2aHawaii

General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: ren on June 23, 2018, 12:01:56 PM

Title: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: ren on June 23, 2018, 12:01:56 PM
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xG9DtaPjT80 (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xG9DtaPjT80)

lots of discussion points but Bill tries to relate the 2A to a person wanting drugs...fail :crazy: :grrr:
Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on June 23, 2018, 12:28:01 PM
When talking about gun confiscation, Colion should have mentioned New Orleans during Katrina.

Many states passed laws afterward to protect gun owners from that scenario during future disasters.

So, the idea that the government, be it federal, state, or local, would confiscate firearms for any reason is by no means improbable. 

That puts to rest the claim that registrations would not lead to confiscations.
Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: groveler on June 24, 2018, 10:50:45 AM
When talking about gun confiscation, Colion should have mentioned New Orleans during Katrina.

Many states passed laws afterward to protect gun owners from that scenario during future disasters.

So, the idea that the government, be it federal, state, or local, would confiscate firearms for any reason is by no means improbable. 

That puts to rest the claim that registrations would not lead to confiscations.

Confiscation is the only reason for registration!
Supposedly  confiscation is not allowed here
in Hawaii, but I do not trust the politicians, cops, or
sheriffs here.
Anecdotally,  I suspect the compliance rate for registration is
way lower than 50%.  Only a fool buys a gun in Hawaii.
R/T to most western states and a trip to a gun show will get
you what you want. No hassles. No police. No registration,
at POS.
I used to be able to pick full auto Uzi's in Seattle
from a Samoan gang.  Never did, but I knew how to get such things.
I want to be CLEAR, I do not advocate violating any constitutional
Federal, State, or Local laws.  Nor do I violate any  constitutional
Federal, State, or Local laws.
 
Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: ren on June 24, 2018, 11:24:09 AM
You can only buy marijuana from licensed dispensaries in this state...
And no one does anything illegal.
Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: eyeeatingfish on June 24, 2018, 09:11:48 PM
Confiscation is the only reason for registration!

Not really. There are other reasons for registration, most namely I think is the benefit of law enforcement to solve crimes.
Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on June 24, 2018, 09:48:50 PM
Not really. There are other reasons for registration, most namely I think is the benefit of law enforcement to solve crimes.

Not not really.  Your reason is flawed.

Quote
Gun registration and gun owner licensing wouldn’t prevent or solve crimes. Most people sent to prison for gun crimes
acquire guns from theft, the black market, or acquaintances. (Bureau of Justice Statistics[1]) Half of illegally trafficked firearms
originate with straw purchasers who buy guns for criminals (ATF[2]). Criminals wouldn’t register guns or get gun licenses.

The Supreme Court has ruled that people who are prohibited by law from possessing firearms (such as felons, people adjudicated
mentally incompetent, domestic violence abusers, and drug addicts) cannot be required to register firearms, because doing so
would violate their 5th Amendment right against self-incrimination.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reviewed studies of gun registration and gun owner licensing, and found them
insufficient for determining the restrictions’ effectiveness.

https://www.nraila.org/get-the-facts/registration-licensing/

Maryland scraps gun "fingerprint" database after 15 failed years

Quote
Millions of dollars later, Maryland has officially decided that its 15-year effort to store and catalog the
"fingerprints" of thousands of handguns was a failure.

Since 2000, the state required that gun manufacturers fire every handgun to be sold here and send
the spent bullet casing to authorities. The idea was to build a database of "ballistic fingerprints" to help
solve future crimes.

But the system — plagued by technological problems — never solved a single case. Now the hundreds
of thousands of accumulated casings could be sold for scrap.

http://www.baltimoresun.com/news/maryland/bs-md-bullet-casings-20151107-story.html

With aftermarket parts readily available in shops and on the Internet, it's very easy to swap barrels, slides, firing pins and any other part that might leave a mark on a bullet or casing.  That assumes you didn't keep the casings (police them up or use a revolver). Then it's child's play to ditch the "hot" parts and replace the factory components.  So, even if registration leads the Cops to you for simply owning the right caliber firearm, it has to be tied to the crime scene, and they need motive and opportunity to even count you as a suspect.  They still need a warrant based on probable cause, and just having a like-caliber firearm isn't enough.

Then there's the "my gun was stolen" play. Happens all the time, according to the anti-2A groups.  That's why legal gun owners get the blame for criminals possessing guns.

Then there's the gun found at a crime scene.  There's no registration needed for that.  Manufacturers and wholesalers know the serial numbers and where they were sent, and shops know who bought them.  That's the reverse scenario of finding out which gun did it.  Investigators already know because they can trace the gun to owner.  Registration is only useful for tracing the owner to a type of gun.

Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on June 24, 2018, 10:03:03 PM
Then there's this tidbit, courtesy of Canada:

Canada Tried Registering Long Guns -- And Gave Up

Quote
One persistent suggestion in the post-Newtown conversation about gun control is a law requiring the registration of all guns,
even so-called "long guns" like the rifle Adam Lanza used in the school killings. Lost in the discussion: Canada tried it and
gave up, discovering like several other nations that attempting to identify every gun in the country is an expensive and ultimately
unproductive exercise. Criminals, of course, don't register their guns. And even law-abiding citizens tend to ignore registration
when it comes to long guns mostly used for hunting and target shooting.

Fans say a central registry would make it easier for police to track down weapons used in crimes, and perhaps even make
gun owners more responsible. With all the guns registered, owners could be held liable if their guns turn up at a crime scene
and they failed to report them as stolen.


Universal registration drives NRA types nuts: The more paranoid among them fear it would be a tool for government agents to
seize their guns, while the less so worry that anything that has been registered also can be taxed.

Maybe they shouldn't worry. Universal registration has been tried in several countries, most recently in Canada. The program
turned out to be far more expensive than expected and didn't have any discernable impact on crime, perhaps because long guns
are used so rarely by criminals in the first place.
Canada's gun homicide rate, according to the handy statistics at Gunpolicy.org,
has held steady since the late 1990s.

Canada passed a strict gun-control law in 1995, partly in reaction to a 1989 shooting  at Montreal’s Ecole Polytechnique with a
semiautomatic rifle. The law required universal regulation of guns, including rifles and shotguns. Proponents said the central registry
would give law-enforcement agencies a powerful new tool for tracking guns used in crimes. They also claimed it would help reduce
domestic violence and suicide.

Canada's then-Minister of Justice Allan Rock supported the law,  telling Parliament:

Registration will reduce crime and better equip the police to deal with crime
in Canadian society by providing them with information they often need to
do their job … Registration will assist us to deal with the scourge of domestic
violence … Suicides and accidents provide another example … If a firearm is
not readily available, lives can be saved. If registration, as the police believe, will
encourage owners to store firearms safely so those impulsive acts are less likely,
the result may be different.

The law passed and starting in 1998 Canadians were required to have a license to own firearms and register their weapons with the
government. According to Canadian researcher (and gun enthusiast) Gary Mauser, the Canada Firearms Center quickly rose to 600
employees and the cost of the effort climbed past $600 million. In 2002 Canada's auditor general released a report saying initial cost
estimates of $2 million (Canadian) had increased to $1 billion as the government tried to register the estimated 15 million guns owned
by Canada's 34 million residents.

The registry was plagued with complications like duplicate serial numbers and millions of incomplete records, Mauser reports. One
person managed to register a soldering gun, demonstrating the lack of precise standards. And overshadowing the effort was the
suspicion of misplaced effort: Pistols were used in 66% of gun homicides in 2011, yet they represent about 6% of the guns in Canada.
Legal long guns were used in 11% of killings that year, according to Statistics Canada, while illegal weapons like sawed-off shotguns
and machine guns, which by definition cannot be registered, were used in another 12%.

So the government was spending the bulk of its money -- about $17 million of the Firearms Center's $82 million annual budget -- trying
to register long guns when the statistics showed they weren't the problem.

There was also the question of how registering guns was supposed to reduce crime and suicide in the first place. From 1997 to 2005,
only 13% of the guns used in homicides were registered. Police studies in Canada estimated that 2-16% of guns used in crimes were
stolen from legal owners and thus potentially in the registry. The bulk of the guns, Canadian officials concluded, were unregistered
weapons imported illegally from the U.S. by criminal gangs.

Finally in 2011, conservatives led by Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper voted to abolish the long-gun registry and destroy all its
 records. Liberals argued the law  had contributed to the decline in gun homicides since it was passed. But Mauser notes that gun
homicides have actually been rising in recent years, from 151 in 1999 to 173 in 2009, as violent criminal gangs use guns in their drug
turf wars and other disputes. As in the U.S., most gun homicides in Canada are committed by young males, many of them with criminal
records. In the majority of homicides involving young males, the victim and the killer are know each other.

