2aHawaii
General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: drck1000 on April 12, 2017, 12:02:59 PM
-
They were discussing the War Powers Resolution/Act on NPR the past couple of days. That got me thinking back to Bosnia and Clinton ordering airstrikes. I recall there being similar/same discussion regarding the War Powers Act then, but the roles were reversed in Clinton being President and the Republicans opposing it.
Did some online searching and the articles that I found (within the 10 mins or so that I searched) were the following:
Clinton Emphasizes Morality When Selling Airstrikes
http://articles.latimes.com/1999/mar/25/news/mn-20870 (http://articles.latimes.com/1999/mar/25/news/mn-20870)
Rep. Peter King says Bill Clinton continued Kosovo air campaign after rebuke by House
http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2013/sep/04/peter-king/rep-peter-king-says-bill-clinton-continued-kosovo-/ (http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2013/sep/04/peter-king/rep-peter-king-says-bill-clinton-continued-kosovo-/)
CLINTON PRESSES U.N. FOR AIRSTRIKES IN BOSNIA
https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1993/07/31/clinton-presses-un-for-airstrikes-in-bosnia/e1edd25a-d48d-41d0-b428-5140158d8608/?utm_term=.2696c5cebee0 (https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1993/07/31/clinton-presses-un-for-airstrikes-in-bosnia/e1edd25a-d48d-41d0-b428-5140158d8608/?utm_term=.2696c5cebee0)
The discussion was also something about no President has said that they are in accordance with the WPA, but rather say pursuant to the WPA. Something about no President has acknowledged being bound by the WPA. I found that discussion (or at least whoever said it) interesting.
-
Just found on Wikipedia:
It has been alleged that the War Powers Resolution has been violated in the past – for example, by President Bill Clinton in 1999, during the bombing campaign in Kosovo. Congress has disapproved all such incidents, but none has resulted in any successful legal actions being taken against the president for alleged violations.[2]
-
Just found on Wikipedia:
Can we say "War Crimes".
Kuleana
-
If they ignore the law and we don't enforce it then they can just keep on doing it.
-
Can we say "War Crimes".
Kuleana
Who? Clinton? Trump? Or both?
Care to expand?
Totally not being a wiseass here. Genuinely interested on the topic and all the angles that discussion on NPR and others were talking about.
-
How to avoid the deleration of war,
We are not declaring war on a country, We are targeting individuals within that country who are a treat to other nations or others within that same nation.
-
If they ignore the law and we don't enforce it then they can just keep on doing it.
The way NPR was discussing the terminology and stuff sound like more like no president has acknowledged the act and their statements are worded such that they are essentially skirting the issue. Something about saying that the action is pursuant to the act is somewhat like saying "in the sprit of" whereas in accordance with acknowledges the act and that the actions are following those rules. So if you aren't breaking the rules, what is there to enforce?
-
How to avoid the deleration of war,
We are not declaring war on a country, We are targeting individuals within that country who are a treat to other nations or others within that same nation.
Yeah, I get all of that. That's kind of what I was thinking when I was looking up other airstrikes ordered in the past, but both R and D Presidents. I recall "worse" strikes, but just wasn't sure if the President at the time had acted with Congressional approval, with UN approval, etc.
Basically this came about as counter thoughts to what Schatz et al had to day about the strikes.