2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: hvybarrels on February 13, 2018, 04:30:29 PM

Title: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: hvybarrels on February 13, 2018, 04:30:29 PM
Some people's testimony reads very well and looks super professional while others have definite room for improvement. I sometimes cringe reading mine after they get posted because most of the time I was rushing and trying to sound original, which is rarely a good combination.

What type of tone should we take? How many words minimum/max? Should we include questions or simply make factual statements? Back it up with references? Personal stories?

Mac made a joke earlier about trying to persuade illogical people with logical arguments, but they are people after all and it makes me wonder if there's a certain type of testimony they are more likely to listen to vs the others.

Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: macsak on February 13, 2018, 04:47:01 PM
Some people's testimony reads very well and looks super professional while others have definite room for improvement. I sometimes cringe reading mine after they get posted because most of the time I was rushing and trying to sound original, which is rarely a good combination.

What type of tone should we take? How many words minimum/max? Should we include questions or simply make factual statements? Back it up with references? Personal stories?

Mac made a joke earlier about trying to persuade illogical people with logical arguments, but they are people after all and it makes me wonder if there's a certain type of testimony they are more likely to listen to vs the others.

that wasn't a joke

the main thing is to HAVE NUMBERS OF PEOPLE
and be sure to correctly mark "support" or "oppose"
then have people show up at the committee meetings
and then email/call when it comes up to a floor vote
and VOTE and get your friends/family to vote too
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: zippz on February 13, 2018, 04:57:29 PM
Read testimonies from other organizations and gov departments for gun rights and unrelated bills.

You can get ideas from those.
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: macsak on February 13, 2018, 05:11:05 PM
Read testimonies from other organizations and gov departments for gun rights and unrelated bills.

You can get ideas from those.

what Z said
read other's testimony and choose what style you like
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: edster48 on February 13, 2018, 05:35:38 PM
that wasn't a joke

the main thing is to HAVE NUMBERS OF PEOPLE
and be sure to correctly mark "support" or "oppose"
then have people show up at the committee meetings
and then email/call when it comes up to a floor vote
and VOTE and get your friends/family to vote too

Mac is absolutely correct.

What really makes a difference to them are the opinions of  REGISTERED VOTERS.

Especially large numbers of them that might decide to vote AGAINST them in the next election.

Someone on the Oahu Gun Club FB page noted that they were VERY interested in the thick stack of opposing testimony. This is why.

And please, FOR THE LOVE OF GOD, proofread your testimony and check for spelling errors before you send it.
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: hvybarrels on February 13, 2018, 10:26:59 PM
I learned the hard way that my spell checker doesn't work in the submission box and it's always better to use a word processor and copy/paste. Especially important if you are in a rush!
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: hvybarrels on February 13, 2018, 11:10:08 PM
the main thing is to HAVE NUMBERS OF PEOPLE

I'm not sure I entirely agree with this. If 1000 people oppose in all-caps and fill their testimony with t-shirt slogans like "Molon Labe" and "Cold Dead Hands" then it's much easier for career politicians to ignore all of us as extremists. And when an unpopular small minority of extremists makes public demands then it might ruin the politician's reputation with the rest of their constituency if they end up finding common ground with us. 

Well though out arguments that appeal to their sensibilities might stand a better chance because at this point it's pretty obvious the numbers don't matter.

I'm curious if anybody knows what the people reviewing this testimony actually LIKE to read? If we can find out what kind of style and content is more likely to catch their attention in a positive way we might be a leg up on not only saving what we got left but also possibly figuring out ways to bring shooting sports and self defense back into the mainstream.

Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: punaperson on February 14, 2018, 07:17:27 AM
I'm not sure I entirely agree with this. If 1000 people oppose in all-caps and fill their testimony with t-shirt slogans like "Molon Labe" and "Cold Dead Hands" then it's much easier for career politicians to ignore all of us as extremists. And when an unpopular small minority of extremists makes public demands then it might ruin the politician's reputation with the rest of their constituency if they end up finding common ground with us. 

