2aHawaii
General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: zippz on March 15, 2018, 08:09:51 PM
-
Sheldon Tyau from Hawaii Historic Arms Assoc told me a story of a a Hawaii sportsmans alliance (or something like that) where all of the gun clubs and businesses came together under one banner to oppose the Hawaii handgun and assault weapons ban in the 1990s. They also put a 2 page newspaper ad with a large list of organizations and also planned a 2a conference with the neighbor islands flying in, but didn't take place.
Anyone familiar with this? I think reforming this is the way to go in the future.
-
Sheldon Tyau?
-
Sheldon Tyau?
Yep
-
I don't remember too much about that because I was preoccupied with kids.
Sorry
-
Can you tell us if there were any favorable results from the alliance? Seems like we still had the AW ban, registration, and mag limits all in the 90's. Or were the laws way worst like how the bump stock bill was way worst until we got involved? I mean no disrespect either, just curious. Because I was in elementary/middle school during this time.
-
Can you tell us if there were any favorable results from the alliance? Seems like we still had the AW ban, registration, and mag limits all in the 90's. Or were the laws way worst like how the bump stock bill was way worst until we got involved? I mean no disrespect either, just curious. Because I was in elementary/middle school during this time.
We got to keep handguns and ar15s. The compromise was handgun training requirements, assault pistol ban, and mag limits.
-
We got to keep handguns and ar15s. The compromise was handgun training requirements, assault pistol ban, and mag limits.
They let us keep handguns? Well, that's mighty white of them.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aNiAOSKFNR4
-
They let us keep handguns? Well, that's mighty white of them.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aNiAOSKFNR4
LOL
Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
-
I've been spending time at the library looking for the coalition newspaper ad in the 1990s. Scrolling through thousands of pages really sucks and takes a lot of time.
It'll be worth it if it helps reforming the Hawaii coalition again.
I found a couple of notable ads by the Jews for the Preservation of Firearms Ownership opposing the assault weapons ban proposed in Hawaii and Congress in 1994.(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20180414/5dfaafd503ef70d26f5612eb5a94be67.jpg)(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20180414/15c77e4ad78252b07d39c0d5c8c39422.jpg)
Sent from my LG-H830 using Tapatalk
-
These ads gave me a great idea for future legislative testimony. Ill print it on a poster and hold it up while I testify. Then ill ask who's in favor of gun control. Epic trolling opportunity.
-
These ads gave me a great idea for future legislative testimony. Ill print it on a poster and hold it up while I testify. Then ill ask who's in favor of gun control. Epic trolling opportunity.
"It can't happen here."
Said many Jews shortly before they were loaded into boxcars destined for the "Arbeit Macht Frei" "work camps".
For example, Auschwitz:
(https://s14-eu5.startpage.com/cgi-bin/serveimage?url=https%3A%2F%2Foneway2day.files.wordpress.com%2F2015%2F01%2Fauschwitz-gate-arbeit-macht-frei_thumb.jpg%3Fw%3D583%26amp%3Bh%3D400&sp=78146c35ea51da554500ea968cbb9e00)
-
"It can't happen here."
Said many Jews shortly before they were loaded into boxcars destined for the "Arbeit Macht Frei" "work camps".
For example, Auschwitz:
(https://s14-eu5.startpage.com/cgi-bin/serveimage?url=https%3A%2F%2Foneway2day.files.wordpress.com%2F2015%2F01%2Fauschwitz-gate-arbeit-macht-frei_thumb.jpg%3Fw%3D583%26amp%3Bh%3D400&sp=78146c35ea51da554500ea968cbb9e00)
Gun owners in Hawaii are registered, and already targeted.
Were it not for the fact they can't even do day to day operations
efficiently you would find a law disarming the public being passed.
If they could they would hunt you down and take your guns away.
It is the Hawaiian government way, only one party runs this state.
But they don't have enough money, the jails are already full, and we
know where the cops live, so we get to pretend we have rights.
-
The problem with these ads featuring Nazi rhetoric and examples is that
1) there are no legitimate sources to cite where Hitler ever said anything about gun registration, and the ones that are referenced have been proven to be falsely attributed to Hitler or complete frauds, similar to the "behind every blade of grass" quote attributed to Yamamoto, which is now believed to come from MacArthur.
