2aHawaii

General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: Paladin4CA on August 08, 2018, 07:37:01 AM

Title: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: Paladin4CA on August 08, 2018, 07:37:01 AM
IIRC, on Aug 22nd Hawaii County will ask their County Council for approval for hiring outside legal counsel to fight against the 3-judge panel decision in Young which found a 2nd A Right to Loaded Open Carry. Since the deadline for actually filing a petition for rehearing/rehearing en banc isn't until Sept 14th, this meeting will give us our first indication that they're actually going to appeal it (and risk a subsequent loss at SCOTUS that applies to the entire nation), and possibly of who they'll hire to fight against us.

I think the Council meeting will be open to the public. Is anyone going to attend and get back to us here to let us know how it went???
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: zippz on August 08, 2018, 08:51:20 AM
The Hawaii attorney at the last appeals hearing seemed very underprepared and overworked.  Hawaii count will certainly hire a good attorney and get pressured from the State and other states to do a good job on this case
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: oldfart on August 08, 2018, 10:44:42 AM
It sucks that we, the taxpayers, have to pay to fight against ourselves.
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: RSN172 on August 08, 2018, 03:47:50 PM
I think Young will lose en banc.  Too many liberals.  Then he will win at SCOTUS, if they decide to hear the case.  So in 3 to 7 years, we may have the right to legally carry in Hawaii.
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: 2ahavvaii on August 08, 2018, 03:58:55 PM
nra wont sponsor a high powered attorney?
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: 6716J on August 09, 2018, 10:58:23 AM
It sucks that we, the taxpayers, have to pay to fight against ourselves.

 :(
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: aieahound on August 09, 2018, 11:18:40 AM
It sucks that we, the taxpayers, have to pay to fight against ourselves.
It does suck tax payers have to pay to attempt to fight against our own Rights.

I hope our CCW application drive we did a couple years ago helps the cause in the Young case.
Numerous applications and all denied.   (I think we had like 20 to 30 out of our hundreds of members)
Virtually no ccw's issued in last twenty years (none on the BI) and only security can get open carry by the letter of the law.
Hawaii is in practicality, a no issue State for law abiding citizens.
En Banc is a crap shoot. Do law abiding citizens have a right to bear arms for self-defense?
Circuits are split on this. But so many circuits have issued opinions for both yes and no, I would hope the Supreme Court would have to take the case.
So many split circuits is generally a criteria for granting certiorari.
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: Paladin4CA on August 12, 2018, 05:24:01 PM
Seems like nobody answered the question I posed: Is anyone going to attend [the Hawaii County Council meeting on Aug. 22nd] and get back to us here to let us know how it went [re. the Young case]? The Council meeting is only 10 days away.

IIRC, on Aug 22nd Hawaii County will ask their County Council for approval for hiring outside legal counsel to fight against the 3-judge panel decision in Young which found a 2nd A Right to Loaded Open Carry. Since the deadline for actually filing a petition for rehearing/rehearing en banc isn't until Sept 14th, this meeting will give us our first indication that they're actually going to appeal it (and risk a subsequent loss at SCOTUS that applies to the entire nation), and possibly of who they'll hire to fight against us.

I think the Council meeting will be open to the public. Is anyone going to attend and get back to us here to let us know how it went???
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: Coolscout on August 15, 2018, 01:06:10 PM
If I am not working that day I will go. I am a Retired LEO under 926C and I have no issues with the open carry as long as the ones who apply and take the class and shoot qualify. They are looking on how it will affect tourism but they dont see that tourists spend one to two weeks here and do not see the crime because they go to the beach, do helecopter rides or stay at their hotel. Those of us that live here se much more that is not reported in the mainland.
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: zippz on August 15, 2018, 08:05:34 PM
I'll need whomever is attending to take notes and contact me after the meeting so I can get the amicus briefs started.
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: RSN172 on August 15, 2018, 08:57:02 PM
Might have a hurricane or TS that day.
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: punaperson on August 16, 2018, 10:11:27 AM
Just got off the phone with a long list of people after seeing the 22nd council agenda published this morning with no mention of the outside hire.

County Clerk confirmed it wasn't on the agenda for the 22nd, sent me to Council Services. That person confirmed it wasn't on the agenda for 22nd as "papers" had to be sent back to County/Corporation Counsel office to be reworked. She said she thought it would most likely be on the Oct. 3 agenda [which would mean the County Corporation Counsel would have to be planning on asking for another time extension since this one ends on September 14, though they could simply file for en banc prior to the 14th deadline and THEN attempt to hire someone to litigate it at a later Council meeting.] Sent me to Corporation Counsel.

