2aHawaii

General Topics => General Discussion => Topic started by: Mdotweber on August 08, 2019, 02:47:43 PM

Title: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Mdotweber on August 08, 2019, 02:47:43 PM
https://www.thegatewaypundit.com/2019/08/breaking-armed-man-with-rifle-handgun-and-body-armor-stopped-and-arrested-outside-springfield-missouri-walmart/

Was stopped and held at gunpoint by an off duty fireman with CCW
Title: Re: close call 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart
Post by: RSN172 on August 08, 2019, 03:43:11 PM
I think there is more to this story.  He peacefully surrendered.  MO is a permitless carry state, so he may very well be carrying the guns for protection, same as wearing the body armor.  IIRC, London808 wore body armor at Ala Moana Shopping Center.  He peacefully surrendered so no good guys would get hurt until this got sorted out.  That is one scenario that immediately came to my mind.  I am sure we will hear more about it.
Title: Re: close call 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart
Post by: Mdotweber on August 08, 2019, 04:07:56 PM
I think there is more to this story.  He peacefully surrendered.  MO is a permitless carry state, so he may very well be carrying the guns for protection, same as wearing the body armor.  IIRC, London808 wore body armor at Ala Moana Shopping Center.  He peacefully surrendered so no good guys would get hurt until this got sorted out.  That is one scenario that immediately came to my mind.  I am sure we will hear more about it.

You have a point, I admit that in light of recent events I jumped to the conclusion that this dude was bad news. Could have very well been someone who took somewhat of a misguided initiative to guard the store. I will update story/title as more info comes out.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Mdotweber on August 09, 2019, 02:22:47 PM
Not much info about motive mostly conjecture. The young man had previously displayed anger at walmart when they stopped selling firearms to those under 21. Possibly some form of statement/protest. I can confirm that he did not ever brandish his weapons.


https://www.thegatewaypundit.com/2019/08/jackass-charged-with-terroristic-threats-after-walking-into-springfield-walmart-with-rifle-handgun-100-rounds-of-ammo-and-body-armor-faces-up-to-4-yrs-in-prison/
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: changemyoil66 on August 09, 2019, 03:05:51 PM
So since he did not brandish anything (rifle was slung), wouldn't the CCW holder be the one who broke the law?  Pointed his gun at other guy and gave commanding orders to him.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: zippz on August 09, 2019, 03:13:21 PM
So since he did not brandish anything (rifle was slung), wouldn't the CCW holder be the one who broke the law?  Pointed his gun at other guy and gave commanding orders to him.

I see a lawsuit against the firefighter and police department coming up, and looks like he has a good chance of winning unless he made some sort of threat.  Guy likely did this to get attention which sucks, but it's still his right to do.

It's good to see a CCW take the initiative, however it seems like he did it out of fear instead of an actual threat.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on August 09, 2019, 03:19:40 PM
I hope to hell that the reporter and/or the "attorneys" he "spoke to" are wrong. The guy did nothing against any laws by openly carrying in that location, or taking video of himself openly carrying. Yet he's been charged with "terroristic threatening". What did he say or do to communicate a terroristic threat? Nothing. According the the reporter/attorneys, if he was "perceived as a threat", that is terroristic threatening! That is so full of shit. This is worse than the fucking "red flag" laws. Totally dependent on someone's "perception"? That's inane. Okay. I perceive Ige, and Lyin' Harry Kim, and Green and Rhoads and Lee and Baker et al. as threats. Can someone please go arrest all of them now and charge and try and convict and imprison them? Please. I'm serious. I "feel" "threatened" by them. No? Why not? Only if someone is legally bearing a weapon? Give me a fucking break.

And changemyoil is right, once someone draws a weapon and points it at you you have the moral and legal right to defend yourself with lethal force, which is being directed against you. Is that fucking fireman now going to be walking around WalMart all day looking for people who are "printing" and assume/"feel" that they are terroristic threats and draw on them?

What a pile of shit. If open carry ever happens here we can expect this kind of crap on steroids. Fuck them.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on August 09, 2019, 03:30:12 PM
I see a lawsuit against the firefighter and police department coming up, and looks like he has a good chance of winning unless he made some sort of threat.  Guy likely did this to get attention which sucks, but it's still his right to do.

It's good to see a CCW take the initiative, however it seems like he did it out of fear instead of an actual threat.
Yeah, just like the superstitious racist criminals blocking the public roadway at Mauna Kea... except no one has to "perceive" them being a threat, they are literally breaking the law, getting attention for it. and allowed to continue their criminal acts for weeks while being ignored, coddled and encouraged by all the corrupt racist Democrats in charge of this place. Must be nice. Any Second Amendment-protected rights supporter who blocked a public roadway to demonstrate that their clearly Constitutionally-delineated rights are being violated (no bearing arms for self-defense) would be removed within a few minutes of cops arriving, if that long. Hypocrites.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: rustyeleio on August 09, 2019, 03:39:49 PM
That's why open carry sucks.  No need the controversy, just allow concealed carry then the sheep can go on grazing with a 100% false sense of security (that is there right) and the rest of us can actually have a little security (that is our right).  I am lazy and cheap, so I don't want to have to go to court every time I walk into Walmart with my AR slung on my back.  Better to just cruze in, get what you came for and cruze out, no need have your "olos" hangin' out to show off to the world.  That just make drama for everyone.

Not saying the guy was wrong, just too much dramas.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: zippz on August 09, 2019, 10:39:09 PM
No way the charge is going to stick.

https://www.foxnews.com/us/suspect-in-disturbance-at-missouri-walmart-said-he-was-testing-2nd-amendment-rights-prosecutors


The probable cause document quoted Andreychenko as saying he “wanted to know if Walmart honored the Second Amendment.” He said he had bought the rifle and body armor because of three recent shootings and a stabbing, and wanted to protect himself.

“Missouri protects the right of people to open-carry a firearm, but that does not allow an individual to act in a reckless and criminal manner endangering other citizens," Greene County Prosecuting Attorney Dan Patterson said in a statement announcing charges. Patterson compared the actions of the accused to "falsely shouting fire in a theater, causing a panic."
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Heavies on August 09, 2019, 10:48:02 PM
If this dude thinks he was helping the 2A cause, he's a fucking moron, and will set us back in this battle.   

Darwin award winner...
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: zippz on August 10, 2019, 01:37:36 AM
If this dude thinks he was helping the 2A cause, he's a fucking moron, and will set us back in this battle.   

Darwin award winner...

My first instinct is to say that this whole incident is stupid.  However I relate it to what may happen in Hawaii.  Young v Hawaii may determine that open carry is constitutional but CCW is not.  People here would freak out just the same if there was a mass shooting with a handgun here and see people open carrying which they are not used to.  Then would the proper thing be not to open carry?
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on August 10, 2019, 07:16:08 AM
My first instinct is to say that this whole incident is stupid.  However I relate it to what may happen in Hawaii.  Young v Hawaii may determine that open carry is constitutional but CCW is not.  People here would freak out just the same if there was a mass shooting with a handgun here and see people open carrying which they are not used to.  Then would the proper thing be not to open carry?
A great number of people here will "freak out" if they see a "civilian" open carrying (even just a handgun) even without there being any "mass shooting". Of course they will actually be in greater "danger" from people carrying concealed, because the percentage of criminals who open carry is zero, and the percentage of criminals who carry concealed is 100%. So they are in greater danger, but they are too stupid to know that they are actually in greater danger. If someday only open carry is legal, I'm betting most criminals will still carry concealed, in order to have the "secret advantage" over people who will not know they are armed, just like now.

If the argument is along the lines of the articles as I posted above, that "perceived threat", in the form of open carrying even when completely legal, is a crime... then the only, and obvious, answer to preventing those crimes is to ban open carry... because then no one will be able to "perceive a threat" (even though there is an equal or greater threat from people carrying concealed). If SCOTUS practices stare decisis and continues to conclude that concealed carry is not a right and may be banned (see: Heller, MacDonald, Kavanaugh testimony at his confirmation hearing, etc.), then there will be "no carry", which is what we have here now (well, except for the criminals who carry everywhere every day, as evidence by multiple events in the past week). So, whatever you do, don't get perceived as a threat, for whatever reason, or you're going to jail and you'll ruin everything for everyone else who shares whatever characteristic and/or action that got you arrested and charged as a "perceived threat" (e.g. large black man in white neighborhood at night, etc.).
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 10, 2019, 10:14:54 AM
My first instinct is to sue that fireman for false arrest, brandishing a firearm, assault and kidnapping -- along with all the emotional distress and public defamation and humiliation that ensued.

It's not the public's job to prevent imaginary crimes.  The fireman should have called police to investigate and, if still concerned, follow and observe the "suspect".  He should only take action if the person acts in a threatening or dangerous manner.

In other words, the fireman had NO CAUSE to point a firearm at the man.  Until and unless that man brandished his own weapon/s, there was no justification for  assuming ill intent.

Yeah, I would sue.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: RSN172 on August 10, 2019, 10:18:02 AM
That 20 yr old did nothing illegal.  He was just stupid. 
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: changemyoil66 on August 10, 2019, 10:58:27 AM
At least the guy obeyed commands from someone with a gun pointed at him and didnt argue or escalate the situation.

Overzelous ccw holder, overzelous cops. Watch OC get banned there.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Heavies on August 11, 2019, 10:18:58 AM
Just because something is legal, doesn't make it smart or right.  Common sense is absent in this day and age.  All parties need to apologize to each other and go their separate ways, and hope a lesson was learned.

If a pedestrian steps out into the street, not paying attention, in a crosswalk, and gets nailed by a car, he's the loser.  Was the pedestrian within his legal rights to have the "right of way" in the crosswalk?  Yep, BUT that still doesn't make it right, nor smart. 

It's fucken stupid,  and so was this dingbat,  fucken stupid.

Makes all gun owners look stupid.
I refuse to defend this idiot.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on August 11, 2019, 12:23:02 PM
Just because something is legal, doesn't make it smart or right.  Common sense is absent in this day and age.  All parties need to apologize to each other and go their separate ways, and hope a lesson was learned.

If a pedestrian steps out into the street, not paying attention, in a crosswalk, and gets nailed by a car, he's the loser.  Was the pedestrian within his legal rights to have the "right of way" in the crosswalk?  Yep, BUT that still doesn't make it right, nor smart. 

It's fucken stupid,  and so was this dingbat,  fucken stupid.

Makes all gun owners look stupid.
I refuse to defend this idiot.
So what, exactly, was the "stupid" part?

Should no one anywhere ever (there will always be "gun violence" within the past few days) open carry a handgun in any retail store? Anywhere? A rifle? Either while wearing "tactical gear"? Maybe it would be easier for you to describe the circumstance and details about "not stupid" open carry: What, when, where, etc.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Heavies on August 11, 2019, 12:33:05 PM
So what, exactly, was the "stupid" part?

Should no one anywhere ever (there will always be "gun violence" within the past few days) open carry a handgun in any retail store? Anywhere? A rifle? Either while wearing "tactical gear"? Maybe it would be easier for you to describe the circumstance and details about "not stupid" open carry: What, when, where, etc.

If you can't figure that one out, I can't help you with my explanation.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: zippz on August 11, 2019, 12:50:22 PM
The 20year old guy could sue the fireman.  But receiving an apology would be the proper thing to do.  The fireman may have been overzealous, but he's a firearm owner and took the initiative to do what he thought was right.

Can sue the police since they should've known better about charging him with terroristic threatening.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: ren on August 11, 2019, 01:02:37 PM
with a right there comes a responsibility
Like the 1st amendment...you can yell what ever you want - but don't yell fire or bomb in some places that are inappropriate i.e. airport, shopping mall etc.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Heavies on August 11, 2019, 01:06:30 PM
with a right there comes a responsibility
Like the 1st amendment...you can yell what ever you want - but don't yell fire or bomb in some places that are inappropriate i.e. airport, shopping mall etc.
^^THIS^^
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: groveler on August 11, 2019, 01:17:21 PM
If you can't figure that one out, I can't help you with my explanation.
I used to go up to Alaska to visit my brother and fish while he was at work,
he often loaned me his truck.
Since I was in bear country I carried a model 1911,  open or concealed.
I also,  depending on the location carried an SKS type 56 Carbine.
There is a un-wriiten way to behave set of rules with Alaska open carry.
In a market you covered the pistol, but kept it on you
and left the rifle in the truck.
You could walk down the city sidewalks and roads carrying both openly.
If you are in an area where you think if you left your rifle in the rifle rack
and it might get stolen from a vehicle,  then carry it with you and ask if you can
leave it with a store person till you're done shopping.
Just use a little sense.  That is the way it should work.


Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on August 11, 2019, 01:28:06 PM
I see a lawsuit against the firefighter and police department coming up, and looks like he has a good chance of winning unless he made some sort of threat.  Guy likely did this to get attention which sucks, but it's still his right to do.

It's good to see a CCW take the initiative, however it seems like he did it out of fear instead of an actual threat.

Legally sure he could do that but given the context it was stupid.

I could also stand in a crowd and yell Alah Akbar "praise god" but given the context it would also be stupid.

I could glue flares to my chest in a row and walk around but it would be stupid.


Legal doesn't mean it was a good idea and legal doesn't mean that someone else's response wouldn't be reasonable.


I think the guy was trying to make a point but it wasn't a smart way or time to do it.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: groveler on August 11, 2019, 01:28:44 PM
The 20year old guy could sue the fireman.  But receiving an apology would be the proper thing to do.  The fireman may have been overzealous, but he's a firearm owner and took the initiative to do what he thought was right.

Can sue the police since they should've known better about charging him with terroristic threatening.
The cops know the charges will be dropped.  They won't get any pushback
from lawsuits.  After all the taxpayer is footing the bill.
They just charged him so they can take
his gun and force him to go through the courts to get it back.
This is called processing you through the system.
When you get your gun back in two years and thousands of lawyers dollars later,
you'll find it was stored in a leaky container and is rust damaged.
There is nothing you can do about it!
And you can't sue the cops.
Isn't modern Democrat America great?
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on August 11, 2019, 01:44:40 PM
If you can't figure that one out, I can't help you with my explanation.
Yeah, that's what I thought. You are unwilling to state your position. No surprise.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on August 11, 2019, 01:53:41 PM
with a right there comes a responsibility
Like the 1st amendment...you can yell what ever you want - but don't yell fire or bomb in some places that are inappropriate i.e. airport, shopping mall etc.
^^THIS^^
The above example of yelling something that causes a panic and results in injuries and/or deaths of people is a totally false analogy to what happened at the Missouri Walmart. (Another big First Amendment exemption is libeling or slandering people.) He wasn't doing anything illegal, AND apparently he walked around for at least several minutes without anyone being trampled due to panicking when seeing him engaged in legal open carry. The only possible danger happened when the store manager panicked and set off the fire alarm. At that point the open carrier also exited the building, at which point there may have been some slight danger by the ex-fireman drawing his weapon on someone well outside the store. I'd like to see his (or any other ) video and if it includes people reacting to seeing him and if any of them "panicked".
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on August 11, 2019, 02:01:35 PM
I think the guy was trying to make a point but it wasn't a smart way or time to do it.
So said the vast majority of colonists who wanted the colonies to remain colonies in the 1770s and viewed acts such as "The Boston Tea Party" as "stupid" and seditious.

We can clearly see here in Hawaii how toeing the line and "no make stink" has resulted in such a wonderful legal climate for us to exercise our Second Amendment-protected rights. So said no one. Ever.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on August 11, 2019, 02:07:04 PM
So said the vast majority of colonists who wanted the colonies to remain colonies in the 1770s and viewed acts such as "The Boston Tea Party" as "stupid" and seditious.

We can clearly see here in Hawaii how toeing the line and "no make stink" has resulted in such a wonderful legal climate for us to exercise our Second Amendment-protected rights. So said no one. Ever.

So instead we should push the envelope by doing things that are technically legal but scare the hell out of people?
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 11, 2019, 03:18:45 PM
So instead we should push the envelope by doing things that are technically legal but scare the hell out of people?