2) gun restrictions, and ultimately prohibition and confiscation, were implemented by the Weimar Republic, not the Nazis. Laws were passed in January of 1919, essentially banning the possession of all firearms, of which was then increased in severity after the Treaty of Versailles, and were law until 1928,when restrictions were relaxed and licensing/registration protocols were put into place. Therefore, it is far more justifiable that the victors in WWI are responsible for what happened to gun ownership, the rise of Hitler and ultimately the Jews being unable to protect themselves, as we implemented the harsh requirements and stipulations of the Treaty of Versailles that inspired The harsh gun laws in the Weimar Republic, which did nothing to stop the Nazis taking power and everything that happened after.
Its important to be sure that the information you put out is correct. This issue of believing and promoting false propaganda is as much an issue for the pro-gun community as it is for the antis
-
I didnt know about the pre Nazi gun restrictions. The Nazis, along with Hitler at the helm, would still bear responsibility since they continued to ban and confiscate guns for Jews and other citizens for the purpose of rising to power and killing off the Jews.
I don't think Jews owning guns would have changed much though since most of them were conned into going to the death camps. If the Jews knew they were going to get slaughtered when the Nazi party took over then I'm sure they wouldve had an armed rebellion.
I think the ad is still accurate and serves as a lesson to not start down the gun control path or unexpected things can happen.
-
I didnt know about the pre Nazi gun restrictions. The Nazis, along with Hitler at the helm, would still bear responsibility since they continued to ban and confiscate guns for Jews and other citizens for the purpose of rising to power and killing off the Jews.
I don't think Jews owning guns would have changed much though since most of them were conned into going to the death camps. If the Jews knew they were going to get slaughtered when the Nazi party took over then I'm sure they wouldve had an armed rebellion.
I think the ad is still accurate and serves as a lesson to not start down the gun control path or unexpected things can happen.
I don't understand that logic. If Hitler didn't implement gun restriction to begin with, how can you blame him for gun laws already in place?
The problem with the ad is that it is inaccurate and misleading, and knowledgeable opponents will call you out on it and use it to justify the the notion that you are spreading propaganda. If you want an idea to have lasting effect and significant impact, it needs to be irrefutable factually, so that no one can prove you wrong.
-
I don't understand that logic. If Hitler didn't implement gun restriction to begin with, how can you blame him for gun laws already in place?
The problem with the ad is that it is inaccurate and misleading, and knowledgeable opponents will call you out on it and use it to justify the the notion that you are spreading propaganda. If you want an idea to have lasting effect and significant impact, it needs to be irrefutable factually, so that no one can prove you wrong.
The same way Trump is being blamed for prohibited people getting guns and committing mass murder even though many of the problems with FBI. NICS, and lack of laws requiring states to report prohibitive information to the FBI could have been fixed under Obama's watch. In fact, after Sandy Hook, all of these problems were studied and reported on. There were Congressional hearings. There were attempts to enact another AWB on steroids.
If something was implemented under the previous regime, and the current regime allows the status quo to remain as is, they share in the consequences. Hitler's admin could have easily relaxed restriction on gun ownership -- even encouraged ownership -- if he thought it would have made Germany stronger.
-
I don't understand that logic. If Hitler didn't implement gun restriction to begin with, how can you blame him for gun laws already in place?
The problem with the ad is that it is inaccurate and misleading, and knowledgeable opponents will call you out on it and use it to justify the the notion that you are spreading propaganda. If you want an idea to have lasting effect and significant impact, it needs to be irrefutable factually, so that no one can prove you wrong.
Can be viewed different ways
-
The same way Trump is being blamed for prohibited people getting guns and committing mass murder even though many of the problems with FBI. NICS, and lack of laws requiring states to report prohibitive information to the FBI could have been fixed under Obama's watch. In fact, after Sandy Hook, all of these problems were studied and reported on. There were Congressional hearings. There were attempts to enact another AWB on steroids.
If something was implemented under the previous regime, and the current regime allows the status quo to remain as is, they share in the consequences. Hitler's admin could have easily relaxed restriction on gun ownership -- even encouraged ownership -- if he thought it would have made Germany stronger.
But as you stated, Trump isn't responsible for the laws; he failed to act differently or disregard laws and policies implemented before he took office.
