2aHawaii
General Topics => Off Topic => Topic started by: ren on June 16, 2016, 08:08:07 AM
-
http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/32234076/kamehameha-schools-seniors-spark-debate-by-protesting-national-anthem-at-graduation-ceremony (http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/32234076/kamehameha-schools-seniors-spark-debate-by-protesting-national-anthem-at-graduation-ceremony)
"I feel like any place is the right place to remind people that Hawaii is Hawaii and that we are an occupied country," said Jamaica Osorio, a 2008 Kamehameha Schools graduate.
-
It upsets my kids because it's embarrassing but I frequently sit during Hawaii Pono'i because I refuse to pledge allegiance/service to a king.
Have you ever read the lyrics. (My dad pointed this out to me)
This is the U.S. Of 'Murica.
Hawaii Aloha should be the State Anthem. (Check out those lyrics. Tears to my eyes)
-
I never knew the english translation of Hawaii Pono'i... Have to ponder that one.
It is interesting that the school mentioned disciplining the students. that basically means students are forced to sing the national anthem but if it is forced then it means nothing.
What these students did doesn't really upset me. It didn't create a disturbance. On the one hand I can see where they are coming from, the overthrow was illegal. But on the other hand, it has been so long since a Hawaiian government was in place that it seems like it is just something in history you have to accept and move on.
I have never much been one for songs and anthems though.
-
I never knew the english translation of Hawaii Pono'i... Have to ponder that one.
It is interesting that the school mentioned disciplining the students. that basically means students are forced to sing the national anthem but if it is forced then it means nothing.
What these students did doesn't really upset me. It didn't create a disturbance. On the one hand I can see where they are coming from, the overthrow was illegal. But on the other hand, it has been so long since a Hawaiian government was in place that it seems like it is just something in history you have to accept and move on.
I have never much been one for songs and anthems though.
They aren't forced to sing the national anthem.
They are being punished because they disrupted the ceremony with their behavior, which is inspired by the anti-American, pro-Hawaiian ideology promoted by faculty at the school.
The overthrow was illegal, but it was literally a revolution by a group of Hawaiian citizens, no different than the American revolution, Chinese Revolution, Russian Revolution, etc. This is why the WORLD accepted the Republic of Hawaii within 48 hours of the overthrow, because they didn't care.
-
No disrespect to anyone, but can't rule out that much of this stuff is part of the same divide and conquer basket that has been passed around in recent years, weakening the whole citizen body.
-
Our national anthem is bad ass
Read the lyrics of the Star Spangled Banner, understand the context and it is the epitome of defending freedom.
My kids, and my players when I was coaching baseball, couldn't remember the lyrics.
When I explained it to them in context and they visualized it, they all remembered the lyrics.
It's a story, not just an anthem.
It is symbolic of all the problems our Country faces.
We battle for our rights and freedom.
Twilight comes and we're not sure if we'll come out the other side as an intact Country.
But at dawn, the sun rises and the Star-Spangled Banner yet waves.
O'er the Land of the Free and the Home of the Brave.
-
It's the same with almost everyone in society. People want their rights to be recognized as sacred by others, however have no problems trampling on the rights of others.
-
It's the same with almost everyone in society. People want their rights to be recognized as sacred by others, however have no problems trampling on the rights of others.
"You can do, say, kill whatever you want as long as I approve of it."
As is the case in every historical situation of socialist-communist revolution, the tables get turned around once all the rights are gone and the legal system is stacked against the ordinary person.
Used to be the case, you'd wait a while until America eventually comes to rescue you...
-
Long live the Constitution.
And the Star-Spangled Banner.
-
Long live the Constitution.
And the Star-Spangled Banner.
IMUA!
-
In my unpopular opinion no student should ever be required to say the United States pledge of allegiance, sing a hawaiian song, or attend church sermons. I had to do all 3 growing up. A lot. The only thing that resulted from this was a resentment towards all 3 entities.
-
In my unpopular opinion no student should ever be required to say the United States pledge of allegiance, sing a hawaiian song, or attend church sermons. I had to do all 3 growing up. A lot. The only thing that resulted from this was a resentment towards all 3 entities.
