2aHawaii

General Topics => Political Discussion => Topic started by: eyeeatingfish on September 11, 2018, 11:47:56 PM

Title: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 11, 2018, 11:47:56 PM
EDIT: I figured the poll part out.

The controversial article in the New York Times recently and Bob Woodward's new book seem to make similar claims about how Trump behaves in the Whitehouse. A previous book made some of the same types of allegations about the president's behavior as well.

So whether you like Trump or not, agree with him or not, do you believe the claims that are being made about Trump? Do you believe the reports about how Trump treats his staff and how many of them secretly have negative opinions about Trump's behavior? Or do you think they were fabricated at some level?
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: Inspector on September 12, 2018, 09:04:00 AM
I think there is little to some truth in there. But like most or all anonymous sourced books/articles most of it is highly exaggerated. If you want to believe some of what is in his book then he accidentally (or purposely) debunks the MSM’s Russian collusion hoax. Also, it is too much of a coincidence that the NYT op-ed comes out a day after and says almost word for word some of the the same things. So it sounds like it might be just one person trying to make extra money by leaking info and lies. Either way, there are always two sides to everything and a person who only wants to believe one side of anonymous sourced and written things without hearing the other side is a fool. Especially when most of the book and op-ed articles have been debunked already and reliable sources claim that some of these anonymous sourced items are lies.

So do I want to believe anonymous sources about anything? I think I am smarter than to fall for such diatribe. JMHO
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 12, 2018, 09:52:37 AM
Are all the stories true like in Omorosa's book?

A broken clock is right twice a day reference comes to mind.

I don't think he treats his staff bad, because he knows lawsuits are waiting to happen and that the dems will fund any and all lawsuits.  People may think they're being treated bad (getting fired), but it's because you're not doing your job.  This has been Trumps philosophy for a while now.  Don't do your job, "You're Fired".  Which is what I like about him.  The days of being in a position and doing nothing are over.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: punaperson on September 12, 2018, 10:11:08 AM
Let's see. All the accusations could be true. All the accusations could be false. Some accusations could be true. Some accusations could be false.

The only people that "know" whether an accusation is true or false are the people who were present at the incident. We have contradictory claims from some of those claimed to be present compared to the accounts of either "anonymous sources" and/or "disgruntled former employees".

One could extrapolate from previous incidents involving some of those same people/reporters/authors and conclude that they are now continuing that pattern of being correct or being wrong. That would be guesswork, supposition, and assuming that past perfornmance guarantees future results.

Without unedited/unaltered video or audio evidence... none of us will ever know the truth about those reported incidents.

I only know one thing:

TRUMP 2020
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 12, 2018, 12:49:59 PM
Let's see. All the accusations could be true. All the accusations could be false. Some accusations could be true. Some accusations could be false.

The only people that "know" whether an accusation is true or false are the people who were present at the incident. We have contradictory claims from some of those claimed to be present compared to the accounts of either "anonymous sources" and/or "disgruntled former employees".

One could extrapolate from previous incidents involving some of those same people/reporters/authors and conclude that they are now continuing that pattern of being correct or being wrong. That would be guesswork, supposition, and assuming that past perfornmance guarantees future results.

Without unedited/unaltered video or audio evidence... none of us will ever know the truth about those reported incidents.

I only know one thing:

TRUMP 2020

There have already been people in both Omarosa's and Woodward's books, and in the OpEd, who said the words or actions attributed to them never happened.

Falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: drck1000 on September 12, 2018, 01:11:16 PM
Appearance of impropriety.  That's what this is all about.  I haven't read much about what is contained in the book, op-eds, etc.  At least not yet. 

I was listening to a Woodward interview.  I think it was on NPR.  Woodward was asked what he had hoped would come out of the release of the book.  He mentioned something like that it would "start conversations".  That even before the book was released, the speculation on what was in the book was "truly exciting".  That folks were getting energized by the potential fallout from this book and that drove popularity without anyone having even read a word.  That told me quite a bit. . .

Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 12, 2018, 04:45:33 PM
(https://i.imgur.com/0ih5NwV.jpg)
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: RSN172 on September 12, 2018, 10:34:02 PM
It's on the Internet, it's in a published book, so it must be true.  ;D
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: punaperson on September 13, 2018, 12:56:51 PM
(https://media.townhall.com/Townhall/Car/b/stg091318dAPR20180913024506.jpg)
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 13, 2018, 11:04:50 PM
I think there is little to some truth in there. But like most or all anonymous sourced books/articles most of it is highly exaggerated. If you want to believe some of what is in his book then he accidentally (or purposely) debunks the MSM’s Russian collusion hoax. Also, it is too much of a coincidence that the NYT op-ed comes out a day after and says almost word for word some of the the same things. So it sounds like it might be just one person trying to make extra money by leaking info and lies. Either way, there are always two sides to everything and a person who only wants to believe one side of anonymous sourced and written things without hearing the other side is a fool. Especially when most of the book and op-ed articles have been debunked already and reliable sources claim that some of these anonymous sourced items are lies.

So do I want to believe anonymous sources about anything? I think I am smarter than to fall for such diatribe. JMHO

The op-ed saying a lot of the same things could be seen as indications of dishonesty, but it could also be indications of corroboration. Hard to know if they had anything to do with each other. Woodward might have been using the author of the op-ed as one of his sources which would explain the similarities either way.

I do know that being anonymous doesn't inherently discount what is being reported. There are many valid reasons for someone wanting to remain anonymous.

I haven't seen proof that what the book claims are lies. Only contradictory evidence I see are Trump's staff saying that they never said those things. Of course it could be because those things are lies, but it could also be because they don't want to admit saying bad things about Trump.

To me, one of the things that lends credibility to the anonymous source's claims is that the behavior alleged by Trump seems rather consistent with stuff he already says publicly. Of course it could be a well manufactured lie, but many of the things being reported in the book aren't exactly a surprise given what he tweets and says in public.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 13, 2018, 11:08:19 PM
Are all the stories true like in Omorosa's book?

A broken clock is right twice a day reference comes to mind.

I don't think he treats his staff bad, because he knows lawsuits are waiting to happen and that the dems will fund any and all lawsuits.  People may think they're being treated bad (getting fired), but it's because you're not doing your job.  This has been Trumps philosophy for a while now.  Don't do your job, "You're Fired".  Which is what I like about him.  The days of being in a position and doing nothing are over.

Why would Trump get sued for treating his staff bad? I mean I could see if he committed sexual harassment.

Seems they would be more worried about getting sued by him given the NDAs he had them sign.

Trump has publicly said negative things about some of the people who he hired that were doing their job though.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 13, 2018, 11:13:45 PM
There have already been people in both Omarosa's and Woodward's books, and in the OpEd, who said the words or actions attributed to them never happened.

Falsus in uno, falsus in omnibus.

And do you believe them just because they publicly said so?

There are many good reasons why they would lie and deny such allegations. Think about it, if you said something bad about your boss behind his back and someone told on you, would you admit it or deny it? If you needed the job or you would be faced with an NDA it would be very understandable for you to deny saying bad things about your boss.

The fact these people denied the allegations really doesn't prove anything one way or the other.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 14, 2018, 01:22:36 AM
And do you believe them just because they publicly said so?

There are many good reasons why they would lie and deny such allegations. Think about it, if you said something bad about your boss behind his back and someone told on you, would you admit it or deny it? If you needed the job or you would be faced with an NDA it would be very understandable for you to deny saying bad things about your boss.

The fact these people denied the allegations really doesn't prove anything one way or the other.

You'd be a fool to believe someone writing a book for purely financial gain is more credible than the "sources" who claim their quotes are fabricated or taken out of context.

People know who and what Woodward is. They know anything they say could get publicized. It would have the same effect as the quotes being used without permission.  they wouldn't;t say these things. Period.

From what I read, the vast majority of Woodward's quotes are not exact quotes (even though he portrays them in quotation marks).  They are recollections of what the source remembers saying (could have been paraphrased or misremembered), or secondhand recounting of what someone said. Woodward counts a second-or third-hand report of someone's words as a quote by the source, but doesn't make it apparent to the reader it's hearsay.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: macsak on September 14, 2018, 05:15:35 AM
I haven't seen proof that what the book claims are lies.

have you seen proof that what the book claims are the truth?
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: punaperson on September 14, 2018, 07:11:39 AM
Woodward is threatening to release "tapes" if the people saying that his claims about their "quotes" are lies don't recant and admit that what Woodward wrote are true quotes.

Perfect. Release the "tapes". The original versions, so they can be subject to forensic investigation. That should settle that. My only question is why is he "threatening" to release them rather than actually release them? Why just "say" "people are lying about what they said", when you could easily "prove" that by simply releasing the tapes? Something doesn't smell right.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 14, 2018, 12:17:24 PM
Woodward is threatening to release "tapes" if the people saying that his claims about their "quotes" are lies don't recant and admit that what Woodward wrote are true quotes.

