2aHawaii

General Topics => Off Topic => Topic started by: eyeeatingfish on August 25, 2019, 05:34:29 PM

Title: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: eyeeatingfish on August 25, 2019, 05:34:29 PM
California signed into law a bill that changed how courts are supposed to judge a police officer's use of force. The current nationwide standard is reasonableness. So the question is was the officer's use of force reasonable given what he knew at the time. It has changed now to necessary. So was the officer's use of force necessary given the situation.

So if a cop shoots someone with a realistic looking toy gun, in the past they would get off because the officer had reason to believe their life was in danger. However under the new standard the officer could be prosecuted for murder because it was not necessary to kill someone who only had a toy gun. Under the new standard (if I understand it correctly) the suspect would have to fire first so that the officer could attest that he knew the gun was real. Puts them at a huge disadvantage at that point.

I am sure someone will challenge this law but if it stands challenge I wouldn't be surprised if there was an exodus of officers in California.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2019/08/19/police-shootings-new-california-law-raises-standard-use-force/2054368001/
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 25, 2019, 05:36:20 PM
California signed into law a bill that changed how courts are supposed to judge a police officer's use of force. The current nationwide standard is reasonableness. So the question is was the officer's use of force reasonable given what he knew at the time. It has changed now to necessary. So was the officer's use of force necessary given the situation.

So if a cop shoots someone with a realistic looking toy gun, in the past they would get off because the officer had reason to believe their life was in danger. However under the new standard the officer could be prosecuted for murder because it was not necessary to kill someone who only had a toy gun. Under the new standard (if I understand it correctly) the suspect would have to fire first so that the officer could attest that he knew the gun was real. Puts them at a huge disadvantage at that point.

I am sure someone will challenge this law but if it stands challenge I wouldn't be surprised if there was an exodus of officers in California.

https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2019/08/19/police-shootings-new-california-law-raises-standard-use-force/2054368001/

Why would a Cop have a realistic toy gun, and why would he shoot someone with it?
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: zippz on August 25, 2019, 07:05:15 PM
Why would a Cop have a realistic toy gun, and why would he shoot someone with it?

It's California.  That's next year's law.
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: changemyoil66 on August 25, 2019, 10:13:10 PM
More DNC logic. Not sure why LEO enforce unconstitutional laws in CA.

They need to do what the sheriffs did across the nation and say they will not enforce unconstitutional law.

LEOSA permits will be next and more anti LEO laws, hung out to dry.

DNC hates LEOs.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: RSN172 on August 26, 2019, 06:06:46 AM
I stopped going to CA 7 years ago.  I won't give them one penny of my money.  If you have a handicap placard, you are free to use it in all states except CA. 
You have to go and apply for a visitor permit first.  That is how screwed up their laws are.  The other 49 states should return the favor and not honor the CA placard unless their handicapped residents got an additional permit first.
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: drck1000 on August 26, 2019, 07:23:53 AM
Quote
“We’re trying to raise the public’s consciousness to see that, if you say you followed the law to the letter and the law says it’s justifiable to take the life of an unarmed person, then we believe the law needs reexamining,’’ she said.

More emotionally based approaches...

Easy to second guess someone from the safety of behind your keyboard or your safe space. My first impression is that this either doesn’t do anything of what they intend or further puts innocent folks at greater risk.
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: ren on August 26, 2019, 08:09:11 AM
Why would a Cop have a realistic toy gun, and why would he shoot someone with it?

I would just play dead like a horrible B movie.
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: changemyoil66 on August 26, 2019, 10:27:45 AM
More emotionally based approaches...

Easy to second guess someone from the safety of behind your keyboard or your safe space. My first impression is that this either doesn’t do anything of what they intend or further puts innocent folks at greater risk.

Put PD at greater risk and more PD charged with murder/manslaughter. 

*edit
PD should strike
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: eyeeatingfish on August 26, 2019, 09:35:02 PM
Put PD at greater risk and more PD charged with murder/manslaughter. 

*edit
PD should strike

I wonder what that would look like. I don't think they are allowed to strike so if they did it could essentially be them losing their jobs. I wonder how long they would survive if there was an exodus of police officers. How long before they saw the necessity or started forming their own armed force.