Jesus still loves you :love:
-
I saw this on the news along with the interview with the students who sat.... those younglings have no idea what they are talking about. I respect their right to not sing the star spangled banner, their right to protest this so called "occupation" of the Hawaiian kingdom. But these kids better be wearing the malo, pounding poi, and tending to the land like the Hawaiians did before captain cook and the missionaries came. If any one of these kids has a facebook, a smartphone, uses the internet, lives in a house, has a summer job, and pays taxes on said summer job then they are 100% assonine hypocrites. They are as much part of the problem that they are fighting against.
-
I saw this on the news along with the interview with the students who sat.... those younglings have no idea what they are talking about. I respect their right to not sing the star spangled banner, their right to protest this so called "occupation" of the Hawaiian kingdom. But these kids better be wearing the malo, pounding poi, and tending to the land like the Hawaiians did before captain cook and the missionaries came. If any one of these kids has a facebook, a smartphone, uses the internet, lives in a house, has a summer job, and pays taxes on said summer job then they are 100% assonine hypocrites. They are as much part of the problem that they are fighting against.
Do they drive on city or state highways? Do they utilize other infrastructure?
When I was doing a project in Lahaina, we held public information hearings in west Maui. At these meetings, the general sentiment was "no development", "we want things to go back to the way it was in ancient Hawaii", "we don't want or need the government", etc. Well, the majority of them either worked or had family that worked at the resorts in the area.
That said, there were the folks that "walked the walk" and lived totally off the land and pretty much fully subsistence lifestyle. It was interesting that most of them wanted nothing to do with the people that were "fighting" for sovereignty as noted above.
-
The bishop estate which subsidizes their educations at Kamehameha schools earns money from leases and rentals and sales of property owned by the estate. These kids are direct beneficiaries of the capitalist "system" that they are protesting. I'll be damned if these kids go on to further education and recieve benefit any further from said "system".
But then again that's none of business.......
-
Makes you wonder what the result would have been if the other 432 students sat down for Hawaii Pono'i. ? ???
(Troll)
-
Been debating people all day on actual facts.
Its so hilarious to see their arguments crumble, with their last resort being name calling and threats.
-
They aren't forced to sing the national anthem.
They are being punished because they disrupted the ceremony with their behavior, which is inspired by the anti-American, pro-Hawaiian ideology promoted by faculty at the school.
The overthrow was illegal, but it was literally a revolution by a group of Hawaiian citizens, no different than the American revolution, Chinese Revolution, Russian Revolution, etc. This is why the WORLD accepted the Republic of Hawaii within 48 hours of the overthrow, because they didn't care.
How was the ceremony disrupted? Did they make noise that delayed the ceremony or caused people to be unable to hear the national anthem? Did they block the free movement of people?
They visually disrupted it by not standing? Whether their position has merit or not, no one can seriously claim they were truly disrupted by such an act if all they did was sat quietly while others stood and sang.
People fought and died for their right to free speech but only as long as they use it for an approved issue?
-
Do they drive on city or state highways? Do they utilize other infrastructure?
When I was doing a project in Lahaina, we held public information hearings in west Maui. At these meetings, the general sentiment was "no development", "we want things to go back to the way it was in ancient Hawaii", "we don't want or need the government", etc. Well, the majority of them either worked or had family that worked at the resorts in the area.
That said, there were the folks that "walked the walk" and lived totally off the land and pretty much fully subsistence lifestyle. It was interesting that most of them wanted nothing to do with the people that were "fighting" for sovereignty as noted above.
I don't think using technology or infrastructure obligates them to a particular position. As ideated as their principles are, realistically they still have to fit into the current system to survive whether they like it or not.
-
I don't think using technology or infrastructure obligates them to a particular position. As ideated as their principles are, realistically they still have to fit into the current system to survive whether they like it or not.
Uh. Did you read anything I posted?
They don't want development. They want to go back to they way it was in ancient Hawaii, without the government (federal, state, city, whatevers). Yet, they take advantage of the employment opportunities that private corporations offer. They take advantage of the infrastructure that government builds. They are hypocrites. To the point where even others that they claim to be on their side want nothing to do with them.
-
Different Hawaiians want different things. Not everyone wants things to go back to the ancient ways. Some might want to be modern, but to be free to govern themselves. eyeeatingfish describes yet another possibility: those wanting everything be ancient if possible, but since they are stuck in the modern world, they must do modern things to survive.
That being said I don't have much sympathy for Hawaiians. They got conquered fair and square because they were weak. If America were tyrannical, that would be the end of it and they would be forced to say the pledge of allegiance.
But since America professes to be the land of the free, no one should be forced to say the pledge of allegiance.
-
I don't think using technology or infrastructure obligates them to a particular position. As ideated as their principles are, realistically they still have to fit into the current system to survive whether they like it or not.
The kid in the interview on the news stated that they were protesting the "system" by staying seated. "System" a vague term used by an imbecile, the system more than includes the infrastructure and technology that they directly utilize and benefit from. This student's inability to elaborate on what exactly the system is or what parts of the system they were against indicates their juvenile understanding of their own situation.
-
Seen this a while back,
(https://scontent-lax3-1.xx.fbcdn.net/t31.0-8/11901454_10155952737800634_2583549432988857203_o.jpg)
-
Different Hawaiians want different things. Not everyone wants things to go back to the ancient ways. Some might want to be modern, but to be free to govern themselves. eyeeatingfish describes yet another possibility: those wanting everything be ancient if possible, but since they are stuck in the modern world, they must do modern things to survive.
That being said I don't have much sympathy for Hawaiians. They got conquered fair and square because they were weak. If America were tyrannical, that would be the end of it and they would be forced to say the pledge of allegiance.
But since America professes to be the land of the free, no one should be forced to say the pledge of allegiance.
Yes, I understand that not all are like the example that I mentioned. Just an example that I remembered from experiences having public meetings.
-
When one is handed a gift without having to earn it, one tends to take such gifts for granted, lacking complete appreciation for its value.
-
The kid in the interview on the news stated that they were protesting the "system" by staying seated. "System" a vague term used by an imbecile, the system more than includes the infrastructure and technology that they directly utilize and benefit from. This student's inability to elaborate on what exactly the system is or what parts of the system they were against indicates their juvenile understanding of their own situation.
Possibly. But we all know that TV news interviews often cut out a lot of information so I would hesitate to assume the kid has no idea what he is talking about. Inarticulate also does not mean unintelligent either. It is difficult to summarize the entire overthrow in a 15 second news interview.
-
Uh. Did you read anything I posted?
They don't want development. They want to go back to they way it was in ancient Hawaii, without the government (federal, state, city, whatevers). Yet, they take advantage of the employment opportunities that private corporations offer. They take advantage of the infrastructure that government builds. They are hypocrites. To the point where even others that they claim to be on their side want nothing to do with them.
When Hawaii was overthrown it was't "ancient." The palace had electrical lighting before the white house. They had a fairly modern functional government. So it would be a fallacy to assume that people who protest the overthrow just want a restoration of wearing a loin cloth and living off the land in an ahupuaa.
-
Deleted...
-
Personally IMO, restoration to a Monarchy is not a modern functional government.
And less than that is not a restoration.
-
Personally IMO, restoration to a Monarchy is not a modern functional government.
And less than that is not a restoration.
As I understand it they did have an elected system of representatives, it was not a pure monarchy. I didn't mean it was modern by our definition but it was fairly modern for the era.
But either way, I doubt we would ever see a successful return to an Independent Hawaiian government. A lot of power to transfer over, too many conflicting interest, a question of who would be the actual monarch, etc.
I sympathize with the injustice that happened, but it already happened and we aren't going to change that. Dumping this government isn't going to guarantee any improvement. As much an injustice as it was, we still have a good system here of freedom, rights, and representation. Besides, if we are going to keep a record, then what about how Kamehameha the 1st violently took over all the islands, what about that injustice?
-
When Hawaii was overthrown it was't "ancient." The palace had electrical lighting before the white house. They had a fairly modern functional government. So it would be a fallacy to assume that people who protest the overthrow just want a restoration of wearing a loin cloth and living off the land in an ahupuaa.
an·cient
1. belonging to the very distant past and no longer in existence.
I didn't say anything about malos and the like.
Fallacy to assume? Those were the words of the people at the public meetings. Not mine. I could try to dig up the transcripts from those meetings as they were public testimony, but I doubt that would help. You would just find another angle to "discuss". I would encourage you to go to West Maui and talk to them yourself, but with your seemingly enjoyment and desire for arguing, I fear that you might return with less teeth.
Again, not all of the people that submitted public testimony voiced such opinions. To be honest, they probably were the minority, but they were a very vocal group and one that I remember. So if getting their message out was the goal, it definitely succeeded. However, just like this example, those who chose to no stand during the national anthem were the minority and they were certainly noticed.
-
There's nothing non-modern about having a King. Perhaps people in America believe that because we are brainwashed to believe that democracy is the only form of proper government. Aside from that, do we even have a true democracy in America? Even that point is arguable.
-
Democracy is the only proper form of government.......in The U.S. of A.. :thumbsup:
Enjoy the Freedoms that the "brainwashed" bestowed upon us when they wrote the Constitution.
But that might be discussion for another thread. ;)
-
The Constitution is great, except for when our government doesn't follow it. Our 1A, 2A, and 4A rights are being eroded as we speak.
-
an·cient
1. belonging to the very distant past and no longer in existence.
I didn't say anything about malos and the like.
Fallacy to assume? Those were the words of the people at the public meetings. Not mine. I could try to dig up the transcripts from those meetings as they were public testimony, but I doubt that would help. You would just find another angle to "discuss". I would encourage you to go to West Maui and talk to them yourself, but with your seemingly enjoyment and desire for arguing, I fear that you might return with less teeth.
Again, not all of the people that submitted public testimony voiced such opinions. To be honest, they probably were the minority, but they were a very vocal group and one that I remember. So if getting their message out was the goal, it definitely succeeded. However, just like this example, those who chose to no stand during the national anthem were the minority and they were certainly noticed.
Sorry, I didn't mean the comments of those protestors specifically, I meant protestors on this issue in general.
I wouldn't consider the Hawaiian Kingdom when it was overthrown ancient, only about 130 years ago, but I get what you meant by ancient.
-
With youths there will always be dreamers and activism and they will find a topic to champion. Kamehameha is no different and of no great surprise of what their topic of protest is about. I do have my own beliefs on the Hawaii / Hawaiian topic, but I don't even come close to aligning with the extreme sovereign separatists. As for the method of protest of the kids at the KS graduation, I personally think the manner in which they chose to make that statement sucks. If my son were to do that at Kamehameha graduation, we would be having words afterwards. However that is not something that would even be necessary due to our conversations on the topic of Hawaii and native Hawaiians in history and now. FWIW, we are proud native Hawaiians, but we are also proud Americans.
Also, we are not a democracy. They don't work. We are a Constitutional Republic. There is a huge difference between the two and we need to remain that way. There is a reason that this very young country became such a huge, successful superpower in such a short period of time. The more and more we start looking like a democracy or something worse, the closer we are to circling the toilet bowl with the rest of the turds.
-
Constitutional Democracy, constitutional Republic.
Potato, potahto.
My Kirkland tissue is not Kleenex.
Same thing in common vernacular.
But that's a different discussion.
-
Constitutional Democracy, constitutional Republic.
Potato, potahto.
My Kirkland tissue is not Kleenex.
Same thing in common vernacular.
But that's a different discussion.
I can't find the link right now, but I remember seeing Kleenex actually makes Kirkland Tissues.
:rofl: :crazy: >:D
-
Where on Google does it say Kirkland tissue is made by Kleenex? Please post your sources!
:rofl:
Sarc ::)
-
Constitutional Democracy, constitutional Republic.
Potato, potahto.
My Kirkland tissue is not Kleenex.
Same thing in common vernacular.
But that's a different discussion.
Many of Kirkland products are just screw up batches of name brands, particularly with their liquor.
-
I can't find the link right now, but I remember seeing Kleenex actually makes Kirkland Tissues.
:rofl: :crazy: >:D
My wife won't let me buy the cheaper Kirkland tissues because she says they are not as soft as the Kleenex ones. My wife is the one I must obey. :love: :love: :love:
-
My wife won't let me buy the cheaper Kirkland tissues because she says they are not as soft as the Kleenex ones. My wife is the one I must obey. :love: :love: :love:
That was fun!!
We now return you to your regularly scheduled topic .... :rofl:
:stopjack: