goes. Law enforcement likes a very, very passive population.
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: vooduchikn on August 30, 2011, 07:20:42 PM
I guess I'm just excited... I got the email regarding the lawsuit, and my usual mental picking apart the issue began. Believe me - I would be in line immediately for CCW here, regardless. Yes, I would imagine a harrassment suit would be in order, but you know how that goes. Law enforcement likes a very, very passive population.

This state would do well to mimic other states laws and go with it. Georgia has good gun laws and a city the size of Oahu. No shootouts on the streets at high noon by GWL holders.  Texas the same, and the list goes on.

The state is suppressing a constitutional right while missing out on a revenue and job creation all at once.

AMAZING!
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: kong on August 30, 2011, 07:42:09 PM
I know when I had my WA CPL and worked at a local range we taught that when the Officer comes to the window asking for the requisite license, registration and proof of insurance you also hand them your CPL for their situational awareness.  I never did get pulled over while CCW so I do not have any first hand knowledge.  Though this thread is a little like putting the cart before the horse.
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: vooduchikn on August 30, 2011, 08:19:28 PM
I know when I had my WA CPL and worked at a local range we taught that when the Officer comes to the window asking for the requisite license, registration and proof of insurance you also hand them your CPL for their situational awareness.  I never did get pulled over while CCW so I do not have any first hand knowledge.  Though this thread is a little like putting the cart before the horse.
Kong. It depends on the states laws. Some are a notification state, some are not. Best to take into account laws that already WORK instead of re-inventing the wheel.

The horse, the cart....this is important.

You have to ask how we ended up with nonsensical regulations in the first place.
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: Kingkeoni on August 30, 2011, 08:44:50 PM
I would definitely be in line to acquire a CCW permit, as should all of you.

If we are "granted" our constitutional right to bear arms and no one gets permits, the powers that be will point out how they should not have allowed concealed carry.

Initially, the Gestapo err I mean police will go on a propaganda rampage, telling the sheep how this new law will mean gunfights in the streets and people pulling guns on everyone that doesn't smile at them.

They will also try and "bait" and entrap law abiding citizens into violations, especially if the law is written in the confusing manner at the rest of our laws are.

Once the hoopla dies down, we will be able to feel secure that the predators of the world no longer have the upper hand when it comes to personal safety.

Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: vooduchikn on August 30, 2011, 09:08:18 PM
I would definitely be in line to acquire a CCW permit, as should all of you.

If we are "granted" our constitutional right to bear arms and no one gets permits, the powers that will point out how they should not have allowed concealed carry.

Initially, the Gestapo err I mean police will go on a propaganda rampage, telling the sheep how this new law will mean gunfights in the streets and people pulling guns on everyone that doesn't smile at them.

They will also try and "bait" and entrap law abiding citizens into violations, especially if the law is written in the confusing manner at the rest of our laws are.

Once the hoopla dies down, we will be able to feel secure that the predators of the world no longer have the upper hand when it comes to personal safety.

good post.
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: Cougar8045 on August 30, 2011, 10:12:19 PM
I know when I had my WA CPL and worked at a local range we taught that when the Officer comes to the window asking for the requisite license, registration and proof of insurance you also hand them your CPL for their situational awareness.  I never did get pulled over while CCW so I do not have any first hand knowledge.  Though this thread is a little like putting the cart before the horse.
Kong. It depends on the states laws. Some are a notification state, some are not. Best to take into account laws that already WORK instead of re-inventing the wheel.

The horse, the cart....this is important.

You have to ask how we ended up with nonsensical regulations in the first place.
Letting the officer know you're carrying seems like a good idea, even if it's not required.  I'd hate to reach for the glove box to get my registration and *oops*, shirt rode up.  Now we're getting proned out on the median, blah, blah, blah.  Of course, in Hawaii, that might happen anyway as soon as you tell them, "Officer, I am a CCW permit holder and I'm carrying my firearm."  I don't know, but I like to ponder the wonderful day when we can all go stand in line for our CCW's.  Horse, cart, who cares?  It's going to take years anyway; we might as well fantasize about how awesome it's going to be.
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: Old Guy on August 30, 2011, 10:17:03 PM
This whole thing will get interesting very fast when HPD pulls over a woman with a permit.

Especially if the firearm is in a "gun purse" and she has to get her paper work.

A lot of guys who are Not instructors or Range Officers have a "problems" so to speak when dealing with

a woman who is very competant with firearms.

I've had one IPSC RO get a little flustered when my Wife ran his stage.  Hopefully, things are waaay different today.

given that many HPD officers are Not gun people, when they stop a person with a CCW and they have to "secure" a

firearm that they have no knowledge on handling/function, interesting things may hapen.

Personally, I'm all for letting LEO know that I'm legally carrying and letting him/her take it from there.

More interesting when LEO discovers a lot of people are carrying bigger, heavier calibers than they are.
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: Funtimes on August 31, 2011, 01:19:34 AM
Let us just say that, especially *when* the laws go into effect, that if you are not carrying with a video  and audio recording device, you are screwing yourselves big time.
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: kaneohegrown on August 31, 2011, 08:39:14 AM
Let us just say that, especially *when* the laws go into effect, that if you are not carrying with a video  and audio recording device, you are screwing yourselves big time.

Beat me to it. Just hit your cell phone video camera button and let it record everything that happens during the stop (or at least catch audio). Just a good CYA precaution for anyone in a situation where you feel LE's may try to take advantage.

As for to carry or not to carry, my take is like wearing my motorcycle helmet. Statistically speaking, a 5 mile ride down the road is the "most" dangerous time to be on a bike. So even though I'm just riding to the store down the block, I always wear my helmet. Because if that "one" time I'm going to get in an accident is on that ride, I better be prepared... :thumbsup:
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: vooduchikn on August 31, 2011, 10:53:52 AM
Let us just say that, especially *when* the laws go into effect, that if you are not carrying with a video  and audio recording device, you are screwing yourselves big time.

Beat me to it. Just hit your cell phone video camera button and let it record everything that happens during the stop (or at least catch audio). Just a good CYA precaution for anyone in a situation where you feel LE's may try to take advantage.

As for to carry or not to carry, my take is like wearing my motorcycle helmet. Statistically speaking, a 5 mile ride down the road is the "most" dangerous time to be on a bike. So even though I'm just riding to the store down the block, I always wear my helmet. Because if that "one" time I'm going to get in an accident is on that ride, I better be prepared... :thumbsup:

This. Don't leave home without it!
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: colorado_shooter_dh on August 31, 2011, 04:39:33 PM

Initially, the Gestapo err I mean police will go on a propaganda rampage, telling the sheep how this new law will mean gunfights in the streets and people pulling guns on everyone that doesn't smile at them.

They will also try and "bait" and entrap law abiding citizens into violations, especially if the law is written in the confusing manner at the rest of our laws are.

Once the hoopla dies down, we will be able to feel secure that the predators of the world no longer have the upper hand when it comes to personal safety.

Ah, now we're getting somewhere with this post! This is exactly what I feel will happen, wanted to see if anyone else could see it coming...
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: Tom_G on August 31, 2011, 04:44:25 PM
When, not if, Hawaii becomes a "shall issue" state, I will carry.  Daily, religiously.  And, whatever the fallout from the powers-that-be, I will persevere. 
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: colorado_shooter_dh on August 31, 2011, 04:48:31 PM
It will also be interesting to see if/when hell freezes over and this all happens, how the laws will fall. In Colorado, if the officer ASKS, you have to inform him of your concealed weapon. If not asked, you are NOT required to offer this information. Most of the LEO's that I have spoken to say that if they don't ask, they don't want to know.... although they probably can see you have the permit anyway ahead of time. Declaring "Officer, I have a firearm" can also lead to a tense situation. Concealed means concealed, and I do not confirm or deny unless it is an LEO asking if I am carrying a weapon (back in Colorado, that is... I apologize if I sound like some butthead who thinks it is better back under the rock I came out from under! I moved here about a year and a half ago and love it here! It is just easy to compare the situation from where I was most familiar....)
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: onfloat on August 31, 2011, 10:08:27 PM

Letting the officer know you're carrying seems like a good idea, even if it's not required.  I'd hate to reach for the glove box to get my registration and *oops*, shirt rode up.  Now we're getting proned out on the median, blah, blah, blah.  Of course, in Hawaii, that might happen anyway as soon as you tell them, "Officer, I am a CCW permit holder and I'm carrying my firearm."  I don't know, but I like to ponder the wonderful day when we can all go stand in line for our CCW's.  Horse, cart, who cares?  It's going to take years anyway; we might as well fantasize about how awesome it's going to be.

Depends, a friend of mine got pulled over in Florida and let the officer know he was carrying because he felt it was the prudent thing to do and ended up in the back of the car while the officer ran his credentials.
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: 2aHawaii on September 01, 2011, 02:55:23 AM
Depends, a friend of mine got pulled over in Florida and let the officer know he was carrying because he felt it was the prudent thing to do and ended up in the back of the car while the officer ran his credentials.

Notifying also sometimes causes problems with officers with no prior experience. I would just do what is required by law.
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: 230RN on September 01, 2011, 04:21:15 AM
Quote
I used to be that guy that would try to break up a fight, negotiate with drunken idiots in an attempt to de-escalate a situation. Since carrying, I stopped this behavior and I don't even do it now unless it is directly aimed at me (rare).

When you carry, these actions can lead you down a road that ends in someone seriously injured or dead and you in steel bracelets. These are the situations that the antis think will happen on a routine basis. Fact is, they do not.

If you are one to get into business that is not your own, then don't carry at places this may happen. I do not mean to lecture, but carrying is a mindset and a lifestyle, not as simple as carrying a pocketknife.

^ Truth.  Carrying a firearm 24/7/365 puts a different light on a lot of situations. I've already described how such a simple thing as my driving has changed.

Even though it's not required here in CO, I do hand over my "permission slip" with my DL when stopped --twice since I got my "permission slip."  The Officers seemed to appreciate the courtesy, even though it was not required.

One thing I would suggest when carry becomes legal is that the police departments institute training classes as to the detailed ins and outs and legalities of private citizens carrying weapons on their persons and in their cars.  Apparently from what I've read, there is often a pretty big information gap, especially in outlying areas, whenever shall-issue becomes law in some States.  I would gently but firmly urge my local police chiefs and administrators to get their staffs up to speed in detail on this so they don't go proning out someone legally carrying and get their asses sued.  I predict that there will be some resentment on the part of the police that some of their "elite" status will be diminished when ordinary Joes and Janes are allowed to carry "GUH-UHNs."

In general, if there's a problem, it pays to advise the officer of it and ask "How do you want to handle  it, Sir?"

"My driver's side windows won't roll down so I can't hand you my paperwork.  How do you want to handle this, Sir?"

"I am carrying a loaded firearm pursuant to State law, and it's in my holster on my left side.  How do you want to handle this, Sir?"

"My stupid-jerk brother-in-law stole this car and I got it back from him and I'm returning it to the owner even though it's still on the stolen car list.  How do you want to handle this, Sir?"

Or Ma'am.

Terry, 230RN

ETA:  I'm reminded of the story of the guy returning from the range with all sorts of guns in the car...  shotguns, rifles, pistols, beaucoup ammo for each.  So he gets stopped for something and the Officer asks, "Do you have any weapons in the car?"

And the guy comes back with, "Sure.  What kind do you want?"

Brrrump-tshhhhh.
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: colorado_shooter_dh on September 01, 2011, 07:03:15 AM
Great reply Terry, further emphasizing the reason for my post. I would bet the resentment will go deep.. VERY good suggestion to ask the officer how he/she wants to handle the sitch.
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: hylandgreen on September 01, 2011, 08:06:56 AM
IF Hawaii ever becomes a SHALL ISSUE state please have the brains to let your local law enforcement know that you are carrying a gun...  USE YOUR BRAINS FOLKS!!! DO NOT GET THEM SHOT OUT!!!!!  Goodluck with your "mission"
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: Cougar8045 on September 01, 2011, 08:51:22 AM
IF Hawaii ever becomes a SHALL ISSUE state please have the brains to let your local law enforcement know that you are carrying a gun...  USE YOUR BRAINS FOLKS!!! DO NOT GET THEM SHOT OUT!!!!!  Goodluck with your "mission"
Not sure if you're implying that cops are idiots who will shoot on sight if you're carrying, or if you're implying that shooting someone who doesn't have the courtesy to tell a cop he's carrying is reasonable, but neither of them are correct.  Nobody's going to get killed one way or the other; we're just talking about the best way to avoid having a simple speeding ticket turn into an hour-long session with the steel jewelry in the back of a cop car while he straightens things out.
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: Cougar8045 on September 01, 2011, 08:55:57 AM
Great post, Terry, and it underscores a point that gun-grabbers consistently fail to recognize: that having a loaded firearm in your possession makes people nicer.  I think the Brady Bunch see the saying, "An armed society is a polite society" as saying that people are courteous under threat of death from others, but it's exactly 180* out from that.  People who are armed are polite because they do not want to have to shoot someone.  Much better to smile and say "excuse me" when you bump someone than have it go: *bump*>watch it, a**hole!>YOU watch it, pal!>push>shove>fisticuffs>gunfight.  When people are armed, it's not the other guy's gun that motivates them to avoid confrontation, it's their own. 
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: 230RN on September 01, 2011, 09:32:13 AM
Cougar8045 Spake Thus:

Quote
When honest people are armed, it's not the other guy's gun that motivates them to avoid confrontation, it's their own.

Somebody engrave that deeply into a thick stainless steel plaque and rivet it to the State House's front door.