Perfect. Release the "tapes". The original versions, so they can be subject to forensic investigation. That should settle that. My only question is why is he "threatening" to release them rather than actually release them? Why just "say" "people are lying about what they said", when you could easily "prove" that by simply releasing the tapes? Something doesn't smell right.

Because his tapes aren't the actual quotes.  They are sources who told him they may have said, heard, or was told someone else heard a statement.  All it does is show he trusted his sources, but there's no corroborating evidence to substantiate the sources.

Poor journalism.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 14, 2018, 12:36:23 PM
Because his tapes aren't the actual quotes.  They are sources who told him they may have said, heard, or was told someone else heard a statement.  All it does is show he trusted his sources, but there's no corroborating evidence to substantiate the sources.

Poor journalism.

Dont you know, all you need to do is say "source" and you can make up what every story you want.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 14, 2018, 01:02:01 PM
Dont you know, all you need to do is say "source" and you can make up what every story you want.

I thought we learned better during the McCarthy hearings ...  Maybe they stopped teaching US history in US History classes?
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: drck1000 on September 14, 2018, 02:38:45 PM
Woodward is threatening to release "tapes" if the people saying that his claims about their "quotes" are lies don't recant and admit that what Woodward wrote are true quotes.

Perfect. Release the "tapes". The original versions, so they can be subject to forensic investigation. That should settle that. My only question is why is he "threatening" to release them rather than actually release them? Why just "say" "people are lying about what they said", when you could easily "prove" that by simply releasing the tapes? Something doesn't smell right.
The threat of information make for more sensational “news” than actually information, whether it be truth or fabrication.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 14, 2018, 10:00:32 PM
I am listening to a podcast called 1A and the topic is about "The Deep State" and whether there are individuals oar an entity functioning in the government that serves to challenge the president. It is kind of interesting with the historical examples being mentioned and whether they could be seen as good or bad. The general tone of the conversation was that the New York Times Op-ed was accurate but then whether it was an action of someone in the deep state and what the aim was.

An interesting idea was brought up that I hadn't considered earlier and that is that the op-ed was written not to badmouth the president or undermine public confidence, but to undermine the president's confidence in his staff. Maybe to cause his office to fall apart from the inside due to mistrust. That idea adds a whole new layer to the question of what is alleged in the book and op-ed.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 14, 2018, 10:14:30 PM
You'd be a fool to believe someone writing a book for purely financial gain is more credible than the "sources" who claim their quotes are fabricated or taken out of context.

People know who and what Woodward is. They know anything they say could get publicized. It would have the same effect as the quotes being used without permission.  they wouldn't;t say these things. Period.

From what I read, the vast majority of Woodward's quotes are not exact quotes (even though he portrays them in quotation marks).  They are recollections of what the source remembers saying (could have been paraphrased or misremembered), or secondhand recounting of what someone said. Woodward counts a second-or third-hand report of someone's words as a quote by the source, but doesn't make it apparent to the reader it's hearsay.

What reason do I have to believe that Woodward is making a book purely for financial gain?

Deepthroat from the Watergate scandal publicly denied be the source for decades until he decided to make his name public.

A good journalist is going to make clear to his anonymous source (anonymous to others, not to the journalist) and go over the details of what is on and off the record, what they want to put in the story, etc. So if say Gen. Mattis were the source, he and Woodward could very well come to an agreement that the allegation would be in the book but that publicly he would deny it. Now even if the source were not the person who made the comments but a third party present and stated that Gen. Mattis said this or that, of course Gen Mattis is going to deny it even if it is true. If these allegations are true then there are many perfectly reasonable reasons to deny them publicly.

Sometimes people do "the right thing" under the condition of anonymity and deny it if confronted. I see no real reason that the public denying of these allegations disproves them. Besides, as the old adage goes, politicians are always lying to us right?
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 14, 2018, 10:18:41 PM
have you seen proof that what the book claims are the truth?

Not personally, no.

I know Woodward stated that he has hours of recorded interviews that he would consider releasing and I know that many of the allegations are consistent with the way Trump talks publicly. I think there are reasons to consider the allegations could be accurate.

