2aHawaii

Tools and Uses => Firearms and Accessories => Topic started by: drck1000 on April 23, 2018, 08:50:28 AM

Title: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: drck1000 on April 23, 2018, 08:50:28 AM
What are your preferences for red dot for an AR?

I just ordered an EoTech EXPS 3-0 for an AR.  My first AR had an EoTech 512, but I got rid of that dot a while ago.  Nothing was wrong with it and I didn't experience the problems with the battery compartment that many others reported.  I just chose to go a different way at the time.

Since the 512, all of my ARs have had Aimpoints.  CompM4s, T-1s, and a PRO.  All have worked flawlessly.  I recently sent the CompM4s back to Aimpoint because the dot would come on when the knob was turned completely off.  While the dot still worked, I didn't like that if I had the dot off when storing that it would drain the battery.  Aimpoint ended up replacing it with a new one.

My preferences currently are just 1x.  I haven't really tried a magnifier for that long, but I have never felt the need for one.  For my shooting, the 1x is fine, but I also understand that there are other uses where the magnifier would be helpful.  I've wanted to try a 1-6x or 1-8x for a while, but I could also see the magnifier being "competitive" in that group. 

For weight, I like that the T-1s are super light, but the size or weight of the CompM4s or the PRO have (ETA:) never really bothered me.

What is important is durability and reliability.  Aimpoints are well known for both.  I've read many things about the EoTechs and I've seen them have problems in classes as well as just on the range, but I also wondered if those were knockoff.  That and I've also seen Aimpoints have problems as well. 

I've also been interested in trying out dots like Primary Arms and Vortex, but just haven't had the chance. 
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: Drakiir84 on April 23, 2018, 09:00:17 AM
Aimpoint micro series is hard to beat in terms of ruggedness and reliability.  Always on feature is fantastic for home defense and I'm currently running a T2 on my AR.  I love Eotechs when the company doesn't lie their fucking balls off about thermal drift factors but as far as I know the problem is fixed on newer models.  It's really hard to beat their holographic reticle for both speed and precision and it's astigmatism proof.

Was using a Trijicon MRO for a while but the dot isn't nearly as crisp as the T2.  The blue tinge didn't bother me.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: drck1000 on April 23, 2018, 09:09:42 AM
Aimpoint micro series is hard to beat in terms of ruggedness and reliability.  Always on feature is fantastic for home defense and I'm currently running a T2 on my AR.  I love Eotechs when the company doesn't lie their fucking balls off about thermal drift factors but as far as I know the problem is fixed on newer models.  It's really hard to beat their holographic reticle for both speed and precision and it's astigmatism proof.

Was using a Trijicon MRO for a while but the dot isn't nearly as crisp as the T2.  The blue tinge didn't bother me.
While I'm not too concerned about the thermal shift nor parallax issues, from reviews I've seen/read, the EXPS 3-0 has corrected that and has tested one of the best at minimizing effect of parallax. 

I too liked the EoTech reticle, or at least never found anything that I didn't like.

I wouldn't mind trying a T-2 or a CompM5, but those things are pricey.  I have two T-1s and I don't see myself needing to upgrade. 

I haven't really tried the MRO much, but I've heard good things.  I wouldn't mind trying one for a while as well. 

I have astigmatism. My contacts and glasses correct for it.  While even the 2 MOA dot can tend to bloom for me, I've never really noticed it being bad.  Some have reported that the dot looks like a " , " , but I haven't really noticed.  I zeroed my CompM4s this past weekend and when I zero, I dial it down to where I can barely see it and I recall the dot looking pretty crisp.  But yeah, the 1 MOA dot for the EoTech I always thought was super crisp, even with the brightness on the higher settings. 
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: drck1000 on April 23, 2018, 09:12:12 AM
Aimpoint micro series is hard to beat in terms of ruggedness and reliability.  Always on feature is fantastic for home defense and I'm currently running a T2 on my AR.  I love Eotechs when the company doesn't lie their fucking balls off about thermal drift factors but as far as I know the problem is fixed on newer models.  It's really hard to beat their holographic reticle for both speed and precision and it's astigmatism proof.

Was using a Trijicon MRO for a while but the dot isn't nearly as crisp as the T2.  The blue tinge didn't bother me.
Wait, "was" using?  So you got rid of it?  Or at least replaced with a T-2? 

Wow, big ballin'!   ;D
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: Drakiir84 on April 23, 2018, 09:40:26 AM
While I'm not too concerned about the thermal shift nor parallax issues, from reviews I've seen/read, the EXPS 3-0 has corrected that and has tested one of the best at minimizing effect of parallax. 

