2aHawaii
General Topics => Off Topic => Topic started by: Heavies on January 22, 2018, 05:21:55 PM
-
This is from Facebook group Stolen Stuff Hawaii... https://www.facebook.com/groups/stolenstuffhawaii/
I need to bring HB1996 to everyone's attention. This bill has just been introduced and in a nutshell:
"Requires courts to order any person charged with a criminal offense to be released on personal recognizance pending trial, unless the person is a flight risk, unlikely to appear for trial, or a danger to others. Requires the Judiciary to establish and maintain a Pretrial Services Program to conduct pretrial risk assessments. Repeals state laws relating to bail."
It essentially eliminates the bail system and allows anyone not considered a threat to be released immediately. So someone steals your car, gets arrested, given a trial date, and then is released immediately.
I know the bail system has it's negatives, but do we really want this? IMHO, with only a cursory review, enacting this as law will essentially release a ton of criminals back onto the streets...allowing them more opportunities to victimize our communities again and again. This sounds absolutely insane.
Am I reading this wrong? Is this what this group wants? Our community wants? Or deserves? Do you think our legislature is leading us down the wrong path with this? If so, contact them and let them know!
It was introduced by Represenatives Ing, Brower, Creagan, Gates, Keohokalole, Lown. It's past first reading.
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=HB&billnumber=1996&year=2018
If there is any doubt that Democrats HATE law abiding citizen, and LOVE CRIMINALS, this should put your doubts to rest.
Seems like at every opportunity, they remove your rights only to give them over to criminals.
>:( :grrr: >:( :grrr: >:(
-
So wait Some one accused of a crime who is not a danger to themselves, others or a flight risk gets to go free whilst waiting for their trial and you have a problem with that ?
INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN GUILTY.
i present the 8th amendment
"Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted."
Most of these people would get out on a low bail amount anyway. +1 to the constitution
This is from Facebook group Stolen Stuff Hawaii... https://www.facebook.com/groups/stolenstuffhawaii/
If there is any doubt that Democrats HATE law abiding citizen, and LOVE CRIMINALS, this should put your doubts to rest.
Seems like at every opportunity, they remove your rights only to give them over to criminals.
>:( :grrr: >:( :grrr: >:(
-
So wait Some one accused of a crime who is not a danger to themselves, others or a flight risk gets to go free whilst waiting for their trial and you have a problem with that ?
INNOCENT UNTIL PROVEN GUILTY.
i present the 8th amendment
"Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted."
Most of these people would get out on a low bail amount anyway. +1 to the constitution
"Excessive bail shall not be required, nor excessive fines imposed, nor cruel and unusual punishments inflicted."
NOT NO BAIL
Why even arrest them at all? Why not just give them a letter asking very nicely to appear in court like a traffic ticket? Are you kidding? THIS is the reason why property crime is going through the roof! There are practically ZERO consequences for these criminals.
-
NOT NO BAIL
Why even arrest them at all? Why not just give them a letter asking very nicely to appear in court like a traffic ticket? Are you kidding? THIS is the reason why property crime is going through the roof! There are practically ZERO consequences for these criminals.
The reason property crime is going through the roof is not because they are out on bail (paid or not) its because they are not getting convicted and when they are its a minimum punishment.
-
The reason property crime is going through the roof is not because they are out on bail (paid or not) its because they are not getting convicted and when they are its a minimum punishment.
Paying bail is collateral for incentive to appear in court. If they are then found not guilty then it may be returned. Judges have a job. They can set bail high, low, what ever.... Do we really need ANOTHER bureaucracy to hold a judges hand and tell him that a suspect is or is not a risk to society? Do we need one more drain on our pocketbooks, through taxation, to coddle the thieving dregs of society?
-
"Pretrial Services Program"
why not "minority report"?
-
Paying bail is collateral for incentive to appear in court. If they are then found not guilty then it may be returned. Judges have a job. They can set bail high, low, what ever.... Do we really need ANOTHER bureaucracy to hold a judges hand and tell him that a suspect is or is not a risk to society? Do we need one more drain on our pocketbooks, through taxation, to coddle the thieving dregs of society?
What about those accused of a crime who dont have money for bail ? or those that are innocent ?
How many people lose their jobs, homes, cars because they cant work because they are held on remand pending a trial that would most likely have them facing no jail time anyway ?
Locking up people who have not been found guilty for an inability to pay bail is bullshit and costs more in taxation then a monitoring program.
-
there is a simpler more cost effective solution - eliminate HOPE and keep the bail system the way it is.
-
there is a simpler more cost effective solution - eliminate HOPE and keep the bail system the way it is.
THIS
-
THIS
+1
-
Ok, "non violent" until they become violent? Has everyone already forgot about Telma Boinville who was brutally murdered by "non violent" burglars and drug addicts? Doesn't people that get arrested get a hearing and charges, if there is actual evidence of a crime being committed, before their bail is set? That's the reason people are released "pending further investigation", there is not enough evidence to support charges! So NO, there is no constitutional RIGHT being violated by requiring someone bail to be released before trial!
-
THIS
I wish I could transform that into a Governor Ren vote. Make Hawaii Great Again!
-
This is from Facebook group Stolen Stuff Hawaii... https://www.facebook.com/groups/stolenstuffhawaii/
If there is any doubt that Democrats HATE law abiding citizen, and LOVE CRIMINALS, this should put your doubts to rest.
Seems like at every opportunity, they remove your rights only to give them over to criminals.
>:( :grrr: >:( :grrr: >:(
I think the bail system needs some reform but this could take it too far. I can see things like petty misdemeanors but not felony charges. Depends how they classify flight risk though. If they have a single warrant for not showing up to court then they have a history showing them a flight risk and I would bet this would hold most regular criminals.
