2aHawaii

General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: drck1000 on April 05, 2018, 07:54:20 AM

Title: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on April 05, 2018, 07:54:20 AM
Going with a 14.5" barrel on a new(er) AR and looking at muzzle devices.   So far, I've narrowed down to the BC 1.5, Precision Armament AFAB and VG6 Epsilon.  All of those were in that article from TTAB and all performed pretty well and about what I was looking for.  Open to other suggestions as well.

I have a BC 1.0 on one gun, but the rest of my ARs have the A2.  I don't have a problem with the A2, but if I'm going to pin/weld something, I decided to go with a comp.  I like the BC, but I also think that there's gotta be newer/better out there. 

Other devices that I considered include the BCM Comp and one from SLR Rifleworks.  The SLR is still in consideration and most likely going with that one for my AK. 

I've shot friend's guns with the FSC and Surefire, but not really considering any of those right now. 
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 05, 2018, 08:50:41 AM
If youtube still has it, there are comparisons done with some comps.  They fire and draw the "line" and play in slow-mo to see the recoil.

When I was looking, I chose the VG6 Gamma over the Epsilon.  I forgot the reason why I chose the Gamma over Epsilon.  But it must have been for a good reason.

I learned at a HDF carbine class that the Gamma kicks up a lot of dirt when shooting from the bottom portion of the VTAC board.  Like gotta wait a 1-2 seconds between shots to let the dust settle because I can't see.  So that might be a factor also.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on April 05, 2018, 09:13:28 AM
If youtube still has it, there are comparisons done with some comps.  They fire and draw the "line" and play in slow-mo to see the recoil.

When I was looking, I chose the VG6 Gamma over the Epsilon.  I forgot the reason why I chose the Gamma over Epsilon.  But it must have been for a good reason.

I learned at a HDF carbine class that the Gamma kicks up a lot of dirt when shooting from the bottom portion of the VTAC board.  Like gotta wait a 1-2 seconds between shots to let the dust settle because I can't see.  So that might be a factor also.
I believe the Gamma is more of a brake (resists recoil impulse) and the Epsilon is more of a comp (muzzle rise).  From that TTAG study, seems like they both performed well.  I considered the Gamma as well. 

For the issue with kicking up dirt, assume you were shooting with the gun rotated about 90 degrees.  Yeah, I experienced that with my gun with the BC on it too.  Nature of comps and brakes.  I prefer the bottom of the muzzle device being closed off, but it's not like I shoot in prone very often. 
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: mangosteenqueen on April 05, 2018, 09:23:35 AM
Just shot with my SureFire warcomp CTN for a quick range session recently but I didn’t get around to doing prone or urban prone but the noise seemed low and the muzzle was pretty tamed and didn’t notice flash and the bottom of the device is closed off so I wasn’t worried if it would kick up dirt in the prone anyway, although I was using a H1 buffer on a 16” middy upper.
Really looking at the AFAB too for my other AR, I’ve heard it’s a well balanced hybrid device.

Is it me or the BCM comp seems overrated according to other forums? I don’t have any experience with one but that’s what I’m getting out of the comments from there.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: rklapp on April 05, 2018, 09:26:31 AM
If youtube still has it, there are comparisons done with some comps.  They fire and draw the "line" and play in slow-mo to see the recoil.
After watching several of these videos, I didn't see a correlation between expensive and cheap compensators using the parameters they used.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on April 05, 2018, 09:38:06 AM
Just shot with my SureFire warcomp CTN for a quick range session recently but I didn’t get around to doing prone or urban prone but the noise seemed low and the muzzle was pretty tamed and didn’t notice flash and the bottom of the device is closed off so I wasn’t worried if it would kick up dirt in the prone anyway, although I was using a H1 buffer on a 16” middy upper.
Really looking at the AFAB too for my other AR, I’ve heard it’s a well balanced hybrid device.

Is it me or the BCM comp seems overrated according to other forums? I don’t have any experience with one but that’s what I’m getting out of the comments from there.
Never really looked into that Surefire and others that are suppressor adapters.  I'd absolutely LOVE to have suppressors for one or two of my ARs, but. . .

When I'm shooting, I don't notice the difference in noise very much.  Even with the louder ones like the PWS, Miculek, etc.  However, when someone is shooting my gun on the range and I'm outside about 45 degrees either side behind them, or shooting next to someone on a firing line, I can tell.  With the real loud ones, I can feel it in that jaw joint.  Haha.

Yeah, I noticed that about the BCM comp, I have read a lot of meh comments.  I was initially interested as it was billed as an effective flash hider with compensation, but seems like it's not that much more effective than the A2.  I mean I am fine with the A2.  I have that on a couple guns that I've shot in competition and training and I don't feel super behind the curve.  I mean, yeah, guns with brakes and comps could help for sure, but it's not to the level that I felt a comp was essential.  I really wanted to try a gun with it, but since I'm going pinned on this gun, I decided against. 
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: TubbsMcGee on April 05, 2018, 09:57:43 AM
I was looking at the EFAB as a hybrid, I've read good things. I could be wrong but it is my understanding that the AFAB is very similar to the EFAB, except the EFAB performs slightly better (also $50 more). Slightly off topic but is it extremely hard to replace a pin/welded muzzle device with another? I have a rifle coming in with a Surefire SF3P and am thinking about replacing it with the EFAB if it's not too difficult (gonna have a shop do it).
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 05, 2018, 09:57:50 AM
After watching several of these videos, I didn't see a correlation between expensive and cheap compensators using the parameters they used.

Yup, that's why the Gamma is cheap and gets the job done.  That was also a factor.  The Mrs. was looking at the Tactical Advantage Armory the anodized ones that run $300 just cause they look cool.  She got a dragon slayer from Dexter instead from the gun show last year.

