2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: London808 on January 27, 2016, 05:46:55 PM

Title: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: London808 on January 27, 2016, 05:46:55 PM
BAck in November i had to file a Lawsuit in Federal court in regards to HPD violating my rights and potentially the rights of others,

I First Acquired a Rifle permit and was issued it with no problem, I Then tried to get a pistol permit a couple of weeks latter and this is where i ran into a problem. HPD claimed to have a "policy"

They claimed that the policy stated that Non-Citizens were required to provide documentation (a letter or copy of their criminal history) from their country of origin or the embassy or consulate of that country. When asked for a copy of the policy they claimed it was a verbal policy issued from the cheifes/city lawyers.
They claimed the policy was because the NCIS check they are required to do does not show family crimes or misdemeanors that would prohibit owning a gun in Hawaii.
I explained to them they were wrong and that it does show this (i even checked with Homeland security) I explained that the law required that they do the background check, I also explained that if i went to get my citizenship (which i am in the process of doing) they wouldn't even ask about my history before hand (their is no history anyway).
This is where it gets really stupid, I had already been issued a valid rifle permit, So i went and bought a cheap shotgun. I then took this shotgun to HPD to register, They seized my shotgun and revoked my permit. They told me the permit was issued in error and as such i should of never been able to buy the shotgun. I explained that although they may believe that to be the case, The law does not allow them to seize my legally purchased/owned firearm and doing so was a violation of my rights, I asked them under what law they were seizing it and they could not answer, I asked them if i had broken a law they told me no.

I was left with little to no choice but to file suit. I called Richard L Holcomb (If you need a lawyer for this type of thing he is the guy)  I expalined the situation to him and he was right on it, We filled the lawsuit in federal court on November 6th 2015 (a copy of which can be found here http://www.hawaiifreepress.com/Portals/0/Article%20Attachments/Roberts%20v%20Honolulu%202nd%20Amendment.pdf)

It is a 2nd, 4th and 14th amendment case,

The city settled the case  this past week, They accept no liability or wrong doing But gave me back my rifle and issued me both my permits, They also changed HPD policy to state that they can/will not require additional background checks of non-citizens other then allowed by law (via the NCIS database)

Now im not sure how many other people they may have done this too who were not aware of what their rights are, But even tho this dose not affect that many people here in Hawaii, it is still a 2A win for everyone.
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: suka on January 27, 2016, 06:18:09 PM
Good Job to you and Mr. Holcomb.

Were any compensation paid to the Lawyer for fees and ACLU donation?

Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: London808 on January 27, 2016, 06:26:27 PM
When you ask for compensation, lawsuits tend to take a lot longer, I wanted to get this taken care of as quick as possible, Fees are being taken care of to the maximum extent that the law allows
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: suka on January 27, 2016, 06:27:54 PM
Good,  I just want the City to pay $ for such actions.
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: Inspector on January 27, 2016, 08:24:02 PM
Congrats!!! Good job to you and Holcomb. I applaud you both!!!!  :thumbsup:
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 27, 2016, 09:07:02 PM
Good,  I just want the City to pay $ for such actions.

You mean you want all of us to pay with our tax dollars?

In the end, I think they did have to pay for lawyer opinions and whatnot.
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: mauidog on January 27, 2016, 09:21:51 PM
You mean you want all of us to pay with our tax dollars?

In the end, I think they did have to pay for lawyer opinions and whatnot.

If there was no admission or finding of wrong doing, governments have insurance policies to pay these claims.  Taxes pay for the insurance coverage, but the claims are not paid with tax dollars.  That's one reason they are always quick with a settlement offer to avoid a judgement against them -- especially if the case against the gov't is strong.
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: Dumbgun on January 28, 2016, 01:34:05 AM
A win is a win. Good job and congrats. Let us know when go American. You effected positive change without thought of $$$. You deserve something for time and effort.  I ain't got no money so.... :shaka:
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: Rocky on January 28, 2016, 07:41:52 AM
    Way to go London808 and Mr. Holcomb.  :thumbsup:

    Think of  any taxpayer payment of fees this way.
The anti's helped pay for it  :rofl:  :rofl:  :rofl:
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: Inspector on January 28, 2016, 11:24:46 AM
You mean you want all of us to pay with our tax dollars?

