2aHawaii

General Topics => Off Topic => Topic started by: Inspector on August 23, 2017, 08:22:05 AM

Title: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: Inspector on August 23, 2017, 08:22:05 AM
My wife has never received the jury questionaire. I just got the questionaire, again. Last time I got it they tapped me for a jury case and I was out of work for 3 days. First day I waited. Second day I got picked, third day I served.

Why me? I lived in CA for 50+ years and only got the questionaire twice. And they allowed me to get off for finanical hardship as at that time it was a hardship for me. I have lived on Oahu for 7 years and I have received the questionaire twice and I cannot get out from underneath the juror requirement. And I know once I return the questionaire, I will be picked shortly thereafter. Which is what occurred the last time.

Anyone else feel like they are being targeted or picked for jury duty more often than normal?
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: drck1000 on August 23, 2017, 08:28:12 AM
Federal employees seem to get "hit" more often.  People I work with get selected left and right. 

I was selected maybe 5-6 years ago.  It was actually a fun experience.  It was a super short case.  Expected to be 2 days max.  First day was selection and we had the testimony completed by around 3 pm.  We deliberated for maybe an hour and then went home.  We were done by 11 am the next morning.  It was about a stolen vehicle.  They asked if anyone had their car stolen and I was the only one that said yes. I answered honestly that I could remain impartial.  I figured no way the defense keeps me around.  Well, I was wrong.  Haha. 

One of my best friends is a former prosecutor and from what I was told, the prosecutor on this case was terrible, and he really was.  His case was pretty much "liar, liar, pants on fire".  Well, we convicted anyways, but mostly because of the her own testimony!

ETA: There were a couple English as second language ladies in my jury pool.  One had her number called.  She made the excuse that she couldn't really understand the language.  Well, I heard her speaking to someone in the pool room and her English was just fine!   :grrr:
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: changemyoil66 on August 23, 2017, 08:44:02 AM
I just got the questioner last week.  I've been summoned 2x in the past 3 years and each time I called (24hours prior), the case was settled.

If I have to go in, I'm going to wear a MAGA hat and a 2a shirt.
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: Inspector on August 23, 2017, 09:13:08 AM
I just got the questioner last week.  I've been summoned 2x in the past 3 years and each time I called (24hours prior), the case was settled.

If I have to go in, I'm going to wear a MAGA hat and a 2a shirt.
I have an NRA hat I am going to wear.  :shake: :shake: :shake:
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: Inspector on August 23, 2017, 09:22:10 AM
This last case I was on was about a guy who beat the shit out of his girlfriend. And she pressed charges against him. Then they arrested him and she dropped the charges. But they felt they had enough of a case to prosecute him any way because they still had her sworn testimony and brought her in as a witness. As a witness she swore she was coerced by the prosecutors to testify against him and that he didn't beat her.
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: oldfart on August 23, 2017, 09:28:30 AM
This last case I was on was about a guy who beat the shit out of his girlfriend. And she pressed charges against him. Then they arrested him and she dropped the charges. But they felt they had enough of a case to prosecute him any way because they still had her sworn testimony and brought her in as a witness. As a witness she swore she was coerced by the prosecutors to testify against him and that he didn't beat her.
....
That sounds just like those tv crime dramas
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: Lihikai on August 23, 2017, 11:20:42 AM
I only had to serve once on a criminal case and it was interesting.  Look at it this way - if you're ever the guy that's being prosecuted, wouldn't you want to have jurors that are open-minded and willing to serve?  I think most jurors hate being there so the defendant is already starting off in the hole.
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: Tom_G on August 23, 2017, 03:01:34 PM
I've been called three times since I moved here. Once the case was settled before the selection process; the other two times, I served as a juror. While I admit that the selection process doesn't seem very random, and the timing is rarely convenient, it really irks me to hear people complain about jury duty, or to discuss strategies for not getting selected. And on a forum dedicated to the support of the US Constitution? My sympathy meter is at 0% and trying to go lower.
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 23, 2017, 03:13:25 PM
I had to call in for possible jury duty in June.  Case was settled, so no need to show up.  This was my third time being added to the "pool", but haven't served yet.

