2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: hvybarrels on June 14, 2016, 03:00:54 PM
-
We definitely won't get concealed carry done in this state without some serious coalition building, and according to some news reports it's possible a good number of the casualties at the Pulse night club shooting were from SWAT responding with little regard for the patrons. These are only initial reports, but if it turns out to be true then it begs the question if police view LGBT as second class citizens and expendable.
Regardless there never was a better opportunity to bring them over to our side, and possibly save some of their lives (and those around them) from extremist violence.
http://thefreethoughtproject.com/police-admit-officers-orlando-shooting/
-
We definitely won't get concealed carry done in this state without some serious coalition building, and according to some news reports it's possible a good number of the casualties at the Pulse night club shooting were from SWAT responding with little regard for the patrons. These are only initial reports, but if it turns out to be true then it begs the question if police view LGBT as second class citizens and expendable.
Regardless there never was a better opportunity to bring them over to our side, and possibly save some of their lives (and those around them) from extremist violence.
http://thefreethoughtproject.com/police-admit-officers-orlando-shooting/
I don't fault your intentions, but this is troubling to me.
I've seen many researchers and stats talking about the mental issues some in the LGBT community suffer from, most notably the transgenders. I've personally known a few openly gay and lesbian coworkers who superficially appeared very normal in a workplace setting. But under pressure or dealing with personal issues in their lives were a different story. I won't stereotype by trying to describe what I saw, but to me, they had some definite problems handling stress and seemed to revert to "it's because I'm Gay" when someone had a disagreement -- almost the same as playing the race card when a minority doesn't get what they wanted.
Even with the mental health screening that's done here, I fear the lack of prior counseling or diagnosis will let more people slip through the cracks. I'm not painting the whole group as crazy, but the stats show a higher frequency of psychological issues in the LGBT community than the general population.
Here's one source:
LGBTQ individuals are almost 3 times more likely than others to experience a mental health condition such as major depression or generalized anxiety disorder. This fear of coming out and being discriminated against for sexual orientation and gender identities, can lead to depression, posttraumatic stress disorder, thoughts of suicide and substance abuse.
LGBTQ people must confront stigma and prejudice based on their sexual orientation or gender identity while also dealing with the societal bias against mental health conditions. Some people report having to hide their sexual orientation from those in the mental health system for fear of being ridiculed or rejected. Some hide their mental health conditions from their LGBTQ friends.
As a community, LGBTQ individuals do not often talk about mental health and may lack awareness about mental health conditions. This sometimes prevents people from seeking the treatment and support that they need to get better.
https://www.nami.org/Find-Support/LGBTQ
-
I mentioned in another thread that my friend went to a rally at the state capital after the incident. His words of support were for the right for gays to have CCW so they could shoot the terrorist and he didn't receive a very warm welcome even though he was truly supportive of them. But overall, I will take any new supporters I can.
-
From that same article I posted:
The LGBTQ community is at a higher risk for suicide because we lack peer support and face harassment, mental health conditions and substance abuse. For LGBTQ people aged 10–24, suicide is one of the leading causes of death. LGBTQ youth are 4 times more likely and questioning youth are 3 times more likely to attempt suicide, experience suicidal thoughts or engage in self-harm than straight people. Between 38-65% of transgender individuals experience suicidal ideation.
Family support plays a particularly important role in affecting the likelihood of suicide. Someone who faced rejection after coming out to their families were more than 8 times more likely to have attempted suicide than someone who was accepted by their family after revealing their sexual orientation.
Since 61% of firearms deaths annually are suicides, is it really a good idea to introduce firearms to the community? There's 2A, and then there is common sense.
After every mass shooting, we call for better mental health evals so we can prevent having guns in the wrong hands. Knowing the incidence of mental heath problems and suicides in this group, I'm just curious what your (OP) thoughts are.
-
A little bit of a side issue but does anyone else thing combining LGBT into one group ends up being misleading? They combine different groups of people with their own unique issues into one group and then tries to make statements as if they apply to all in the group. For example suicide rates are higher but are they equally higher among all of the groups or is just one segment of the group the cause for the higher rate of suicide?