Well though out arguments that appeal to their sensibilities might stand a better chance because at this point it's pretty obvious the numbers don't matter.

I'm curious if anybody knows what the people reviewing this testimony actually LIKE to read? If we can find out what kind of style and content is more likely to catch their attention in a positive way we might be a leg up on not only saving what we got left but also possibly figuring out ways to bring shooting sports and self defense back into the mainstream.
There are 500 or so bills. Each bill that is heard is heard in multiple committees. Each legislator sits on multiple committees. Nobody is reading all the testimony for the bills that get voted on. Adding up "For" and "Opposed", yes. Reading it, no.
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: hvybarrels on February 14, 2018, 08:27:13 AM
So in other words don't try too hard and keep it short since they probably won't read it anyway?

I'm sure they don't read every last word but it would be good to have some guidelines to help make the best presentation possible in the event that one's testimony catches their eye.
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: punaperson on February 14, 2018, 08:41:49 AM
So in other words don't try too hard and keep it short since they probably won't read it anyway?

I'm sure they don't read every last word but it would be good to have some guidelines to help make the best presentation possible in the event that one's testimony catches their eye.
I write lengthy detailed testimony in most cases because I don't want them to have any room to later claim the "I didn't know what it meant" excuse. And I suspect that in the case of specific firearms related bills, such as the current crop of "bumpstock"/"increased rate of fire" bills, many have no idea what they are legislating (obviously).

zippz would probably be the one to make suggestions re "presentation" and he already did that above. Any other suggestions are welcome, but I doubt even the "assistants" read all the testimony, and certainly the legislators don't.
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: rklapp on February 14, 2018, 09:11:55 AM
I start my testimony with I oppose (or the rare support) so the reader knows my view off the bat and then follow with one logical viewpoint so they don’t get overwhelmed. I also make sure to manually use the spelling feature.
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: hvybarrels on February 14, 2018, 09:47:37 AM
Those are great suggestions. I also liked what zippz said about copying the style and formatting of organizations and gov departments but at the same time had concerns about making it sound too formal.

This may be a case of overthinking things, but thanks for humoring me. My last attempts kinda sucked and I'd like to do better in the future.
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: hvybarrels on February 14, 2018, 10:32:18 AM
This is the main text from NRA-ILA automated letter that someone linked to in the other thread. It is surrounded by a business letter heading and footer.

Quote
As a law-abiding Hawaii gun owner, I respectfully urge you to oppose House Bill 1908.

House Bill 1908 would make it a felony for any person who "manufactures or causes to be manufactured, imports into the State, keeps for sale, or offers or exposes for sale, or who gives, lends, or possesses" certain trigger modifications. The broad language of this bill could encompass many common modifications done by law-abiding gun owners to make their firearms more suitable for self-defense, competition, hunting, or even overcoming disability.

Again, as a fellow Hawaii resident, I urge you to oppose House Bill 1908.

I like the respectful tone, sticking to the facts, and call to action. Also the "fellow Hawaii resident" is a nice touch because it's an attempt at building rapport. They seem to realize that maintaining bridges is important especially when you have people calling you terrorists/source of all evil/etc.

Then again it is a form letter, it didn't take much effort on the part of the "voter", and without a personal story or connection to the issue it's easy to disregard the pleasantries as superficial.
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: rklapp on February 14, 2018, 12:16:28 PM
I recommend not starting out with “You lying stinky piles of shit”. Might set the wrong tone.  :D.   :rofl:
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: changemyoil66 on February 14, 2018, 12:41:51 PM
Since they publish the testimonies, I wonder if you attached a pic, they have to publish that also.

My friend handed out resume's right out of college and got no calls.  But when he put his picture on the corner, almost everyone he gave them to (even companies who previously didn't call him back from prior resume) called him.
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: zippz on February 14, 2018, 07:22:08 PM
Another thing you can do is follow my thread

https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=29982.0

and

https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=29599.0
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: hvybarrels on February 15, 2018, 07:16:28 AM
Thanks zippz. Those are great threads and make the legislators seem more like people than slime pit monsters. Although I have to say seeing all those paniolos wear their hats indoors is a little disappointing. Don't know if it's the same here as back west (?) but they should know better.