I too liked the EoTech reticle, or at least never found anything that I didn't like.

I wouldn't mind trying a T-2 or a CompM5, but those things are pricey.  I have two T-1s and I don't see myself needing to upgrade. 

I haven't really tried the MRO much, but I've heard good things.  I wouldn't mind trying one for a while as well. 

I have astigmatism. My contacts and glasses correct for it.  While even the 2 MOA dot can tend to bloom for me, I've never really noticed it being bad.  Some have reported that the dot looks like a " , " , but I haven't really noticed.  I zeroed my CompM4s this past weekend and when I zero, I dial it down to where I can barely see it and I recall the dot looking pretty crisp.  But yeah, the 1 MOA dot for the EoTech I always thought was super crisp, even with the brightness on the higher settings.

The thermal shift was real.  Left my AR out in the sun when we had one of our shoots, think my zero moved about 3 inches at the 40-50 yards we were shooting at.  That's some crazy shit and for me was unacceptable... still haven't washed the taste out of my mouth lol.
 
I've got the same astigmatism, completely corrected with my glasses but it's not too bad without them.  Definitely notice it less on the aimpoint.

Wait, "was" using?  So you got rid of it?  Or at least replaced with a T-2? 

Wow, big ballin'!   ;D

Yeah man, was my last purchase before Zoey crashed the party lol.  I've always loved their micros, finally decided to pull the trigger.  Also funny, I left the MRO on an AR I sold someone so I need to get that back lol... Maybe I'll let Bill try it out, I think he's still looking for a red dot for the DD AR he won at the FNRA dinner.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: drck1000 on April 23, 2018, 09:48:17 AM
The thermal shift was real.  Left my AR out in the sun when we had one of our shoots, think my zero moved about 3 inches at the 40-50 yards we were shooting at.  That's some crazy shit and for me was unacceptable... still haven't washed the taste out of my mouth lol.
 
I've got the same astigmatism, completely corrected with my glasses but it's not too bad without them.  Definitely notice it less on the aimpoint.

Yeah man, was my last purchase before Zoey crashed the party lol.  I've always loved their micros, finally decided to pull the trigger.  Also funny, I left the MRO on an AR I sold someone so I need to get that back lol... Maybe I'll let Bill try it out, I think he's still looking for a red dot for the DD AR he won at the FNRA dinner.
Ya.  I wasn't saying that the thermal shift issues wasn't real.  I actually had perfect opportunities to test that as well.  In a class I took in Alaska, it was around 10 F in the morning and then the snow stopped and sun came out and it was 40-50s by the end of the day.  Crazy weather!  We had been shooting out to 200 that day as well. 

I've been interested in the T-2, but can't justify the upgrade from the T-1s I have.  Maybe if I could sell one of them for even half of what I paid for them, I would consider.  But then again, that's very much a "want" and not a "need". 

Bill hasn't gotten a red dot on that AR yet?  Isn't it like 3 years old?  Well, since you're such a nice guy, maybe you should loan it to him for testing, for like the next 5 years.   :P
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: Drakiir84 on April 23, 2018, 10:06:10 AM
Ya.  I wasn't saying that the thermal shift issues wasn't real.  I actually had perfect opportunities to test that as well.  In a class I took in Alaska, it was around 10 F in the morning and then the snow stopped and sun came out and it was 40-50s by the end of the day.  Crazy weather!  We had been shooting out to 200 that day as well. 

I've been interested in the T-2, but can't justify the upgrade from the T-1s I have.  Maybe if I could sell one of them for even half of what I paid for them, I would consider.  But then again, that's very much a "want" and not a "need". 

Bill hasn't gotten a red dot on that AR yet?  Isn't it like 3 years old?  Well, since you're such a nice guy, maybe you should loan it to him for testing, for like the next 5 years.   :P

lol I probably would do a "long term loan", Malia says I have a bad habit of giving my stuff away.  But no he just won it last November.  Was the HRA gun that we raffled off.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: drck1000 on April 23, 2018, 10:09:25 AM
lol I probably would do a "long term loan", Malia says I have a bad habit of giving my stuff away.  But no he just won it last November.  Was the HRA gun that we raffled off.
Anything else you looking to give away?   :thumbsup:
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: Drakiir84 on April 23, 2018, 10:12:11 AM
Anything else you looking to give away?   :thumbsup:

Think I got some holsters lololol
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: WTF?Shane on April 24, 2018, 09:10:51 PM
I like the Eotech EXPS, but it goes through batteries quick.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: Drakiir84 on April 25, 2018, 09:09:33 AM
I like the Eotech EXPS, but it goes through batteries quick.

Yeah, the battery life is definitely a trade-off for the Eotechs.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: drck1000 on April 25, 2018, 10:04:10 AM
I like the Eotech EXPS, but it goes through batteries quick.
Yeah.  I don't recall the 512 eating through AAs that quickly, but I heard that the XPS series does go through them pretty quickly.  I have a good amount of CR123s for other things already, so hopefully can hopefully go through old stock. 
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: rklapp on April 25, 2018, 09:45:57 PM
(http://www.southertonguns.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/Red-Dot.jpg)
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: drck1000 on April 26, 2018, 08:33:36 AM
The EXPS came in last night.  Super fast shipping from OpticsPlanet.  Ordered super early Monday am, shipped out within hours.  Arrived in a little over 48 hours! 

Waiting for the upper to come back from having the muzzle device pinned/welded.  Hope to get the red dot zeroed this weekend. 

I was checking the EXPS out last night and the cover for the battery compartment was frozen.  I thought I was going to break the slot on the battery compartment cover.  I need a coin to replace the batteries on the Aimpoint Micro, but not sure if a quarter will be enough to open this one. 
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 26, 2018, 09:07:56 AM
OP, you're going to get a dozen recomendations.  For me it boiled down to the auto on/off feature that SIG Romeo5 has.

You touch the rifle, it turns on.  No movement for 2 mins, it turns off.  Extending battery life to 3 years or so. 

If I were to use my rifle for SD, i won't have time to turn the red dot on.  More important time spent pulling the charging handle.

And the Romeo5 is pretty cheap compared to others.  My AR has 1 and so does the wife's.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: drck1000 on April 26, 2018, 09:25:46 AM
OP, you're going to get a dozen recomendations.  For me it boiled down to the auto on/off feature that SIG Romeo5 has.

You touch the rifle, it turns on.  No movement for 2 mins, it turns off.  Extending battery life to 3 years or so. 

If I were to use my rifle for SD, i won't have time to turn the red dot on.  More important time spent pulling the charging handle.

And the Romeo5 is pretty cheap compared to others.  My AR has 1 and so does the wife's.
Thanks.  In my case, I pretty much had my mind made up and was more or less starting a discussion to see what other's thoughts are.  That said, my mind isn't so made up that I won't try other things.  Like I mentioned above, I've been wanting to try other dots, like the Holosun and the newer Vortex UH-1.  Personal preference is a big thing as well as budget.  When I first got into ARs, the main choices I had were EoTech or Aimpoint.  I'm like to try out and decide for myself, so I ended up with a 512 on one gun and a T-1 on a second gun.  However, that was also when I had more gun funds to experiment like that. 

I've heard of good feedback on the Romeo5.  I've also seem the auto-on function as well as the mounting hardware fail.  That said, I've seen plenty of EoTechs and Aimpoints fail too. 
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 26, 2018, 10:42:12 AM
Both haven't failed yet, thanks now Murphy's gonna drop a bomb on the wife and I.  Good thing we got back up sights on both AR's.

What made me stay away from EO Tech was the price.  I'm not going to be in the bush, so I don't need a super weather resistant red dot.  If I were in the bush or LE, I would go with EO Tech.  The only other sight that was in the budget was the Hi-Lux red dot.  It stays on for 2-3 years.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: zippz on April 26, 2018, 11:02:46 AM
I still use the CompM2 that I bought used about 15 years ago.  Still works great though I wish it had a smaller dot.  I'll replace it later when it breaks.  Probably never.

(https://i.imgur.com/ykqDRyy.jpg)
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: changemyoil66 on April 26, 2018, 12:42:18 PM
Zipps, you coming HDF shoot on Sat?  I know you mentioned you wanted to try my Gamma 556 comp.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: drck1000 on May 30, 2018, 03:39:55 PM
Thinking of trying the Vortex “Huey” UH-1. It’s been getting quite good reviews and can be had for a decent price. I have other guns with “proven” red dots, so would be good to try against those.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: Drakiir84 on May 31, 2018, 08:06:46 AM
If I were picking up a new "budget" optic I'd probably get this.  https://holosun.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=50&products_id=63

Has the "shake awake" feature that the romeo's have and you can switch between reticles.

$329 on amazon.
https://www.amazon.com/HOLOSUN-HE510C-GR-ELITE/dp/B079PH36FX/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1527790031&sr=8-1&keywords=he510c-gr+elite&dpID=41Ic2v9DCTL&preST=_SY300_QL70_&dpSrc=srch
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: drck1000 on May 31, 2018, 09:21:10 AM
If I were picking up a new "budget" optic I'd probably get this.  https://holosun.com/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=50&products_id=63

Has the "shake awake" feature that the romeo's have and you can switch between reticles.

