2aHawaii
General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: Inspector on July 10, 2017, 12:03:50 PM
-
Hawaii soldier arrested for alleged ties to Islamic State
http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/35850537/hawaii-soldier-arrested-for-alleged-ties-to-terrorist-group
-
Hang em high
Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk
-
It's sad to see a local boy go crazy like that.
-
Like his dad said "Good [34-year-old] kid". Probably enticed, goaded, and entrapped by FBI. Had "problems", didn't know what he was doing. Not his fault. Would never hurt a fly. Just shooting off his mouth. Etc. (See: future defense attorney statement).
-
Exactly.
Of course they had his 18 year old grad photo in the paper and Dad showed all his young kid days photos. ( Guy is 34 years old)
Defense atty. says he doesn't know anything about the case other than what's in the complaint, then quickly adds could have mental issues, presumably from combat tours as an air traffic controller.
-
...then quickly adds could have mental issues, presumably from combat tours as an air traffic controller.
There is his defense right there in a nutshell. :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
-
Would be nice to see something nice about Hawaii in the national news once and awhile.
We always get mentioned for high rent, high taxes, bad traffic, drugs, corrupt cops, failing rail and now this.
:wtf:
-
Would be nice to see something nice about Hawaii in the national news once and awhile.
We always get mentioned for high rent, high taxes, bad traffic, drugs, corrupt cops, failing rail and now this.
:wtf:
============
Truer words were never spoken :(
-
Would be nice to see something nice about Hawaii in the national news once and awhile.
We always get mentioned for high rent, high taxes, bad traffic, drugs, corrupt cops, failing rail and now this.
:wtf:
I've seen Hawaii mentioned favorably in several articles touting the wonderfulness of extremely strict gun control laws. :shaka:
-
Imagine if he did go on active shooter, we would all be sitting ducks.
Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk
-
Imagine if he did go on active shooter, we would all be sitting ducks.
Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk
owners of big dogs would be ok according to chief robinson
-
the responses from locals are naive.
"So close to home"
"how could it happen here?"
How do you stop an ideology? It can happen anywhere. Information is ubiquitous. Radicalization doesn't need to arrive in a USPS package nor do they fly in from Syria.
The tragedy here is that we law abiding citizens have (currently) the means to defend ourselves from this kind of threat, except our tools are locked up away from our immediate time of need.
-
https://www.investigativeproject.org/6391/islamic-radicalization-in-the-military-surfaces
from link at HawaiiFreePress: http://hawaiifreepress.com/ArticlesMain/tabid/56/ID/19947/Political-Correctness-Kept-Radical-Muslim-in-Army-for-Years.aspx
Islamic Radicalization in the Military Surfaces Again
The Kang case demonstrates the longstanding military practice of genuflection before the altar of political correctness remains. Lethal lessons from Fort Hood have not been learned. Outside the military, the government's Countering Violent Extremism (CVE) program founded under the prior administration sought to downplay radical Islamic terrorism and up-focus "right-wing" extremism, even when facts and statistics failed that narrative. The current administration has begun the effort to turn that CVE process in the better direction, but that process is not easy.
-
F stringing him up, static line him into ISIS territory and put a few Reapers with cameras to follow him and live broadcast how long it takes them to send him to the virgins.
-
the responses from locals are naive.
"So close to home"
"how could it happen here?"
How do you stop an ideology? It can happen anywhere. Information is ubiquitous. Radicalization doesn't need to arrive in a USPS package nor do they fly in from Syria.
The tragedy here is that we law abiding citizens have (currently) the means to defend ourselves from this kind of threat, except our tools are locked up away from our immediate time of need.
You want to stop the ideology from spreading as quickly around the world like it is? Cut off all access to the Internet. Do what China and North Korea does. Sensor, sensor sensor. That is what government regulation (also known as Net Neutrality) will bring.
We need to be able to defend ourselves under these situations and the government has in essence disarmed us. :( :( :(
-
http://wunc.org/post/span-struggles-balance-national-security-free-speech#stream/0
FRAYER: But such laws may also be part of the reason why Spain has not suffered a terror attack since the Madrid train bombings in 2004. On the sidelines of a terrorism conference in Madrid, the country's top terrorism expert, Fernando Reinares, says Spain errs on the side of limiting free speech in order to fight terrorism because, otherwise, he says...