The ads zippz is referencing implies that Hitler enacted gun restriction and confiscation, which is in fact false, as those laws were already in place long before he ever took power. Further more, he did nothing illegal with regard to the anti-gun policies that he carried over, as they were justified and legal laws that were voted on, passed and implemented by both the Weimar Republic and the League of Nations (via the Treaty of Versailles).
So again, if blame needs to be placed on anyone, it needs to be placed on those responsible for implementing the policy that prevented the common people from having the ability to stop what the Nazis did before they assumed power.
Also, of course Hitler wouldn't implement policy that would allow the populace to rise up against his government. The reason why the Weimar Republic (and ultimately the League of Nations) passed those laws was precisely to prevent the same thing as they wanted to ensure the German people had no way to resist the malicious policies being imposed upon them, which ironically was the major catalyst for the Nazis to obtain power.
-
I start with,
I do not violate any constitutional federal, state, or local laws.
But if you register your guns you are an idiot
that will be processed.
-
But as you stated, Trump isn't responsible for the laws; he failed to act differently or disregard laws and policies implemented before he took office.
The ads zippz is referencing implies that Hitler enacted gun restriction and confiscation, which is in fact false, as those laws were already in place long before he ever took power. Further more, he did nothing illegal with regard to the anti-gun policies that he carried over, as they were justified and legal laws that were voted on, passed and implemented by both the Weimar Republic and the League of Nations (via the Treaty of Versailles).
So again, if blame needs to be placed on anyone, it needs to be placed on those responsible for implementing the policy that prevented the common people from having the ability to stop what the Nazis did before they assumed power.
Also, of course Hitler wouldn't implement policy that would allow the populace to rise up against his government. The reason why the Weimar Republic (and ultimately the League of Nations) passed those laws was precisely to prevent the same thing as they wanted to ensure the German people had no way to resist the malicious policies being imposed upon them, which ironically was the major catalyst for the Nazis to obtain power.
Great points! You got it. I like your assertiveness and attention to detail. I want you on my coalition team. Meeting this Wed 6pm at Brewseum. See you there.
-
Haven't found the ad yet. Supposed to be a full spread ad. Sigh.
I did find more info behind the 1994 Hawaii handgun ban. It came down to the wire in conference committee. Almost banned handguns....or almost failed. These things can happen when people don't do anything.
(https://i.imgur.com/b6ThFZL.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/ZwljW69.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/LNMkm3L.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/sGiePnd.jpg)
(https://i.imgur.com/PjCJtyG.jpg)
-
“Germans who wish to use firearms should join the SS or the SA -- ordinary citizens don't need guns, as their having guns doesn't serve the State.”
― Heinrich Himmler
-
“Germans who wish to use firearms should join the SS or the SA -- ordinary citizens don't need guns, as their having guns doesn't serve the State.”
― Heinrich Himmler
This is another perfect example of an unverified quote being attributed to an individual and being used as propaganda.
There is no verified source or cited work that confirms Himmler ever said this. In fact, of all the controversial quotes attributed to Himmler, this is literally the only one that is disputed.
-
Interesting article I found in a magazine. Could use some of these groups here to build up our base.
(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20180415/3d7cc5b768a76830d222372134568d73.jpg)
-
After 6 hours of searching I finally found it in the advertiser!(https://uploads.tapatalk-cdn.com/20180421/25edfafec019128a9ed526a45179de4a.jpg)
Sent from my LG-H830 using Tapatalk
-
I went to the State Archives office today (https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=29982.40) and pulled some old bills. The handgun ban and the $1,000 handgun tax bills.
-
If they were going to ban all handguns, did the NRA-ILA get involved or any other org? Seems like we gave up a lot, just to keep something that would not have been banned or major lawsuits and the ban overturned.
-
If they were going to ban all handguns, did the NRA-ILA get involved or any other org? Seems like we gave up a lot, just to keep something that would not have been banned or major lawsuits and the ban overturned.
Would have to look up the old testimonies which I wanted to do, but would've taken too long. The handgun ban was very close to taking effect. The original bill introduced banned all possession of handguns and existing ones would've been confiscated, but was later amended for grandfathering. It could've been like Washington DC, who had their handgun ban since 1975, and we wouldn't have been able to own handguns from 1994 to 2008 until the Heller case.
-
Talked to Allan Gotlieb pres of SAF and he was intrigued by the coalition and said that Sam Slim was on their board. Also got info on NRA club affiliation. Looking good.