2aHawaii

General Topics => Off Topic => Topic started by: 6716J on September 16, 2019, 02:38:04 PM

Title: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: 6716J on September 16, 2019, 02:38:04 PM
My friend posted this and got me wondering... how much will this affect us in Hawaii? Probably even more than the mainland as everything comes by boat or air.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

That my facebook feed is not full of discussion about Saudi Arabia highlights how little the American public understands the global economy.

The first thing to understand is that oil markets are fully fungible. What that means, is that the market is fully global. Any one supplier going away just means there's less oil on the entirety of the market. Where the oil comes from, (Saudi exports, US exports) and where it goes (California, Toyko, France) doesn't matter. Five percent off the market affects every buyer and every seller.

Five to six percent of the market is offline now. And the way the Iranians struck was designed to take that oil off the market for a long time. They hit key processing facilities that cannot be easily and quickly rebuilt.

Five percent of the world's supply is gone, and will stay that way for up to a year.

Iran is directly threatening 15-20% more, above and beyond what they just took offline.

Make note: WESTERN ECONOMIES LIVE ON ENERGY.

Products cannot be made without it. Products cannot be shipped without it. Food cannot be grown without it. Food cannot be transported without it.

The price of exactly everything, not just gasoline, is under grave threat from Munich to Los Angeles.

And here is your non-partisan statement for the day: US Presidents do not get reelected in a downward spiraling economy with upward spiraling prices on everything from carrots to diapers.

"But we're an exporter now, it doesn't matter."

Except it does. Why on earth do you think Exxon-Mobile will sell to American refiners and distributors for $80/bbl when they can put it on a tanker and sell it internationally for $240/bbl? No major oil company, no matter where they're located, puts America first. Their bottom line is always first.

I'm not making predictions on where this will go. I really don't know. But this is perhaps the most pivotal security event we've seen since 2003.

Edit: The last time 10% of the world's oil supply was attacked militarily, me and 4000 of my closest friends boarded boats and took a little trip.

(https://scontent.fslc2-1.fna.fbcdn.net/v/t1.0-9/70282015_10157935699049274_5401287271573880832_n.jpg?_nc_cat=109&_nc_oc=AQm1WY2qCFdqoOTj9PppWPWtLf08sbl3OuCryxIwZfl360RDeF05aGSfD2oZdN1mo9E&_nc_ht=scontent.fslc2-1.fna&oh=9e4b81a400ba927e2bdf4c731423f984&oe=5DF023DC)
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: drck1000 on September 16, 2019, 02:52:07 PM
I read national projections is a 10 cent per gallon increase, so probably more in HI. Also that Trump approved release of about 4 Mil barrels, or enough for something like 2 weeks supply.

Then something like SA is supposed to be able to get over 50 percent of that capacity back in about a week. I work with a bunch of POL guys, so they are all over this one.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: zippz on September 16, 2019, 04:46:26 PM
Should have less effect than the past.  The US is now a net exporter of oil.  We got the petroleum reserve.  Natural gas and renewables are making a larger portion of the market every year.  And the Saudis had to reduce production to help bring oil prices up

It'll be a small blip on the radar.  The bigger and longer term issue is Iran's influence in the region and how oil production and transport is vulnerable
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 16, 2019, 04:56:30 PM
During the height of US energy dependence on OPEC, we were approaching 80% of our oil coming from the Middle East.

As of 2015, Saudi Arabia only provided 14% of US oils imports.  Canada provided 43% (hello pipelines!). 

The 1973 oil crisis, when OPEC crippled us by severely cutting exports, caused prices to soar and supplies to be used up faster than they could be replenished. The reason for Saudis cutting exports was the US support of Israel in their fight with the Palestinians.  We were only about 30% dependent on OPEC at that time. 