Have you seen the way most people drive?   :shake:
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Heavies on August 11, 2019, 03:39:13 PM
Yeah, that's what I thought. You are unwilling to state your position. No surprise.

I stated my position already. 
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Heavies on August 11, 2019, 03:39:37 PM
I used to go up to Alaska to visit my brother and fish while he was at work,
he often loaned me his truck.
Since I was in bear country I carried a model 1911,  open or concealed.
I also,  depending on the location carried an SKS type 56 Carbine.
There is a un-wriiten way to behave set of rules with Alaska open carry.
In a market you covered the pistol, but kept it on you
and left the rifle in the truck.
You could walk down the city sidewalks and roads carrying both openly.
If you are in an area where you think if you left your rifle in the rifle rack
and it might get stolen from a vehicle,  then carry it with you and ask if you can
leave it with a store person till you're done shopping.
Just use a little sense.  That is the way it should work.




^^THIS^^
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Heavies on August 11, 2019, 03:41:08 PM
The cops know the charges will be dropped.  They won't get any pushback
from lawsuits.  After all the taxpayer is footing the bill.
They just charged him so they can take
his gun and force him to go through the courts to get it back.
This is called processing you through the system.
When you get your gun back in two years and thousands of lawyers dollars later,
you'll find it was stored in a leaky container and is rust damaged.
There is nothing you can do about it!
And you can't sue the cops.
Isn't modern Democrat America great?


Its Missouri, so I think as long as everybody has come to an understanding,  he'll get his stuff back.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on August 11, 2019, 04:00:36 PM
So instead we should push the envelope by doing things that are technically legal but scare the hell out of people?
You mean like a black person sitting at a whites only lunch counter, or riding in the front of the bus, or attempting to enter a public school? You mean like asserting that we have a natural individual fundamental civil right to bear arms outside our home for the purpose of self-defense even though it "scares the hell out of" Ige, Lyin' Harry, Green, Rhoads, Lee, Baker, et al.? If concealed carry were legal, would you advise against it because you know that so many people, including the red shirt wearing Demanding Moms are "scared to hell" by people doing so? What about open carry? What kind, level, or amount of "fear" should determine what legal activities ought to be curbed?

"Push the envelope"?  "Technically legal"? "Scare the hell out of people"? Where do you come up with this crap?

There are a lot of people, who for whatever reasons and past experience are "scared" of cops... should the cops not go into those neighborhoods because they will "scare the hell out of people"?
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 11, 2019, 04:48:14 PM
You mean like a black person sitting at a whites only lunch counter, or riding in the front of the bus, or attempting to enter a public school? You mean like asserting that we have a natural individual fundamental civil right to bear arms outside our home for the purpose of self-defense even though it "scares the hell out of" Ige, Lyin' Harry, Green, Rhoads, Lee, Baker, et al.? If concealed carry were legal, would you advise against it because you know that so many people, including the red shirt wearing Demanding Moms are "scared to hell" by people doing so? What about open carry? What kind, level, or amount of "fear" should determine what legal activities ought to be curbed?

"Push the envelope"?  "Technically legal"? "Scare the hell out of people"? Where do you come up with this crap?

There are a lot of people, who for whatever reasons and past experience are "scared" of cops... should the cops not go into those neighborhoods because they will "scare the hell out of people"?

(https://i.imgur.com/YzH3dGH.jpg)

Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: changemyoil66 on August 11, 2019, 05:31:12 PM
If hawaii allowed OC, would u not OC right away because it may scare people not used to it?

Im on the fence.  Yes with recent events, to do so may cause an uneccessary panic. But the walmart manager who pulled the fire alarm should have know better and been trained better. I think he paniced.

OCer hears fire alarm and runs out of the store just like everyone else. Ive run with a rifle slung and put at least 1 hand on it because a rifle bouncing around while running is not fun. Even if slung tightly, it still moves. So add people running out of the store, plus this guy with probabaly 1 hand holding his rifle against his body, would equal suspicion by anyone.

To me the manager is the most to blame.

Also the law and rights dont end because people might be scared. Regardless if he was testing anything or not.

I would have probably OCed a rifle for a few days if it were legal after recent events, instead of just carrying a pistol. Def not walk around in body armor. But it would be in my trunk with ammo cans.

Cops are in the wrong for charging him. Any other day of the week, he would have been free to go. They looked for a reason to take his gun away. I hope he sues the hell out of them.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: zippz on August 11, 2019, 06:08:52 PM
Oh my God the insanity continues.  No more open carry for the police.

Police investigation prompts panic at Queen Kaahumanu Center

Shortly after 8 p.m., witnesses observed several officers walking through the complex with rifles.

Authorities said they were looking for a Wailea theft suspect.

Tenants and shoppers at the mall at the time say they had to be evacuated, however police said they did not order the evacuation.

https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2019/08/12/police-investigation-prompts-panic-queen-kaahumanu-center/
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on August 11, 2019, 07:32:31 PM
Oh my God the insanity continues.  No more open carry for the police.

Police investigation prompts panic at Queen Kaahumanu Center

Shortly after 8 p.m., witnesses observed several officers walking through the complex with rifles.

Authorities said they were looking for a Wailea theft suspect.

Tenants and shoppers at the mall at the time say they had to be evacuated, however police said they did not order the evacuation.

https://www.hawaiinewsnow.com/2019/08/12/police-investigation-prompts-panic-queen-kaahumanu-center/
Haha. I just came here to post that very article.

"Technically legal" but "stupid", yeah?! Dumb fakas "pushing the envelope"! Open carrying rifles in a mall after what happened last weekend? They "scared the hell out of people"!
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: drck1000 on August 12, 2019, 12:23:32 PM
with a right there comes a responsibility
Like the 1st amendment...you can yell what ever you want - but don't yell fire or bomb in some places that are inappropriate i.e. airport, shopping mall etc.
Yup.  So many (or too many) folks doing stuff because they could, without putting much thought into whether or not they should.  Similar with innovation.  Innovation for the sake of innovation can at times be counterproductive. . .
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on August 12, 2019, 01:04:48 PM
I stated my position already.
No you didn't. Not with any specificity or clarity.

Maybe someone else will be willing to tell us what you meant. What is "Heavies" position, exactly.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: changemyoil66 on August 12, 2019, 01:04:57 PM
Yup.  So many (or too many) folks doing stuff because they could, without putting much thought into whether or not they should.  Similar with innovation.  Innovation for the sake of innovation can at times be counterproductive. . .

I wonder if rights weren't trampled on, would people still do stuff to see what they can get away with?
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 12, 2019, 01:13:49 PM
Yup.  So many (or too many) folks doing stuff because they could, without putting much thought into whether or not they should.  Similar with innovation.  Innovation for the sake of innovation can at times be counterproductive. . .

"You can't yell 'FIRE!' in a crowded theater" is just wrong.

The original quote from Justice Holmes was "falsely shouting fire in a theatre and causing a panic".

Notice the word "crowded" is missing, and the word "falsely" precedes "shouting."  Those are 2 important words that qualify whether or not the act is considered protected speech or not.

If there's an actual fire, then your speech is lawful if announcing a fire.  If the theater is empty, or there is no panic caused (nobody got hurt), then even a false announcement of "FIRE!" will result in no criminal charges.

That entire "fire in a theater" example was actually part of a decision that was overturned.  Yet, people learn what they were taught.

Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: drck1000 on August 12, 2019, 01:20:31 PM
I wonder if rights weren't trampled on, would people still do stuff to see what they can get away with?
You mean would people want or need to push limits if freedoms were reality?  For firearms, I think so.  Always be folks pushing things.

"You can't yell 'FIRE!' in a crowded theater" is just wrong.

The original quote from Justice Holmes was "falsely shouting fire in a theatre and causing a panic".

Notice the word "crowded" is missing, and the word "falsely" precedes "shouting."  Those are 2 important words that qualify whether or not the act is considered protected speech or not.

If there's an actual fire, then your speech is lawful if announcing a fire.  If the theater is empty, or there is no panic caused (nobody got hurt), then even a false announcement of "FIRE!" will result in no criminal charges.

That entire "fire in a theater" example was actually part of a decision that was overturned.  Yet, people learn what they were taught.

I was referring to the "with a right there comes a responsibility" part.  I wasn't referring to the "person who yelled fire". . . but thank you for the educational experience. . .
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 12, 2019, 01:37:54 PM
You mean would people want or need to push limits if freedoms were reality?  For firearms, I think so.  Always be folks pushing things.
I was referring to the "with a right there comes a responsibility" part.  I wasn't referring to the "person who yelled fire". . . but thank you for the educational experience. . .

The problem with the concept of "with rights come responsibilities" is there is no mechanism to enforce it.  There is no "Bill of Responsibilities" in the Constitution.

Responsibilities are taught by responsible parents and other adults in a position to teach.  Unfortunately, too many adults grew up being taught that they are not responsible for themselves.  Government, oppressive racists, corporations, the greedy 1%, the Cops, their abusive parents, bullies, Conservatives, MAGA hat wearers and Trump are to blame for everything bad in their lives and to give them everything they need to live a fulfilling life.

I'd put it more in the words, "With rights come consequences."  One of those consequences is we must allow people to exercise their rights in ways we find distasteful or morally wrong.  As long as their actions don't violate the safety or rights of others (deliberately causing a panic and injuring people), then it's up to the individual how they exercise their rights.

In any free society, liberties can be abused.  Look at the US Press and how they hide behind the Constitution while spreading lies about Trump and his supporters. Fake News exists because society hasn't yet stopped rewarding those who create and spread it.  Hopefully one day we'll all band together and stop the divisive behavior of the press.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: drck1000 on August 12, 2019, 01:43:49 PM
The problem with the concept of "with rights come responsibilities" is there is no mechanism to enforce it.  There is no "Bill of Responsibilities" in the Constitution.

Responsibilities are taught by responsible parents and other adults in a position to teach.  Unfortunately, too many adults grew up being taught that they are not responsible for themselves.  Government, oppressive racists, corporations, the greedy 1%, the Cops, their abusive parents, bullies, Conservatives, MAGA hat wearers and Trump are to blame for everything bad in their lives and to give them everything they need to live a fulfilling life.

I'd put it more in the words, "With rights come consequences."  One of those consequences is we must allow people to exercise their rights in ways we find distasteful or morally wrong.  As long as their actions don't violate the safety or rights of others (deliberately causing a panic and injuring people), then it's up to the individual how they exercise their rights.

In any free society, liberties can be abused.  Look at the US Press and how they hide behind the Constitution while spreading lies about Trump and his supporters. Fake News exists because society hasn't yet stopped rewarding those who create and spread it.  Hopefully one day we'll all band together and stop the divisive behavior of the press.
:thumbsup:  :shaka:
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Heavies on August 12, 2019, 03:37:58 PM
No you didn't. Not with any specificity or clarity.

Maybe someone else will be willing to tell us what you meant. What is "Heavies" position, exactly.

If this dude thinks he was helping the 2A cause, he's a fucking moron, and will set us back in this battle.   

Darwin award winner...

Just because something is legal, doesn't make it smart or right.  Common sense is absent in this day and age.  All parties need to apologize to each other and go their separate ways, and hope a lesson was learned.

If a pedestrian steps out into the street, not paying attention, in a crosswalk, and gets nailed by a car, he's the loser.  Was the pedestrian within his legal rights to have the "right of way" in the crosswalk?  Yep, BUT that still doesn't make it right, nor smart. 

It's fucken stupid,  and so was this dingbat,  fucken stupid.

Makes all gun owners look stupid.
I refuse to defend this idiot.

Seems pretty clear to me. 
And yet again, another thread of people arguing just for the sake of arguing.     ::)
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: drck1000 on August 12, 2019, 04:20:55 PM
Seems pretty clear to me. 
And yet again, another thread of people arguing just for the sake of arguing.     ::)
I disagree! 

I meant disagree as to which is better.  Ruger or S&W revolvers.   ;D
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on August 12, 2019, 04:27:27 PM
Seems pretty clear to me. 
And yet again, another thread of people arguing just for the sake of arguing.     ::)
Yeah, I can read what you wrote. That's exactly why I asked the questions I asked, that you refuse to answer. It's not clear, at all, what you are implying should be the laws re open and/or concealed carry, but most specifically (apparently) open carry. If, according to you, it's always "stupid" to open carry a firearm in a retail store, then shouldn't the law re open carry state that open carry is not allowed in retail stores? The questions seem pretty clear to me. And the reason for asking the questions, given what you wrote, seems pretty clear to. But if you want me to I can further explain and fully spell out each question.

Why do you avoid answering them?

Reminder: So what, exactly, was the "stupid" part?

Should no one anywhere ever (there will always be "gun violence" within the past few days) open carry a handgun in any retail store? Anywhere? A rifle? Either while wearing "tactical gear"? Maybe it would be easier for you to describe the circumstance and details about "not stupid" open carry: What, when, where, etc.

Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 12, 2019, 05:03:23 PM
If the fireman hadn't intervened as he did but instead simply called the cops, I doubt seriously anyone on this thread would have heard about it -- just like we never hear about EVERY OTHER 2A "SURVEY" unless the person involved posts it to YouTube.

In that situation, Heavies would not have made the judgment that the guy acted stupidly, because he'd have never heard about it.

So, if someone decides to take a specific action, and people who don't like those types of actions never hear about them from the MSM, was the person still stupid?  Or, did he get the answer he was looking for -- direct information he needed to let his representatives know things need to change?
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on August 12, 2019, 08:32:43 PM
You mean like a black person sitting at a whites only lunch counter, or riding in the front of the bus, or attempting to enter a public school? You mean like asserting that we have a natural individual fundamental civil right to bear arms outside our home for the purpose of self-defense even though it "scares the hell out of" Ige, Lyin' Harry, Green, Rhoads, Lee, Baker, et al.? If concealed carry were legal, would you advise against it because you know that so many people, including the red shirt wearing Demanding Moms are "scared to hell" by people doing so? What about open carry? What kind, level, or amount of "fear" should determine what legal activities ought to be curbed?

"Push the envelope"?  "Technically legal"? "Scare the hell out of people"? Where do you come up with this crap?

There are a lot of people, who for whatever reasons and past experience are "scared" of cops... should the cops not go into those neighborhoods because they will "scare the hell out of people"?

You completely missed my point.  This has nothing to do with black people sitting at the lunch counter. You are trying to equate any and all fear with reasonable rationale fear.

There are just things you don't do.

How about to prove your point you walk into a bank with a ski mask then act dumbfounded when people start reacting.

If you ever meet Trump go ahead and yell Allah Akbar as you are about to shake his hand. Then you can correctly point out how legal it is when secret service are tackling you (if you are lucky)

I can come up with a dozen more if you like.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 12, 2019, 08:43:55 PM
You completely missed my point.  This has nothing to do with black people sitting at the lunch counter. You are trying to equate any and all fear with reasonable rationale fear.

There are just things you don't do.

How about to prove your point you walk into a bank with a ski mask then act dumbfounded when people start reacting.

If you ever meet Trump go ahead and yell Allah Akbar as you are about to shake his hand. Then you can correctly point out how legal it is when secret service are tackling you (if you are lucky)

I can come up with a dozen more if you like.

Please point to the part of the Constitution that says wearing something to obscure your face in a bank is an inalienable right.

While you're at it, where is the part of the Constitution that says you have the right to yell Allah Akbar when shaking hands with the President without any context?

Are your dozen other examples also irrelevant examples of actions that are not Constitutionally-protected rights?
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on August 12, 2019, 08:59:06 PM
Please point to the part of the Constitution that says wearing something to obscure your face in a bank is an inalienable right.

While you're at it, where is the part of the Constitution that says you have the right to yell Allah Akbar when shaking hands with the President without any context?

Are your dozen other examples also irrelevant examples of actions that are not Constitutionally-protected rights?

You are focusing on legality, I am focusing on common sense and the things that allow society to function.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 12, 2019, 09:10:03 PM
You are focusing on legality, I am focusing on common sense and the things that allow society to function.

No, you are creating straw argument using irrelevant examples that have nothing to do with Constitutional rights.

I won't go roller skating in a watermelon patch, but that in no way equates to whether or not I should exercise a Constitutional right in any given situation.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on August 12, 2019, 09:13:58 PM
No, you are creating straw argument using irrelevant examples that have nothing to do with Constitutional rights.

I won't go roller skating in a watermelon patch, but that in no way equates to whether or not I should exercise a Constitutional right in any given situation.

I never made a single argument about constitutional rights. In fact I clearly pointed out that all the scenarios I listed are technically legal.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 12, 2019, 09:18:26 PM
I never made a single argument about constitutional rights. In fact I clearly pointed out that all the scenarios I listed are technically legal.

That's because you came up with irrelevant examples that make zero points in the argument.

Open carry == Constitutional right
Sitting at the "Whites Only" lunch counter == Constitutional right
Attending a "Whites Only" school == Constitutional right

You see a pattern now?
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on August 13, 2019, 06:38:46 AM
That's because you came up with irrelevant examples that make zero points in the argument.

Open carry == Constitutional right
Sitting at the "Whites Only" lunch counter == Constitutional right
Attending a "Whites Only" school == Constitutional right

You see a pattern now?
No, the people here that condemn the guy and/or his actions as "stupid", etc. won't acknowledge the pattern nor tell us specifically what is "not stupid" re open carry... for some reason. And that's what I want to know. I won't bother to speculate as to what they think about open carry, in whatever places and circumstances is "not stupid"... how would I know? It'd just be speculation. They could simply write a few sentences about when, where, etc. it is and ought to be legal and "commonsense" to carry openly, but they won't do that. Why? Seems simple. It's a constitutionally-protected right (even the Ninth Circuit has said so!). How hard could it be for those condemning this guy to just tell us what they think both the law and the "commonsense" "rules" should be about open carry? Is any action, even though completely legal, to be held to some standard of "commonsense" re the amount of fear it might instill in other people? Would it have been "not stupid" for him to do it the day BEFORE the shooting at Walmart? What about a year afterwards? Six months afterwards? Two weeks afterwards? Some store other than Walmart? Etc. I guess it's too hard for them to clarify what they mean.

Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on August 13, 2019, 09:13:33 AM
What we've seen here (and elsewhere on other threads regarding this incident) is that many people are arguing along the lines of "Well, it wasn't "illegal", and he didn't actually engage in any threatening acts or verbalizations, but COMMONSENSE should dictate, and make obvious that he shouldn't have done it... because it's stupid...", etc.

I find this so ironic that people who claim to support Second Amendment-protected rights would turn to such a vague and ambiguous term as "commonsense" to argue their point, when that term is what is used by nearly all the opponents of Second Amendment-protected rights in calling for "commonsense gun safety regulations". That is, it's an appeal to something that is supposed to be so obvious and clear to anyone capable of normal perception and cognition, that it can't be disputed. Right? So anyone who disagrees with the "commonsense" notion that civilians ought not have any firearms ever in any public place (or have a suppressor or a semi-automatic long gun or be allowed to transfer a firearm without government approval, etc.,etc., etc.)... well, those people are crazy gun nuts, or some kind of demented deplorables. Yet here we have the very targets of those "commonsense" arguments arguing using the same, I'll call it false, argument. It should be "obvious", that if people vehemently and diametrically disagree about what is or isn't "commonsense", that there really is no such thing and any argument using anything resembling an appeal to any such or similar concept is false. Say what you actually mean, otherwise you might as well argue it's because "the gods have decreed it".

And, here, from another thread on another topic, is a post from something using the screen name "commonsense", which pretty much sums it up:

commonsense August 11, 2019 9:26 am 

Absolutely! The second amendment is not sensible in this day and age. I believe most people would agree not to completely outlaw every gun, just have much stricter laws and enforcement. Ban all assault and semi-automatic guns.

Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: RSN172 on August 13, 2019, 10:10:47 AM
OK, let me take a stab at this, as earlier I said it wasn’t illegal, it was just stupid.  Maybe stupid was the wrong word to use so I will change it to prudent.  Tensions were very high given the 3 shootings.  If he was prudent and wanted to protect himself, he could have just carried his handgun and he could have worn his vest but not sling that rifle over his shoulder and walk into the store like that.  He could have easily gotten himself shot.  Just like it would not be prudent, if you had a lot of money, to dress up, wear your $15k Rolex watch and 2k diamond ring and drive your $200k Bentley to go eat at at your favorite soul food restaurant located in the inner city.  It is your right, you are not doing anything illegal, but it isn't prudent and you are not using “common sense.”

Others have other opinions, may feel that they have the “right” because it is not illegal, but that kind of thinking can get you killed or suffer grievous bodily harm.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 13, 2019, 10:19:25 AM
What we've seen here (and elsewhere on other threads regarding this incident) is that many people are arguing along the lines of "Well, it wasn't "illegal", and he didn't actually engage in any threatening acts or verbalizations, but COMMONSENSE should dictate, and make obvious that he shouldn't have done it... because it's stupid...", etc.

I find this so ironic that people who claim to support Second Amendment-protected rights would turn to such a vague and ambiguous term as "commonsense" to argue their point, when that term is what is used by nearly all the opponents of Second Amendment-protected rights in calling for "commonsense gun safety regulations". That is, it's an appeal to something that is supposed to be so obvious and clear to anyone capable of normal perception and cognition, that it can't be disputed. Right? So anyone who disagrees with the "commonsense" notion that civilians ought not have any firearms ever in any public place (or have a suppressor or a semi-automatic long gun or be allowed to transfer a firearm without government approval, etc.,etc., etc.)... well, those people are crazy gun nuts, or some kind of demented deplorables. Yet here we have the very targets of those "commonsense" arguments arguing using the same, I'll call it false, argument. It should be "obvious", that if people vehemently and diametrically disagree about what is or isn't "commonsense", that there really is no such thing and any argument using anything resembling an appeal to any such or similar concept is false. Say what you actually mean, otherwise you might as well argue it's because "the gods have decreed it".

And, here, from another thread on another topic, is a post from something using the screen name "commonsense", which pretty much sums it up:

commonsense August 11, 2019 9:26 am 

Absolutely! The second amendment is not sensible in this day and age. I believe most people would agree not to completely outlaw every gun, just have much stricter laws and enforcement. Ban all assault and semi-automatic guns.


Common sense tells me, if no one (even EEF's red flag laws) can reduce the chances of evil from causing violence -- with or without a firearm -- then the only solution is for each individual to be prepared to meet force with like or greater force.

Prevention will not work.  We know that, even though some on here choose to believe there's some predictive solution just waiting for lawmakers (who can't accurately describe the rifles they want to ban) to codify it.  If that's a given, then the only common sense solution remains: train, practice and carry your own firearm.

Here is a numerical hypothetical:

-- last year, 100 mass shootings happened
-- Congress passes red flag laws the same year
-- this year only 50 mass shootings happened, a reduction attributed to keeping guns out of the hands of the mentally ill
-- also this year, 250 people had their guns taken from them by force before any hearing occurred. 75 of those died in the police raids to take their guns, because they refused to give up their rights.  The 50 shootings that were supposedly prevented were assumed to be in that 250.  So, 200 people who were not going to be mass murderers had their guns taken as well.
-- since the mass shootings that were "prevented" never happened, we have only a trend to support the supposition that any mass shootings were prevented. Trends don't indicate causes -- only the direction
    -- up or down -- of the data.  It's possible there was some initiating event that caused the number to hit 100 last year, more than in recent years, and that 50 was the normal number.  Removing the causal event from this year's factors may have been the direct reason for cutting that number in half.  The red flag laws did nothing to stop any of them.

The entire prevention argument is an emotional red herring.  Human behavior is too complicated and subject to too many influencers for anyone to predict.  Taking the civil rights of people who "just don't look/act right" is a subjective standard that solves nothing.

Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: changemyoil66 on August 13, 2019, 10:47:31 AM
Police in Maryland served a red flag warrant and the owner was killed by the PD last November. 
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on August 13, 2019, 11:49:01 AM
OK, let me take a stab at this, as earlier I said it wasn’t illegal, it was just stupid.  Maybe stupid was the wrong word to use so I will change it to prudent.  Tensions were very high given the 3 shootings.  If he was prudent and wanted to protect himself, he could have just carried his handgun and he could have worn his vest but not sling that rifle over his shoulder and walk into the store like that.  He could have easily gotten himself shot.  Just like it would not be prudent, if you had a lot of money, to dress up, wear your $15k Rolex watch and 2k diamond ring and drive your $200k Bentley to go eat at at your favorite soul food restaurant located in the inner city.  It is your right, you are not doing anything illegal, but it isn't prudent and you are not using “common sense.”

Others have other opinions, may feel that they have the “right” because it is not illegal, but that kind of thinking can get you killed or suffer grievous bodily harm.
Thank you for taking the time to attempt to explain why you label the legal actions "stupid", and have changed your term to "(not) prudent".


1. "Tensions were very high given the 3 shootings." This event took place a week after the previous Walmart shooting. At what point after the original event would you say it would have been "prudent" for him to do what he did? How would anyone determine how long (a week, am month, a year) after what kind of event where (anywhere, same state, same store chain, etc.) it would then be prudent to engage in such legal activity?  I'm asking because it's clear from comments I've seen that some people (who claim to be gun rights advocates) firmly believe that no one should ever be allowed in public, or at least a public building, while openly carrying a long gun, maybe a handgun, and maybe even a "tactical vest" with either or both. To me, this puts them dangerously close to those who argue that no one should be allowed in public carrying concealed. Where's the line, and why draw it there? If that depends on "the feelings of people in the area", why? What percentage of the "alarmed" people have to be how alarmed to make such an act "imprudent" or illegal?

2. "He could have easily gotten himself shot." Do you think he wasn't aware of that possibility? If he was aware of that possibility, and that openly carrying a handgun and a rifle while wearing a "tactical vest" could increase the chances of that, but still wanted to "make his point", do you still think he was "wrong"/"imprudent"? I'm asking because some people seem to be arguing that independent of whatever may or may not have happened to this individual, what he did was "stupid" because of how it somehow reflects negatively on the gun rights advocate community as a whole. The gun rights opposition runs the gamut of beliefs from "no assault rifles in stores" to "no concealed carry for anyone anywhere" to "no guns". Their goal is not get to everyone to agree that such acts are "imprudent" or "stupid", but that they should be illegal and result in arrest, prosecution, and incarceration. If an act is imprudent or stupid, why should it be legal in the first place? I'm trying to get people to delineate that question. When, or if, under what conditions and circumstances, a person could follow the current law and go into a retail establishment openly carrying a rifle and a handgun and wearing a "tactical vest". Some gun rights acrtivists seem to be saying "never", and thus are really advocating for a change in the law and outlawing at least some specific acts in some specific or general locations. I have't seen any of them really clarify anything. They all seem to be saying "I support open carry, but..." Sound familiar?

3. "...go eat at at your favorite soul food restaurant located in the inner city...". Aside from the implicit racism in that comment, what if that person did that (as I'm pretty sure certain gold and diamond-bedecked rappers have done) and nothing "bad" happens, what does that mean about your judgment that such an act was "not prudent" or "commonsense"? Because in the example we are talking about in Missouri, nothing "bad" happened to this guy, except for one manager pulling the fire alarm resulting in him exiting the store where he was confronted by someone pointing a gun at him, and then the police getting involved and the prosecutor claiming "terroristic threatening". Since he has said he "wanted to see if Walmart would respect his Second Amendment rights", he was obviously aware that "something" could have happened, but chose to make his political speech statement anyway.

Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: drck1000 on August 13, 2019, 01:34:39 PM
Open carry at police station in Dearborn, MI

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4j8la_mu6HY

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LslQDDfqmbg

Was this their right?  Was this act stupid or smart?  You decide. . .

I believe this may have been discussed in another thread on 2a, but figured it fit right into this one. . .
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: changemyoil66 on August 13, 2019, 01:51:59 PM
Sucks how prosecution looked for reasons.  I can see that happening here if OC is ever legal.  Someone will call HPD.  HPD will overreact and arrest person.  Prosecution will look for a reason.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: RSN172 on August 13, 2019, 02:18:47 PM
Thank you for taking the time to attempt to explain why you label the legal actions "stupid", and have changed your term to "(not) prudent".


1. "Tensions were very high given the 3 shootings." This event took place a week after the previous Walmart shooting. At what point after the original event would you say it would have been "prudent" for him to do what he did? How would anyone determine how long (a week, am month, a year) after what kind of event where (anywhere, same state, same store chain, etc.) it would then be prudent to engage in such legal activity?  I'm asking because it's clear from comments I've seen that some people (who claim to be gun rights advocates) firmly believe that no one should ever be allowed in public, or at least a public building, while openly carrying a long gun, maybe a handgun, and maybe even a "tactical vest" with either or both. To me, this puts them dangerously close to those who argue that no one should be allowed in public carrying concealed. Where's the line, and why draw it there? If that depends on "the feelings of people in the area", why? What percentage of the "alarmed" people have to be how alarmed to make such an act "imprudent" or illegal?

It is impossible to set a specific time frame because no one knows what might happen in the future.  You have to use your own judgement as to what YOU want do to based on current circumstances.   As to what percentage question, I don’t  know and neither do I care because it doesn’t change my opinion.

2. "He could have easily gotten himself shot." Do you think he wasn't aware of that possibility? If he was aware of that possibility, and that openly carrying a handgun and a rifle while wearing a "tactical vest" could increase the chances of that, but still wanted to "make his point", do you still think he was "wrong"/"imprudent"? I'm asking because some people seem to be arguing that independent of whatever may or may not have happened to this individual, what he did was "stupid" because of how it somehow reflects negatively on the gun rights advocate community as a whole. The gun rights opposition runs the gamut of beliefs from "no assault rifles in stores" to "no concealed carry for anyone anywhere" to "no guns". Their goal is not get to everyone to agree that such acts are "imprudent" or "stupid", but that they should be illegal and result in arrest, prosecution, and incarceration. If an act is imprudent or stupid, why should it be legal in the first place? I'm trying to get people to delineate that question. When, or if, under what conditions and circumstances, a person could follow the current law and go into a retail establishment openly carrying a rifle and a handgun and wearing a "tactical vest". Some gun rights acrtivists seem to be saying "never", and thus are really advocating for a change in the law and outlawing at least some specific acts in some specific or general locations. I have't seen any of them really clarify anything. They all seem to be saying "I support open carry, but..." Sound familiar?

I don’t know if he was aware of the danger he was putting himself in, but he should be aware of trigger happy cops that have shot people for a lot less. 

3. "...go eat at at your favorite soul food restaurant located in the inner city...". Aside from the implicit racism in that comment, what if that person did that (as I'm pretty sure certain gold and diamond-bedecked rappers have done) and nothing "bad" happens, what does that mean about your judgment that such an act was "not prudent" or "commonsense"? Because in the example we are talking about in Missouri, nothing "bad" happened to this guy, except for one manager pulling the fire alarm resulting in him exiting the store where he was confronted by someone pointing a gun at him, and then the police getting involved and the prosecutor claiming "terroristic threatening". Since he has said he "wanted to see if Walmart would respect his Second Amendment rights", he was obviously aware that "something" could have happened, but chose to make his political speech statement anyway.
Not being racist.  People want to be so politically correct that you can’t tell the truth because it might offend someone.  Most people know the inner city of almost all cities is a dangerous place.  Those rappers you refer to usually go with a large contingent and are well known so most times nothing bad happens, but as you know, several high profile black celebrities have been killed on the street.  Even locally tourists are warned not to venture off Kalakaua Ave at night.  Las Vegas says the same thing.  Stay on the Strip if you are walking around at night and do not walk on the side or back streets.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: changemyoil66 on August 13, 2019, 02:29:37 PM
B4 I carried in Vegas, we walked from the pawn shop (gold and silver) to Freemont. On the map it didn't look that far.  That was a mistake.  Even though we pass the courthouse, ioutside the entire streets were empty.  We were the only people walking.  We even stopped into another pawn shop along the way because bums were following us.  Then finally made it to Freemont street.  Won't be doing that walk again.

Not to be racist, but black guys end up shooting themselves also.  Plaxaco Burres screwed my FF season when he shot himself in the leg inside the night club.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Heavies on August 13, 2019, 02:49:18 PM
I still say STUPID,

and his actions HURT the cause of the 2nd Amendment, and gives fuel to the gun grabbing factions in the public and government.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 13, 2019, 05:13:10 PM
I still say STUPID,

and his actions HURT the cause of the 2nd Amendment, and gives fuel to the gun grabbing factions in the public and government.

I say the fireman was more stupid.  CCW license, career in public safety, yet judges a man DOING NOTHING THREATENING as a criminal and holds him at gun point -- potentially initiating something more violent than would have happened otherwise.

The fireman HURT the cause of the 2A by showing how someone with poor judgement and a license to carry can be a bad combination.  He may have had a badge (firefighter), but he's not supposed to be playing Cop.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: 19pontiac79 on August 13, 2019, 06:03:25 PM
I say the fireman was more stupid.  CCW license, career in public safety, yet judges a man DOING NOTHING THREATENING as a criminal and holds him at gun point -- potentially initiating something more violent than would have happened otherwise.

The fireman HURT the cause of the 2A by showing how someone with poor judgement and a license to carry can be a bad combination.  He may have had a badge (firefighter), but he's not supposed to be playing Cop.

I'm on the fence this one. Maybe he watched too much news. And was thinking " if I draw second. I die". On the other hand the rifle guy lucky the fireman wasn't the type to think " I ain't a cop or enforcement. I don't have to say freeze. Stop. Get down. Put your hands up"  and just shot him. This could have ended being one big embarrassment cluster f*ck and laughing point for gun grabbers.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 13, 2019, 06:09:20 PM
I'm on the fence this one. Maybe he watched too much news. And was thinking " if I draw second. I die". On the other hand the rifle guy lucky the fireman wasn't the type to think " I ain't a cop or enforcement. I don't have to say freeze. Stop. Get down. Put your hands up"  and just shot him. This could have ended being one big embarrassment cluster f*ck and laughing point for gun grabbers.

That's my point.  Both players had guns.  Only the one that wasn't stupid (as others called him) is viewed as a "hero".  I see him as playing vigilante, going into the situation, gun drawn, when the better decision would have been call 911 and observe.  Only draw your gun if the subject threatens you or others.  Until then, wait for the authorities -- the real Cops -- to arrive.

Two civilians with guns holding each other at bay out of fear is something the Left can applaud.  It feeds their "can't be trusted with guns in public" narrative.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on August 13, 2019, 06:38:40 PM
Boston Tea Party.

Stupid? Hurt the cause? Made the colonists look bad?

Lexington and Concord "confrontations" (regardless of who shot first).

Stupid? Hurt the cause? Made the colonists look bad?

Etc.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on August 13, 2019, 06:41:25 PM
Sucks how prosecution looked for reasons.  I can see that happening here if OC is ever legal.  Someone will call HPD.  HPD will overreact and arrest person.  Prosecution will look for a reason.
And they won't have to bother to go "judge shopping".
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Heavies on August 13, 2019, 08:41:47 PM


stu·pid

/ˈst(y)o͞opəd/





adjective

adjective: stupid; comparative adjective: stupider; superlative adjective: stupidest



1.


having or showing a great lack of intelligence or common sense.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: drck1000 on August 13, 2019, 08:54:06 PM
http://cavemancircus.com/2019/08/13/open-carry-attention-seekers/

Scroll to bottom
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Heavies on August 13, 2019, 08:58:56 PM
http://cavemancircus.com/2019/08/13/open-carry-attention-seekers/

Scroll to bottom
I like the chromed out AK.   ;D
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: drck1000 on August 13, 2019, 09:02:09 PM
I like the chromed out AK.   ;D
And here I was wondering how Mr Revolver managed to keep his pants up.  :P  ;D
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Heavies on August 13, 2019, 09:03:19 PM
And here I was wondering how Mr Revolver managed to keep his pants up.  :P  ;D

 :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on August 13, 2019, 09:17:08 PM
That's because you came up with irrelevant examples that make zero points in the argument.

Open carry == Constitutional right
Sitting at the "Whites Only" lunch counter == Constitutional right
Attending a "Whites Only" school == Constitutional right

You see a pattern now?

The pattern is you fail to recognize the difference between legal and smart.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on August 13, 2019, 09:19:12 PM
OK, let me take a stab at this, as earlier I said it wasn’t illegal, it was just stupid.  Maybe stupid was the wrong word to use so I will change it to prudent.  Tensions were very high given the 3 shootings.  If he was prudent and wanted to protect himself, he could have just carried his handgun and he could have worn his vest but not sling that rifle over his shoulder and walk into the store like that.  He could have easily gotten himself shot.  Just like it would not be prudent, if you had a lot of money, to dress up, wear your $15k Rolex watch and 2k diamond ring and drive your $200k Bentley to go eat at at your favorite soul food restaurant located in the inner city.  It is your right, you are not doing anything illegal, but it isn't prudent and you are not using “common sense.”

Others have other opinions, may feel that they have the “right” because it is not illegal, but that kind of thinking can get you killed or suffer grievous bodily harm.

Someone gets it!
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on August 13, 2019, 09:26:37 PM
I'm on the fence this one. Maybe he watched too much news. And was thinking " if I draw second. I die". On the other hand the rifle guy lucky the fireman wasn't the type to think " I ain't a cop or enforcement. I don't have to say freeze. Stop. Get down. Put your hands up"  and just shot him. This could have ended being one big embarrassment cluster f*ck and laughing point for gun grabbers.

Those are valid tactical questions.

Imagine you see a muslim looking man walk into a crowd and he has what appears to be TNT strapped to his chest. He yells Allah Akbar. You are there with a legal CCW. Do you shoot, do you run, do you stand there and hope he isn't just practicing his constitutional right to say praise god?

Kill him and maybe you saved everyone or maybe you killed a guy who was pulling a prank and only had flares on his chest
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on August 14, 2019, 07:54:08 AM

stu·pid

/ˈst(y)o͞opəd/

adjective

adjective: stupid; comparative adjective: stupider; superlative adjective: stupidest

1. having or showing a great lack of intelligence or common sense.
So the people who oppose "commonsense gun safety regulations" are stupid and demonstrate a great lack of intelligence. Good to know. That's what I always thought. So, since it's likely you don't consider yourself stupid, may we presume you're turning in your semi-automatics?
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: changemyoil66 on August 14, 2019, 09:06:05 AM
Those are valid tactical questions.

Imagine you see a muslim looking man walk into a crowd and he has what appears to be TNT strapped to his chest. He yells Allah Akbar. You are there with a legal CCW. Do you shoot, do you run, do you stand there and hope he isn't just practicing his constitutional right to say praise god?

Kill him and maybe you saved everyone or maybe you killed a guy who was pulling a prank and only had flares on his chest

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lXDEsnwHkQ0

Jalala Brothers known for their pranks in the UK.  Good thing no one has CCW up there.  Especially their clown with an axe.  Guy coming at me with an axe is asking for trouble.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_b9oQ22NCs0

4:27
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 14, 2019, 10:19:18 AM
Those are valid tactical questions.

Imagine you see a muslim looking man walk into a crowd and he has what appears to be TNT strapped to his chest. He yells Allah Akbar. You are there with a legal CCW. Do you shoot, do you run, do you stand there and hope he isn't just practicing his constitutional right to say praise god?

Kill him and maybe you saved everyone or maybe you killed a guy who was pulling a prank and only had flares on his chest

Prank?  You mean like pointing a replica handgun at someone?  Same thing as displaying "fake" TNT.

