2aHawaii

General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: antoinebugleboy on October 15, 2011, 09:22:31 PM

Title: BAD NEWS: My SIG/GSG 1911 22 broke!
Post by: antoinebugleboy on October 15, 2011, 09:22:31 PM
I was at the silhouette range with my wife today, shooting the 1911 22 and having fun, when all of a sudden, the guide rod flew out of my gun! When I disassembled my gun and took a look at it, it was exactly like what you see in this video:

GSG 1911 Broken Guide Rod (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6aazxqysqRM#ws)

To top it off, the spring flew off and I can't find it. :(  I think there's a general recall on these guns, too. I'll have to call SIG Monday and find out for sure. It's a fun gun, and other than this, I haven't had any real problems with it, though I'm finding some uncomplimentary things on the web about this gun: slides cracking big pieces off, chunks flying off, etc. Looking closely at my gun, I see a "fault line" in the back of the slide where the hammer drops.

Needless to say, I'm very disappointed. I guess I'll have to retract my recommendation for this gun and suggest instead that if you want to shoot 22s out of a 1911, get a real 1911 get a conversion kit. :-/
Title: Re: BAD NEWS: My SIG/GSG 1911 22 broke!
Post by: Colt808 on October 15, 2011, 09:37:10 PM
I was at the silhouette range with my wife today, shooting the 1911 22 and having fun, when all of a sudden, the guide rod flew out of my gun! When I disassembled my gun and took a look at it, it was exactly like what you see in this video:

GSG 1911 Broken Guide Rod (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6aazxqysqRM#ws)

To top it off, the spring flew off and I can't find it. :(  I think there's a general recall on these guns, too. I'll have to call SIG Monday and find out for sure. It's a fun gun, and other than this, I haven't had any real problems with it, though I'm finding some uncomplimentary things on the web about this gun: slides cracking big pieces off, chunks flying off, etc. Looking closely at my gun, I see a "fault line" in the back of the slide where the hammer drops.

Needless to say, I'm very disappointed. I guess I'll have to retract my recommendation for this gun and suggest instead that if you want to shoot 22s out of a 1911, get a real 1911 get a conversion kit. :-/

That sucks, but as long as no one was hurt.  My brother-in-law had the same issue. He called, gave them the serial # and received a parts kit 4 days later.
Title: Re: BAD NEWS: My SIG/GSG 1911 22 broke!
Post by: sirkaiks on October 15, 2011, 09:38:01 PM
damn man!  but it was so pretty! hope everything works out.
Title: Re: BAD NEWS: My SIG/GSG 1911 22 broke!
Post by: Funtimes on October 15, 2011, 09:54:11 PM
*cough* 1911!!!  /cymbaltap!
Title: Re: BAD NEWS: My SIG/GSG 1911 22 broke!
Post by: 42itus on October 15, 2011, 09:58:59 PM
that sucks.  but we're lucky you or anyone around you didn't get hurt.
Title: Re: BAD NEWS: My SIG/GSG 1911 22 broke!
Post by: Kingkeoni on October 15, 2011, 10:09:11 PM
I hope they fix it for you but after this, might I recommend a Ruger Mark 3.

This gun is built SOLID

I have three of these Rugers.

Two Mark 2's and a Mark 3.

Great 22lr pistols.
Title: Re: BAD NEWS: My SIG/GSG 1911 22 broke!
Post by: antoinebugleboy on October 15, 2011, 10:23:42 PM
My original choices were the Ruger Mark III and Glock 17, but I got swayed by lower prices (which, in the end, didn't turn out to be that much lower). Looking back, if I could do it again, I'd probably get the Ruger Mark III and Glock 19. I still like my guns, but with this guide rod problem, and the P250's long double-action only trigger pull, I'm having some minor regrets.
Title: Re: BAD NEWS: My SIG/GSG 1911 22 broke!
Post by: Foxen on October 15, 2011, 10:52:23 PM
Sorry to hear that... =(
Title: Re: BAD NEWS: My SIG/GSG 1911 22 broke!
Post by: Jaydawg on October 16, 2011, 05:42:51 AM
Ouch!  I'm glad no one got hurt. 
Title: Re: BAD NEWS: My SIG/GSG 1911 22 broke!
Post by: Kingkeoni on October 16, 2011, 05:45:48 AM
My original choices were the Ruger Mark III and Glock 17