Shows why we should never willfully put the nation in that position again.  Dems running for President in 2020 have said they support an end to offshore oil drilling and fracking.  They want to place us once again in a position of being dependent on foreign countries for something we can drill for ourselves.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Heavies on September 16, 2019, 09:26:14 PM
Read Trump was going to open up our reserves to offset pricing. 
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: drck1000 on September 16, 2019, 09:28:59 PM
Read Trump was going to open up our reserves to offset pricing.
Yeah. Reports mentioned he released 4 mil barrels as stopgap measure (see post above  ;D )
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Heavies on September 16, 2019, 09:30:48 PM
Yeah. Reports mentioned he released 4 mil barrels as stopgap measure (see post above  ;D )
#nofocus #heads   ;D
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: 6716J on September 17, 2019, 07:52:44 AM
More from my friend. He's a global intel specialist so I leave it to him, but judging from his posts, this is gonna hurt.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

This explains how severe the Saudi attacks are from a technical perspective, in lay terms.

https://twitter.com/AmyJaffeenergy/status/1173211181441568769?fbclid=IwAR09qEK1otDxxv7ZfxpiDzaLpv9rHQeOP2n6F3AlezmCkCN1fS7TrtOO4hQ (https://twitter.com/AmyJaffeenergy/status/1173211181441568769?fbclid=IwAR09qEK1otDxxv7ZfxpiDzaLpv9rHQeOP2n6F3AlezmCkCN1fS7TrtOO4hQ)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

An additional, and often overlooked point regarding Saudi. Half of Saudi's production was destroyed (for six months to a year) by highly precise strikes, that hit individual processing components within a massive processing facility.

What is NOT BEING SAID IN MEDIA: This was not "a crippling blow." This was a demonstration of capability.

Read that again. This was a demonstration of Iranian capability.

The OTHER half of Saudi Arabian production (plus reserves) remains under direct threat of devastating destruction. Iran has demonstrated they can END Saudi Arabia economically.

This threat remains as I type.

If that threat comes to fruition, 10-12% of global oil production goes away. Price will skyrocket. There will be shortages globally. Cascading economic impacts will find your wallet with a quickness.

This blow to global production is unprecedented, and Iran can double it at any moment. Our CiC had better act wisely.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: drck1000 on September 17, 2019, 08:42:21 AM
Other speculation is that the impact of global oil production/supply impacts China just as hard, and at a time that they are particularly vulnerable with impacts from tariffs. Yeah, China gets most of their oil from Russia, but everyone who mostly imports (China) will hurt more.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 17, 2019, 11:03:39 AM
Other speculation is that the impact of global oil production/supply impacts China just as hard, and at a time that they are particularly vulnerable with impacts from tariffs. Yeah, China gets most of their oil from Russia, but everyone who mostly imports (China) will hurt more.

Where a country imports from is not the issue.  When the world's supply drops as much as is being projected, the prices rise among all other producers.

Supply and demand.  Basic economics, no matter capitalist, socialist, or whatever.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: drck1000 on September 17, 2019, 11:13:04 AM
Where a country imports from is not the issue.  When the world's supply drops as much as is being projected, the prices rise among all other producers.

Supply and demand.  Basic economics, no matter capitalist, socialist, or whatever.
Yes, maybe I wasn’t clear. All countries are gonna feel the hurt, just varying degrees. Even despite China getting most of their oil from Russia. At least IMO.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: 6716J on September 17, 2019, 01:37:18 PM
More from my intel guy

--------------------------

All messaging signalling indicates a Chamberlain-esque response from the whitehouse.

Sources report Trump is searching for the "Goldilocks" response from the pentagon. Let me break down that concept.

Too hot: A response that is severe enough that it leads to a severe escalation.

Too cold: A response that does not deter future aggression,

Just right (Goldilocks): Severe enough that Iran is deterred from future attacks, but not so severe that they go batshit, and severely escalate.

The problem is that with Iran, there is no goldilocks response. The only response that doesn't result in escalation is blowing up Iranians in Syria. And that will not deter them in the slightest.

Persians are fiercely nationalistic. The first bomb that hits Iranian soil results in full on, no-holds-barred, batshit response, to include (literally as step 1) activating Hamas and Hezbollah, drawing Israel into the conflict.

