2aHawaii
General Topics => Off Topic => Topic started by: monster796 on July 05, 2016, 08:22:54 PM
-
I want to start a petition tomorrow, but it needs lots of signatures to go public.
-
I voted maybe. Honestly I don't know enough about the case to say whether there was in fact enough evidence wrongdoing to take a case to court.
-
I voted maybe.
what a surprise
-
I voted maybe. Honestly I don't know enough about the case to say whether there was in fact enough evidence wrongdoing to take a case to court.
Did you not watch the reveal by the FBI director? Every thing the dude presented is a CRIME. The fact that he recommends not pursuing a case is a CRIME. Any reasonable person with an iota of common sense and decency would have to convict, even with what little was revealed in the news conference.
-
Did you not watch the reveal by the FBI director? Every thing the dude presented is a CRIME. The fact that he recommends not pursuing a case is a CRIME. Any reasonable person with an iota of common sense and decency would have to convict, even with what little was revealed in the news conference.
Simply put, I do not know what the FBI knows. I don't know the federal codes and I don't know what exculpatory evidence there might be.
I know Hillary sent classified information through her email, but I doubt that alone is enough information to convict her. Were these emails marked classified to the point she knew they were classified? Did they contain information that Clinton knows should be considered classified? If the FBI cannot prove that Clinton knew or should have known the emails she sent were classified then they can't prove she knowingly broke the law. I am not saying there aren't concerns for corruption but I am considering that it is possible there was not enough to take the case to trial.
We may all know she is guilty as hell but when it comes to a court setting, if a prosecutor cannot show enough evidence to prove beyond a reasonable doubt then they might decide not to take it to trial.
What I do think we have enough evidence of is her lying to the public on serious issues that would discount her ability to serve in office. As Kris Paronto (combatant in Benghazi) said, he wasn't that angry the Benghazi happened, mistakes happen in combat. He was angry that she lied about it and covered it up. That is enough for a petition to have her resign in my mind.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WhxhaJ--3CA
-
Simply put, I do not know what the FBI knows. I don't know the federal codes and I don't know what exculpatory evidence there might be.
I know Hillary sent classified information through her email (Illegal, anyone that held any type of clearance knows and is briefed NEVER TO DO THIS or face criminal charges), but I doubt that alone is enough information to convict her (YES, Yes it is. It has been done many times before WITH convictions). Were these emails marked classified to the point she knew they were classified?( (This does not matter. The originator has the responsibility to safeguard any data that could be possibly classified) Did they contain information that Clinton knows should be considered classified? (This does not matter. The originator has the responsibility to safeguard any data that could be possibly classified) If the FBI cannot prove that Clinton knew or should have known the emails she sent were classified then they can't prove she knowingly broke the law. (Any person privy to clearance is briefed and trained on this, she did know, or should have known, even if she claimed ignorance, that is no excuse in the eyes of the law. She should have known as a responsibility and duty of her office.)
We may all know she is guilty as hell but when it comes to a court setting, if a prosecutor cannot show enough evidence to prove beyond a reasonable doubt then they might decide not to take it to trial. (Cases have been made AND WON on much less. Certain people, less 'connected', have met their consequence for data breech. The corruption is plain to see.)
-
How does it not matter if she knew it was classified? Not saying you are wrong but trying to reason through a criminal prosecution case.
Say I email you about something but I don't tell you it is classified. You then forward or reply to this email not knowing it contained classified information. How are you culpable?
Hopefully a prosecutor will disregard the FBI's recommendation then! I am not holding my breath.
-
Having had a day to think about this, I find myself conflicted regarding this poll.
While I absolutely believe Clinton should be charged, convicted, and disqualified from running for ANY public office for mishandling classified information , I'm less inclined to demand Comey's resignation.
Here's why: Think about his statements. He laid out what basically amounts to a cut and dried case against Clinton. He took great pains to list each and every instance where she had abused the the regulations regarding the handling of classified materials. He then proceeded to inform us that if it were anyone else, or should someone try this in the future, they would indeed face prosecution. The break occurred when he discussed what the DOJ would do, or wouldn't do, to be more accurate. He basically informed us that the DOJ wouldn't press charges against Clinton, regardless of the evidence presented and the fact that anyone else WOULD be prosecuted.
Granted, he should have recommended indictment, but in doing so he would've committed professional suicide. Knowing how those that go up against the Clinton's tend to have "accidents" it may have been a more personal worry.
I think he was doing what he could to let us know that the "fix" was in, and that his hands were being tied due to orders from above.
-
Having had a day to think about this, I find myself conflicted regarding this poll.