On a side note I recall a psychological study where they found out that danger made people more likely to be conservative... Maybe things would get more dangerous and California would turn to a red state!
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: RSN172 on August 26, 2019, 11:10:43 PM
All Trump's fault plus CA sucks anyway.
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: Heavies on August 27, 2019, 12:31:03 AM
This lefty craziness loves criminals over the citizens and LEO.   And Hawaii will just follow along.   SMH
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: bass monkey on August 27, 2019, 11:21:43 AM
The police will just take even longer to respond if they bother coming at all. 
Better to just wait until the criminal leaves and only the victim is left so they don't see anything and not put in any situations.
Just write the report and go
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: changemyoil66 on August 28, 2019, 09:06:04 AM
The police will just take even longer to respond if they bother coming at all. 
Better to just wait until the criminal leaves and only the victim is left so they don't see anything and not put in any situations.
Just write the report and go

And so they don't end up on youtube.

Then crime will continue to rise and people will move from there to other states and vote the same way.
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: Kuleana on August 28, 2019, 10:39:57 AM
The police will just take even longer to respond if they bother coming at all. 
Better to just wait until the criminal leaves and only the victim is left so they don't see anything and not put in any situations.
Just write the report and go

Isn't that what the situation is now, police always arriving too late to stop crimes in progress?

Isn't that also the main reason why we argue for the 2nd Amendment, concealed/open carry, etc.?
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: bass monkey on August 28, 2019, 11:43:40 AM
Isn't that what the situation is now, police always arriving too late to stop crimes in progress?

Isn't that also the main reason why we argue for the 2nd Amendment, concealed/open carry, etc.?

Its California,  they believe on pissing yourself to stop an attacker. 
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: Heavies on August 28, 2019, 04:02:57 PM
Its California,  they believe on pissing yourself to stop an attacker. 

OR they just do this.  No attackers will touch after this....

https://www.facebook.com/steve.v.nichols1/videos/10220121967786359/
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: eyeeatingfish on August 28, 2019, 11:24:53 PM
Isn't that what the situation is now, police always arriving too late to stop crimes in progress?

Isn't that also the main reason why we argue for the 2nd Amendment, concealed/open carry, etc.?

If they increase the standard for a police officer to shoot then how much harder will they judge the rest of us in a self defense shooting?
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 29, 2019, 10:42:28 AM
If they increase the standard for a police officer to shoot then how much harder will they judge the rest of us in a self defense shooting?

Go back and read your academy training material.

"Self defense" is only part of the continuum of force.  In contrast, a "civilian" in a self defense situation is not trying to effect an arrest.  He is ONLY being "judged" on the "reasonable person" standard for perceiving a threat and deeming lethal force as an appropriate measure to stop that threat.

Quote
Law enforcement officers should use only the amount of force necessary to mitigate an incident, make an arrest, or protect themselves or others from harm.
The levels, or continuum, of force police use include basic verbal and physical restraint, less-lethal force, and lethal force.

Nobody in the justice system will ask why you didn't use your hand or stun gun to force the assailant to drop the bat he was holding.
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: changemyoil66 on August 29, 2019, 01:50:06 PM
Go back and read your academy training material.

"Self defense" is only part of the continuum of force.  In contrast, a "civilian" in a self defense situation is not trying to effect an arrest.  He is ONLY being "judged" on the "reasonable person" standard for perceiving a threat and deeming lethal force as an appropriate measure to stop that threat.


You said "he", what about she and other pronouns?
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 29, 2019, 02:43:23 PM
You said "he", what about she and other pronouns?

Step away from the Kool Aid.....
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: eyeeatingfish on August 29, 2019, 10:54:23 PM
Go back and read your academy training material.

"Self defense" is only part of the continuum of force.  In contrast, a "civilian" in a self defense situation is not trying to effect an arrest.  He is ONLY being "judged" on the "reasonable person" standard for perceiving a threat and deeming lethal force as an appropriate measure to stop that threat.

Nobody in the justice system will ask why you didn't use your hand or stun gun to force the assailant to drop the bat he was holding.

You missed the point. If the overall system is making it harder for cops to use force then I think there is good reason they are going to do the same thing to us when we use force.
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 30, 2019, 10:27:16 AM
You missed the point. If the overall system is making it harder for cops to use force then I think there is good reason they are going to do the same thing to us when we use force.

Nope.  YOU missed the point.  Police are employees of the state and have to follow the rules set by the police department.  Non-LE are individuals with no rules other than the statutes.

You're assuming a hypothetical that's based on an irrational belief -- that a judge deciding on a claim of self defense for non-LE will apply police department guidance.  Won't happen. 
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: eyeeatingfish on August 30, 2019, 09:47:18 PM
Nope.  YOU missed the point.  Police are employees of the state and have to follow the rules set by the police department.  Non-LE are individuals with no rules other than the statutes.

You're assuming a hypothetical that's based on an irrational belief -- that a judge deciding on a claim of self defense for non-LE will apply police department guidance.  Won't happen.