But ultimately I am only interested in the truth. I don't want the allegations to be true nor do I want them to be false, I only want to know whether they are true.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 14, 2018, 10:23:19 PM
Woodward is threatening to release "tapes" if the people saying that his claims about their "quotes" are lies don't recant and admit that what Woodward wrote are true quotes.

Perfect. Release the "tapes". The original versions, so they can be subject to forensic investigation. That should settle that. My only question is why is he "threatening" to release them rather than actually release them? Why just "say" "people are lying about what they said", when you could easily "prove" that by simply releasing the tapes? Something doesn't smell right.

A valid question but there could be some issues. Agreements between Woodward and a source for starters. Also in hours of conversation there may be stuff that was said that was off the record such as personal details that should not be released and that the recording would need to have parts of it redacted first. I don't know if that is the case or not but those are some of the possibilities of why he hasn't yet released the tapes.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 14, 2018, 11:52:32 PM
What reason do I have to believe that Woodward is making a book purely for financial gain?

Deepthroat from the Watergate scandal publicly denied be the source for decades until he decided to make his name public.

A good journalist is going to make clear to his anonymous source (anonymous to others, not to the journalist) and go over the details of what is on and off the record, what they want to put in the story, etc. So if say Gen. Mattis were the source, he and Woodward could very well come to an agreement that the allegation would be in the book but that publicly he would deny it. Now even if the source were not the person who made the comments but a third party present and stated that Gen. Mattis said this or that, of course Gen Mattis is going to deny it even if it is true. If these allegations are true then there are many perfectly reasonable reasons to deny them publicly.

Sometimes people do "the right thing" under the condition of anonymity and deny it if confronted. I see no real reason that the public denying of these allegations disproves them. Besides, as the old adage goes, politicians are always lying to us right?

Watergate was about a President that supposedly knew about a crime.

This latest book is about calling Trump a meanie.

There is no morally redeeming value in a "hit piece" type of book.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: Inspector on September 15, 2018, 06:59:19 AM
I am listening to a podcast called 1A and the topic is about "The Deep State" and whether there are individuals oar an entity functioning in the government that serves to challenge the president. It is kind of interesting with the historical examples being mentioned and whether they could be seen as good or bad. The general tone of the conversation was that the New York Times Op-ed was accurate but then whether it was an action of someone in the deep state and what the aim was.

An interesting idea was brought up that I hadn't considered earlier and that is that the op-ed was written not to badmouth the president or undermine public confidence, but to undermine the president's confidence in his staff. Maybe to cause his office to fall apart from the inside due to mistrust. That idea adds a whole new layer to the question of what is alleged in the book and op-ed.
Are you saying then that due to the book and the op-ed that the MSM is now admitting that there actually is a deep state or shadow government in the Trump administration? If so, do you think they should apologize to Trump for mocking and making fun of him when he suggested the same? Just curious.

Isn’t it a contradiction that the person in the Trump administration that wrote the op-ed who is undermining the presidents efforts is trying to undermine the president’s confidence in his staff? If the op-ed is successful in undermining Trumps confidence in his staff I would think that would work against the writer who is operating within the administration due to Trumps confidence in his staff. If trump starts firing people he could fire the same people who are part of the shadow government. They operate in secret because Trump has confidence in them to do their job. That doesn’t seem right to me.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: drck1000 on September 15, 2018, 07:37:36 AM
Are you saying then that due to the book and the op-ed that the MSM is now admitting that there actually is a deep state or shadow government in the Trump administration? If so, do you think they should apologize to Trump for mocking and making fun of him when he suggested the same? Just curious.

Isn’t it a contradiction that the person in the Trump administration that wrote the op-ed who is undermining the presidents efforts is trying to undermine the president’s confidence in his staff? If the op-ed is successful in undermining Trumps confidence in his staff I would think that would work against the writer who is operating within the administration due to Trumps confidence in his staff. If trump starts firing people he could fire the same people who are part of the shadow government. They operate in secret because Trump has confidence in them to do their job. That doesn’t seem right to me.
You’re trying to find reason with unreasonable people.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: Inspector on September 15, 2018, 07:41:19 AM
You’re trying to find reason with unreasonable people.
Yeah, I should have known better.  :o :o :o
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 16, 2018, 09:25:15 PM
Watergate was about a President that supposedly knew about a crime.

This latest book is about calling Trump a meanie.

There is no morally redeeming value in a "hit piece" type of book.

I disagree. Just because a publican official has not committed a crime does not mean that they haven't done things that raise serious ethical or moral issues that maybe the public should know about. 

Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 16, 2018, 09:38:19 PM
Are you saying then that due to the book and the op-ed that the MSM is now admitting that there actually is a deep state or shadow government in the Trump administration? If so, do you think they should apologize to Trump for mocking and making fun of him when he suggested the same? Just curious.

Isn’t it a contradiction that the person in the Trump administration that wrote the op-ed who is undermining the presidents efforts is trying to undermine the president’s confidence in his staff? If the op-ed is successful in undermining Trumps confidence in his staff I would think that would work against the writer who is operating within the administration due to Trumps confidence in his staff. If trump starts firing people he could fire the same people who are part of the shadow government. They operate in secret because Trump has confidence in them to do their job. That doesn’t seem right to me.

The podcast just seemed to be discussing all the ways and forms a deep state could exist and how it could do what it does. It wasn't illuminati level conspiracy, rather something much more possible, like how Hoover influenced politicians using the FBI.

Not everyone in the podcast (one of them was a Trump strategist IIRC) even agreed such a thing existed. The discussion wasn't really trying to prove anything in particular.

I just thought the discussion and idea interesting since my poll design hadn't incorporated it. I guess the answers would cover it technically but the motive wasn't. Writing such a letter as this could have multiple possible motives.

There is a very valid moral question though that you touched on. Assuming the allegations are true that leaves the author two basic steps. Either speak out about what they believe is wrong knowing they will likely lose their job and may even be sued, or remain within the administration without speaking out but trying to mitigate the damage they believe is happening. It isn't clear which one would have a bigger effect on changing what is going on in the Whitehouse.

One of the allegations in the book was that Trump asked to have a foreign leader assassinated and General Mattis said ok but when Trump walked away he said to the others present we won't be doing that. Now if true, what does one do with that? Follow through because it was an order, wait till he forgets about it, resign in protest?

How about next time you let me answer before suggesting you can't find reason.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 17, 2018, 02:12:07 AM
I disagree. Just because a publican official has not committed a crime does not mean that they haven't done things that raise serious ethical or moral issues that maybe the public should know about.

Of course you disagree.  People who are wrong all the time tend to do that often, if not constantly.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: Inspector on September 17, 2018, 04:58:45 AM
The podcast just seemed to be discussing all the ways and forms a deep state could exist and how it could do what it does. It wasn't illuminati level conspiracy, rather something much more possible, like how Hoover influenced politicians using the FBI.

Not everyone in the podcast (one of them was a Trump strategist IIRC) even agreed such a thing existed. The discussion wasn't really trying to prove anything in particular.

I just thought the discussion and idea interesting since my poll design hadn't incorporated it. I guess the answers would cover it technically but the motive wasn't. Writing such a letter as this could have multiple possible motives.

There is a very valid moral question though that you touched on. Assuming the allegations are true that leaves the author two basic steps. Either speak out about what they believe is wrong knowing they will likely lose their job and may even be sued, or remain within the administration without speaking out but trying to mitigate the damage they believe is happening. It isn't clear which one would have a bigger effect on changing what is going on in the Whitehouse.

One of the allegations in the book was that Trump asked to have a foreign leader assassinated and General Mattis said ok but when Trump walked away he said to the others present we won't be doing that. Now if true, what does one do with that? Follow through because it was an order, wait till he forgets about it, resign in protest?

How about next time you let me answer before suggesting you can't find reason.
I think motive is very important here. Which brings me to the motive of the people writing and publishing these things. There is the possibility, a great possibility IMHO due to past reputations of Woodward and the NYT, that all of this may have been made up as well. As long as the sources remain anonymous, there is very little validity to all of this. Just like in the Kavanaugh case. As long as his accuser remained anonymous it is really a nothing burger. Now that she has come forth and is willing to testify, her accusations went from unbelievable to let’s see if she is believable. It’s the same for the op-ed and Woodward’s book. Anonymous is a nothing burger. All these writings are nothing more than suggestions of impropriety. If and when the sources become known and are willing to come forward and testify, then we can have all of the facts for us to make up our minds. I just think it is ridiculous for anyone to consider any of this nothing burger as real until we have the identities, testimonies and all the facts here. JMHO
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 17, 2018, 08:44:22 PM
Of course you disagree.  People who are wrong all the time tend to do that often, if not constantly.

Oh, I see your logic. If I disagree with you I must be wrong. Gotcha.

