2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: onfloat on September 21, 2011, 09:00:59 PM
-
Councilman Tom Berg posted this on Facebook earlier tonight
Please help establish a public firing range in West Oahu- hearing is Sept 27 at 10:30am Honolulu Hale.
FOR ACTION
2. RESOLUTION 11-263 - PUBLIC SHOOTING COMPLEX IN KALAELOA. Resolution urging the City to develop a public shooting complex in Kalaeloa.
It's time to flood the Honolulu Hale and show our support! :D
-
I also asked if he would take statements if we were unable to attend. His Reply:
Tom Berg Yes- email me at tomberg00 [at] yahoo [dot] com and I can send you the details via regular email.
Here is the link for submitting testimony on- line.
http://www4.honolulu.gov/docushare/dsweb/Get/Document-117106/6b4x7jqg.pdf (http://www4.honolulu.gov/docushare/dsweb/Get/Document-117106/6b4x7jqg.pdf)
-
:thumbsup:
-
More,
CITY COUNCIL
CITY AND COUNTY OF HONOLULU
HONOLULU, HAWAII 96813-3077
COMMITTEE ON PARKS AND
CULTURAL AFFAIRS
Voting Members:
Tom Berg, Chair
Ikaika Anderson, Vice Chair
Romy M. Cachola
Nestor Garcia
Breene Harimoto
AGENDA
REGULAR MEETING
COMMITTEE MEETING ROOM
TUESDAY, SEPTEMBER 27, 2011
10:30 A.M.
SPEAKER REGISTRATION:
Persons wishing to speak on items listed on the agenda are requested to register by 10:30 a.m. in the interest of time management as follows:
a. use the On-Line City Council Speaker Registration form available at http://www1.honolulu.gov/council/attnspkpca.htm; (http://www1.honolulu.gov/council/attnspkpca.htm;)
b. send a fax to 768-3827 indicating your desire to register to speak, along with your name, phone number and subject matter;
c. fill out the registration form in person; or
d. call 768-3820.
Each speaker is limited to a one-minute presentation.
Persons who have not registered to speak should raise their hands at the time the item is announced and they will be given an opportunity to speak following oral testimonies of the registered speakers.
WRITTEN TESTIMONY:
If you wish to submit written testimony:
a. fax to 768-3827 or
b. go to http://www1.honolulu.gov/council/emailpca.htm (http://www1.honolulu.gov/council/emailpca.htm) to email your written testimony.
By submitting written testimony, you are not automatically registered to speak. Refer to “SPEAKER REGISTRATION” procedures above.
If submitted, written testimonies, including the testifier’s address, e-mail address, and phone number, may be posted by the City Clerk and available to the public on the City’s DocuShare Website.
Any physically challenged person requiring special assistance should call 768-3820 for details at least one day prior to the meeting date.
FOR APPROVAL
MINUTES OF THE AUGUST 30, 2011 MEETING
FOR ACCEPTANCE OF GIFTS / DONATIONS TO THE CITY
1. RESOLUTION 11-261 – ACCEPTANCE OF GIFT FROM THE HAWAII GARDENIA CIRCLE. Relating to the acceptance of a gift to the City, valued at $10,887.72, from the Hawaii Gardenia Circle for the upkeep of the Ala Wai Golf Course 2nd Floor Multipurpose Facility. (Transmitted by Communication D-636)
FOR ACTION
2. RESOLUTION 11-263 – PUBLIC SHOOTING COMPLEX IN KALAELOA. Resolution urging the City to develop a public shooting complex in Kalaeloa.
FOR DISCUSSION
3. ONEULA BEACH PARK IMPACTS. Oneula Beach Park update including status on Master Plan: jersey barricades gifted to the City in non-compliance; adjacent properties to Oneula Beach Park to include drainage; and the status of native Hawaiian concerns pertinent to the development surrounding and of party to Oneula Beach Park.
4. PALOLO DISTRICT PARK. Status on the repair of playground equipment at Palolo District Park.
Related communication:
D-639 Palolo Neighborhood Board No. 6, Resolution calling on the City to better maintain playground equipment at Palolo District Park.
TOM BERG, Chair
Committee on Parks and Cultural Affairs
Attention Speak Parks and Cultural Affairs, Official Web Site for The City and County of Honolulu
www1.honolulu.gov
If you do not receive an e-mail confirmation, our office has not received your registration. Please call the number shown on the respective council/committee agenda or try again.
-
http://hawaiiccw.com/news/gun-range-action-required-now/ (http://hawaiiccw.com/news/gun-range-action-required-now/)
[Your Name]
[Your Address]
[E-mail and / or Contact Number]
Tom Berg, City Council
City and County of Honolulu
Honolulu, Hawaii 96813-3077
Committee on Parks and Cultural Affairs
Dear Voting Members:
I strongly support resolution 11-263 “Public Shooting Complex in Kalaeloa.â€
Training with a firearm on a shooting range is a very critical part of learning to safely operate and handle firearms. It is so important that the state demands citizens have it prior to purchasing a handgun for any purpose. The problem is that currently we have almost nowhere to go and conduct this training.
Please help us solve this problem.
A lack of available training facilities is detrimental to the safety of the public, our families, and our children. It is of the utmost importance that we have additional places to educate ourselves and others on the safe and proper use of firearms. Ultimately, trained citizens are more responsible and are also less likely to be involved in a negligent discharges. Shouldn’t we work together to promote safety?
Lastly, Hawaii firearm ownership is rapidly on the rise. In fact, over the last decade, there were 224,130 firearms registered in our State. This trend of increasing firearm ownership means that every day there are more people and less park. Our only public range, Kokohead Shooting Complex, already has scarce hours and can’t support the public demand. Most importantly, Kokohead’s hours of operation are a burden for West Oahu residents. There is a clear need for a facility in West Oahu.
In the interest of public safety and recreation, I graciously request your support for this resolution.
Please vote yes for Resolution 11-263!
Mahalo,
[Your Name]
-
Chris Baker posted a form letter over at the Hawaii CCW website (http://www.hawaiiccw.com), so you can just fill in the blanks. Filing in the blanks and submitting is much better than nothing, but if you can take the time to do some personalization, it will be better. Feel free to add in stuff like your drive time, how often you would the range, etc. But at the very least, please fill out the form letter and submit it!
EDIT: Nevermind,Chris posted it here!
-
email sent ! thanks for the link and template :thumbsup:
-
Sweet I'll write up my own testimony. As for the 27th unfortunately I'm unable to show face as I have a conference to attend for work. =(
-
Just submitted my written testimony!! :thumbsup:
-
Me, too!
-
Submitted.
-
I was looking through the resolution; I like what it was saying. There are many old sites on Barbers that were previously rifle ranges, that I know of.
The last part of the resolution troubles me though.
"...that any new public shooting complex prohibit the use of ammunition that is environmentally harmful..."
http://www4.honolulu.gov/docushare/dsweb/Get/Document-117106/6b4x7jqg.pdf (http://www4.honolulu.gov/docushare/dsweb/Get/Document-117106/6b4x7jqg.pdf)
Is lead and lead cored ammunition considered 'environmentally harmful'? ???
If that is the case then that is a very disturbing, it opens the door for a ban on lead ammunition.
Non-lead ammo is very very expensive, and will kill the benefit of having a new firing range for leeward shooters.