I'm going to go ahead and repost what you wrote in case someone finds my thread before yours. It's very helpful.

Quote
Writing Testimony

There are guides for writing testimony at http://lrbhawaii.org/par/pub/egtest.pdf and http://lrbhawaii.org/par/pub/tipscomleg.pdf

How to submit testimony online:  http://lrbhawaii.org/par/pub/howtotest.pdf

Tips for testimony:

    Keep it short , concise, and get to the point.  Legislators don't have much time and will go through testimony quickly.  The shorter it is the more likely they'll read it and understand your points.
    Include facts and references.  Attach charts, pictures, court decisions, and other things that get the word across quickly.
    Include your own experiences
    Bring up different points - You don't need 100 people saying CCW is a 2a right.  Instead bring up other things like CCW benefit women more, 13 constitutional carry states, etc.
    Be courteous, no one's going to read scathing remarks.  And the point is for them to read it.
    Word it to someone that doesn't know anything about guns
    Keep it simple and in your own words.  Don't try to be fancy or use a bunch of legal jargon.
    Use bulletpoints and other formatting techniques to make it easier to read.


Forgot to mention you can also make suggestions on how to change or improve the bill.
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: hvybarrels on February 15, 2018, 07:21:30 AM
Oops. I see in the second thread you mentioned the workshops which are still ongoing. I'm definitely interested.

Maybe someone can make a sticky about improving legislative testimony? I'm sure it's something that will keep coming up and it would be great to have a place to point people who have questions or are feeling shy.
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: Tom_G on February 15, 2018, 06:52:40 PM
I haven't bothered writing testimony since I attended my first meeting. Those tater-tots don't read a word of it. There's an announcement: "53 pieces in support, 42 pieces opposing." Boom. That's the attention your carefully-crafted words get. Hell, they don't even listen to the people who testify in person! Go to one of these hearings, sit there and watch the faces of the committee members. If you're saying what they want to hear, they are intent. If you're saying anything else, they're thinking about the color of their new carpet.
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: punaperson on February 15, 2018, 08:22:37 PM
I haven't bothered writing testimony since I attended my first meeting. Those tater-tots don't read a word of it. There's an announcement: "53 pieces in support, 42 pieces opposing." Boom. That's the attention your carefully-crafted words get. Hell, they don't even listen to the people who testify in person! Go to one of these hearings, sit there and watch the faces of the committee members. If you're saying what they want to hear, they are intent. If you're saying anything else, they're thinking about the color of their new carpet.
That was your first mistake... never look at the face or into they eyes of a politician. Nothing good can come of that.  :shaka:
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: hvybarrels on February 26, 2018, 02:11:23 PM
Wow that was depressing. Yeah sometimes it feels like it's going nowhere but then with the trigger mod bill they seemed to listen and actually attempted to change the language a bit. You could look at it from a couple different angles, but I prefer to see it as they have a mandate to do whatever the Democratic National Committee says or face having their careers destroyed. We can't change their minds as to the Yes or No but we do have an effect on the content of what is passed.

Eventually as the DNC continues to fall in popularity (which started when it abandoned working people long ago) then this line of communication could become increasingly useful. It seems like a frustrating waste of time now but we are actually building the bridges of tomorrow, and are already way ahead of the rest of the population as far as political awareness.
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: hvybarrels on February 26, 2018, 02:21:39 PM
Something else I'm going to start doing is including the bill number and a short description inside my testimony and stating clearly that I support or oppose right up front. Had a testimony go down the wrong pipe today which forced me to call the Public Access Room and then a couple committee chairs to get it straightened out. I think it was the result of having too many windows open at the same time and some wires got crossed when I logged back in.

