2aHawaii

Tools and Uses => Reloading => Topic started by: oldfart on January 28, 2018, 09:45:17 AM

Title: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: oldfart on January 28, 2018, 09:45:17 AM
Just for reference

I went to the range last week with fellow 2A member scorpio.
He had a beautiful SW 625 with 4"bbl and shooting some Fed RTP white box ammo (Range-Target-Practice)
I had not shot any factory ammo in a long time so I was curious what they put in their econo-ammo nowadays.

Here is what I found:

45 acp-230 gr Federal RTP lot #Q20M229
Headstamp=Federal 45 Auto
OAL= 1.266 "
Mouth dia=0.470"
Bullet=conventional Full Metal Jacket with NO sealer
Bullet weight=231.7 gr.
Bullet dia=0.4505"
Propellant=5.0 gr. of fine grain flakes
Velocity from the SW 625 4"bbl=837 fps with an SD of 7 fps
Velocity from my 5.5" bar-sto bbl was 857 fps and SD of 8 fps

See pictures-
Note the similar appearance of the powder when compared to Bullseye
Title: Re: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: Inspector on January 28, 2018, 03:18:26 PM
Thanks for doing this. I find your deconstruction threads interesting.
Title: Re: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: oldfart on January 28, 2018, 04:27:57 PM
Thanks for doing this. I find your deconstruction threads interesting.
....
Thanks
Next up is a round of 45acp from the era of Bonnie and Clyde.
Title: Re: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: rklapp on January 28, 2018, 08:24:22 PM
Do you use a camera attached to a microscope to take a picture of the powder?
Title: Re: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: oldfart on January 28, 2018, 08:44:27 PM
Do you use a camera attached to a microscope to take a picture of the powder?
....
It's a fancy toy electronic microscope.
It can go up to 200x
Title: Re: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: rklapp on January 29, 2018, 07:15:12 AM
Science!
https://www.amazon.com/Mattel-P510002-Digital-Blue-Microscope/dp/B000059TF3
Title: Re: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: oldfart on January 29, 2018, 09:19:57 AM
Science!
https://www.amazon.com/Mattel-P510002-Digital-Blue-Microscope/dp/B000059TF3
...
Yes, that is the microscope.
It is old and the software driver just barely works with Windows XP.
I wouldn't even attempt to load it on win 10
Title: Re: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: bass monkey on January 30, 2018, 05:35:26 PM
Under velocity section:
Velocity from the SW 625 4"bbl=837 fps with an SD of 7 fps
Velocity from my 5.5" bar-sto bbl was 857 fps and SD of 8 fps

What is SD?
Title: Re: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: macsak on January 30, 2018, 05:58:23 PM
Under velocity section:
Velocity from the SW 625 4"bbl=837 fps with an SD of 7 fps
Velocity from my 5.5" bar-sto bbl was 857 fps and SD of 8 fps

What is SD?

standard deviation
measures how consistent the results are
lower is better
Title: Re: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: Heavies on January 30, 2018, 06:06:58 PM
standard deviation
measures how consistent the results are
lower is better

That's pretty good numbers for cheepo ammo
Title: Re: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: oldfart on January 30, 2018, 06:23:57 PM
standard deviation
measures how consistent the results are
lower is better
....
For geeky electrical and electronics engineers, SD is the equivalent of RMS voltage of a sine wave.

In practical use, it is the range where 70.7% of the shots fall.
In the case of the revolver, the reading was 837 /7
So 70% of the shots fell between 830 and 841.
Title: Re: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: scorpio ps on February 04, 2018, 06:47:01 PM
Just for reference

I went to the range last week with fellow 2A member scorpio.
He had a beautiful SW 625 with 4"bbl and shooting some Fed RTP white box ammo (Range-Target-Practice)
I had not shot any factory ammo in a long time so I was curious what they put in their econo-ammo nowadays.

Here is what I found:

45 acp-230 gr Federal RTP lot #Q20M229
Headstamp=Federal 45 Auto
OAL= 1.266 "
Mouth dia=0.470"
Bullet=conventional Full Metal Jacket with NO sealer
Bullet weight=231.7 gr.
Bullet dia=0.4505"
Propellant=5.0 gr. of fine grain flakes
Velocity from the SW 625 4"bbl=837 fps with an SD of 7 fps
Velocity from my 5.5" bar-sto bbl was 857 fps and SD of 8 fps

See pictures-
Note the similar appearance of the powder when compared to Bullseye

What's causing the faster speed. Twist,  5" barrel or is the speed difference insignificant to postulate. I'll look for a different  45 for you to test. I think I have a veriety. 
Title: Re: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: scorpio ps on February 04, 2018, 06:49:09 PM
Can deconstruction be used to reverse engineer.
Title: Re: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: Inspector on February 04, 2018, 06:57:16 PM
Can deconstruction be used to reverse engineer.
It may be possible if you can identify the powder and it is still manufactured today? Maybe a chemical analysis of the powder? The problem is some of the old powders used in military cartridges is not being made or copied.
Title: Re: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: oldfart on February 04, 2018, 08:25:15 PM
Can deconstruction be used to reverse engineer?
....
In most cases, no.

In this case, the powder sure looks like alliant bullseye powder.
The amount is consistent with bullseye too.
The bullet is of conventional design.
So yeah I can duplicate it. But this generic box ammo is nothing to get excited about.
Guys have been replicating 45ball for decades.
Title: Re: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: rklapp on February 04, 2018, 11:33:58 PM
Probability curve for Standard Deviation. The percentage relates to the area under the curve with the median being the average.

(http://manufacturingindia.weebly.com/uploads/2/9/8/1/2981622/1627914_orig.jpg)
Title: Re: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: oldfart on February 05, 2018, 07:51:02 AM
There's 2 different methods of calculating SD.
That Bell curve is one of them. Not sure which.
I think rms is like the other one.
The difference is something to do with the mean value.
Title: Re: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: Heavies on February 05, 2018, 01:34:38 PM
What's causing the faster speed. Twist,  5" barrel or is the speed difference insignificant to postulate. I'll look for a different  45 for you to test. I think I have a veriety. 
Probably a combination of the extra barrel length and the small loss of pressure from the cylinder gap on the revolver.
Title: Re: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: Heavies on February 05, 2018, 01:37:13 PM
5 grns of bullseye would be a pretty warm load with 230grn ball
Title: Re: Deconstruction: Fed 45 ACP White Box
Post by: oldfart on February 05, 2018, 02:53:41 PM
5 grns of bullseye would be a pretty warm load with 230grn ball
...
Yep, very similar to military ball