Unless you are well funded military or LE. I would hate for a new complex become a hangout for the rich and privileged elite!
This is troubling me, and I have not written any thing yet. I would like to know more details, but the deadline is near.
Anyone have any facts about 'environmentally harmful ammunition'? ???
-
I saw that too, and it worried me as well. Very interesting and it sounds like a ban on lead ammunition. I don't know any other reason that would be in there.
-
Letter submitted
-
I saw that too, and it worried me as well. Very interesting and it sounds like a ban on lead ammunition. I don't know any other reason that would be in there.
Does anybody know what Hawaii's definition is on evironmentally harmful ammunition?
I would suggest your folks testimony include not banning lead and lead core ammunition!
-
EPA has already lost on "lead ammo" issues; that is almost non-issue. We can't even use frangible ammo here, which is the prime substitute for lead if I am not mistaken.
-
Submitted
-
EPA has already lost on "lead ammo" issues; that is almost non-issue. We can't even use frangible ammo here, which is the prime substitute for lead if I am not mistaken.
You're right about the EPA, but I don't know if I'd be so quick to dismiss the concern about lead ammo. City & County of Honolulu is not a federal agency, and I doubt the gun-grabbers would much care that there's no viable alternative for legal ammunition here. I'd recommend including something in your letter along the lines of, "...provided that "enviromentally harmful ammunition" does not include ammunition containing lead, as having a range that bans lead ammunition would render the benefits of having a range on West Oahu practically nill."
-
EPA has already lost on "lead ammo" issues; that is almost non-issue. We can't even use frangible ammo here, which is the prime substitute for lead if I am not mistaken.
You're right about the EPA, but I don't know if I'd be so quick to dismiss the concern about lead ammo. City & County of Honolulu is not a federal agency, and I doubt the gun-grabbers would much care that there's no viable alternative for legal ammunition here. I'd recommend including something in your letter along the lines of, "...provided that "enviromentally harmful ammunition" does not include ammunition containing lead, as having a range that bans lead ammunition would render the benefits of having a range on West Oahu practically nill."
This! Exactly!
I don't trust these politicians as far as I can throw them, and that is not too far, trust me.
Hawaii has proven time and time again on how they can screw up things by wording alone.
I totally and completely support a range on the leeward side, but if it would entail using non lead ammo, the range is pointless. It would be a congregation of rich folk that can afford to blast off expensive as f$@# ammo, and leave all the common folk wondering what happened.
Sorry to say this, but I would rather see no range if it comes to no conventional ammunition.
It would also make it easier to ban such things at our only other public shooting facility.
Just a quick google foo.
Non lead 9mm $30.99 for 50 @ MidwayUSA
Non lead 45acp $31.95 for 20 @ MidwayUSA
Non lead .308win $43.84 for 20 @ cheaperthandirt
Keep in mind they do not ship to Hawaii, so you know what the shops will increase these prices for hazmat and to break a profit.
Even for reloaders this would increase costs to something like double or more, and your ammo WILL NOT be as accurate.
-
$2.19 for a shot with your .308, and you can't hit shit! The gun grabbers would love that!
-
Heavies, I agree and I commend you on actually reading the proposal. Baby-bathwater saying... let's just get this thing moving forward, policies can change later IMHO.
-
I wouldn't mind a range out in the west side so I don't need to drive all the way down to koko head. But instead of the state spending all this money on a new facility I would be happy if they would just open the range 7 days a week and extended the hours.
-
Alright so I asked Tom Berg how 'environmentally harmful ammunition' was being defined. His response:
I will get back to you- should have answer tomorrow- we can remove that language too- not a problem.
I will let you know what he says tomorrow.
-
Alright so I asked Tom Berg how 'environmentally harmful ammunition' was being defined. His response:
I will get back to you- should have answer tomorrow- we can remove that language too- not a problem.
I will let you know what he says tomorrow.
BOlded....needs to go.
-
Public private venture.
http://www.bizjournals.com/pacific/blog/2011/09/berg-wants-shooting-complex-for-west.html?fb_comment_id=fbc_10150304181909915_18798164_10150304196024915&ref=notif¬if_t=open_graph_comment (http://www.bizjournals.com/pacific/blog/2011/09/berg-wants-shooting-complex-for-west.html?fb_comment_id=fbc_10150304181909915_18798164_10150304196024915&ref=notif¬if_t=open_graph_comment)
-
Testimony sent. Hopefully we're worrying about nothing with the lead thing, but I did go ahead and add a paragraph at the end of my letter addressing my concerns. The thing I don't like is exactly what 808shooter said, policies can change. So if the range has a regulation that says no environmentally harmful ammunition, that might mean tracers today, and lead bullets tomorrow. I'm all for moving the thing forward, but if we can move it forward without vague wording about environmental harm, so much the better. Or at least, with a specific exemption stating that lead-based ammunition does not constitute an environmentally harmful substance.
-
Here is one thing, the police and other agencies will use the range. They are not going to use non-lead ammo; this is why they can't afford to shoot at their OWN range in Waipahu!
-
Here is one thing, the police and other agencies will use the range. They are not going to use non-lead ammo; this is why they can't afford to shoot at their OWN range in Waipahu!
Yep, and it is a known fact that the police and other agencies use our public facilities in any way they please, not following any of the stringent rules the general public must adhere to.
I am going to try to contact Berg today and solicit an answer. I let everyone know what his comments are.
-
The proposal was mentioned in the Pacific Business news
http://www.bizjournals.com/pacific/blog/2011/09/berg-wants-shooting-complex-for-west.html (http://www.bizjournals.com/pacific/blog/2011/09/berg-wants-shooting-complex-for-west.html)
Strangely enough, so was this article on the DLNR and feral cows. I guess it's a slow business week :P
http://www.bizjournals.com/pacific/blog/2011/09/dlnr-having-a-cow-over-feral-cattle.html (http://www.bizjournals.com/pacific/blog/2011/09/dlnr-having-a-cow-over-feral-cattle.html)
-
Tom Berg just posted this over on the HawaiiCCW facebook page but is asking if it should be removed.
This is the reasoning I got regarding why the reso for firing range in Kalaeloa has "environmental friendly" language in it:
For the purpose of being a "Match" range (firing at Paper Targets)
The bullets for an "historic WW-II range" would be much safer than
Older high powered bullets that contain lead.
These bullets also SHATTER and are also designed to be issued to
Undercover officers on aircraft so that a terrorist could be shot - but
the bullets won't penetrate the skin of the aircraft.
Basically they are designed for "short range" use and not long distance
or armor penetrating. This would make for a Safer "Environmental"
Historic WW-II Rifle and Pistol Range ...
http://frangibleammo.com/ (http://frangibleammo.com/)
Made from a copper/tin composite the SinterFire Bullet does not contain
lead.
By design, its controlled frangibility causes it to break apart upon contact
with
an item harder than itself.
Inherent accuracy and transparency to its lead counterpart, have made the
SinterFire Bullet the frangible bullet of choice. Major ammunition
manufacturers
like Winchester , Federal, ATK/CCI-Speer, and many others all feature
frangible lines
of ammunition utilizing the SinterFire Bullet. A leader in lead free bullets
and lead
free ammunition.
At FrangibleAmmo.com our goal is to make sure that everyone has access
to the safety and environmental benefits of SinterFire bullets and
ammunition.
-
I wouldn't mind a range out in the west side so I don't need to drive all the way down to koko head. But instead of the state spending all this money on a new facility I would be happy if they would just open the range 7 days a week and extended the hours.
This is the City & County.
I look at it like the whole Rail issue. Supposedly this is a public-private venture. If the City can't come up with the money then it's up to the private sector to make up the shortfall. In this case the shooting community is large enough it might be able to survive as a viable venture. It might end up being expensive and I'd be interested to see how the community in the area would greet a range.
-
Tom Berg just posted this over on the HawaiiCCW facebook page but is asking if it should be removed.
This is the reasoning I got regarding why the reso for firing range in Kalaeloa has "environmental friendly" language in it:
For the purpose of being a "Match" range (firing at Paper Targets)
The bullets for an "historic WW-II range" would be much safer than
Older high powered bullets that contain lead.
These bullets also SHATTER and are also designed to be issued to
Undercover officers on aircraft so that a terrorist could be shot - but
the bullets won't penetrate the skin of the aircraft.
Basically they are designed for "short range" use and not long distance
or armor penetrating. This would make for a Safer "Environmental"
Historic WW-II Rifle and Pistol Range ...
http://frangibleammo.com/ (http://frangibleammo.com/)
Made from a copper/tin composite the SinterFire Bullet does not contain
lead.
By design, its controlled frangibility causes it to break apart upon contact
with
an item harder than itself.
Inherent accuracy and transparency to its lead counterpart, have made the
SinterFire Bullet the frangible bullet of choice. Major ammunition
manufacturers
like Winchester , Federal, ATK/CCI-Speer, and many others all feature
frangible lines
of ammunition utilizing the SinterFire Bullet. A leader in lead free bullets
and lead
free ammunition.
At FrangibleAmmo.com our goal is to make sure that everyone has access
to the safety and environmental benefits of SinterFire bullets and
ammunition.
This is also what he just emailed me.
It is exactly what we DO NOT WANT!
This will cost shooters! I would recommend you folks ask it be removed from there, and conventional ammo be allowed!
-
This is also what he just emailed me.
It is exactly what we DO NOT WANT!
This will cost shooters! I would recommend you folks ask it be removed from there, and conventional ammo be allowed!
"Older high powered bullets that contain lead."
What a load of bs.
-
A public range on West Oahu is a great idea and not something new to discussion, however the timing for the former Barbers Pt location and its transition from the Navy to the C&C is great timing and is the best chance of success in these economic times. I would also strongly suggest that everyone press Councilman Berg to remove the "environmentally friendly" verbiage from the proposal, I know I will.
Here is one thing, the police and other agencies will use the range. They are not going to use non-lead ammo; this is why they can't afford to shoot at their OWN range in Waipahu!
Your statements about the Waipahu indoor facility is not correct. It is in full use every weekday. However the logic that you mention in regards to the HPD is a good way to impress upon Councilman Berg that there is a legitimate need to remove such verbiage. In other words the "implied benefit" of frangible or lead free ammo, is not a worthwhile trade off for practical and economic reasons. No one would even think twice if that wording wasn't there. Now if he includes it, he puts ideas into peoples heads and then it will be too late.
Here is one thing, the police and other agencies will use the range. They are not going to use non-lead ammo; this is why they can't afford to shoot at their OWN range in Waipahu!
Yep, and it is a known fact that the police and other agencies use our public facilities in any way they please, not following any of the stringent rules the general public must adhere to.
I am going to try to contact Berg today and solicit an answer. I let everyone know what his comments are.
I am not sure why there is any negativity towards the HPD usage of the City and County Koko Head facility? They are following "best practice" principles that any major metro PD would follow for range use and LE training. In reality the HPD training exceeds most others standards in how a facility is utilized by a LE agency. The City must provide training and are mandated by the courts to provide varying types of training and again Koko Head is City owned. I would love to see public facilities that would allow more options for the general shooting community, but being negative toward the HPD for doing what they are supposed to be doing seems a bit misguided to me. It also seems to be overlooked that there are many within the HPD that are supportive of the issues discussed on this site. However quickly reading threads around here does little to get the support of those individuals who might actually make great proponents in favor of these issues.
-
Got a response from Berg as to the concerns about the ammo.
I am amending the reso with a CD1 version to strike/remove that friendly environmental language...MAHALO
Tom
-
Cool. That's good news.
He also posted this to facebook:
Hawaii News Now filmed myself and others at the OLD firing range in Kalaeloa today- watch today on the TV news- spread the word...thanks.
-
I am not sure why there is any negativity towards the HPD usage of the City and County Koko Head facility? They are following "best practice" principles that any major metro PD would follow for range use and LE training. In reality the HPD training exceeds most others standards in how a facility is utilized by a LE agency. The City must provide training and are mandated by the courts to provide varying types of training and again Koko Head is City owned. I would love to see public facilities that would allow more options for the general shooting community, but being negative toward the HPD for doing what they are supposed to be doing seems a bit misguided to me. It also seems to be overlooked that there are many within the HPD that are supportive of the issues discussed on this site. However quickly reading threads around here does little to get the support of those individuals who might actually make great proponents in favor of these issues.
You got me wrong. The negativity is not with the HPD. I wish they would practice more, if they could.
The real issue is I am so irritated at the double standards with the rules and regs imposed by the city and state when it involves firearms and the general public, treating the law abiding citizen as some kind of infantile child unable to responsibly practice the art of self defense with a firearm. I mean they will reprimand you for putting up a human silhouette target, I mean come on now.
-
You got me wrong. The negativity is not with the HPD. I wish they would practice more, if they could.
The real issue is I am so irritated at the double standards with the rules and regs imposed by the city and state when it involves firearms and the general public, treating the law abiding citizen as some kind of infantile child unable to responsibly practice the art of self defense with a firearm. I mean they will reprimand you for putting up a human silhouette target, I mean come on now.
[/quote]
The C&C ROs treat HPD with the same rules and distain. Police Officers may not carry holstered weapons unless on duty at Koko Head public pistol range. They are not allowed to draw and shoot from the holster or use human silhouette targets at the public range unless it is a specific HPD training event or sanctioned competition. The same impolite people that yell at the general public yell at badged officers also.
-
I have to agree with Techi and Heavies. It is not a distain for HPD. It is for a system that allows officers with a viable venue to shoot to use the only available public range to the detriment of the public's use of said range. If the range at the academy isn't sufficient to meet the needs of the police, then that is their administration's fault and the shooting public should not get the short end of the proverbial stick because of poor planning by the police department. A secondary issue is that HPD is allowed to train in a manner that none of the public are allowed to do, such as holster draws, rapid follow up shots, or shooting at something besides that ridiculous 25 yards for handguns. And that does not take into account the ability to use the range during the week when no one else can, even if they try to sign up for it.
And, as someone who frequently uses the range after HPD does, I can tell you that they are not very responsible in cleaning up after themselves....if one of the "clubs" using the action bays were to leave it in such a sorry state, they'd have their privileges yanked.
-
I don't know what standards you think you are comparing HPD to, but I think your quite wrong Surf. I've just had close friend go through the Academy, and know about how much "firearms" training they get. With the exception of HRT, standard officers are not required to train enough. Some who enjoy firearms train on their own, but many times they are out alone at kokohead. Furthemore, the City, like almost all government agencies including the Marines and the Army, have significantly cut back their firearms training because of money.
All said - the issue is not with HPD, it is with double standards. Citizens should be allowed to train just like any other law enforcement agency. We have the same responsibilities when discharging a firearm as they do. The exception is, when an officer accidentally kills someone in the line of duty nothing happens. When a citizen accidentally kills someone because of a bad shot, they go to court to face possible criminal and or civil penalties. That is just the reality of civil immunity that many government agents enjoy.
The other problem is that if there are no safety issues with the police department using the range outside of normal public hours, why shouldn't the public be able to use it under the same circumstances. (I.e., permits etc.)
-
Just watched the report on Hawaii News Now (http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/15537882/councilman-pushing-for-gun-range-in-kalaeloa#).
I am very familiar with the area they are speaking of. This old firing range would be the perfect spot for a new complex. Regular residents are miles away, the area faces toward the ocean, and I believe most of the berms are still in place. There are tons of overgrowth that needs to be cleared, but I'm sure it will be a great place to shoot.
-
Sounds like the perfect volunteer opportunity. Having spoken with a few people on a similar issue, this can be done for very minimal costs I believe. It would not take long for us to raise the funding.
-
Yeah i saw it on the news too. Looks quite promising. Clearning out the growth shouldnt be to bad, chop down the trees and sell the wood to get some money back to finance the range.
-
I've got a machete that I still haven't found a use for...
-
I believe I speak for the silent majority when saying I wanna help. maybe we should email Berg and let him know that volunteers are standing by.
-
I believe I speak for the silent majority when saying I wanna help. maybe we should email Berg and let him know that volunteers are standing by.
You can count me in!! :thumbsup:
-
I will preface this post by saying that we are often our own worst enemies. Public shooters and LE included. You will find very good people in either group, or you will find some that think they know it all, been there done that, been in a position for years and are quite comfortable with status quo, or don't like having their little "piece of the pie" messed with. I think that is easily seen amongst various shooting groups, gun shops, clubs, or shooting cliques. Again this does not exclude LE. There is a lot that some people in LE and Military can offer to the public shooting scene, but traditionally there has been a bit of a disconnect between the two, even with those who would actually like to offer support, teaching, training, etc but shy away for various reasons.
You got me wrong. The negativity is not with the HPD. I wish they would practice more, if they could.
"Yep, and it is a known fact that the police and other agencies use our public facilities in any way they please, not following any of the stringent rules the general public must adhere to."
Sorry, I know much often gets left out of the written word on a screen with the lack of inflection of speech, but I would think it is not difficult to see how this statement is easily seen as a negative.
I have to agree with Techi and Heavies. It is not a distain for HPD. It is for a system that allows officers with a viable venue to shoot to use the only available public range to the detriment of the public's use of said range. If the range at the academy isn't sufficient to meet the needs of the police, then that is their administration's fault and the shooting public should not get the short end of the proverbial stick because of poor planning by the police department. A secondary issue is that HPD is allowed to train in a manner that none of the public are allowed to do, such as holster draws, rapid follow up shots, or shooting at something besides that ridiculous 25 yards for handguns. And that does not take into account the ability to use the range during the week when no one else can, even if they try to sign up for it.
And, as someone who frequently uses the range after HPD does, I can tell you that they are not very responsible in cleaning up after themselves....if one of the "clubs" using the action bays were to leave it in such a sorry state, they'd have their privileges yanked.
I never used the word disdain, but the comment very much comes across as negative. Now there are other threads or replies in other threads around here that I would classify as disdain.
I would hope that there would be a better understanding of how things might work with the City and the HPD. It isn't a lack of planning or attempt to build on behalf of the HPD but rather an issue of funding approvals from the City and budgets. The master plan for the Waipahu academy included many things and were on the books since the late 80's. Look how long it took to get the funds to build the first phase or the indoor range. It isn't because HPD hasn't asked for the funding every single year for the past 20 years. Don't think that the HPD wouldn't like to be self sufficient with its own ranges as they would. It isn't the fault of the HPD. We should also remember that even if LE or any agencies didn't use the lower combat, or action bays, the City couldn't pay for the employees to staff and maintain running it. Heck the City can't even keep normal hours of business. The City also wins by having the HPD presence and training on days that the park is closed to the public by monitoring and running the facility, even chasing people off the silhouette range on off hours.
No excuses made, but there are many who appreciate the leftover once fired, Federal brass. I rarely see it last overnight. You might often find it located in places neatly in boxes left on benches even. I cannot even begin to count how many times, on my own, that I have hauled shot up pallets, target frames and other misc stuff to the dumpsters on a Monday. I don't like it, but don't complain either. We also need to remember that there are also many other agencies using the ranges.
I do not disagree with what the public wishes to do in regards to shooting and being able to practice and hone skills. Your barking up the wrong tree with me. Your talking to a shooter and a huge proponent of the issues discussed. I don't disagree with the needs that you are talking about.
I don't know what standards you think you are comparing HPD to, but I think your quite wrong Surf. I've just had close friend go through the Academy, and know about how much "firearms" training they get. With the exception of HRT, standard officers are not required to train enough. Some who enjoy firearms train on their own, but many times they are out alone at kokohead. Furthemore, the City, like almost all government agencies including the Marines and the Army, have significantly cut back their firearms training because of money.
I was talking about the way in which they run the range logistically speaking. The number of RSO's / instructors per student etc...not really about the type of training. But since you mention the training aspect I will say that the HPD is highly regarded in LE in general being only 1 of the 3 CALEA Tri Arc accredited agencies in the Nation. The HPD Academy is considered to be one of the tops in the country. As an example the largest LE organizational body is POST. Most POST academies are around 5 weeks. The HPD conducts 6 months of academy training. The amount of training hours obtained is staggering in comparison to POST or the majority of LE nationwide. There is a huge reason that other departments nationwide try heavily to recruit HPD Officers and give laterals. While HPD requires that ALL people even current LE, to go through the entire HPD academy.
I will be the first to state that more incumbent Officers need to shoot more often. That is a combination of budget, logistics and honestly lack of personal initiative. However I know the exact curriculum and training hours for a new recruit. While it might not bolster your confidence in LE in general, the HPD recruits obtain far more training hours than the majority of LE agencies nationwide. Most don't even come close. Most who come out of the academy are actually shooting very well. There are no issues with washing out a recruit for firearms and it happens often enough. The issue over time generally becomes a combination of what I mentioned above because shooting is a perishable skill. 90% of LE are not "gun people". It is looked at like a tool. In reality the pen gets far more use. I am not agreeing with this mentality, just acknowledging reality.
All said - the issue is not with HPD, it is with double standards. Citizens should be allowed to train just like any other law enforcement agency. We have the same responsibilities when discharging a firearm as they do. The exception is, when an officer accidentally kills someone in the line of duty nothing happens. When a citizen accidentally kills someone because of a bad shot, they go to court to face possible criminal and or civil penalties. That is just the reality of civil immunity that many government agents enjoy.