Two excellent guns
Title: Re: BAD NEWS: My SIG/GSG 1911 22 broke!
Post by: antoinebugleboy on October 17, 2011, 07:07:13 AM
Called SIG this morning and they're shipping out a replacement part. Didn't even ask for my serial number.  :thumbsup:
Title: Re: BAD NEWS: My SIG/GSG 1911 22 broke!
Post by: sirkaiks on October 17, 2011, 12:53:39 PM
Called SIG this morning and they're shipping out a replacement part. Didn't even ask for my serial number.  :thumbsup:

good to hear :thumbsup:
Title: Re: BAD NEWS: My SIG/GSG 1911 22 broke!
Post by: GZire on October 17, 2011, 04:09:53 PM
My original choices were the Ruger Mark III and Glock 17, but I got swayed by lower prices (which, in the end, didn't turn out to be that much lower). Looking back, if I could do it again, I'd probably get the Ruger Mark III and Glock 19. I still like my guns, but with this guide rod problem, and the P250's long double-action only trigger pull, I'm having some minor regrets.

Luckily for you this is not permanent.  You can fix it and sell it.
Title: Re: BAD NEWS: My SIG/GSG 1911 22 broke!
Post by: antoinebugleboy on October 17, 2011, 04:56:15 PM
My original choices were the Ruger Mark III and Glock 17, but I got swayed by lower prices (which, in the end, didn't turn out to be that much lower). Looking back, if I could do it again, I'd probably get the Ruger Mark III and Glock 19. I still like my guns, but with this guide rod problem, and the P250's long double-action only trigger pull, I'm having some minor regrets.

Luckily for you this is not permanent.  You can fix it and sell it.

Until the guide rod broke, I was perfectly happy with my 1911 22. We'll see if the replacement part works any better.

As for the P250c, I may trade it in for a Glock 19. It's not a bad gun. It's a really good gun, actually. The DAO trigger just makes accurate shooting more difficult.

I do wish we could shoot 9mm carbines at the silhouette range, though. I have no idea whether I hit that bell, because the .22 slug is so small. :(
Title: Re: BAD NEWS: My SIG/GSG 1911 22 broke!
Post by: vooduchikn on October 17, 2011, 06:32:35 PM
My original choices were the Ruger Mark III and Glock 17, but I got swayed by lower prices (which, in the end, didn't turn out to be that much lower). Looking back, if I could do it again, I'd probably get the Ruger Mark III and Glock 19. I still like my guns, but with this guide rod problem, and the P250's long double-action only trigger pull, I'm having some minor regrets.

Luckily for you this is not permanent.  You can fix it and sell it.

Until the guide rod broke, I was perfectly happy with my 1911 22. We'll see if the replacement part works any better.

As for the P250c, I may trade it in for a Glock 19. It's not a bad gun. It's a really good gun, actually. The DAO trigger just makes accurate shooting more difficult.

I do wish we could shoot 9mm carbines at the silhouette range, though. I have no idea whether I hit that bell, because the .22 slug is so small. :(

Not when you get used to it. Its not a true DAO.  Come shoot with us and see what you think. I love the Glock trigger. Not as crisp as my 1911, but no issues with them out of the box.  There are several kits you can install to change the feel. I like them stock. I put 30 rounds through a hole the size of a silver dollar rather quickly. Like anything, it takes practice.
Title: Re: BAD NEWS: My SIG/GSG 1911 22 broke!
Post by: antoinebugleboy on October 17, 2011, 09:58:46 PM
My original choices were the Ruger Mark III and Glock 17, but I got swayed by lower prices (which, in the end, didn't turn out to be that much lower). Looking back, if I could do it again, I'd probably get the Ruger Mark III and Glock 19. I still like my guns, but with this guide rod problem, and the P250's long double-action only trigger pull, I'm having some minor regrets.

Luckily for you this is not permanent.  You can fix it and sell it.

Until the guide rod broke, I was perfectly happy with my 1911 22. We'll see if the replacement part works any better.

As for the P250c, I may trade it in for a Glock 19. It's not a bad gun. It's a really good gun, actually. The DAO trigger just makes accurate shooting more difficult.

I do wish we could shoot 9mm carbines at the silhouette range, though. I have no idea whether I hit that bell, because the .22 slug is so small. :(

Not when you get used to it. Its not a true DAO.  Come shoot with us and see what you think. I love the Glock trigger. Not as crisp as my 1911, but no issues with them out of the box.  There are several kits you can install to change the feel. I like them stock. I put 30 rounds through a hole the size of a silver dollar rather quickly. Like anything, it takes practice.

Sorry, I didn't write that very clearly. The DAO is on the SIG P250, which is the gun I currently own. I really like the Glock trigger, and have no problems with it.