2aHawaii

General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: eyeeatingfish on January 08, 2016, 09:59:22 PM

Title: Mental illness and firearm ownership
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 08, 2016, 09:59:22 PM
There issus of mental illness and firearms repeatedly come up in this board as well as conversations in public. Even pro 2a politicians say we need to keep guna out of the hands of crazy people but there is little of substamce on how to do that.

As a pro gun rights community we need to have a proposal on how to tackle the peoblem. Saying we need to keep guns out of the hands of crazy people is empty if we refuse to consider any sort or gun control.

We don't want to scare people away from getting help but  that cannot be an excuse to do nothing either otherwise we would never stop crazy people from doing anything.

We need to have some answer.
Title: Re: Mental illness and firearm ownership
Post by: bass monkey on January 08, 2016, 10:12:22 PM
Since there is no way to determine who will commit a crime, and no way to control the black market, all law abiding citizens should be allowed to conceal carry, through constitutional carry.
My theory is, since we don't know when crime will happen, by having the most people armed and ready to respond will have the best possibility of containing a situation quickly.
Why call and wait for someone with a gun to show up (police), when we can have armed citizens as well.
Title: Re: Mental illness and firearm ownership
Post by: mauidog on January 08, 2016, 10:16:17 PM
There issus of mental illness and firearms repeatedly come up in this board as well as conversations in public. Even pro 2a politicians say we need to keep guna out of the hands of crazy people but there is little of substamce on how to do that.

As a pro gun rights community we need to have a proposal on how to tackle the peoblem. Saying we need to keep guns out of the hands of crazy people is empty if we refuse to consider any sort or gun control.

We don't want to scare people away from getting help but  that cannot be an excuse to do nothing either otherwise we would never stop crazy people from doing anything.

We need to have some answer.

Let's cut to the chase:

#1 - Nobody can keep the guns out of the hands of crazy people.  You can identify those who are obvious threats, and you can identify those who make verbal and written threats, but we can never predict when anyone, including the mentally ill, will become violent.  You can't force people to self-identify, families don't often identify them, and even police and doctors don't always see the seriousness of individual's psychological issues.  Case in point, the 22 year old shooting up the area near the Santa Barbara campus.  He was reported and left alone to do his mass murdering.

#2 - Since #1 is true, and the threat of crazy people becoming violent in public is real, the only real solution is to be prepared to defend yourself should you be in the line of fire.

Prevention is always preferred, but it will never, ever be 100% effective.  We can't diagnose, treat, disarm or incarcerate every violent person in advance of their illegal acts, sane or crazy.

Therefore, preparation and defensive use of guns should be allowed for everyone, everywhere with minimal limitations.

In other words, until we are able to guarantee all violence caused by the mentally ill can be identified and prevented, it only makes sense to be ready and be armed.

Title: Re: Mental illness and firearm ownership
Post by: PeaShooter on January 09, 2016, 12:24:30 PM
Not this again.

We should NOT be pushing for ways to find more crazy people, before they demonstrate that they are crazy by their actions. That just opens the door for the government to say anyone and everyone is crazy. Before you know it, the government will say you are crazy and punish you just for saying that you support the second amendment. It has already happened, actually.
Title: Re: Mental illness and firearm ownership
Post by: Inspector on January 10, 2016, 02:37:07 PM
Don't feed the toll.  :closed:
Title: Re: Mental illness and firearm ownership
Post by: Q on January 10, 2016, 03:09:40 PM
As I've stated before: EEF must support the disarmament of veterans, because most veterans have some sort of mental illness from combat.
Title: Re: Mental illness and firearm ownership
Post by: bass monkey on January 10, 2016, 03:37:20 PM
Seems like he lost interest in his own thread
Title: Re: Mental illness and firearm ownership
Post by: Inspector on January 10, 2016, 04:03:55 PM
Except for EEF, I know that there is no perfect system and there is no law(s) can prevent this sort of thing from occurring. What EEF refuses to admit is that not only can this not be prevented by any law(s) but here in Murica we have the best (not perfect) system in the world. As long as we enforce the laws we already have and to the fullest extent that we can and allow the law abiding citizens full and unfettered access to firearms then we will then minimize the ability of the people who are mentally unstable to obtain firearms and to minimize carnage in the event a mentally unstable person obtains and uses a gun. This is the best system in the world. And no law or laws are going to change this nor make this any better.

He has tried to discuss this issue before. I suspect he is trying to bring this up again in an attempt to try and rile up those that have not caught on yet to the fact that bringing this up again and again is the same as the moves and motives of a troll. So don't feed the troll.  :closed:
Title: Re: Mental illness and firearm ownership
Post by: bass monkey on January 10, 2016, 04:26:56 PM
Hopefully he comes down on the 20th and meets some of the guys