I am the one who made my point. I know what I meant. I was not suggesting that judges will interpret civilian action based on LEO use of force policy. I was talking about the overall nature of society changing the way it looks at force justification.
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 30, 2019, 09:49:01 PM
I am the one who made my point. I know what I meant. I was not suggesting that judges will interpret civilian action based on LEO use of force policy. I was talking about the overall nature of society changing the way it looks at force justification.

There's no data to back up that hypothesis.  One story is not a "trend".   :sleeping:
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: eyeeatingfish on August 30, 2019, 10:08:47 PM
There's no data to back up that hypothesis.  One story is not a "trend".   :sleeping:

It wasn't even a hypothesis, it was a rhetorical question. You know, a question that is not seeking an answer but to make one think...
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: ren on August 30, 2019, 10:12:26 PM
mine as well take away firearms from LEOs too :-\
more power to criminals
In light of recent negative perspectives of LEOs in general, I surmise it would take an exceptional person to become an officer today. I don't know why politicians continue to fan the flame of anti-police rhetoric and pass laws limiting or second-guessing their decisions. I guess these same politicians would like to govern over a cesspool instead of a prosperous, lawful society.
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on August 30, 2019, 10:29:45 PM
If they increase the standard for a police officer to shoot then how much harder will they judge the rest of us in a self defense shooting?

I am the one who made my point. I know what I meant. I was not suggesting that judges will interpret civilian action based on LEO use of force policy. I was talking about the overall nature of society changing the way it looks at force justification.

It wasn't even a hypothesis, it was a rhetorical question. You know, a question that is not seeking an answer but to make one think...


Wait.  You said you were making a point.  Now you're saying it was rhetorical.

Try reading what you wrote before posting another comment.  if you can't keep your lies and BS straight, how do you think we feel?
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 01, 2019, 10:18:37 PM

Wait.  You said you were making a point.  Now you're saying it was rhetorical.

Try reading what you wrote before posting another comment.  if you can't keep your lies and BS straight, how do you think we feel?

Face palm... Can you not comprehend a rhetorical point?
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 01, 2019, 10:42:37 PM
Face palm... Can you not comprehend a rhetorical point?

No such animal as a "rhetorical point."  You made that shit up (color me shocked!   :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:).


Quote
... a rhetorical question is asked when the questioner himself knows the answer already,
or an answer is not actually demanded.
So, an answer is not expected from the audience.

Such a question is used to emphasize a point or draw the audience’s attention.

So, by definition the point is NOT rhetorical.  The device (rhetorical question) is separate and apart from the point.

Your question, "how much harder will they judge the rest of us in a self defense shooting," is only rhetorical *IF* either

(a) you already know the answer, or

(b) the answer is obvious & doesn't require an answer from the audience.

Neither of those is correct, because nobody knows the answer.  You might have an opinion of your own, but that's not the undisputed answer.

Basically your attempt at a rhetorical question to make your point sucked,   :geekdanc:

Maybe an example would help you get it.  What if I said, "Wow! Have you ever seen someone as ignorant in your life as this EEF character?!" 

I'm not looking for a comparative answer debating whether someone knows a person as ignorant as you.  I'm using a rhetorical question to make the point that you're really ignorant.

Maybe you should state the point you were making again, so we can just skip the quasi-rhetorical excuses. 
Title: Re: Police Use Of Force in California Changed From Reasonable to Necessary
Post by: eyeeatingfish on September 03, 2019, 09:59:08 PM
No such animal as a "rhetorical point."  You made that shit up (color me shocked!   :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:).


So, by definition the point is NOT rhetorical.  The device (rhetorical question) is separate and apart from the point.

Your question, "how much harder will they judge the rest of us in a self defense shooting," is only rhetorical *IF* either

(a) you already know the answer, or

(b) the answer is obvious & doesn't require an answer from the audience.

Neither of those is correct, because nobody knows the answer.  You might have an opinion of your own, but that's not the undisputed answer.

Basically your attempt at a rhetorical question to make your point sucked,   :geekdanc:

Maybe an example would help you get it.  What if I said, "Wow! Have you ever seen someone as ignorant in your life as this EEF character?!" 

I'm not looking for a comparative answer debating whether someone knows a person as ignorant as you.  I'm using a rhetorical question to make the point that you're really ignorant.

Maybe you should state the point you were making again, so we can just skip the quasi-rhetorical excuses.

Ok, I will let you play grammar nazi so you can try to cover up the fact you were wrong about everything else.

I will fix my statement for you, it was a rhetorical question to make a point. Happy?

 :stopjack: