2aHawaii
General Topics => Off Topic => Topic started by: suka on September 20, 2015, 05:47:54 AM
-
Residential electricity rates in Hawaii average 37.34¢/kWh, which ranks the state 1st in the nation.
The Nation average is 11.88¢/kWh.
It is 7.34¢/kWh in PA.
The average residential electricity rate of 37.34¢/kWh in HI is 214.31% greater than the national average residential rate of 11.88¢/kWh.
PRICES DOES NOT INCLUDE TAXES AND OTHER SURCHARGES !!!!!! :wtf:
-
We have a warehouse in an Industrial area and is paying
The average industrial electricity rate in .................. is 1.35¢/kWh.
This average (industrial) electricity rate in ................is 81.33% less than the Pennsylvania average rate of 7.23¢/kWh.
The average (industrial) electricity rate in ................is 79.76% less than the national average rate of 6.67¢/kWh.
Industrial rates in the U.S. range from 4.13¢/kWh to 30.82¢/kWh.
-
That industrial rate is here on Oahu?
I always wondered why the industrial rate would be cheaper, I figured it would be more expensive since they use more. Maybe they get it in bulk price...
I bet the neighbor islands pay more than Oahu though.
-
Price is from West Penn Power.
Highest in the nation is HILO at 42.3 ¢/kWh
-
Commercial and Industrial power comes in normally at 380v or 240v, all of which is 3 phase.
I have seen them come in at 600v.
It may cheaper for the power company not to step it down to 220v single phase for residential.
-
It's not just the energy usage that commercial clients pay. The big energy users also have a demand meter. measured in kW They pay for the energy used as well as the "energy generation capacity" they demanded that month.
When a business has big AC chillers, shop machines, electric motors running who knows what, warehouse lighting and vast amounts of refrigeration, HECO has to plan on generating enough power to run everything there. The investment to have that generating capacity in place is borne by the customers whose demand requires the extra production capacity.
So, even if they don't use it (kWh), they still pay into the kitty for being able to use it when they do need it (kW).
HECO has "tariff schedules" to classify customers into categories for billing. Schedule J is the majority of big businesses/buildings here. The cost for demand per month is $11.69/kW They pay based on the greatest level of metered demand, whether or not they actually use that much all month long.
They also pay a monthly service fee of $60 for single phase service, and $82.00 for three-phase. The kWh (energy usage) charge is 16.9734 cents per kWh.
There's also a Supply Voltage Delivery discount if HECO doesn't have to go through a transformer. If the customer takes the voltage at the transmission level, the discount is 2.9%. If they can use it at distribution voltage, the discount is 2.1%. They do this because there is a loss associated with transmission which varies by island. The transformers require more energy generated to deliver it, to compensate for the loss factor. If they don't go through transformers, less energy must be generated for delivery, hence a discount.
There are other adjustments. All the schedules are on HECO's site:
http://www.hawaiianelectric.com/heco/Residential/Electric-Rates/Hawaiian-Electric-Rates
If you are curious about residential charges, that would usually fall under schedule R. Small business are usually schedule G (General).
Let me know if you have any questions. I work for Hawaii Energy, the state's conservation and efficiency contractor. We aren't HECO, although I have access to energy usage/demand databases. :)
We are also the people who process and pay rebates on energy efficient appliances, CFL and LED light bulbs, etc. If you walk through Costco or Home Depot, you'll see signs with Hawaii Energy on them offering rebates for energy saving appliances and bulbs -- paid down using our program's funds. :thumbsup:
We also have some web tools to show you how your energy usage compares to people near you.
https://hawaiienergy.com
-
thank you dog,
that is some great info!
-
Not only is HECO expensive, they also suck for reliability because the power always goes out in Hawaii for the smallest things, or no reason at all. That never happened to me in any other state.
-
Not only is HECO expensive, they also suck for reliability because the power always goes out in Hawaii for the smallest things, or no reason at all. That never happened to me in any other state.
The whole North America is under one giant grid.
All transmissions lines are all interconnected somehow.
-
The whole North America is under one giant grid.
All transmissions lines are all interconnected somehow.
On the mainland, power companies can buy power from other states/companies if they have the need. If a generator is down, distribution path is offline, or the local demand is just exceeding capacity, they can substitute or augment their power from other plants.
There is no cable to join Hawaii's power grid with anyone else. So if something fails, we are SOL until it's fixed.
There were proposals to join Oahu and Maui to feed Oahu's grid in the event we had generator failure. A new proposal is looking for a 2-way cable to basically operate both Oahu and Maui power plants together as one, eliminating redundancy and dismantling generators in favor of green/clean energy alternatives.
http://energy.hawaii.gov/renewable-energy/oahu-maui-gridtie
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/10/30/undersea-cable-oahu-maui_n_4179529.html
-
Nuclear...... safe , cheap, green.
anyway we look at it , at the end of the days it still a giant steam engine.
-
I've heard the generator/grid excuse before, but I'm not sure I buy into that. No matter how infallible the generators, or redundant the grid system, if the local power lines to your house or neighborhood are damaged, you will lose power for a short while. Those are the kind of frequent outages I experience, not the longer ones which are due to generator failure (such as when we had those earthquakes that left some of us without power for days). Why is it that on average I experience one short power outage every couple months, while on the mainland I experienced no power outages, ever?
-
I've heard the generator/grid excuse before, but I'm not sure I buy into that. No matter how infallible the generators, or redundant the grid system, if the local power lines to your house or neighborhood are damaged, you will lose power for a short while. Those are the kind of frequent outages I experience, not the longer ones which are due to generator failure (such as when we had those earthquakes that left some of us without power for days). Why is it that on average I experience one short power outage every couple months, while on the mainland I experienced no power outages, ever?
Not sure where you live, but Mililani has buried nearly all their power lines. Trees, wind and heavy rain don't damage the lines, so localized interruption here is very uncommon. When we see problems, it's when a transformer or component at the substation fails, but that's rare. The last time I remember an outage at my house not related to a generator problem was an idiot running into some electric device down the street. The power company had to cut the power on the street to fix it. It was a very short interruption of service.
The majority of issues here, as with most places, isn't black outs, but brown outs. When voltage drops, it can screw with your electronic devices. I've sat here and heard my UPS backups kick in for a couple of seconds. The lights barely dimmed, but the voltage dropped enough to trigger the UPS on the computers.
I'd recommend an UPS on all sensitive electronic equipment to guard against voltage drops. Will save you money and headaches in the long run.
-
dog,
how's the quality of the sine waves and frequncies from the outlets
I don't have my ocilascope anymore and curious
-
dog,
how's the quality of the sine waves and frequncies from the outlets
I don't have my ocilascope anymore and curious
I've never used any instruments other than the readings on my UPS. The new ones have some nice basic readings, but nothing as accurate as quality test equipment could show. I'm actually afraid to check ... :shake:
The UPS says I get exactly 60 Hz Freq cycle. Voltage usually shows above 110v AC, usually in the 120-124 range. Now and then I see it drop down to the 116v area.
-
Typical sine wave from your home outlet.
(http://www.smartmetereducationnetwork.com/images/dirty-electricity/Dirty%20Electricity,%20Windmills.png)
-
Typical sine wave from your home outlet.
Typical sign wave in Mililani ....
(http://i.imgur.com/xihL2zx.jpg)
:D
-
Typical sine wave from your home outlet.
(http://www.smartmetereducationnetwork.com/images/dirty-electricity/Dirty%20Electricity,%20Windmills.png)
not exactly pure... clean...
Typical sign wave in Mililani ....
(http://i.imgur.com/xihL2zx.jpg)
:D
married to my neighbor..
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_S._Chang
(http://static1.squarespace.com/static/513939c7e4b073120966609d/t/51423f03e4b037dd5e206f47/1363296026947/DavidChangPhoto.jpg?format=500w)
http://changholding.com/ceodavidchang/ (http://changholding.com/ceodavidchang/)
-
Commercial and Industrial power comes in normally at 380v or 240v, all of which is 3 phase.
I have seen them come in at 600v.
It may cheaper for the power company not to step it down to 220v single phase for residential.
I have a very basic understanding of electricity but the phase thing confuses me. I guess you are saying though that it costs extra to convert the 3 phase down to another level that is used by a residential area? I have seen warnings about making sure not to use certain electrical motors on certain types of phase electricity sources which left me worried since I don't know which phase comes out of my home and which phase particular power tools work at.
-
hahahahaha
-
nearly all residential power with 110/220v in the US are single phase.
(http://i.stack.imgur.com/HdUzm.gif)
(http://www.bristolwatch.com/ele/img/pole_xformer.jpg)
3 Phase service
(http://www.engineeringradio.us/blog/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/3-phase-delta.png)
(http://waterheatertimer.org/images/3-phase-transformers-IMG_2333-700.jpg)
(http://waterheatertimer.org/images/3-phase-from-single-phase-550.jpg)
-
https://youtu.be/hWyO7FCDMig
-
HaHa, Thats Euproean power....
ANSI uses 220v it comes in on 3 lines lines , two insulated hot wires and a bare ground cable. 3Phase has 4 wires coming in 3 hot wires and a bare ground.
-
HaHa, Thats Euproean power....
ANSI uses 220v it comes in on 3 lines lines , two insulated hot wires and a bare ground cable. 3Phase has 4 wires coming in 3 hot wires and a bare ground.
I liked the accent and the cute drawings :)
-
Shhhhh, Im hunting Wabbits......
-
I have a very basic understanding of electricity but the phase thing confuses me. I guess you are saying though that it costs extra to convert the 3 phase down to another level that is used by a residential area? I have seen warnings about making sure not to use certain electrical motors on certain types of phase electricity sources which left me worried since I don't know which phase comes out of my home and which phase particular power tools work at.
Here's the way I understand 3-phase vs. single phase power. If you look at the sine wave graph that Suka posted, which I believe is a graph of voltage over time, you'll see peaks and valleys and a horizontal line (the one with the sub-major tick marks) about halfway in between the peaks and valleys. 60 times per second, the voltage delivered from your outlet is zero (where the graph crosses the mid-line). With three phase power, imagine two more lines on that graph, each with peaks and valleys offset by one third of the distance. Since voltage is the measurement for electromotive force, the three phases of power enable the delivery of more power more consistently with less wire required. (hat tip to Wikipedia) Three phase is generally used for higher load applications (because of the increased power, i.e. the increased capability to do "work").
Anytime you convert electricity in voltage (and I assume in phase), it's never 100% efficient, which is why it's more expensive. Say, for a completely random example, your house requires 2500 watts of power, and the overall efficiency of the system that gets the electricity to your house is 90%... That means that HECO would have to produce 2777 watts to supply 2500 watts to you (2500/.9= (about) 2777).
Caveat: I am not an electrical engineer, and I almost failed the one electrical engineering course I took in college. Anybody who understands it better, please correct me...
-
Shhhhh, Im hunting Wabbits......
duck season!
-
Here's the way I understand 3-phase vs. single phase power. If you look at the sine wave graph that Suka posted, which I believe is a graph of voltage over time, you'll see peaks and valleys and a horizontal line (the one with the sub-major tick marks) about halfway in between the peaks and valleys. 60 times per second, the voltage delivered from your outlet is zero (where the graph crosses the mid-line). With three phase power, imagine two more lines on that graph, each with peaks and valleys offset by one third of the distance. Since voltage is the measurement for electromotive force, the three phases of power enable the delivery of more power more consistently with less wire required. (hat tip to Wikipedia) Three phase is generally used for higher load applications (because of the increased power, i.e. the increased capability to do "work").
Anytime you convert electricity in voltage (and I assume in phase), it's never 100% efficient, which is why it's more expensive. Say, for a completely random example, your house requires 2500 watts of power, and the overall efficiency of the system that gets the electricity to your house is 90%... That means that HECO would have to produce 2777 watts to supply 2500 watts to you (2500/.9= (about) 2777).
Caveat: I am not an electrical engineer, and I almost failed the one electrical engineering course I took in college. Anybody who understands it better, please correct me...
As Suka said, there are usually 2 "hot" lines and a neutral coming into homes. Those are 2 x 120v single phase lines. That provides the 240 to the service box. Breakers touch either one or both of the lines via the bars inside the circuit breaker box to provide either a 120v or 240v circuit to the outlets.
A 3 phase application uses 3 lines to deliver 3 single phase 120v connections and one 208v 3-phase circuit. The timing of the 3 phase lines must be correct, or the circuit is out of balance and can cause inefficiencies in the energy usage (higher bill and possible detrimental effects on the equipment being used).
Current is what pushes energy through the lines. It takes less current to deliver the 3-phase voltage than the single phase voltage. Current is measured in AMPs. The more amps it takes to deliver the electricity, the thicker the wires must be to safely sustain the heat generated.
I'm not an electrician either, but I've learned quite a lot about basic electrical wiring and service working on my own homes . My present (current? :) ) job also requires more than a casual understanding of how electricity is generated by HECO and used by business and residential customers. My boss is an electrical engineer and knows pretty much everything electrical, so any questions I have are quick to get a good answer that I can understand! :geekdanc:
-
Those are pretty good explanations, thanks. The part about how the line is not in use for a portion of the time makes a lot of sense, like you are timing for that little open window to send your signal and then after yours is the next will have a tiny window to send theirs?
I came across the warning when reading about motors for belt sanders for knife making, something about certain phase motors. The phase system makes sense I guess but still not sure about compatibility. Maybe it will work one way but not the other, like a 3 phase motor will work on a 1 phase but a 1 phase will not work on a 3 phase? Or is that type of thing not something that will come into play for those using normal power tools in a home setting?
-
Those are pretty good explanations, thanks. The part about how the line is not in use for a portion of the time makes a lot of sense, like you are timing for that little open window to send your signal and then after yours is the next will have a tiny window to send theirs?
I came across the warning when reading about motors for belt sanders for knife making, something about certain phase motors. The phase system makes sense I guess but still not sure about compatibility. Maybe it will work one way but not the other, like a 3 phase motor will work on a 1 phase but a 1 phase will not work on a 3 phase? Or is that type of thing not something that will come into play for those using normal power tools in a home setting?
If all your circuits at home are all 120v or 240v +/- 10V, then you have single phase service. Homes for the most part get power from transformers which are connected to substations. The power at substations are generally being fed with 3 phase lines. When it travels to your transformer in your neighborhood, it is probably already stepped down to 120v single phase. From the local transformer to the meter, you'll have 2 120v lines and a neutral. So there's little worry of having 3 phase on a circuit at home.
3 phase is capable of being used to service a home. A large place with 2 stories, a basement, an additional house out back for grandma, a large garage and worksop, and lots of electric demand could have 3 phase coming into the house. It would just be an unusual situation. If you can find the service line connection on your house, count the incoming lines. If you see 4, then you may actually have 3 phase coming in. How it's distributed in your home would then be the question.
Just like hooking up a 240v appliance, the types of plugs will indicate the voltage. So don't worry about putting a 208v motor on the wrong outlet. There are specific outlets and plugs that match to keep voltages and amperages together. You can't plug a washer into a dryer outlet, for example, or a dishwasher into a range outlet. A 20AMP 120v outlet has an extra notch on one prong that allows you to use 20Amp plugs with a sideways prong as well as normal lower amp devices with regular 120v plugs. The sideways prong on the 20A plug prevents you from plugging it into a lower amp circuit.
Some machines might actually be able to handle 208v or 240v outlet connections. The plugs and outlets they match will let you know if they are compatible.
Here's one example of a 208v plug ...
(http://i.imgur.com/4U4cwMEm.png)
-
With three phase power, imagine two more lines on that graph, each with peaks and valleys offset by one third of the distance.
Your description most accurately describes the current wave that flows in the ground wire of a 3-phase system. Further, if you think about, assuming all your 3 sine waves are of equal amplitude (voltage) the sum of all 3 with offset phases should equal zero current. And indeed, it is not uncommon for 3-phase systems to completely omit the ground (return current) wire, as it is not needed to complete a circuit, in part due to this reason (the "ground" wire is always supposed to carry zero current in theory). Note that engineers call this a ground wire, but a physicist might not, as it is not a wire that connects a circuit to the earth (which is what physicists as well as engineers call a grounding wire).
Part of the reason 3-phase design is most commonly used in energy transmission is that you can just dump the ground (return wire) and thus eliminate one-quarter to one-half (depending on how you look at it) of all the wire you are using in the world, saving on wire cost.
From the point of view of ordinary household power outlets and electronic devices you use, 3-phase power is invisible because by the time it gets to you, it's just an ordinary single-phase circuit. Only 1 of the 3 wires/waves/phases physically goes to your house or outlet, and each phase is like a single-phase circuit.
There is yet another terminology clash with physicists and engineers over what a single-phase circuit means. For this post I am using the physics/high school definition of single-phase circuit: a basic loop circuit. The picture that suka posted at the top of this page is what physicists might call a split-phase circuit. However, engineers got lazy and started calling that a single-phase circuit, too. A better name for split-phase circuit would be to call it a 2-phase circuit, not single-phase circuit. (But instead, engineers call something else a 2-phase circuit, something that is never used in practice).
I probably should understand 3-phase power better than most people (my job description has been mentioned in this thread) but I don't really care about it. I have a master's degree in theoretical physics yet never learned about it in school. I believe it's something that only electrical engineers concern themselves with.
-
Three Phase has three separate circuits with phases 120 Degrees apart. You need three separate transformers, one for each phase.
The primary on each is fed with a single phase and produces an output of a single phase on 208 (Y) or 240 (Delta) VAC. Depending on
whether the circuit is Wye or Delta, you can have multiple voltages. Each phase-pair carries the full voltage. On Wye with Neutral, the
voltage between the phase and Neutral will be slightly less than three-fifths of (it's one-third of the square root of 3, for electronics geeks)
the voltage between each phase leg. On Delta, you only have each phase available with no Neutral.
(http://i.imgur.com/UfobYLE.png)
If we hook up an oscilloscope to each of the line terminals, we see the following waveform, three independent power paths, 120 degrees
phase shifted which when applied to a three phase motor, provide a rotating vortex magnetic field which makes 3 phase motors self-starting
without the requirement of a start capacitor, start winding or other method of kludging in a phase shifted winding to provide the rotational force
to start the motor spinning.
(http://i.imgur.com/a1wKtse.png)
http://diy.stackexchange.com/questions/42043/whats-the-difference-between-three-phase-240-v-and-standard-household-240-v