With stainless steel rivets.  Like Luther's 99 Theses.  'Cept only One Thesis. And not nailed.  Riveted.  With the above-mentioned stainless steel rivets.  That orta do the trick, by gum, by golly!

Best way of putting it I've ever heard. (I added the "honest.")


Terry, 230RN
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: Tom_G on September 01, 2011, 10:31:30 AM
Like Luther's 99 Theses.

Waxing esoteric, are we?  :)
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: Vladimir on September 01, 2011, 02:43:09 PM
Is there a possibility that when the CCW law takes effect, the state, police, etc will counter back with something?

Take for example our magazine capacity law. It pretty much gets looked over and is vaguely enforced for rifles. Or like that recent article on that county in California allowing for CCW but at a ridiculous fee and requirements.
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: 2aHawaii on September 01, 2011, 02:48:45 PM
Is there a possibility that when the CCW law takes effect, the state, police, etc will counter back with something?

Take for example our magazine capacity law. It pretty much gets looked over and is vaguely enforced for rifles. Or like that recent article on that county in California allowing for CCW but at a ridiculous fee and requirements.

If you aren't doing anything illegal you don't have to worry about it right  ;)

Of course the state can enact very tough laws like Chicago has. But if they are smart, they would look at Chicago and see how much money they are losing (through lost cases).
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: Cougar8045 on September 01, 2011, 04:18:43 PM
Is there a possibility that when the CCW law takes effect, the state, police, etc will counter back with something?

Take for example our magazine capacity law. It pretty much gets looked over and is vaguely enforced for rifles. Or like that recent article on that county in California allowing for CCW but at a ridiculous fee and requirements.
I'd say it's a virtual certainty.  They'll change the laws as much as they need to in order to satisfy the court's specific requirements, but still deny everyone a permit to carry.  Then there'll be another lawsuit, on and on, until some panel of judges somewhere says enough is enough and hands down a court order revising Hawaii's statutes to constitutional carry.  At least, that's what I think.  I have no expectation that a court order is going to cause the state to see the light; they're going to piss away a bunch more taxpayer dollars defending lawsuits they know they can't win, but at least they'll get the satisfaction of sitting on people's rights for a few years longer.
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: Cougar8045 on September 01, 2011, 04:19:25 PM
Cougar8045 Spake Thus:

Quote
When honest people are armed, it's not the other guy's gun that motivates them to avoid confrontation, it's their own.

Somebody engrave that deeply into a thick stainless steel plaque and rivet it to the State House's front door.

With stainless steel rivets.  Like Luther's 99 Theses.  'Cept only One Thesis. And not nailed.  Riveted.  With the above-mentioned stainless steel rivets.  That orta do the trick, by gum, by golly!

Best way of putting it I've ever heard. (I added the "honest.")


Terry, 230RN
Thanks, Terry.  Good point on adding the "honest".  Never met a gangbanger with any manners, that's for sure!
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: Aegis808 on September 02, 2011, 11:24:14 AM
i would hope that with the change in the law on CCW that there would be wide sweeping reforms in the laws on self defence and use of force. So that it coud help alleaviate our concerns from the ridiculous ramafications that those defending themselves in Hawaii have to worry about right now.
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: 230RN on September 04, 2011, 04:36:33 AM
Aegis808 brought this up:


Quote
i would hope that with the change in the law on CCW that there would be wide sweeping reforms in the laws on self defence and use of force. So that it could help alleviate our concerns from the ridiculous ramafications that those defending themselves in Hawaii have to worry about right now.

Can someone educate this mainlander by PM a little bit?  I'm interested in what restrictions there are on self-defense in Hawaii, but I don't want to start a thread drift.

I know in England (and probably Australia) it's almost to the point where if you're attacked, your only legal option is to lie kneel there and take it like a good little subject. 

I'm reminded of the response Jeff Cooper made to the remark that "Violence only begets violence."

He said, basically, "I certainly hope so."

Terry, 230RN

REF:

http://www.buckeyefirearms.org/quotations-of-jeff-cooper (http://www.buckeyefirearms.org/quotations-of-jeff-cooper)

Full quote (about halfway down in the above link):

Quote
One bleeding-heart type asked me in a recent interview if I did not agree that 'violence begets violence.' I told him that it is my earnest endeavor to see that it does. I would like very much to ensure — and in some cases I have — that any man who offers violence to his fellow citizen begets a whole lot more in return than he can enjoy.
Title: Re: So what if CCW *is* allowed in Hawaii?
Post by: Cougar8045 on September 04, 2011, 06:38:01 AM
Thanks for the link, Terry, that little gem should keep me stocked on Facebook statuses for at least a week!  :geekdanc: