2aHawaii
General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: antoinebugleboy on November 15, 2011, 08:22:35 AM
-
Not sure where this should go, so I'll post it here. Mods, please move to appropriate forum as you see fit.
I recently bought two knives, and within one day, both showed rust spots on their blades! These aren't super-expensive, deluxe knives, but they're not cheap, either (Kershaw OSO Sweet and Kershaw Skyline). In your experience, is this normal? I returned the OSO Sweet (Sorry, Sports Authority. $30 when Amazon's got it for $22?) and when I got the skyline, I applied a bit of oil on the blade immediately.
Is there a particular type of steel I should look for, or is this just to be expected from living on a tropical island?
Also, recently, I was annoyed to find rust on my pistol. I scrubbed the **** out of it and oiled it real good. Maybe there's something in the air near where I live. :(
EDIT: C-r-a-p gets censored? :rofl:
-
I'm interested in this too.
The only real knife I ever had was a CRKT M16-13z and that has stood up to any abuse I've put it through. I've never oiled it and it hasn't picked up any rust except for in the little holes in the handle. The difference may be in the type of steel.
Do you live particularly close to the ocean?
-
Not too close. In town, a couple miles from shore. I leave my window open all the time, so maybe that has something to do with it.
I ordered the M-16, too. I had it shipped Amazon Prime to my brother in LA. I'll be picking it up soon.
Rust problem aside, the Skyline is awesome. It is literally razor sharp, and I can't believe how light it is. It's not assisted opening, but it's so smooth, that with a little bit of practice, I've learned to make the blade flick out just like it was, with no wrist movement at all.
-
I can't say enough about the rust inhibiting properties of BreakFree CLP. I use that stuff on everything; knives, tools, and of course the guns, and no rust on anything I've oiled with it yet. It leaves some sort of protective film or residue or something when you wipe stuff down with it, because it protects against rust even when the steel looks perfectly dry and oil-free. I've seen a few tests people have done with salt water and iron nails, and BreakFree is always at or near the top. I've only seen it here in aerosol cans, and rarely at that, but back home or via your trusty web connection, you'll be able to buy it in a squeeze bottle with a little straw that helps get it into all the tight little nooks and crannies. Try some!
-
I'm all for economical knives too. So I don't feel bad about prying with it or losing it.
My kershaw scallion is about 5 years old and doing good. I also have about a year old CRKT Lake 111. They spend most of the time sitting on my desk but one or both go hiking a couple times a month and hunting a few times a year. They usually don't get used hiking. But the kershaw is my dressing and cleaning knife. So it's used on most hunting trips. I haven't done anything special to take care of either. Most times if it's used it gets washed off with water and maybe a little scrubbing or picking to get everything out of the folds. I don't want to oil them since it would get on the meat.
If it's salt air where you live I'd think you'd see corrosion or wear on your faucets, door knobs, handles in your house too. The stuff that gets touched and handled a lot.
-
watch this video, what you described is very common on Kershaw knives Edit: thanks 2a :thumbsup:
Knife Maintenance : Rust Speckling / Surface Rust (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6BoC5NvfN-M#ws)
-
Thanks, Cougar. I'll definitely have to check out BreakFree CLP.
s15, a lot of stuff at my place does rust, and quite badly. :( I was just surprised to see it happen so quickly, on what I thought was supposed to be corrosion-resistant steel.
808shooter, I think I read something about bead blasting somewhere else, too. Creates more surface area for corrosion or something. The Skyline is bead blasted. I don't think the OSO Sweet was, but it's the same 8Cr13MoV steel that's in the video. I had a link to the different kinds of steel used in blades nowadays and their properties, but I can't seem to find them. I'm pretty sure the 8Cr13MoV is Chinese, and is considered a cheaper steel.
EDIT: Oh, here it is: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spyderco#Blade_Steels (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spyderco#Blade_Steels)
-
one of the best products i found to protect my stuff has been ballistol.
-
Thanks, Aegis. I'll check that out as well.
-
+1 on ballistol. It is the best product I have used to protect both metal and leather.
-
+1 on ballistol. It is the best product I have used to protect both metal and leather.
Never heard of it. Where do you guys buy it? I've been using break free as well with no rusting, but am willing to try something new.
-
+1 on ballistol. It is the best product I have used to protect both metal and leather.
Never heard of it. Where do you guys buy it? I've been using break free as well with no rusting, but am willing to try something new.
you can get em on amazon in the non aerosol version for a decent price. i usually buy from http://www.armoryexpressoutlet.com/Ballistol-_c_4.html (http://www.armoryexpressoutlet.com/Ballistol-_c_4.html)
but it looks like amazon is cheaper right now if you aren't gonna be buying a box full of 'em for now.
-
Do your knives have the black dlc or whatever they call it coating on it, or are they stainless? If you have a chance, maybe try and switch your order to one with that coating. I have a Kershaw shallot thats all black. I took it out torching one night, where it was completely submerged in my pocket as I was walking, then forgot it in my friends truck. When I found it a couple months later, all it had was a single tiny rust spot on the tip of the blade. Like the other guy said, a little bit of CLP took it right off.
-
I can't say enough about the rust inhibiting properties of BreakFree CLP. I use that stuff on everything; knives, tools, and of course the guns, and no rust on anything I've oiled with it yet. It leaves some sort of protective film or residue or something when you wipe stuff down with it, because it protects against rust even when the steel looks perfectly dry and oil-free. I've seen a few tests people have done with salt water and iron nails, and BreakFree is always at or near the top. I've only seen it here in aerosol cans, and rarely at that, but back home or via your trusty web connection, you'll be able to buy it in a squeeze bottle with a little straw that helps get it into all the tight little nooks and crannies. Try some!
Security Equipment has a whole bunch of 1 liter CLP bottles with the pump trigger spray for $22.
-
I can't say enough about the rust inhibiting properties of BreakFree CLP. I use that stuff on everything; knives, tools, and of course the guns, and no rust on anything I've oiled with it yet. It leaves some sort of protective film or residue or something when you wipe stuff down with it, because it protects against rust even when the steel looks perfectly dry and oil-free. I've seen a few tests people have done with salt water and iron nails, and BreakFree is always at or near the top. I've only seen it here in aerosol cans, and rarely at that, but back home or via your trusty web connection, you'll be able to buy it in a squeeze bottle with a little straw that helps get it into all the tight little nooks and crannies. Try some!
Security Equipment has a whole bunch of 1 liter CLP bottles with the pump trigger spray for $22.
^+1
security equipment tends to have the best selection of cleaning chemicals.
-
At another forum I used to frequent, a knife maker suggested using Sentry Solutions Marine Tuf-cloth on his tool steel (i.e. really non-stainless steel) knives. He also suggested that if your knives were going to be used on any kind of food you plan to eat, use mineral oil instead since it is edible.
-
I hate to stir up the pot but I stopped using breakfree years ago after the controversy over the health effects of exposure to breakfree. The MSDS for breakfree lists liver and kidney damage as health hazards. The key to this hazard is the amount of exposure required to adversely affect the human body. Just to be on the safe side I no longer use it. I am sure that most people will probably not experience any ill effects from using break free. If it was really hazardous it would have been pulled from the market. I would not apply it to a blade that would contact any food. Just my 2 cents.
-
I hate to stir up the pot but I stopped using breakfree years ago after the controversy over the health effects of exposure to breakfree. The MSDS for breakfree lists liver and kidney damage as health hazards. The key to this hazard is the amount of exposure required to adversely affect the human body. Just to be on the safe side I no longer use it. I am sure that most people will probably not experience any ill effects from using break free. If it was really hazardous it would have been pulled from the market. I would not apply it to a blade that would contact any food. Just my 2 cents.
Same reason why I went to Slip2000 EWL for my guns and knives. It is non-toxic and doesnt burn off and cake up carbon on AR bolts like CLP, especially when using a suppressor. For long term rust protection, I use corrosion X, smells like gear oil but works as advertised. Great for protecting tools and firearms and such when away for things like year long deployments.
-
At another forum I used to frequent, a knife maker suggested using Sentry Solutions Marine Tuf-cloth on his tool steel (i.e. really non-stainless steel) knives. He also suggested that if your knives were going to be used on any kind of food you plan to eat, use mineral oil instead since it is edible.
Good tip on the mineral oil. Thanks!
-
I hate to stir up the pot but I stopped using breakfree years ago after the controversy over the health effects of exposure to breakfree. The MSDS for breakfree lists liver and kidney damage as health hazards. The key to this hazard is the amount of exposure required to adversely affect the human body. Just to be on the safe side I no longer use it. I am sure that most people will probably not experience any ill effects from using break free. If it was really hazardous it would have been pulled from the market. I would not apply it to a blade that would contact any food. Just my 2 cents.
Good to know! :shake: Thanks! :shaka:
-
It's funny, my knives marked with Taiwan are nicer than my knives marked with China... My CRKT M16 doesn't rust and it's marked Taiwan but the SOG Tanto blade use to rust and was marked China....
-
At another forum I used to frequent, a knife maker suggested using Sentry Solutions Marine Tuf-cloth on his tool steel (i.e. really non-stainless steel) knives. He also suggested that if your knives were going to be used on any kind of food you plan to eat, use mineral oil instead since it is edible.
I haven't tried mineral oil but after I sharpen my knives with a 2 stage kitchen knife sharpener, I always put some canola or olive oil on a paper napkin and run it on the metal surface. I've noticed little flakes of lint stick on the blade since I've done this though, probably from my pocket.
Not sure if the cooking oil is a good idea or not but the knife seems to work fine and stays sharp.
-
At another forum I used to frequent, a knife maker suggested using Sentry Solutions Marine Tuf-cloth on his tool steel (i.e. really non-stainless steel) knives. He also suggested that if your knives were going to be used on any kind of food you plan to eat, use mineral oil instead since it is edible.
I haven't tried mineral oil but after I sharpen my knives with a 2 stage kitchen knife sharpener, I always put some canola or olive oil on a paper napkin and run it on the metal surface. I've noticed little flakes of lint stick on the blade since I've done this though, probably from my pocket.
Not sure if the cooking oil is a good idea or not but the knife seems to work fine and stays sharp.
...and tasty! :crazy:
I know you season cast iron skillets with cooking oil, so I guess there's no reason why it wouldn't work on knives.
-
At another forum I used to frequent, a knife maker suggested using Sentry Solutions Marine Tuf-cloth on his tool steel (i.e. really non-stainless steel) knives. He also suggested that if your knives were going to be used on any kind of food you plan to eat, use mineral oil instead since it is edible.
I haven't tried mineral oil but after I sharpen my knives with a 2 stage kitchen knife sharpener, I always put some canola or olive oil on a paper napkin and run it on the metal surface. I've noticed little flakes of lint stick on the blade since I've done this though, probably from my pocket.
Not sure if the cooking oil is a good idea or not but the knife seems to work fine and stays sharp.
...and tasty! :crazy:
I know you season cast iron skillets with cooking oil, so I guess there's no reason why it wouldn't work on knives.
........because knives aren't cast iron?
-
At another forum I used to frequent, a knife maker suggested using Sentry Solutions Marine Tuf-cloth on his tool steel (i.e. really non-stainless steel) knives. He also suggested that if your knives were going to be used on any kind of food you plan to eat, use mineral oil instead since it is edible.
I haven't tried mineral oil but after I sharpen my knives with a 2 stage kitchen knife sharpener, I always put some canola or olive oil on a paper napkin and run it on the metal surface. I've noticed little flakes of lint stick on the blade since I've done this though, probably from my pocket.
Not sure if the cooking oil is a good idea or not but the knife seems to work fine and stays sharp.
...and tasty! :crazy:
I know you season cast iron skillets with cooking oil, so I guess there's no reason why it wouldn't work on knives.
........because knives aren't cast iron?
Let him try.
He will be the only one who has bacon smelling knives. :rofl:
-
At another forum I used to frequent, a knife maker suggested using Sentry Solutions Marine Tuf-cloth on his tool steel (i.e. really non-stainless steel) knives. He also suggested that if your knives were going to be used on any kind of food you plan to eat, use mineral oil instead since it is edible.
I haven't tried mineral oil but after I sharpen my knives with a 2 stage kitchen knife sharpener, I always put some canola or olive oil on a paper napkin and run it on the metal surface. I've noticed little flakes of lint stick on the blade since I've done this though, probably from my pocket.
Not sure if the cooking oil is a good idea or not but the knife seems to work fine and stays sharp.
...and tasty! :crazy:
I know you season cast iron skillets with cooking oil, so I guess there's no reason why it wouldn't work on knives.
........because knives aren't cast iron?
Let him try.
He will be the only one who has bacon smelling knives. :rofl:
Fitting, if the knife in question is a pig sticker...
-
At another forum I used to frequent, a knife maker suggested using Sentry Solutions Marine Tuf-cloth on his tool steel (i.e. really non-stainless steel) knives. He also suggested that if your knives were going to be used on any kind of food you plan to eat, use mineral oil instead since it is edible.
I haven't tried mineral oil but after I sharpen my knives with a 2 stage kitchen knife sharpener, I always put some canola or olive oil on a paper napkin and run it on the metal surface. I've noticed little flakes of lint stick on the blade since I've done this though, probably from my pocket.
Not sure if the cooking oil is a good idea or not but the knife seems to work fine and stays sharp.
...and tasty! :crazy:
I know you season cast iron skillets with cooking oil, so I guess there's no reason why it wouldn't work on knives.
........because knives aren't cast iron?
Let him try.
He will be the only one who has bacon smelling knives. :rofl:
Fitting, if the knife in question is a pig sticker...
He's a collector, never hunted in his life. :(
-
At another forum I used to frequent, a knife maker suggested using Sentry Solutions Marine Tuf-cloth on his tool steel (i.e. really non-stainless steel) knives. He also suggested that if your knives were going to be used on any kind of food you plan to eat, use mineral oil instead since it is edible.
I haven't tried mineral oil but after I sharpen my knives with a 2 stage kitchen knife sharpener, I always put some canola or olive oil on a paper napkin and run it on the metal surface. I've noticed little flakes of lint stick on the blade since I've done this though, probably from my pocket.
Not sure if the cooking oil is a good idea or not but the knife seems to work fine and stays sharp.
...and tasty! :crazy:
I know you season cast iron skillets with cooking oil, so I guess there's no reason why it wouldn't work on knives.
........because knives aren't cast iron?
I guess I should stop trying to make eggs on my knives, then.
-
He's a collector, never hunted in his life. :(
You are correct. Thanks for representing me. :shaka:
-
I found out the following, which I hope will be useful to at least a few of you out there:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silica_gel (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silica_gel)
Cat litter
Silica gel is also used as cat litter,[7] by itself or in combination with more traditional materials, such as clays including bentonite. It is trackless and virtually odorless. Purchasing silica in the form of cat litter can be an easy and cost effective way for retail consumers to purchase silica gel for use in other applications, such as maintaining the desired relative humidity in humidors, keeping tools or other materials rust-free in damp environments or long-term storage, and preserving dried food.
Get some crystal cat litter, tie off a bit in an old sock or other porous sack, and voila! Cheap desiccant pack! :) I can see tying off a big sock full of this stuff to put in a gun safe, for example.
-
Also, I picked up a couple of these Flambeau Zerust plastic boxes at Wal-mart for about $4 each.
http://www.flambeauoutdoors.com/fishing/zerust-protection/default.asp (http://www.flambeauoutdoors.com/fishing/zerust-protection/default.asp)
This plastic supposedly releases a harmless vapor that fights rust. I've only had it a couple weeks, so I cannot speak to its effectiveness, but it's as cheap as other plastic bins, so why not? The dividers are perfectly sized for my knives.
And I also include a silica gel desiccant with each knife, after I've wiped them down with some RemOil (It was what they had at the store I went to.).
If my knives rust at this point (They're all of varying steels, from AUS-8A and Sandvik to CrMoV-whatchamacallits.), I'm just giving up and resigning myself to having to inspect them regularly and wiping rust off them. :(