The bigger lesson of Canada's experiment, Mauser says, is that gun registration rarely delivers the results proponents expect. In most
countries the actual number registered settles out at about a sixth. Germany required registration during the Baader-Meinhof reign of terror
in the 1970s, and recorded 3.2 million of the estimated 17 million guns in that country; England tried to register pump-action and semiautomatic
shotguns in the 1980s, but only got about 50,000 of the estimated 300,000 such guns stored in homes around the country.
:    :
:    :
But Canada's experience suggests focusing on the hardware instead of the shooter is an expensive and ultimately fruitless endeavor. I would
be curious whether that country's pistol registry has been more effective.


https://www.forbes.com/sites/danielfisher/2013/01/22/canada-tried-registering-long-guns-and-gave-up/#6e3e6f905a1b
Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: changemyoil66 on June 25, 2018, 11:32:39 AM
Eye,

Can you expand on benefits of registration (srs)?  The way I see it, if a criminal buys a stolen gun, first thing they would do is file off the serial #.  Unless data supports that criminals don't do this.  This would tie into the returning the gun to it's rightful owner.
Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on June 25, 2018, 11:36:57 AM
Eye,

Can you expand on benefits of registration (srs)?  The way I see it, if a criminal buys a stolen gun, first thing they would do is file off the serial #.  Unless data supports that criminals don't do this.  This would tie into the returning the gun to it's rightful owner.

That's a good point.  If the serial number is defaced and unretreivable, what good is registration going to do?
Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: rklapp on June 25, 2018, 02:47:12 PM
It funny that HBO blocked the content on Colion's account but available on their own.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U0QGZSY35sI&t=313s

It amazes me how much time and resources are wasted by Hawaii on registration so that legal gun owners are held accountable. It's ridiculous. Hawaii is the only State that requires owner registration but doubt it's worth the time and money, i.e., taxes.
Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: ren on June 25, 2018, 02:56:46 PM
I want metrics on this registration system. How much times it has been accessed by LE to solve crimes.
Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: rklapp on June 25, 2018, 03:27:46 PM
I'd also like to know how many people have been identified by the rapback system as new felons and their firearms taken away. I suspect that the FBI is just pocketing our $30 and wasting our time and privacy.
Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: groveler on June 25, 2018, 03:28:12 PM
I want metrics on this registration system. How much times it has been accessed by LE to solve crimes.

Are you being sarcastic?  You,  I and any intelligent person knows registration is useless.
Criminals don't register guns. There is a Supreme Court ruling saying they don't have to.
There is this irritating 5th Amendment.  But Hawaii politicians would not know what a
constitution is.  They just make it up as they go.
Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: ren on June 25, 2018, 04:12:44 PM
Are you being sarcastic?  You,  I and any intelligent person knows registration is useless.
Criminals don't register guns. There is a Supreme Court ruling saying they don't have to.
There is this irritating 5th Amendment.  But Hawaii politicians would not know what a
constitution is.  They just make it up as they go.

I'm sarcastically serious. One person believes in this system / procedure. I wonder if he has accessed it to help him in his job.
Can he cite one instance in his career span of __ years that it helped him / her solve a case.
Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on June 25, 2018, 04:43:28 PM
I'm sarcastically serious. One person believes in this system / procedure. I wonder if he has accessed it to help him in his job.
Can he cite one instance in his career span of __ years that it helped him / her solve a case.

This was from 2000. Maybe a case was prosecuted since then, but it's doubtful.

Quote
In theory, if a gun is left at the scene of the crime, licensing and registration will allow a gun to be traced back to its owner.
But, amazingly, despite police spending tens of thousands of man hours administering these laws in Hawaii (the one state
with both rules), as well as in big urban areas with similar laws, such as Chicago and Washington, D.C., there is not even
a single case where the laws have been instrumental in identifying someone who has committed a crime.


http://articles.latimes.com/2000/aug/23/local/me-8924

Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: rklapp on June 25, 2018, 05:28:25 PM
This was from 2000. Maybe a case was prosecuted since then, but it's doubtful.

http://articles.latimes.com/2000/aug/23/local/me-8924
I agree that it's doubtful. Registration might protect an owner but only if the owner reported the firearm as stolen (or victim of a boating accident) before it was recovered in a crime.
Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: changemyoil66 on June 26, 2018, 09:00:51 AM
I agree that it's doubtful. Registration might protect an owner but only if the owner reported the firearm as stolen (or victim of a boating accident) before it was recovered in a crime.

We need special duty at all boating trips (like at family events over 100 people).  Seems like a big loss often.
Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: eyeeatingfish on June 26, 2018, 03:26:09 PM
Eye,

Can you expand on benefits of registration (srs)?  The way I see it, if a criminal buys a stolen gun, first thing they would do is file off the serial #.  Unless data supports that criminals don't do this.  This would tie into the returning the gun to it's rightful owner.

Current technology can actually recover serial numbers that have been filed off.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/scientists-develop-a-technique-to-find-serial-numbers-that-have-been-filed-off/2015/05/11/45e76fce-d489-11e4-8fce-3941fc548f1c_story.html?utm_term=.aa931d54534a

Of course a serial number isn't a guarantee that a crime will be solved but it is a piece of information that can lead to other things which could ultimately solve the crime. First step would be to get the serial number on the gun. Then look at the registered owner to see if they are a possible suspect. If not see what happened to the gun. Stolen, lost, sold? Sold to who and when?

In the Oklahoma bombing it was a vehicle VIN (serial number) which helped them solve the crime.

Now as Flapp pointed out, it is possible to replace parts and do other things to a gun to make them harder to track down and connect to a crime. Indeed, no system is perfect but as we all know, criminals aren't either and when they mess up things like gun registration is a means by which to catch them.

Understand though that I am not saying all guns should be registered, (I have an unregistered pistol myself) but I am acknowledging that there is a benefit to registration. Registration is a double edged sword with positives and negatives and we should recognize both.
Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: groveler on June 26, 2018, 04:36:27 PM
Current technology can actually recover serial numbers that have been filed off.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/scientists-develop-a-technique-to-find-serial-numbers-that-have-been-filed-off/2015/05/11/45e76fce-d489-11e4-8fce-3941fc548f1c_story.html?utm_term=.aa931d54534a

Of course a serial number isn't a guarantee that a crime will be solved but it is a piece of information that can lead to other things which could ultimately solve the crime. First step would be to get the serial number on the gun. Then look at the registered owner to see if they are a possible suspect. If not see what happened to the gun. Stolen, lost, sold? Sold to who and when?

In the Oklahoma bombing it was a vehicle VIN (serial number) which helped them solve the crime.

Now as Flapp pointed out, it is possible to replace parts and do other things to a gun to make them harder to track down and connect to a crime. Indeed, no system is perfect but as we all know, criminals aren't either and when they mess up things like gun registration is a means by which to catch them.

Understand though that I am not saying all guns should be registered, (I have an unregistered pistol myself) but I am acknowledging that there is a benefit to registration. Registration is a double edged sword with positives and negatives and we should recognize both.

Eye,
"(I have an unregistered pistol myself)"
I must assume the gun  is not in Hawaii.
This is a public forum.
You should never admit to or commit violations
of Federal, State, or Local laws.

Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: ren on June 26, 2018, 04:49:25 PM
Current technology can actually recover serial numbers that have been filed off.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/scientists-develop-a-technique-to-find-serial-numbers-that-have-been-filed-off/2015/05/11/45e76fce-d489-11e4-8fce-3941fc548f1c_story.html?utm_term=.aa931d54534a

Of course a serial number isn't a guarantee that a crime will be solved but it is a piece of information that can lead to other things which could ultimately solve the crime. First step would be to get the serial number on the gun. Then look at the registered owner to see if they are a possible suspect. If not see what happened to the gun. Stolen, lost, sold? Sold to who and when?

In the Oklahoma bombing it was a vehicle VIN (serial number) which helped them solve the crime.

Now as Flapp pointed out, it is possible to replace parts and do other things to a gun to make them harder to track down and connect to a crime. Indeed, no system is perfect but as we all know, criminals aren't either and when they mess up things like gun registration is a means by which to catch them.

Understand though that I am not saying all guns should be registered, (I have an unregistered pistol myself) but I am acknowledging that there is a benefit to registration. Registration is a double edged sword with positives and negatives and we should recognize both.

Huh? You say there are some benefits to register a gun but dont register your pistol?
Title: Re: Colion Noir with Bill Maher
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on June 26, 2018, 05:24:09 PM
It's a fact 80% or so of criminals committing crimes get their guns through associates, straw purchasers, or theft. They will never register those guns.

Another portion of owners buy guns in private sales but will never register them, since prohibited possessors are protected from registration laws.

Another portion will dispose of the gun after a crime, because it's worse being caught with a murder/crime weapon than failing to report it stolen/lost.

The small percentage of crimes that have a gun recovered (at the scene or not) which have serial numbers (recovered or not defaced) can still be traced to the original buyer through other means. 4473 forms are kept by dealers. Dealers no longer in business turn their records over the the FBI.

The small number of crime investigations that might get some small benefit from tracing a gun to an owner isn't justified by the cost of tracking hundreds of thousands of transactions annually.  Nor does that justify the impact to lawful owners who have to take their time and spend their money complying with registrations laws.

COST > BENEFIT