The Gamma is loud to those around you, but not  yourself.  I've had guys ask me "eh, what you shooting over there?" at the range.  IDK if as loud as the Lantac Dragon.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: mangosteenqueen on April 05, 2018, 10:01:58 AM
Yeah it was a bit of an afterthought for me when it came to the price (it is a bit pricey, about $150). At the time I was going for a hybrid device that worked well and came across the warcomp ctn, which was basically a long A2 flash hider with some precision drilled holes on the top...etc.
I don’t hate it because it works effectively as a hybrid device, but it’s not entirely worth the price unless Hawaii finally becomes suppressor friendly.
.
Either way it’s much better than the J-Comp V2 I was previously using which had quite a blast out to the sides and not so hearing safe.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on April 05, 2018, 10:28:24 AM
I was looking at the EFAB as a hybrid, I've read good things. I could be wrong but it is my understanding that the AFAB is very similar to the EFAB, except the EFAB performs slightly better (also $50 more). Slightly off topic but is it extremely hard to replace a pin/welded muzzle device with another? I have a rifle coming in with a Surefire SF3P and am thinking about replacing it with the EFAB if it's not too difficult (gonna have a shop do it).
Yeah, I read about the EFAB too.  While not beyond what I could spend, the $50 does make the AFAB much more attractive.  Especially when you have to add the $25-30 for their washer kit. 

No personal experience about how difficult to remove a pinned/welded muzzle device, but I've heard that it's not that big of a deal.  Also not that big of a deal to do properly (and not mess up the barrel) by competent folks.  While most "home gunsmiths" can't do themselves, it's not like I change my muzzle devices often.  For me, I don't really change them up. 
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on April 05, 2018, 12:29:49 PM
Been watching some videos at lunch.  Less interested in the VG6 Epsilon now.  Liked the reviews of the AFAB and EFAB that I saw.  Between those two, probably the AFAB.  Since I already have a gun with a BC, thinking AFAB.

I'd like to shoot the SLR Synergy comp on an AR.  Not that many reviews online.  Probably not that much difference, but just one of those things where I'd like to try them side-by-side. 
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: rklapp on April 05, 2018, 12:42:54 PM
Easy...   :rofl:

(https://www.easy-do-it-yourself-home-improvements.com/images/xsoldering-copper-pipe.jpg.pagespeed.ic.N1hDty5ooE.jpg)
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on April 05, 2018, 12:44:17 PM
In my opinion, the AR-15 has such low recoil/muzzle-flip to start with, a brake seems like total overkill.

I like the AAC flash hider.  It's hard to find one that reduces muzzle flash better that that design.  Since it's creation, there are many others using a similar 3-prong design.

The AAC Blackout 51T was developed to complement the AAC Blackout rifle.  With subsonic ammo and a low flash device, a suppressor does a better job of noise reduction.  The 51T comes with threads for a suppressor to fit right on the device.

Even without the suppressor, the flash hider almost completely eliminates any flash from an AR-15.  I have this on several rifles, because I figured I would need less flash in Hawaii where suppressors are forbidden.  The 3-prong design means you don't have to index it for upward exhaust to reduce dirt blasts.  I have mine with one prong at the 6 o'clock position, but I don't think that really matters.  Gas will be exhausted evenly out of all 3 gaps between the prongs.

https://youtu.be/YlyisaKGUVg
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: mangosteenqueen on April 05, 2018, 12:56:45 PM
I think A2 birdcage works just fine over the 3 prong, not that it kills flash more effectively than the 3 prong but it eliminates your dust signature when you shoot prone in the dirt because the bottom of the device is closed off and the birdcage design doesn’t allow snagging.

Adams arms makes a extended A2 flash hider that you can pin and weld to a 14.5” barrel but the diameter of the flash hider is also small enough so that you can slide any gas block over it if you ever so decide that you need to change your gas block to something better or different. https://www.adamsarms.net/vdi-manimal-extended-flash-hider (https://www.adamsarms.net/vdi-manimal-extended-flash-hider)
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on April 05, 2018, 01:31:57 PM
In my opinion, the AR-15 has such low recoil/muzzle-flip to start with, a brake seems like total overkill.

I like the AAC flash hider.  It's hard to find one that reduces muzzle flash better that that design.  Since it's creation, there are many others using a similar 3-prong design.

The AAC Blackout 51T was developed to complement the AAC Blackout rifle.  With subsonic ammo and a low flash device, a suppressor does a better job of noise reduction.  The 51T comes with threads for a suppressor to fit right on the device.

Even without the suppressor, the flash hider almost completely eliminates any flash from an AR-15.  I have this on several rifles, because I figured I would need less flash in Hawaii where suppressors are forbidden.  The 3-prong design means you don't have to index it for upward exhaust to reduce dirt blasts.  I have mine with one prong at the 6 o'clock position, but I don't think that really matters.  Gas will be exhausted evenly out of all 3 gaps between the prongs.


The recoil impulse in 5.56 doesn't bother me.  Even the muzzle rise, I can deal with good stance and grip.  However, I do notice a difference with a comp with my shooting and anything that helps, well, helps.  I'm just fine with an A2, but just decided to go with a comp on this one. 

There are also times when one can't have good stance and grip, such as improvised shooting positions, where stuff like brakes and comps can help.  I personally don't care for brakes, but I do think that comps and even hybrid comps help my shooting. 
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on April 05, 2018, 01:35:47 PM
I think A2 birdcage works just fine over the 3 prong, not that it kills flash more effectively than the 3 prong but it eliminates your dust signature when you shoot prone in the dirt because the bottom of the device is closed off and the birdcage design doesn’t allow snagging.

Adams arms makes a extended A2 flash hider that you can pin and weld to a 14.5” barrel but the diameter of the flash hider is also small enough so that you can slide any gas block over it if you ever so decide that you need to change your gas block to something better or different. https://www.adamsarms.net/vdi-manimal-extended-flash-hider (https://www.adamsarms.net/vdi-manimal-extended-flash-hider)
I'm not really one to change things much.  Just somehow the pinning/welding is making me think a little bit more. 

I haven't really shot many guns with the longer three-prong flash hider.  However, I have seen the fireballs that come out of brakes like the Lantac and I think one of the JP models.  At a low-light part of a course, one guy had a bare muzzle AR.  I swear that thing shot out a long skinny flame like 2-3 feet!  Could often even see it in the daylight. 
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 05, 2018, 01:44:24 PM
I thought about the flash hider vs. break when I first looked to upgrade the AR.  Took me a while also because both have their pros and cons.

But then thought to myself, I don't see me having to shoot from concealment at night, unless Red Dawn happens.  And by then I'll either be shooting a milspec AR or an AK recovered from an invading soldier.

