2aHawaii
General Topics => Legal and Activism => Topic started by: punaperson on June 06, 2019, 12:59:21 PM
-
Can't wait for Hawaii courts and Ninth Circuit to make a similar ruling! :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: But... I don't think I wanna be the test case. :geekdanc:
Pennsylvania is a long long long way from Hawaii physically. It's not even in the same universe philosophically regarding rights of citizens to keep and bear arms.
Speaking of bearing arms... since the state claims that anyone can apply for and be issued either an open carry or concealed carry license (if they meet a few minor requirements :D), has anyone ever seen any locations in Hawaii with the signs noting that no firearms are allowed, openly or concealed, on their premises? The famous notification signs usually having the silhouette of a handgun with a red circle and slash over it? Since the state is adamant they don't deny licenses in any arbitrary and capricious manner, you'd think businesses would be posting their "no guns" placards on doors all over the state. I've never seen one myself... but I don't get out much. Or maybe all the businesses in Hawaii welcome those bearing firearms into their places of business?
http://www.abajournal.com/news/article/spotting-a-concealed-gun-is-not-reason-enough-for-police-to-stop-and-investigate-top-state-court-rules#When:18:21:00Z
Spotting concealed gun isn’t reason enough for police to stop and investigate, top state court rules
“We find no justification for the notion that a police officer may infer criminal activity merely from an individual’s possession of a concealed firearm in public,” the state high court said. “Absent some other circumstances giving rise to a suspicion of criminality, a seizure upon that basis alone is unreasonable.”
Some people are barred from gun ownership, and a license is required for a concealed firearm, the court said. But “there is no way to ascertain an individual’s licensing status, or status as a prohibited person, merely by his outward appearance.”
-
I can't count how many "Second Amendment Rights" videos I've seen where the Cops arrive because "someone called about a man walking down the street with a gun", then asks the subject, "How can I know if you're not a prohibited gun owner if you don't identify yourself?" The answer is, he needs suspicion to that effect. It's not up to the subject to prove himself to be lawfully carrying a firearm with no reason to suspect otherwise on the part of the officer.
Cart before the horse. Chicken and the egg. Catch 22.
Until possession of a firearm once again becomes more of a right and less of a possible crime, there will be no actual resolution to this dilemma without repealing the 4th and 5th amendments protecting us against violation of unreasonable search and seizure and self-incrimination.
"Are you prohibited from owning a firearm?"
"No."
"Can you prove it?"
"I don't have to prove it. Do you have reason to suspect I'm prohibited?"
"If you haven't broken the law, then you have nothing to hide. Refusing to cooperate can get you arrested for obstruction. I have to investigate the 911 call, which means I need your ID to put in my report. How do I know you're not breaking the law unless you prove you aren't?"
Our system needs work.
-
"License and registration please"
"Can I ask why I was pulled over?"
"I believe you are driving without a license"
"I have a license"
"Then hand me your license and registration."
"But was I driving in any manner to warrant being pulled over?"
"I did not see your drivers license prominently displayed."
-
Can't wait for Hawaii courts and Ninth Circuit to make a similar ruling! :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl: But... I don't think I wanna be the test case. :geekdanc:
The 9th circuit made a similar ruling on Wednesday and raised the bar for police, at least in Washington State. One can run from the police carrying a handgun (concealed or openly) and that does not constitute probable cause or reasonable suspicion to stop that person. http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2019/06/05/17-30191.pdf (http://cdn.ca9.uscourts.gov/datastore/opinions/2019/06/05/17-30191.pdf)
In California, a reliable tip coupled with the panels conclusion that "Given the insignificant number of concealed carry permits issued in California, a reasonable officer could conclude that there is a high probability that a person identified in a 911 call as carrying a concealed handgun is violating California's gun laws." defeats the Fourth Amendment. See Foster v. City of Indio, 908 F. 3d 1204, 1216 (2018). Does this create a split with other circuits and state courts of last resort (SCOTUS Rule 10)? Yes. Does it conflict with prior, binding, SCOTUS decisions? Yes. Was an en banc or cert petition filed? No.
Possession of a firearm under California law is, by default, an innocent act. The question turns on the elements of the crime which renders the otherwise innocent possession of a firearm unlawful, such as possession by a felon, carried concealed, loaded and unregistered, which constitute four separate crimes under California law, and prohibited persons cannot be punished for violating the latter three under California law.
Some people are barred from gun ownership, and a license is required for a concealed firearm, the court said. But “there is no way to ascertain an individual’s licensing status, or status as a prohibited person, merely by his outward appearance.”
The Fourth Amendment analysis is fairly straightforward if one pretends the decisions in Heller and McDonald never happened.
1. Is possession of a firearm by default a criminal act? In California, No. I don't know about Hawaii.
There was a 7th circuit court of appeals decision by now retired Judge Poser (ca 1980's) which held that since the possession of firearms is by default a criminal act in Illinois then the sight of a firearm, or reasonable suspicion, defeats the protections of the Fourth Amendment. In his decision, he noted that this was not the case in other states and that the Fourth Amendment analysis would change in Illinois if Illinois were to change its law.
2. Does the totality of the circumstances give rise to a "reasonable suspicion" that a crime has been/is/or will be committed? The California decision I cited above involved "qualified immunity" which makes it kind of squishy as the only thing the police need to skate free is that their illegal conduct was not "clearly established" at the time it occurred. But there is enough California case law which says the Fourth Amendment protects those unlawfully carrying concealed weapons, and for that matter, a lot of prior 9th circuit case law as well. Note that purely innocent conduct can give rise to "reasonable suspicion." See Terry v. Ohio.
These two factors are why the California state's attorney asked the three-judge panel in my appeal to create a rule, based on a single 1970 California appellate decision, that a search and seizure of a person and his firearm in a place where it is legal for him to openly carry a firearm and for others, such as hunters, to carry the firearm loaded, is neither a search nor seizure but if it is then it is a "reasonable search (and seizure)."
That rule would create decades of splits within and without the 9th circuit as well as with the California Supreme Court. As Judge Berzon observed during the oral argument in my appeal, even the "automobile exception" requires probable cause.
The State of California does not argue that my openly carrying my unloaded antique constitutes reasonable suspicion justifying a Terry Stop and waived any such defense.
The State did concede that if I win my 2A claim then I win my 4th Amendment claim as well.
He's right. And if I win my 2A claim then openly carrying a firearm for the purpose of self-defense and for other lawful purposes becomes protected by the 4th Amendment in Hawaii as well (Young has no 4th Amendment claim).
-
Glad the court is ruling on what has been the basic tenant for law enforcement for quite some time now. Not sure why it had to go so far, the prosecutors should have shut it down if it made its way past the first supervisor.