In the end, I think they did have to pay for lawyer opinions and whatnot.
If I had a choice of where my taxpayer's dollars went to I would say this was money well spent!

It was stupid that we had to go through this in the first place. But since we did I am glad they lost and had to pay up.
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: wolfwood on January 29, 2016, 03:36:07 AM
Good Job to you and Mr. Holcomb.

Were any compensation paid to the Lawyer for fees and ACLU donation?

Rick and I are petitioning the Court for fees right now. It will be awhile before we know how much we get. 
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: suka on January 29, 2016, 08:25:18 AM
Rick and I are petitioning the Court for fees right now. It will be awhile before we know how much we get.

Great thank you for standing up for us.
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: dirtylickins on January 29, 2016, 08:53:05 AM
Thanks to all involved. The time and effort. I know I appreciate it!
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: suka on January 29, 2016, 03:37:01 PM
Rick and I are petitioning the Court for fees right now. It will be awhile before we know how much we get.
I might have a case for you , PM me if you want to hear of it.


Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: macsak on January 29, 2016, 04:07:42 PM
I might have a case for you , PM me if you want to hear of it.

call them
his number is in one of the other threads
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: asinapple8805 on January 29, 2016, 06:01:13 PM
If there was no admission or finding of wrong doing, governments have insurance policies to pay these claims.  Taxes pay for the insurance coverage, but the claims are not paid with tax dollars.  That's one reason they are always quick with a settlement offer to avoid a judgement against them -- especially if the case against the gov't is strong.

Are you sure about that?

There's usually a bill every year in the Legislature that makes appropriations out of the General Fund for the settlement of claims against the state, or its departments.

Here's the one from last year:
http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/Archives/measure_indiv_Archives.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=896&year=2015
http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/session2015/bills/HB896_CD1_.htm
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: wolfwood on June 03, 2016, 02:28:51 PM
well don't think I am trying to get rich off of these cases
The attorney fee award finally came out today

Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: Inspector on June 03, 2016, 02:47:09 PM
well don't think I am trying to get rich off of these cases
The attorney fee award finally came out today
Well, I certainly believe you deserve a lot more for all the work you did.

I have only used 2 lawyers in my life. One was my father's estate case that went on for 3 years. While he refused to go after the opposing attorney (we have enough evidence to get that attorney disbarred) he still did a good job for us.

The other attorney was for my workman's comp case and while I thought he got a lot of money for what little he did, he made sure I didn't get ripped off. That was worth the money I paid.

Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: GlockNewb on June 03, 2016, 02:47:25 PM
Wheels of justice turn slowly indeed, but congratulations on the win and thank you for your diligence.
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: suka on June 03, 2016, 07:44:06 PM
I read the whole pdf file and noted this remark in the order...........




“counsel would have been better off financially had they
 abandoned the practice of law and apprenticed as a plumber.”
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: London808 on June 04, 2016, 09:27:13 AM
well don't think I am trying to get rich off of these cases
The attorney fee award finally came out today

I really do thank you and Rick for your help with this, Your work and end results were awesome and im glad everything is finally taken care of for you guys. 
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: London808 on June 04, 2016, 09:28:45 AM
I read the whole pdf file and noted this remark in the order...........




“counsel would have been better off financially had they
 abandoned the practice of law and apprenticed as a plumber.”


I boticed that too and laughed my ass off.
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: PeaShooter on June 09, 2016, 04:11:18 PM
I might regret saying this, but with my very slight amount of experience regarding how much attorneys ask for their fees (both when their client is paying, or when the opposition ends up paying) the amounts I saw looked shockingly excessive. Maybe the attorneys I've talked to were trying to help me for free, I don't know. I'm glad that everyone is happy with the result here, but I would feel bad if Chris were paying this much out of his pocket in his case. (If it's the other side that pays, that's fine though).
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: zippz on June 09, 2016, 04:21:39 PM
(If it's the other side that pays, that's fine though).

We all pay if the other side pays.
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: PeaShooter on June 09, 2016, 04:32:23 PM
True, but I don't think we should think like that. We (on this forum) are still closer to the plaintiffs' side than we are to the government's side. We (on this forum) pay relatively little of the losing side's costs, which get diluted by the rest of the US populace (including those who are not our allies) also paying.
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: wolfwood on June 10, 2016, 02:08:12 AM
I might regret saying this, but with my very slight amount of experience regarding how much attorneys ask for their fees (both when their client is paying, or when the opposition ends up paying) the amounts I saw looked shockingly excessive. Maybe the attorneys I've talked to were trying to help me for free, I don't know. I'm glad that everyone is happy with the result here, but I would feel bad if Chris were paying this much out of his pocket in his case. (If it's the other side that pays, that's fine though).

I've never taken any money from Chris. As to the rest if here was money to be had in these cases every law firm in town would take them
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: London808 on June 10, 2016, 03:39:44 PM
The lawyers that helped me with this case, Both Rick and Alan NEVER took any money from me, They took this case on the risk of losing, If they lost they would of got nothing . The only time they get paid is by winning the case and getting the court to order the city/HPD to pay the fees.

Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: London808 on June 10, 2016, 03:46:51 PM
We all pay if the other side pays.

And so we should, We all stand idly by letting these idiots pass law after law without  doing shit to stop it, When gun laws come up we get 30-40 people submit testimony against them,  WHERE THE HELL IS EVERY ONE ELSE ???  we have over 1 million guns in the state so unless those 40 people own 25k guns each something is wrong.
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: PeaShooter on June 10, 2016, 03:55:07 PM
The lawyers that helped me with this case, Both Rick and Alan NEVER took any money from me, They took this case on the risk of losing, If they lost they would of got nothing . The only time they get paid is by winning the case and getting the court to order the city/HPD to pay the fees.
In that case, awesome. :thumbsup:

They should also get as much from the city as they can. 2A cases aren't common or run-of-the-mill, so they take on risk with these cases that most other attorneys would not.
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: London808 on February 25, 2018, 11:43:14 AM
digging up a 2 year old post.

This case is being hurd at the 9th circuit in June regarding lawyers fees. This could set some very important case law.
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: wolfwood on March 09, 2018, 01:31:30 AM
digging up a 2 year old post.

This case is being hurd at the 9th circuit in June regarding lawyers fees. This could set some very important case law.

Hopefully we can rock the boat a little.  It is not a coincidence the Hawaii Courts view civil rights cases as being much less valuable than say medical malpractice.
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: 6716J on March 09, 2018, 09:53:56 AM
And so we should, We all stand idly by letting these idiots pass law after law without  doing shit to stop it, When gun laws come up we get 30-40 people submit testimony against them,  WHERE THE HELL IS EVERY ONE ELSE ???  we have over 1 million guns in the state so unless those 40 people own 25k guns each something is wrong.

I am saying the same thing over on the CCW permit thread. Roughly 150,000 handgun permits to acquire (gag - the fact I have to ask permission to exercise a right.) were issued in the last 4 years. So taking that with getting 4 handguns per person, that's 37,500 owners out there. Where is everyone? I've asked why don't we have a "Day at the Legislature" and have 1000+ owners show up with empty  :( holsters and gun bags and show them we are here and want our voice heard.
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: punaperson on March 09, 2018, 10:17:43 AM
I am saying the same thing over on the CCW permit thread. Roughly 150,000 handgun permits to acquire (gag - the fact I have to ask permission to exercise a right.) were issued in the last 4 years. So taking that with getting 4 handguns per person, that's 37,500 owners out there. Where is everyone? I've asked why don't we have a "Day at the Legislature" and have 1000+ owners show up with empty  :( holsters and gun bags and show them we are here and want our voice heard.
Do you expect a different result?

Hope for is another..

Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: aieahound on March 09, 2018, 11:16:32 AM
Where is everyone? I've asked why don't we have a "Day at the Legislature" and have 1000+ owners show up with empty  :( holsters and gun bags and show them we are here and want our voice heard.

We tried it once couple years ago.
We got 12 guys....

Kick their ass Wolfwood!
Good luck and keep fighting the good fights!
We appreciate it.
Title: Re: My Lawsuit Update,
Post by: zippz on March 09, 2018, 11:22:21 AM
Is there anything that we can do to help this lawsuit along?  I know it prevents the attorneys from taking on other 2a cases because they have to wait to get paid.