Right now, it appears Trump will aim for the "too cold" option. First, leaks are coming out of the Whitehouse that specifically mention attacking Iranian Republican Guard Corps (IRGC) assets. The leaks do not say where, but combined with the other bit of messaging should be taken to mean "in Syria." US strikes on Iranians in Syria happen because it's Tuesday. This is not a deterrent at all.

The other bit of message, is that the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, as well as US sources, are touting that the Saudi oil supply is now back to normal levels.

"No problem. Nothing to see here, folks. Move along to Kavanaugh or the next shiny thing."

This ignores a critical distinction. Saudi is back to 100% supply. But that comes via a triad that ignores production capacity.

1) 5 million barrels per day remaining production after the attack.
2) 2.5-ish million bpd of "reserve capacity" brought online in the wake of the attacks.
3) An unknown rate of release from an unknown volume of Saudi's strategic reserve. (Lots of oil sitting in tanks.)

Saudi's "production capacity" remains severely degraded, with the remainder (totaling about 7 Mbpd including reserve capacity currently in use) under severe and imminent threat.

In the face of this threat, Saudi and the US are downplaying the impact, while Trump searches for the non-existent Goldilocks Response.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Rocky on September 17, 2019, 03:25:32 PM
Did they bomb US territories or SA territory ?  ???

Have we not sold BILION$ of dollar$ of military equipment to SA in the last couple of years ?   :P

   Let them respond directly themselves and leave "The big Bad Wolf" out of the story.  ::)
JMHO
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Heavies on September 17, 2019, 04:04:50 PM
Makes me wonder how Irans nuclear weapons capability is coming along, and if they are provoking a fight so they can try it out...  serious sht going on here, IMO...
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Kuleana on September 17, 2019, 04:15:04 PM
Makes me wonder how Irans nuclear weapons capability is coming along, and if they are provoking a fight so they can try it out...  serious sht going on here, IMO...

If any country is provoking a Middle East war, there are a number of other countries that are guilty.  For example, the US and Israel are also guilty of provoking Iran as well.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: ren on September 17, 2019, 04:39:55 PM
If any country is provoking a Middle East war, there are a number of other countries that are guilty.  For example, the US and Israel are also guilty of provoking Iran as well.

no. provocation is not part of  US foreign policy.containment is.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 17, 2019, 05:21:02 PM
Did they bomb US territories or SA territory ?  ???

Have we not sold BILION$ of dollar$ of military equipment to SA in the last couple of years ?   :P

   Let them respond directly themselves and leave "The big Bad Wolf" out of the story.  ::)
JMHO

Since the US abandoned the Gold Standard, our currency had to be backed by something tangible to maintain its value.

The US negotiated with the Saudis to provide for their military security via selling them hardware, technology and training.  In return, they required everyone buying oil from them do so using US dollars.

I don't think the US is going to abandon our allies there in their time of need.  We have too much to lose with regard to our currency.

So, while the Saudis do have the means to make war, we also have a decades old agreement to give them military assistance.  They were instrumental in the war against Iraq, as that was the logistics and staging area for US and coalition troops.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 17, 2019, 05:23:09 PM
Didn't do much fact checking on this, so take time yourself if you want to use this information as a basis for your opinion.

Lots of good backstory on the US-Saudi relations.

https://youtu.be/ugZi5Y-eHUI
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 17, 2019, 08:03:00 PM
4d chess? Prices will rise and for a while. So trump does away with lots of oil drilling/fraking regs.

Boom more US oil and tree huggers upset.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk

Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: drck1000 on September 17, 2019, 08:08:14 PM
4d chess? Prices will rise and for a while. So trump does away with lots of oil drilling/fraking regs.

Boom more US oil and tree huggers upset.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
Push to get more pipelines approved. Supposedly thousands of wells read to produce, but lacking efficient distribution infrastructure.

Wait, so Trump made Iranians bomb SA? Trump was working with Houthi rebels. Damn, that’s some man on the grassy knoll stuff.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 18, 2019, 12:36:27 AM
Push to get more pipelines approved. Supposedly thousands of wells read to produce, but lacking efficient distribution infrastructure.