While I absolutely believe Clinton should be charged, convicted, and disqualified from running for ANY public office for mishandling classified information , I'm less inclined to demand Comey's resignation.
Here's why: Think about his statements. He laid out what basically amounts to a cut and dried case against Clinton. He took great pains to list each and every instance where she had abused the the regulations regarding the handling of classified materials. He then proceeded to inform us that if it were anyone else, or should someone try this in the future, they would indeed face prosecution. The break occurred when he discussed what the DOJ would do, or wouldn't do, to be more accurate. He basically informed us that the DOJ wouldn't press charges against Clinton, regardless of the evidence presented and the fact that anyone else WOULD be prosecuted.
Granted, he should have recommended indictment, but in doing so he would've committed professional suicide. Knowing how those that go up against the Clinton's tend to have "accidents" it may have been a more personal worry.
I think he was doing what he could to let us know that the "fix" was in, and that his hands were being tied due to orders from above.
I can't agree more with your statement. :thumbsup: :thumbsup: :thumbsup:
-
How does it not matter if she knew it was classified? Not saying you are wrong but trying to reason through a criminal prosecution case.
Say I email you about something but I don't tell you it is classified. You then forward or reply to this email not knowing it contained classified information. How are you culpable?
Hopefully a prosecutor will disregard the FBI's recommendation then! I am not holding my breath.
If the case were to go to court, then the details of why it is wrong, illegal, and completely clinton's responsibility would be explained and laid out. All I can say is that she is responsible for the data sent. Persons that may have forwarded sensitive information should have been flagging that as potential for a sensitive data breech, and are now just as responsible for not reporting improper handling of the data.
I agree with what ed said above. However, isn't in the dude's job description, ethically, and morally to service justice and the American people? He should step down if he cannot fulfill his job and oath of office.
-
How does it not matter if she knew it was classified? Not saying you are wrong but trying to reason through a criminal prosecution case.
Say I email you about something but I don't tell you it is classified. You then forward or reply to this email not knowing it contained classified information. How are you culpable?
Hopefully a prosecutor will disregard the FBI's recommendation then! I am not holding my breath.
If there comes a day where you are granted the required security clearance and go through the precautionary briefs, required yearly training, etc. perhaps you will understand the situation better. Until then, you are simply speculating on situations that you have no experience. Or at least appear to have no experience since I have no idea whether or not you actually have security clearance. You very may well have security clearance and are just trying to be argumentative. You seem to keep asking questions that have been answered for you.
What level of sensitivity that particular information is and how it can be distributed can be quite complex. The standards read worse than many gun laws. Anyways, just the presence of the classified information on the server is a HUGE no-no. It was my understanding that she knew that some of those emails contained classified information since apparently she commented something in the effect of "filter stuff" so that it can be transmitted via unsecure channels. Ok, say she didn't know something was classified and it was passed to her. If you have ever handled classified documents, you KNOW when they are classified.
-
Having had a day to think about this, I find myself conflicted regarding this poll.
While I absolutely believe Clinton should be charged, convicted, and disqualified from running for ANY public office for mishandling classified information , I'm less inclined to demand Comey's resignation.
Here's why: Think about his statements. He laid out what basically amounts to a cut and dried case against Clinton. He took great pains to list each and every instance where she had abused the the regulations regarding the handling of classified materials. He then proceeded to inform us that if it were anyone else, or should someone try this in the future, they would indeed face prosecution. The break occurred when he discussed what the DOJ would do, or wouldn't do, to be more accurate. He basically informed us that the DOJ wouldn't press charges against Clinton, regardless of the evidence presented and the fact that anyone else WOULD be prosecuted.
Granted, he should have recommended indictment, but in doing so he would've committed professional suicide. Knowing how those that go up against the Clinton's tend to have "accidents" it may have been a more personal worry.
I think he was doing what he could to let us know that the "fix" was in, and that his hands were being tied due to orders from above.
Kind of what I was thinking. Sort of the "I can't say any names, but . . . . " sort of message.
-
If the case were to go to court, then the details of why it is wrong, illegal, and completely clinton's responsibility would be explained and laid out. All I can say is that she is responsible for the data sent. Persons that may have forwarded sensitive information should have been flagging that as potential for a sensitive data breech, and are now just as responsible for not reporting improper handling of the data.
I agree with what ed said above. However, isn't in the dude's job description, ethically, and morally to service justice and the American people? He should step down if he cannot fulfill his job and oath of office.
It is part of his job, but if he resigns who takes his place? Some lackey that will do as they're told without question and without alerting the public to what's really going on. He didn't have to list all the instances where Clinton broke the rules. He could have simply said "We don't have sufficient evidence to recommend charges against her." I'm sure Clinton and the DOJ would have preferred that. Instead, he went out on a limb to make sure this was part of the public record.
-
If there comes a day where you are granted the required security clearance and go through the precautionary briefs, required yearly training, etc. perhaps you will understand the situation better. Until then, you are simply speculating on situations that you have no experience. Or at least appear to have no experience since I have no idea whether or not you actually have security clearance. You very may well have security clearance and are just trying to be argumentative. You seem to keep asking questions that have been answered for you.
What level of sensitivity that particular information is and how it can be distributed can be quite complex. The standards read worse than many gun laws. Anyways, just the presence of the classified information on the server is a HUGE no-no. It was my understanding that she knew that some of those emails contained classified information since apparently she commented something in the effect of "filter stuff" so that it can be transmitted via unsecure channels. Ok, say she didn't know something was classified and it was passed to her. If you have ever handled classified documents, you KNOW when they are classified.
I am looking at this from a defense attorney angle. They are going to look for a technicality and try to create doubt in a juror's mind. The prosecutor has to be confident they can overcome the questions a defense attorney will try to raise. That is why I was thinking that if they couldn't prove that she knew or should have known an email she sent then they might not be able to meet the proof needed to obtain a conviction. Yes I am speculating here, I am trying to give the FBI the benefit of the doubt in case there is some actual good reason for them to not recommend prosecution because it Is theoretically possible there was not enough evidence for a criminal conviction. Hopefully subsequent inquiry will answer this question.
Don't get me wrong, it sure reeks of corruption but I try to be objective even though I would be happy to see Clinton crash and burn.
-
It is part of his job, but if he resigns who takes his place? Some lackey that will do as they're told without question and without alerting the public to what's really going on. He didn't have to list all the instances where Clinton broke the rules. He could have simply said "We don't have sufficient evidence to recommend charges against her." I'm sure Clinton and the DOJ would have preferred that. Instead, he went out on a limb to make sure this was part of the public record.
Maybe is sort of coming out and washing his hands of it, stopping just short of saying charges should be brought but my boss won't let me? Or he was trying to walk the thin line between providing too much information vs not enough information and didn't do it that well.
Feds love big high publicity cases though. Catch someone famous or important and they will jump at it. They make a name for themselves on such cases. Imagine being able to say "I had the case that took down Clinton." That is why I don't think you would have trouble finding an agent willing to go as far as possible with the charges. This is why I think that if something was run afoul in the investigation someone will end up leaking the truth.
-
I am looking at this from a defense attorney angle. They are going to look for a technicality and try to create doubt in a juror's mind. The prosecutor has to be confident they can overcome the questions a defense attorney will try to raise. That is why I was thinking that if they couldn't prove that she knew or should have known an email she sent then they might not be able to meet the proof needed to obtain a conviction. Yes I am speculating here, I am trying to give the FBI the benefit of the doubt in case there is some actual good reason for them to not recommend prosecution because it Is theoretically possible there was not enough evidence for a criminal conviction. Hopefully subsequent inquiry will answer this question.
Don't get me wrong, it sure reeks of corruption but I try to be objective even though I would be happy to see Clinton crash and burn.
Sounds like you've read this article. https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/five-myths-about-classified-information/2015/09/18/a164c1a4-5d72-11e5-b38e-06883aacba64_story.html (https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/five-myths-about-classified-information/2015/09/18/a164c1a4-5d72-11e5-b38e-06883aacba64_story.html)
Well, I'll back track in that I have NO idea what sort of documents was passed through the Clinton email servers. I do agree with the writer's opinion that the classification guides are not easy to decipher. All I can say is that the classified information that I've had access to, I absolutely knew they were classified. That said, the writer's opinion was one that it was impractical for officials to know the sensitivity of the regulations. However, it is my understanding that anyone who is granted access signs agreements/statements regarding the handling of that information. Like I said before, I would even have to go back and see what the exact language is in what I signed. That said, I would be willing to bet that I would be facing charges if I had classified information on my home computer, no matter how secure, encrypted, etc.
-
http://downtrend.com/markeece/white-house-petition-to-charge-hillary-clinton-reaches-60000-signatures?utm_source=not3&utm_medium=facebook
-
http://dailycaller.com/2016/07/06/fbi-announces-no-charges-for-hillary-edward-snowden-immediately-does-this/?utm_campaign=thedcmainpage&utm_source=Facebook&utm_medium=Social
-
79,000+ signatures.
-
The petition to charge Clinton despite the FBI recommendation got 107,000 signatures in 30 hours. I can hardly wait for the Whitehouse "response".
https://petitions.whitehouse.gov//petition/charge-hillary-rodham-clinton-pursuant-18-usc-641-793-794-798-952-and-1924
-
Sounds like you've read this article. https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/five-myths-about-classified-information/2015/09/18/a164c1a4-5d72-11e5-b38e-06883aacba64_story.html (https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/five-myths-about-classified-information/2015/09/18/a164c1a4-5d72-11e5-b38e-06883aacba64_story.html)
Well, I'll back track in that I have NO idea what sort of documents was passed through the Clinton email servers. I do agree with the writer's opinion that the classification guides are not easy to decipher. All I can say is that the classified information that I've had access to, I absolutely knew they were classified. That said, the writer's opinion was one that it was impractical for officials to know the sensitivity of the regulations. However, it is my understanding that anyone who is granted access signs agreements/statements regarding the handling of that information. Like I said before, I would even have to go back and see what the exact language is in what I signed. That said, I would be willing to bet that I would be facing charges if I had classified information on my home computer, no matter how secure, encrypted, etc.
I had not read that article until now. Is there reason to think it inaccurate though?
Ignorance of the law is absolutely not a defense. I agree that if she had clearance then she is expected to know all the rules and regulations. At work we have thousands of pages of regulations and we are expected to know them all and can be held accountable. Of course that would be a regulation violation not a criminal violation but either way she cannot claim she didn't know the regulation.
I don't know what the standard is to meet the threshold of being "classified". I do know that certain information, a social security number for example, is sensitive private information and one does not need to be told it cannot be made public.
Honestly though, the more I have read and heard about this throughout the day, the more I think she should be charged.
-
1) I had not read that article until now. Is there reason to think it inaccurate though?
2) Ignorance of the law is absolutely not a defense. I agree that if she had clearance then she is expected to know all the rules and regulations. At work we have thousands of pages of regulations and we are expected to know them all and can be held accountable. Of course that would be a regulation violation not a criminal violation but either way she cannot claim she didn't know the regulation.
3) I don't know what the standard is to meet the threshold of being "classified". I do know that certain information, a social security number for example, is sensitive private information and one does not need to be told it cannot be made public.
Honestly though, the more I have read and heard about this throughout the day, the more I think she should be charged.
1) One person's opinion. I agree and see her point on many things, particularly from a practical perspective. However, there's what's practical and what's the regulation/requirement.
2) What she is expected to know is irrelevant IMO. I believe in the agreement that I had to sign to get clearance it states that I shall abide by the regulations/statutes/requirements for proper handling of sensitive documents (again, I would have to go back and look) and if one is found to mishandle or not in compliance with the agreement that one is subject to penalty and that includes jail time. Yes, many of the statues deal with knowingly disclosing sensitive information to protect/deter against spy and espionage type KBG stuff. However, the simple mishandling of classified documents carry severe consequences. Yeah, people are splitting hairs with the exact wording of the statues, but to me the basic question is did she put classified information at risk that could have resulted in harm to national defense, security, etc. I believe yes, but I'm not the one that gets to make that call.
3) Classified, sensitive, etc in this context is in terms of damage to national security if the information is release. Your SSN, while certainly sensitive, presents a danger to your credit and risk of identity theft, not national security. At least I don't think. :P
-
This is what people have to sign to access classified ....
(http://i.imgur.com/LkCjY2y.png)
(http://i.imgur.com/AZa9HRE.png)
-
This is what people have to sign to access classified ....
Thanks! I checked my files the other day and I couldn't find a copy of what I signed.
To be honest, the agreement that I signed for the travel CC is more scary. . . :o
-
If anyone needs another example of how much damage this former Secretary of State may have done, let's put it in context.
She quibbles about classified not being marked classified. So, by that admission, that she doesn't know classified is classified without markings, how many conversations has she had with foreign agents, leaders, citizens and US citizens in the media, corporations, and her "Foundation", how many times has she divulged classified information?
Logic tells us, given the volume of emails discovered with information classified at the time it was sent, she absolutely has a high probability of divulging similar information verbally or in writing. You can't believe she is unable to identify classified when in email form but then is a security expert when speaking to others about the same topics!
-
I think he was doing what he could to let us know that the "fix" was in, and that his hands were being tied due to orders from above.
If so, an honorable man would immediately and very publicly resign, telling the world why he was doing it.
-
If so, an honorable man would immediately and very publicly resign, telling the world why he was.
He's in too deep to finally blow the whistle. He's already complicit in scandal after scandal, failure after failure.
To step forward now would be quashed as a politically motivated, anti-Clinton move, not to mention his lack of successes in finding the Benghazi "perps", protecting us from terrorists, etc.