2aHawaii
General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: causa mortis on December 11, 2015, 12:06:03 PM
-
Like the title says. I'm thinking about getting a .357 revolver and these are the two models I have in mind. I'm asking the members that have owned/fired one or both what they would prefer. Thanks.
-
Reload Hawaii did a review on this
https://youtu.be/1c8zhJ-Xex8
-
Personally, I don't think you can go wrong with either of these two revolvers. I think if money was no object I would buy the S&W. If money was a concern I would not hesitate to buy the Ruger. I own both Ruger and Smith revolvers and enjoy them both. Not these exact models. I have owned a 686 and I own the previous model to the GP100 which is a similar design. I have shot the GP100 extensively as well, though. The Smith is probably a little more refined looking and feeling which is why if money was no object I would buy it over the Ruger.
Otherwise I would say guns are worth the money.
-
My recommendation: get both!
I have the 686, have owned a 586, and I have the SP101. The 686 is the PLUS model with 7-rd cylinder and 6" barrel. My SP101 holds 5 rds and has the 3" barrel. Obviously, each has it's own benefits and drawbacks.
The GP100 is available in many barrel lengths and holds 6 rds.
You need to look at all the options each model offers and any aftermarket accessories you may want to add. Some accessories like holsters are very common in 4" and 6" sizes, but a 3" barrel limits your available options. Same hold true for the 7-rd cylinder. Not all manufacturers that make speedloaders offer them to fit the 686+ 7-rd models.
So, look at capacity, barrel, sights, accessories, grips, etc. Make a list of all your preferences. THEN go shopping. You'll see it's very difficult to find every one of your top choices available at all local and online retailers. an LGS can order what you want, but special orders can be more expensive.
I bought my 686+ locally when it went on sale. I bought one SP101 brand new online during a sale, and the local FFL I shipped it to told me I paid well below their cost. My second SP101 I bought used.
Do some "window shopping," prioritize your preferences, and pick up the first one you come across at a good price. You might even run across an earlier model revolver in brand new condition. Many seek out the pre-lock era revolvers, as it has been reported some actually have had the built-in locks engage while shooting. That could be a bad thing!
Have fun!
-
So. for someone that detests double action triggers pulls, which is better out out the box?
Had a Ruger Super Redhawk that I attempted to improve the DA pull on, to little avail.
Did handle a small SW snubby something or other a guy was passing around to hype his trigger services and it was quite smooth. Would want a gun a lot closer to that from the start before I would consider a DA revolver.
Heck, a Glock is far smoother than any DA first or stock revolver. Always hoping of course.
-
Personally, I don't think you can go wrong with either of these two revolvers. I think if money was no object I would buy the S&W. If money was a concern I would not hesitate to buy the Ruger. I own both Ruger and Smith revolvers and enjoy them both. Not these exact models. I have owned a 686 and I own the previous model to the GP100 which is a similar design. I have shot the GP100 extensively as well, though. The Smith is probably a little more refined looking and feeling which is why if money was no object I would buy it over the Ruger.
Those would be my comments if Inspector didn't post them first. :thumbsup: I have shot both and if I had to pick one, it would be the Smith by the SLIGHTEST of margins because it felt more comfortable in my hands...no macsak :wave: comments please.
-
GP100 for the win.
-
Find an older Smith for the trigger and external firing pin.
With either one, if don't hit what your shooting at, you can beat it to death.
Is it worth the price difference ?
That's the question.....
And lots of Ruger fans among our members.
Must be for a reason.
-
If you show up to the next HDF free shoot, you can try out my GP100.
-
If you show up to the next HDF free shoot, you can try out my GP100.
HI FRED!
-
GP100! :thumbsup:
I needed to have one for each hand
and one of each color bc I don't discriminate
the stainless one is about 30 years old, still like new. but it wasn't shot much either.
S&W are great revolvers too.
I have 2 GP100's and they are my favorite handguns to shoot.
Ruger......built like a tank
(http://i243.photobucket.com/albums/ff26/onederful100/guns/gp100%20twins.jpg) (http://s243.photobucket.com/user/onederful100/media/guns/gp100%20twins.jpg.html)
(http://i243.photobucket.com/albums/ff26/onederful100/guns/gp100%20twins1.jpg) (http://s243.photobucket.com/user/onederful100/media/guns/gp100%20twins1.jpg.html)
-
GP100! :thumbsup:
I needed to have one for each hand
and one of each color bc I don't discriminate
the stainless one is about 30 years old, still like new. but it wasn't shot much either.
S&W are great revolvers too.
I have 2 GP100's and they are my favorite handguns to shoot.
Ruger......built like a tank
(http://i243.photobucket.com/albums/ff26/onederful100/guns/gp100%20twins.jpg) (http://s243.photobucket.com/user/onederful100/media/guns/gp100%20twins.jpg.html)
(http://i243.photobucket.com/albums/ff26/onederful100/guns/gp100%20twins1.jpg) (http://s243.photobucket.com/user/onederful100/media/guns/gp100%20twins1.jpg.html)
black revolvers matter!
-
I think this thread just proves everyone has their preferences. It seems split pretty evenly. And that there is nothing bad that can be said about either revolver/brand.
-
Get a Colt(http://images.tapatalk-cdn.com/15/12/13/e80c417e3eaf8da2fa78fdfd2961087c.jpg)lol!
(http://images.tapatalk-cdn.com/15/12/13/6f382a61472685c0419ebe41c56eb3ce.jpg)Colt Trooper Mk III on the left and a S&W 586 on the right.
-
If I were going to get a GP100 I would probably opt for the Match Champion model:
http://www.ruger.com/products/gp100MatchChampion/models.html
-
I got the GP100 in 6". Now I want a smith probably the model 60 though.
-
Those girls lookin' sexy! Good pic bro. :thumbsup:
-
Those would be my comments if Inspector didn't post them first. :thumbsup: I have shot both and if I had to pick one, it would be the Smith by the SLIGHTEST of margins because it felt more comfortable in my hands...no macsak :wave: comments please.
You've held Macsak in your hands?......Never mind, don't want to know.......... :stopjack:
-
I've owned my S&W Model 686 Plus with 4 inch barrel for some years now. It is my favorite gun to shoot. Ruger is nice also and I'm planning on buying a Super Redhawk Alaskan. Go big or go home :-)
-
You've held Macsak in your hands?......Never mind, don't want to know.......... :stopjack:
It took you over two months to come up with that? ???
-
I got a gp100 match champ and a 686 pro in the shop. I love my rugers but man that 686 is smooth. I might pick up that 686 pro.