2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: GZire on November 14, 2011, 03:28:55 PM
-
So I get these emails from the NRA (being a member and all) and I just got this one.
Just a portion of the email:
HI01
National Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act to be voted on in the U.S. House of Representatives this week!
On Tuesday, November 15, the U.S. House of Representatives will vote on H.R. 822, the "National Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act." Please contact Representative Hanabusa and urge her to vote for this pro-gun legislation. This important bill would allow any law-abiding concealed carry permit holder to legally carry a concealed firearm while visiting any state that does not prohibit concealed carry.
Please contact Rep. Hanabusa as soon as possible and urge her to vote for H.R. 822, the "National Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act".
Phone:
Washington, DC (202) 225-2726
Honolulu (808) 541-2570
Email: http://www.capwiz.com/nra/issues/alert/?alertid=55111516 (http://www.capwiz.com/nra/issues/alert/?alertid=55111516)
OK...........really petition Hanabusa? Is this state dependent or does the NRA not have an anti-gun list of the members of Congress? WTH?
-
Couldn't hurt. At least, if she got enough petitions, she'd know she has constituents that are pro-gun, and that might influence her to moderate her stance a bit.
-
Couldn't hurt. At least, if she got enough petitions, she'd know she has constituents that are pro-gun, and that might influence her to moderate her stance a bit.
Nice thoughts. ;D
But I highly doubt she will moderate anything... Unless there is something in it for hanabusa.
Been getting these emails too, and others by the other 'pro gunners' saying it will cause overstepping of the Feds in the realm of CC.
Dunno what to believe, and both sides of the card make sense. Maybe if Hanas votes for this bill I'll know i need to worry about it. Cause I'll know somethings up. :P
-
I think she can be bought. The question is how much.
-
if everyone on HI that owned a gun called in or emailed you can bet you'd get a sure sign of one of two things.
1. she will listen to her constituency
or
2. she has no regard for them a will do things on her own accord
-
Do you think that the passing of this bill will help the Hawaii cause?
Maybe everyone here is a little kid at heart and the, "if there doing it we can too" mentality will ensue. Yeah right.
What do you guys think though?
Oh i also emailed in. Couldnt hurt, or at least i hope not
-
Nah. Even if the whole state emailed, she wouldn't vote pro. Unless there was something in it for her. Just sayin.
-
Do you think that the passing of this bill will help the Hawaii cause?
Maybe everyone here is a little kid at heart and the, "if there doing it we can too" mentality will ensue. Yeah right.
What do you guys think though?
Oh i also emailed in. Couldnt hurt, or at least i hope not
I don't think this will help Hawaii. Until Hawaii gets sued and is forced to go to a shall carry mentality nothing will change.
-
Sent in my email. Like I said, couldn't hurt.
-
just sent my email out
-
hanabusa voted nay
http://clerk.house.gov/evs/2011/roll842.xml (http://clerk.house.gov/evs/2011/roll842.xml)
-
hanabusa voted nay
http://clerk.house.gov/evs/2011/roll842.xml (http://clerk.house.gov/evs/2011/roll842.xml)
No way, you don't say... I can't believe it. :o
-
So it was voted on and it passed the House.
http://www.nraila.org/News/Read/NewsReleases.aspx?id=15773 (http://www.nraila.org/News/Read/NewsReleases.aspx?id=15773)
-
ooops wrong thread my bad
-
Stop me if I read wrong but... this means that if any person legally possessing a CCP from another state could CC in Hawaii providing that he/she abides by Hawaii carry laws for those few and precious Hawaii permits that do get issued?
Yes, Yes, that is taking into account that it will pass the senate and further...
-
I also read that it prohibits citizens getting a CCW in another state to carry in theirs. I may be wrong?
-
So I get these emails from the NRA (being a member and all) and I just got this one.
Just a portion of the email:
HI01
National Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act to be voted on in the U.S. House of Representatives this week!
On Tuesday, November 15, the U.S. House of Representatives will vote on H.R. 822, the "National Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act." Please contact Representative Hanabusa and urge her to vote for this pro-gun legislation. This important bill would allow any law-abiding concealed carry permit holder to legally carry a concealed firearm while visiting any state that does not prohibit concealed carry.
Please contact Rep. Hanabusa as soon as possible and urge her to vote for H.R. 822, the "National Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act".
Phone:
Washington, DC (202) 225-2726
Honolulu (808) 541-2570
Email: http://www.capwiz.com/nra/issues/alert/?alertid=55111516 (http://www.capwiz.com/nra/issues/alert/?alertid=55111516)
OK...........really petition Hanabusa? Is this state dependent or does the NRA not have an anti-gun list of the members of Congress? WTH?
I also read that it prohibits citizens getting a CCW in another state to carry in theirs. I may be wrong?
The way it sounds to me, only people visiting can carry. If you had your cc for vegas or texas, you still wouldnt be able to cause your a resident and not "visiting"
Thats my translation of it
-
Looks like I'm changing my state of residence
-
Looks like I'm changing my state of residence
King! I made us HR 822 T-shirts dude... this will be great. We can wear them together :love:
In all honesty, I'm sure it wouldn't take long for the public message to turn into this. Which could be a good thing. It might actually motivate people to turn out and demand they too should be able to carry firearms.
It will be a losing battle for Hawaii to attempt to screw with people lawfully exercising their rights under Federal law. More importantly, you can't argue that when one person can do something, an entire populace, simply because of where their residency is, are some how inherently more dangerous or less valuable. Win - Win. GG! (good game) :thumbsup:
--- T-shirt is purely satire (a joke) in nature. :rofl:
[attachment deleted by admin]
-
Yeah that's what I was saying earlier about the whole if everyone else can ccw here why can't residents. Hopefully it helps the cause.
Also was this vote just the house, and than we have to wait another lifetime before the senate votes or when are they scheduled to hear it?
-
a Cali rep said that they would ban carry all together if this bill passes so that no one can do it. but i suppose the direct infringement on a constitutional right should be more than enough of a signal to start taking direct action against the politicians in office.
-
From what I understand, it already passed the senate.
-
a Cali rep said that they would ban carry all together if this bill passes so that no one can do it. but i suppose the direct infringement on a constitutional right should be more than enough of a signal to start taking direct action against the politicians in office.
They wouldn't do it.. They are full of it. There are PLENTY of people in CA who like guns.
-
From what I understand, it already passed the senate.
Just the house, unless you have a source I missed. We wait for some procedural slight of hand to get this through the Senate.
-
a Cali rep said that they would ban carry all together if this bill passes so that no one can do it. but i suppose the direct infringement on a constitutional right should be more than enough of a signal to start taking direct action against the politicians in office.
They wouldn't do it.. They are full of it. There are PLENTY of people in CA who like guns.
but would we do if the politicians in HI attempted to do the same?
-
but would we do if the politicians in HI attempted to do the same?
That isn't a winning proposition for the State. It's probably the least of my concerns. If it did happen, what would be different for us? We already have a ban.
Bans on self-defense are much easier to argue against, then selective restrictions.
-
I also read that it prohibits citizens getting a CCW in another state to carry in theirs. I may be wrong?
The way it sounds to me, only people visiting can carry. If you had your cc for vegas or texas, you still wouldnt be able to cause your a resident and not "visiting"
Thats my translation of it
This is correct. If the state of residence does NOT issue, this measure has specific language to mitigate any circumvention of that states policy. For example, you live in State X that doesn not issue. Next door is State W or Y and they do. You cannot get a permit from the neighboring state and be legal tocarry in your state of residence because State X does not issue. You would be in violation of the State Law as well as the Federal Reciprocity.
-
Even if this does nothing at all to directly affect Hawaii's residents, it's a step in the right direction. Aside from the arguments locals will be able to make about non-resident military and tourists carrying, it serves to underscore the fact that Hawaii is not on the same page as the rest of the country. For the sovereignty advocates, I suppose that's good news. The rest of the state, on the other hand, is eventually going to notice that Hawaii is turning into a bastard stepchild as the rest of the country moves to a stronger 2A stance, and they're not going to like it. Especially the state lawmakers with their eyes set on moving up to Washington DC! The state legislators are the ones we need to change their minds about concealed carry. The better things get for gun owners on the mainland, the easier it is for us out here to say, "Why are you being so backward? Gun control is sooooo 1960's, and is a proven failure. Get with the times, dog!"
-
Hawaii calls itself a shall issue state.
As such, I believe something needs to change, one way or the other.
Either they'll honor the federal law which means they'll start issuing permits, or they'll pass additional legislation meaning they won't issue permits (as usual) as a matter of law.
-
Hawaii calls itself a shall issue state.
I knew what you meant, but Hawaii calls itself a "may issue" state. As in they "may issue" you a permit or not. In our case "not" is the consistant answer making it an effective ban.
-
http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/CarryL (http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/CarryL)
the house debate on the national carry bill. it's a bit long but if you got the time it's pretty nice to watch.
-
http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/CarryL (http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/CarryL)
the house debate on the national carry bill. it's a bit long but if you got the time it's pretty nice to watch.
Don't have time right now, but did you see C-Span's description of the video?
Committee members considered rules for House floor debate on H.S. 822, the National Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act. The legislation would allow lawful gun owners to carry concealed guns in other states, even if those other states prohibit concealed arms.
The bill does nothing of the sort!
-
http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/CarryL (http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/CarryL)
the house debate on the national carry bill. it's a bit long but if you got the time it's pretty nice to watch.
Don't have time right now, but did you see C-Span's description of the video?
Committee members considered rules for House floor debate on H.S. 822, the National Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act. The legislation would allow lawful gun owners to carry concealed guns in other states, even if those other states prohibit concealed arms.
The bill does nothing of the sort!
the long story short of it was that the usual OMG EVERYONE HAS GUNS NOW!!! argument and for the children bs happened. everytime someone came out to speak against it they never cited facts and strawmanned their way into everything. one of the reps even tried to bring in the Gabrielle Giffords incident as some how being related to people with CCWs. One of the shinning moments however came from a supporter stating that if the opposition is against things that can kill people then we should even ban butter knives.
-
So does anyone know how long before the senate hears and decides on it
-
http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/CarryL (http://www.c-spanvideo.org/program/CarryL)
the house debate on the national carry bill. it's a bit long but if you got the time it's pretty nice to watch.
At around 1hr and 14min in I actually saw eye candy. O0
-
found more info. about this....
The bill is pretty much gutted by all the amendments and red tape added on to it: Amendment No. 1—Rep. Woodall (R-GA): This amendment would protect the rights of states that already have reciprocal agreements in place for the concealed carry of firearms to continue enforcing those preexisting agreements.
Amendment No. 2—Rep. McCarthy (D-NY): This amendment would specify that the legislation can only go into effect in states that have passed legislation enacting the bill.
Amendment No. 3—Rep. Hastings (D-FL): This amendment would exempt states from issuing a carry permit on the basis of state reciprocity which do not require individuals to apply for and complete a carry permit application in person.
Amendment No. 4—Rep. Jackson Lee (D-TX): This amendment would require a state to create a comprehensive database to contain all permits and licenses issued by the state for carrying a concealed weapon and make this comprehensive database available to law enforcement officers from all states 24 hours a day.
Amendment No. 5—Rep. Conyers (D-MI): This amendment would effectively gut the bill by “preserving†state laws with respect to eligibility for concealed-carry.
Amendment No. 6—Rep. Johnson (D-GA): This amendment would require the possession or carrying of a concealed handgun in a state to be subject to “any law of the state that limits the eligibility to possess or carry a concealed handgun to persons who have received firearm safety training that includes a live-fire exercise.’’
Amendment No. 7—Rep. Cohen (D-TN): This amendment would exempt from the bill any state law requiring a person to be at least 21 years of age to possess or carry a concealed handgun.
Amendment No. 8—Rep. Jackson Lee (D-TX): This amendment would require a person intending to carry or possess a concealed handgun in a state to inform that state’s law enforcement of their intentions at least 24 hours prior.
Amendment No. 9—Rep. Cicilline (D-RI): This amendment would limit the bill from taking effect in a state until the State Attorney General, head of the State police, and the Secretary of State have jointly certified that the other state’s carry laws are substantially similar to its own licensing or permitting requirements.
Amendment No. 10—Rep. Reichert (R-WA): This amendment would require a Government Accountability Office (GAO) study on the ability of state and local law enforcement authorities to verify the validity of out-of-state concealed firearms permits.
and more stuff...
Not only was H.R. 822 -- the Trojan horse gun control bill -- passed out of the House of Representatives this evening, it was passed with an amendment that would open the door to federal biometric requirements for concealed firearms permits and a federally-administered database of all permit holders.
Only 7 Republican Members of Congress stood against federal overreach in the concealed carry process by opposing this bill (you can see how your Representative voted here: http://clerk.house.gov/evs/2011/roll852.xml (http://clerk.house.gov/evs/2011/roll852.xml)).
The bill was amended this afternoon by ostensibly “pro-gun†Republicans to require a study be done on the ability of law enforcement officers to verify the validity of out-of-state concealed firearm permits.
You and I both know what this means. A year from now, the study will come back stating that the only way to “verify†out-of-state permits is through federally-mandated biometric requirements for concealed firearm permits and Congress “must†create a nationally administered database of all concealed weapon permit holders.
One of my biggest concerns about this bill -- the lists of gun owners a permit process creates -- should send shivers down your spine: Imagine Eric Holder and the BATFE with a national database of concealed carry permit holders.
It’s bad enough to have those lists exist at a state level. Once Eric Holder and his cronies find a way to request that list from a state, they’ll do it -- all the in the name of “implementing H.R. 822.â€
The legislation now moves to the Harry Reid-run Senate, where companion legislation is expected to be introduced in the coming days. I have no doubt that the anti-gunners in the Senate will use this as an opportunity to make H.R. 822 even worse.
What troubles me most about this battle is the institutional gun lobby has been leading the charge for this legislation. In fact, they’ve been brow-beating Members of Congress who dare to question the consequences of passing such a broad, overreaching piece of legislation.
Republican Congressman Justin Amash (MI-03) fought back against the institutional gun lobby for its support of H.R. 822:
"It's remarkably bold of the National Rifle Association to send out false and misleading messages regarding H R 822, an unconstitutional bill that improperly applies the Commerce Clause to concealed carry licensing. I would support legislation that gets the federal government out of the way of states that want to recognize other states' concealed carry permits. In contrast, H R 822 will hurt gun rights by conceding broad new authority to the federal government to override state sovereignty.
Gun rights advocates have fought hard to prevent liberal abuse of the Commerce Clause that would restrict gun rights... I am disappointed that the NRA has decided to put its own interests ahead of the interests of gun owners. Fortunately, many other gun rights groups rightly oppose H R 822."
Please call your Senator at (202) 224-3121 and tell them you want to keep the government’s hands off your permit and that you oppose federal intrusion into the concealed weapons permit process.
Thank you for taking action to keep the federal government out of the concealed firearms permit system.
-
So this bill is died?
-
No. All that bullshit was tossed out ;p. It's already passed and now we wait for the Senate battle.
Additionally, one must ask themselves, other than suing the post office, NAGR and GOA have done exactly... what?
-
Do you think that the passing of this bill will help the Hawaii cause?
Maybe everyone here is a little kid at heart and the, "if there doing it we can too" mentality will ensue. Yeah right.
What do you guys think though?
Oh i also emailed in. Couldnt hurt, or at least i hope not
I don't think this will help Hawaii. Until Hawaii gets sued and is forced to go to a shall carry mentality nothing will change.
Wouldnt this be a loophole for those Hawaii residents with non-resident permits in other states, allowing them to carry at home under a different card?
-
it would work for Hawaii citizens if they became not-Hawaii citizens and they change their residence elsewhere, but still live here. Whether they carry a non-resident permit is not considered. You can only get a ccp in your home state if your home state allows you to. But, you can get a non-resident permit, and it will be valid anywhere else in the nation (other than your home state) when traveling, that has ccp/ccw laws in their books.
-
So as a local resident, you get pulled over and you're asked if you have any weapons on you and declare your ccw as well as your out-of-state ccp. As long as your residence is in Hawaii, and you don't have a Hawaii ccp, you're in big trouble.
Same with any other state. California!
As long as your residence is California, and you don't have a California ccp, you're in big trouble.
So, if you're not a residence of Hawaii, and carry an out-of-state ccp, then you're safe. No harm done. Because the ccp is reciprocal to any state but your home state.
-
I don't think this law would help us much.
As a Hawaii resident you would still find yourself arrested by a Hawaii cop and in a Hawaii court with Hawaiian jurors defending yourself against Hawaii's CC laws. Unless you had the CC permit before moving here you'd have a tough time convincing the court that you weren't just trying to get around the law.
It would help ~in general~ though. Kinda like drivers' licenses. It would be nice to not have to worry about violating obscure local laws if you're just passing through. If one state decides that you are safe to drive (or carry) why would another state take issue with that? I'd get a CC permit somewhere just for when I'm traveling on the mainland.
-
I don't think this law would help us much.
As a Hawaii resident you would still find yourself arrested by a Hawaii cop and in a Hawaii court with Hawaiian jurors defending yourself against Hawaii's CC laws. Unless you had the CC permit before moving here you'd have a tough time convincing the court that you weren't just trying to get around the law.
It would help ~in general~ though. Kinda like drivers' licenses. It would be nice to not have to worry about violating obscure local laws if you're just passing through. If one state decides that you are safe to drive (or carry) why would another state take issue with that? I'd get a CC permit somewhere just for when I'm traveling on the mainland.
It's going to help plenty. When a tourist can carry a gun but you can't... there are some obvious flaws in the system that will not stay around.
-
Email in my inbox today. Name changed. :P
November 29, 2011
Dear Mr. BUGLEBOY,
Thank you for your correspondence expressing your support for H.R. 822, the National Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act of 2011. This legislation was introduced by Representative Cliff Stearns (FL) on February 18th, 2011.
The purpose of this bill is to amend the federal criminal code to authorize a person who is carrying a government-issued photographic identification document and a valid permit to carry a concealed firearm in one state, and who is not prohibited from possessing, transporting, shipping, or receiving a firearm under federal law, to carry a concealed handgun (other than a machine gun or destructive device) in another state in accordance with the restrictions of that state.
On November 16th, 2011 this legislation came to the House floor for consideration and passed by a vote of 272-154. I voted against this legislation as there are a number of disconcerting implications of this bill that must be considered. First, because state laws regarding concealed carry permitting vary so widely, a permit in one state is not necessarily equal to another state's permit. If this bill were to become law, someone who is denied a permit in their home state could technically go to a more lenient state and obtain the same permit with fewer restrictions. Moreover, this bill would create a federal mandate and thereby essentially limit states' rights.
While we may not agree on this specific policy, I respect your views and always appreciate hearing from you regarding your thoughts on the critical issues facing our country.
Should similar matters be brought to the House floor for discussion and deliberation during the 112th Congress, I will be sure to keep your comments in mind.
Again, thank you for expressing your views on this crucial issue. I hope you will continue to contact me on federal matters of concern to you. If you would like regular updates, please sign up for my e-newsletter at http://hanabusa.house.gov (http://hanabusa.house.gov)
Sincerely,
Colleen Hanabusa
Member of Congress
-
woah i just checked my e mail and got the same message. I wonder if it reads the same? Seems pretty clear to me, that you cannot go to another state and obtain a ccw to carry in your residence state.
I feel like writing back and pointing that out to her. Should i write back on my own, or we all come up with a response email to send back to her? I bet she would also be surprised to know that there are residents here that have their ccw in places like AZ, and where ever else, (me personally i don't have any yet)
Dear Me,
Thank you for your correspondence expressing your support for H.R. 822, the National Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act of 2011. This legislation was introduced by Representative Cliff Stearns (FL) on February 18th, 2011.
The purpose of this bill is to amend the federal criminal code to authorize a person who is carrying a government-issued photographic identification document and a valid permit to carry a concealed firearm in one state, and who is not prohibited from possessing, transporting, shipping, or receiving a firearm under federal law, to carry a concealed handgun (other than a machine gun or destructive device) in another state in accordance with the restrictions of that state.
On November 16th, 2011 this legislation came to the House floor for consideration and passed by a vote of 272-154. I voted against this legislation as there are a number of disconcerting implications of this bill that must be considered. First, because state laws regarding concealed carry permitting vary so widely, a permit in one state is not necessarily equal to another state's permit. If this bill were to become law, someone who is denied a permit in their home state could technically go to a more lenient state and obtain the same permit with fewer restrictions. Moreover, this bill would create a federal mandate and thereby essentially limit states' rights.
While we may not agree on this specific policy, I respect your views and always appreciate hearing from you regarding your thoughts on the critical issues facing our country.
Should similar matters be brought to the House floor for discussion and deliberation during the 112th Congress, I will be sure to keep your comments in mind.
Again, thank you for expressing your views on this crucial issue. I hope you will continue to contact me on federal matters of concern to you. If you would like regular updates, please sign up for my e-newsletter at http://hanabusa.house.gov (http://hanabusa.house.gov)
Sincerely,
Colleen Hanabusa
Member of Congress
-
The first letter of each paragraph reads: TTOWSA.
Coincidence?...*puts on tinfoil*...I think not!
-
What does that stand for?
-
What does that stand for?
T[something] T[something] Occupy Wall Street. A[something].
-
What does that stand for?
T[something] T[something] Occupy Wall Street. A[something].
The True Occupy Wall Street. Advocates.
now entering DEFCON 1!!!
-
I love it. The letter essential says:
Dear Constituent That I Represent:
My opinion is clearly better and more informed than yours. Thanks for participating in the process!
Of course the bill already passed the House so there isn't much to say other than what she did and why.