2aHawaii
General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: omnigun on May 19, 2017, 04:35:33 PM
-
Clark County Public Defender Phil Kohn derided the charge of attempted murder as “a legal impossibility,” saying someone can’t kill an inanimate object.
http://www.providencejournal.com/news/20170308/las-vegas-man-charged-with-attempted-murder-in-mannequin-hammer-attack
I think the defender is correct you can't murder something that is not alive. Charges are BS.
-
Clark County Public Defender Phil Kohn derided the charge of attempted murder as “a legal impossibility,” saying someone can’t kill an inanimate object.
http://www.providencejournal.com/news/20170308/las-vegas-man-charged-with-attempted-murder-in-mannequin-hammer-attack
I think the defender is correct you can't murder something that is not alive. Charges are BS.
Your title is inaccurate. He was chaged with ATTEMPTED murder. Should read, "Can you attempt to murder something that's not alive?"
The [Nevada] state Supreme Court in 1976 rejected an argument asserting that “since it is legally impossible to commit the crime, it must also be legally impossible to attempt the crime."
No difference than any other sting operation using fake items.
This guy attempted to bomb the New York Federal Reserve using a 1,000 lb bomb. The explosives he bought from undercover agents were inert. He believed they were real and tried to detonate them.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/oct/17/fbi-federal-reserve-bomb-plot
Mens Rea ("Guilty Mind"): the intention or knowledge of wrongdoing that constitutes part of a crime, as opposed to the action or conduct of the accused.
LVPD said 2 other homeless killed by a hammer used to crush the skull. Same MO. If the Cops tie him to at least one of the other killings, he's toast no matter what his defense says about "impossibility."
-
Clark County Public Defender Phil Kohn derided the charge of attempted murder as “a legal impossibility,” saying someone can’t kill an inanimate object.
http://www.providencejournal.com/news/20170308/las-vegas-man-charged-with-attempted-murder-in-mannequin-hammer-attack
I think the defender is correct you can't murder something that is not alive. Charges are BS.
too easy...
-
Clark County Public Defender Phil Kohn derided the charge of attempted murder as “a legal impossibility,” saying someone can’t kill an inanimate object.
http://www.providencejournal.com/news/20170308/las-vegas-man-charged-with-attempted-murder-in-mannequin-hammer-attack
I think the defender is correct you can't murder something that is not alive. Charges are BS.
-
Your title is inaccurate. He was chaged with ATTEMPTED murder. Should read, "Can you attempt to murder something that's not alive?"
No difference than any other sting operation using fake items.
This guy attempted to bomb the New York Federal Reserve using a 1,000 lb bomb. The explosives he bought from undercover agents were inert. He believed they were real and tried to detonate them.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/oct/17/fbi-federal-reserve-bomb-plot
Mens Rea ("Guilty Mind"): the intention or knowledge of wrongdoing that constitutes part of a crime, as opposed to the action or conduct of the accused.
LVPD said 2 other homeless killed by a hammer used to crush the skull. Same MO. If the Cops tie him to at least one of the other killings, he's toast no matter what his defense says about "impossibility."
What no....the guy can say he knew it was a dummy. Because he attacked an item not a person, it is not attempted murder. While it is wrong to destroy personal property that is not the same as murder. There is no logical way other than a confession to prove intent. The guy who attempted to bomb the federal reserve bought "explosives" in a plot to harm REAL people. This was not a real person.
I feel this is just a slippery slope till thought crimes are illegal. First you outlaw things that look like people. Then you outlaw violence/sex in video games/books/fantasy/drawings cause they are people too. Then you outlaw thinking about people.
-
What no....the guy can say he knew it was a dummy. Because he attacked an item not a person, it is not attempted murder. While it is wrong to destroy personal property that is not the same as murder. There is no logical way other than a confession to prove intent. The guy who attempted to bomb the federal reserve bought "explosives" in a plot to harm REAL people. This was not a real person.
I feel this is just a slippery slope till thought crimes are illegal. First you outlaw things that look like people. Then you outlaw violence/sex in video games/books/fantasy/drawings cause they are people too. Then you outlaw thinking about people.
-
What no....the guy can say he knew it was a dummy. Because he attacked an item not a person, it is not attempted murder. While it is wrong to destroy personal property that is not the same as murder. There is no logical way other than a confession to prove intent. The guy who attempted to bomb the federal reserve bought "explosives" in a plot to harm REAL people. This was not a real person.
I feel this is just a slippery slope till thought crimes are illegal. First you outlaw things that look like people. Then you outlaw violence/sex in video games/books/fantasy/drawings cause they are people too. Then you outlaw thinking about people.
You're repeating the same arguments.
You have not changed the title to be more accurate.