I did notice the reduction for the red dot remaining on target (POA).  Shot at an indoor range and at 10 yards, the A2 was about 6 inches between shots fired (muzzle rising then coming back at original POA).  With the Gamma, 2 inches.  But this was also a stock M&P15.  Now I got a front grip and other goodies.

I've never shot an AR with nothing screwed into the barrel.  I did drive a Subaru Impreza with no headers.  Sounded like a bubble machine during idle (blub, blub, blub, blub) and a damn dragon when pressing the gas (raaaawwwwrrrrrrrrrr).  Louder than a Harley.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: mangosteenqueen on April 05, 2018, 04:33:33 PM
I'm not really one to change things much.  Just somehow the pinning/welding is making me think a little bit more. 

I haven't really shot many guns with the longer three-prong flash hider.  However, I have seen the fireballs that come out of brakes like the Lantac and I think one of the JP models.  At a low-light part of a course, one guy had a bare muzzle AR.  I swear that thing shot out a long skinny flame like 2-3 feet!  Could often even see it in the daylight.

InrangeTV is running the extended a2 birdcage (for legality reasons too) on their 14.5” “what would Stoner do?” ARs and it seemed to do them just fine. Not saying that the a2 is the way to go if you want some kind of extra to mitigate recoil/muzzle rise, but it’s an option. I haven’t researched the AFAB enough to see if it’s perfect but I know sometimes you can find good data by eating videos of people shooting with the AFAB in the dirt or whatever but not reviewing it. I can tell you one guy did a pretty good review and demonstration on the warcomp CTN https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=9DXNRZiJvps (https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=9DXNRZiJvps) since the warcomp is a contender for a hybrid device long enough to fit on a 14.5.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: Surf on April 05, 2018, 07:48:33 PM
If I were to guess, I probably have somewhere north of $2.5K in just muzzle devices.  I run an AFAB on two rifles and Randy runs one on his primary rifle.  A few of our guys run them also and I would suggest the AFAB.

For those that don't see the benefit of a brake or a compensator, they don't have the same needs as others, or they are not at the ragged edge of performance where hundreds or tenths make a difference.  Not just benefitted by recoil management, but transitional speeds benefit greatly at high levels.  There is a reason you don't see a professional world class shooter not having one.  If that isn't your goals, then an A2 is about one of the best at what it does.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: mauiblue on April 05, 2018, 08:16:51 PM
I got the nastiest and loudest muzzle brake (Miculek) I could find at the time I was shopping around for one and was pleasantly surprised at recoil control. Plus I could chased off all the guys that was shooting next to me that had muzzle brakes on their hunting rifles. Ha! Damn Miculek muzzle brake is fricking nuts LOUD!
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: mangosteenqueen on April 05, 2018, 08:31:26 PM
I got the nastiest and loudest muzzle brake (Miculek) I could find at the time I was shopping around for one and was pleasantly surprised at recoil control. Plus I could chased off all the guys that was shooting next to me that had muzzle brakes on their hunting rifles. Ha! Damn Miculek muzzle brake is fricking nuts LOUD!

It’s a 3-gun muzzle brake, where you can care less about your shooting neighbors cuz all you want is performance in controlling the muzzle and recoil
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on April 05, 2018, 08:46:30 PM
I’ve shot next to the Miculek and a couple of the JP ones. Those were loud and rattled my teeth.  :o  ;D
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: zippz on April 05, 2018, 08:49:17 PM
How are muzzle brakes for real world use?  I haven't seen any military or law enforcement use them except for 50 cal.  Wondering if they blast is extreme like when fired in a hallway or in the dark or kicking up dust in the prone.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: rpoL98 on April 05, 2018, 08:53:24 PM
I thought the PA M4-72 did pretty good in the TTAG reviews, but serious concussive blast generator.  I like the LANTAC for barrels that are being shortened in addition to P&W because it's longer than 2.5", I tell the gunsmith to make it come out to 16.1".  The M4-72 works out perfectly for 14.5" barrels.  depends on the handguard length also, and whether I want the max recoil reduction (M4-72), minimal muzzle rise.  The M4-72 puts more residue on anything within 3-5" behind the muzzle.  I also use the VG6 Epsilon as a lower-cost alternative.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 05, 2018, 08:57:16 PM
How are muzzle brakes for real world use?  I haven't seen any military or law enforcement use them except for 50 cal.  Wondering if they blast is extreme like when fired in a hallway or in the dark or kicking up dust in the prone.
Next range day if u wanna shoot mine prone, u can. Bring face wipes.

Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on April 05, 2018, 09:01:14 PM
If I were to guess, I probably have somewhere north of $2.5K in just muzzle devices.  I run an AFAB on two rifles and Randy runs one on his primary rifle.  A few of our guys run them also and I would suggest the AFAB.

For those that don't see the benefit of a brake or a compensator, they don't have the same needs as others, or they are not at the ragged edge of performance where hundreds or tenths make a difference.  Not just benefitted by recoil management, but transitional speeds benefit greatly at high levels.  There is a reason you don't see a professional world class shooter not having one.  If that isn't your goals, then an A2 is about one of the best at what it does.
When I started shooting ARs, I was “taught” that A2 is all that you need and learn to shoot better by technique over technology. That was ingrained for many years. As I got to training with others and competing, I saw the benefits of comps and brakes. Eventually found that I preferred comps, like the BC. Then I sort of took a break from any real interest in tinkering with my ARs. Got the big again for sure.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: zippz on April 05, 2018, 09:01:49 PM
Next range day if u wanna shoot mine prone, u can. Bring face wipes.

Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk

I'll take you up on that, I don't think I've fired a rifle with a muzzle brake.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on April 05, 2018, 09:07:39 PM
How are muzzle brakes for real world use?  I haven't seen any military or law enforcement use them except for 50 cal.  Wondering if they blast is extreme like when fired in a hallway or in the dark or kicking up dust in the prone.
Maybe depends on department. A buddy in Houston PD is allowed quite a bit as long as he qualifies with it. His duty rifle has a KAC comp. Another is in Seattle and they share duty rifles that they need to sign out of a central Armory. Those are about as vanilla as you’ll find.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: Surf on April 05, 2018, 09:28:34 PM
I got the nastiest and loudest muzzle brake (Miculek) I could find at the time I was shopping around for one and was pleasantly surprised at recoil control. Plus I could chased off all the guys that was shooting next to me that had muzzle brakes on their hunting rifles. Ha! Damn Miculek muzzle brake is fricking nuts LOUD!
Yes, the Miculek is obnoxious.  The most effective that I own is the SJC Titan.  If I were to compete full time, the SJC Titan would be my choice, but it is also one of THE loudest.  I also run several Surefire's and they are very offensive also.  If it is highly effective, it is going to be a teeth-rattler and ear piercer.  I rarely shoot any of these and several are not even mounted on rifles anymore.

How are muzzle brakes for real world use?  I haven't seen any military or law enforcement use them except for 50 cal.  Wondering if they blast is extreme like when fired in a hallway or in the dark or kicking up dust in the prone.
While the best world would be suppressors, I see devices used quite a bit in LE, depending on policy of course.  Work in a team environment with SBR's and devices in shoothouses all the time.  Don't really notice it, too focused.  Most guys are.  Let's not forget that a muzzle device is nowhere near as loud/concussive as a 4-6 or 8-gram, flashbang or a frag grenade in a similar enclosed environment, even if you are on the other side of the threshold.  Guys who complain about this, I question their actual experiences, or they have very different ones from me.

Darkness, over-rated topic, unless if it is an absolute flame-thrower or a complete smoke wagon.  Dust and debris when prone can be legit.  Most of this means you need to pick a sensible hybrid option.     
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: TubbsMcGee on April 05, 2018, 10:26:59 PM
If I were to guess, I probably have somewhere north of $2.5K in just muzzle devices.  I run an AFAB on two rifles and Randy runs one on his primary rifle.  A few of our guys run them also and I would suggest the AFAB.

For those that don't see the benefit of a brake or a compensator, they don't have the same needs as others, or they are not at the ragged edge of performance where hundreds or tenths make a difference.  Not just benefitted by recoil management, but transitional speeds benefit greatly at high levels.  There is a reason you don't see a professional world class shooter not having one.  If that isn't your goals, then an A2 is about one of the best at what it does.

Curious as to why the AFAB over the EFAB? Was it just the price difference or was the performance vs price not worth the extra $50?
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: aieahound on April 05, 2018, 11:11:27 PM
Check out the goguns brake

https://gogunusa.com/collections/supercomp-no-talon-rifle-brakes

Works well.
I got a pin and welded 14.5 with a A2 though.

Just cause a 14.5 shouldn't be broken    ;)
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: mauiblue on April 06, 2018, 07:54:42 PM


<snip>Wondering if they blast is extreme like when fired in a hallway or in the dark or kicking up dust in the prone.

I would not even think about using my Miculek equipped AR-15 in an enclosed area. My eyes would burst from the blast concussion.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: sa594 on April 07, 2018, 07:56:02 PM
Also have the SJC Titan comp, great at keeping muzzle flat but extremely loud. I had a chance to shoot with it at the indoor range and it turned quite a bit of heads, great for quick follow up shots but bad news for others around you. Had to order a shim kit to get mine properly aligned/timed.
Just ordered the Fortis RED for my latest build, read good reviews so figured I'd give it a try. Haven't tested it out yet but hopefully soon
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: rklapp on April 08, 2018, 12:25:28 AM
I agree with FJ that it's not necessary for an AR-15 but seems that the 1/2-28 is the most available style on the market. I guess it just means that AR-15 owners are more apt to mod their rifles than other platforms.

Had to look it up.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wXgSOUnIBtU
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: Surf on April 08, 2018, 10:35:46 AM
I agree with FJ that it's not necessary for an AR-15 but seems that the 1/2-28 is the most available style on the market. I guess it just means that AR-15 owners are more apt to mod their rifles than other platforms.
Compensators are lost on most recreational shooters or perhaps unnecessary.  If a shooters skill level is not maxed or nearly maxed out the benefit of the compensator is not as nearly apparent.  Most people who shoot at KKHD on the topside will see zero benefits and will experience all of the negatives.  Even many on the lower side don't have the skills to outrun the A2 or the needs that may necessitate compensation. 

At a certain level of skill, especially in competition, it becomes an equipment race where winning and losing is equated in hundredths of seconds.  This is not just restricted to competition, there are great benefits of compensation or suppression in defensive or tactical environments as well.       
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on April 08, 2018, 12:41:46 PM
I agree with FJ that it's not necessary for an AR-15 but seems that the 1/2-28 is the most available style on the market. I guess it just means that AR-15 owners are more apt to mod their rifles than other platforms.

Had to look it up.

What does availability of 1/2-28 have to do with necessity of a muzzle device?

From what I can tell from your posts, you’re a bench shooter who enjoys the misadventures of loading your own ammo. For your style of shooting, a bare muzzle would suit you just fine.

I don’t really care to tinker much with my guns. While I appreciate skill required to shoot with precision, my shooting with ARs are for training and competition. As Surf mentioned above, comps and brakes indeed can help in those regards. I haven’t shot A2 and comps side by side in a while, but I do notice a benefit, particularly in shot splits.