Didn't realize you were the arbiter of truth.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 17, 2018, 08:59:57 PM
I think motive is very important here. Which brings me to the motive of the people writing and publishing these things. There is the possibility, a great possibility IMHO due to past reputations of Woodward and the NYT, that all of this may have been made up as well. As long as the sources remain anonymous, there is very little validity to all of this. Just like in the Kavanaugh case. As long as his accuser remained anonymous it is really a nothing burger. Now that she has come forth and is willing to testify, her accusations went from unbelievable to let’s see if she is believable. It’s the same for the op-ed and Woodward’s book. Anonymous is a nothing burger. All these writings are nothing more than suggestions of impropriety. If and when the sources become known and are willing to come forward and testify, then we can have all of the facts for us to make up our minds. I just think it is ridiculous for anyone to consider any of this nothing burger as real until we have the identities, testimonies and all the facts here. JMHO

I agree, motive is an important thing to consider but there are lots of potential motives, some honorable, some not.

I forgot to mention this earlier, but one of the things that gives credence to the NYT Op-ed is that Trump was demanding the identify of the author be released. If the accusations were completely fabricated and in no way came from someone inside the whitehouse why demand an identity? I think that corroborates some of the claims.

I agree that anonymity means the claim should be looked at more skeptically but I also know that there are valid reasons for wanting to remain anonymous. It is easy to be principled about speaking out publicly but in reality, when the wheels hit the road a lot of people are too scared, shy, ashamed, etc to publicly identify themselves but do still report things. I agree that if the author really did see and hear everything he/she claimed then he/she should speak out publicly and that it would strengthen the allegations but I can also understand reasons why they don't. So I certainly don't consider the op-ed to be  canon by any means but it isn't a nothing burger.

Let me ask you this, say this person did come out publicly and was an official higher up in the food chain of the whitehouse. Would you believe the claims? And if the claims were all true, what do you think should be done about it?
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 17, 2018, 10:30:47 PM
Oh, I see your logic. If I disagree with you I must be wrong. Gotcha.

Didn't realize you were the arbiter of truth.

If I told you I am, you'd just disagree again ... and we know what that means.   :rofl:
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: Inspector on September 18, 2018, 07:02:29 AM
I agree, motive is an important thing to consider but there are lots of potential motives, some honorable, some not.

I forgot to mention this earlier, but one of the things that gives credence to the NYT Op-ed is that Trump was demanding the identify of the author be released. If the accusations were completely fabricated and in no way came from someone inside the whitehouse why demand an identity? I think that corroborates some of the claims.
You are missing the possibility that he is calling their bluff. Which I think makes it look like a nothing burger until all the identities and facts are in place so we the people can make up our own minds. NYT demands transparency from the Trump administration, yet they hope and expect that people will believe the least transparent of all op-Ed’s. And will not provide transparency themselves. Hypocrites. Hypocrites=Liars IMHO.

I agree that anonymity means the claim should be looked at more skeptically but I also know that there are valid reasons for wanting to remain anonymous. It is easy to be principled about speaking out publicly but in reality, when the wheels hit the road a lot of people are too scared, shy, ashamed, etc to publicly identify themselves but do still report things. I agree that if the author really did see and hear everything he/she claimed then he/she should speak out publicly and that it would strengthen the allegations but I can also understand reasons why they don't. So I certainly don't consider the op-ed to be  canon by any means but it isn't a nothing burger.
Obviously you don’t consider this a nothing burger. This is your opinion only backed up by your feelings because without transparency, there are no facts. Only feelings.