Wait, so Trump made Iranians bomb SA? Trump was working with Houthi rebels. Damn, that’s some man on the grassy knoll stuff.

Trump fired National Security Advisor John Bolton last week.

Bolton was a hawk on Iran and has been for decades.

Iran saw this as their chance to act up while the President was no longer being advised by his anti-Iran hawk.

You do the 4D math!   
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 18, 2019, 09:06:55 AM
Trump fired National Security Advisor John Bolton last week.

Bolton was a hawk on Iran and has been for decades.

Iran saw this as their chance to act up while the President was no longer being advised by his anti-Iran hawk.

You do the 4D math!

4D ain't math, it's chess.  ;D
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: drck1000 on September 18, 2019, 09:51:17 AM
Trump fired National Security Advisor John Bolton last week.

Bolton was a hawk on Iran and has been for decades.

Iran saw this as their chance to act up while the President was no longer being advised by his anti-Iran hawk.

You do the 4D math!
I’m an engineer. I don’t to math  :P
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 18, 2019, 09:59:35 AM
4D ain't math, it's chess.  ;D

You must not play chess -- at least not seriously.

Chess is all about math, primarily related to logic, game theory and problem solving.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 18, 2019, 10:56:14 AM
You must not play chess -- at least not seriously.

Chess is all about math, primarily related to logic, game theory and problem solving.

1+1=3?
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: RSN172 on September 18, 2019, 11:22:09 AM
1+1=3?
Two Wongs make one Wright?
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 18, 2019, 01:55:54 PM
Two Wongs make one Wright?

Waycist.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Kuleana on September 19, 2019, 07:32:51 AM
no. provocation is not part of  US foreign policy.containment is.

Really, I don't see how sailing warships to intimidate China in the Taiwan straits as containment.

Moreover, is surrounding Russia, China, and Iran with US military bases it can't financially afford containment?  Its seems more like garrisons to govern an imperial empire to me.


QUESTION:  If Russia and China ARE NOT building bases in countries bordering the continental US, then WHICH NATION is provoking the others?   

ANSWER: USA!
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: ren on September 19, 2019, 08:10:42 AM
Really, I don't see how sailing warships to intimidate China in the Taiwan straits as containment.

Moreover, is surrounding Russia, China, and Iran with US military bases it can't financially afford containment?  Its seems more like garrisons to govern an imperial empire to me.


QUESTION:  If Russia and China ARE NOT building bases in countries bordering the continental US, then WHICH NATION is provoking the others?   

ANSWER: USA!

Military bases is just ONE aspect of foreign policy. There are other lines of efforts.
Generalizing the sailing of warships as an intimidation effort is haphazard analysis. You/We don't understand their mission or task and purpose so to make an assumption like that is inaccurate.
Russian and China have military presences in other countries. Countries such as Bangladesh, Japan, Singapore have presences in other countries as well.
Do you know any concepts in strategic planning?
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: robtmc on September 19, 2019, 09:00:29 AM
Really, I don't see how sailing warships to intimidate China in the Taiwan straits as containment.
Hey genius, we have treaty obligations with several countries in that area.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: drck1000 on September 19, 2019, 09:57:56 AM
Hey genius, we have treaty obligations with several countries in that area.
What?  You mean they aren't sailing in those areas for the adventure and promise of seeing the world?  Now THAT would be genius. . .

[end sarcasm\]
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Heavies on September 19, 2019, 10:18:22 AM
Really, I don't see how sailing warships to intimidate China in the Taiwan straits as containment.

Moreover, is surrounding Russia, China, and Iran with US military bases it can't financially afford containment?  Its seems more like garrisons to govern an imperial empire to me.


QUESTION:  If Russia and China ARE NOT building bases in countries bordering the continental US, then WHICH NATION is provoking the others?   

ANSWER: USA!