I kinda see your point in that many folks into ARs really enjoys trying various stuff, mods for the sake of modding, etc.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: rklapp on April 08, 2018, 01:50:57 PM
What does availability of 1/2-28 have to do with necessity of a muzzle device?
From what I can tell from your posts, you’re a bench shooter who enjoys the misadventures of loading your own ammo. For your style of shooting, a bare muzzle would suit you just fine.
I don’t really care to tinker much with my guns. While I appreciate skill required to shoot with precision, my shooting with ARs are for training and competition. As Surf mentioned above, comps and brakes indeed can help in those regards. I haven’t shot A2 and comps side by side in a while, but I do notice a benefit, particularly in shot splits.
I kinda see your point in that many folks into ARs really enjoys trying various stuff, mods for the sake of modding, etc.
Agreed. My rhetorical question is why are there so many 5.56 muzzle brakes available if they are mostly unnecessary as compared to an AK for example. I had Dexter thread a muzzle brake on my VEPR but resisting the urge to do so on my AR bull barrel. The main reason why I use a brake is so the blast doesn't affect the chrono. My Mosin almost destroyed the chrono, but the nice people at Caldwell sent me replacement parts for free. I tried one of those muzzle attachments but didn't stay for long.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on April 08, 2018, 02:42:37 PM
Agreed. My rhetorical question is why are there so many 5.56 muzzle brakes available if they are mostly unnecessary as compared to an AK for example. I had Dexter thread a muzzle brake on my VEPR but resisting the urge to do so on my AR bull barrel. The main reason why I use a brake is so the blast doesn't affect the chrono. My Mosin almost destroyed the chrono, but the nice people at Caldwell sent me replacement parts for free. I tried one of those muzzle attachments but didn't stay for long.
Your use of brakes are definitely unconventional. I guess that somehow makes sense in your mind. Not surprised. Anyways, your opinion of unnessary is relative to your shooting needs. Are 400 hp engines necessary? Well, it depends on your needs and wants. Like with many performance based elements, it definitely can help, but maybe only truly appreciated by some.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: ren on April 08, 2018, 03:55:29 PM
Agreed. My rhetorical question is why are there so many 5.56 muzzle brakes available if they are mostly unnecessary as compared to an AK for example. I had Dexter thread a muzzle brake on my VEPR but resisting the urge to do so on my AR bull barrel. The main reason why I use a brake is so the blast doesn't affect the chrono. My Mosin almost destroyed the chrono, but the nice people at Caldwell sent me replacement parts for free. I tried one of those muzzle attachments but didn't stay for long.
Your chrono is too close if it affects your readings.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: dogman on April 08, 2018, 04:18:59 PM
I agree with FJ that it's not necessary for an AR-15 but seems that the 1/2-28 is the most available style on the market. I guess it just means that AR-15 owners are more apt to mod their rifles than other platforms.
I don't participate in any competitions but when shooting an AR-15 platform 223/556 at HDF Range Days and certain HRA/LIFE Fun Shoots, there may often be a timer on you and that is when I realize the benefits of having a muzzle brake. When I shoot 223/556 at the Rifle range my AR has an unthreaded bull barrel.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: rklapp on April 08, 2018, 04:37:49 PM
Your chrono is too close if it affects your readings.
Yes, the problem with KHSC is that the far left tables are too short for me and prone is problematic. Some day I'll get a magnetospeed but saving up for a better scope.


I don't participate in any competitions but when shooting an AR-15 platform 223/556 at HDF Range Days and certain HRA/LIFE Fun Shoots, there may often be a timer on you and that is when I realize the benefits of having a muzzle brake. When I shoot 223/556 at the Rifle range my AR has an unthreaded bull barrel.
That makes sense.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on April 08, 2018, 06:06:57 PM
I don't participate in any competitions but when shooting an AR-15 platform 223/556 at HDF Range Days and certain HRA/LIFE Fun Shoots, there may often be a timer on you and that is when I realize the benefits of having a muzzle brake. When I shoot 223/556 at the Rifle range my AR has an unthreaded bull barrel.
We’ve done multiple shots with HRA/LIFE and I would like to get to multiple targets.  That’s where I notice where the comp helps me cut down the times. The VTAC 1-5 is a pretty well known one that combines both.

And when the timer is out and you’re shooting with friends (other shooters), you’re competiting.   ;D
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 10, 2018, 09:27:26 AM
We’ve done multiple shots with HRA/LIFE and I would like to get to multiple targets.  That’s where I notice where the comp helps me cut down the times. The VTAC 1-5 is a pretty well known one that combines both.

And when the timer is out and you’re shooting with friends (other shooters), you’re competiting.   ;D

At the HDF carbine class, my wife shot the VTAC board faster than me.  I guess when  you're using free ammo, you can spray and pray more.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on April 11, 2018, 08:56:02 AM
AFAB is on it's way.  Ordered the SLR Rifleworks Synergy Comp 5.56 for another gun (non-pinned).  Looking forward to trying both.  Will be able to compare with BC.  Though the gas systems and overall weights of guns will be different, should be a fun comparison. 
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on April 30, 2018, 01:29:44 PM
Was able to shoot ARs with both the AFAB and SLR Synergy comp this past weekend.  Wasn't able to really see the benefits of either as I was mostly concentrating on zeroing the red dots on both, but it was a good opportunity to evaluate them both.

AFAB is on Colt 14.5" carbine gas upper with BCM KMR rail and EoTech EXPS 3-0.  Probably one of my lightest AR setups, if not the lightest.  I could have paired with an T-1 and it would be quite a bit lighter.  I'd have to weight them, but my BCM middy upper with lightweight barrel and T-1 might be lighter, but it has a somewhat heavier DD Omega rail. 

SLR Synergy is on an LMT 16" mid-length gas with MRP 12" monolithic upper with Comp M4s.  This is the heaviest AR setup that I have. 

Overall impressions is that the SLR is noticeably louder and more concussive blast felt than the AFAB.  However, both weren't as loud as most side venting brakes that I've been around.  There was another shooter with a size venting brake shooting a couple of benches over and that thing was pretty loud.  I didn't get a chance to see what ammo he was shooting.  One of the black powder guys was guessing it was 300 BLK, but it seemed louder than most 300 BLK loadings that I've heard.  But then again, many of those 300 BLK loadings were for competition and likely loaded lighter. 

Both are hybrid comps and flash hiders, with the intent on controlling muzzle rise/movement (or at least I believe and that's what I was looking for).  When some others were shooting both guns, I was able to observe from the side and almost even with the muzzle to behind the shooter.  The AFAB seemed louder than an A2, but the concussive blast/pressure was much milder than I had thought.  I'm guessing that is due to the very small vents.  The AFAB actually seemed louder and more felt concussive force at about 45 degrees behind the muzzle than directly to the side. 

The SLR Synergy has much larger vent holes and is somewhat like a BC but with much larger holes and short 4 prong flash hider.  I was surprised that it was noticeably louder than the AFAB, especially considering the AFAB was on a 14.5" carbine gas and the SLR was on a 16" midlength.  It wasn't obnoxious, but was louder than the AFAB. 

