2aHawaii

General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: ren on September 23, 2016, 01:15:02 PM

Title: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: ren on September 23, 2016, 01:15:02 PM
http://bearingarms.com/beth-b/2016/09/22/georgia-woman-uses-handgun-fend-burglars/ (http://bearingarms.com/beth-b/2016/09/22/georgia-woman-uses-handgun-fend-burglars/)
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: London808 on September 23, 2016, 01:18:18 PM
Dumb luck she wasent killed.
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: troy tanaka on September 23, 2016, 03:08:42 PM
What if these criminals was rapist, come to rape your wife or daughter. She did great, next time I expect an ar15 in her hand so she shoot all three in defense! I'm surprised she handled that gun with one hand, but adrenaline will make you stronger and that fight or flight humans have within ourselves comes in handy.
I can say we have one less thief in this world, and that's a good thing
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: aieahound on September 23, 2016, 04:08:13 PM
There's an example of the argument for 10 rounds.....or more.....for self-defense.
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: London808 on September 23, 2016, 04:38:29 PM
There's an example of the argument for 10 rounds.....or more.....for self-defense.

No this is an example of need for  firearms training, she had the drop on these guys and was shooting all gangsta I'm surprised she hit any of them.
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: aieahound on September 23, 2016, 05:20:16 PM
Amen brother.
But yeah they apparently weren't all hangers with 1 dead perp.

But they were running like the devil was chasing them and doing serpentine, serpentine.
That's some tough targets.

They were returning fire over their backs though so she is lucky neither she nor her roommate was hit.

Still say plenty rounds helped her.
Particularly if you fire indiscriminately like she did.

She was spray and pray and she won the day. Hooray for 2A !
(And enough rounds of ammo)
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: zippz on September 23, 2016, 05:30:40 PM
It's a good example where ordinary people can use a gun to protect themselves.  People will say this kind of stuff never happens, or just run away, or call the police.

Good things I get from this is she survived without getting injured, stopped the threat, caught them off guard and took advantage of that, stayed hidden in the bedroom as long as possible and started firing before they got too close.

Things to improve on is she should have taken cover in her bedroom instead of being out in the open, shouldn't have left the bedroom, should have dropped the phone, she ran past one of the guys who was then behind her, should have retreated (or reloaded) when she was empty, should have retreated back to her bedroom until help arrived.  And practice to get rid of her flinch.

Lucky she survived and those guys will probably never try that again (especially the dead guy).  Good example of how just taking a basic pistol class isn't enough for self defense and it requires constant practice even for veteran shooters.
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: macsak on September 23, 2016, 05:32:06 PM
http://bearingarms.com/beth-b/2016/09/22/georgia-woman-uses-handgun-fend-burglars/ (http://bearingarms.com/beth-b/2016/09/22/georgia-woman-uses-handgun-fend-burglars/)

i'm thinking there's more to that story- why are there 3 of them with pistols breaking into a house that is filled with paper goods? why did she come out shooting like that, was she expecting trouble? how come the roommate wasn't armed and helping, he obviously knew gun handling better than her, he cleared the gun right away?
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: London808 on September 23, 2016, 05:49:13 PM
i'm thinking there's more to that story- why are there 3 of them with pistols breaking into a house that is filled with paper goods? why did she come out shooting like that, was she expecting trouble? how come the roommate wasn't armed and helping, he obviously knew gun handling better than her, he cleared the gun right away?

Chances are they knew what they were after, she is a restraunt owner and they properly followed her home. Most home invasions use 3 or 4 people. 1 staye outside as the getaway driver the others enter the home, they tie up or secure the occupants and take possessions and force them to open up safes ect... they will then often steal cars and escape.

As a small business owner this is one of the things I am worried about. My other big worry is getting hit between exiting my van and entering my house. If their is a car behind me when I pull onto my block I will circle and wait till I'm clear .   
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: zippz on September 23, 2016, 05:54:56 PM
My other big worry is getting hit between exiting my van and entering my house.

If only there was something we could do for this....
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: whynow? on September 23, 2016, 10:25:05 PM
Reminds me of the shootout in Wahiawa Hgts few years ago, where the female resident defended their home with a handgun.   She was not charged.
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/2484510/posts
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: ren on September 23, 2016, 10:35:58 PM
Reminds me of the shootout in Wahiawa Hgts few years ago, where the female resident defended their home with a handgun.   She was not charged.
http://www.freerepublic.com/focus/f-news/2484510/posts

WOW. DIdn't ever recall reading about that story
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: oldfart on September 24, 2016, 07:02:17 AM
I was just having a discussion with a coworker about this sort of thing.
I told him that I would throw some cash at the perp, show him (or her) my SD firearm, and tell him to leave and don't ever come back.
That would be far less costly and traumatic  than pulling the trigger.
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: passivekinetic on September 24, 2016, 12:52:20 PM
WOW. DIdn't ever recall reading about that story

Luckily the KITV website removed that news article otherwise gun supporters might find it and use it as supporting evidence.
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: whynow? on September 24, 2016, 01:19:07 PM
Luckily the KITV website removed that news article otherwise gun supporters might find it and use it as supporting evidence.
Here is the Advertiser story on this.  Note that no mention of the homeowner firing the shots that wounded the perps, probably from anti-2A influence.  IIRC, the residents were outside after dinner, the car pulls up with the armed perps who force the residents inside.  Can't remember when the husband was injured, but once inside the house, the female gets a handgun and starts shooting at the perps, who then retreat to the car.   She was never charged as this was a righteous shoot.
http://the.honoluluadvertiser.com/article/2010/Mar/31/br/hawaii100330087.html
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: FBI on September 24, 2016, 04:26:08 PM
Amen brother.
But yeah they apparently weren't all hangers with 1 dead perp.

But they were running like the devil was chasing them and doing serpentine, serpentine.
That's some tough targets.

They were returning fire over their backs though so she is lucky neither she nor her roommate was hit.

Still say plenty rounds helped her.
Particularly if you fire indiscriminately like she did.

She was spray and pray and she won the day. Hooray for 2A !
(And enough rounds of ammo)

Cops spray and pray all the time. I could post many many examples.
Never use a pistol for close up home defense,
Use a shotgun, then a half awake spray and pray will work better and
it will give you time to
focus as you chamber
a new round.
Rifles are for long rang home defense.
Pistols are for self defense.

It was great to see someone show you how useless
911 and depending on police for help, really is. 





Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: zippz on September 24, 2016, 05:32:50 PM
At first I thought this would make for great testimony for CCW.  3 guys planned to rob or assault the victims and they drive up and threaten them with a gun.  One of the victims grabs a handgun from inside the house and shoots at the suspects causing them to flee.  Then I see the testimony from one of the victims and realize the victims were drug dealers:  "during that  prior incident the robbers had taken marijuana that Aaron had  been distributing out of the house."

This document has more details on the wahiawa incident, detailed testimony from four of the victims and one of the invaders.
http://www.courts.state.hi.us/docs/opin_ord/sct/2013/November/SCWC-12-0000359ada.pdf
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: zippz on September 24, 2016, 05:44:08 PM
Cops spray and pray all the time. I could post many many examples.
Never use a pistol for close up home defense,
Use a shotgun, then a half awake spray and pray will work better and
it will give you time to
focus as you chamber
a new round.
Rifles are for long rang home defense.
Pistols are for self defense.

It was great to see someone show you how useless
911 and depending on police for help, really is.

The police are getting better with their handguns where you see newstories of them making good stops nowadays compared to the past.  The training is pretty good where they are better than the majority of active handgun shooters, but they still could use a lot more practice and most of them are not gun people, and firearm training is at the bottom of the priority list.

Firearm owners should try and see how quickly they can get to their firearm in a home invasion scenario.  Most people wouldn't be able to get to their firearm within seconds.
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: whynow? on September 24, 2016, 08:11:08 PM
At first I thought this would make for great testimony for CCW.  3 guys planned to rob or assault the victims and they drive up and threaten them with a gun.  One of the victims grabs a handgun from inside the house and shoots at the suspects causing them to flee.  Then I see the testimony from one of the victims and realize the victims were drug dealers:  "during that  prior incident the robbers had taken marijuana that Aaron had  been distributing out of the house."

This document has more details on the wahiawa incident, detailed testimony from four of the victims and one of the invaders.
http://www.courts.state.hi.us/docs/opin_ord/sct/2013/November/SCWC-12-0000359ada.pdf

zippz good find for details of this incident.  Didn't read all the testimony, all the main actors may be dirty in some way, but the claim comes from one of the perps.  Too bad if it's true, but basically a firearm in HI repelled a home invasion.   The wahine had the will to shoot and battle it out with multiple attackers.   None of this "I'll count to 3 and then shoot or don't cross my redline" kaka. 
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: PeaShooter on September 25, 2016, 03:43:10 PM
Wow I thought she was pretty bad ass. The 3 thugs kicked the door open and entered with guns drawn at night, I can't think of anything more menacing than that. Shoot to kill is obvious in that situation without needing to identify the enemy first. She didn't really have the drop on them, they entered the home armed and looking for trouble. If they were taken by surprise that is their fault. At the close distances she was at, spray and pray is fine, and did kill one. A sword could have been used. (Not that I'm recommending one, but it's all I have readily available to me since I don't keep my firearms loaded yet.)

She had her cell phone with her, something I neglected to do when I had a very minor home invasion once.

A definite argument for more than 10 rounds in self-defense. I counted at least 8 shots fired by her plus you need to have some left over, she could've benefited from like 20 rounds. (This also bothers me since some of my handguns only hold 7+1).

She was running while firing one handed which is difficult and recoil was noticeable, I wonder what caliber she was shooting? She had a big fat flashlight so she probably couldn't do the normal method of shooting.
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: London808 on September 25, 2016, 04:01:12 PM
Heres the timeline,

im going to break it down from the original video.

Camera 5
3:43:27, Door is kicked in full open (this is where the video starts).
3:44:37, The victim appears in the doorway with 2 armed men infront of her.
3:44:39, guy points gun at her and moves in her direction.
3:44:40, She draws her weapon and fires the first shot which is high.
3:44:42, both men flea, she chases them them towards the door.
3:44:44, man runs from halway to her right almost coliding with her. she ignores him and contiunes in the directon of the fleaing men
3:44:48, man from hallway runs through kitchen door, (face first through the glass, like literately through it.)
3:35:57, victim appears back in screen useing cellphone. Firearm in hand, with slide locked in empty position.

The second view show is the same thing it shows her shooting out of the doorway at the fleeing robbers she stops fireing at 3:44:53 because she has no ammo left.
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: London808 on September 25, 2016, 04:10:12 PM
So now you see because of the news's shorten version it makes it look like the whole episode happened in 10 seconds instead of the 2 and a half minutes it really took.

Instead of staying in the safety of her bedroom, She decided to go gun and cellphone in hand to confront what must of been a very vilonet noise. You can see the mean who entered the home talking to each other and turning on switches, She must of been aware that some one was in her home.

She steps completely into a doorway silhouette in the doorway, with the gun in one hand at her side and her cellphone in the other. instead of seeking cover she draws on an already drawn weapon.

She fires at the bad guys and misses, They turn and flea. She then chases them. She narrowly avoids getting flattened by the man running from the hallway. She fails to even acknowledge him as a threat and continues to chase the fleeing men. Once the men are gone she is out of ammo. She dosent know if any of them are left in the house and does not even attempt to seek cover or concealment and fails to clear the property. Even if she did clear the property she had no ammo left.

Now im not an expert and i know this is in hind site but she made some serious mistakes and is extremly lucky that most badguys run away when shots are fired.
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: London808 on September 25, 2016, 04:10:37 PM
The unedited version.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z4wjq6cn0To
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: PeaShooter on September 25, 2016, 04:14:58 PM
Thanks! I'll watch it now. Unfortunately when I watch videos on this computer I have no sound, I am just going by the images.

3:44:44, man runs from halway to her right almost coliding with her. she ignores him and contiunes in the directon of the fleaing men

By the way, I watched the crappy version video again, and I realized I made the same mistake as you did. She didn't ignore him. She fired a shot at point-blank distance, practically touching his chest. That was the kill shot. No wonder it didn't miss. So 9+ shots. I wasn't able to see that the slide was locked back either in the crappy news version video, it was too low quality, but you are right.

edited: hmm, maybe not. It is hard to tell. Maybe she ignored him as you said. The guy managed to keep running through the glass door...

gun in one hand at her side and her cellphone in the other

Whoops you are right! Dang that first video was such low video quality that I thought it was one of those giant flashlights, but it was her cellphone light. Not good form then.
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: PeaShooter on September 25, 2016, 04:28:08 PM
The unedited version, as I am watching it now, is not totally superior to the crappy news version. It has a video quality problem at least on my PC that I'm not clear on. For example, the 4th gunshot is absolutely invisible in this unedited video (there is no flash) but clearly visible (big flash) in the crappy news version. The "3rd shot" is the mostly-invisible kill shot that was taken at point blank, for counting purposes, as I might be off by shot count.

Instead of staying in the safety of her bedroom, She decided to go gun and cellphone in hand to confront

Given the proper timing of the longer version as you said, I sort of agree this was questionable, but I still can't say it was bad as she was armed by that point. I guess it depends on the skill of the homeowner. In her case, maybe hiding was better, but she didn't.

She fails to even acknowledge him as a threat and continues to chase the fleeing men.

I think she may have shot him but I can't tell. She saw and pointed her gun straight into his body for sure.

Once the men are gone she is out of ammo. She dosent know if any of them are left in the house and does not even attempt to seek cover

Yeah that was horrible. For letting herself waste her last ammo without even using the sights, and for not even checking behind for the other guy, unless she was sure he was dead, which she wasn't since he ran out the black glass door. Maybe she heard it at least.

extremly lucky that most badguys run away when shots are fired.

As you said I guess that's why she took her first shot and missed. She was banking on scaring them off, not a good move but that's just my opinion. With me, I would have closed in and tried to make sure the first shot is a kill. But then I would not know there are 3 guys and not 1 guy, I would kill 1 or 2 guys for sure but maybe the 3rd guy would have killed me, while that woman's choices let her survive.

It's also sad that the guy walks out later really slowly, like "Where's my dinner?"
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: London808 on September 25, 2016, 04:49:34 PM
im not seeing a shot on the 3rd guy (no muzzle flash or recoil. I do however see his right arm collide with her hand pushing the gun down and to her right.)

It has been uploaded in 480p but was most likely shot in 720 (most common for home cameras)

This one has the 911 call over the top of it.
the audio shows that they had access to the cameras and could see the people in the house with guns.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fDrCfcHLiK8
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: PeaShooter on September 25, 2016, 04:57:55 PM
Great eye on the guns colliding, yeah maybe that's what happened instead. I cannot tell for sure. Two guns colliding like that, what are the chances of that?!
Title: Re: home invasion or firefight?
Post by: omnigun on September 25, 2016, 05:42:12 PM
She got em good.  Too bad two of them got away.  Not sure why it took so long for them to find her and the fight to start they were all over the house.  No idea where her friend was either must of been some big ass house.