I already proved you are wrong based on state appellate case law.
You lose, Troll Boy!
:sleeping: :sleeping: :sleeping:
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P690t9IzvjU
-
Clark County Public Defender Phil Kohn derided the charge of attempted murder as “a legal impossibility,” saying someone can’t kill an inanimate object.
http://www.providencejournal.com/news/20170308/las-vegas-man-charged-with-attempted-murder-in-mannequin-hammer-attack
I think the defender is correct you can't murder something that is not alive. Charges are BS.
I think the prosecution needs to prove that the individual believed the mannequin to be real. It is what this man intended to do that is the question here. The man may try to say he knew it was a mannequin asa defense. Not the easiest thing to prove what was in this man's mind but it can be done. It has to do with the circumstances as the individual believed them to be, not what they actually are necessarily.
What was the alternative, put an undercover officer there to be hit in the head and then charge the man with murder/attempted murder?
-
I think the prosecution needs to prove that the individual believed the mannequin to be real. It is what this man intended to do that is the question here. The man may try to say he knew it was a mannequin asa defense. Not the easiest thing to prove what was in this man's mind but it can be done. It has to do with the circumstances as the individual believed them to be, not what they actually are necessarily.
What was the alternative, put an undercover officer there to be hit in the head and then charge the man with murder/attempted murder?
This...flapp isnt smart enough to understand
-
This...flapp isnt smart enough to understand
You do realize that I am disagreeing with you? It is possible to build a prosecution for attempted murder in this case.
Are you going to suggest that if the FBI sells a fake bomb to the terrorist and the terrorist plants the fake bomb in an attempt to kill a bunch of people that he cannot be prosecuted because the bomb was never real?
-
You do realize that I am disagreeing with you? It is possible to build a prosecution for attempted murder in this case.
Are you going to suggest that if the FBI sells a fake bomb to the terrorist and the terrorist plants the fake bomb in an attempt to kill a bunch of people that he cannot be prosecuted because the bomb was never real?
Hmmm? No you can interpenetrate it as this. The man was a vandal he liked to hit inanimate objects with a hammer. Trashcans etc, he saw a mannequin and proceeded to hit it. Its a far cry from selling someone a fake bomb who goes to a location to use said fake bomb. There is clear intent to do harm to people. Vs this could be some dude who likes to hit inanimate objects with hammers. There is no proof that he thought it was a person. And no proving beyond a reasonable doubt a random person could not identify the object was a mannequin.
The whole point of being innocent b4 found guilty is that the prosecutor has to prove that the man thought it was real and a human he was hitting. That is VERY hard in this case.
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h4UqMyldS7Q
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h4UqMyldS7Q
Today I didn't even have to use my HK
I got to say it was a good day
-
Hmmm? No you can interpenetrate it as this. The man was a vandal he liked to hit inanimate objects with a hammer. Trashcans etc, he saw a mannequin and proceeded to hit it. Its a far cry from selling someone a fake bomb who goes to a location to use said fake bomb. There is clear intent to do harm to people. Vs this could be some dude who likes to hit inanimate objects with hammers. There is no proof that he thought it was a person. And no proving beyond a reasonable doubt a random person could not identify the object was a mannequin.
The whole point of being innocent b4 found guilty is that the prosecutor has to prove that the man thought it was real and a human he was hitting. That is VERY hard in this case.
They don't have to prove what he thought, Mr. Mason.
They only have to prove what any reasonable person would have thought.
If the decoy was good enough, and the area was dark enough, it should be no problem.
-
You guys are arguing over some strange shit.
-
You guys are arguing over some strange shit.
NO, WE ARE NOT!
-
They don't have to prove what he thought, Mr. Mason.
They only have to prove what any reasonable person would have thought.
If the decoy was good enough, and the area was dark enough, it should be no problem.
I still think a completely reasonable person would know its not alive.
-
I still think a completely reasonable person would know its not alive.
Based on what? Oh, I forgot .....
You're a journalist at heart, too.
(http://i.imgur.com/OsK3fHn.jpg)
-
Hmmm? No you can interpenetrate it as this. The man was a vandal he liked to hit inanimate objects with a hammer. Trashcans etc, he saw a mannequin and proceeded to hit it. Its a far cry from selling someone a fake bomb who goes to a location to use said fake bomb. There is clear intent to do harm to people. Vs this could be some dude who likes to hit inanimate objects with hammers. There is no proof that he thought it was a person. And no proving beyond a reasonable doubt a random person could not identify the object was a mannequin.
The whole point of being innocent b4 found guilty is that the prosecutor has to prove that the man thought it was real and a human he was hitting. That is VERY hard in this case.