Let me ask you this, say this person did come out publicly and was an official higher up in the food chain of the whitehouse. Would you believe the claims? And if the claims were all true, what do you think should be done about it?
Assuming there even is a real person you mean? You seem to keep deleting that this is a huge possibility. And assuming that the person (if real) is really in a high enough position to have some knowledge? Don’t forget about the lies the NYT seems to like to print and the last NYT anonymous op-ed written that turned out the source was a low level clerk when the claim was a high level person. I have already stated that we should know all of the facts of these allegations before we can determine what the truth is. Without them, we cannot even begin to know the truth. And as I already stated that there is usually some truth to these types of allegations once all the facts are in place assuming the op-ed facts and the source are revealed. So you already knew my answer prior to asking the question. As far as what should be done, it all depends upon what exactly it turns out to be true. Without that knowledge, I cannot begin to know how the things that may turn out to be true should be handled.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 18, 2018, 09:53:37 AM
You are missing the possibility that he is calling their bluff. Which I think makes it look like a nothing burger until all the identities and facts are in place so we the people can make up our own minds. NYT demands transparency from the Trump administration, yet they hope and expect that people will believe the least transparent of all op-Ed’s. And will not provide transparency themselves. Hypocrites. Hypocrites=Liars IMHO.
Obviously you don’t consider this a nothing burger. This is your opinion only backed up by your feelings because without transparency, there are no facts. Only feelings.
Assuming there even is a real person you mean? You seem to keep deleting that this is a huge possibility. And assuming that the person (if real) is really in a high enough position to have some knowledge? Don’t forget about the lies the NYT seems to like to print and the last NYT anonymous op-ed written that turned out the source was a low level clerk when the claim was a high level person. I have already stated that we should know all of the facts of these allegations before we can determine what the truth is. Without them, we cannot even begin to know the truth. And as I already stated that there is usually some truth to these types of allegations once all the facts are in place assuming the op-ed facts and the source are revealed. So you already knew my answer prior to asking the question. As far as what should be done, it all depends upon what exactly it turns out to be true. Without that knowledge, I cannot begin to know how the things that may turn out to be true should be handled.

The purpose of this "survey" was to find people who can take EEF's side on these latest Trump hit-pieces.  Nothing more.

In absence of support and agreement, he's using every Liberal tactic in his arsenal to argue against logic and reason. Innuendo, rumor, assumptions and hypotheticals are not facts, but to hear him use them, they cannot be ignored without allowing Trump a pass.

That, to EEF, is totally unacceptable -- what with his "higher standards" and all that.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 18, 2018, 09:10:16 PM
The purpose of this "survey" was to find people who can take EEF's side on these latest Trump hit-pieces.  Nothing more.


Yes, I am using an anonymous survey to identify people.  :wacko:
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 18, 2018, 09:31:59 PM
You are missing the possibility that he is calling their bluff. Which I think makes it look like a nothing burger until all the identities and facts are in place so we the people can make up our own minds. NYT demands transparency from the Trump administration, yet they hope and expect that people will believe the least transparent of all op-Ed’s. And will not provide transparency themselves. Hypocrites. Hypocrites=Liars IMHO.

You are right, Trump might be trying to call a bluff, I doubt it but it is certainly a possibility that shouldn't be discounted.
But I would say the conclusions that the NYT is hypercritical is unfounded. It is the author's choice to remain anonymous, not the choice of the New York Times. The NYT entered into an agreement with the author that the letter be published and the identity not be given up, they have to honor that agreement or people won't trust them to supply information. That is why some journalists have gone to prison before, they received information with an agreement to protect the identity.

Quote
Obviously you don’t consider this a nothing burger. This is your opinion only backed up by your feelings because without transparency, there are no facts. Only feelings.

Not true, feelings are irrelevant and I don't possess any feelings about this. This conversation should be seen as nothing more than an objective analysis of all the information publicly available. There is no aim to prove the letter true or prove it false. I am sorry if considering the letter could be valid makes you think I have some feeling or desire but you are mistaken.
Unfortunately the tone of this thread seems more interested in defending Trump than it does in being objective.

Quote
Assuming there even is a real person you mean? You seem to keep deleting that this is a huge possibility. And assuming that the person (if real) is really in a high enough position to have some knowledge? Don’t forget about the lies the NYT seems to like to print and the last NYT anonymous op-ed written that turned out the source was a low level clerk when the claim was a high level person. I have already stated that we should know all of the facts of these allegations before we can determine what the truth is. Without them, we cannot even begin to know the truth. And as I already stated that there is usually some truth to these types of allegations once all the facts are in place assuming the op-ed facts and the source are revealed. So you already knew my answer prior to asking the question. As far as what should be done, it all depends upon what exactly it turns out to be true. Without that knowledge, I cannot begin to know how the things that may turn out to be true should be handled.

Well yes, the question inherently relies on the assumption that the person is real. The question would be moot if we did not assume the person to be real for the sake of that line of questioning. Ok, so your answer is basically "it depends" but that isn't really an answer because I specifically set out the terms of the question of all the claims being true and it being an actual high level official. And the point of asking that the anonymous source go public is that for some (maybe not you) it really wouldn't change anything. People have publicly made comments about Trump before and it doesn't seem to give them any more credibility compared to being anonymous and it doesn't seem like it changes anyone's mind.