They apparently didn't have too much trouble tracking it down using my email address, but a clear-as-day title showing that it's in the wrong place might really be helpful in case it happens again.
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: rpoL98 on February 26, 2018, 04:18:48 PM
posted above, "Be courteous, no one's going to read scathing remarks."

it's really difficult to not be "scathing" when they treat us with indifference that borders on blatant in-your-face extreme rudeness.  For our elected legislators to totally ignore the voting public seems to be par for the course here in Hawaii?  They're thinking, "well, these are not MY people".  I guess they presume we're too busy reading the surf reports, or doing our recyclables, balancing the checkbook, or some other brainless minion task.

I'm sorry, but I do lose my cool when submitting testimony, but try to wrap it up before I get too hot under the collar for our "representatives".  I mean, I really wish I could lay hellfire and brimstone on them, and strike the fear of god in them, but hey, that's not going to work.  Tune to a different radio channel, yup, they're thinking bout the color of the new carpet in their office.  and besides, aren't we transitioning to a god-less state anyways?

But regardless, I do diligently post testimony for every hearing, revison, SB, HB, sofar.  one of the 300 OPPOSE, I guess.  Hey, Spartacus?

alright, nuff already.
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: hvybarrels on February 27, 2018, 07:53:51 AM
I have a suspicion that we are being trained to be discourteous in order to limit our political effectiveness. The media presents ideas like Muslim or the NRA are pure evil and then sits back and lets us duke it out over the details. Meanwhile they get away with whatever they want.

If all sides could meet and find some common ground about legislative reform, enough to force a constitutional convention, it would be their worst nightmare.

Right now it's a dream job, carpet thoughts and all.
Title: Re: Legislative Testimony Style Guide
Post by: zippz on March 07, 2018, 08:01:56 AM
This is my testimony for the CCW reciprocity opposition resolutions.  It is very important to keep it personal, use past and current experiences, and to include your contact info and address.  Take a different approach from everyone else.  In the first line post your position and summary why.  I've heard the same recommendations by legislators, lobbyists, and even the opposition.  That is what it takes to write effective testimony.  I'm constantly trying to improve my writing each time.





I am OPPOSED to SCR9 because Concealed Carry Weapons is a right everyone should have.

I am a firearms instructor and retired military servicemember with concealed carry weapons permits from Nevada and Arizona. I was able to carry a weapon for self defense while deployed overseas and can currently carry a weapon in many other States on the mainland with my CCW permits which currently have State to State reciprocity over most of the US. I was fortunate that I have never been attacked while overseas or on the mainland. However I was attacked twice here at home in Hawaii. In Kalihi I was carjacked on the road after school one night. In Aiea I was robbed when a gang threatened me with a weapon, assaulted me, and attempted to get my wallet. Fortunately I was able to escape in both situations. I have friends and family who are also afraid of walking alone at night on their way home after work.  I support the carrying of concealed handguns for self-defense and any law abiding person should be able to choose wether to do it or not.

HAWAII DOES NOT ISSUE CCW PERMITS TO THE PUBLIC


The second paragraph in the bill "WHEREAS, the State of Hawaii has allowed the concealed carry of firearm..." is a lie. Hawaii has not issued any Concealed Carry Weapons permits for decades except for a couple that were erroneously issued. Please check with the local police departments and AG so that you can see the statistics for yourself. Or apply for a permit for yourself and see what the process is like. This is a violation of my civil rights. The reasons listed on the bill for denial of permits such as prior criminal history, domestic abuse, physical standards, determination of recklessness, etc are not the reasons used for denial. The HRA conducted a CCW drive where law abiding people applied for permits and none were granted.

THE POLICE WILL NOT ISSUE ANY CCW PERMITS TO THE PUBLIC FOR ANY REASON.

Please make a phone call to each of the police chiefs to ask why they will not issue any permits.

I am OPPOSED to SCR9. Please contact me if you have any questions.


Todd xxxxxxxxx
Phone (808) xxx-xxxxx

xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Aiea, HI 96701