Well that all depends on how good a job police did of setting up the sting. Did they put a fake looking mannequin or did they put a realistic looking mannequin. Then did they document it well with photos or video? And it wasn't just some random sting either, it was based on there being similar attacks on actual individuals in the same area previously.
I don't know the facts in the case so of course I cannot say whether he is guilty but you seem to be suggesting that there is no way that a successful case could be made.
-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=P690t9IzvjU
https://youtu.be/oGFVySHbeqA
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Game wardens use decoys to arrest and successfully prosecute poachers. Seems a pretty strong parallel.
-
Let's look at WHY they used a decoy,
2 homo as people had already been bludgened to death in the same area,
-
If DLNR sets up a Mouflon, Goat or Deer mannequin in a non-hunting area and somebody poaching shoots the mannequin, are they arrested for breaking the law.
:closed:
-
If DLNR sets up a Mouflon, Goat or Deer mannequin in a non-hunting area and somebody poaching shoots the mannequin, are they arrested for breaking the law.
:closed:
Happens on the mainland all the time.
https://youtu.be/NT6PYfMUtq8
-
If DLNR sets up a Mouflon, or Deer mannequin in a non-hunting area and somebody poaching shoots the mannequin, are they arrested for breaking the law.
:closed:
Not on oahu because we don't have those.
remember there was that goat or sheep running around aiea. It was illegal and the owners ended up putting it down.
Anywho deer on oahu would cause so much damage
-
so burning or hitting an effigy counts?
-
so burning or hitting an effigy counts?
The thing with an effigy is that you most likely know it's an effigy. You knowingly went to the effigy-burning party, or bought your own from effigies-R-us for a private gathering, or made one out of household items. It may land you at the receiving end of a hate crime charge, but not attempted murder. But were you to break into my house, see a form under a sheet on the bed and proceed to hit it with a hammer, not knowing that I keep a mannequin in my bed and actually sleep in the attic, I think that attempted murder would likely stick.
And I just realized I now have to move my secret sleeping spot, and get a second mannequin for the attic!
-
The thing with an effigy is that you most likely know it's an effigy. You knowingly went to the effigy-burning party, or bought your own from effigies-R-us for a private gathering, or made one out of household items. It may land you at the receiving end of a hate crime charge, but not attempted murder. But were you to break into my house, see a form under a sheet on the bed and proceed to hit it with a hammer, not knowing that I keep a mannequin in my bed and actually sleep in the attic, I think that attempted murder would likely stick.
And I just realized I now have to move my secret sleeping spot, and get a second mannequin for the attic!
There is a difference between your home and the outside. It much more reasonable to have a mannequin on the side of the street like trash than under the covers of someones bed.
-
It much more reasonable to have a mannequin on the side of the street like trash than under the covers of someones bed.
I would prefer not to have a mannequin "...on the side of the street like trash..." nor would I prefer to have a mannequin "...under the covers of someones bed."
I prefer real live women over mannequin any day, personally!!! :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
Sorry, couldn't help it. You opened yourself up for that one.
-
It much more reasonable to have a mannequin on the side of the street like trash than under the covers of someones bed.
Can 't.......stop.......laughing.........
-
I would prefer not to have a mannequin "...on the side of the street like trash..." nor would I prefer to have a mannequin "...under the covers of someones bed."
I prefer real live women over mannequin any day, personally!!! :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
Sorry, couldn't help it. You opened yourself up for that one.
Lol hey when they invent good sexbots/robots I will gladly buy one :D It would be like having a personal maid. Would make life much better.
-
Lol hey when they invent good sexbots/robots I will gladly buy one :D It would be like having a personal maid. Would make life much better.
You mean you haven't checked out the Real Doll products? It won't clean your house, but it will make you not care!
There is a reason they cost $4k-$7k. You can even have a person show up to the factory in San Diego to have a 3-D scan done of their face and/or body to have a lifesize replica made. They don't say how much that costs, but they do say it's prohibitively expensive for most people.
I've never seen one to touch, but I've checked out the website and some videos. First time I saw one was on an HBO Playboy video.
If the Cops used a Real Doll for the decoy, the jury will convict in 10 minutes!!
-
Lol hey when they invent good sexbots/robots I will gladly buy one :D It would be like having a personal maid. Would make life much better.
You can always just keep her under your bed like these guys did their mother. Bringing her out whenever they wanted sex....
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=wZLUHQzN6i8
-
You mean you haven't checked out the Real Doll products? It won't clean your house, but it will make you not care!
There is a reason they cost $4k-$7k. You can even have a person show up to the factory in San Diego to have a 3-D scan done of their face and/or body to have a lifesize replica made. They don't say how much that costs, but they do say it's prohibitively expensive for most people.
I've never seen one to touch, but I've checked out the website and some videos. First time I saw one was on an HBO Playboy video.