That is not provoking,  that is deterrence and a warning.   SMH
(https://legalinsurrection.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Sign-Texas-High-School-Staff-Trained-To-Meet-Threats-With-Deadly-Force1-e1440897721395-620x424.png)
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: macsak on September 19, 2019, 10:34:25 AM
Do you know any concepts in strategic planning?

he learned strategic planning from mother earth news
it was the issue right after the one with the ICBM silos
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: changemyoil66 on September 19, 2019, 11:24:33 AM
That is not provoking,  that is deterrence and a warning.   SMH
(https://legalinsurrection.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Sign-Texas-High-School-Staff-Trained-To-Meet-Threats-With-Deadly-Force1-e1440897721395-620x424.png)

That sign might get someone red flagged.  Had the guy in OR who said if he was attacked by antifa, he would slaughter them.  Because the Sheriffs refused to enforce red flag confiscation, the FBI confiscated his guns.

https://www.military.com/daily-news/2019/09/02/remarks-against-antifa-prompt-fbi-seizure-ex-marines-weapons-under-oregons-red-flag-law.html
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: drck1000 on September 19, 2019, 12:18:26 PM
he learned strategic planning from mother earth news
it was the issue right after the one with the ICBM silos
Is that what those things were that were reported opening when the alert sirens went off yesterday?   :o
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Kuleana on September 19, 2019, 04:03:36 PM
Generalizing the sailing of warships as an intimidation effort is haphazard analysis. You/We don't understand their mission or task and purpose so to make an assumption like that is inaccurate.

Russian and China have military presences in other countries. Countries such as Bangladesh, Japan, Singapore.

If a nation sees the presence of warships of their coast or military bases being built right across their borders from a nation that openly sees them as an adversary, it is with a high probability such military deployments can be viewed as provocations.  The US surely believes in this kind of reasoning as it does with China building islands in the South China Sea.

Russia and China has a military presence in Japan?  Really, since when?
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Kuleana on September 19, 2019, 04:04:22 PM
Hey genius, we have treaty obligations with several countries in that area.

Treaty obligations does not mean sailing your ships right in China's back yard.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: ren on September 19, 2019, 04:19:16 PM
Treaty obligations does not mean sailing your ships right in China's back yard.

Define China's "backyard" or what they claim.
BTW, you took my post out of context. The countries I mentioned are in the UN and are active participants in the world.
Did you major in political science?
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Kuleana on September 19, 2019, 04:30:23 PM
Define China's "backyard" or what they claim.

The US clearly understands the geopolitical situation between China and Taiwan.

The US has a treaty to assist Taiwan if attacked, but the treaty does not make provisions for the US to recklessly sail ships in the waters between them.  If the militaries of both sides wants to posture against one another, that is their business.  The US is not obligated to partake is such activities.  In fact, the US should be working for peace between them.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: ren on September 19, 2019, 06:09:19 PM
The US clearly understands the geopolitical situation between China and Taiwan.

The US has a treaty to assist Taiwan if attacked, but the treaty does not make provisions for the US to recklessly sail ships in the waters between them.  If the militaries of both sides wants to posture against one another, that is their business.  The US is not obligated to partake is such activities.  In fact, the US should be working for peace between them.

Yes. The U.S. does and recognizes international waters. Apparently the self-proclaimed Hawaiian Nation doesn't understand foreign policy especially because it doesn't have a Navy.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Kuleana on September 19, 2019, 07:02:51 PM
Yes. The U.S. does and recognizes international waters. Apparently the self-proclaimed Hawaiian Nation doesn't understand foreign policy especially because it doesn't have a Navy.

You need to stay on topic and not let the movement to deoccupy Hawaii from the US interfere in this thread.

Using the pretext of sailing through "international waters" is very lame and nothing short of an act of provocation.  Such moves are not helpful or productive and, if fact, expensive for the US to maintain.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: ren on September 19, 2019, 07:28:54 PM
You need to stay on topic and not let the movement to deoccupy Hawaii from the US interfere in this thread.

Using the pretext of sailing through "international waters" is very lame and nothing short of an act of provocation.  Such moves are not helpful or productive and, if fact, expensive for the US to maintain.

I did not state that these vessels sail indiscriminately through international waters to "provoke" a response. As I mentioned before do you know their mission? Can you state their task and purpose? As you mentioned these ships are VERY expensive to maintain. They have missions: whether training or real world. Ship Captains don't joyride. They receive orders and carry them out as military commanders do. What determines this is a campaign plan which is ultimately driven by the President and his staff. It's a very thorough process.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Kuleana on September 19, 2019, 07:34:49 PM
I did not state that these vessels sail indiscriminately through international waters to "provoke" a response. As I mentioned before do you know their mission? Can you state their task and purpose? As you mentioned these ships are VERY expensive to maintain. They have missions: whether training or real world. Ship Captains don't joyride. They receive orders and carry them out as military commanders do. What determines this is a campaign plan which is ultimately driven by the President and his staff. It's a very thorough process.

I can't imagine what kind of mission sailing between China and Taiwan could possibly be other than a show of force against China.

If they want to travel through the area, why don't they travel on the other side of Taiwan.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: ren on September 19, 2019, 07:41:32 PM
I can't imagine what kind of mission sailing between China and Taiwan could possibly be other than a show of force against China.
If they want to travel through the area, why don't they travel on the other side of Taiwan.

As mentioned, ships are expensive, going around may incur increased fuel consumption or there may be a storm system or they have to take the fastest route to a destination.

https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your-military/2018/10/22/two-navy-warships-transit-taiwan-strait/ (https://www.militarytimes.com/news/your-military/2018/10/22/two-navy-warships-transit-taiwan-strait/)

In the image caption you can see them perform refueling operations at sea in international waters. They may also work with other nations in the area on various training or real-world missions.

https://www.scmp.com/news/china/military/article/2169728/two-us-navy-ships-sail-through-taiwan-strait-move-likely-anger (https://www.scmp.com/news/china/military/article/2169728/two-us-navy-ships-sail-through-taiwan-strait-move-likely-anger)
"The US Navy will continue to fly, sail and operate anywhere international law permits. - US Colonel Rob Manning"
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: drck1000 on September 19, 2019, 07:51:18 PM
For one, supporting/enforcing/ensuring freedom of navigation rights.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: drck1000 on September 19, 2019, 07:58:58 PM
For one, supporting/enforcing/ensuring freedom of navigation rights.
And as I am watching a show on WWII where Germany has started the attack on Britain shipping lanes.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Kuleana on September 19, 2019, 08:59:08 PM
"The US Navy will continue to fly, sail and operate anywhere international law permits. - US Colonel Rob Manning"

Since when does a US army or marine colonel make naval operation decisions when it is clear he is not in the navy.    :wtf:
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: ren on September 19, 2019, 09:13:03 PM
Since when does a US army or marine colonel make naval operation decisions when it is clear he is not in the navy.    :wtf:

He / she is on the joint staff.
In order to be qualified at that rank the officer attends War College and the officer can go to the Naval College. Regardless, they have studied joint operations at that rank.

Or the article's author misread the rank. The officer could be a Navy Captain and the author interpreted the eagle as a Colonel.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 19, 2019, 10:06:21 PM
He / she is on the joint staff.
In order to be qualified at that rank the officer attends War College and the officer can go to the Naval College. Regardless, they have studied joint operations at that rank.

Or the article's author misread the rank. The officer could be a Navy Captain and the author interpreted the eagle as a Colonel.

We have different command structures in day-to-day peacetime missions versus joint operational missions. 

When deployed to a combat or military exercise location, each component (Army, Navy and Air Force) basically gives up their resources (people, equipment, ...) to a Unified Combat Command.  That command's head can be from any branch.

One example would be USCENTCOM which is in charge of combat operations in the Persian Gulf region.  They are actually headquartered in FL, but maintain their regional mission in Bahrain. Right now a Marine leads that organization.  The commander before him was Army.

Each component command still maintains their own subordinate command structure for that region, but they are "unified" under one commander.
Title: Re: Saudi Arabian Oil
Post by: Flapp_Jackson on September 19, 2019, 10:10:54 PM
Now that I look up the individual in question, assuming I have the right guy, Army Col Rob Manning is a career public affairs officer.

Most recently, he was Director of Defense Press Operations for the U.S. Department of Defense.

Giving official statements is kind of his job.