$329 on amazon.
https://www.amazon.com/HOLOSUN-HE510C-GR-ELITE/dp/B079PH36FX/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1527790031&sr=8-1&keywords=he510c-gr+elite&dpID=41Ic2v9DCTL&preST=_SY300_QL70_&dpSrc=srch
I was looking at Primary Arms/Holosun and they seemed to have decent reviews. Pricing is great. I also know of a couple guys who have the Holosun on a “hard use” training gun. Haven’t picked their brain about how the dot has held up, but it’s still on there, so that told me a lot. They said, I’ve also read quite a number of bad experiences with them, which has me staying away. At least for now.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: changemyoil66 on May 31, 2018, 10:37:12 AM
I got my SIG Romeo5 for $165 & $180.  So way less than $329.

If you're going to "hard use" the optic, then EO Tech would be the best option due to it's durability.  But then you're spending way over budget.

My wife and I both run Romeo5's at the HDF carbine skill builders.  No durability issues (knocking on wood).  But it's basically just dust that gets at the optic.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: TooFewPews on May 31, 2018, 11:57:00 AM
I was looking at Primary Arms/Holosun and they seemed to have decent reviews. Pricing is great. I also know of a couple guys who have the Holosun on a “hard use” training gun. Haven’t picked their brain about how the dot has held up, but it’s still on there, so that told me a lot. They said, I’ve also read quite a number of bad experiences with them, which has been staying away. At least for now.

according to internet lore, the Holosun HS503, Primary Arms, Sig Romeo 5, and the TruGlo Tru-Tec 20mm are all made by the same company.

I picked up two of the TruGlo Tru-Tec 20mm red dots on sale at Cabelas.  All in all it cost less than $100 each.  one sits on an Ultimak gas tube rail mount on my AKM and the other occasionally sits on an AR (when i don't have my ACOG mounted).  of the two, i think the one mounted on the AKM has taken a pretty good amount of abuse.  it seems to maintain zero even when i've heated up the gas tube from long strings of fire to the point that it is hot to the touch.

if i could do it again, i'd probably pick up a couple more at that price.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: drck1000 on May 31, 2018, 12:19:54 PM
according to internet lore, the Holosun HS503, Primary Arms, Sig Romeo 5, and the TruGlo Tru-Tec 20mm are all made by the same company.

I picked up two of the TruGlo Tru-Tec 20mm red dots on sale at Cabelas.  All in all it cost less than $100 each.  one sits on an Ultimak gas tube rail mount on my AKM and the other occasionally sits on an AR (when i don't have my ACOG mounted).  of the two, i think the one mounted on the AKM has taken a pretty good amount of abuse.  it seems to maintain zero even when i've heated up the gas tube from long strings of fire to the point that it is hot to the touch.

if i could do it again, i'd probably pick up a couple more at that price.
I thought PA and Holosun collaborated or somehow worked together on one of the micro dots that I was looking at.  Not sure which one off the top of my head, but I believe it had an EoTech-like appearance with a dot and circle around it. 

I've shot a couple of guns with the Sig, but pretty much 10 rounds at a time here and there.  Haven't tried the Tru-Glo.  I don't doubt the "internet lore" that you mentioned to be true.

Incidentally, I was thinking of putting a Holosun/PA on my AK.  For now, one of my Aimpoint T-1 is going on the AK, but that could change.  The got will be mounted on a picatinny section of rail for the gas tube, so the heat aspect is something I'm wondering about.  I've seen Trijicon RMRs and Leupold Deltapoints on the same gas tube mount, so I'm assuming they are just fine.  But still, that area gets pretty darn hot. 

I finally have all the parts in for the AK project and hopefully will update that thread in the next 1-2 weeks.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: changemyoil66 on May 31, 2018, 01:35:40 PM
So many choices.  Just run iron sights and problem solved. =P
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: ren on May 31, 2018, 03:58:43 PM
So many choices.  Just run iron sights and problem solved. =P

Went back to irons. Good all the way out to 600 yards.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: drck1000 on May 31, 2018, 07:43:52 PM
Irons? Get lots of choices there too! Haha

I currently use DD fixed and mix in some ARMS folding rear sights on some guns.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: mangosteenqueen on May 31, 2018, 07:54:31 PM
Still waiting for Primary arms to release their 1x cyclops prism sight but seems that they’ve delayed it just a little longer than they estimated. They’ve been saying you can use a magnifier with it too.
Supposedly the eta will be July
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: Inspector on June 01, 2018, 07:45:29 AM
I just picked up a Vortex Venom (3 MOA Dot) slightly used. I will probably put it on my .357 but I am considering putting it on my AR before it gets permanently attached to the revolver.

If I like it I may have my Glock 17 slide modded to fit a reflex dot on it. Decisions, decisions.  ;) ;) ;)
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: changemyoil66 on June 01, 2018, 10:20:04 AM
Irons? Get lots of choices there too! Haha

I currently use DD fixed and mix in some ARMS folding rear sights on some guns.

I just looked that up too.  Damn didn't know so many choices.  In this case, no need sights, use guesstimation.

I run the Mbus Magpul flip sights as my back up.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: drck1000 on June 01, 2018, 02:02:55 PM
I just looked that up too.  Damn didn't know so many choices.  In this case, no need sights, use guesstimation.

I run the Mbus Magpul flip sights as my back up.
I actually want to get a basic 6920 with carry handle and keep it just like that and shoot it a lot.

For guestamation, I used to shoot with this older guy at SRGC and he said his vision was such that he had a hard time picking up sights. Being a long time shotgunner, he learned to point shoot. Basically pointing the finger on his support hand and that worked really well for him shooting clays. He did in the defensive courses of fire and actually did quite well. We were shooting full size silhouette targets at like 5-10 yards, but he was still getting pretty good hits.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: robtmc on June 01, 2018, 07:58:06 PM
Went back to irons. Good all the way out to 600 yards.
My .22 Benjamin Discovery PCP rifle stays with Wiliams peep sight to keep me honest.  Can be shocking how I can get 22 yard groups with irons just about as good as with a scope.

Part of that is the pellet choice, but it is a confidence builder.

I currently like the KAC- USMC surplus folding BUIS.  Have a Matech, but the elevation calibration is goofy toward the upper end of the scale.  The KAC should fit underneath any scope i might get in the future.  Price is right as well.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: drck1000 on June 06, 2018, 07:26:58 AM
My .22 Benjamin Discovery PCP rifle stays with Wiliams peep sight to keep me honest.  Can be shocking how I can get 22 yard groups with irons just about as good as with a scope.

Part of that is the pellet choice, but it is a confidence builder.

I currently like the KAC- USMC surplus folding BUIS.  Have a Matech, but the elevation calibration is goofy toward the upper end of the scale.  The KAC should fit underneath any scope i might get in the future.  Price is right as well.
I've never shot a gun with the KAC rear sight.  They seem like one of the gold standards, but they are a little pricey.  I had a gun that came with the MaTech, but I sold the upper before I had a chance to shoot it. 
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: Bushido on July 26, 2018, 08:07:25 PM
Went back to irons. Good all the way out to 600 yards.

Looking for recommendations for BUIS with adjustable elevation. KAC, LMT and where to buy especially with all the counterfeits out there?

Also, what AAA batteries are you running in your red dots? Mine leaked, I caught it early so not much damage.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: ren on July 26, 2018, 08:12:03 PM
Looking for recommendations for BUIS with adjustable elevation. KAC, LMT and where to buy especially with all the counterfeits out there?

Also, what AAA batteries are you running in your red dots? Mine leaked, I caught it early so not much damage.

I ran a cut carry handle that looks like the LMT with an Aimpoint in front. It was lower 1/3 co witnessed.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: drck1000 on July 26, 2018, 09:29:03 PM
I have an LMT rear sight that came off my MRP.

For batteries, I have lithium for my red dots with AA batteries. They haven’t leaked.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: Bushido on July 27, 2018, 06:45:19 PM
Thanks I use rechargeable lithium ions everyday at work. I had no clue they had one time use lithiums. Gonna try some out supposedly leak proof.
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: Soleyobo on July 30, 2018, 07:31:54 AM
I know this is for ARs but how about RDS on hand guns?
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: drck1000 on July 30, 2018, 08:09:30 AM
I know this is for ARs but how about RDS on hand guns?
I have a Trijicon RMR Type 2 for my Glock 17.  I have shot guns with other dots, like Deltapoint and Sig Romeo (I think that's it).  There are quite a few videos on them.  Try looking up Mrgunsngear and TRexArms.  I'm still a relative newbie to red dots on handguns. 
Title: Re: Red Dot Preferences for AR?
Post by: All_rice on July 31, 2018, 06:36:49 PM
I know this is for ARs but how about RDS on hand guns?

Look into shield rms also