If the Cops used a Real Doll for the decoy, the jury will convict in 10 minutes!!
I've seen those but I need a movable bot with some intelligence. Need to perform more than 1 task and 1 use else it simply isn't worth.
-
I've seen those but I need a movable bot with some intelligence. Need to perform more than 1 task and 1 use else it simply isn't worth.
Since you've seen those, you have to admit it's unlikely anyone walking up in the dark with a hammer would know it's a decoy.
So, there's a chance the decoy was good enough to satisfy the "reasonable man" standard that he thought it was a real person given the lifelike replicas available on the open market.
These can be ordered with tighter joints in the frame for holding poses, as some use them in art projects and photo shoots.
-
Aside from the fact that some thought crimes have actually indeed become illegal in current America, presuming there is no such thing as a thought crime (as it should be) then you can't look into the perpetrator's state of mind. But Flapp's last argument finally gets it right, I think.
They don't have to prove what he thought.
They only have to prove what any reasonable person would have thought.
If the decoy was good enough, and the area was dark enough, it should be no problem.
That's the sneaky backdoor the courts use to get around the "looking into the mind" dilemma. So this guy can't be charged with murder, but he can be charged with attempted murder.
-
Since you've seen those, you have to admit it's unlikely anyone walking up in the dark with a hammer would know it's a decoy.
So, there's a chance the decoy was good enough to satisfy the "reasonable man" standard that he thought it was a real person given the lifelike replicas available on the open market.
These can be ordered with tighter joints in the frame for holding poses, as some use them in art projects and photo shoots.
The problem is we don't know exact what mannequin used. I doubt it was "real sex doll". And yes while i do agree they are very human like its still not perfect still in uncanny valley as of right now. Its close though. But imagine if say you are 100% right and there were replica humans everywhere, where you could not tell a difference. What the law could do with that. Anyone trying to harm anyone could say they believed it was a robot because there is no real way to tell the difference. You still can't murder objects.
-
The problem is we don't know exact what mannequin used. I doubt it was "real sex doll". And yes while i do agree they are very human like its still not perfect still in uncanny valley as of right now. Its close though. But imagine if say you are 100% right and there were replica humans everywhere, where you could not tell a difference. What the law could do with that. Anyone trying to harm anyone could say they believed it was a robot because there is no real way to tell the difference. You still can't murder objects.
Your hypothetical is irrelevant to the facts.
If a reasonable person would have believed the decoy was real, it was attempted murder. Period.
-
The problem is we don't know exact what mannequin used. I doubt it was "real sex doll". And yes while i do agree they are very human like its still not perfect still in uncanny valley as of right now. Its close though. But imagine if say you are 100% right and there were replica humans everywhere, where you could not tell a difference. What the law could do with that. Anyone trying to harm anyone could say they believed it was a robot because there is no real way to tell the difference. You still can't murder objects.
We don't have to know how relate doll looked, that is up to the jury to decide.
You seem to be protesting the fact he was charged with murder despite not knowing the details of the case.
-
sexbots/robots, Real Doll products? , "real sex doll", one to touch,
I've checked out the website and some videos, under your bed,
good enough to satisfy the "reasonable man" ?
Reasonable ? :wacko:
Flap /Omni, you guy's need to get out more. :shake: :shake: :shake:
PeaShooters "sneaky backdoor" is acceptable. :o
:rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
-
STOP FEEDING THE TROLL
-
sexbots/robots, Real Doll products? , "real sex doll", one to touch,
I've checked out the website and some videos, under your bed,
good enough to satisfy the "reasonable man" ?
Reasonable ? :wacko:
Flap /Omni, you guy's need to get out more. :shake: :shake: :shake:
PeaShooters "sneaky backdoor" is acceptable. :o
:rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
Rocky, :wave:
Sounds like your head is about to explode!!! :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
-
sexbots/robots, Real Doll products? , "real sex doll", one to touch,
I've checked out the website and some videos, under your bed,
good enough to satisfy the "reasonable man" ?
Reasonable ? :wacko:
Flap /Omni, you guy's need to get out more. :shake: :shake: :shake:
PeaShooters "sneaky backdoor" is acceptable. :o
:rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
Your mind starts out in the gutter pretty early in the day! That's scary! :shake:
-
Your mind starts out in the gutter pretty early in the day! That's scary! :shake:
That was early if you did'nt get to bed. :sleeping: :sleeping: :sleeping: :sleeping:
Besides, this post started on an attempted murder charge and ended up on sex dolls. :wacko: :D
And of all of the post's, no comment on how one of the most used murder weapons, a "4-pound ball-peen hammer" was used in the crime in a rather gun liberal state ! ::)