I don't know if this matters in terms of where we get gun support from but it seems like combining groups like this could end up drowning out individual voices and issues unique to that group.
Does anyone have any ideas on how we might go about attracting individuals who are gay or trans or bi?
-
A little bit of a side issue but does anyone else thing combining LGBT into one group ends up being misleading? They combine different groups of people with their own unique issues into one group and then tries to make statements as if they apply to all in the group. For example suicide rates are higher but are they equally higher among all of the groups or is just one segment of the group the cause for the higher rate of suicide?
I don't know if this matters in terms of where we get gun support from but it seems like combining groups like this could end up drowning out individual voices and issues unique to that group.
Does anyone have any ideas on how we might go about attracting individuals who are gay or trans or bi?
An earlier report published in April 2011 by the Williams Institute estimated that 3.8 percent of Americans identified as gay/lesbian, bisexual, or transgender: 1.7 percent as lesbian or gay, 1.8 percent as bisexual, and 0.3 percent as transgender.
By voluntarily joining as one group, the subgroups have a slightly larger voice than they would separately. Trying to segregate them for any purpose is not going to sit well with the community as a whole. They see their lifestyles as something they have in common, and using suicide rates to treat them differently from each other will be seen as divisive and discriminatory.
-
It's understandable how people might have some issues after being constantly condemned their whole lives as sexual deviants, even though historically (as wellas through the modern era) they have been some of the fiercest warriors and have made countless valuable contributions to society.
-
It's understandable how people might have some issues if they are constantly condemned their whole lives as sexual deviants, even though historically (as wellas through the modern era) they have been some of the fiercest warriors and have made countless valuable contributions to society.
Being a fierce warrior is a great thing, if you are in a war or mortal combat.
In our current situation, we need psychologically balanced people owning guns. Until there is a tool or test for figuring out how balanced or unbalanced someone is, straight or not, we should look at existing risk factors. If studies show LGBTQ communities have a higher instance of mental health issues, maybe that doesn't need to be an immediate disqualifier. Maybe it can be a flag to require a more indepth background check, including friend and family interviews, and a professional psych eval versus simple records check??
-
It would set a dangerous precedent, and ultimately undermine the goal of becoming more inclusive. Do you really want more gun laws than are already on the books?
-
I don't see the problem because in the end people can do what they want. If the person feels they want the responsibility of protecting themselves and their loved ones, go right for it. I don't see how this would be different than any other group of individuals. The right to defend one self is for everyone. Seems that the message the leaders of these groups is that of appeasement towards their attackers, and many still fall in line. Why? I cannot understand? If I was a particularly targeted person, I'd want to fight for that right, even more so. However, many don't feel that way.
-
By voluntarily joining as one group, the subgroups have a slightly larger voice than they would separately. Trying to segregate them for any purpose is not going to sit well with the community as a whole. They see their lifestyles as something they have in common, and using suicide rates to treat them differently from each other will be seen as divisive and discriminatory.
That certainly makes sense but theoretically you could have a gay individual who does not support the transgender issue.
-
Being a fierce warrior is a great thing, if you are in a war or mortal combat.
In our current situation, we need psychologically balanced people owning guns. Until there is a tool or test for figuring out how balanced or unbalanced someone is, straight or not, we should look at existing risk factors. If studies show LGBTQ communities have a higher instance of mental health issues, maybe that doesn't need to be an immediate disqualifier. Maybe it can be a flag to require a more indepth background check, including friend and family interviews, and a professional psych eval versus simple records check??
How would the government even go about addressing that issue? Put on gun permit applications a question of whether they are LGBT and requiring them to go see a doctor?
I see the concern you are getting at but I think you run into great difficulty because that solution ends up hurting the rights of the majority for a small minority.
Black males commit crime at a higher rate but we couldn't justify stopping them more just because they are black.
-
Black males commit crime at a higher rate but we couldn't justify stopping them more just because they are black.
Yeah, "profiling" is the epitome of political incorrectness. Thus the 85-year-old woman at the airport is randomly selected for extensive screening/searched while the obvious younger muslim is randomly allowed to pass the least intrusive check. That makes sense.
