2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: Jl808 on February 26, 2016, 06:54:47 PM
-
Spreadsheet updated 2/26/2016 6:40pm
Link to spreadsheet -> https://goo.gl/1kZGOI
Guys something major is happening on 3/1/2016!
SB2954 SD1 Firearms; Registration; Hawaii Criminal Justice Data Center; Database Management
RELATING TO FIREARMS. Authorizes the Hawaii criminal justice data center to access firearm registration data. (SD1)
Bill -> http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=SB&billnumber=2954
S 2/26/2016: The committee(s) on JDL will hold a public decision making on 03-01-16 9:05AM in conference room 016.
SB2955 Firearms; Background Checks; Permit; Permanent Resident Alien
RELATING TO FIREARMS. Allows permanent resident aliens to receive a permit to acquire a firearm. Requires the issuing authority for firearms permits to perform an inquiry on an applicant using the Criminal Justice Information System (CJIS), National Law Enforcement Telecommunications System (NLETS) including the Immigration and Customs Enforcement query in NLETS, National Crime Information Center (NCIC), National Instant Criminal Background Check System (NICS). Adds permanent resident aliens to required background checks. Clarifies requirements for permanent resident aliens to obtain a firearms permit.
Bill -> http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=SB&billnumber=2955
S 2/26/2016: The committee(s) on JDL has scheduled a public hearing on 03-01-16 9:00AM in conference room 016.
SB2956 Firearms; Mental Illness; Surrender of Firearms
RELATING TO FIREARMS. Requires firearm owners who have been disqualified from owning a firearm due to mental illness to immediately surrender their firearms to the chief of police upon notification and authorizes the chief of police to seize the firearms if the owner fails to comply.
Bill -> http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=SB&billnumber=2956
S 2/26/2016: The committee(s) on JDL will hold a public decision making on 03-01-16 9:05AM in conference room 016.
HB2629 HD1 Criminal History Record Checks; Police; Permits to Acquire Firearms; Firearm Registration; Rapback System
RELATING TO CRIMINAL HISTORY RECORD CHECKS. Authorizes county police departments to enroll firearms applicants and individuals who are registering their firearms into a criminal record monitoring service used to alert police when an owner of a firearm is arrested for a criminal offense anywhere in the country. (HB2629 HD1)
Bill -> http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=2629
H 2/26/2016: Bill scheduled to be heard by JUD on Tuesday, 03-01-16 2:00PM in House conference room 325.
HB2631 Firearms; Permits; Criminal History Record Checks; Rap Back System
RELATING TO FIREARMS. Amends the qualification requirements to allow lawful permanent residents to apply for a permit to acquire a firearm. Clarifies the background check process for firearm permit applicants and authorizes county police departments to enroll firearm permit applicants into a criminal record monitoring service.
Bill -> http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=2631
H 2/26/2016: Bill scheduled to be heard by JUD on Tuesday, 03-01-16 2:00PM in House conference room 325.
HB625 Firearms Possession; Misdemeanor Stalking and Sexual Assault
RELATING TO FIREARMS. Includes misdemeanor stalking and sexual assault among the offenses that disqualify a person from owning, possessing, or controlling any firearm or ammunition.
Bill -> http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=625
H 2/26/2016: Bill scheduled for decision making on Tuesday, 03-01-16 2:00PM in conference room 325.
HB626 Firearms; Possession While Consuming or Under the Influence of Intoxicants
RELATING TO THE POSSESSION OF FIREARMS WHILE CONSUMING OR UNDER THE INFLUENCE OF AN INTOXICANT. Prohibits the physical possession of any firearm while consuming or under the influence of an intoxicant.
Bill -> http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=626
H 2/26/2016: The committee(s) on JUD recommend(s) that the measure be deferred until 03-01-16 2:05PM in room 325.
Testimonies need to be in by Monday 2/29/2016 9:00am (JDL) and 2/29/2016 2:00pm (JUD)!
Tuesday would probably be a good one to show up in person en masse.
-
I will see what I can do to show up on this day to support our rights. Hopefully I can make it! Please attempt to do so as well folks!
-
submitted testimony opposing all of the bills.
I wasn't able to oppose bills HB625 & HB6626. Anyone else have that problem?
-
How come some of the ones that were closed previously are now open to testimony again?
-
The bills that are scheduled for decision making are no longer taking testimonies.