I very much disagree here. The HPD goes after its own with far more commitment of resources and voracity than they would with the general public for a similar incident. The local Feds and the Prosecutors do exactly the same. Traditionally a convicted LE Officer will get a far stiffer penalty than the the average person. I am not disagreeing with this as LE should be held to a higher standard, but to think anything otherwise is very much incorrect. Give your friend some time with the HPD and he will quickly tell you the same. On any investigation, you are guilty on mere allegation, until proven otherwise. Officers are more often than not, put on ROPA (relieved of police authority), for mere allegations.
The other problem is that if there are no safety issues with the police department using the range outside of normal public hours, why shouldn't the public be able to use it under the same circumstances. (I.e., permits etc.)
What safety issues? Perhaps I can help clarify something? Public shooting organizations have night shoots? I know there might be issues as of late, but there is more to that story. Again, some groups can be their own worst enemies. The HPD has their own RSO's / instructors and certain units have their own medics (TEMS and EMT) on site at training. The HPD is responsible for the entire complex, including upper ranges on Mon and Tue all day. And are responsible for the upper ranges in the AM hours M-F and are responsible for the lower ranges M-F and of course like any other park, during any hours of night or day. This is a benefit to the City and the HPD. We must also understand that the City has quite a bit of liability and insurance issues to think about. Yes I understand how waiver's work, but this is a City property and your dealing with a City that is very liberal in nature.
-
>:D
-
Submitted. Took me a while because I wanted to be careful about handling the ammo issue.
-
Well said, Surf Dude. It's tough trying to keep everyone happy and maintain all the certifications to run ranges. And thanks for letting everyone know where I get my good 9mm brass.
-
email sent!
-
I also had my wife send one as well..... O0
-
I got this in my NRA update today.
Would be nice to get in on this action!
http://m.gazette.com/opinion/gun-125577-ranges-shooting.html (http://m.gazette.com/opinion/gun-125577-ranges-shooting.html)
-
I got this in my NRA update today.
Would be nice to get in on this action!
http://m.gazette.com/opinion/gun-125577-ranges-shooting.html (http://m.gazette.com/opinion/gun-125577-ranges-shooting.html)
I would just like to add that some of the reasons HDF is going 501.c3 is to qualify for range grants and corporate donations that could help fund ranges and shooting activities. It also makes a range cheaper to operate, corporate income tax can smack a for-profit institution pretty hard.
-
Well, fellers, the day of the hearing is upon us. I won't be able to get off work to go, but I hope lots of you other guys are going to be there. Good luck, Mr. Berg!
-
Was anyone able to make it out to the hearing thing today? How did it go? Anyone got a update?
-
according to hawaii news now, it moved forward. :geekdanc:
-
There was a nice turnout at todays meeting with the vast majority of the people supporting the range. It passed committee and is headed to a full City Council vote.
-
SHOOTS!
-
"Yep, and it is a known fact that the police and other agencies use our public facilities in any way they please, not following any of the stringent rules the general public must adhere to."
Sorry, I know much often gets left out of the written word on a screen with the lack of inflection of speech, but I would think it is not difficult to see how this statement is easily seen as a negative.
It is not negative to point out the truth. HPD and other LE agengies DO get to use the range and DO get to disregard the rules that the general public must adhere to. Do LEOs get to use human targets? Yes. Do they get to do "holster presentations?" Yes. Do they get to use the range when it's "closed?" Yes. Does anyone from the public get to do this? Nope.
I never used the word disdain, but the comment very much comes across as negative. Now there are other threads or replies in other threads around here that I would classify as disdain.
I would hope that there would be a better understanding of how things might work with the City and the HPD. It isn't a lack of planning or attempt to build on behalf of the HPD but rather an issue of funding approvals from the City and budgets. The master plan for the Waipahu academy included many things and were on the books since the late 80's. Look how long it took to get the funds to build the first phase or the indoor range. It isn't because HPD hasn't asked for the funding every single year for the past 20 years. Don't think that the HPD wouldn't like to be self sufficient with its own ranges as they would. It isn't the fault of the HPD. We should also remember that even if LE or any agencies didn't use the lower combat, or action bays, the City couldn't pay for the employees to staff and maintain running it. Heck the City can't even keep normal hours of business. The City also wins by having the HPD presence and training on days that the park is closed to the public by monitoring and running the facility, even chasing people off the silhouette range on off hours.
No excuses made, but there are many who appreciate the leftover once fired, Federal brass. I rarely see it last overnight. You might often find it located in places neatly in boxes left on benches even. I cannot even begin to count how many times, on my own, that I have hauled shot up pallets, target frames and other misc stuff to the dumpsters on a Monday. I don't like it, but don't complain either. We also need to remember that there are also many other agencies using the ranges
I never said you did...it was a word of my choosing. I disagree with your assertion that it is not a lack of planning. Let me ask you how much the academy range was supposed to cost and when was it supposed to open? I will let you research the issue but suffice it to say that it went WAY over budget and was opened far later than planned.
And, the point you make that the range is closed when HPD uses it (even if you cite lack of funding as the cause) is exactly what we are talking about. Why can't a club or organization that agrees to use a RSO or adhere to a reasonable and objective safety standard, use the range during "off" hours just like HPD? I am sure the presence of armed, law-abiding citizens would have much the same deterrent affect as you suggest the presence of HPD does.
When I have to clean up the bay after anyone else uses it, I don't normally complain either...I just do it. But the point, again, is that if the general public were to treat the ranges in the same fashion as HPD, or any of the other LE agencies do, they would not be "invited" back. Yet LE agencies keep getting to use the range. It is, again, an obvious case of disparate treatment. One where the "public" is subject to much more strict rules and significantly harsher punishment than LE in the same situation.
I very much disagree here. The HPD goes after its own with far more commitment of resources and voracity than they would with the general public for a similar incident. The local Feds and the Prosecutors do exactly the same. Traditionally a convicted LE Officer will get a far stiffer penalty than the the average person. I am not disagreeing with this as LE should be held to a higher standard, but to think anything otherwise is very much incorrect. Give your friend some time with the HPD and he will quickly tell you the same. On any investigation, you are guilty on mere allegation, until proven otherwise. Officers are more often than not, put on ROPA (relieved of police authority), for mere allegations.
I think you miss the point here. He was not trying to say HPD officers are less likely to be given harsher sentences when convicted. He was saying that in the course of doing their duties, an officer that has an otherwise "good" shoot but has the misfortune of injuring or killing an innocent bystander, or shooting the "wrong" person, is provided a level of immunity from civil and criminal prosecution that a citizen, in the same situation would not be afforded. As for the summary ROPA of any officer accused of impropriety, I happen to think it is wrong. But, what I do find interesting is that one of the big complaints of officers so relieved of their police authority, is that they can no longer carry their firearm off-duty. After all, if relying on the police to protect you is good enough for the mere citizens of this state, why are police officers so upset about having to do so as well?
What safety issues? Perhaps I can help clarify something? Public shooting organizations have night shoots? I know there might be issues as of late, but there is more to that story. Again, some groups can be their own worst enemies. The HPD has their own RSO's / instructors and certain units have their own medics (TEMS and EMT) on site at training. The HPD is responsible for the entire complex, including upper ranges on Mon and Tue all day. And are responsible for the upper ranges in the AM hours M-F and are responsible for the lower ranges M-F and of course like any other park, during any hours of night or day. This is a benefit to the City and the HPD. We must also understand that the City has quite a bit of liability and insurance issues to think about. Yes I understand how waiver's work, but this is a City property and your dealing with a City that is very liberal in nature.
Again, I think you miss the point...if HPD is required to have an RSO and medic in order to use our public range duing the times "we" cannot, then why can't a club or organization that meets these requirements use the range in similar fashion and during those same off-times. I know that when I am at one of our shoots, we have an RSO and medic present. And, at least to the best of my knowledge, I do not think HPD has any TEMS trained medics routinely deployed. I know a couple of the officers are former medics, and that EMS has been training some of the officers is more advanced first aid, but it's not TEMS....
Look, the bottom line is that neither I, nor anyone (at least as far as I can tell...) expressing concern over this issue have any "distain" for the police. And, furthermore most would be happy to share the range with HPD and other LE agencies if it could do so under the same rules for using it. So it's not cop bashing to suggest that they (the LE community) have to play by the same rules as everyone else and that the public be given at least the same opportunities to use the only public range as they are. No more, NO LESS
-
Here's another update from Tom Berg on FB:
Good News! The Firing Range resolution for Kalaeloa is up for adoption/a vote to pass full City Council on November 2- and the meeting will NOT take place at Honolulu Hale but Kapolei Hale! Stay tuned for more details. The Mayor is against this reso- he went public that we need to wait for HCDA to approve our plan first. Boooo. That could take years. Boooo hisss- keep up the fight as this hearing Nov 2 will be a battle as one Councilmember- Breene Harimoto is against the reso passing as well.
The reso will either be on the 10am agenda on Nov 2- or the 1pm agenda...as soon as that decision is made by the Council Chair I will post- but please pass the word- gear up and prep and mark your calendars. I really think the reso passed in committee because so many came forward and submitted testimony- for the Nov 2 hearing, we must improve upon that to counter the Mayor and naysayers who want to wait, and wait, and wait.
-
HCDA, ahh another government red tape machine. :P
-
It is not negative to point out the truth. HPD and other LE agengies DO get to use the range and DO get to disregard the rules that the general public must adhere to. Do LEOs get to use human targets? Yes. Do they get to do "holster presentations?" Yes. Do they get to use the range when it's "closed?" Yes. Does anyone from the public get to do this? Nope.
They are not disregarding any rules. They follow the rules that apply to their training needs. The City as the employer has a duty to train many things. Failure to do so would fall under deliberate indifference and we would all be paying out of our pockets. Not only the City derives a direct benefit, but so do you and I and all tax payers. I understand what you are attempting to say and I agree that the rules are different for LE and for the general shooting public. If you want to look at it from the City side of things as a Civil Suit issue, failure to train LE can cost them money. Allowing drawing from the holster, etc, etc, from the public can cost them money. So yes, LE is not restricted by the all the same rules that the City imposes on the public shooters. Again, I am not saying that I agree with all the rules that exist.
As for shooting after hours, clubs have done night shoots, after normal park hours. Again some people are their own worst enemies.
I never said you did...it was a word of my choosing. I disagree with your assertion that it is not a lack of planning. Let me ask you how much the academy range was supposed to cost and when was it supposed to open? I will let you research the issue but suffice it to say that it went WAY over budget and was opened far later than planned.
I have no need to research the issue. I understand it far too well. Disagree all you like but there is a lot more to it than you make it sound. Suffice it to say it was not a lack of planning on behalf of the HPD. You might want to research and have a better understanding of how the City works, especially with approval of funding and the entire process works for getting anything done. Not to mention the bid process and who wins them. Pick the lowest bidder and you might just get what you pay for. Your assertion is far more than a bit simplified.
And, the point you make that the range is closed when HPD uses it (even if you cite lack of funding as the cause) is exactly what we are talking about. Why can't a club or organization that agrees to use a RSO or adhere to a reasonable and objective safety standard, use the range during "off" hours just like HPD? I am sure the presence of armed, law-abiding citizens would have much the same deterrent affect as you suggest the presence of HPD does.
As I mentioned earlier clubs have been approved to use range time after hours. If they are having a difficult time getting range space now after hours, maybe we need to look at the reasons for this. FWIW when HPD uses the range after hours, the time frame is the same as placed on the clubs. I will say 99.9% that you won't hear a shot fired by an official HPD training event after 2000 hours. Lets just say that the Hawaii Kai community will be on the phone at 2001 hours if this happens. They also have a lot of pull.
When I have to clean up the bay after anyone else uses it, I don't normally complain either...I just do it. But the point, again, is that if the general public were to treat the ranges in the same fashion as HPD, or any of the other LE agencies do, they would not be "invited" back. Yet LE agencies keep getting to use the range. It is, again, an obvious case of disparate treatment. One where the "public" is subject to much more strict rules and significantly harsher punishment than LE in the same situation.
Sorry but I will have to disagree with you when it comes to the HPD. I am not speaking about the other LE agencies etc, who use the range. I will say that the HPD only fires brass cased ammo. That rarely lasts overnight and there are many people like Teichi who appreciates that. I am sure he can tell you that he is not alone. Rarely will this once fired brass last overnight. Again I will say that there are some very thankful people on the rifle side who find boxes of policed up brass sitting on the benches (again only speaking about the HPD). I rarely see the type of mess left on the lower ranges that I will find on a Monday.
I think you miss the point here. He was not trying to say HPD officers are less likely to be given harsher sentences when convicted. He was saying that in the course of doing their duties, an officer that has an otherwise "good" shoot but has the misfortune of injuring or killing an innocent bystander, or shooting the "wrong" person, is provided a level of immunity from civil and criminal prosecution that a citizen, in the same situation would not be afforded. As for the summary ROPA of any officer accused of impropriety, I happen to think it is wrong. But, what I do find interesting is that one of the big complaints of officers so relieved of their police authority, is that they can no longer carry their firearm off-duty. After all, if relying on the police to protect you is good enough for the mere citizens of this state, why are police officers so upset about having to do so as well?
When good people have to go after bad people, there are times when bad things happen. This really really sucks for everyone involved but it is reality. However attempting to mitigate the possibilities of this happening is why the HPD has a legal and moral obligation to train their Officers, which ties into what was discussed above about why the HPD is afforded the ability to train. We can cry all we want about allowing the public to have the ability to do more in their training, of which I agree and am a proponent, but coming off like HPD is violating some type of rules is silly. They are following the rules set forth upon them.
Again, I think you miss the point...if HPD is required to have an RSO and medic in order to use our public range duing the times "we" cannot, then why can't a club or organization that meets these requirements use the range in similar fashion and during those same off-times. I know that when I am at one of our shoots, we have an RSO and medic present. And, at least to the best of my knowledge, I do not think HPD has any TEMS trained medics routinely deployed. I know a couple of the officers are former medics, and that EMS has been training some of the officers is more advanced first aid, but it's not TEMS....
I never said the HPD is required to have a Medic on site during training. I stated that certain units may have their own medics. In brief on the TEMS topic, there are a lot more of them than you are obviously aware of. Also there are HPD units who have EMT qualified personnel. Not just former medics, but those who achieved EMT certifications after joining the HPD. There are also a handful who have gone through Military combat medic courses which are more advanced than EMT courses.
Where did I ever say that I am against public groups using range space during off hours? I am NOT against it. Suggesting anything otherwise is pure ignorance.
It would be of more benefit to refrain from wording my posts to suit certain arguments / agenda's. I am not against this community and many posts, including yours really are not helping the issues discussed here. I am a very reasonable person, but I am under no obligation to help clarify anything. Quite frankly, there is so much flat out incorrect information on SOP / MOP of the HPD that is discussed in many threads here. I would think that correct information and certain other opinions would be an asset to the issues discussed here?
Look, the bottom line is that neither I, nor anyone (at least as far as I can tell...) expressing concern over this issue have any "distain" for the police. And, furthermore most would be happy to share the range with HPD and other LE agencies if it could do so under the same rules for using it. So it's not cop bashing to suggest that they (the LE community) have to play by the same rules as everyone else and that the public be given at least the same opportunities to use the only public range as they are. No more, NO LESS
I never suggested "distain" for the police. As you mentioned you did as it was your choice of words. If anyone wants to go crying to the City that the public should be allowed to shoot and or train in similar ways as does the HPD, they will not get very far. I already gave reasons for the City's rebuttal. Simple reasons that the courts mandate certain training to avoid failure to train and deliberate indifference of patently obvious needs for training placed upon all LE. This need has not be set for the public and the City ears would be closed. We may not like or agree with the argument, but any law school student could tell you that the City has a good reason to shoot any proposals down and no one, not even the City council would vote otherwise. This is a liberal state and coming from that angle is setting ones self up for instant failure.
Again I support the issues discussed.
-
Just got this from Councilman Berg's 10/1/11 email newsletter:
EFFORT TO GET PUBLIC FIRING RANGE IN KALAELOA
The turnout in support of taking a small pre-existing, abandoned firing range in Kalaeloa and turning it into a potential revenue maker for the city passed the Parks and Cultural Affairs Committee earlier this week. Good news - Reso 11-263 is to be put on the full Council's agenda for a vote on November 2- of which hearing will be held at KAPOLEI HALE! See television coverage.
Sorry if this is old and/or redundant information
-
http://www.mszu.de/ (http://www.mszu.de/)
Check out the the German's indoor range. 25/100/300 meter rifle, Pistol Skeet, Trap, Pro shop and Restaurant. I better brush up on my German. This place is on my bucket list.
-
Sorry Surf, but you are incorrect, or I may be splitting hairs, but at a PUBLIC range, (and the only public range at that) the rules should be the same for every one. Including the LE community.
So yes, LE is not restricted by the all the same rules that the City imposes on the public shooters. Again, I am not saying that I agree with all the rules that exist.
As for shooting after hours, clubs have done night shoots, after normal park hours. Again some people are their own worst enemies.
Sorry again, but "not restricted by all the same rules" reads, to me, as being able to disregard the rules that we, John Q public must adhere to when using the range. As for "some People" being their own worst enemies, well, I think you should check up on the facts....in fact, there was ONE club that was allowed to do night shoots. When another entity tried to get range time at night, they were shot down and subsequent actions by the City (probably because they knew they were exposing themselves to legal challenges by disparate treatment....) was the reason the only club previously allowed to use the range at night "suddenly" lost that ability. No one, except HPD, has been able to use the range at night since....
I realize that the "government" has a duty to train in order to minimize their liability exposure, and I am actually fine with that. Again, my issue is the use of the public range, to the detriment of the public's ability to use the range, for police training. You can claim all the "it's for the greater good" and protection of the CIty from future legal claims, but it is, IMHO, a red herring that detracts from the admittedly simple concept of the public should be able to use their range, for their training, and that the police, with a viable alternative to satisfy their training needs, should not adversely affect that right. And, unless the range at the academy is running 24/7, then there is room to expanding the training opportunities there, which should lessen the need to use Kokohead.
And, speaking of the academy range, yes I did simplify it a bit, but not because of any lack of knowledge about the process by which City, State and Federal agencies have to use to procure services. But, the bottom line is that HPD had a measure of oversight of the project. That they OK'd the range to be opened only to discover the ventilation system was inadequate and that the subsequent delays were quite extended. There were other issues, but suffice it to say that HPD played no small role in some of the issues that caused the project to be over budget and delayed.
When I speak of the bays needing "cleaning" after use by LE (and I will be the first to admit I do not know if it is HPD or other agencies...) I am not talking about brass....I am talking about bottles and cans, used "humanoid" targets (another rule LE gets to "disregard" ), boxes and other refuse.
When good people have to go after bad people, there are times when bad things happen. This really really sucks for everyone involved but it is reality. However attempting to mitigate the possibilities of this happening is why the HPD has a legal and moral obligation to train their Officers, which ties into what was discussed above about why the HPD is afforded the ability to train. We can cry all we want about allowing the public to have the ability to do more in their training, of which I agree and am a proponent, but coming off like HPD is violating some type of rules is silly. They are following the rules set forth upon them.
And, when good people who are not LE have good reason to utilize the same tools that LE uses, and do not reap the benefit of qualified immunity in the tragic event a "bad" thing happens, the City and State have an arguably greater legal and moral obligation to allow citizens the ability to train in a similar fashion the LE community is allowed to do. And, personally, I take some offense to saying that trying to hold HPD to the same rules as regular users of the range is "silly." If shooting at humanoid targets is OK and beneficial to an objective training need for HPD, it should be OK for citizens to do the same. As far as I know, there is only one set of "rules" for the range, and many of those are unwritten or made up on the spot. I do not know of a second set of rules for LE, and that is the point. You can split hairs all you like in terms of the LE community not violating rules that "we" must adhere to because they "need" the training, but it seems pretty black and white to me. "We" have to follow the rules at the range, LE doesn't.
As for the TEMS issue, I think I understand the issue pretty good, even, dare I say, better than you. I know there are EMT's, and military trained medics, I even know of a couple of officers that were paramedics. I also know of current, ongoing training to officers, which although originally touted as "TEMS-like" is in reality far from any objective standards of a TEMS course.....and that, by the way, came from the admin responsible for doing the training.....so, if you have any officers certified in TEMS, point them out to the folks doing your training, 'cause they don't seem to know about them.
I appreciate that you think "we" should be able to use the range more often and in a simialr fashion as LE. I just disagree with your reasoning as to why LE gets a pass from many of the rules we now must adhere to....to that end, I think my position is pretty clear. It is obvious we disagree on terminology and possibly some philosophical issues, but I appreciate the conversation/debate. Because I recognize that an online forum may not confer all the nuances of a face-to-face discussion, I hope nothing I 'said' came across as attacking....and if so, it was unintentional.
Aloha
-
They (HPD) should have a shoot with the public day.
They could teach the public some pointers on the good shoots and the no shoots, handling, and increase public awareness and relations all in one swoop. Maybe the HPD and the gun owning public could build more trust with each other. After all, they are doing the job they are paid to do, they do not make the unfair laws we all must abide by, they only enforce them.
Also, the public can experience the level of difficulty the officers qual course can be.
Sound like a good idea, or am I living in a pipe dream??
-
fwiw, the armed guard test is harder than the HPD test, so are the LEOSA quals.
-
They (HPD) should have a shoot with the public day.
They could teach the public some pointers on the good shoots and the no shoots, handling, and increase public awareness and relations all in one swoop. Maybe the HPD and the gun owning public could build more trust with each other. After all, they are doing the job they are paid to do, they do not make the unfair laws we all must abide by, they only enforce them.
Also, the public can experience the level of difficulty the officers qual course can be.
Sound like a good idea, or am I living in a pipe dream??
Here's the issue I see with this one. With politically-correct, legislation-happy society: As unreasonable as people are, one WILL find a way to blame the homicide/manslaughter/wrongful death on the "paramilitary training" (<--- media spin) received by the city's occupying police force. Or, maybe there was a wrongful death; it could be from "lack of proper training" by the premier publicly-funded firearm training agency/program on the island.
Or maybe not. Who knows.
-
from what i've seen law enforcement is one of the least trained when it comes to firearms knowledge and as far the HPD goes they may not be the ones making the rules but they sure are quick to say those rules somehow protect them from criminals. To me that puts them against our goals.
-
I've called HPD Firearms Section twice regarding my AR and both times was told magazine capacity limit is 10 rounds. The law pertains to handguns and not rifles the way I understand it. There are retailers that sell higher capacity magazines than 10. I think they need some education regarding the laws they are supposed to be knowledgeable about otherwise their enforcement is purely subjective.
-
I've called HPD Firearms Section twice regarding my AR and both times was told magazine capacity limit is 10 rounds. The law pertains to handguns and not rifles the way I understand it. There are retailers that sell higher capacity magazines than 10. I think they need some education regarding the laws they are supposed to be knowledgeable about otherwise their enforcement is purely subjective.
nothing to do with the range. Let's not go down that road about AR mags.
-
I've called HPD Firearms Section twice regarding my AR and both times was told magazine capacity limit is 10 rounds. The law pertains to handguns and not rifles the way I understand it. There are retailers that sell higher capacity magazines than 10. I think they need some education regarding the laws they are supposed to be knowledgeable about otherwise their enforcement is purely subjective.
The language of the statue is magazines "capable of being used" in handguns. With the statutory language defining a handgun as anything with a barrel less than 16 inches, most rifle magazines can be used in "handguns" and therefore are limited to 10 rounds.
You should review the prior threads on this subject to see a more detailed discussion onthe subject.
-
fwiw, the armed guard test is harder than the HPD test, so are the LEOSA quals.
I was speaking to a neighbor island cop a couple of weeks ago about this and he agrees....as someone who is going to retire soon he too was expressing his concerns that the quals for LEOSA are more stringent than those for active duty officers.....
-
Hey, Moderators...
Any chance we can split this topic? There are those of us who really do want to stay abreast of developments in the firing range initiative, but couldn't care much less about debates over what HPD gets away with. ;) Just sayin'
-
Hey, Moderators...
Any chance we can split this topic? There are those of us who really do want to stay abreast of developments in the firing range initiative, but couldn't care much less about debates over what HPD gets away with. ;) Just sayin'
I second the motion.
-
Hey, Moderators...
Any chance we can split this topic? There are those of us who really do want to stay abreast of developments in the firing range initiative, but couldn't care much less about debates over what HPD gets away with. ;) Just sayin'
I second the motion.
There is way to much shit to split, just get :stopjack:
-
:popcorn: The hearing is coming up today! Hope all goes well, and I hope a lot of folks are able to attend. If you have not submitted a letter do it now! haha! :shaka:
-
Anyone have a update about how it went today?
-
All I know is, it passed. Now we play the waiting game.
-
All I know is, it passed. Now we play the waiting game.
Awesome, and unfortunately I wasn't able to take time off of work today to partake in the festivities. However I'm curious if someone can break this down Barney style for me as to what was exactly got accomplished today and what is needed to happen next, etc.... Excuse my lack of understanding the thorough process and legal matters that is encompassing this whole ordeal.
-
I'm far from an expert, but I was asking Funtimes some of the same questions on the facebook page. As I understand it, the resolution isn't binding, which is unfortunate, because now the mayor will be the next hurdle. In any event, the city hasn't taken over the land yet, but apparently once it does a non-profit like HDF or HRA or some other outfit can get started planning and doing up the range. I'm told the very first thing that will likely happen will be renovation of the pistol range, since there'll be much less red tape for pistols than for rifles as far as stray bullets go. I guess the first big question is whether it'll be indoor or outdoor; my vote is personally for outdoor.
That's about all I know; it isn't much, and is probably subject to change pending someone weighing in who knows more than I do, but hopefully that'll tide you over until they get here. :thumbsup:
-
I'm far from an expert, but I was asking Funtimes some of the same questions on the facebook page. As I understand it, the resolution isn't binding, which is unfortunate, because now the mayor will be the next hurdle. In any event, the city hasn't taken over the land yet, but apparently once it does a non-profit like HDF or HRA or some other outfit can get started planning and doing up the range. I'm told the very first thing that will likely happen will be renovation of the pistol range, since there'll be much less red tape for pistols than for rifles as far as stray bullets go. I guess the first big question is whether it'll be indoor or outdoor; my vote is personally for outdoor.
That's about all I know; it isn't much, and is probably subject to change pending someone weighing in who knows more than I do, but hopefully that'll tide you over until they get here. :thumbsup:
i would assume it would be outdoor, just because itʻs an old navy firing range which is now overgrown. If you ever drove through barbers point, chances are you drove right pass the entrance without even knowing it.
-
There is going to be a lot of QQ on indoor / outdoor. We will have to wait and see. Personally, I have scoped out the costs of indoor ranges and it would cost around 40k a lane for purchase + operating expenses. Outdoor is really easy to setup and control, and would be a great start.
-
Councilman Berg thinks indoor is the way to go; he's concerned about HASECO raising a stink because their housing developments would be within earshot of the range. I don't know what the rules and regulations are, it seems like an outdoor range would be cheaper both to build and to maintain, but I guess it would face more opposition than an indoor range. What I'm wondering about is the private venture, worth the cost thing that Berg talks about. We already have a number of private indoor ranges, and I don't think their high cost is due to a lack of competition, is it? I suppose if it were run by a non-profit organization or something it might work better than a strictly business venture. Personally, I don't really like government funding of things, but I'd advocate government funds for public shooting ranges way before golf courses, or swimming pools, or dog parks. Nobody's ever had a negligent discharge of a golf club due to a lack of training!
-
Councilman Berg thinks indoor is the way to go; he's concerned about HASECO raising a stink because their housing developments would be within earshot of the range. I don't know what the rules and regulations are, it seems like an outdoor range would be cheaper both to build and to maintain, but I guess it would face more opposition than an indoor range. What I'm wondering about is the private venture, worth the cost thing that Berg talks about. We already have a number of private indoor ranges, and I don't think their high cost is due to a lack of competition, is it? I suppose if it were run by a non-profit organization or something it might work better than a strictly business venture. Personally, I don't really like government funding of things, but I'd advocate government funds for public shooting ranges way before golf courses, or swimming pools, or dog parks. Nobody's ever had a negligent discharge of a golf club due to a lack of training!
Land and space is always a big factor. There are already ranges in the area, so I don't know. Once it's approved as a range.... we can start from there. It will have to be a partnership between multiple entities. One of them will have to be a charitable association, otherwise it will be hard to get the $$$.
-
At least were moving forward sorta
-
Anybody know the status of this?