Talk about stupid.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on August 14, 2019, 02:58:21 PM
Here's Dean Weingarten's take on it. Includes the Missouri "terroristic threatening" statute, which indicates 10 people or more must be involved, which of course there were more than that in Walmart, but it's interesting that at least they specified a number (how they came up with that number would be a video I'd like to watch). He makes the opposite point of most commentators who only focus on the effect of the recent previous "mass public shootings" on the unarmed people in a store, as opposed the effect those events would have on a person who is normally armed in public places (i.e. they'd be more inclined to take extra "precautions"). Also, he can't confirm the claim of "body armor". I'm (as is Dean Weingarten) still looking forward to the videos of the guy in the store and reactions to him prior to the fire alarm being pulled. Since we have plenty of photos of other open carriers carrying long guns in public retail establishments with no one around them apparently even batting an eye, I wonder if these videos (store security and his phone) will tell a different story? I also wonder if we'll ever see either of them.

http://gunwatch.blogspot.com/2019/08/springfield-missouri-open-carry-of.html

Tuesday, August 13, 2019

Springfield Missouri Open Carry of Rifle, Pistol, Becomes Panic Driven by Media Contagion


At about 4:10 p.m. on 8 August, 2019, Dmitriy Andreychenco walked into the Walmart Neighborhood Market in Springfield, Missouri. He had a slung AR type rifle and was wearing a T-shirt and tactical vest. He obtained a shopping cart and was videoing himself on a cell phone while pushing the cart through the store. He did not threaten anyone, point the rifle at anyone, or make any threats that are known at this time.

A manager at the store pulled the store alarm, causing a panic while customers evacuated the store. Dmitriy evacuated with the other customers. As he left the store, a firefighter with a concealed carry permit, who was armed, drew his pistol and held Dmitriy for police. In the video from outside the store, you can see that Dmitri calmly complying with police orders. Look at his black t-shirt. I do not see any evidence of body armor being worn.

He is wearing some sort of web gear, which it appears, the media denoted as "body armor". Identification of web gear as body armor has been common in the media.

Open carry is legal in Missouri. It has been hard fought for. Opponents of an armed population have worked hard to characterize open carry as threatening. The last few days of media blitz on the rampage murders in El Paso, Texas, and Dayton, Ohio, have put the country on edge. The message has been that every young white male is a deadly threat.  The manager at Walmart seems to have bought into the message.

In the video, Dmitriy quickly and calmly follows the police orders. There is no indication, from the video, that he was wearing body armor. From the T-shirt he is wearing, it does not look as if he is wearing body armor. 

Link to video From  ky3.com: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HSJPnTmeYJo

Officers booked Dmitriy N. Andreychenko, 20, on suspicion of first-degree making a terroristic threat. Greene County Prosecutor Dan Patterson has yet to file formal charges in the case.

The Springfield Police Department arrived on scene within three minutes of the call. Police stated Andreychenko pulled up to the Walmart, where he donned body armor and military fatigues. Police say the man had tactical weapons.

Police then say Andreychenko walked into the Walmart Neighborhood Market where he grabbed a cart and began pushing it around the store. Police say the man was recording himself walking through the store via a cell phone.

The store manager at the Neighborhood Market pulled a fire alarm, urging people to escape the store.

Police say Andreychenko then made his way out an emergency exit where a former firefighter held the man at gunpoint. At that moment Springfield Police arrived on scene and detained the man.


No video from inside the store has been released at this point. When it is, I suspect it will show Dmitriy calmly pushing a cart through Walmart while recording himself on a cell phone. I suspect the cell phone images will show the same thing. That is what is indicated when you consider the calm way that Dmitriy followed police orders. The police are already saying Dmitriy had no intention of shooting anyone.  The police have said the initial arrest charge will be a terrorist threat in the first degree. Here is the definition in Missouri statutes.

Terrorist threat - 1st Degree 574.115-004Y From law.justia.com:

574.115. 1. A person commits the offense of making a terrorist threat in the first degree if such person, with the purpose of frightening ten or more people or causing the evacuation, quarantine or closure of any portion of a building, inhabitable structure, place of assembly or facility of transportation, knowingly:

(1) Communicates an express or implied threat to cause an incident or condition involving danger to life; or

(2) Communicates a false report of an incident or condition involving danger to life; or

(3) Causes a false belief or fear that an incident has occurred or that a condition exists involving danger to life.

2. The offense of making a terrorist threat in the first degree is a class D felony.

3. No offense is committed under this section by a person acting in good faith with the purpose to prevent har
m.

The Green County Prosecutor has not filed formal charges at the time of this writing, according to the Springfield Police Department. I doubt the terrorist threat charge will be filed. It is not warranted by the facts. The Walmart manager might be guilty of a terrorist threat; but section 3 specifically exempts threats made in good faith.

We have not heard anything from Dimitriy. I suspect his side of the events will help calm down the current media frenzy.  It is worth noting that even when confronted by another armed citizen, neither of them felt the need to fire any shots.

Rights are not very useful if they can be taken from you when you need them the most. The public is fearful because two mass murders have been given so much press in the last week. It is not unreasonable for people to wish to be armed in public places.

The right to carry is not worth much if simply carrying legal weapons in a public place, while videoing yourself, can be charged as a terrorist threat.  If that is the standard, the Second Amendment and the right to bear arms mean little.

©2019 by Dean Weingarten: Permission to share is granted when this notice and link are included.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on August 15, 2019, 09:55:17 PM
Prank?  You mean like pointing a replica handgun at someone?  Same thing as displaying "fake" TNT.

Talk about stupid.

Pointing a replica handgun at someone is clearly a crime so not applicable.

Who is to say what fake TNT looks like? You can try to nitpick the examples to avoid the actual issue if you want but I can come up with a bunch more.

How about you place a pressure cooker in a garbage can at a crowded event.
Wear a ski mask into a bank
Walk into a government bag with a loudly ticking clock.

Shall I go on?
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on August 15, 2019, 09:56:38 PM
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lXDEsnwHkQ0

Jalala Brothers known for their pranks in the UK.  Good thing no one has CCW up there.  Especially their clown with an axe.  Guy coming at me with an axe is asking for trouble.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_b9oQ22NCs0

4:27

I have seen some of those. Pretty hilarious for anyone watching. Pretty scary for the people getting the prank pulled on them. Thank god no one had a CCW on them and chose to shoot.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on October 02, 2019, 02:09:57 PM
So... is it "okay" NOW (eight weeks after this event) to openly carry a long gun (or any gun) into a WalMart where open carry is legal, or is it STILL "stupid"?

If not NOW, WHEN? What time period, exactly, and why, makes it go from "stupid" to "okay"? If "never", why? If "never" for long guns, why allow handguns? Or handguns "never" as well?

If no long guns and handguns ever, why allow concealed carry?

Thank you in advance for the cogent arguments and evidence.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 02, 2019, 10:27:58 PM
So... is it "okay" NOW (eight weeks after this event) to openly carry a long gun (or any gun) into a WalMart where open carry is legal, or is it STILL "stupid"?

If not NOW, WHEN? What time period, exactly, and why, makes it go from "stupid" to "okay"? If "never", why? If "never" for long guns, why allow handguns? Or handguns "never" as well?

If no long guns and handguns ever, why allow concealed carry?

Thank you in advance for the cogent arguments and evidence.

It is the whole picture not any one single thing.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: punaperson on October 03, 2019, 06:30:38 AM
It is the whole picture not any one single thing.
In other words, you have no cogent argument nor evidence.
Title: Re: 20yo male arrested outside MO Walmart with weapons.
Post by: eyeeatingfish on October 03, 2019, 10:42:10 PM
In other words, you have no cogent argument nor evidence.

I can't help that you refuse to recognize the nature of the situation. As I have said before there are things that are legal but still a bad idea. If you don't believe me then go leave a pressure cooker on the sidewalk at the next Boston Marathon then complain by saying so many years has passed. Wear a mask next time you go into the bank and pass your withdrawal request on a note while wearing gloves then complain when something happens to you that you didn't break any laws.

It isn't just having a firearm, it is the whole picture. It is the location, the firearm, the body armor, etc.