-
done
-
Hawaii Rifle Association
State Affiliate of the National Rifle Association - Founded in 1857
February 28, 2016
Senator Keith-Agaran, Chair of the Hawaii Senate Judiciary Committee, will give decision on SB2956 Tuesday March 1, 2016.
Senate rules provide that, since the bill was already heard in its first committee, Public Safety, and public testimony was taken, no public testimony is needed to pass the bill out of the Judiciary Committee Tuesday. No testimony will be accepted.
State law provides that a person may be involuntarily committed to a mental hospital if they are a danger to self or others. A police officer, a police psychologist, and an emergency room doctor can determine if such a hospitalization is necessary. SB2956 requires the county police to immediately seize all firearms from any person so hospitalized.
Please e-mail or fax Senator Keith-Agaran something like this, fax: 808-586-7348 or
senkeithagaran@capitol.hawaii.gov before Tuesday, 9am:
Dear Senator Keith-Agaran,
Please amend SB2956 to require court action before seizing guns as required under state mental health law: §334-61 Presumption; civil rights. No presumption of insanity or legal incompetency shall exist with respect to any patient by reason of the patient’s admission to a psychiatric facility under this chapter. The fact of the admission shall not in itself modify or vary any civil right of any such person, including but not limited to civil service statutes or rights relating to the granting, forfeiture, or denial of a license, permit, privilege, or benefit pursuant to any law, or the right to dispose of property, execute instruments, make purchases, enter into contractual relationships, and to vote. If the administrator of a psychiatric facility or the deputy is of the opinion that a patient should not exercise any civil right, application for a show cause order shall be made to the court under the above proceedings after notice pursuant to section 334-60.4.
Very respectfully,
(your name)
MAHALO,
HARVEY GERWIG, LEGISLATIVE LIAISON and PRESIDENT, HRA
-
Spreadsheet updated 3/3/2016 11:15am
Link to spreadsheet -> https://goo.gl/1kZGOI
I don't know guys... these a-holes are doing whatever they want despite testimonies in opposition.
HB1813 HD1 Relating to Firearms; Terrorist Screening Database
RELATING TO FIREARMS. Temporarily prohibits a person listed in the federal Terrorist Screening Database from owning, possessing, or controlling a firearm or ammunition. Requires surrender or disposal of firearms and ammunition. Allows for removal of the disqualification. (HB1813 HD1)
Bill -> http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=1813
H 3/3/2016: Reported from JUD (Stand. Com. Rep. No. 720-16) as amended in HD 1, recommending passage on Second Reading and placement on the calendar for Third Reading.
2/26/16 Testimonies in support: 7
2/26/16 Testimonies in opposition: 86
HB625 HD1 Firearms Possession; Misdemeanor Stalking and Sexual Assault
RELATING TO FIREARMS. Includes misdemeanor stalking and sexual assault among the offenses that disqualify a person from owning, possessing, or controlling any firearm or ammunition. (HB625 HD1)
Bill -> http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=625
H 3/3/2016: Reported from JUD (Stand. Com. Rep. No. 723-16) as amended in HD 1, recommending passage on Second Reading and placement on the calendar for Third Reading.
2/25/16 Testimonies in support: 17
2/25/16 Testimonies in opposition: 24
HB626 HD1 Firearms; Possession While Consuming Alcohol
RELATING TO THE POSSESSION OF FIREARMS WHILE CONSUMING OR UNDER THE INFLUENCE OF AN INTOXICANT. Prohibits the actual physical possession of any firearm while consuming alcohol outside of the home, a temporary residence, or place of sojourn. Establishes violation as a petty misdemeanor. (HB626 HD1)
Bill -> http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=626
H 3/3/2016: Reported from JUD (Stand. Com. Rep. No. 724-16) as amended in HD 1, recommending passage on Second Reading and placement on the calendar for Third Reading.
2/26/16 Testimonies in support: 8
2/26/16 Testimonies in opposition: 98
-
Spreadsheet updated 3/3/2016 11:15am
Link to spreadsheet -> https://goo.gl/1kZGOI
I don't know guys... these a-holes are doing whatever they want despite testimonies in opposition.
Be great to know who else they are listening to (and taking orders from). The peasants do not seem to matter to them at all.
-
How many of you have contacted KHON or KITV and demanded this be reported on?
Instead of sitting around and whining on 2a, how about you get pro-active and start contacting the media to bring some light on this.
I already contacted them several days ago, and I'm sure if more people bring this to light, they will eventually report on it.
-
Given the biases of most media outlets, including the local ones, I rather doubt that a few "commonsense gun safety regulations" are considered newsworthy. If anything, the angle would likely be along the lines of "The testimony received by the committee was 12 to one opposing the measure to keep firearms out of the hands of terrorists. We asked committee chairperson Karl Marx what could have caused so many gun nuts to come out of the woodwork." But it's worth a try. :shaka:
-
Given the biases of most media outlets, including the local ones, I rather doubt that a few "commonsense gun safety regulations" are considered newsworthy. If anything, the angle would likely be along the lines of "The testimony received by the committee was 12 to one opposing the measure to keep firearms out of the hands of terrorists. We asked committee chairperson Karl Marx what could have caused so many gun nuts to come out of the woodwork." But it's worth a try. :shaka:
The general focus shouldn't be related to 2a only.
The fact of the matter is that they are disregarding testimony submitted by the people that they represent, and are voting in their own interest.
Remember how everyone said that bill for term limits doesn't matter? Well guess what just got ignored and deferred, and pissed the senator who introduced it off:
http://www.senatorlaurathielen.com/survey-results/ (http://www.senatorlaurathielen.com/survey-results/)
-
The general focus shouldn't be related to 2a only.
The fact of the matter is that they are disregarding testimony submitted by the people that they represent, and are voting in their own interest.
Remember how everyone said that bill for term limits doesn't matter? Well guess what just got ignored and deferred, and pissed the senator who introduced it off:
http://www.senatorlaurathielen.com/survey-results/ (http://www.senatorlaurathielen.com/survey-results/)
In my testimony I pointed out that had that constitutional amendment been adopted it would have been, by far, the most lax, least restrictive "term limits" law in the United States... and still they wouldn't even consider it. Lucky we live Hawaii.
Senator Thielen wrote: "The Chair deferred the bill. I asked why, given the fact that he was recommending passage of other constitutional amendments that had only one or two testimonies in support.
He declined to answer and deferred the bill."
Yeah, "declined to answer". I get that a lot when I ask "my public servants" who supposedly act "with the consent of the governed" for the reasons and evidence for their support or opposition to a particular piece of legislation. They are not accountable in any way really, other than being caught in some outright criminal enterprise, and even then some of them get re-elected. Because this is all "business as usual" it's not really "newsworthy".
The committee chairs have far too much power, as one single individual has the power to kill a bill. Yet, there is absolutely no support for having some minimum requirement for support from x number of legislators to force a committee to hold a legitimate and fair hearing on a bill (see no hearings on any CCW reform for years...). In Florida the House passed, by overwhelming majorities both "open carry" and "campus carry" bills, and they would likely have passed in the Senate as well, but the "Republican" chair of the judiciary committee didn't want them to become law so he merely refused to hold hearings on either bill, and thus killed them. That's one man holding the entire state legislature and all the citizens of the state hostage. That's how the system works. Yes, there were a couple of stories written about it, but a few days later and it's back to "business as usual", with no proposed laws to change that obviously "undemocratic" parliamentary procedure in place.
What can we do?
-
Isnt there some way legal action can be brought to them on infringement of our rights?
-
Spreadsheet updated 3/11/2016 2:55pm
Link to spreadsheet -> https://goo.gl/1kZGOI
Senate PSM Committee is having a hearing on the anti-2a bills from the house. Please send in testimonies before Monday 3/14/2016 1:20pm. The senate is the only chance to kill these bills.
HB2629 HD2 Criminal History Record Checks; Police; Permits to Acquire Firearms; Firearm Registration; Rapback System
RELATING TO CRIMINAL HISTORY RECORD CHECKS. Authorizes county police departments to enroll firearms applicants and individuals who are registering their firearms into a criminal record monitoring service used to alert police when an owner of a firearm is arrested for a criminal offense anywhere in the country. (HB2629 HD2) Data sharing; Criminalization; Amendments Needed; Oppose
Bill -> http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=2629
S 3/11/2016: The committee(s) on PSM has scheduled a public hearing on 03-15-16 1:20PM in conference room 229.
HB625 HD1 Firearms Possession; Misdemeanor Stalking and Sexual Assault
RELATING TO FIREARMS. Includes misdemeanor stalking and sexual assault among the offenses that disqualify a person from owning, possessing, or controlling any firearm or ammunition. (HB625 HD1) Prohibition; Stalking; Sexual Assault; Confiscation; Misdemeanor stalking can mean unwelcomed texts; Oppose
Bill -> http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=625
S 3/11/2016: The committee(s) on PSM has scheduled a public hearing on 03-15-16 1:20PM in conference room 229.