It's a much nicer system now.  The first time I was told to call every month from Jul to Dec.  The jury was already selected or not needed each time, so I was given a new date the next month to call back.  Six months of calling, and never told to come down to the courthouse.

I also received the Jury Service Questionnaire about a week ago last Friday.  Sent it back last week Monday. 

The form said it's for 2018, so I assume it's FY 2018 --> Oct 2017 - Sep 2018.

Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: PeaShooter on August 23, 2017, 04:46:55 PM
A long time ago I had a spurt of receiving the questionnaire several times in a few years, but never had to go, although it once got close to the actual date. It's been maybe ten years now since I last got it. I might be blacklisted.
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: zippz on August 23, 2017, 06:54:37 PM
I got the questionnaire last week too.  I would like to be on a jury just to see what it's like.  Previously my cases were settled.
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: rklapp on August 23, 2017, 07:11:07 PM
I'm 49 years old and have never been called. Apparently, the trick is to bring a book.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qgIvg9BBNAs
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: aieahound on August 23, 2017, 08:23:46 PM
I got the questionnaire last week too.

Might be a 2A get together.
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: macsak on August 23, 2017, 08:43:38 PM
I got the questionnaire last week too.

Might be a 2A get together.

lots of people i know got it
my people are exempt...
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: oldfart on August 23, 2017, 08:57:45 PM
My son got a questionnaire. I would rather go jury duty than go to work.
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: robtmc on August 24, 2017, 11:12:18 AM
If I have to go in, I'm going to wear a MAGA hat and a 2a shirt.

+1  If it is a criminal case, my answers to defense lawyer pool questioning will likely get me out of there fast.

Mentioning jury nullification will have prosecution booting you out of the pool.

Had to laugh when Honolulu sent me a jury notice, after living on the BI for years.  Recently wife got a notice, apparently for the Hilo court.  That should get her out of it.
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: tillamook on August 24, 2017, 04:07:38 PM
as much as it sucks I go to jury duty.  Because if I was accused of a crime I'd want a peer on the jury, not just a bunch of unemployed people that could not figure out how to get out of jury duty.

Plus jury nullification.  If it is a crap law, especially a firearm law, I will call out that BS and refuse to punish someone for some idiot legislator's billionaire funded law. 
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: aieahound on August 24, 2017, 06:47:31 PM
Wow.
I didn't even know about jury nullification.
That a jury can declare a law unjust or unconstitutional and therefore basically acquit the otherwise guilty defendant on the grounds of a violation of an unjust law.

That's pretty Radical.
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: robtmc on August 25, 2017, 10:38:30 AM
Plus jury nullification.  If it is a crap law, especially a firearm law, I will call out that BS and refuse to punish someone for some idiot legislator's billionaire funded law.
I gather they do not tell you what the trial is about before hand.  Probably to prevent jurors from picking and choosing trials that have personal interest for them.  No prejudge I suppose.

No way would they let me on the Bundy trial jury.
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: tillamook on August 25, 2017, 11:02:34 AM
I gather they do not tell you what the trial is about before hand.  Probably to prevent jurors from picking and choosing trials that have personal interest for them.  No prejudge I suppose.

No way would they let me on the Bundy trial jury.

No they do not tell you until you are in the courtroom doing jury selection. 

Unfortunately every time I go to jury duty I get thrown out because Im a physician.  I think the attorneys worry that I will influence the other jurors so they dismiss me.   Last case was someone busted for "allegedly"  selling meth.  The defense attorney asked me if I know how meth effects people and I said yes and they sent me home on the spot before the trial started. 

But I keep going.  I hope to be called for some stupid firearm law that clearly is unconstitutional.  Like Hawaii requiring physician clearance for purchasing a firearm.   as a physician in Hawaii, I literally can call the police on any patient and have their firearm license revoked for any reason I see fit.  When I started working here I called the firearm enforcement division to see what my responsibilities were.  no due process.   Total BS.   The second amendment does not say anything about doctor clearance to own a firearm. 

