2aHawaii

General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: macsak on January 04, 2019, 10:44:57 AM

Title: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: macsak on January 04, 2019, 10:44:57 AM
sponsored by gabby giffords on the 8 year anniversary of her shooting
they are saying "97 percent of the country support background checks"
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 04, 2019, 12:05:35 PM
Can you post the link?

My google-fu showed its a water bill
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: macsak on January 04, 2019, 12:08:07 PM
Can you post the link?

My google-fu showed its a water bill

heads
https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/politics/house-dems-to-introduce-gun-backgrounds-checks-bill-on-tuesday/ar-BBROzSs?ocid=spartanntp
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 04, 2019, 12:20:52 PM
Interesting how that senator who got shot at the softball practice never introduced any infringements to the 2a.  Nor did anyone else at the practice due to the shooting.

Neither did the senator who was a high school student at the time of the Columbine shooting.

The diff, DNC vs. GOP.
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: tillamook on January 04, 2019, 01:34:13 PM
Imagine if there was a party where day one they were introducing pro-gun bills?  Sad that I'll never see the day. 
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 04, 2019, 01:40:06 PM
Imagine if there was a party where day one they were introducing pro-gun bills?  Sad that I'll never see the day.

I would say more like a party who undo's infringing laws. 

Background checks for private party sales sounds good, but then you would need a registration to keep track of the guns.  And that don't fly with many states.
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: zippz on January 04, 2019, 02:31:21 PM
I would say more like a party who undo's infringing laws. 

Background checks for private party sales sounds good, but then you would need a registration to keep track of the guns.  And that don't fly with many states.

It would have to go through an FFL or local LE.  Another option is to have individual call it in somehow for a background check and make them liable if they don't do the check or ignore a rejection.
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: mrgaf on January 04, 2019, 03:53:10 PM
Interesting how that senator who got shot at the softball practice never introduced any infringements to the 2a.  Nor did anyone else at the practice due to the shooting.

Neither did the senator who was a high school student at the time of the Columbine shooting.

The diff, DNC vs. GOP.

Simply because that senator has a brain and Gifford only half.....
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: tillamook on January 04, 2019, 04:26:39 PM
I would say more like a party who undo's infringing laws. 

Background checks for private party sales sounds good, but then you would need a registration to keep track of the guns.  And that don't fly with many states.

they added universal background checks in oregon stating there were 10-20 thousand private sales a month.  Several years later there are perhaps 300-400 a month actually checked..  Also extremely low denial rates with pretty much no arrests.   Lots of non-compliance and it turns out only the really stupid criminals go to a FFL to complete their background checks. 

At the same time they made the Curios and Relics 03 FFL illegal.  Since I guess of all those crimes with WWI bolt action guns. 

And then if you look at the actual records in the FBI NICS background check database these are the total listed records in Oregon by category.:
Felony: 2
Under Indictment: 0
Fugitive from Justice: 0
Unlawful user/addicted to a controlled substance 0
Illegal Alien  0
Dishonorable discharge 0
Renounced US citizenship 0
Restraining order for domestic Violence 0
Convicted of Domestic abuse 2

So despite making a law that all all private transfers are illegal without a background check, it turns out very few are bothering.  And then, the background check database has a total of 4 felonies and Domestic violence convictions to check 

On top of that, many of the counties that still respect the constitution said that they will not convict anyone if they dont do a private sale background check

another interesting fact.  Wyoming only lists 7 (seven) mental health records in the background check database.  Wyoming either has the most mentally stable people on the planet or the state is not actually reporting the records. 
Even more interesting??  Wyoming has the least "mass shootings" in all of the US every year.  They dont even bother reporting mental health disqualifiers and they have the least crazy people shooting up malls.  I wonder why that is?

See why a universal background checks are quite dumb without a reasonably functioning background check database?


Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 04, 2019, 06:09:22 PM
The NCIS doesnt get reported to by many states, even hawaii. IIRC the entire state of Alamaba has only 44 felons.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 07, 2019, 10:11:23 PM
I think the majority favor the idea of a background check but polls never go into the details that make or break a good and just background check system.
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: punaperson on January 08, 2019, 07:18:44 AM
https://www.wrdw.com/content/news/Dems-to-push-gun-control-on-anniversary-of-Giffords-shooting-503989451.html

Giffords, who co-founded a gun safety group with her husband, Mark Kelly, said in a statement Friday she was thrilled that her former House colleagues were responding to a gun-violence epidemic that killed nearly 40,000 people in 2017.

The bill expanding background checks "marks a critical first step toward strengthening America's gun laws and making our country a safer place to live, work, study, worship and play," Giffords said. "I stand ready to do everything in my power to get this legislation across the finish line."

Gabby gives a hint. Any questions?
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 08, 2019, 09:45:59 AM
Her bill would not have prevented her from getting shot...
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: punaperson on January 08, 2019, 12:52:44 PM
Her bill would not have prevented her from getting shot...
Nor any other victim of a "mass public shooting" in the 21st century. Like Giffords's attacker, they almost all passed background checks to lawfully acquire the firearm(s). The few that didn't pass background checks were the ones who stole the guns they used. Not one single one of the murderers acquired their guns via a "gun show loophole" private sale that would supposedly have been prevented by "universal background checks" ("the first step").
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 08, 2019, 01:01:21 PM
Nor any other victim of a "mass public shooting" in the 21st century. Like Giffords's attacker, they almost all passed background checks to lawfully acquire the firearm(s). The few that didn't pass background checks were the ones who stole the guns they used. Not one single one of the murderers acquired their guns via a "gun show loophole" private sale that would supposedly have been prevented by "universal background checks" ("the first step").

100% correct.  She is using emotion and her situation to get a bill passed.  Hope the senate rejects it. 
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 10, 2019, 09:32:24 PM
Nor any other victim of a "mass public shooting" in the 21st century. Like Giffords's attacker, they almost all passed background checks to lawfully acquire the firearm(s). The few that didn't pass background checks were the ones who stole the guns they used. Not one single one of the murderers acquired their guns via a "gun show loophole" private sale that would supposedly have been prevented by "universal background checks" ("the first step").

I wouldn't say it wouldn't have prevented any of them. Some of them may have been prevented, specifically instances where there were a lot of red flags ahead of time. However there were absolutely a large number where there were no significant warning signs and advanced background checks would not have prevented.
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: punaperson on January 11, 2019, 06:26:31 AM
I wouldn't say it wouldn't have prevented any of them.
Then you'd be wrong.


Some of them may have been prevented, specifically instances where there were a lot of red flags ahead of time.
They all passed background checks. So, you're wrong again.

However there were absolutely a large number where there were no significant warning signs and advanced background checks would not have prevented.
What's an "advanced background check"? There is no such thing as part of the bill for "universal background checks"... all it does is make private sales illegal. And of course, as stated above, people who steal guns or otherwise obtain them illegally don't submit to any background check, "advanced" or otherwise, and never will.
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: RSN172 on January 11, 2019, 06:56:15 AM
In states that do not require a permit to buy or registration, how would they know if A sold a gun to B in a private sale.  Another stupid law.
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 11, 2019, 08:52:33 AM
I wouldn't say it wouldn't have prevented any of them. Some of them may have been prevented, specifically instances where there were a lot of red flags ahead of time. However there were absolutely a large number where there were no significant warning signs and advanced background checks would not have prevented.

Red flags were all over Nick Cruz, but nothing was done.  So the million dollar question is how do you prevent something without violating rights (due process)?  Although some states have already violated them due to red flag laws (WA & FL).

Vegas was unforeseeable, well the CIA knew...

Pulse Night Club, FBI knew...

The list goes on how our LE who work very hard, but can let us down due to being human.  Mainly their failures are known, but not their successes.
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: punaperson on January 11, 2019, 09:20:30 AM
In states that do not require a permit to buy or registration, how would they know if A sold a gun to B in a private sale.  Another stupid law.
The people behind proposing these laws (not the rank and file stupid Demanding Moms, etc.) already know that "universal background checks" cannot "work" without a gun registry... even the DOJ published a study saying so. Thus they will pass the "universal background checks" and none of the stats re crime will change and they will say that is because the law cannot be effectively enforced without a registry, therefore we need gun registration. Of course that doesn't change anything either, as criminals are not known for following new laws when they didn't follow any of the old laws. I'd argue it's not a "stupid law" so much as it is a tactic in the arsenal of the civilian disarmament fascists in their incremental approach to achieving their ultimate goal... and they know the law (and all subsequent laws short of confiscation) will be "ineffective". That's what they want and how the whole "program" is designed. Makes one wonder what they have in mind that would be too difficult to carry out if civilians are armed.
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 11, 2019, 09:40:10 AM
Cool story, my friend moved to OK and worked late nights in the office sometimes.  Her boss handed her a pistol and said "here you can have this since you work late.  I want you to protect yourself".

OK has no registration and since they did the background check for employment, he knew she had no felonies.

She declined because she is uncomfortable with guns.  She was also freaked out when she saw people in OK open carrying.  But after a few months she didn't even care or notice.  She adjusted.
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: groveler on January 11, 2019, 01:10:21 PM
In states that do not require a permit to buy or registration, how would they know if A sold a gun to B in a private sale.  Another stupid law.
Do you really think anybody other than an idiot, registers their guns?
Or asks for permission to buy one?
I'm just curious.
I never violate any constitutional Federal, state or local laws.
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: RSN172 on January 11, 2019, 01:23:32 PM
Do you really think anybody other than an idiot, registers their guns?
Or asks for permission to buy one?
I'm just curious.
I never violate any constitutional Federal, state or local laws.
Judging by the success they had in Connecticut and the success they are having in NJ with the magazine ban, I would have to say no.  If you built up a 80%er, rifle or handgun, would you register it?  Don’t answer.  I know we all would because nobody here does anything illegal.
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 15, 2019, 08:14:42 PM
Then you'd be wrong.

They all passed background checks. So, you're wrong again.
What's an "advanced background check"? There is no such thing as part of the bill for "universal background checks"... all it does is make private sales illegal. And of course, as stated above, people who steal guns or otherwise obtain them illegally don't submit to any background check, "advanced" or otherwise, and never will.

How can you say they would have passed a hypothetical background check? The whole thread is around the topic of new "better" background checks, therefore you cannot state with certainty that 100% of them would pass these yet to exist background checks.
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 15, 2019, 08:31:05 PM
Red flags were all over Nick Cruz, but nothing was done. 

And that is their strongest argument for why a "newer better" background system needs to be implemented. Honestly it is a good argument because it hits us either way we respond. If we say current background checks don't work then they get to say that better background checks must be needed. But if we say background checks will never work then they simply say that we are right and therefore guns must be taken away.



Quote
So the million dollar question is how do you prevent something without violating rights (due process)?  Although some states have already violated them due to red flag laws (WA & FL).

You are right, this is the million dollar question and it is a very tough question. It is also where I feel that the gun rights crowd is failing. We seem to just be digging in and I fear we are losing. The 2nd amendment rights are being slowly eroded away and we need to be proactive in proposing real solutions to the problem. I think the liberals are winning because they can point to the NRA and gun rights groups and show that they really have done nothing to address the mental health issues as it relates to background checks. Some NRA spokesman says "the best way to stop a bag guy with a gun is a good guy with a gun" but that doesn't work very well when someone makes a machine gun nest and barricades themself inside while killing dozens of people. We need to address that million dollar question because if we don't we just look like we are refusing the problem.

Now I don't claim to be a genius, I don't have the perfect answer to that question. I know that no system will 100% protect rights and stop these guys at the same time. Now having said that I do think we could do better. I have some rough ideas on a system that could better address the red flags while at the same time be minimally restrictive of our rights. Sometimes information may justify a temporary revocation of rights and when that does happen, the appeals process for the person whose rights were restricted must be very quick. When police arrest someone they have 48 hours to get charges filed. That could be a start for a framework. I will stop there, if we want to have a discussion about gun rights group ideas on a better background check system we can start a separate thread.
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: punaperson on January 15, 2019, 08:53:58 PM
How can you say they would have passed a hypothetical background check? The whole thread is around the topic of new "better" background checks, therefore you cannot state with certainty that 100% of them would pass these yet to exist background checks.
:wtf: You're full of shit, or a liar, or just plain stupid... maybe all three.

Where did you get the plainly wrong idea that "The whole thread is around the topic of new "better" background checks"? No, NO it's not. It's about the title of the thread: HR8. Dumbass. Can't you even fucking read? I guess not. On page one of HR8, the bill referenced in the title of this thread, it says that the new law will  "utilize the current background checks process". Can you fucking read it now? Can you comprehend it now? You're just making shit up out of thin air. All this bill does, as I've and others have repeatedly written, is make a now legal private transfer (not in Hawaii of course where it's already illegal) illegal, as a felony. So if a father-in-law lends his daughter-in-law a gun to protect herself from a stalker without going to a gun store and formally transferring it for a nice fee, he is a felon. And, NO, IT'S NOT A "NEW 'BETTER' BACKGROUND CHECK".

I didn't say they would have passed a hypothetical background check, dumbass, I said they passed the existing background check, which is exactly the same background check that will be utilized by HR8 if it passes the House, the Senate, and Trump signs it. You think that criminals that now don't submit to background checks in acquiring firearms are suddenly going to do so in honor of their deep respect for Gabby?

SMH  :wtf:
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on January 15, 2019, 09:25:15 PM
DOJ: Less than 3 Percent of Nation’s Prisoners Acquired Firearms at Retail Stores, Gun Shows

Quote
A January 2019 Department of Justice report shows fewer than three percent of prisoners who used guns
in crime acquired those guns at retail stores or at a gun show.

The report, titled, “Source and Use of Firearms Involved in Crimes: Survey of Prison Inmates, 2016,” presents
information ascertained via face-to-face interviews with some of the nearly 300,000 prisoners who used a gun
in commission of a crime.

It shows that roughly “1.3 percent of prisoners obtained a gun from a retail source and used it during their
offense.” Only 0.8 percent of prisoners acquired their guns at a gun show.

The vast majority of all criminals–56 percent–stole their guns, acquired them at the scene of a crime, or got them
via the black market.

This information undercuts Democrat claims that expanding background checks will keep us safer.

Politico quoted Rep. Mike Thompson (D-CA) saying universal background check legislation “will help save lives.”
But how will it save lives if less than three percent of criminals acquire their guns at retail or gun show while the
vast majority steal or otherwise acquire them on the side?

https://www.breitbart.com/politics/2019/01/15/doj-less-3-percent-nations-prisoners-acquired-firearms-retail-gun-shows/
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 15, 2019, 11:01:28 PM
EEF, we have a mental health problem disguised as a gun problem.

How many active shooters had pharma drugs in their system. Once you do sufficient research about that, follow the money...

Look at that guy in his undies in Ross with the knife. He was released and deamed not crazy, then killed someone the next day. Because sane people go into Ross in their undies all the time.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 24, 2019, 06:57:55 PM
:wtf: You're full of shit, or a liar, or just plain stupid... maybe all three.

Where did you get the plainly wrong idea that "The whole thread is around the topic of new "better" background checks"? No, NO it's not.

Gosh, do you even read the thread? The post talked about a bill Gabby Gifford is planning on introducing. It hasn't been passed, it hasn't become law, hence it is a hypothetical.
Since you missed it apparently, I used quotation marks to illustrate they claim it to be a better system, not that I actually think it will be a better system. It is a bit of what we call sarcasm.


Quote
I didn't say they would have passed a hypothetical background check, dumbass, I said they passed the existing background check, which is exactly the same background check that will be utilized by HR8 if it passes the House, the Senate, and Trump signs it. You think that criminals that now don't submit to background checks in acquiring firearms are suddenly going to do so in honor of their deep respect for Gabby?

Apparently I have to post your own statement for you to read....  :wtf:

You piggy backed on changemyoil's statement that Gabby's bill would not have prevented her from being shot by saying
"Nor any other victim of a "mass public shooting" in the 21st century."

Now I am going to spell this out for you since you seem to have trouble following.
1. You are making a blanket statement about dozens/hundreds of incidences
2. The bill Gabby proposed does not yet exist as law
3. You are making an affirmative statement that this yet to exist law would not have caught a single individual.

Now maybe I am making a foolish assumption, maybe you have researched each mass shooting over the past 19 years, and maybe you tracked each gun and confirmed that none of the guns used in any of these shootings were ever sold to someone who would have failed a background check but I am betting you haven't.

Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 24, 2019, 07:34:13 PM
EEF, we have a mental health problem disguised as a gun problem.

How many active shooters had pharma drugs in their system. Once you do sufficient research about that, follow the money...

Look at that guy in his undies in Ross with the knife. He was released and deamed not crazy, then killed someone the next day. Because sane people go into Ross in their undies all the time.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Well yes and no. Our gun violence problem isn't limited to mental people shooting up random crowds but I do agree that when it comes to most of these mass shootings that it is a mental health problem.

I think that it is very important that we as a gun rights crowd try to do something so address that mental health otherwise we will continue to lose gun rights because it looks like we ignoring the problem instead of trying to solve it. We can't continuously say "that won't work".

The pharma question is a difficult one because often it remains unknown if the pharmaceuticals were the cause or the symptom. Was the killer murderous because of medications or was he on the medications because of his murderous thoughts? And the answer can be different for different medications.

The hard question that I think the gun rights crowd shies away from is when and how shall a mental diagnosis and/or use of certain medications disqualify someone (permanently or temporarily) from owning firearms. The second question is how to ensure that the system is able to screen transactions to the point that it can catch a significant number of these individuals.


I have a few ideas for a framework but they need a bit of work. I do keep thinking about how to bring it to an elected representative but the process is a little daunting.
Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: changemyoil66 on January 24, 2019, 08:23:08 PM
Its not a hard question. Majority of active shootings happen in gun free zones. So do Way and maybe a good guy with a gun can reduce the deaths.

Shortly after the batman shooting, a mall shooting also happened in OR. Good guy with a gun stopped it. Guess how much media attention it got?

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: HR8 2019- "universal background checks"
Post by: eyeeatingfish on January 25, 2019, 07:54:21 PM
Its not a hard question. Majority of active shootings happen in gun free zones. So do Way and maybe a good guy with a gun can reduce the deaths.

Shortly after the batman shooting, a mall shooting also happened in OR. Good guy with a gun stopped it. Guess how much media attention it got?

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Three reasons I don't think we should put all our eggs in that one basket:
1. It relies on a good guy with a gun being in the right place at the right time. Now of course sometimes this happens and when it does the casualties certainly decrease but statistically speaking there are still going to be times when there just isn't a good guy with a gun. In a shopping mall there are better odds but in a school the odds are much lower.
2. There will always be gun free zones. Places like bars, courthouses, etc. But I also don't see any evidence that a lack of gun free zones would deter these shooters, these people are often on a suicide mission. Of course they choose easier targets like schools but we have no reason to believe that they would simply give up if they couldn't find a gun free zone.
3. The good guy with a gun is a reactive response to the problem, not a pro-active one. It serves to reduce the body count but not to prevent the incident. Nothing wrong with reactive solutions but they shouldn't be the only answer.

There are also a number of examples where a good guy with a gun could really do nothing to stop the bad guy with the gun. The most notable would be the Las Vegas shooting. Note that I am not knocking on a good guy with a gun idea, I like it and I want to see it in Hawaii but it cannot be our only solution.

To add to the importance of being proactive, it is only a matter of time until someone thinks of a different way to cause mass casualties and once successful you will see copy cats. In fact I can think of a number of very violent means these crazies could rack up large body counts even without guns and in ways the good guy with a gun would simply be ineffective. I won't share them because I don't want to give anyone ideas but that is why I think we need proactive responses and not just reactive.