I was able to shoot the AFAB standing.  I was able to keep the dot on a steel plate at 100 yards in between shots and was able to get follow-up hits in what I felt was decent splits.  I am guessing that the plate was 10-12" in diameter.  I was very happy about that.  I didn't have a chance to shoot the SLR standing though. 

Overall, I am very happy with the AFAB.  I just found that I had to push the light further back as the carbon was getting on the lens of the light.  I was thinking of pushing the light and front sight back a little anyways.  I ended up pushing the light and front sight back two positions on the top rail and was able to keep the position of the short vertical grip that I used as a handstop.  Will see how that works out and if that position keeps carbon from building up on the light. 

I'll have to shoot the gun with the SLR a bit more.  I have the same comp for my AK build, so that might be a fun comparison. 
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on April 30, 2018, 01:30:59 PM
I don't participate in any competitions but when shooting an AR-15 platform 223/556 at HDF Range Days and certain HRA/LIFE Fun Shoots, there may often be a timer on you and that is when I realize the benefits of having a muzzle brake. When I shoot 223/556 at the Rifle range my AR has an unthreaded bull barrel.
A side-by-side comparison of the AFAB and your gun with the VG6 (Epsilon or Gamma) would be interesting.   :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: Wake27 on May 01, 2018, 08:50:37 AM
I know you already purchased but just because it was brought up, I'm a big fan of my BCM GF comps. I had them on three different guns but just switched my primary to the CTN Warcomp to try. My purposes for these guns require some type of hybrid more than anything else.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on May 01, 2018, 12:04:02 PM
I know you already purchased but just because it was brought up, I'm a big fan of my BCM GF comps. I had them on three different guns but just switched my primary to the CTN Warcomp to try. My purposes for these guns require some type of hybrid more than anything else.
I've wanted to try the BCM GF comp for a while, but just decided a different direction for this particular gun.  I still might try that on another gun though. 

I looked as some Surefire ones, but they were mostly brakes.  I'd love to have one for mounting a suppressor. . . of course, with the suppressor. 
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: Surf on May 01, 2018, 03:06:19 PM
I have a BCM GF comp around somewhere, I'll see if I can find it and let you try it out.  It wasn't as good overall as the Battlecomp.  Did a side by side on my old YouTube channel.  Probably still have the video if I can dig it up.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on May 02, 2018, 08:03:45 AM
I have a BCM GF comp around somewhere, I'll see if I can find it and let you try it out.  It wasn't as good overall as the Battlecomp.  Did a side by side on my old YouTube channel.  Probably still have the video if I can dig it up.
Great.  Maybe one of these days.  I don't see changing muzzle devices that I have on now for a while.  Maybe if I were to get another upper in the future. 

Maybe not the most scientific or comprehensive video, but I would love to do some comparisons like the video below.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XleToiBk8Rw (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XleToiBk8Rw)
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on May 07, 2018, 09:03:29 AM
Was able to shoot both of my guns with the AFAB and the SLR Synergy Comp over the weekend.  Probably around 300 rounds through each. 

AFAB - Love that device. It wasn't obnoxious at all.  I asked the shooters either side of me and they said it wasn't noticeably louder than an A2.  The shooter on the left of me was pretty new to shooting an AR, and it didn't bother her at all.  Though I think much of that was due to her pretty intense focus on the shooting, which I thought was great!  The upper that the AFAB was on is probably my lightest and the muzzle rise was minimal.  We did a number of cadence and multiple target exercises and didn't notice the dot jumping around much.  I wish I had the exact same upper set up with a pure flash hider to have done some side-by-side.  The only negative was that the device had worked loose after about 300 rounds, so back to the shop it goes today.  Not sure what happened, but the shim was able to spin freely and the device itself seemed to be timed about right, even though it would twist slightly back and forth.

SLR - Switched to that upper after I noticed the AFAB had worked loose.  To me, it's louder than the AFAB.  We were doing multiple target exercises at that point and it seemed to help with keeping the dot from dancing around too much.  However, this is probably the heaviest upper that I have and I feel that that weight helps with the muzzle rise, so tougher to gauge.  But overall, I did feel that it helped with muzzle control.  One thing I did notice is every so often, I would see a red flash rise from the device.  Sort of like a quick red flame coming straight up.  Not super distracting, but something that I noticed here and there.  Not sure if I will stick with this one.  Might see it offered up in the classified section.  I have one for my AK47, so will see. 
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on May 07, 2018, 11:50:53 AM
Took the upper back to the guy who did the pin and weld.  Apparently, a little bit of play is normal.  He explained that since most muzzle devices work to counter the rifles "natural" movement, the pins get fatigued and can develop some give.  Apparently mine was on the "more give" end of the spectrum.  No evidence of muzzle strikes, but there was both some twist play and side to side tilt play.  So he suggested an alternate/supplement weld to help mitigate that.  This being a relatively new gun and one that I envision shooting a lot and definitely not babying, I was not comfortable with the side to side play.  So going to replace the device and use the alternate weld method. 
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: changemyoil66 on May 07, 2018, 01:14:31 PM
So they don't screw on the break then weld it so it cannot be removed to keep the 16 inch law requirement?
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: Heavies on May 07, 2018, 02:57:36 PM
Took the upper back to the guy who did the pin and weld.  Apparently, a little bit of play is normal.  He explained that since most muzzle devices work to counter the rifles "natural" movement, the pins get fatigued and can develop some give.  Apparently mine was on the "more give" end of the spectrum.  No evidence of muzzle strikes, but there was both some twist play and side to side tilt play.  So he suggested an alternate/supplement weld to help mitigate that.  This being a relatively new gun and one that I envision shooting a lot and definitely not babying, I was not comfortable with the side to side play.  So going to replace the device and use the alternate weld method. 

There shouldn't be any play in the muzzle device, that would really screw with accuracy. 
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on May 07, 2018, 02:59:50 PM
So they don't screw on the break then weld it so it cannot be removed to keep the 16 inch law requirement?
As I understand it, the play is where the pin meets the dimple in the barrel.  Since the pin is welded near the surface of the device, would need to remove the weld and the pin in order to tighten back down.  However, no way to remove the weld without ruining the device, so. . .
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: Heavies on May 07, 2018, 03:01:06 PM
So they don't screw on the break then weld it so it cannot be removed to keep the 16 inch law requirement?