FERNANDO REINARES: While you are investigating these people, they are planning an attack, which actually takes place. And then you have to face your population saying, yes, we knew about this individual, but we didn't arrest them on time.
-
http://wunc.org/post/span-struggles-balance-national-security-free-speech#stream/0
FRAYER: But such laws may also be part of the reason why Spain has not suffered a terror attack since the Madrid train bombings in 2004. On the sidelines of a terrorism conference in Madrid, the country's top terrorism expert, Fernando Reinares, says Spain errs on the side of limiting free speech in order to fight terrorism because, otherwise, he says...
FERNANDO REINARES: While you are investigating these people, they are planning an attack, which actually takes place. And then you have to face your population saying, yes, we knew about this individual, but we didn't arrest them on time.
Spain is an interesting country to study about the lack of terror attacks. And while the article you posted is interesting and may have something to do with the lack of attacks, Spain has a very active undercover investigative team. And they are much more proactive in arresting and convicting potential terrorists. Which in my mind is the biggest reason why they have fewer terrorist attacks. I would actually think loosening up the 1st amendment rights on social media would be more beneficial to the undercover investigators. But who knows?
-
The only free speech not allowed in social media ASAIK is libel and threats against the government. How can it be looser than that? If one threatens the President on Twitter, then the SS come knocking.
-
The only free speech not allowed in social media ASAIK is libel and threats against the government. How can it be looser than that? If one threatens the President on Twitter, then the SS come knocking.
I meant loosening up free speech in Spain. Remember the subject of your posting is about the lack of free speech in Spain? Stay on topic RK. :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
-
There is his defense right there in a nutshell. :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
I think it plausible that a mental illness played a role, whether from PTSD or a pre-existing condition. Certainly the courts should consider a mental evaluation for this man.
-
I think it plausible that a mental illness played a role, whether from PTSD or a pre-existing condition. Certainly the courts should consider a mental evaluation for this man.
Isn't it "plausible that a mental illness played a role" in the case of anyone committing any crime and getting caught? Why would anyone of sound mind risk the total loss of freedom by committing an illegal act unless they were diagnosable with some "mental illness"? Certainly anyone who commits violence against another person in any situation other than self-defense MUST be mentally ill, right? All criminals need not be held truly responsible for their actions, because their illegal acts in themselves are the diagnostic data needed to prove mental illness, at least "plausibly so", right?
-
Isn't it "plausible that a mental illness played a role" in the case of anyone committing any crime and getting caught? Why would anyone of sound mind risk the total loss of freedom by committing an illegal act unless they were diagnosable with some "mental illness"? Certainly anyone who commits violence against another person in any situation other than self-defense MUST be mentally ill, right? All criminals need not be held truly responsible for their actions, because their illegal acts in themselves are the diagnostic data needed to prove mental illness, at least "plausibly so", right?
Are you saying the courts shouldn't consider that? If a mental illness angle isn't addressed in/before trial and a conviction is found it could be overturned later if found that he was mentally ill and it wasn't addressed. State of mind matters when it comes to having the elements of a crime, was it done intentionally, knowingly, recklessly or negligently?. It isn't always a black and white line of course, someone isn't always completely crazy. For example, maybe he did have PTSD but what matters is if it was severe enough that it interfered with his ability to know what he was doing and that is something the court has to decide. The insanity plea isn't some guaranteed defense though, it takes some work to prove someone is that the defendant was mentally ill at the time. Beyond guilt, it can also come into play in deciding an appropriate sentencing. Addressing mental illness would be a part of a thorough prosecution if there is a chance it played a role.