And no, I never discounted the possibility that there is no real person who wrote the letter. That is why I included one of the questions in the poll was covering that specific possibility.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: Inspector on September 19, 2018, 05:17:46 AM
You are right, Trump might be trying to call a bluff, I doubt it but it is certainly a possibility that shouldn't be discounted.
But I would say the conclusions that the NYT is hypercritical is unfounded. It is the author's choice to remain anonymous, not the choice of the New York Times. The NYT entered into an agreement with the author that the letter be published and the identity not be given up, they have to honor that agreement or people won't trust them to supply information. That is why some journalists have gone to prison before, they received information with an agreement to protect the identity.

Not true, feelings are irrelevant and I don't possess any feelings about this. This conversation should be seen as nothing more than an objective analysis of all the information publicly available. There is no aim to prove the letter true or prove it false. I am sorry if considering the letter could be valid makes you think I have some feeling or desire but you are mistaken.
Unfortunately the tone of this thread seems more interested in defending Trump than it does in being objective.

Well yes, the question inherently relies on the assumption that the person is real. The question would be moot if we did not assume the person to be real for the sake of that line of questioning. Ok, so your answer is basically "it depends" but that isn't really an answer because I specifically set out the terms of the question of all the claims being true and it being an actual high level official. And the point of asking that the anonymous source go public is that for some (maybe not you) it really wouldn't change anything. People have publicly made comments about Trump before and it doesn't seem to give them any more credibility compared to being anonymous and it doesn't seem like it changes anyone's mind.

And no, I never discounted the possibility that there is no real person who wrote the letter. That is why I included one of the questions in the poll was covering that specific possibility.
I am sorry I got into this circular conversation with you. I understand what you are trying to do here but I know that you don’t understand nor see what the rest of us do and how frustrating these circular conversations can be. I don’t need nor want to be enlightened by you. I do my own DD. It is not only frustrating but you are insulting and when someone calls out your insult you deny being insulting. When I call BS and say there is no proof of what happened here, you come back and say there is proof but you do not provide anything to back up your claim. So I’m done wasting my time with these types of never ending conversations that go round and round and round and...
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 19, 2018, 11:27:34 AM
I am sorry I got into this circular conversation with you. I understand what you are trying to do here but I know that you don’t understand nor see what the rest of us do and how frustrating these circular conversations can be. I don’t need nor want to be enlightened by you. I do my own DD. It is not only frustrating but you are insulting and when someone calls out your insult you deny being insulting. When I call BS and say there is no proof of what happened here, you come back and say there is proof but you do not provide anything to back up your claim. So I’m done wasting my time with these types of never ending conversations that go round and round and round and...

As I said many times, he likes to argue more about what someone said/meant than the topic.  That's completely unproductive and irritating. 
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: robtmc on September 19, 2018, 05:01:38 PM
I am sorry I got into this circular conversation with you. I understand what you are trying to do here but I know that you don’t understand nor see what the rest of us do

That is where the ignore function is nice.  Now if people will stop quoting the HPD troll, he will be all but invisible.
Title: Re: Do you believe accusations about Trump from the Op-Ed and Woodward's new Book?
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 21, 2018, 11:06:27 PM
I am sorry I got into this circular conversation with you. I understand what you are trying to do here but I know that you don’t understand nor see what the rest of us do and how frustrating these circular conversations can be. I don’t need nor want to be enlightened by you. I do my own DD. It is not only frustrating but you are insulting and when someone calls out your insult you deny being insulting. When I call BS and say there is no proof of what happened here, you come back and say there is proof but you do not provide anything to back up your claim. So I’m done wasting my time with these types of never ending conversations that go round and round and round and...

We are obviously looking at the same set of circumstances and coming to different conclusions. You think yours is right and I think mine is right. We have gone back and forth covering all the angles and still cannot agree so I guess we will just have to agree to disagree.

As for insults, my record on 2Ahawaii clearly shows I am not the first to throw blows. I may take positions that are not liked by some members but I never start off with ad hom attacks. This particular thread, though contentious, has actually been fairly tame. A few sarcastic replies and an insult by ROBTMC at the end but that is about it. Our exchanges were very civil though we disagreed and I mentioned multiple times that you brought up some valid points and questions though I don't feel you gave any of my points the same consideration but at least we disagreed civilly.

If you asked for proof of some assertion and I failed to prove it I apologize for missing it. Sometimes in all the posts and replying I miss something.