It's screwed down and a pin is installed into a detent drilled into the threads.  The end of the pin is then welded over to prevent the muzzle device from being unscrewed.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on May 07, 2018, 03:01:24 PM
There shouldn't be any play in the muzzle device, that would really screw with accuracy.
I agree.  One proposed fix was to add a "retaining" weld, but that the device as it had some lateral play bothered me.  Enough that I chose to abandon the existing device and replace. 

Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: Heavies on May 07, 2018, 03:02:39 PM
As I understand it, the play is where the pin meets the dimple in the barrel.  Since the pin is welded near the surface of the device, would need to remove the weld and the pin in order to tighten back down.  However, no way to remove the weld without ruining the device, so. . .

The pin should be a hardened pin, like drill rod.  it shouldn't give.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on May 07, 2018, 03:20:37 PM
The pin should be a hardened pin, like drill rod.  it shouldn't give.
I hear what you're saying and that's what I thought, but obviously something happened and just relaying how it was explained to me.  That the operation of the device often involves a torsional stress between the device and the barrel.  That that stress "fatigues" the contact point between the barrel and the pin and that leads to the play.  Something about all devices with pin and weld experience it to a certain level.  The fix here is to have a "setting weld" that runs from the face of the device and forms a bead line of weld to the barrel.  Supposedly that prevents the fatigue effect. 

This is a trusted installer, so I'm taking his word at this point.  He's working with me to make it right, so that's the main thing right now.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: Heavies on May 07, 2018, 04:02:28 PM
I hear what you're saying and that's what I thought, but obviously something happened and just relaying how it was explained to me.  That the operation of the device often involves a torsional stress between the device and the barrel.  That that stress "fatigues" the contact point between the barrel and the pin and that leads to the play.  Something about all devices with pin and weld experience it to a certain level.  The fix here is to have a "setting weld" that runs from the face of the device and forms a bead line of weld to the barrel.  Supposedly that prevents the fatigue effect. 

This is a trusted installer, so I'm taking his word at this point.  He's working with me to make it right, so that's the main thing right now.
Roger that. Not implying anything. Things wear out.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: dogman on May 07, 2018, 07:58:46 PM
If you have a threaded barrel, I believe the pin is not to stabilize the muzzle device but to make it "permanently attached". If you installed the muzzle device on a 16" barrel no pin would be required. I don't see how adding the pin could possibly cause "play". Am I misunderstanding something? Has anyone else had this problem with a pinned muzzle device? I have at least 4000 rounds on my pinned Epsilon and it is solid.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on May 07, 2018, 08:24:03 PM
If you have a threaded barrel, I believe the pin is not to stabilize the muzzle device but to make it "permanently attached". If you installed the muzzle device on a 16" barrel no pin would be required. I don't see how adding the pin could possibly cause "play". Am I misunderstanding something? Has anyone else had this problem with a pinned muzzle device? I have at least 4000 rounds on my pinned Epsilon and it is solid.
You’d have to ask the guy for more detailed info. I was asking questions, but he and I both had other things to do. That said, the way I understood it is that the pin sits in a dimple in the barrel. That that interface gets stressed repeatedly as there’s torque applied to the connection between the device and barrel. If just a crush washer or shim, both have some give to it and it absorbs some of torque applied to the connection of the device to the barrel. That the way the pin sits in the dimple, that gets “fatigued” from that repeated stress and the play develops.

I was trying to ask if the device was tightened down properly, howit could come loose, but never got there. I’ll ask when I go back for the follow up. I beleive the crush washers help keep things from working loose. But since this device uses shims, it doesn’t react the same.

The SLR was installed with leftover shims from the set that I bought for the AFAB and the SLR comp is still on there solid. That upper is a 16” barrel, so no pin. I shot prob about the same round count with the SLR after switching to it. The SLR was also used in the part of the course where the pace of shooting was higher.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: Wake27 on May 07, 2018, 09:18:08 PM
That sounds kind of sketchy dude, especially after only 300 rounds. I’ve had six pinned 14.5 uppers and every single one has been rock solid. My current Noveske has about 4k rounds on it and won’t budge.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on May 07, 2018, 09:27:06 PM
That sounds kind of sketchy dude, especially after only 300 rounds. I’ve had six pinned 14.5 uppers and every single one has been rock solid. My current Noveske has about 4k rounds on it and won’t budge.
Are those installed with crush washers or shims?
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on May 08, 2018, 01:38:37 PM
I emailed Precision Armament and got a reply first thing this morning.  Awesome responsiveness and feedback from the co-CEO and President of the company.  Gotta love that!

Anyways, the feedback was that if followed the instructions for the accu-washers, there should have been enough "pre-load" on the comp that it shouldn't have moved.  They also recommend application of high temp Loctite 272 or Flexbar Rocksett.  I have printed out all the various instructions and feedback and will present them to the installer. 

When I picked up the upper after the install, the person who did it mentioned that they had to try an alternate method (not their usual method with a reaction bar) to torque down the comp.  I made sure that issue was taken care of for this go around, so maybe that will help. 

Overall still not sure in my mind what happened and definitely see what dogman and Wake indicated and really that's what I had expected.  Hopefully things will get done right this time.  Again, the guy is working with me to make it right, so that's always important. 
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: Surf on May 08, 2018, 10:08:06 PM
I am no engineer, but I don't like the answers either.  Good, it is being addressed.  Any issues, please let me know and I will help.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on May 09, 2018, 07:29:30 AM
I am no engineer, but I don't like the answers either.  Good, it is being addressed.  Any issues, please let me know and I will help.
Yeah, the explanations given left me scratching my head.  I mean I'm no expert at pinned and welded brakes/comps, but the play thing definitely didn't sound right.  Hopefully things will get put together properly this time. 
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on July 15, 2018, 02:16:22 PM
Shot the gun with the AFAB in a carbine class yesterday and seems like this installation is holding.  I had shot the gun after getting it back after the comp was taken off and new one installed (with pin and weld), but just to zero and didn't get the gun that hot.  I believe thread locker was applied as well.  Don't recall what was used, but it left some clear red residue.  The class included may drill that got the gun pretty hot, which is where I noticed the muzzle device working lose.  Checked it here and there during the class and after and seems to be on there solid. 

Still not sure what happened with the initial install.  The first time, the installer mentioned not being able to get the light off of the rail, so had to use an alternate method of securing the upper than he typically does.  So maybe he was not able to torque the comp down properly.  For the reinstall, he used threadlocker as recommended by the manufacturer, but not sure if that was the issue as I believe shooting will get the comp hot enough to affect the threadlocker. 

When the comp worked loose, in between courses of fire, I had leaned the gun up against a tree when I reloaded mags.  I recall resting the comp on the tree.  While I wouldn't think that would cause anything, something that I figured I would avoid from now on.  So yesterday, when I put the rifle down, I made sure to rest it on the handguard. 
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: zippz on July 15, 2018, 06:54:07 PM
For the reinstall, he used threadlocker as recommended by the manufacturer, but not sure if that was the issue as I believe shooting will get the comp hot enough to affect the threadlocker. 

Loctite Red is rated between 300-450 degrees depending which version you have.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on July 15, 2018, 08:25:28 PM
Loctite Red is rated between 300-450 degrees depending which version you have.
I don’t recall what he used. He told me the product, but can’t tbink of it right now. PA recommends Loctite 272 (red) and Rocksett. I do recall it wasn’t either of those.
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on July 16, 2018, 07:36:01 AM
Some feedback on the AFAB.  I was able to shoot my Colt with the AFAB and a BCM with the BCM Comp, which is closer to an A2 than most other comps on the market.  Pretty similar setups and weight.  Probably the only main difference was my gun has an M4 profile barrel and the BCM had a lighter profile barrel.  Otherwise, pretty close to the same setup for comparison.

When I tried the BCM, we were doing drills that included multiple shots on multiple targets.  I was actually trying this gun for the trigger, but then I noticed how much the dot was jumping around between shots.  We were shooting on smaller targets and trying to ensure our hits were in the selected target and accounting for the proper holdover.  The target areas were maybe as small as 1" wide by 3" tall in some instances, so you could definitely notice when the dot moved off the target.

When I went back to my gun with the AFAB, I immediately noticed how much easier it was to keep the dot on the target.  I wouldn't say no muzzle jump, but much less and mostly was able to keep the dot from jumping out of the target area. 

That was a good side-by-side comparison of the muzzle devices and how effective the AFAB is at controlling muzzle jump, which is what I wanted.  It also made me wonder if shooting the gun with the AFAB will make me lax on solid muzzle control techniques.  Before about 3 months ago, I mostly shot with the A2 and what I was used to.  I certainly see the benefits of using a comp, but I also will make time to shoot the guns with the A2 to work on solid muzzle control techniques. 
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on July 31, 2018, 08:41:22 AM
Tried dogman's AR with the VG6 Epsilon with the CAGE thing and I was pretty impressed.  Was shooting with irons and the front sight wasn't jumping around very much at all.  Think the rail was 13" ish, so the front sight was way out there.  Even then, it seemed like the front sight stayed pretty close to on target. 

Then I observed when dogman shot it to get a feel for the blast with the CAGE device, which is supposed to help mitigate the side blast.  It wasn't bad at all.  I would have liked to have observed that side-by-side with the AFAB.  I would say that the VG6 Epsilon was a little louder than the AFAB, but not that much.  I was standing about 3 feet left of the muzzle and it wasn't bad. 

A few weeks ago, I was shooting next to someone with the Lantac Dragon and that thing vented a LOT of gasses sideways.  Felt like someone was blowing compressed air at me. 

Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: macsak on July 31, 2018, 10:03:31 AM
Tried dogman's AR with the VG6 Epsilon with the CAGE thing and I was pretty impressed.  Was shooting with irons and the front sight wasn't jumping around very much at all.  Think the rail was 13" ish, so the front sight was way out there.  Even then, it seemed like the front sight stayed pretty close to on target. 

Then I observed when dogman shot it to get a feel for the blast with the CAGE device, which is supposed to help mitigate the side blast.  It wasn't bad at all.  I would have liked to have observed that side-by-side with the AFAB.  I would say that the VG6 Epsilon was a little louder than the AFAB, but not that much.  I was standing about 3 feet left of the muzzle and it wasn't bad. 

A few weeks ago, I was shooting next to someone with the Lantac Dragon and that thing vented a LOT of gasses sideways.  Felt like someone was blowing compressed air at me.


what is the CAGE thing?

I guess I should focus and google
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on July 31, 2018, 10:10:06 AM

what is the CAGE thing?

I guess I should focus and google

CAGE = Concussion Altering Gas Expansion Device

"The CAGE is the pinnacle of concussion reduction technology. Its primary essential task was to disrupt side concussion while keeping or enhancing the characteristics of the Gamma and Epsilon series of muzzle devices. It accomplishes this with ease."

http://www.vg6precision.com/muzzle-devices/60-cage-device.html (http://www.vg6precision.com/muzzle-devices/60-cage-device.html)

You have to work on your Googlefu  ;D
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: macsak on July 31, 2018, 10:14:37 AM
CAGE = Concussion Altering Gas Expansion Device

"The CAGE is the pinnacle of concussion reduction technology. Its primary essential task was to disrupt side concussion while keeping or enhancing the characteristics of the Gamma and Epsilon series of muzzle devices. It accomplishes this with ease."

http://www.vg6precision.com/muzzle-devices/60-cage-device.html (http://www.vg6precision.com/muzzle-devices/60-cage-device.html)

You have to work on your Googlefu  ;D


heads


the way I tell how effective a muzzle device is, how many people on either side of me say "what brake is THAT!" or if people move benches
lol
Title: Re: Muzzle Device for AR15
Post by: drck1000 on July 31, 2018, 10:23:54 AM

heads


the way I tell how effective a muzzle device is, how many people on either side of me say "what brake is THAT!" or if people move benches
lol
I've shot next to one of the range regulars when he was shooting his Savage .338 Lapua with a pretty "effective" brake.  The side blast from that thing would knock over my spotting scope!   :o  Luckily he would shoot like 5 rounds at the start of a relay and just cruise for the rest.