-
Are you saying the courts shouldn't consider that? If a mental illness angle isn't addressed in/before trial and a conviction is found it could be overturned later if found that he was mentally ill and it wasn't addressed. State of mind matters when it comes to having the elements of a crime, was it done intentionally, knowingly, recklessly or negligently?. It isn't always a black and white line of course, someone isn't always completely crazy. For example, maybe he did have PTSD but what matters is if it was severe enough that it interfered with his ability to know what he was doing and that is something the court has to decide. The insanity plea isn't some guaranteed defense though, it takes some work to prove someone is that the defendant was mentally ill at the time. Beyond guilt, it can also come into play in deciding an appropriate sentencing. Addressing mental illness would be a part of a thorough prosecution if there is a chance it played a role.
There are "psychologists" out there who would testify that anyone who commits a crime is ipso facto defined "mentally ill"/has a diagnosable psychological disorder ("antisocial personality disorder"). Whether a judge or jury buys the "explanation" is another story. Defense attorneys could be hesitant to use such a defense depending on their experience with the locale/judge in a particular case, but you asserting that mental illness is "plausible" would apply to every crime and criminal from a broad "psychology" perspective.
-
There are "psychologists" out there who would testify that anyone who commits a crime is ipso facto defined "mentally ill"/has a diagnosable psychological disorder ("antisocial personality disorder"). Whether a judge or jury buys the "explanation" is another story. Defense attorneys could be hesitant to use such a defense depending on their experience with the locale/judge in a particular case, but you asserting that mental illness is "plausible" would apply to every crime and criminal from a broad "psychology" perspective.
I think that in this case it would be more plausible than say your average thief. But regardless, if they didn't address it could come up later. It is just part of a complete prosecution I think. I certainly wouldn't write it off because what if this guy really did have a legitimate mental illness?
The insanity defense is hard to prove and is not very successful. Even if successful it doesn't mean the person walks free, they are often then just put in a mental facility instead of a prison but still essentially incarcerated.
-
I think that in this case it would be more plausible than say your average thief. But regardless, if they didn't address it could come up later. It is just part of a complete prosecution I think. I certainly wouldn't write it off because what if this guy really did have a legitimate mental illness?
The insanity defense is hard to prove and is not very successful. Even if successful it doesn't mean the person walks free, they are often then just put in a mental facility instead of a prison but still essentially incarcerated.
Existence of a mental illness is not the legal standard for a defense. He has to be shown to lack the capacity to differentiate between right and wrong. There are people who were raised with anti-social ideas that qualify as lacking that capacity.
-
Imagine if he did go on active shooter, we would all be sitting ducks.
Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk
When I participated in the carry permit application drive a couple of years ago, my explanation of "extraordinary circumstances" (which was three pages long) heavily referred to lone wolf attacks by radical groups in western nations... I remember thinking that there had been no credible threats in Hawaii. I wonder if they'd look at it differently now?
HAHAHA! Just kidding. HPD would do exactly what they did the first time... Not look at it at all, and auto-send me the standard denial letter.
-
Insanity defense is a last ditch effort. You're admitting to being guilty because of the insanity. If the court doesn't buy the insanity, then you're still guilty.
-
When I participated in the carry permit application drive a couple of years ago, my explanation of "extraordinary circumstances" (which was three pages long) heavily referred to lone wolf attacks by radical groups in western nations... I remember thinking that there had been no credible threats in Hawaii. I wonder if they'd look at it differently now?
HAHAHA! Just kidding. HPD would do exactly what they did the first time... Not look at it at all, and auto-send me the standard denial letter.
I know you were joking, but the "terrorist attack threat" claim would be perfectly in line with NOT being "an exceptional case", as those attacks are "random" (just like "ordinary crime"), and thus no particular individual is "an exceptional case". Even if the attacks were predominantly against military members (which they haven't been), no particular military member would be an "exceptional case". Even in a hypothetical case where, say, members of the legislature were specifically targeted by terrorists, the only result would be that they either voted themselves exclusively the legal right to bear in public (see: one of the bills in Congress after the Republican baseball practice shooting), or they would vote themselves individual 24 hour armed bodyguards. As you say, let's face it, no one in the state of Hawaii will be legally allowed to bear arms outside the home for self-defense until, more or less, hell freezes over (and according to Al Gore, that will never happen). So even if the above would-be ISIS soldier said he was going to do such and such in Hawaii to civilians, it would not change the de facto no issue policy at all.