2aHawaii

General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: ren on July 04, 2017, 05:18:14 PM

Title: 123 years ago
Post by: ren on July 04, 2017, 05:18:14 PM
Hawaii was stolen
http://www.kitv.com/story/35811053/local-group-reenacted-the-theft-of-hawaiis-independence-at-iolani-palace (http://www.kitv.com/story/35811053/local-group-reenacted-the-theft-of-hawaiis-independence-at-iolani-palace)

didn't realize that was a long time ago!

I went to public skool
Title: Re: 241 years ago
Post by: punaperson on July 04, 2017, 06:14:46 PM
Hawaii was stolen
http://www.kitv.com/story/35811053/local-group-reenacted-the-theft-of-hawaiis-independence-at-iolani-palace (http://www.kitv.com/story/35811053/local-group-reenacted-the-theft-of-hawaiis-independence-at-iolani-palace)

didn't realize that was a long time ago!
"241-years ago today, the United States commemorated the adoption of the Declaration of Independence." [July 4, 1776]

"Dozens of people gathered along the Iolani Palace lawn to get a glimpse of Hawaii's history and learn what took place on July 4, 1894 ([T]he provisional government announced they had written what they called a new constitution for the Republic of Hawaii.)." [123 years]
Title: Re: 123 years ago
Post by: mrgaf on July 05, 2017, 08:31:28 PM
Hawaii was stolen
http://www.kitv.com/story/35811053/local-group-reenacted-the-theft-of-hawaiis-independence-at-iolani-palace (http://www.kitv.com/story/35811053/local-group-reenacted-the-theft-of-hawaiis-independence-at-iolani-palace)

didn't realize that was a long time ago!

I went to public skool
Being 25% Native American, I can appreciate the sadness and indignation that was felt by all Native Hawaiians having thier nation stolen from them. On the other hand I feel that while we should never let anything like the annexation happen again, we have to move on and pressure our government to formally and legally proclaim that the Hawaiian people ARE the natives of these islands and to afford them all the privileges of all indigenous people that are part of the United States.
Title: Re: 123 years ago
Post by: punaperson on July 05, 2017, 08:59:57 PM
Being 25% Native American, I can appreciate the sadness and indignation that was felt by all Native Hawaiians having thier nation stolen from them. On the other hand I feel that while we should never let anything like the annexation happen again, we have to move on and pressure our government to formally and legally proclaim that the Hawaiian people ARE the natives of these islands and to afford them all the privileges of all indigenous people that are part of the United States.
At least some of the "experts" in the field believe that there were several successive "waves" of "immigrants" who voyaged to the islands and "took over" (i.e. conducted warfare ("stole"?) and defeated the existing inhabitants with the resulting ceding of land/power). If the "original voyagers" who were the first humans to settle on the islands were the "native hawaiians", what does that make the following foreigners from other Pacific locations who took over (and were than called "native hawaiians" by some later people)?
Title: Re: 123 years ago
Post by: rklapp on July 05, 2017, 11:19:04 PM
Existing inhabitants? What experts are you referring to?
Title: Re: 123 years ago
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on July 06, 2017, 12:15:13 AM
Quote
There have been changing views about initial Polynesian discovery and settlement of Hawai'i.[2] Radiocarbon dating in Hawai'i initially indicated a possible settlement as early as 124.[3][4] Patrick Vinton Kirch's
books on Hawaiian archeology, standard textbooks, date the first Polynesian settlements to about 300 with more recent suggestions by Kirch as late as 600. Other theories suggest dating as late as 700 to 800.[2]

In 2010 researchers announced new findings using revised, high-precision radiocarbon dating based on more reliable samples than were previously used in many dating studies.[5] This new data indicates that
the period of eastern and northern Polynesian colonization took place much later, in a shorter time frame of two waves: the "earliest in the Society Islands A.D. ∼1025–1120, four centuries later than previously
assumed; then after 70–265 y, dispersal continued in one major pulse to all remaining islands A.D. ∼1190–1290."[1] According to this research, settlement of the Hawaiian Islands took place circa 1219–1266 CE.[1]
This rapid colonization is believed to account for the "remarkable uniformity of East Polynesia culture, biology and language."[1]

Some writers believe that there were other settlers in Hawaiʻi, peoples who were forced back into remote valleys by newer arrivals. They claim that stories about menehune, little people who built heiau and fishponds,
prove the existence of ancient peoples who settled the islands before the Hawaiians.[6]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ancient_Hawaii
Title: Re: 123 years ago
Post by: oldfart on July 06, 2017, 06:26:02 AM
Look like publicity for da guys book

Slow news day
Title: Re: 123 years ago
Post by: davgdavg on July 07, 2017, 10:45:34 AM
Funny how all peoples always need a scapegoat for all of their problems.

If it wasn't the U.S. (and assuming no one else grabbed Hawaii, which is a long stretch.) People on Kauai, Maui, Molokai, and Oahu would be complaining about how the big meanie Kamehameha had stolen their islands from them and/or sold them to others by using Western weapons and aid. 

Regardless, history, archaeology, and paleontology have all shown that with an increasingly better understanding of humans and human related species, the term "native" is an increasingly ambiguous term.
Title: Re: 123 years ago
Post by: punaperson on July 09, 2017, 09:45:56 AM
Existing inhabitants? What experts are you referring to?
There are numerous academics who have written on the history of the populating of the Hawaiian islands. There is not unanimous agreement on how many "waves" of immigration there were, where they came from, nor exactly which islands they populated and for how long, nor on how "peaceful" or "warlike" they were. One things is for sure: there was more than one mass immigration of different people from different locations having different values and (cultural and political) practices, and the newer immigrants overpowered the previous inhabitants by either killing them, enslaving them, and/or intimidating them  into submission.

Whatever the (argued) details, it is clear that the "original inhabitants"/"native Hawaiians" of the islands were destroyed and/or enslaved by people arriving later... and thus calling those later arrivals who destroyed the previous culture "native Hawaiians" and railing against the next culture that came along and unseated them as being "racists" or whatever, is disingenuous at best, and maybe even a "Big Lie".

Here is one (over?) simplified version of the early events:

AD 400            Estimated to be the time of the first explorers to Owhyhee from southeast Asia and the Marquesas Islands, a gentle people free of class subjugation and war.  I have personally seen their intricate work on the exquisite fish ponds of Kauai.  Sometimes called the Melanesian Polynesians and even sometimes thought to have been the mythical Menehuni of the Polynesian Hawaiian legends.

AD 900-1100  These [sic] immigration(s) of war like people from Tahiti enslaved the previous migrations of people and the leaders maintained rule by fear and  violence, smashed heads, gouged eyes, branding, drowning, strangulation, decapitation, live burials and roasting alive to name only a few of the methods of rule.  The Tahitian immigration brought a warring people who took peace from the land for nearly a thousand years.  The common people lived in everyday fear of death and in slavery.  Even the shadow of a commoner falling across the feet on an Alii could cause death.

http://hawaii-inns.com/history/
Title: Re: 123 years ago
Post by: rklapp on July 09, 2017, 01:26:13 PM
Every society has their own cultural grievances. There are always two sides to every story.