HB626 HD1 Firearms; Possession While Consuming Alcohol
RELATING TO THE POSSESSION OF FIREARMS WHILE CONSUMING OR UNDER THE INFLUENCE OF AN INTOXICANT. Prohibits the actual physical possession of any firearm while consuming alcohol outside of the home, a temporary residence, or place of sojourn. Establishes violation as a petty misdemeanor. (HB626 HD1) Possession; Alcohol; Oppose
Bill -> http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=626
S 3/11/2016: The committee(s) on PSM has scheduled a public hearing on 03-15-16 1:20PM in conference room 229.
-
Spreadsheet updated 3/11/2016 2:55pm
Link to spreadsheet -> https://goo.gl/1kZGOI
Senate PSM Committee is having a hearing on the anti-2a bills from the house. Please send in testimonies before Monday 3/14/2016 1:20pm. The senate is the only chance to kill these bills.
HB2629 HD2 Criminal History Record Checks; Police; Permits to Acquire Firearms; Firearm Registration; Rapback System
RELATING TO CRIMINAL HISTORY RECORD CHECKS. Authorizes county police departments to enroll firearms applicants and individuals who are registering their firearms into a criminal record monitoring service used to alert police when an owner of a firearm is arrested for a criminal offense anywhere in the country. (HB2629 HD2) Data sharing; Criminalization; Amendments Needed; Oppose
Bill -> http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=2629
S 3/11/2016: The committee(s) on PSM has scheduled a public hearing on 03-15-16 1:20PM in conference room 229.
HB625 HD1 Firearms Possession; Misdemeanor Stalking and Sexual Assault
RELATING TO FIREARMS. Includes misdemeanor stalking and sexual assault among the offenses that disqualify a person from owning, possessing, or controlling any firearm or ammunition. (HB625 HD1) Prohibition; Stalking; Sexual Assault; Confiscation; Misdemeanor stalking can mean unwelcomed texts; Oppose
Bill -> http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=625
S 3/11/2016: The committee(s) on PSM has scheduled a public hearing on 03-15-16 1:20PM in conference room 229.
HB626 HD1 Firearms; Possession While Consuming Alcohol
RELATING TO THE POSSESSION OF FIREARMS WHILE CONSUMING OR UNDER THE INFLUENCE OF AN INTOXICANT. Prohibits the actual physical possession of any firearm while consuming alcohol outside of the home, a temporary residence, or place of sojourn. Establishes violation as a petty misdemeanor. (HB626 HD1) Possession; Alcohol; Oppose
Bill -> http://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=626
S 3/11/2016: The committee(s) on PSM has scheduled a public hearing on 03-15-16 1:20PM in conference room 229.
I am trying to figure out if an argument can be made that any of these are unconstitutional. I oppose the last two but if I can go, I want to take the unconstitutional argument with me as I think it will have more weight.
-
I'm not sure these guys understand what unconstitutional means.
What mostly gets the legislators' attention is how expensive something will be to implement.
-
I am trying to figure out if an argument can be made that any of these are unconstitutional. I oppose the last two but if I can go, I want to take the unconstitutional argument with me as I think it will have more weight.
As for HB625 and HB626 you could quote the first SCOTUS oral arguments comment in 10 years from Justice Thomas last week: "Can you give me another area where a misdemeanor violation suspends a constitutional right?" Of course that's not legal precedent but it does indicate that a Supreme Court justice is concerned about denial of Second Amendment rights due to misdemeanor convictions. Under these bills, sending an "unwanted" text message, or holding a beer will become crimes that deny an otherwise law-abiding citizen their natural/God-given individual enumerated Constitutionally-guaranteed civil right to keep and bear arms. They're going to pass those bills, whether they are unconstitutional or not, but you can try. Next year there will be a bill for firearm confiscation if you give someone a "look" they find "offensive", as that will be a "micro-agression" against their "safe space".
-
HB2629-
The law already requires that a convicted felon surrender all firearms or have them confiscated. Police departments have access to such knowledge and should be using such public databases to do their background checks and process. Thus, keeping weapons out of the hands of criminals. Databasing private firearms owners, who have no criminal record, nor conviction of felonious activities, should not be treated as a criminal. Logging and data basing, of law abiding citizens, on the grounds of 'being a gun owner' is a huge infringement of said law abiding citizen's privacy, is VERY unconstitutional. Please focus laws on catching, prosecuting, and punishing CRIMINALS, not the law abiding gun owners. I STRONGLY OPPOSE THIS LEGISLATION. Thank You
HB625-
I Oppose passage of this bill.
"Can you give me another area where a misdemeanor violation suspends a constitutional right?"
-Justice Thomas
Thank you
HB626-
Possession of a firearm outside the prescribed places is not permitted in any case, for the law abiding citizen, as permits to conceal or open carry firearms are NOT issued.
Is this law intended for Law Enforcement Officers, as these are the only persons permitted to carry firearms on their persons in public?
If the laws are changed where Law Abiding Citizens are issued permits to carry on their person, then a law like this is needed. Otherwise the law is pointless, as a problem of this nature has not been encountered, other than law enforcement officers.
I OPPOSE as written and presented. Vote to remove this bill from consideration.
Thank you.
Modify message
-
I am trying to figure out if an argument can be made that any of these are unconstitutional. I oppose the last two but if I can go, I want to take the unconstitutional argument with me as I think it will have more weight.
They changed the wording for the alcohol bill, however, IMO it is not needed. When we are allowed to CCW then I may consider supporting something like this bill.
As for the others testimoniy above is how I feel.
No due process of law is unconstitutional. One should be convicted of a actual crime BEFORE rights are removed. That is the whole point of the constitution and the spirit of freedom. Arbitrary removal of rights is NOT constitutional.
-
From HRA
Hawaii Rifle Association
State Affiliate of the National Rifle Association - Founded in 1857
March 12, 2016
The Senate Public Safety Committee, Chairman Senator Clarence K. Nishihara, will hear 3 gun bills Tuesday, March 15, 2016.
Please go to capitol.hawaii.gov , sign in, and click on the orange "submit testimony" button to send testimony on all three bills.
Deadline to submit testimony, 1:20pm Monday March 14.
HB625 Includes misdemeanor stalking among the offenses that disqualify a person from owning, possessing, or controlling any firearm or ammunition. 4th degree stalking can be as little as sending unwanted texts or e-mails, and conviction means permanent loss of gun rights, restorable only by Governor's pardon. OPPOSE. Support if 4th degree stalking removed.
HB626 Petty misdemeanor for drinking alcohol outside your home while possessing a firearm. Former Mayor Carlisle's "Deedy" bill. Targets police, as no one else can lawfully carry. OPPOSE. Off duty police carrying is a public safety benefit. The courts may eventually force Hawaii police chiefs to issue carry permits to civilians. Needs an amendment specifying .08 alcohol level.
HB2629 Requires the county police to enroll all gun permit applicants and those registering firearms in "Rap Back," a FBI data base of individuals arrested anywhere in the US, including on misdemeanor and even some civil charges. A fee of approximately $50 will be charged. The system is used now to screen job applicants for sensitive jobs, like foster parents, etc. No state currently uses it for firearms acquisitions. HRA OPPOSES. It creates a permanent federal list of firearms owners and charges a fee for exercising a civil right.
MAHALO,
HARVEY GERWIG, LEGISLATIVE LIAISON and PRESIDENT, HRA
EMAIL: HGHAWAII@GMAIL.COM, PHONE: (808) 306-7194
-
They changed the wording for the alcohol bill, however, IMO it is not needed. When we are allowed to CCW then I may consider supporting something like this bill.
As for the others testimoniy above is how I feel.
No due process of law is unconstitutional. One should be convicted of a actual crime BEFORE rights are removed. That is the whole point of the constitution and the spirit of freedom. Arbitrary removal of rights is NOT constitutional.
I was wondering about the due process argument. Not every law has some due process clause in it. So if I am going to go make the argument that there is no due process in the way the new law is written, I want to make sure that I don't get blindsided by them just pointing to some coverall law that says "appeal to any action under these laws can be made through the court by doing......"
-
I was wondering about the due process argument. Not every law has some due process clause in it. So if I am going to go make the argument that there is no due process in the way the new law is written, I want to make sure that I don't get blindsided by them just pointing to some coverall law that says "appeal to any action under these laws can be made through the court by doing......"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Due_Process_Clause
The Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments to the United States Constitution each contain a due process clause. Due process deals with the administration of justice and thus the due process clause acts as a safeguard from arbitrary denial of life, liberty, or property by the Government outside the sanction of law.[1] The Supreme Court of the United States interprets the clauses more broadly because these clauses provide four protections: procedural due process (in civil and criminal proceedings), substantive due process, a prohibition against vague laws, and as the vehicle for the incorporation of the Bill of Rights. Due process ensures the rights and equality of all citizens.
The Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution provides:
[N]or shall any person . . . be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law . . . .[5]
Section One of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution provides:
[N]or shall any State deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law . . . .[6]
The city and state of Hawaii seems to do all of the above regularly with any and all legislation they come up with.... Vagueness, no due process, arbitrary removal of rights based on whatevaz....
Yet life goes on. More and more it feels like this place is not even a part of the USA. No wonder Amazon won't ship select items to me, they were right, I am in an other country... heh
-
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Due_Process_Clause
The city and state of Hawaii seems to do all of the above regularly with any and all legislation they come up with.... Vagueness, no due process, arbitrary removal of rights based on whatevaz....
Yet life goes on. More and more it feels like this place is not even a part of the USA. No wonder Amazon won't ship select items to me, they were right, I am in an other country... heh
I am not sure if there really is no due process. Just because these specific laws do not list a due process procedure doesn't mean that there isn't one that covers them. That is what I want to know because that is what is part of the argument. The vagueness is very true also though.
-
I am not sure if there really is no due process. Just because these specific laws do not list a due process procedure doesn't mean that there isn't one that covers them. That is what I want to know because that is what is part of the argument. The vagueness is very true also though.
You are right. I was thinking of the other bill. The bills above probably don't apply to that. I just thought about due process from your question on it.
I still stand by my testimony though.
-
Just submitted testimony.
I encourage everyone to do the same
-
done
-
I have to be in town in the morning but not sure I can bleed away my whole day tomorrow to testify. Any idea how long these things can go? Looks like 7 or 8 bills are going to be heard at the 1:30 start time.
-
My testimony for HB2629
According to a 2009 report on facial recognition technology authored by Helen Nissenbaum and Lucas Introna, the Next Generation Identification (NGI) project aggressively being pushed by the FBI actually hinders intelligence by creating false positives and wasting resources on needless investigations. The rap-back scheme is a way of implementing NGI for the non-criminal population, which inefficiently attempts to find “needles in the haystack” by piling more hay on the stack.
It also has devastating consequences for privacy and civil liberties, but here my main concern is with biometric technology that can never hope to keep up with such a huge often-homogeneous data set. I already have one doppelganger on the North Shore that I know about. Lucky for me he's a good guy, and lucky for him so am I but if one of us did get into trouble and had our facial features scanned by a NGI-connected camera then the other could be investigated and possibly prosecuted for crimes they did not commit. All this because one of us was 'voluntarily' signed up to be scanned into machines that have no business sifting through the facial geometries of 300,000,000 people.
You may think I'm exaggerating, but do your own research through the Electronic Frontier Foundation instead of browsing the latest promotional material from FBI that gives itself glowing reviews while ignoring the consequences. What if this system ever falls into the wrong hands? What if you, in your duties as a government official, are forced to make a choice between your constituents and an all-powerful oligarchy that knows everything about you? That's pretty much the antithesis of democracy and the death of the republic.
If you haven't seen the movie Brazil by Terry Gilliam then I suggest you watch the opening scene where a machine makes an error, changing the last name on an arrest warrant from Mr. Tuttle to Mr. Buttle. This results in an innocent family man getting ambushed by a militarized police force, extraordinarily renditioned, indefinitely detained with enhanced interrogation, and finally targeted for assassination as an enemy combatant. It most definitely CAN happen here, and your recent familiarity with those specific terms means you are aware that it's been happening for a while now.
Rap-back is a waste of resources that puts us all in danger. In the end there is no substitute for good old-fashioned police work, and the current system seems to be working just fine.
-
From reading the updated bill on firearms and intoxication, I am no longer against it. Instead of just possession it says physical possession and it also says outside of the home. So basically someone carrying a gun around can't be intoxicated. This isa law I would favor if there was CCW anyway.
-
From reading the updated bill on firearms and intoxication, I am no longer against it. Instead of just possession it says physical possession and it also says outside of the home. So basically someone carrying a gun around can't be intoxicated. This isa law I would favor if there was CCW anyway.
The bill does NOT state "intoxicated", and gives no definition of what intoxicated would be even if it did.
"(g) No person shall be in actual physical possession of any firearm outside of a residence, a temporary residence, or place of sojourn while consuming any alcohol, as defined in section 291E-1."
"They" like these vague ambiguous laws because they can stretch/interpret them to mean almost anything they want them to. As written, technically a person could no have "actual physical possession" and consume alcohol and then "be in actual physical possession of any firearm" and not be chargeable under this statute, since it requires that one be BOTH "in actual physical possession" AND "consuming any alcohol". Someone hands their firearm to a buddy, takes a drink, takes the firearm back: not chargeable. If they want to have a law that says you can't be intoxicated (and define intoxication) and possess a firearm outside the home, they should just write that bill. How hard is that? One has to wonder what their real goal is since plain language is so simple to understand.
How about this:
"(g) No person shall be in actual physical possession of any firearm outside of a residence, a temporary residence, or place of sojourn while intoxicated (.08 blood alcohol or greater) or demonstrably physically or mentally impaired by any intoxicating substance (subject to blood test verification). "
-
The bill does NOT state "intoxicated", and gives no definition of what intoxicated would be even if it did.
"(g) No person shall be in actual physical possession of any firearm outside of a residence, a temporary residence, or place of sojourn while consuming any alcohol, as defined in section 291E-1."
"They" like these vague ambiguous laws because they can stretch/interpret them to mean almost anything they want them to. As written, technically a person could no have "actual physical possession" and consume alcohol and then "be in actual physical possession of any firearm" and not be chargeable under this statute, since it requires that one be BOTH "in actual physical possession" AND "consuming any alcohol". Someone hands their firearm to a buddy, takes a drink, takes the firearm back: not chargeable. If they want to have a law that says you can't be intoxicated (and define intoxication) and possess a firearm outside the home, they should just write that bill. How hard is that? One has to wonder what their real goal is since plain language is so simple to understand.
How about this:
"(g) No person shall be in actual physical possession of any firearm outside of a residence, a temporary residence, or place of sojourn while intoxicated (.08 blood alcohol or greater) or demonstrably physically or mentally impaired by any intoxicating substance (subject to blood test verification). "
That would be a better version of this law.
-
no...they won't abuse the database.... :wacko:
http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/31469838/denver-monitor-urges-steep-penalty-for-crime-database-abuse (http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/31469838/denver-monitor-urges-steep-penalty-for-crime-database-abuse)
-
Just read through today's submitted testimony on HB 626, simultaneously possessing a firearm and consuming alcohol criminalization bill.
Overwhelming opposition (I didn't do a count).
Noticed that both HPD and HRA's Max Cooper submitted testimony for bills other than HB 626.
-
From HRA:
---------------------------------------------
Hawaii Rifle Association
State Affiliate of the National Rifle Association - Founded in 1857
March 16, 2016
Decision on all three BAD gun bills heard by the Senate Committee on Public Safety, Intergovernmental and Military Affairs was deferred until next Tuesday, March 22. IT IS TIME FOR ACTION! WE NEED TO KILL THESE BILLS BEFORE THEY MOVE FORWARD AND IT'S TOO LATE.
Contact the Committee Chair, Senator Clarence Nishihara at sennishihara@capitol.hawaii.gov, or call him at 808-586-6970 or fax him at 586-6879.
Also, contact the Committee Vice Chair, Senator Will Espero at senespero@capitol.hawaii.gov, or call him at 808-586-6360 or fax him at 808-586-6361.
Let them know your concerns and displeasure.
You should also contact your district Representative and Senator if you are a registered voter. If you aren't sure who that is, go to: www.capitol.hawaii.gov and on the upper right of the page, enter your street name where it says "Find your legislator". This is an election year and they need to know that you vote and you are watching how they vote on bills affecting your Second Amendment rights. Be sure to identify your district in all contacts with your legislators.
The bills are:
HB 625, HD1 - Misdemeanor Stalking (includes unwanted text messages, calls, and emails) disqualifies ownership, possession, or control of a firearm
HB 626, HD 1 - Consumption of any alcohol (no quantification identified) while in possess of a firearm is a misdemeanor
HB 2629, HD2 - Enrolls all firearm applicants in the federal Rap Back system at the cost of the firearm applicant, about $50.
MAHALO,
HARVEY GERWIG, LEGISLATIVE LIAISON and PRESIDENT, HRA
EMAIL: HGHAWAII@GMAIL.COM, PHONE: (808) 306-7194