So use your power as a juror.  Same as the president gets to pardon someone.  we can decide if a law is unjust or unconstitutional and refuse to send someone to jail.   (just dont say jury nullification.  the judges and attorneys dont want anyone to know about that)
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: macsak on August 25, 2017, 11:08:12 AM
physicians and dentists are exempt from jury duty
it is #2 exemption on the jury duty questionaire

No they do not tell you until you are in the courtroom doing jury selection. 

Unfortunately every time I go to jury duty I get thrown out because Im a physician.  I think the attorneys worry that I will influence the other jurors so they dismiss me.   Last case was someone busted for "allegedly"  selling meth.  The defense attorney asked me if I know how meth effects people and I said yes and they sent me home on the spot before the trial started. 

But I keep going.  I hope to be called for some stupid firearm law that clearly is unconstitutional.  Like Hawaii requiring physician clearance for purchasing a firearm.   as a physician in Hawaii, I literally can call the police on any patient and have their firearm license revoked for any reason I see fit.  When I started working here I called the firearm enforcement division to see what my responsibilities were.  no due process.   Total BS.   The second amendment does not say anything about doctor clearance to own a firearm. 

So use your power as a juror.  Same as the president gets to pardon someone.  we can decide if a law is unjust or unconstitutional and refuse to send someone to jail.   (just dont say jury nullification.  the judges and attorneys dont want anyone to know about that)
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: tillamook on August 25, 2017, 11:13:13 AM
physicians and dentists are exempt from jury duty
it is #2 exemption on the jury duty questionaire

still going to go.  Im not an emergency doc and I have partners to cover a day at Jury duty.  Like I said, if Im on the other end of that jury, I'd want a peer in the jury
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: PeaShooter on August 25, 2017, 12:44:28 PM
Since there is one here, do doctors automatically get a questionnaire if I purchase a firearm? For all my previous purchases I wrote "no doctor" as I indeed had not gone to see a doctor in a long time (I get sick a lot, I just don't bother going to the doctor).

However I went once more recently and the doctor wanted me to call HMSA and officially add them as my personal physician or something. I debated whether or not I should do it, but I did. Does this mean I have to write their name on the permit form now? Can I, like, disavow them or something and go to a different physician next time, or add them back later?
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 25, 2017, 12:55:51 PM
Since there is one here, do doctors automatically get a questionnaire if I purchase a firearm? For all my previous purchases I wrote "no doctor" as I indeed had not gone to see a doctor in a long time (I get sick a lot, I just don't bother going to the doctor).

However I went once more recently and the doctor wanted me to call HMSA and officially add them as my personal physician or something. I debated whether or not I should do it, but I did. Does this mean I have to write their name on the permit form now? Can I, like, disavow them or something and go to a different physician next time, or add them back later?

How is this related to Jury Duty??

Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: tillamook on August 25, 2017, 01:23:07 PM
Since there is one here, do doctors automatically get a questionnaire if I purchase a firearm? For all my previous purchases I wrote "no doctor" as I indeed had not gone to see a doctor in a long time (I get sick a lot, I just don't bother going to the doctor).

However I went once more recently and the doctor wanted me to call HMSA and officially add them as my personal physician or something. I debated whether or not I should do it, but I did. Does this mean I have to write their name on the permit form now? Can I, like, disavow them or something and go to a different physician next time, or add them back later?

feel free to start a new thread and I can try and answer questions.  But if you mark anything on this form then you have to see a doctor to get clearance
http://honolulupd.org/downloads/applicationquestionnaire_HPD131BR05_13.pdf

But your doctor can call the firearm department at any time and say "I dont think this person should have firearms" and the police will flag the license and deny renewal  (what I was told by the person working my local firearms enforcement at the police station. 
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: mrgaf on August 26, 2017, 07:20:20 AM
Hmmm been here since 1985, retired from the military in 1988, was a fed employee from 1989 to 2016 and have never gotten a jury duty notice. Oh crap, now that I said something.......  :'( :shake:
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: robtmc on August 26, 2017, 08:11:44 AM
Hmmm been here since 1985, retired from the military in 1988, was a fed employee from 1989 to 2016 and have never gotten a jury duty notice. Oh crap, now that I said something.......  :'( :shake:
In Calif, they use the voter registration roles.  I think Hawaii uses something else, as  I wes not registered here first time I got a summons (McCain).  Tax records, maybe?
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: RSN172 on August 26, 2017, 10:01:00 AM
Hawaii previously used voter registration, but now uses driver license records since so many people here don't vote.
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: pj_benn on August 26, 2017, 12:45:07 PM
i got a letter too but didn't look really official. though if it was real id have to sign for it or something. thought it might be some weird identity theft scam. tried to look online what the letter looks like, no luck. whats the return addy on your letters?
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 26, 2017, 01:42:58 PM
i got a letter too but didn't look really official. though if it was real id have to sign for it or something. thought it might be some weird identity theft scam. tried to look online what the letter looks like, no luck. whats the return addy on your letters?

These are not sent with signature receipt.  So, no, you would not be required to sign for it.

There's a short questionnaire to give you the chance to claim an exemption if you think you're entitled to be excused from jury duty.  Not filling out the form isn't going to automatically stop you from being added to the pool.

If you thought it was a scam, did you try to call the court to find out?  You can look up the phone number online and see if it matches the numbers in the letter.

The sending of the letters was announced on the news.

http://khon2.com/2017/08/01/state-to-mail-out-jury-questionnaires-for-2018/

http://www.courts.state.hi.us/news_and_reports/2017/08/jury-questionnaires-to-be-mailed-out-for-2018


If you threw the letter away, you can request a replacement:

Quote
Where can I get a replacement jury questionnaire form?

If you have lost or misplaced the jury questionnaire that was mailed to you, please contact your Circuit for a replacement.

First Circuit – O’ahu: (808) 539-4360
Second Circuit – Maui, Moloka’i, Lana’i: (808) 244-2706
Third Circuit – Island Of Hawai’i: (808) 961-7412
Fifth Circuit – Kaua’i, Niihau: (808) 482-2394

http://www.courts.state.hi.us/general_information/jury/jury_q_faqs#Q1

Not returning the questionnaire can result in a penalty.
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: pj_benn on August 28, 2017, 06:11:04 PM
good call on googling the phone number. not sure if there is one tho. ill check. if not ill try the address
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: Heavies on August 29, 2017, 01:40:55 AM
I've been called three times since I moved here. Once the case was settled before the selection process; the other two times, I served as a juror. While I admit that the selection process doesn't seem very random, and the timing is rarely convenient, it really irks me to hear people complain about jury duty, or to discuss strategies for not getting selected. And on a forum dedicated to the support of the US Constitution? My sympathy meter is at 0% and trying to go lower.
I agree with you Tom, on this being ones civic duty.  However, I can also sympathize on why many don't want to do it, especially in Hawaii's economy.   If one has bills to pay, and is not blessed with a job that will absorb that, one could be in dire straits if having to spend days, weeks, months(?) in the courtroom. 

I have been called, have served, did my duty.  Luckily I've been blessed with a job that allows that.  Still waiting to be called again, but I have that luxury and blessing, i couldn't fault those who do not.  It's hard...
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: Heavies on August 29, 2017, 01:46:31 AM
I too hope to someday be on that 'place to keep' jury where someone did some good.  That would be awesome. Sadly during a retrial, because of the hung jury, that poor person would probably be done a number on...  :(
Title: Re: Arghhhhhhhh, Jury Duty Again!!!!
Post by: drck1000 on August 29, 2017, 07:32:53 AM
My work paid me fully for jury duty, but for many other jurors, they were out of work without pay for the time that they served.  A few were on their only days off and only time to see their kids.  I truly felt for those folks.  The trial that I was on was expected to be super short, so the judge did give somewhat of a lecture on those who would try to get out on BS excuses. 

The bailiff was a friend of a friend and she told me that this judge's next trial was a murder trial.  Just the jury selection alone was expected to last weeks. A coworker was in the jury pool for the Deedy trial.  He was out of the office a bunch.  While I agree about the civic duty part, I can see how a trial like that and being out of work for that long is a true hardship.