I think London brings up some real problems though. I don't know about Hawaii but in some places the bail system has been seriously abused. Large bails for minor crimes and people kept in jail for moths or years till their trial date.
This video had some worthy criticisms of the bail system
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TGomdoO368g
-
I don't like that Dog guy
-
This bill seems more like bail reform to improve the whole system, would have to hear more about it at the committee hearing.
There are negatives in keeping people in jail unnecessarily. As mentioned earlier it puts a burden on those that may be innocent or keeping them in jail for petty crimes causing them to lose their jobs, become homeless, have to go on welfare, etc. When that happens it can become a bigger problem for society. It also costs taxpayer money to keep them in jail.
-
This bill seems more like bail reform to improve the whole system, would have to hear more about it at the committee hearing.
There are negatives in keeping people in jail unnecessarily. As mentioned earlier it puts a burden on those that may be innocent or keeping them in jail for petty crimes causing them to lose their jobs, become homeless, have to go on welfare, etc. When that happens it can become a bigger problem for society. It also costs taxpayer money to keep them in jail.
Isn't the goal to make illegal activities not attractive?
-
Isn't the goal to make illegal activities not attractive?
The assumption is someone is innocent until proven guilty, and bail is used as a guarantee that a person will show up to trial and not commit crimes in the meantime.
The problem is if there is someone with a clean record or accused of a petty crime such as littering is put in jail and has no money to make even a low bail. They could stay in jail for a month. This could be seen as an unfair punishment. They could also lose their job which can cause homelessness and other problems to society in the future. And what happens if they go through all that and are found to be innocent?
Repeat offenders or flights risks would still be charged bail. The law appears to set standards instead of each judge making up their own standards.
I'd rather not have a law like this to allow discretion to the courts, but if there is a problem then I'd support this law.
-
The assumption is someone is innocent until proven guilty, and bail is used as a guarantee that a person will show up to trial and not commit crimes in the meantime.
The problem is if there is someone with a clean record or accused of a petty crime such as littering is put in jail and has no money to make even a low bail. They could stay in jail for a month. This could be seen as an unfair punishment. They could also lose their job which can cause homelessness and other problems to society in the future. And what happens if they go through all that and are found to be innocent?
Repeat offenders or flights risks would still be charged bail. The law appears to set standards instead of each judge making up their own standards.
I'd rather not have a law like this to allow discretion to the courts, but if there is a problem then I'd support this law.
Ok, "non violent" until they become violent? Has everyone already forgot about Telma Boinville who was brutally murdered by "non violent" burglars and drug addicts? Doesn't people that get arrested get a hearing and charges, if there is actual evidence of a crime being committed, before their bail is set? That's the reason people are released "pending further investigation", there is not enough evidence to support charges! So NO, there is no constitutional RIGHT being violated by requiring someone bail to be released before trial!
Judges have the power to not set bail for litter bugs. No new law needed
-
Judges have the power to not set bail for litter bugs. No new law needed
Even the police have that power for misdemeanor type crimes in special circumstances. Released on own recognizance or something like that.
-
Senate version is going to hearing tomorrow. 24 hours for testimony is 1:15pm today.
https://www.capitol.hawaii.gov/measure_indiv.aspx?billtype=SB&billnumber=2860&year=2018
-
here's something relevant to bail
http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/37378822/waianae-man-accused-of-shooting-at-police-also-wanted-by-dog-the-bounty-hunter (http://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/story/37378822/waianae-man-accused-of-shooting-at-police-also-wanted-by-dog-the-bounty-hunter)
-
If anyone is interested in submitting testimony on this, there are now 4 bills in the house and senate on 'no bail for badguys'
https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=10216090457801241&set=gm.2030430350552967&type=3&theater&ifg=1
-
I submitted testimony against.
My reasoning is that this bill is written far too vaguely and will allow repeat offenders to be released to commit even more crimes.
The bail amount for repeat offenders should go up, not down.
If they were to re-write it to give more discretion to judges for first time offenders and those known as responsible citizens, for minor infractions, I might be more amenable.
I also strenuously object to another layer of bureaucracy added to an already dysfunctional judiciary system, at our expense.
As it is, it's lazy and irresponsible legislation, and does nothing to improve the safety and well being of the citizenry.
-
I submitted testimony against.
My reasoning is that this bill is written far too vaguely and will allow repeat offenders to be released to commit even more crimes.
The bail amount for repeat offenders should go up, not down.
If they were to re-write it to give more discretion to judges for first time offenders and those known as responsible citizens, for minor infractions, I might be more amenable.
I also strenuously object to another layer of bureaucracy added to an already dysfunctional judiciary system, at our expense.
As it is, it's lazy and irresponsible legislation, and does nothing to improve the safety and well being of the citizenry.
THIS
-
Report: Bail Set Too High For Half Of Hawaii’s Jail Inmates
Pre-trial detainees in Honolulu wait in jail an average of 71 days, according to the ACLU.
Former prosecutor Peter Carlisle disputed the union’s findings, saying the state of Hawaii has had “huge success in criminal law.”
“We have one of the lowest violent crime rates anywhere so is that a system that’s broken?” Carlisle said.
The report is the result of an ongoing, statewide investigation and analysis of the state’s bail-setting practices and how it affects
families and communities.
The union studied bail-setting practices during the first six months of 2017. Researchers found circuit courts in Hawaii set bail
money as a condition of release in 88 percent of cases, though only 44 percent of those people managed to eventually post the
amount set by the court.
http://www.civilbeat.org/2018/02/report-bail-set-too-high-for-half-of-hawaiis-jail-inmates/?utm_content=buffer32b04&utm_medium=social&utm_source=facebook.com&utm_campaign=buffer