Corporation Counsel office first talked to Horowitz who told her he thought it was still on the 22nd. She then talked to Lorraine Martin, supervisor for litigation, who confirmed it was NOT on the agenda for the 22nd but would be on an agenda "sometime in September".

All accomplished in a mere 30 minutes on the phone. About 90% of that on "hold".
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: zippz on August 16, 2018, 11:07:43 AM
Thanks for the info Puna.  Hope their extension gets denied.  I wonder if they're delaying for other reasons to help their case.
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: 2ahavvaii on August 16, 2018, 12:29:06 PM
i thought the extension for deadline to make a decision wasl 8/14?
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: zippz on August 16, 2018, 12:38:33 PM
The State of Hawaii is taking over the defense so county doesnt need the hearing anymore.
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: 2ahavvaii on August 16, 2018, 03:27:09 PM
The State of Hawaii is taking over the defense so county doesnt need the hearing anymore.

great!  the state of hawaii has limitless money and resources to waste on denying 2a rights, just look at the travel ban as an example
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: Paladin4CA on August 16, 2018, 06:18:30 PM
The State of Hawaii is taking over the defense so county doesnt need the hearing anymore.
Source/link?
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: zippz on August 16, 2018, 06:20:46 PM
Source/link?

It'll all be covered at Saturdays meeting.
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: RSN172 on August 16, 2018, 07:46:29 PM
great!  the state of hawaii has limitless money and resources to waste on denying 2a rights, just look at the travel ban as an example

Yes.  Imagine how much money they would get for an anti 2a fund by taxing each resident a dollar.
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: Paladin4CA on August 16, 2018, 08:01:04 PM
It'll all be covered at Saturdays meeting.
Will someone post what is covered for those who can't attend?
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: wolfwood on August 23, 2018, 05:20:46 AM
Did anyone go?
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: punaperson on August 23, 2018, 06:25:00 AM
Did anyone go?
I didn't go and submit my live oral testimony for the reasons outlined in my response #11 above: https://2ahawaii.com/index.php?topic=32036.msg283960#msg283960

The request for funding the outside counsel hire was sent back to corporation counsel for a re-write and thus removed from the agenda. I was told on the phone that Lorraine Martin, supervisor of litigation, said that the request would be on the council agenda "in September". There are two council meetings in September, 5th (Hilo) and 19th (Kona). The agendas are published six days prior to the meetings, at approximately 8:30 AM. I will be looking for them at that time. If/when the funding request is on the agenda, I will be either at the meeting Hilo), or submitting my oral testimony via live video (if the meeting is in Kona).

Just a heads up: I'm only allowed three minutes, but I'm not going to be saying anything nice about the state, the county, the police department,  the corporation counsel, the mayor, or the council itself. Should go over real well.
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: wolfwood on August 23, 2018, 10:02:46 AM
I talked to the County lawyer and he said

The retention of outside counsel was postponed until the September 5 meeting.
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: Sodie on August 27, 2018, 07:40:13 PM
According to this: http://michellawyers.com/young-v-hawaii/ (http://michellawyers.com/young-v-hawaii/), the state has a couple of attorneys from D.C. involved.
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: macsak on August 27, 2018, 07:57:26 PM
According to this: http://michellawyers.com/young-v-hawaii/ (http://michellawyers.com/young-v-hawaii/), the state has a couple of attorneys from D.C. involved.

watch out, they're "Super Lawyers"
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: robtmc on August 27, 2018, 08:30:07 PM
watch out, they're "Super Lawyers"
On permanent retainer to György Schwartz
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: punaperson on August 30, 2018, 08:26:10 AM
It's on. Page 3. [Note: It's resolution 666... I'm just sayin'...] If I try to copy it the format is so messed up I don't want to spend the time to fix it. Read it for yourself. I'm not sure exactly what that language means. I do see that it requires a 2/3 vote of "all members", and since Ruggles isn't voting anymore we'd need at least two three NO votes to defeat it. 9 AM, Wednesday, September 5th in Hilo.

http://records.co.hawaii.hi.us/weblink/0/doc/965054/Page1.aspx

EDIT:

Res. 666-18:        AUTHORIZES THE EMPLOYMENT OF A PRIVATE ATTORNEY AS PART OF AN INTERGOVERNMENTAL AGREEMENT WITH THE STATE OF HAWAII TO REPRESENT THE COUNTY OF HAWAII AND NAMED COUNTY OFFICIALS IN YOUNG VERSUS STATE OF HAWAII,
                     NO. 12-17808
                     Would allow the County to enter into an agreement with the State of Hawaii to retain the legal services of Mr. Neal Katyal as special counsel, with the State to pay all fees and costs.  The County desires to retain special counsel to seek an en banc review by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals of its decision published on July 24, 2018, finding that there is a constitutional right to open carry firearms pursuant to the Second Amendment of the United States Constitution and that a portion of Section 134-9 of the Hawaii Revised Statutes violated the Second Amendment of the United States Constitution.
                                    Reference:      Comm. 1041
                                    Intr. by:    Ms. David (B/R)
                                    Waived:    FC
                                    Note:        Requires 2/3 vote of the entire membership, pursuant to Section 6-5.5            Hawaii County Charter

* * * * *
So apparently the county wouldn't be using any county funds to finance it... "just" our state taxpayer dollars.

Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: zippz on September 04, 2018, 09:56:51 PM
So apparently the county wouldn't be using any county funds to finance it... "just" our state taxpayer dollars.

I'll use this for my gun show table next month.  Your tax money is being used to ban public carry.
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: punaperson on September 05, 2018, 06:22:45 AM
I'll use this for my gun show table next month.  Your tax money is being used to ban public carry.
Your tax money is continuing to be used in even greater amounts to continue the ban on public carry.

Fixed it.

I've had no luck thus far (duh!) trying to get any state agency or person to tell me about the contract with the D.C. law firm and how much taxpayer money is or will be spent. Transparency. Democrats. Zero.
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: punaperson on September 05, 2018, 06:40:14 PM
Hawaii County Council update:

They passed the bill unanimously, 8-0 (one absent).

They asked a few non-substantive questions of attorney Horowitz, who "argued" before the O'Scannlain panel for the county. They mostly wanted to be sure the county wasn't going to be on the hook for any money to hire the "special counsel". Not one single word about why the county and the county employees sued ought to be let of the hook.

Not really worth watching unless you want to be disgusted by their total lack of interest in the actual issue, as opposed to making sure they weren't getting charged for anything. But just in case:

video: http://hawaiicounty.granicus.com/Vie....php?view_id=1
(beneath "Archived Videos", click "Hawaii County Council". Today's meeting is at the top of the list, Sept. 5.)

The county streaming feed is really really slow, so it might take a while to get to the "discussion" which is at 2h 28m 50sec

My comment is at 1:06:34. The person immediately prior to me, at 1:03:23, entered three minutes of MomsDemand/Giffords/Brady et al. talking points...  :crazy:

A couple of other people did comment after I left, but none of them seemed to understand what this resolution was for (entering into an agreement to have special counsel hired by the state represent all the county parties at no cost to the state). More about "don't waste money" (but the county council has no input on the state spending money).

Speaking of which, I have both calls and emails into the governor's office and the AG's office asking for details about the costs involved. Haven't heard back yet.

 :shaka:
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 05, 2018, 07:27:45 PM
They should pass a law that what ever 1 guy spends on the atty, the responding party cant exceed that. So in this case, hawaii cant get a million dollar atty.

Even the playing field.

Sent from my SM-G920V using Tapatalk

Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: zippz on September 05, 2018, 08:13:30 PM
Here's a better direct link to the video. http://hawaiicounty.granicus.com/MediaPlayer.php?view_id=1&clip_id=1185 (http://hawaiicounty.granicus.com/MediaPlayer.php?view_id=1&clip_id=1185).  The lady goes over suicide stats a lot which has nothing to do with public carry.

Other testimonies
1:57
2:05:30



Should've brought up that the county will still have to pay attorney's fees to Beck and Stamboulieh if they lose.  Those fees will rise sharply with each appeal and will cost $1million+ if we win at SCOTUS.
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: RSN172 on September 05, 2018, 08:42:33 PM
They will win if, or should I say, when Kavanaugh gets confirmed.
Title: Re: County of Hawaii Council meeting re. hiring outside legal counsel for Young case
Post by: punaperson on September 05, 2018, 08:53:03 PM
Should've brought up that the county will still have to pay attorney's fees to Beck and Stamboulieh if they lose.  Those fees will rise sharply with each appeal and will cost $1million+ if we win at SCOTUS.
That would have made no difference in the argument nor the vote because 1. the county council has no say at all in what the state will do, and 2. the state will likely file for en banc whether the county would do so separately or not, so even if the county were to not file for en banc, the state still would and thus subject the county to the same financial liability in case of loss as if the county was participating, and 3. everything the Office of the Corporation Counsel said in their letter to the council re resolution 666 was that the reason the county should approve the intergovernmental agreement was that both the state and county would file for en banc separately if not together and the county doesn't have the "legal expertise"to pursue the case at the en banc and cert level on its own, and 4. the county may or may not have to payout in the event of an eventual loss because their financial liability may be covered by the state.