-
How would the government even go about addressing that issue? Put on gun permit applications a question of whether they are LGBT and requiring them to go see a doctor?
I see the concern you are getting at but I think you run into great difficulty because that solution ends up hurting the rights of the majority for a small minority.
Black males commit crime at a higher rate but we couldn't justify stopping them more just because they are black.
That's funny, since the small minority of law abiding, legal gun owners ever commit crimes, yet the vast majority are asked to compromise their rights.
-
For me, taking the libertarian stance, gay or not gay, whatever, irrelevant.
American = right to bear arms.
If that individual decides to commit suicide, that is their own choice.
If that individual decides to go on a gun rampage, he or she should be shot by nearby armed Americans and/or police.
Prejudice = pre judging someone based on something they have not yet done or even might ever do. It is unAmerican to presume a person guilty simply by association (perceived association in many cases; for example nobody chooses to be born with a certain skin color, or even perhaps sexual orientation -- I say perhaps because in some cases it seems it is a choice and in other cases not a choice, and either way I think we need to remember all these are individual people and, specifically, American people).
In a nutshell, are they Americans? If so, then add them to the general pool of people with American rights. (That other people freely waive their own rights of arms is their own choice, so long as it does not infringe upon the rights of other Americans to bear arms -- that is the principle of course)
-
For me, taking the libertarian stance, gay or not gay, whatever, irrelevant.
American = right to bear arms.
If that individual decides to commit suicide, that is their own choice.
If that individual decides to go on a gun rampage, he or she should be shot by nearby armed Americans and/or police.
Prejudice = pre judging someone based on something they have not yet done or even might ever do. It is unAmerican to presume a person guilty simply by association (perceived association in many cases; for example nobody chooses to be born with a certain skin color, or even perhaps sexual orientation -- I say perhaps because in some cases it seems it is a choice and in other cases not a choice, and either way I think we need to remember all these are individual people and, specifically, American people).
In a nutshell, are they Americans? If so, then add them to the general pool of people with American rights. (That other people freely waive their own rights of arms is their own choice, so long as it does not infringe upon the rights of other Americans to bear arms -- that is the principle of course)
Are you saying there is no line between certain "high risk groups" and "Americans in general?"
Mental incompetence or psychosis
Violent Felons
People with a history of suicide attempts
Ties with known terrorists or other criminals (organized crime)
Sexual Predators
Domestic Abusers
Is there no room in the Libertarian dictionary for "high risk groups," or are we all allowed to make our own choice no matter what?
-
It seems to be pretty obvious AT FIRST BLUSH that high risk groups should be considered separately.
BUT first using the libertarian principle, I then test to see if it is valid and makes sense.
Now, ASSUMING that the "high risk group" has not already committed crimes (back to the "presumed innocent" discussion), they are therefore considered everyday Americans.
FURTHERMORE, if you consider that "patriotic Americans" (those who "cling" to the Constitution) can in the future (actually already) labeled a "high risk group" then you can see why the libertarian principle makes sense.
Gun rights are provided to Americans as a whole class of citizenry. The abuse of gun rights of one person, or a small group, is to be thwarted by other armed lawful Americans in self-defense.
No different than abuse of free speech (libel/slander) is to be thwarted by free speech (proving the slander was a lie, and therefore subject to lawsuit).
-
So just to highlight the "gay risk" issue, what this means is, if one wishes to say that LGBT people are high risk, then their mental condition needs to be legally defined as such.
It used to be the case, but is not today. (Homosexuality was defined as an abnormal mental condition).
I am making no judgement on that. I am saying that is what is the factual and legal basis.
You can legally define black people as high risk. You can legally define black people as having no American rights. Etc. (All this has happened before).
Hopefully now you can see why it is a "high risk" area to wander into, when groups are being defined in certain ways.
You MUST have valid medical, scientific reason, to categorize people to DENY them rights.
(I am NOT saying that BONA FIDE MENTALLY INCOMPETENT or VIOLENT ABUSERS are to be given guns, but they must be LEGALLY and FACTUALLY proven to be such persons).
-
http://www.dailywire.com/news/6612/west-hollywood-inundated-poster-rainbow-gadsen-hank-berrien
-
Enjoy!
-
Are you saying there is no line between certain "high risk groups" and "Americans in general?"
Being in a "high risk group" does not justify denying peoples rights. The individual has to be specifically shown to have done something wrong before you can take away their rights. The government has to justify each and every instance when they take away someone's civil rights (there may be very limited exceptions).
Do you think the USA was right to put Japanese Americans into internment camps because they were considered higher risk?
-
Enjoy!
Do you think they might be hesitant to support the NRA and gun rights given that conservatives weren't exactly lining up to support them when they wanted to marry? They might think we are just using them as pawn pieces.
-
Do you think they might be hesitant to support the NRA and gun rights given that conservatives weren't exactly lining up to support them when they wanted to marry? They might think we are just using them as pawn pieces.
The OP never mentioned the NRA. I am not sure why anyone here would attempt to get anyone from the LGBT groups to support the NRA? I know I certainly would not. I don't recall the NRA taking any sort of stance on gay marriage. So I don't understand how you are relating the NRA to this subject? I don't understand why you even brought it up? I spent most of my life not supporting the NRA until I came to my senses.
With that said you do bring up a good point due to most LGBT are not conservatives. But I do know a lot of LGBT and they are gun owners. So I believe we have nothing to lose and everything to gain. Besides, if we are sincere and we make them feel welcome to join us we just made a bunch of new friends. :-* :love: :-*
-
Being in a "high risk group" does not justify denying peoples rights. The individual has to be specifically shown to have done something wrong before you can take away their rights. The government has to justify each and every instance when they take away someone's civil rights (there may be very limited exceptions).
Do you think the USA was right to put Japanese Americans into internment camps because they were considered higher risk?
Try telling that to the law makers!!
In places where medical marijuana is LEGAL, you are still denied the right to own a gun if you have a MM card. Partly, that's due to the feds still classifying you as an "addict" and marijuana as a schedule 1 drug (along with heroin).
So, yes, by simply having a condition that you treat with MM, you CAN and DO have your 2A rights denied without being charged with any crime.
Try again.
-
In our current situation, we need psychologically balanced people owning guns.
This statement made me ponder:
It's ironic how guns should be in the hands of the peacekeeper, the most morally sound individuals.
-
This statement made me ponder:
It's ironic how guns should be in the hands of the peacekeeper, the most morally sound individuals.
"Peace through strength" is an ancient phrase and concept that implies strength of arms is a necessary component of peace.
-
The OP never mentioned the NRA. I am not sure why anyone here would attempt to get anyone from the LGBT groups to support the NRA? I know I certainly would not. I don't recall the NRA taking any sort of stance on gay marriage. So I don't understand how you are relating the NRA to this subject? I don't understand why you even brought it up? I spent most of my life not supporting the NRA until I came to my senses.
With that said you do bring up a good point due to most LGBT are not conservatives. But I do know a lot of LGBT and they are gun owners. So I believe we have nothing to lose and everything to gain. Besides, if we are sincere and we make them feel welcome to join us we just made a bunch of new friends. :-* :love: :-*
I mentioned the NRA as sort of the face of gun rights, I didn't mean that NRA took a particular stance. I don't know who made the graphic at the bottom of the last page. Sorry for the confusion.
-
Try telling that to the law makers!!
In places where medical marijuana is LEGAL, you are still denied the right to own a gun if you have a MM card. Partly, that's due to the feds still classifying you as an "addict" and marijuana as a schedule 1 drug (along with heroin).
So, yes, by simply having a condition that you treat with MM, you CAN and DO have your 2A rights denied without being charged with any crime.
Try again.
'
You are comparing two different jurisdiction's laws. Medical marijuana is not legal under federal law, thus it is not a high risk category, it is a breaking the law category.
I noticed to didn't answer my question about Japanese Americans being put into internment camps.
-
'
You are comparing two different jurisdiction's laws. Medical marijuana is not legal under federal law, thus it is not a high risk category, it is a breaking the law category.
I noticed to didn't answer my question about Japanese Americans being put into internment camps.
According to you, no one is a criminal unless they have been arrested, charged, tried ,and found guilty.
"innocent until proven guilty"
Is your new position that you are a criminal just for breaking the law without actually having a record?
-
According to you, no one is a criminal unless they have been arrested, charged, tried ,and found guilty.
"innocent until proven guilty"
Is your new position that you are a criminal just for breaking the law without actually having a record?
It is a safe assumption that if you go and get a medical marijuana license then you are using marijuana. Yes, there may be no actual conviction, but has this withstood legal challenge? There are certainly constitutional questions to such decisions. But you will notice that I originally said there may be a few exceptions to the rule.
I'll note that you are avoiding answering the question about Japanese Americans being put into internment camps. I can only suspect that you feel it is justifiable.
Hope you never find yourself to be an a higher risk group because you are basically making the case for your own rights to be taken away based on the risk assessment of the group.
-
It is a safe assumption that if you go and get a medical marijuana license then you are using marijuana. Yes, there may be no actual conviction, but has this withstood legal challenge? There are certainly constitutional questions to such decisions. But you will notice that I originally said there may be a few exceptions to the rule.
I'll note that you are avoiding answering the question about Japanese Americans being put into internment camps. I can only suspect that you feel it is justifiable.
Hope you never find yourself to be an a higher risk group because you are basically making the case for your own rights to be taken away based on the risk assessment of the group.
Yes, I'm avoiding your attempt to once again sidetrack this discussion on an unrelated tangential direction.
You've been accused several times of that, and this is a perfect example of it. Interment Camps have nothing to do with the LGBT question. Just because you want to draw a straw-argument parallel doesn't make it tangential.
-
It is a safe assumption that if you go and get a medical marijuana license then you are using marijuana. Yes, there may be no actual conviction, but has this withstood legal challenge? There are certainly constitutional questions to such decisions. But you will notice that I originally said there may be a few exceptions to the rule.
I'll note that you are avoiding answering the question about Japanese Americans being put into internment camps. I can only suspect that you feel it is justifiable.
Hope you never find yourself to be an a higher risk group because you are basically making the case for your own rights to be taken away based on the risk assessment of the group.
How can you even believe that? If I'm ever declared non compos mentis, diagnosed with psychological problems or addicted to drugs, you can bet I'd want my right to own guns revoked! Do we not keep throwing around the phrase RESPONSIBLE GUN OWNER? How responsible would it be to refuse to give up your right to have guns when you may not have clear and responsible judgement due to disease or intoxication?
-
How can you even believe that? If I'm ever declared non compos mentis, diagnosed with psychological problems or addicted to drugs, you can bet I'd want my right to own guns revoked! Do we not keep throwing around the phrase RESPONSIBLE GUN OWNER? How responsible would it be to refuse to give up your right to have guns when you may not have clear and responsible judgement due to disease or intoxication?
Being diagnosed with serious psychological problems is an entirely different situation than just being a member of the LGBT community which has a higher rate of suicide than the rest of society.
-
Being diagnosed with serious psychological problems is an entirely different situation than just being a member of the LGBT community which has a higher rate of suicide than the rest of society.
You said if I was ever in a higher risk group [.......]
I have a much higher chance of finding myself in one of the situations I described than in the LGBTQ group. I mean, you can be in any group you want, and it doesn't bother me, but I'll have to pass on that one! If you say it's different being in that group, I'll have to take you at your word this time!
-
You said if I was ever in a higher risk group [.......]
I have a much higher chance of finding myself in one of the situations I described than in the LGBTQ group. I mean, you can be in any group you want, and it doesn't bother me, but I'll have to pass on that one! If you say it's different being in that group, I'll have to take you at your word this time!
Legally taking away an individuals rights has to do with the actions and articulatable facts of that individual. You cannot deny a right to a person because they are a member of a group that as a whole suffers from a higher rate of problems.
-
Legally taking away an individuals rights has to do with the actions and articulatable facts of that individual. You cannot deny a right to a person because they are a member of a group that as a whole suffers from a higher rate of problems.
You should learn to read better. I stated earlier:
If studies show LGBTQ communities have a higher instance of mental health issues, maybe that doesn't need to be an immediate disqualifier. Maybe it can be a flag to require a more indepth background check, including friend and family interviews, and a professional psych eval versus simple records check??
If you make me repost everything I type, we're never going to get anywhere!
-
You should learn to read better. I stated earlier:
If you make me repost everything I type, we're never going to get anywhere!
And how are you going to better screen gay people who want to buy guns? You have trouble even justifying denying their rights longer than all those who are not gay.
-
And how are you going to better screen gay people who want to buy guns? You have trouble even justifying denying their rights longer than all those who are not gay.
We do it all the time. FBI NICS Background checks have a 3 day limit for a response, but Hawaii requires you to wait not 3 days, but 14. Is that not delaying your rights? In that amount of time, the request can be denied pending a more thorough investigation NOT for being Gay, but for being in a group identified as higher risk for mental health issues. The LGBTQ group would not be the only ones in that "extra scrutiny" category. They can cry discrimination as usual, but it won't change the truth. Certain groups should be allowed their rights once their INDIVIDUAL risk is evaluated. I believe that should also include nonviolent felons. Some of them are more in need of self defense due to the limited choices they have on where they live.
To avoid a little extra scrutiny because you feel discriminated against will not help solve the mental health issues as they relate to firearm ownership.
You keep saying "denying". What is it about you that refuses to read the words on your screen? I'm not typing it a third time, Troll Man!!
-
Just for a little historical perspective: The Parker v. Washington DC case was the case that eventually morphed into Heller and subsequently the SCOTUS case affirming an individual right to own a gun regardless of one's militia "status." Parker had several plaintiffs, all except Heller were found to NOT have standing and "their" cases were thrown out and Heller emerged as the only one with standing. One of the original plaintiffs was Tom Palmer, a gay man that alleges that he used a 9mm handgun to defend himself against a "gay bashing" incident. He states that he produced his gun (that was, incidentally, carried illegally...) when a group of men who had been verbally harassing him threatened physical harm. He did not have to fire a shot as the men dispersed, rather quickly, once he drew his handgun.
The point is that any person, regardless of race, color, creed, political affiliation, or sexual orientation, should be allowed to determine what, if any self-defense tool he wishes to use irrespective of the statistical possibility that they "might" have a psychiatric condition. And that distancing ourselves from potential allies because of that potential could be counter productive. After all, soldiers (airmen, sailors, and marines) returning from deployment have a much higher rate of suicide and PTSD. Are we trying to distance ourselves from them or are we trying to get them the help they need while preserving their god given rights and liberties as we try to do the same for ourselves?
-
Just for a little historical perspective: The Parker v. Washington DC case was the case that eventually morphed into Heller and subsequently the SCOTUS case affirming an individual right to own a gun regardless of one's militia "status." Parker had several plaintiffs, all except Heller were found to NOT have standing and "their" cases were thrown out and Heller emerged as the only one with standing. One of the original plaintiffs was Tom Palmer, a gay man that alleges that he used a 9mm handgun to defend himself against a "gay bashing" incident. He states that he produced his gun (that was, incidentally, carried illegally...) when a group of men who had been verbally harassing him threatened physical harm. He did not have to fire a shot as the men dispersed, rather quickly, once he drew his handgun.
The point is that any person, regardless of race, color, creed, political affiliation, or sexual orientation, should be allowed to determine what, if any self-defense tool he wishes to use irrespective of the statistical possibility that they "might" have a psychiatric condition. And that distancing ourselves from potential allies because of that potential could be counter productive. After all, soldiers (airmen, sailors, and marines) returning from deployment have a much higher rate of suicide and PTSD. Are we trying to distance ourselves from them or are we trying to get them the help they need while preserving their god given rights and liberties as we try to do the same for ourselves?
I couldn't agree more with the sentiment. The difficulty comes from seeing the same factors leading to violence. Drugs, Islamic Terrorism, repeat offenders in the courts, domestic abuses which have been slowly escalating in severity, people on psychotropic drugs. The others want to point to one comonality, guns, while ignoring the true causes. They are okay with stripping away that right, then scream bloody murder (figure of speech) that any other "stereotyping" is against civil rights.
There has to be a way to flag high risk people for extra screening without making it a discrimination claim. Would it be reasonable to subject all applicants to the same additional scrutiny requirements? Maybe?
Everyone talks about the weather, but nobody ever does anything about it. The same applies to mental illness.
-
We do it all the time. FBI NICS Background checks have a 3 day limit for a response, but Hawaii requires you to wait not 3 days, but 14. Is that not delaying your rights? In that amount of time, the request can be denied pending a more thorough investigation NOT for being Gay, but for being in a group identified as higher risk for mental health issues. The LGBTQ group would not be the only ones in that "extra scrutiny" category. They can cry discrimination as usual, but it won't change the truth. Certain groups should be allowed their rights once their INDIVIDUAL risk is evaluated. I believe that should also include nonviolent felons. Some of them are more in need of self defense due to the limited choices they have on where they live.
To avoid a little extra scrutiny because you feel discriminated against will not help solve the mental health issues as they relate to firearm ownership.
You keep saying "denying". What is it about you that refuses to read the words on your screen? I'm not typing it a third time, Troll Man!!
I keep saying denying because thats what it is. Not permanent but you are suggesting we subject individuals to extra scrutiny based on their being in a particular class of people that results in them not getting to practice their rights as soon as others. For that extra period of time, a person is having their rights delayed. Blacks commit more crimes, can the justice system treat them different? Women have more accidents, can we require they have different license requirements? The logic at the core of your argument is unconstitutional. Felons is a little bit different, that is something that happened by an individuals choice of actions, not by being born a certain race, sex, etc.
People in Hawaii have to wait longer because of Hawaii law. The feds don't prescribe different waiting periods for different states.
-
I keep saying denying because thats what it is. Not permanent but you are suggesting we subject individuals to extra scrutiny based on their being in a particular class of people that results in them not getting to practice their rights as soon as others. For that extra period of time, a person is having their rights delayed. Blacks commit more crimes, can the justice system treat them different? Women have more accidents, can we require they have different license requirements? The logic at the core of your argument is unconstitutional. Felons is a little bit different, that is something that happened by an individuals choice of actions, not by being born a certain race, sex, etc.
People in Hawaii have to wait longer because of Hawaii law. The feds don't prescribe different waiting periods for different states.
You'd argue with a brick wall if you thought the words a tagger wrote were wrong!
-
You'd argue with a brick wall if you thought the words a tagger wrote were wrong!
Way to avoid how I just proved you wrong.
Your willingness to deny (delay) people gun rights because they are gay worries me. You logic can be used to pretty much further delay any individual from purchasing a gun. Are ou white? More likely to be a serial killer. Are you a man? more likely to be a rapist. Are you black? More likely to commit murder. Etc etc etc.
You have to justify actions based on facts specific to an individual, not based on their membership of a certain class of people.
-
Way to avoid how I just proved you wrong.
Your willingness to deny (delay) people gun rights because they are gay worries me. You logic can be used to pretty much further delay any individual from purchasing a gun. Are ou white? More likely to be a serial killer. Are you a man? more likely to be a rapist. Are you black? More likely to commit murder. Etc etc etc.
You have to justify actions based on facts specific to an individual, not based on their membership of a certain class of people.
Yeah, keep attacking. You have nothing new to say, so you just blah, blah, blah the same point over and over. No matter how many times you repeat a weak argument, it's not going to get any stronger!
For some reason, you think you're right more than anyone else on this forum. You refuse to concede any conclusions EVEN WHEN YOUR "FACTS" ARE PROVEN WRONG!
I'm not going to repeat my point (for the third time I'm not!). Somehow, you haven't figured out you're not going to get me to.
take your Liberal whiny argument and post is somewhere else. We're tired of re-reading it over and over and over...
-
All lawful Americans should have the right to armed self defense for themselves and their loved ones, as provided by the 2nd Amendment to the Constitution of the United States of America. :closed: